Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:JHHC:6774-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JHARKHAND AT RANCHI
W.P.(Cr.) (DB) No.792 of 2025
----Mithilesh Tiwari aged about 34 years, son of Late Ganesh
Tiwari, Resident of Village-Bajrang Tola, Near Mandir,
Chouparan, P.O. & P.S.-Chouparan, Dist-Hazaribag.
…
…
Petitioner
Versus
1. Union of India through the Zonal Director, Narcotics
Control Bureau, Ranchi Zonal Unit, Ranchi, H1215,
Harmu, Panchwati Colony, P.O.-G.P.O, P.S. Argora, DistRanchi.
2. The Joint Secretary, Government of India, Ministry of
Finance, Department of Revenue (PITNDPS Unit), Room
No.156B, 1st Floor, North Block, New Delhi, P.O. Central
Secretariat, P.S. Central Delhi, Dist-Central Delhi.
3. The Deputy Secretary, Government of India, Ministry of
Finance, Department of Revenue (PITNDPS Unit), 2nd
Floor, Room No.202, Jeevan Tara Building, Parliament
Street, New Delhi, P.O.-Head P.O.- New Delhi, P.S.Parliament Street, Dist-Central Delhi.
…
…
Respondents
------CORAM : HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE SUJIT NARAYAN PRASAD
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUN KUMAR RAI
------For the Petitioner
: Mr. Shailendra Jit, Advocate
For the Respondent
: Mr. Prashant Pallav, ASGI
------C.A.V. on 17.02.2026
Pronounced on 12/03/2026
Per Sujit Narayan Prasad, J.
Prayer:
1. This writ petition has been filed under Article 226 of the
Constitution
of India
for
quashing
the
order
dated
13.05.2025 passed in F No.U-11011/33/2025-PITNDPS by
the Joint Secretary, Govt. of India, Ministry of Finance,
Department of Revenue, (PITNDPS Unit), New Delhi under
Section 3(1) of the Prevention of Illicit Traffic in Narcotic
2026:JHHC:6774-DB
Drugs
and
Psychotropic
Substances
Act,
(as
amended), by which the petitioner has been directed to be
detained and kept in Lok Nayak Jaiprakash Narayan
Central Jail, Hazaribag and the petitioner further prays for
quashing the order dated 29.07.2025 passed in F.No.
11012/19/2025 PITNDPS by the Deputy Secretary, Govt. of
India,
Ministry
of
Finance,
Department
of
Revenue,
(PITNDPS Unit), New Delhi under Section 9(f) of the
Prevention
of
Illicit
Traffic
in
Narcotic
Drugs
and
Psychotropic Substances Act, 1988, by which the Central
Govt.
confirms
the
aforesaid
detention
order
dated
13.05.2025 and further under Section 11 of the said Act
petitioner has been directed to be detained for a period of
one years from the date of his detention i.e., 02.06.2025.
Factual Matrix
2.
The brief facts of the case as per the pleading made
in the writ petition, which are required to be enumerated,
read as under:
3. It is stated in the writ petition that vide order dated
13.05.2025 passed by the Joint Secretary, Govt. of India,
Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue (PITNDPS
Unit),
New
Delhi
(Respondent
No.2)
in
F-No.
U-
11011/33/2025-PITNDPS U/s 3(1) of the Prevention of
illicit
Traffic
in
Narcotic
Drugs
and
Psychotropic
2026:JHHC:6774-DB
Substances Act, 1988 (as amended), the petitioner has
been directed to be detained and kept in Lok Nayak
Jaiprakash Narayan Central Jail, Hazaribag with a view to
prevent him from engaging in illicit trafficking of narcotics
drugs & psychotropic substances in future.
4. Thereafter, vide order dated 29.07.2025 passed in F-No.
U-11011/19/2025-PITNDPS by the Deputy Secretary, Govt.
of India, Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue
(PIINDPS Division), New Delhi (Respondent No.3) U/s 9(f) of
the Prevention of illicit Traffic in Narcotic Drugs and
Psychotropic Substances Act, 1988, the Central Govt.
confirms the aforesaid detention order dated 13.05.2025
and further under Section 11 of the said Act, petitioner has
been directed to be detained for a period of one year from
the date of his detention i.e. 02.06.2025.
