Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/8
GAHC040021212025
2026:GAU-AP:466-DB
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WA/52/2025
Miss Mudang Yabyang
Daughter of Late Mudang Tayo, presently residing at Rono Hills, Po and PS
Doimukh, Papum Pare District, Arunachal Pradesh
VERSUS
The Arunachal Pradesh Public Service Commission
through the Secretary, Arunachal Pradesh Public Service Commission, Itanagar
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BUDI HABUNG
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ANJAN MONI KALITA
Advocate for the Appellant
: Mr. Tony Pertin, ld. Adv.
Advocate for the Respondent
: Ms. Nani Anju, ld SC, APPSC,
Date on which Judgment is reserved
:05.05.2026
Date of Hearing
:05.05.2026
Date of Judgment and Order
: 12.05.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the Operative part of the Judgment? :No
Whether the full Judgment has been pronounced ? : Yes
Page No.# 2/8
JUDGMENT & ORDER
(CAV)
[Budi Habung, J]
Heard Mr. Tony Pertin, learned counsel for the appellant. Also heard Ms. Nani
Anju, learned Standing Counsel, APPSC for the State respondent.
2.
The appellant is a person with locomotor disability and is wheelchair-bound.
She is aggrieved by the judgment and order dated 04.12.2025 passed by the
learned Single Judge in WP(C) No. 364 of 2025, whereby the writ petition was
partly allowed and the punishment of debarment imposed by the State Public
Service Commission vide order dated 24.07.2025, debarring the writ petitioner for a
period of one year from appearing in all examinations conducted by the APPSC,
was modified to the period already undergone as on the date of delivery of the
judgment.
3.
The relevant operative portion of the said judgment, being relevant for the
present purpose, is reproduced below:
“Para-41-Having said that it must also be kept in sight that the
petitioner is the person with benchmark Locomotor disability and is wheel-chair
bound. The portioner is a young citizen of State of Arunachal Pradesh and
although she has fairly admitted in her reply that she did posses the mobile
phone during the period of examination but there being no materials placed by
the APPSC to show that the petitioner had used mobile phone during the course
of the examination within the examination hall or even outside, therefore, this
Court considers the imposition of punishment of debarment for a period of one
year to be harsh.
42.
As held in Om Kumar (supra) that where the situation demands,
the quantum of punishment can be suitably moulded by the writ Court although
Page No.# 3/8
it is primarily within the domain of the administrative authority as the Writ Court
is well empowered to decide on the question of quantum of punishment; while
for the reasons discussed, this Court rejects the contentions on behalf of the
writ petitioner. However, this Court considers it appropriate to mould the relief
to the extent that under the facts and circumstances of the case, the
punishment undergone so far in the opinion of the Court is considered be
sufficient. The impugned order to the extent it imposes debarment for a period
of one year is therefore modified to the extent of the period undergone by the
petitioner till the date of delivery of the judgment. The impugned order of
debarment of one year is accordingly suitably modified in terms of the above.
The petitioner will now be able to appear for any such examination conducted
by the APPSC subject to fulfillment of provisions of law.”
4.
The grievance of the appellant in this appeal is that, although the learned
Single Judge found the punishment of one-year debarment to be harsh, the relief
was moulded by adopting the date of pronouncement of the judgment, i.e.
04.12.2025, instead of the date on which arguments were concluded and the
judgment was reserved, i.e. 02.09.2025. This resulted in the denial of an
opportunity to participate in the recruitment process conducted by the APPSC,
despite the appellant having applied by filing an interlocutory application seeking
interim permission.
5.
Being aggrieved thereby, the present writ appeal has been preferred.
6.
The grounds urged by the appellant, in brief, are that although the learned
Single Judge held the punishment of debarment to be harsh and grossly
disproportionate, the relief granted was not made fully effective inasmuch as the
period of debarment was restricted only until the date of pronouncement of the
judgment, i.e. 04.12.2025, instead of the date on which the matter was finally
heard and reserved for judgment, i.e. 02.09.2025.
7.
According to the appellant, continuation of the debarment until 04.12.2025
Page No.# 4/8
effectively amounted to an extension of the punishment for reasons beyond her
control and deprived her of the opportunity to participate in the recruitment
examinations notified vide Advertisement No. APPSC/1/2025 for the post of
Assistant Engineer and Advertisement No. APPSC/5/2025 for the post of Junior
Engineer (E & M), despite the finding that she had already undergone sufficient
punishment.
8.
It is contended that the relief granted by the learned Single Judge became
illusory, as the recruitment processes had already closed by the time the judgment
was delivered. The learned counsel for the appellant further submitted that
recruitment to engineering posts in the State of Arunachal Pradesh is infrequent,
with such examinations being conducted only once in about 8–9 years, and that
denial of participation in such a rare opportunity to a person with locomotor
disability would cause irreparable prejudice to her future career prospects,
particularly as she is approaching the upper age limit for such examinations.
9.
It is also urged that the impugned judgment does not record any finding of
cheating, dishonest intention, moral turpitude, or deliberate use of unfair means in
the said examination. The allegation against the appellant/writ petitioner is
confined to possession of a mobile phone during the examination. Therefore,
according to the appellant, once the debarment was interfered with on the ground
of disproportionality, it ought not to operate as a stigma or adverse character
finding against the appellant affecting her future examination or employment
opportunities.
10.
