Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Civil Extra-Ordinary Jurisdiction)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH: BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P. (C) No. 70 of 2016
Miss Dibya Gurung,
D/o Shri Kharka Bahadur Gurung,
R/o Namnang, Gangtok,
P.O. & P.S. Gangtok,
East Sikkim.
.… Petitioner.
versus
1.
State of Sikkim
Through the Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim, Gangtok, East Sikkim.
2. The Secretary,
Sikkim Public Service Commission,
Government of Sikkim, Gangtok, East Sikkim.
3. The Secretary,
Council of Architecture,
(A statutory body of government of India under Architects
Act, 1972)
India Habitat Centre, Core – 6 A, 1st Floor,
Lodhi Road, New Delhi-110 003.
4. Miss Oshin Rahul Gurung,
D/o Shri P.M. Gurung (Divisional Engineer)
Rural Management & Development Department,
Sub-Division-Jorethang, Government of Sikkim,
South Sikkim.
…. Respondents.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------Application under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
Appearance:
Mr. Rinzing Dorjee Tamang, Ms. Sonam Chhoden
Bhutia, Advocates for the Petitioner.
Mr. Karma Thinlay, Senior Govt. Advocate with Mr.
Thinlay Dorjee, Govt. Advocate and Mr. S. K. Chettri
Assistant Govt. Advocate for Respondent No. 1.
Mr. Bhusan Nepal, Advocate for Respondent No.2.
Mr. Ajay Rathi and Ms. Phurba Diki Sherpa Advocates
for Respondent No.3.
Mr. A. K. Upadhyaya, Senior Advocate with Ms. Aruna
Chhetri, Advocate for Respondent No. 4.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------JUDGMENT
(10.04.2018)
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J
1.
The Petitioner, an “Architect” by profession has preferred
the present Writ Petition challenging the selection of Respondent
No. 4 for the post of “Assistant Architect” by the Respondent No.
2 (Sikkim Public Service Commission) on the ground that at the
time of selection of the Respondent No. 4 to the post of
“Assistant Architect” she was not a registered “Architect” under
the Architect’s Act, 1972 and therefore, ought not to have been
selected by the Respondent No.2.
2.
The factual matrix of the present dispute lies in a narrow
compass.
The
Petitioner
graduated
in
the
Bachelor
of
Architecture in the year 2014. The Respondent No. 4 graduated
in the Bachelor of Architecture with a First Class in the year
2015. The Petitioner registered herself as an “Architect” with the
Respondent No. 3 (Council of Architecture) and possesses a valid
certificate
of
registration
effective
from
20.06.2016.
The
Respondent No.4 applied for registration with the Respondent
No.3 on 15.12.2016 and was duly registered vide registration No.
AC/2016/60614 on 31.12.2016 six months after the Petitioner.
3.
It is an admitted position that the Architects Act, 1972 has
not been enforced in Sikkim. It is the categorical submission of
the State of Sikkim (Respondent No.1) that it is so. Article 371 F
of the Constitution of India is a special provision with respect to
the State of Sikkim. Article 371 F (n) provides:
“Notwithstanding anything in this Constitution,- the President
may, by public notification, extend with such restrictions or
modifications as he thinks fit to the State of Sikkim any enactment
which is in force in a State in India at the date of the notification;”.
4.
Article 371 F of the Constitution of India was inserted by
the Constitution (Thirty-sixth Amendment) Act, 1975 with effect
from 26.04.1975. Thus, any enactment which is in force in a
State of India at the date of the notification is required to be
extended by the President by way of a public notification.
5.
The Architects Act, 1972 was an enactment which was in
force in a State of India at the date of the notification and thus,
the said enactment was required to be extended by the President
by way of public notification.
6.
On
28.06.2001
the
Department
of
Personnel,
Administrative Reforms & Training, Government of Sikkim
issued Notification No.42/GEN/DOP bringing into force the
Sikkim State Architect Service Recruitment Rules, 2001 which
was
published
in
the
Sikkim
Government
Gazette
on
05.07.2001. Under Rule 3 thereof the Method of Recruitment,
age limit, qualification and other matters relating to said post
shall be as specified in Columns 5 to 9 of the Schedule. The
Schedule prescribed a degree of a recognized University in
Architecture as the educational qualification required for direct
recruitment to the post of “Assistant Architect”. There were 9
posts of “Assistant Architects” in the Sikkim State Architects
Service in the year 2001 which was subsequently raised to 14
vide Notification No.J(80)/147/GEN/DOP dated 21.07.2008
published in the Sikkim Government Gazette on 19.08.2008.