5. The sponsoring authority, NCB, Ranchi Zonal Unit in the
PITNDPS Proposal has mentioned that there are two cases
of NDPS Act, 1985 against the petitioner and they are
1. NCB Ranchi Crime No. 02/2024 dated 21.04.2024 and
2. NCB Ranchi Crime No. 01/2016 dated 18.05.2016.
6. It is alleged that on 20.04.2024, a team of NCB Ranchi
visited the house of the petitioner at his old address to
execute the NBWA issued against him in connection with
NCB Ranchi crime No. 01/2016 and on 21.04.2024, the
2026:JHHC:6774-DB
NCB team apprehended the petitioner at his new address at
Chouparan and seized 275 grams of opium and Rs.
1,00,000/- cash from his conscious possession and in
voluntary statement, he has admitted his guilt in trafficking
opium and disclosed that he is main supplier of opium in
small packets weighing 5-10 grams to truck drivers going
towards Haryana and Punjab and further admitted to
assisting his brother Naresh Tiwari in trafficking poppy
straw and being present during the 2016 seizure of 102 kg
poppy straw at Tiwari Hotel, Chouparan (NCB Crime No.
01/2016) and he was arrested on 21.04.2024 U/s 18 (C) of
NDPS Act and remanded to judicial custody on 22.04.2024.
7. In the aforesaid NCB Crime No. 02/2024, petitioner has
been granted bail by the Hon'ble High Court on 24.10.2024
and the case is in evidence stage.
8. In another NCB Ranchi Crime No. 01/2016 dated
18.05.2016, it is alleged that on 18.05.2016, NCB Ranchi
seized 102 Kg poppy straw from Tiwari Hotel, Chouparan,
Hazaribag, located near NH-2 and arrested the accused
Naresh Tiwari (brother of petitioner) u/s 15 NDPS Act, who
was present during the seizure and admitted to operating
the hotel with the petitioner and in this case, petitioner was
summoned U/s 67 NDPS Act to join investigation but he
absconded and notices u/s 67 NDPS Act dated 26.05.2016,
2026:JHHC:6774-DB
03.06.2016, 16.06.2016 and 25.07.2016 were issued
against him, but he did not turn up before the case I.O.,
and final complaint was filed on 09.11.2016 against the
petitioner as an absconding accused and the Learned Court
below issued NBWA against the petitioner on 24.04.2019.
Further, vide Judgment dated 30.04.2019, accused Naresh
Tiwari (brother of petitioner) was convicted to RI for 20
years and a fine of Rs. One lakh.
9. Taking
into
consideration
the
aforesaid
cases
the
authority concerned based upon its subjective satisfaction
has passed the order of detention dated 13.05.2025.
10.
The said impugned detention order has been
challenged by filing the instant writ petition.
Submission of the learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner:
11.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner has
taken the following grounds in assailing the impugned
decision: (i)
The
detaining
authority
(Respondent
No.2)
has
illegally passed the detention order dated 13.05.2025
against the petitioner without application of judicial
mind in view of the fact that detaining authority has
observed that at the time of passing of the detention
order dated 13.05.2025, detaining authority was
aware that at present petitioner is in custody since
2026:JHHC:6774-DB
21.04.2024 in NCB Ranchi Crime No.01/2016 and
there was no material for the detaining authority to
have formed an opinion that there was likelihood of
petitioner being released on bail in connection with
NCB Ranchi Crime No. 01/2016.
(ii)
Submission has been made that when the petitioner is
already in custody, the detaining authorities must
satisfy himself and such satisfaction must be reached
on the basis of cogent material that there is real
possibility of detenue being released on bail, further if
released on bail, the material on record must satisfy
that he would indulge in prejudicial activity again, if
not detained, but, there is no such satisfaction of the
detaining authority in the present case. The issue of
subjective satisfaction, in the facts of the present case,
is relevant since the writ petitioner was made accused
in connection with the cases of illicit trafficking of
narcotic drugs and psychotropic substances.
(iii) While passing the detention order, the detaining
authority has not considered the fact that in NCB
Ranchi Crime No. 01/2016, the petitioner was neither
apprehended at the alleged place of occurrence nor
any recovery was made from him and he has been
made accused only on suspicion that main accused
2026:JHHC:6774-DB
Naresh Tiwari confessed that petitioner is his brother
and assisting him in the running of Hotel and further
the said main accused Naresh Tiwari has never
confessed
that
alleged
seized
poppy
straw
was
supplied by the petitioner. Further, in NCB Ranchi
Crime No. 02/2024, 275-gram opium was recovered
from the petitioner, which is intermediary quantity, so
the findings of the detaining authority that petitioner
is actively involved in trafficking of Narcotics Drugs
and Psychotropic Substances and he is a habitual
offender is not based on the material available on the
record.
