Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3484 I
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
,, ',,.,]:
FR]DAY, THE NINTH DAY OF JANUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M. MOHIUDDIN
CIVIL MISCELLANEOUS
NO: 420 OF 2020
Appeal under Section 30 of Workmen's Compensation Act against the Ordei
dated 16-03.2020 passed in E.C.No.151 of 2008 on the file of the Commissioner for
Employees' Compensation and Assistant Commissioner of Labour-lv, T. Anjaiah
Karmika Samkshema Bhavanam, Hyderabad.
Between
lVlirza Azam Begh, S/o. tttlirza lbrahim Begh, Age. 24 years, Occ: Cleaner R/o.
H.No.5-24. Srinivas Nagar, Chatrinaka, Hyderabad...APPELLANT/APPLICANT
AND
tM. Gopichand, S/o. M Venkat Subbaiah, Age: Major, Occ: Business, R/o. HNo.7-86, Rudrur Village, Bodhan ltllandal, Nizamabad District.
United lndia lnsurance Company Limited, Represented by its Senior
Divisional Manager, 2nd Floor Ramalaya Building, Paradise Circle
Secunderabad
...RESPONDENTS/OPPOSITE PARTIES No.l & 2
Counsel for the Appellant: Sri C. Mohan Prakash
Counsel for the Respondent No.2: Smt. P. Satya Manjula
The Court delivered the following: JUDGMENT
IN TftE HIGH COURT F.OR THE STATT OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE G.M.MOHIUDDIN
CTWL MISCELLANEOUS
No.42O OF 2O2O
pATE:oq.o1.2026
BETWEEN:
Mirza Azam Begh.
....Appellant
AND
M.Gopichand and another.
....Respondents
JUDGMENT
The present appeal is filed by the appellant/claimant for
enhancerr;ent of compensation, aggrieved by the order dated
L6.O3.2O2O passed in E.C.No.151 of 2008 on the file of learned
Commissioner for Employees' Compensation and Assistant
Commissioner of Labour-IV, Hyderabad (hereafter "the Tribunal" for
brevity).
2.
The brief facts of the case are tl.at the appellant was employed
as a cleaner on the lorry bearing No.AP-25-T-640, owned by
respondent No.1. On 27.O8.2OO7, while the appellant was discharging
his dutiesr as cleaner, he accompanied the driver of the said lorry to
Reddy La'f,s, Jeedimetla, for the purpose of loading waste water- The
driver stopped the lorry at the gate of Reddy Labs, and the appellant
\ o\
was engaged in fitting the silencer of the vehicle. In the meantime, the
driver suddenly drove t.l'e lorry in a rash and negligent manner,
causing one of the tyres to run over the appellant's right leg. As a
result, the appellant sustained grievous injuries including a Type-III B
compound fracture of the tibia, a fracture of the frbula and a crush
injury to the right foot along with other multiple injuries over the body.
Immediately after the accident, the appellant was shifted to NIMS
Hospital, where he underwent inpatient treatment and a major surgical
operation. A case in Crime No.722 of 2OO7 was registered by P.S
Jeedimetla and the appellant frled an application before the Tribunal
seeking compensation of Rs.4,OO,00O/-. The lorry was insured with
respondent No.2 and the insurance polrcy was subsisting as on the
dat3 of accident. Hence, respondent Nos.l and 2 are jointly and
severally liable to pay compensation.
3.
After the receipt of notice, respondent Nos.1 and 2 filed counter
wherein, respondent No.1 admitted the employment of the appellant,
but denied his liability ro pay compensation on the ground. that the
appellant has insured his lorry bearing No.AP-25-T-640 with
respondent No.2 and he is not liable to pay compensation. Respondent
No.2 in the counter affidavit has denied the averments mentioned in
the appellant's application including the relationship between tl.e
employee and employer and contended that appellant was only a
J
gratuitous passenger and the claim of compensation is excessive and
prayed to clismiss the application.
4.
During the course of trial before the Tribunal, A.W.Nos.1 and 2
were examinecl and Exs.Al to A11 were marked on behalf of appellant
and nobody was examined on behalf of respondentS and Ex.Bi marked
with the ,:onsent of both the learned counsel. The Tribunal after
considering the evidence on record, oral and documentary evidence
has awarded Rs.2,34,O251- along with 9% per annum on the amount
of compensation frorn 22.08.2014 to 22.08.2016 and from 28.09.2OO7
to 2O.12.?-OLL and from 16.03.2020 till the date of realization.
Dissatished with the quantum of compensation, the present Civil
Miscellaneous Appeal is filed by the appellant/applicant seeking
enhancement of compensation.
5.
Heard Sri C.Mohan Prakash, learned counsel for the appellant
and Smt.l).Satya Manjula, learned counsel for respondent No.2 and
perused the record.
6.
It is the contention of the learned counsel for the appellant that
the Tribunal has fixed the monthly income of the appellant as
Rs.2,944.'.25 ps., per month onlyrby relying on the Minimum Rates of
Wages {ixr:d by Government of Telangana, Hyderabad in employment of
Public Motor Transport under G.O.Ms.No.83, L.E.T & F (Lab-ll)
\
\
i
ii
li
i
Department dated 22.II.2006, whereas, the appellant is a cleaner and
I
i
claimed Rs.3,500/- and Rs.SO/- per day towards batta'
i
Z.