7.
On 10.03.2016, much before the Petitioner as well as the
Respondent No.2 became registered “Architects”, the Respondent
No.2 issued an advertisement inviting applications from eligible
local candidates for filling up four posts of “Assistant Architects”
on temporary regular basis in four categories i.e., unreserved,
Bhutia-Lepcha, Other Backward Classes (Central List) and Other
Backward Classes (State List). A degree in Architecture from a
recognized University was one of the conditions of eligibility
under the requirement of minimum educational qualification. It
was
also
provided
that
in
accordance
with
Notification
No.44/GEN/DOP dated 27.10.2015 candidates who are in the
final/semester of the prescribed course shall be accepted
provided
such
candidates
have
cleared
all
the
previous
semesters at the time of submission of application and subject to
submission of the final year results on or before the dates
specified by Respondent No.2 before the interview. It was
provided that failure to submit the proof of essential educational
qualification by prescribed date shall make the application of
such candidates liable to be rejected without assigning any
reason thereof. The duty of the said post of “Assistant Architect”
was also notified as “designing of buildings”. In paragraph 6 of
the said advertisement it was provided that the candidates need
not submit any documents; however, the candidate should
ensure that they are qualified on the date of interview in all
respect. This paragraph was repeatedly emphasized by the
Learned Counsel appearing for the Petitioner. He submits under
the said clause the requirement that the candidate should
ensure they are qualified on the date of interview “in all respect”
would only mean that the candidate must also be a registered
“Architect” on or before the date of interview. This argument of
the Learned Counsel appearing for the Petitioner would stem
from his pivotal argument that although the Architects Act, 1972
has not been enforced in Sikkim it has been applied and followed
and therefore a law which is binding and thus as per the
definition of the term “Architect” as defined in Section 2(a) of the
Architects Act, 1972 the use of the words “Assistant Architect” in
the advertisement could only mean a person whose name is for
the time being entered in the register maintained by the
Respondent No. 3 prepared and maintained under Section 23
thereof. In such circumstances, a Division Bench of this Court
in re: Dal Bahadur Lama v. Smt. Ratna Kumari Basnet1 had held the
stringent provisions of the Act would not govern the case.
8.
The application form was required to be filled up by the
candidate and submitted in the office of the Respondent No. 2 on
any working day between 10.30 a.m. to 3.30 p.m. along with the
AIR 1986 Sikk 10
original bank receipt of State Bank of Sikkim, for Rs.150/credited to ‘0051-SPSC’. The complete filled in application form
was required to reach the Secretary of the Respondent No. 2 by
hand or by post on or before 3.00 p.m. on 09.04.2016. No
application submitted after 3.00 p.m. on 09.04.2016 would be
accepted.
9.
Those
candidates
who
would qualify in the written
examination were to be called for interview.
10. There was no requirement of the applicant to be a
registered “Architect” in the advertisement. The very fact that in
the conditions of eligibility one of the provisions permitted
candidates who are in the final/semester of the prescribed
course to participate in the examination provided that such
candidates had cleared all the previous semesters at the time of
submission of applications and subject to submission of the final
year result on or before the date specified by the Respondent
No.2 before the interview in accordance with Notification
No.44/GEN/DOP dated 27.10.2015 would clearly reflect the
intention of the Respondent No.2 that the eligibility condition for
the post of “Assistant Architect” was as provided in the Schedule
to the Sikkim Architect Service Recruitment Rules, 2001 and no
more.
11. The Petitioner belonging to the “Gurung” Community and
falling in the Other Backward Classes (Central List) reserved
category submitted her application for the said post. So did the
Respondent No. 4 who also belongs to the same reserved
category. On the date of submission of the application i.e.
09.04.2016 both the Petitioner as well as the Respondent No.4
had not registered themselves with the Respondent No.3 as an
“Architect” since admittedly the Petitioner was registered only on
20.06.2016 and Respondent No.4 was registered on 31.12.2016.
Even then the Petitioner without any hesitation or protest
submitted her application. The Respondent No.4, oblivious of the
future action that the Petitioner would take on the legal premise
sought to be canvassed before this Court, also applied for the
said post.