(iv) It is further submitted that in the aforesaid NCB
Ranchi Crime No. 01/2016, petitioner has been
allowed bail by this Hon'ble Court vide order dated
28.07.2025 in B.A. No. 10458 of 2024 only after the
passing of the detention order dated 13.05.2025.
(v)
Further submission has been made that after passing
the detention order, petitioner has also been acquitted
in NCB Case No. 01/2016 vide Judgment dated
19.09.2025 passed by the Court of the Learned Addl.
Sessions Judge-IX, Hazaribag.
(vi) There is no material brought on record to show that
proper communication of the grounds of the detention
2026:JHHC:6774-DB
has been made available to the petitioner to make his
representation.
(vii) It has further been submitted that the petitioner is
less educated and he can sign in Hindi somehow, but
the grounds of the detention has not been properly
communicated to the petitioner, therefore, he has not
made
his
representation
before
the
appropriate
authority.
12.
Learned counsel, based upon the aforesaid grounds,
has submitted that the order of detention
and its
subsequent confirmation, therefore, suffers from an error
and hence, not sustainable in the eye of law and fit to be
set aside.
Submission made by the learned counsel for the State
13.
Per contra, learned ASGI, has submitted, on the
basis of the counter affidavit filed on behalf of the
respondents, that there is no error in the impugned
decision, since, the petitioner was found to be habitual in
trafficking of the narcotics which would be evident from the
institution of First Information Reports.
14.
Submission has been made that at Para-4 of the
grounds of the detention order dated 13.05.2025, the
detaining authority (Respondent No.2) has observed that he
is aware that the petitioner is in custody since 21.04.2024
2026:JHHC:6774-DB
in NCB Ranchi Crime No. 01/2016. but considering the
conscious involvement in illegal trafficking of drugs and
psychotropic substances in a repeated manner to the
detriment of the society, the impugned order has been
passed.
15.
It has been submitted that from the material
available before the authority, it is clearly established that
the petitioner is actively involved in trafficking of Narcotics
Drugs & Psychotropic Substances and is a habitual
offender and his presence in the society is threat to
innocent person of the locality/State/Nation and his
activities are in prejudicial to society.
16.
It
has
been
submitted
that
no
statutory
or
fundamental right of the petitioner has been violated. All
the actions that have been taken against the petitioner is in
complete
Prevention
compliance
of
Illicit
with
the
Traffic
in
laws,
specifically
Narcotic
Drugs
the
and
Psychotropic Substances Act, 1988 and the respondentsauthorities
while
passing
the
order
has
taken
into
consideration the report and opinion of the Advisory Board.
17.
The petitioner is habitual offender and is involved in
multiple large-scale trafficking operations and he poses a
grave danger to the society at large. If the prayer of the
2026:JHHC:6774-DB
petitioner would be allowed, the harmony of the society can
be at threat.
18.
It is submitted that the petitioner himself had
admitted that he is the supplier of narcotics such as opium.
The grant of bail by this court has no bearing on the order
of prevention detention.
19.
Further submission has been made
that the
petitioner deliberately did not join the investigation and
remained absconding for several years.
20.
Learned counsel has submitted that it is also
incorrect on the part of the petitioner to take the ground
that there is no subjective satisfaction, rather, each and
every
aspect
of
the
matter
has
been
taken
into
consideration by the competent sanctioning authority
which on being deliberated by the Advisory Board has
upheld the decision so taken by the State. When two
authorities have upheld the issue of confining the petitioner
in detention, it cannot be said that there is no subjective
satisfaction.
21.
Learned counsel appearing for the respondents,
based upon the aforesaid grounds, has submitted that it is,
therefore, not a case where the order of detention is said to
suffer from an error.
2026:JHHC:6774-DB
Analysis
22.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and
gone through the order of detention as also the pleadings
made on behalf of the petitioner and the State as available
in the writ petition and the counter affidavits.
23.
The issues which require consideration in the
present case is whether in the facts and circumstances of
the present case, can it be said that the authorities have
got the subjective satisfaction while passing the order of
detention?
24.