Further, by way of filing an additional affidavit, the appellant brought on
record that, pursuant to the interim protection granted by this Court on
23.12.2025, she was permitted to participate in the Junior Engineer (E & M)
Examination, 2025 conducted by the APPSC. Thereafter, the Commission declared
Page No.# 5/8
the result of the said examination, wherein the appellant was declared successful
on her own merit under the PwBD reserved category, and her name appeared at
Serial No. 60 in the final select list published by the Commission on 09.04.2026. It
is contended that the said subsequent development has created a substantive right
in favour of the appellant and that, unless appropriate protection is continued, she
may suffer prejudice at the stage of document verification, recommendation,
appointment, or future recruitment solely on account of the impugned debarment,
which is under challenge in the present appeal.
11.
Ms. Anju, the learned Standing Counsel for the APPSC, while admitting that
the interim order only permitted provisional participation subject to the sealed
cover result, fairly submitted that the Commission nevertheless allowed the
appellant to participate in the entire selection process, declared her result in the
written examination, permitted her to appear in the interview/viva voce, and finally
published the result of selection on 09.04.2026, wherein the name of the writ
petitioner/appellant appeared at Serial No. 60 in the said result list under the PwBD
reserved category.
12.
It is in view of the above subsequent developments brought on record by
way of the additional affidavit filed by the appellant, and the submissions advanced
by the learned counsel for the parties, that this appeal has been taken up for final
disposal.
13.
As seen above, it is not disputed that, by an interim order passed by this
Court on 23.12.2025, the appellant, who is a person with locomotor disability and
is wheelchair-bound, was provisionally permitted to participate in the Junior
Engineer (E&M) Examination, 2025 conducted by the respondent/Public Service
Commission, subject to fulfilment of the other eligibility conditions and subject to
the final outcome of the present writ appeal. The said interim protection was
Page No.# 6/8
granted taking note of the prima facie observations already made by this Court
regarding the nature of the punishment imposed and its consequences upon the
future career prospects of the appellant.
14.
Pursuant thereto, the appellant participated in the selection process. Though
the interim order contemplated that the result of the appellant should be kept in a
sealed cover, the respondent/ Commission not only permitted the appellant to
participate in the written examination but also declared her written examination
result, subsequently permitted her to appear in the interview/viva voce, and
thereafter finally declared the result selecting her for appointment to the post of
Junior Engineer (E&M) under the PwBD reserved category. The final result has
been published, and the appellant’s name admittedly appears at Serial No. 60 in
the said select list.
15.
The learned Standing Counsel for the respondent/Commission has admitted
the aforesaid factual position.
16.
In the peculiar facts and circumstances of the present case, this Court is of
the considered opinion that the subsequent developments have materially altered
the situation that existed at the time of grant of interim protection upon admission
of the appeal. The provisional participation permitted by this Court has already
culminated in the declaration and publication of the final result by the Public
Service Commission itself. The Commission, having consciously carried the
appellant through the entire selection process and published the final select list
including her name at Serial No. 60 thereof, cannot now seek to place the appellant
in a state of uncertainty on the basis of the very debarment order which is the
subject matter of challenge and which had already been interfered with by the
learned Single Judge on the ground of harshness and disproportionality.
17.
It is also relevant to note that neither the original order of debarment passed
Page No.# 7/8
by the Commission nor the judgment under appeal records any finding that the
appellant was guilty of cheating, impersonation, dishonest conduct, moral
turpitude, or deliberate use of unfair means during the examination. The allegation
against the appellant was confined to possession of a mobile phone during the
extra/compensatory time of the examination. The learned Single Judge himself
found the punishment of one-year debarment to be harsh and accordingly modified
the same.
18.
Having regard to the aforesaid circumstances, particularly considering that
the appellant is a candidate with locomotor disability, is wheelchair-bound, and is
an engineering graduate belonging to the PwBD category, this Court is satisfied
that no useful purpose would be served by keeping the present appeal pending any
further.
19.
Accordingly, without entering into the merit of the case, we propose to
dispose of this writ appeal with the following directions:
i.
The interim order passed by this Court on 23.12.2025 permitting the
appellant to participate provisionally in the Junior Engineer (E&M)
Examination, 2025, shall stand merged with the final order.
ii.
The selection and inclusion of the appellant in the final select list dated
09.04.2026 published by the respondent/Public Service Commission pursuant
to the Junior Engineer (E&M) recruitment process shall remain protected and
shall not be disturbed solely on the basis of the impugned debarment order
which forms the subject matter of the present appeal proceedings.
iii.
The impugned order of debarment, as modified by the learned Single
Judge, shall not by itself be construed as involving moral turpitude, cheating,
dishonest conduct, adverse character stigma, or deliberate use of unfair
means so as to automatically disqualify the appellant from appointment or
Page No.# 8/8
future recruitment processes, unless any such disqualification is specifically
contemplated under the applicable statutory recruitment rules.
iv.
The respondent authority shall proceed with the candidature of the
appellant,
including
document
verification,
recommendation,
and
appointment, strictly in accordance with law and subject to fulfilment of the
other eligibility conditions, without giving effect to the impugned debarment
beyond what has already been undergone.
20.
It is, however, clarified that this order has been passed in the peculiar facts
and circumstances of the present case, and particularly taking into consideration
the conduct of the respondent/Public Service Commission in having itself declared
and published the appellant’s final result pursuant to the interim order passed by
this Court on 23.12.2025. Therefore, the same shall not be construed as a
precedent.
21.
Accordingly, this writ appeal stands disposed of in terms of the above
directions.
22.
Pending interlocutory applications, if any, shall also stand disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review