12. The Respondent No.2 vide Notice No. 143/SPSC/2016
dated 10.06.2016 fixed the date for written examination for the
post of “Assistant Architect” under the Sikkim State Architect
Service on 02.07.2016.
13. The Petitioner as well as the Respondent No. 4 appeared in
the said examination held on 02.07.2016 and qualified for the
viva-voce as notified vide Notice No. 149/SPSC/Exam/2016
dated 04.08.2016. In the notice the roll numbers of all the
candidates who had been short-listed in the written examination
was notified. By the said Notice the short-listed candidates were
required to report to the examination section of the Respondent
No. 2 on 18.08.2016 along with the attested copies of all the
required documents mentioned therein for the purpose of
scrutiny and verification. Amongst others, the degree certificate
and mark-sheet were also required to be scrutinized. Again there
was no requirement of the applicant submitting her/his
registration certificate issued by the Respondent No.3 registering
her/him as an “Architect”. On the date of scrutiny and
verification of documents i.e. 18.08.2016 the Petitioner was a
registered “Architect”. However, the Respondent No.4 was not.
The learned Counsel for the Petitioner submits that the
Respondent No.4 ought to have known that under the Architects
Act, 1972 she must mandatorily register herself as an “Architect”
and consequently ensure her registration prior to the date of
verification of documents as was done by the Petitioner. There is
a fundamental flaw in this argument which ignores the fact that
the advertisement did not seek for the registration document at
any stage and there was no requirement for the applicant to have
been a registered “Architect” neither at the time of the application
nor at the time of verification or scrutiny of documents. Even
otherwise, the Petitioner did not protest against the short-listing
of the Respondent No.4. It is difficult to appreciate that a
graduate in Architecture would have the necessary legal acumen
to appreciate that in spite of the Architects Act, 1972 not having
been enforced and the advertisement not having asked for it,
would know that the mandate of the said Architects Act, 1972
was applicable and consequently, ensured her registration as an
“Architect” with the Respondent No. 3 prior to the date of
scrutiny.
14. The post of “Assistant Architect” falls under the Sikkim
State Architect Service Recruitment Rules, 2001 made under the
proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of India. Under the
Schedule thereto the 14 posts of “Assistant Architects” belongs to
the junior grade in the scale of pay of Rs.7000-225-11500. The
method of recruitment is 100% by direct recruitment. The
eligibility condition required for direct recruitment, inter-alia, is a
degree of a recognized university in Architecture. There is no
requirement in the eligibility condition to be a registered
“Architect”. The said Sikkim State Architect Service Recruitment
Rules, 2001 is not under challenge.
15. In the meanwhile the Petitioner filed Right to Information
(RTI) application with the Buildings & Housing Department,
Government of Sikkim seeking certain information which would
be replied on the same date by the said Department on
12.07.2017.
16.
Both the Petitioner as well as the Respondent No. 4
appeared for the viva-voce held on 23.08.2016 whose result was
notified
vide
Notice
Reference
No.154/SPSC/2016
dated
27.08.2016. The Respondent No. 4 along with three others was
declared
qualified
and
their
names
recommended
for
appointment as “Assistant Architect”. Admittedly, the Petitioner
fell in the fifth place in the merit list as would be seen from the
statement of marks obtained in written examination and vivavoce for the post of “Assistant Architect” filed by the Respondent
No.4 and stood unqualified and was not recommended for
appointment. The Petitioner has not challenged the merits of the
selection process and admits her position in the merit list.
17. The
Respondent
reference
No.
No.
604/SPSC/2016
Commissioner-cum-Secretary,
Administrative
vide
Reforms
&
communication
dated
31.08.2016
Department
Trainings
bearing
of
to
the
Personnel
informed
that
applications had been received and all the applicants had
appeared in both sessions of written examination held on
02.07.2016. Out of them a total of 7 candidates had qualified at
the ratio of 1:2 and call for interview. On the basis of the marks
obtained in written examination and interview the following
candidates had been declared qualified in the order of merit and
the names of the selected candidates were recommended for
appointment:
Roll No.