But,
before
considering
the
said
issues,
the
statutory provision as contained under the Prevention of
Illicit
Traffic
in
Narcotic
Drugs
and
Psychotropic
Substances Act, 1988 with its object and intent needs to be
referred herein.
25.
The Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances
Act, 1988 has been enacted keeping in view that in recent
years, India has been facing a problem of transit traffic in
illicit drugs. The spillover from such traffic has caused
problems of abuse and addiction. This trend has created an
illicit demand for drugs within the country which may
result in the increase of illicit cultivation and manufacture
of drugs. Although a number of legislative, administrative
and other preventive measures, including the deterrent
2026:JHHC:6774-DB
penal provisions in the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic
Substances,
Act,
1985,
have
been
taken
by
the
Government, the transit traffic in illicit drugs had not been
completely eliminated. It was, therefore, felt that a
preventive detention law should be enacted with a view to
effectively immobilising the traffickers. The Conservation of
Foreign Exchange and Prevention of Smuggling Activities
Act, 1974 provides for preventive detention in relation to
smuggling of drugs and psychotropic substances, but it
cannot be invoked to deal with persons engaged in illicit
traffic of drugs and psychotropic substances within the
country. It was, therefore, felt that a separate legislation
should be enacted for preventive detention of persons
engaged in any kind of illicit traffic in narcotic drugs and
psychotropic substances.
26.
The relevant provisions which require consideration
are Section 3, 6, 9 and 11 of the Act,1988, which are
necessary to be referred herein which read hereunder as :3. Power to make orders detaining certain persons.-(I)
The Central Government or a State Government, or any officer
of the Central Government, not below the rank of a Joint
Secretary to that Government, specially empowered for the
purposes of this section by that Government, or any officer of
a State Government, not below the rank of a Secretary to that
Government, specially empowered for the purposes of this
section by that Government, may, if satisfied, with respect to
any person (including a foreigner) that, with a view to
preventing him from engaging in illicit traffic in narcotic drugs
2026:JHHC:6774-DB
and psychotropic substances, it is necessary so to do, make
an order directing that such person be detained.
(2) When any order of detention is made by a State
Government or
by
an
officer
empowered
by
a State
Government, the State Government shall, within ten days,
forward to the Central Government a report in respect of the
order.
(3) For the purposes of clause (5) of Article 22 of the
Constitution, the communication to a person detained in
pursuance of a detention order of the grounds on which the
order has been made shall be made as soon as may be after
the detention, but ordinarily not later than five days, and in
exceptional circumstances and for reasons to be recorded in
writing, not later than fifteen days, from the date of detention.
6. Grounds of detention severable.-Where a person has
been detained in pursuance of an order of detention under
sub-section (1) of section 3 which has been made on two or
more grounds, such order of detention shall be deemed to
have been made separately on each of such grounds and
accordingly(a) such order shall not be deemed to be invalid or
inoperative merely because one or some of the grounds is or
are(i) vague,
(ii) non-existent,
(iii) not relevant,
(iv) not connected or not proximately connected with
such person, or
(v) invalid for any other reason whatsoever,
and it is not therefore possible to hold that the Government or
officer making such order would have been satisfied as
provided in sub-section (I) of section 3 with reference to the
remaining ground or grounds and made the order of detention;
(b) the Government or officer making the order of
detention shall be deemed to have made the order of detention
under the said sub-section (I) after being satisfied as provided
in that sub-section with reference to the remaining ground or
grounds.