CANDIDATE NAME
ROSTER POINT
ALLOTED
16754009
NISHA LAMICHANEY
UR / 01
16754011
PENZANG DORJEE LEPCHA
BL / 02
16754013
SAMJANA PRADHAN
OBC (SL)/04
16754010
OSHIN RAHUL GURUNG
OBC (CL)/03
18. On
07.12.2016
the
Petitioner
issued
a
legal
notice
demanding justice to the Chief Secretary, Home Department,
Government of Sikkim as well as the Respondent No.2. For the
first time the Petitioner protested about the selection of the
Respondent No.4 to the post of “Assistant Architect” as the
Respondent No.4 was not a registered “Architect”. This solitary
fact was also the sole ground for the demand for justice.
19. The Petitioner, aggrieved by the fact that although the legal
notice demanding justice had been duly received no action was
taken by the State-Respondents approached this Court by filing
the present Writ Petition on 28.10.2017 seeking to quash the
selection of Respondent No.4 for the post of “Assistant Architect”
and further for the Petitioners’ selection to the said post. Again,
the failure to register herself as a registered “Architect” is the sole
ground of attack on the Respondent No.4 by the Petitioner in the
present Writ Petition.
20. The Sikkim State Architect Service Recruitment Rules,
2001 is not under challenge in the present proceedings, nor is
the advertisement or the Office Order No. 2422/G/DOP dated
28.12.2016 appointing the Respondent No. 4 as “Assistant
Architect” in the junior grade of the Sikkim State Architect
Service Recruitment Rules, 2001. All that the Petitioner seeks is
the quashing of the selection of the Respondent No.4 and the
selection of the Petitioner to the post of the “Assistant Architect”
not on the ground of merit but on the sole ground that the
Respondent No. 4 was not a registered “Architect” on the date of
scrutiny.
21. Mr. Karma Thinlay, Learned Senior Government Advocate
would raise a preliminary objection on the locus standi of the
Petitioner to approach this Court challenging the selection of
Respondent No.4 after having consciously participated in the
selection process without any protest and having failed in the
said selection. Mr. Karma Thinlay would submit, and quite
correctly, that it is settled law that when a candidate appears at
an examination without objection and is subsequently found to
be not successful a challenge to the process is precluded. Mr.
Karma Thinlay would rely on the judgment of the Supreme Court
in re: Ramesh Chandra Shah & Ors. v. Anil Joshi & Ors.2 in which it
was held:
“18. It is settled law that a person who consciously takes part in
the process of selection cannot, thereafter, turn around and question
the method of selection and its outcome.
19. One of the earliest judgments on the subject is Manak Lal v.
Prem Chand Singhvi [AIR 1957 SC 425]. In that case, this Court
considered the question whether the decision taken by the High Court
on the allegation of professional misconduct levelled against the
appellant was vitiated due to bias of the Chairman of the Tribunal
constituted for holding inquiry into the allegation. The appellant alleged
that the Chairman had appeared for the complainant in an earlier
proceeding and, thus, he was disqualified to judge his conduct. This
Court held that by not having taken any objection against the
participation of the Chairman of the Tribunal in the inquiry held against
him, the appellant will be deemed to have waived his objection. Some
of the observations made in the judgment are extracted below: (AIR pp.
431-32, paras 8-9)
“8. … If, in the present case, it appears that the appellant
knew all the facts about the alleged disability of Shri Chhangani
and was also aware that he could effectively request the learned
Chief Justice to nominate some other member instead of Shri
Chhangani and yet did not adopt that course, it may well be that
he deliberately took a chance to obtain a report in his favour from
the Tribunal and when he came to know that the report had gone
against him he thought better of his rights and raised this point
before the High Court for the first time. …
9. From the record it is clear that the appellant never
raised this point before the Tribunal and the manner in which
this point was raised by him even before the High Court is
somewhat significant. The first ground of objection filed by the
appellant against the Tribunal's report was that Shri Chhangani
had pecuniary and personal interest in the complainant Dr Prem
Chand. The learned Judges of the High Court have found that
the allegations about the pecuniary interest of Shri Chhangani in
the present proceedings are wholly unfounded and this finding
has not been challenged before us by Shri Daphtary. The learned
Judges of the High Court have also found that the objection was
raised by the appellant before them only to obtain an order for a
fresh enquiry and thus gain time. … Since we have no doubt that
the appellant knew the material facts and must be deemed to
(2013) 11 SCC 309
have been conscious of his legal rights in that matter, his failure
to take the present plea at the earlier stage of the proceedings
creates an effective bar of waiver against him. It seems clear that
the appellant wanted to take a chance to secure a favourable
report from the Tribunal which was constituted and when he
found that he was confronted with an unfavourable report, he
adopted the device of raising the present technical point.”