2026:JHHC:6774-DB
9. Advisory Boards.-For the purposes of sub-clause (a) of
clause (4) and subclause (c) of clause (7) of article 22 of the
Constitution,(a)
the Central Government' and each State Government
shall, whenever necessary, constitute one or more
Advisory Boards each of which shall consist of a
Chairman and two other persons possessing the
qualifications specified in sub-clause (a) of clause (4) of
article 22 of the Constitution;
(b)
save
as
otherwise
provided
in
section
10,
the
appropriate Government shall, within five weeks from
the date of detention of a person under a detention
order, make a reference in respect thereof to the
Advisory Board constituted under clause (a) to enable
the Advisory Board to make the report under sub-clause
(a) of clause (4) of article 22 of the Constitution;
(c)
the Advisory Board to which a reference is made under
clause (b) shall after considering the reference and the
materials placed before it and after calling for such
further information as it may deem necessary from the
appropriate Government or from any person, called for
the purpose through the appropriate Government or from
the person concerned, and if, in any particular case, it
considers it essential so to do or if the person concerned
desires to be heard in person, after hearing him in
person, prepare its report specifying in a separate
paragraph thereof its opinion as to whether or not there
is sufficient cause for the detention of the person
concerned and submit the same within eleven weeks
from the date of detention of the person concerned;
(d)
when there is a difference of opinion among the
members forming the Advisory Board, the opinion of the
majority of such members shall be deemed to be the
opinion of the Board;
(e)
a person against whom an order of detention has been
made under this Act shall not be entitled to appear by
any legal practitioner in any matter connected with the
reference to the Advisory Board and the proceedings of
2026:JHHC:6774-DB
the Advisory Board and its report, excepting that part of
the report in which the opinion of the Advisory Board is
specified, shall be confidential;
(f)
in every case where the Advisory Board has reported
that there is in its opinion sufficient cause for the
detention of a person, the appropriate Government may
confirm the detention order and continue the detention
of the person concerned for such period as it thinks fit
and in every case where the Advisory Board has
reported that there is in its opinion no sufficient cause
for
the
detention
of
the
person
concerned,
the
appropriate Government shall revoke the detention order
and cause the person to be released forthwith.
11. Maximum period of detention.-The maximum
period for which any person may be detained in
pursuance
of
any
detention
order
to
which
the
provisions of section 10 do not apply and which has
been confirmed under clause (f) of section 9 shall be one
year from the date of detention, and the maximum
period for which any person may be detained in
pursuance
of
any
detention
order
to
which
the
provisions of section 10 apply and which has been
confirmed under clause (f) of section 9, read with subsection (2) of section 10, shall be two years from the
date of detention:
Provided that nothing contained in this section
shall affect the power of appropriate Government in
either case to revoke or modify the detention order at
any earlier time.”
27.
Hence, it is evident that the Act, 1988 has been
enacted since India has been facing a problem of transit
traffic in illicit drugs. It was, therefore, felt that a preventive
detention law should be enacted with a view to effectively
immobilising the traffickers. The Central Government and
the State Governments have been empowered to make
2026:JHHC:6774-DB
orders of detention with respect to any person in respect of
whom an order of detention is made under the Ordinance
at any time before the 31st July, 1990 may be detained
without obtaining the opinion of an Advisory Board for a
period not exceeding one year from the date of his detention
if the detaining authority is satisfied that such person is
engaged, or is likely to engage, in illicit traffic in narcotic
drugs and psychotropic substances in any area highly
vulnerable to such illicit traffic.
28.
Further, the “illicit Traffic” has been defined as
under Section 2(e) of the Act, 1988 which reads hereunder
as :2. (e) "illicit traffic", in relation to narcotic drugs and psychotropic
substances, means(i)
cultivating any coca plant or gathering any portion of coca
plant;
(ii)
cultivating the opium poppy or any cannabis plant;
(iii)
engaging in the production, manufacture, possession, sale,
purchase, transportation, warehousing, concealment, use
or consumption, import inter-State, export inter-State,
import into India, export from India or transhipment, of
narcotic drugs or psychotropic substances;
(iv)
dealing in any activities in narcotic drugs or psychotropic
substances other than those provided in sub-clauses (i) to
(iii); or
(v)
handling or letting any premises for the carrying on of any
of the activities referred to in sub-clauses (i) to (iv),
other than those permitted under the Naroctic Drugs and Psychotropic
Substances Act, 1985 (61 of 1985) or any rule or order made, or any
condition of any licence, term or authorisation issued, thereunder and
includes-
2026:JHHC:6774-DB
(1)
financing, directly or indirectly, any of the aforementioned
activities:
(2)
abetting or conspiring in the furtherance of or in support of
doing any of the aforementioned activities; and
(3)
harbouring persons engaged in any of the aforementioned
activities:
29.
Section 3 of the Act, 1988 provides power to make
orders detaining certain persons wherefrom it is evident
that the competent authority if satisfied, with respect to
any person (including a foreigner) that, with a view to
preventing him from engaging in illicit traffic in narcotic
drugs and psychotropic substances, it is necessary so to
do, make an order directing that such person be detained.
But, for the purpose of clause (5) of Article 22 of the
Constitution, the communication to a person detained in
pursuance of a detention order of the grounds on which the
order has been made shall be made as soon as may be after
the detention, but ordinarily not later than five days, and in
exceptional circumstances and for reasons to be recorded
in writing, not later than fifteen days, from the date of
detention.