20. In G. Sarana v. University of Lucknow [(1976) 3 SCC 585 :
1976 SCC (L&S) 474] , this Court held that the appellant who knew
about the composition of the Selection Committee and took a chance to
be selected cannot, thereafter, question the constitution of the
Committee.
21. In Om Prakash Shukla v. Akhilesh Kumar Shukla [1986
Supp SCC 285 : 1986 SCC (L&S) 644] , a three-Judge Bench ruled that
when the petitioner appeared in the examination without protest, he
was not entitled to challenge the result of the examination. The same
view was reiterated in Madan Lal v. State of J&K [(1995) 3 SCC 486 :
1995 SCC (L&S) 712 : (1995) 29 ATC 603] in the following words: (SCC
p. 493, para 9)
“9. … The petitioners also appeared at the oral interview
conducted by the Members concerned of the Commission who
interviewed the petitioners as well as the contesting respondents
concerned. Thus the petitioners took a chance to get themselves
selected at the said oral interview. Only because they did not
find themselves to have emerged successful as a result of their
combined performance both at written test and oral interview,
they have filed this petition. It is now well settled that if a
candidate takes a calculated chance and appears at the
interview, then, only because the result of the interview is not
palatable to him, he cannot turn round and subsequently contend
that the process of interview was unfair or the Selection
Committee was not properly constituted. In Om Prakash Shukla
v. Akhilesh Kumar Shukla [1986 Supp SCC 285 : 1986 SCC
(L&S) 644] it has been clearly laid down by a Bench of three
learned Judges of this Court that when the petitioner appeared at
the examination without protest and when he found that he
would not succeed in examination he filed a petition challenging
the said examination, the High Court should not have granted
any relief to such a petitioner.”
22. In Manish Kumar Shahi v. State of Bihar [(2010) 12 SCC 576
: (2011) 1 SCC (L&S) 256] , this Court reiterated the principle laid down
in the earlier judgments and observed: (SCC p. 584, para 16)
“16. We also agree with the High Court that after having
taken part in the process of selection knowing fully well that
more than 19% marks have been earmarked for viva voce test,
the petitioner is not entitled to challenge the criteria or process of
selection. Surely, if the petitioner's name had appeared in the
merit list, he would not have even dreamed of challenging the
selection. The petitioner invoked jurisdiction of the High Court
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India only after he found
that his name does not figure in the merit list prepared by the
Commission. This conduct of the petitioner clearly disentitles him
from questioning the selection and the High Court did not commit
any error by refusing to entertain the writ petition.”
23. The doctrine of waiver was also invoked in Vijendra Kumar
Verma v. Public Service Commission [(2011) 1 SCC 150 : (2011) 1 SCC
(L&S) 21] and it was held: (SCC p. 156, para 24)
“24. When the list of successful candidates in the written
examination was published in such notification itself, it was also
made clear that the knowledge of the candidates with regard to
basic knowledge of computer operation would be tested at the
time of interview for which knowledge of Microsoft Operating
System and Microsoft Office operation would be essential. In the
call letter also which was sent to the appellant at the time of
calling him for interview, the aforesaid criteria was reiterated
and spelt out. Therefore, no minimum benchmark or a new
procedure was ever introduced during the midstream of the
selection process. All the candidates knew the requirements of
the selection process and were also fully aware that they must
possess the basic knowledge of computer operation meaning
thereby Microsoft Operating System and Microsoft Office
operation. Knowing the said criteria, the appellant also appeared
in the interview, faced the questions from the expert of computer
application and has taken a chance and opportunity therein
without any protest at any stage and now cannot turn back to
state that the aforesaid procedure adopted was wrong and
without jurisdiction.”
24. In view of the propositions laid down in the above noted
judgments, it must be held that by having taken part in the process of
selection with full knowledge that the recruitment was being made
under the General Rules, the respondents had waived their right to
question the advertisement or the methodology adopted by the Board
for making selection and the learned Single Judge and the Division
Bench of the High Court committed grave error by entertaining the
grievance made by the respondents.”