30.
Section 9 of the Act, 1988 provides constitution of
an Advisory Board with an intent to achieve the purposes of
sub-clause (a) of clause (4) and subclause (c) of clause (7) of
article 22 of the Constitution of India with the conferment
of power upon the Advisory Board that if any reference has
been made and the materials placed before it and after
2026:JHHC:6774-DB
calling for such further information as it may deem
necessary from the appropriate Government or from any
person, called for the purpose through the appropriate
Government or from the person concerned, and if, in any
particular case, it considers it essential so to do or if the
person concerned desires to be heard in person, after
hearing him in person, prepare its report specifying in a
separate paragraph thereof its opinion as to whether or not
there is sufficient cause for the detention of the person
concerned and submit the same within eleven weeks from
the date of detention of the person concerned.
31.
The
maximum
period
of
detention
has
been
provided under Section 11 of the Act, 1988 and as provided
therein any person may be detained in pursuance of any
detention order to which the provisions of section 10 do not
apply and which has been confirmed under clause (f) of
section 9 shall be one year from the date of detention, and
the maximum period for which any person may be detained
in pursuance of any detention order to which the provisions
of section 10 apply and which has been confirmed under
clause (f) of section 9, read with sub-section (2) of section
10, shall be two years from the date of detention.
32.
It is in the backdrop of the aforesaid statutory
provisions; the factual aspect of the present case is to be
2026:JHHC:6774-DB
considered in order to consider the issue as formulated
hereinabove.
33.
Reverting to the issue in the present case. Before,
proceeding further, it would be pertinent to mention the
case of
Ameena Begum v. State of Telangana, (2023) 9
SCC 587, wherein Hon’ble Apex Court has laid down
certain principles to be observed by the Constitutional
Court while examining the legality of orders of preventive
detention. Paragraph-28 of this judgment is quoted herein
below“28. In the circumstances of a given case, a constitutional
court when called upon to test the legality of orders of
preventive detention would be entitled to examine whether:
28.1. The order is based on the requisite satisfaction, albeit
subjective, of the detaining authority, for, the absence of such
satisfaction as to the existence of a matter of fact or law, upon
which validity of the exercise of the power is predicated,
would be the sine qua non for the exercise of the power not
being satisfied;
28.2. In reaching such requisite satisfaction, the detaining
authority has applied its mind to all relevant circumstances
and the same is not based on material extraneous to the
scope and purpose of the statute;
28.3. Power has been exercised for achieving the purpose for
which it has been conferred, or exercised for an improper
purpose, not authorised by the statute, and is therefore ultra
vires;
28.4. The detaining authority has acted independently or
under the dictation of another body;
28.5. The detaining authority, by reason of self-created rules
of policy or in any other manner not authorised by the
2026:JHHC:6774-DB
governing statute, has disabled itself from applying its mind
to the facts of each individual case;
28.6. The satisfaction of the detaining authority rests on
materials which are of rationally probative value, and the
detaining authority has given due regard to the matters as per
the statutory mandate;
28.7. The satisfaction has been arrived at bearing in mind
existence of a live and proximate link between the past
conduct of a person and the imperative need to detain him or
is based on material which is stale;
28.8. The ground(s) for reaching the requisite satisfaction
is/are such which an individual, with some degree of
rationality and prudence, would consider as connected with
the fact and relevant to the subject-matter of the inquiry in
respect whereof the satisfaction is to be reached;
28.9. The grounds on which the order of preventive detention
rests are not vague but are precise, pertinent and relevant
which,
with
sufficient
clarity,
inform
the
detenu
the
satisfaction for the detention, giving him the opportunity to
make a suitable representation; and
28.10. The timelines, as provided under the law, have been
strictly adhered to.”
34.
Hence, Hon’ble Apex Court in case of
Ameena
Begum v. State of Telangana (supra), on the issue of
subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority has laid
down that the order
based on the requisite satisfaction,
albeit subjective, of the detaining authority, for, the
absence of such satisfaction as to the existence of a matter
of fact or law, upon which validity of the exercise of the
power is predicated, would be the sine qua non for the
exercise of the power not being satisfied. Hon’ble Apex
Court further laid down that the court may examine that
2026:JHHC:6774-DB
the satisfaction has been arrived at bearing in mind
existence of a live and proximate link between the past
conduct of a person and the imperative need to detain or is
based on material which is stale.
35.
On
going
through
the
detention
order
dated
13.05.2025, this Court finds that there is reference of two
pending cases against the detenue-NCB Ranchi Crime No.
01/2016 dated 18.05.2016 and NCB Ranchi Crime No.
02/2024 dated 21.04.2024.
36.
Hence, the oldest case against the detenue is of the
year 2016 and the latest case is of the year 2024. So, there
is gap of 8 years in between the two crimes alleged to be
committed by the detenue and in this gap of 8 years there
is no other cases registered against the detenue.
37.
Here, it is pertinent to note that in NCB Ranchi
Crime No. 02/2024, there is allegation of recovery of 275
grams of opium from the detenue and this alleged recovery
was made when the team of NCB Ranchi had visited the
house of the detenue to execute the NBWA issued against
the detenue in connection with NCB Ranchi Crime No.
01/2016.
38.
Hence, this Court is of view that disturbance to the
public order does not arise, when alleged recovery of 275
gm of opium is made during the execution of NBWA against
2026:JHHC:6774-DB
the detenue in connection with NCB Ranchi Crime No.
01/2016
and
consequently,
NCB
Ranchi
Crime
No.
02/2024 registered against the petitioner/detenue, for the
alleged
recovery
of
gm
of
opium
from
the
petitioner/detenue, may be ground for initiating criminal
prosecution against the petitioner/detenue, but, it would
not be a ground for setting in motion preventive detention
as the same would in no way said to be prejudicial to public
order, in light of the fact that there is difference of 8 years
between the alleged offences and in one of the case the writ
petitioner has already been acquitted.
39.
Further, this Court is conscious that detention
order is passed by the competent authority anticipating the
criminality of the detenue. Hence, the ground of bail or
acquittal in some cases cannot be said to affect the decision
taken by the competent authority for preventive detention
rather the accusation so made in the First Information
Report is to be seen for the purpose to have the subjective
satisfaction of the nature of accusation made in the said
FIR.
40.
But, in present case, out of the two pending cases
referred in the impugned detention order, detenue has been
acquitted in NCB Ranchi Crime No. 01/2016, by the
learned Trial Court of Addl. Sessions Judge-IX, Hazaribagh,
2026:JHHC:6774-DB
by order dated 19.09.2025 i.e. after the passing of the
impugned detention order on 13.05.2025 and so far as
NCB Ranchi Crime No. 02/2024,is concerned, in the
preceding
paragraph,
this
Court
has
come
to
the
conclusion that NCB Ranchi Crime No. 02/2024, is not a
ground for setting in motion preventive detention against
the petitioner/detenue. Here, it is also pertinent to note
that petitioner has been granted bail in NCB Ranchi Crime
No. 02/2024, on 24.10.2024, by the Court of law and this
case is at evidence stage.
41.
Hence, this Court finds that detaning authority has
failed to establish live and proximate link between the past
conduct of a detenue and the imperative need to detain him
for the reason that there is gap of 8 years in between the
two crimes referred in the impugned detention order,
alleged to be committed by the detenue and in this gap of 8
years there is no other cases registered against the detenue
and hence, question of disturbance to the public order does
not arise.
42.
So, this court is of the view that there was no
material before the detaining authority to come to a
subjective satisfaction with regard to the disturbance that
was caused to the public order, due to the alleged acts
committed by the detenu.
2026:JHHC:6774-DB
43.
This Court, therefore, is of the view that the
impugned order of detention needs interference.
44.
Accordingly, the detention order dated 13.05.2025
passed
in
F
No.U-11011/33/2025-PITNDPS
by
the
Respondent No.2 Joint Secretary, Govt. of India, Ministry of
Finance, Department of Revenuue, (PITNDPS Unit), New
Delhi
and
order
dated
29.07.2025
passed
in
F.No.
11012/19/2025 PITNDPS by the respondent No. 3 Deputy
Secretary, Govt. of India, Ministry of Finance, Department
of Revenue, (PITNDPS Unit), New Delhi, are hereby quashed
and set aside.
45.
The writ petition stands allowed.
46.
Consequently,
the
petitioner,
abovenamed,
is
directed to be released forthwith from detention if not
required in any other case.
I agree
(Sujit Narayan Prasad, J.)
(Arun Kumar Rai, J.)
(Arun Kumar Rai, J.)
12/03/2026
Alankar/
A.F.R.
Uploaded on 12.03.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review