22. In re: Ashok Kumar v. State of Bihar3 the Supreme Court
would examine the various judgments rendered by it earlier and
ultimately hold thus:“12. The appellants participated in the fresh process of selection. If
the appellants were aggrieved by the decision to hold a fresh process,
they did not espouse their remedy. Instead, they participated in the
fresh process of selection and it was only upon being unsuccessful that
they challenged the result in the writ petition. This was clearly not open
to the appellants. The principle of estoppel would operate.
13. The law on the subject has been crystallised in several
decisions of this Court. In Chandra Prakash Tiwari v. Shakuntala
Shukla [Chandra Prakash Tiwari v. Shakuntala Shukla, (2002) 6 SCC
127 : 2002 SCC (L&S) 830] , this Court laid down the principle that
when a candidate appears at an examination without objection and is
subsequently found to be not successful, a challenge to the process is
(2017) 4 SCC 357
precluded. The question of entertaining a petition challenging an
examination would not arise where a candidate has appeared and
participated. He or she cannot subsequently turn around and contend
that the process was unfair or that there was a lacuna therein, merely
because the result is not palatable. In Union of India v. S. Vinodh
Kumar [Union of India v. S. Vinodh Kumar, (2007) 8 SCC 100 : (2007) 2
SCC (L&S) 792] , this Court held that: (SCC p. 107, para 18)
“18. It is also well settled that those candidates who had
taken part in the selection process knowing fully well the
procedure laid down therein were not entitled to question the
same. (See Munindra Kumar v. Rajiv Govil [Munindra Kumar v.
Rajiv Govil, (1991) 3 SCC 368 : 1991 SCC (L&S) 1052] and
Rashmi Mishra v. M.P. Public Service Commission [Rashmi
Mishra v. M.P. Public Service Commission, (2006) 12 SCC 724 :
(2007) 2 SCC (L&S) 345] .)”
14. The same view was reiterated in Amlan Jyoti Borooah [Amlan
Jyoti Borooah v. State of Assam, (2009) 3 SCC 227 : (2009) 1 SCC
(L&S) 627] wherein it was held to be well settled that the candidates
who have taken part in a selection process knowing fully well the
procedure laid down therein are not entitled to question it upon being
declared to be unsuccessful.
15. In Manish Kumar Shahi v. State of Bihar [Manish Kumar Shahi
v. State of Bihar, (2010) 12 SCC 576 : (2011) 1 SCC (L&S) 256] , the
same principle was reiterated in the following observations: (SCC p.
584, para 16)
“16. We also agree with the High Court [Manish Kumar Shahi
v. State of Bihar, 2008 SCC OnLine Pat 321 : (2009) 4 SLR 272] that
after having taken part in the process of selection knowing fully well
that more than 19% marks have been earmarked for viva voce test,
the petitioner is not entitled to challenge the criteria or process of
selection. Surely, if the petitioner's name had appeared in the merit
list, he would not have even dreamed of challenging the selection.
The petitioner invoked jurisdiction of the High Court under Article
226 of the Constitution of India only after he found that his name
does not figure in the merit list prepared by the Commission. This
conduct of the petitioner clearly disentitles him from questioning the
selection and the High Court did not commit any error by refusing to
entertain the writ petition. Reference in this connection may be
made to the judgments in Madan Lal v. State of J&K [Madan Lal v.
State of J&K, (1995) 3 SCC 486 : 1995 SCC (L&S) 712] , Marripati
Nagaraja v. State of A.P. [Marripati Nagaraja v. State of A.P., (2007)
11 SCC 522 : (2008) 1 SCC (L&S) 68] , Dhananjay Malik v. State of
Uttaranchal [Dhananjay Malik v. State of Uttaranchal, (2008) 4 SCC
171 : (2008) 1 SCC (L&S) 1005 : (2008) 3 PLJR 271] , Amlan Jyoti
Borooah v. State of Assam [Amlan Jyoti Borooah v. State of Assam,
(2009) 3 SCC 227 : (2009) 1 SCC (L&S) 627] and K.A. Nagamani v.
Indian Airlines [K.A. Nagamani v. Indian Airlines,.”
16. In Vijendra Kumar Verma v. Public Service Commission
[Vijendra Kumar Verma v. Public Service Commission, (2011) 1 SCC
150 : (2011) 1 SCC (L&S) 21] , candidates who had participated in the
selection process were aware that they were required to possess
certain specific qualifications in computer operations. The appellants
had appeared in the selection process and after participating in the
interview sought to challenge the selection process as being without
jurisdiction. This was held to be impermissible.
17. In Ramesh Chandra Shah v. Anil Joshi [Ramesh Chandra Shah
v. Anil Joshi, (2013) 11 SCC 309 : (2011) 3 SCC (L&S) 129] ,
candidates who were competing for the post of Physiotherapist in the
State of Uttarakhand participated in a written examination held in
pursuance of an advertisement. This Court held that if they had
cleared the test, the respondents would not have raised any objection
to the selection process or to the methodology adopted. Having taken a
chance of selection, it was held that the respondents were disentitled
to seek relief under Article 226 and would be deemed to have waived
their right to challenge the advertisement or the procedure of selection.
This Court held that: (SCC p. 318, para 18)
“18. It is settled law that a person who consciously takes
part in the process of selection cannot, thereafter, turn around
and question the method of selection and its outcome.”
18. In Chandigarh Admn. v. Jasmine Kaur [Chandigarh Admn. v.
Jasmine Kaur, (2014) 10 SCC 521 : 6 SCEC 745] , it was held that a
candidate who takes a calculated risk or chance by subjecting himself
or herself to the selection process cannot turn around and complain
that the process of selection was unfair after knowing of his or her nonselection. In Pradeep Kumar Rai v. Dinesh Kumar Pandey [Pradeep
Kumar Rai v. Dinesh Kumar Pandey, (2015) 11 SCC 493 : (2015) 3
SCC (L&S) 274] , this Court held that: (SCC p. 500, para 17)
“17. Moreover, we would concur with the Division Bench
on one more point that the appellants had participated in the
process of interview and not challenged it till the results were
declared. There was a gap of almost four months between the
interview and declaration of result. However, the appellants did
not challenge it at that time. This, it appears that only when the
appellants found themselves to be unsuccessful, they challenged
the interview. This cannot be allowed. The candidates cannot
approbate and reprobate at the same time. Either the candidates
should not have participated in the interview and challenged the
procedure or they should have challenged immediately after the
interviews were conducted.”
This principle has been reiterated in a recent judgment in Madras
Institute of Development Studies v. K. Sivasubramaniyan [Madras
Institute of Development Studies v. K. Sivasubramaniyan, (2016) 1 SCC
454 : (2016) 1 SCC (L&S) 164 : 7 SCEC 462] .
“19. In the present case, regard must be had to the fact that the
appellants were clearly on notice, when the fresh selection process took
place that written examination would carry ninety marks and the
interview, ten marks. The appellants participated in the selection
process. Moreover, two other considerations weigh in balance. The
High Court noted in the impugned judgment that the interpretation of
Rule 6 was not free from vagueness. There was, in other words, no
glaring or patent illegality in the process adopted by the High Court.
There was an element of vagueness about whether Rule 6 which dealt
with promotion merely incorporated the requirement of an examination
provided in Rule 5 for direct recruitment to Class III posts or whether
the marks and qualifying marks were also incorporated. Moreover, no
prejudice was established to have been caused to the appellants by the
90 : 10 allocation.”
23. In the present case on the date of the advertisement dated
10.03.2016 the Petitioner was admittedly not a registered
“Architect”. The advertisement dated 10.03.2016 also did not
prescribed any requirement for the applicant to be a registered
“Architect”. Nevertheless, the Petitioner admittedly submitted her
application for the post of “Assistant Architect” on or before
09.04.2016 (i.e. the last date of submission of application as per
the advertisement dated 10.03.2016) knowing well that she was
even by then not a registered “Architect”. Between the date of
advertisement and the date of submission of application there
was a gap of one whole month for the Petitioner to take recourse
to the law and challenge the advertisement which was not done.
The Petitioner appeared in the written examination held on
02.07.2016 on which date she was a registered “Architect”
knowing well that the advertisement had not prescribed any
requirement for the applicants to be a registered “Architect” for
the post of “Assistant Architect” as well as the fact that therefore
there would have been other applicants who may not have been
a registered “Architect” on the date of the advertisement or on the
date of submission of the applications. On 04.08.2016 after a
month of the written examination when the names of the
successful candidates in the written examination were notified
by the Respondent No.2 it was clear that both the Petitioner as
well as
the
Respondent No. 4
had cleared the
written
examination. Even then the Petitioner participated in the
subsequent viva-voce held on 23.08.2016 nearly a month
thereafter along with other applicants including the Respondent
No. 4 who had succeeded in the written examination. The
Petitioner did not object to the participation of the Respondent
No.4 in the written examination as well as the viva-voce.
24.
Admittedly, the Petitioner had filed a Right to Information
application on 12.07.2017 with the Buildings & Housing
Department, raising three questions which were all answered by
the said Department on the same date. The said questions and
answers were as follows:“a)
Is the Council of Architecture regulations under the Architects
Act, 1972 followed in the State of Sikkim?
Ans: Yes, it is being followed.
b)
Is adherence to the said norms and registration with the Council
of Architecture mandatory for functioning as an Architects in the
State of Sikkim?
Ans: Yes, it is mandatory.
c)
Is Registration with the Council of Architecture mandatory to be
recruitment as an Architect under the Government of Sikkim?
Ans: Since the regulations under the Council of Architecture are
being followed, registration is mandatory.”
25. Significantly, therefore, on 12.07.2017 much before the
names of successful candidates had been notified on 04.08.2016
and viva-voce held on 23.08.2016 the Petitioner was informed
that the Council of Architecture Regulations under the Architects
Act, 1972 had been followed in the State of Sikkim and that
adherence to the said norms and registration with the Council of
“Architecture” was mandatory for functioning as an “Architect”.
In spite of the same, the Petitioner participated in the viva-voce
without any protest with the Respondent No. 4 on 23.08.2016
and was declared unsuccessful in the combined selection merit
list of the written examination as well as the viva-voce on
27.08.2016. In such circumstances, the law which is well settled
by the Supreme Court that a candidate who participates in the
selection process knowing well the procedure set down therein is
not
entitled
to
question
the
same
upon
being
declared
unsuccessful, would squarely apply to the Petitioner.
26. From the chronology of the events as set out hereinabove it
is quite evident that the Petitioner started the exercise of seeking
and gathering information about the requirement of registration
of “Architects” in Sikkim after having appeared in the written
examination on 02.07.2016. The Petitioner has nowhere averred
in the Writ Petition that she had submitted her registration
certificate at the time of submission of documents on 18.08.2016
along with the attested copies of all the required documents
mentioned
in
Notice
04.08.2016
for the
No.
149/SPSC/Exam/2016
purpose of
scrutiny
and
dated
verification.
Evidently, the objection of the Petitioner against the Respondent
No. 4 that she was not a registered “Architect” was an
afterthought solely for the purpose of taking advantage of her
being registered as an “Architect” six months prior to the
Respondent No.4’s registration to the Petitioner’s benefit and to
the detriment of the Respondent No. 4. To allow such an
objection to succeed would result in nullifying the merit of the
Respondent No. 4 in the written examination as well as viva-voce
and permitting the Petitioner to dislodge the Respondent No. 4 in
the merit list although admittedly the Petitioner was below the
Respondent No. 4 in merit. This would be impermissible as the
principal of waiver would also operate against the Petitioner.
Further, it is quite evident that there is no fault of the
Respondent No.4 in this entire situation.
27. The matter could have rested at that but the Petitioner also
contends that although the Architects Act, 1972 has not been
enforced in Sikkim, the State-Respondents have all along applied
the said Act in Sikkim and thus the use of the word “Assistant
Architect” to define the post in the advertisement could only
mean a registered “Architect” as defined in Section 2(a) of the
Architects Act, 1972. This plea, weighty as it seems, in the fact of
the present case, need only be mentioned to be rejected in limine.
If that be so, the Petitioner ought not to have applied for the post
of “Assistant Architect” when admittedly on the date of the
application the Petitioner was not a registered “Architect”. Thus,
although the Learned Counsel appearing for the Petitioner has
made extensive and impressive arguments basing his plea under
the Architects Act, 1972 this Court shall refrain from venturing
any finding on the same and leave the question open to be
decided appropriately in another case. It is seen that the
Respondent No.4 is now a registered “Architect” falling within the
definition of the said term in Section 2(a) of the Architects Act,
1972 and as such there would be no impediment for her to hold
the post of “Assistant Architect”.
28. The Writ Petition is dismissed. Parties to bear their
respective costs.
(Bhaskar Raj Pradhan)
Judge
10.04.2018
Approved for reporting: yes.
Internet: yes.
tsh/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review