The learned counsel for the appetlant further contended that the
appellant was employed as cleaner and sustained injuries arising out
of his employment, resulting in permanent disability, as evidenced by
Ex.A6 (Disability Certificate), rendering him to unfit to continue his
work and further contended that A.W.2 - Doctor who treated the
appellant had estimated the permanent disability at 4oo/o and loss of
earning capacity at 45o/o and on re-examination at the time of
deposition, he assessed the loss of earning capacity at 8Oo/o- However,
the Tribunal failed to consider the same and granted 600/o for loss of
earning capacity.
8.
Further, it was contended that the learned Commissioner erred
in law by restricting interest to the periods from 28.O9.2OO4 to
2O.L2.2OL1 and from 16.03.2020 onwards, instead of awarding
interest from the date of accident till realization on the ground of non-
pursuit of the claim which is illegal and contrary to law and prayed to
allow the appeal.
g.
Per @ntra, the learned counsel for the respondent No.2
contended that tJ:e Tribunal rightly fixed the monthly income of the
appellant based on the minimum wages notified under G-O.Ms'No'83
dated 22.1L.2OO6, as the appellant failed to produce any proof to
*/
support his claim of Rs.3,SOO/- per month and Rs.SOl- per day as
batta. It tiras further contended that the Tribunal duly considered
Ex-A6 while awarding compensation and that there was no evidence of
total funct.ional disability, and the restriction of interest to specific
periods was justified as the delay in prosecuting the claim was due to
the appellzLnt himself.
1(). 1 fusrze taken note of the respective contentions urged.
11. On Jrerusal of the impugned order dated L6.O3.2O2O, it is evident
that the Commissioner, after a detailed and proper appreciation of the
oral and clocumentary evidence more particularly evidence of A.Ws.1
and 2 an<l Exs.Al to A11 and Ex.Bl has conclusively held that the
accident occurred on 27.O8.2OO7 during the course of and arising out
of the enrployment of the appellant and granted compensation of
Rs.2,31,563 /-.
L2. Though, the learned counsel for the appellant has raised
contentiorr that the Tribunal has erred in considering the monthly
income as Rs.2,944.251- including Variable Dearness Allowance
(V.D.A) a:i per G.O.Ms.No.83, L.E.T & F (Lab-II) Department dated
22.1L.2OC6 and the appellant was working as a cleaner and earning
.t
Rs.3,SOO/- per month besides Rs.SO/- per day towards batfa. It is to
be noted that, it is an admitted fact that no documentary evidence was
produced by the appellant to substantiate the aforesaid claim.
\
\
\
13' In @utpreet Kaur u. trnited rndia Insurance compang
Limlted'L the Hon'ble Supreme court has held that
issued under the Minimum wages Act can be taken
the Notification
as a guiding factor
only in a case where there is no material available to
assess the
monthly income of the claimant. In the present case, the
absence of
documentary evidence regarding the actual income
of the appelrant is
admitted- Hence, the Tribunal is justified in determining
income of the apperlant based on the minimum wages
the monthly
notification.
14- Therefore, the Tribunar has rightry fixed the monthly income of
the appellant as Rs.2,944-2s/- per month including v.D.A
G'o.Ms.No.83, L.E.T & F (Lab-II) Department dated
as per
22.rr.2006.
15. The learned counsel for the appellant contends that A.w.2 had,
estimated partial and permanent disability at 4oo/o
and loss of earning
capacity at 45o/o and on re-examination, assessed the loss
capacity at 8O%o without any valid basis. In the opinion
of earning
of t6is Court,
the Tribunal after considering the medical evidence and the
overall
facts and circumstances of the case, rightly assessed the
loss of
earning capacity at 60%o.It is pertinent to note that such assessment
by the Tribunal reflects a balanced and reasonable approach. The
Tribunar has neither mechanicaly accepted the higher estimate
ignored the medical opinion. The appellant has no material
' uRNU/scowgllo4/2022 = 2023 (6) KHC 601
nor
to show
that the assessment is arbitrary and unreasonable- Hence, the finding
of the Tribunal in fixing the loss of earning capacity at 600/o does not
call for any interference by this Court-
16. Coming to the point of awarding interest, the Tribunal has
granted ccmpensation along with interest @ 9o/o per annum on the
amount ol compensation from 22.08.2014 to 22.08-2016 and from
28.Og.2OO'l to 20.12.2011 and from L6.O3.2O20 ful till the date of
realization on the ground that the appellant has not pursued the claim
applicatiorL. The liability to pay interest under the Act is statutory and
compensatory in nature. The interest is awarded to cornpensate the
workman for delay in receiving compensation and to enforce the
beneficial object of the welfare legislation. Once tl.e compensation
becomes due, payment of interest follows as a matter of law-
L7. It is; trite law, that the statute does not permit denial or
reduction of interest on the ground of procedural delay or alleged
laches on the part of the claimant. The Apex Court in T.C. John
(Deceaseat) through L.Rs u. V.J.Antong and others2 has held that
the proce<lural delays, even if assumed, cannot defeat a substantive
statutory r'ight conferred under a social welfare enactment-
18. After the liability to pay compensation is established, the
insurer, having stepped into the shoes of the employer, is bound to pay
)
)
MRNU/sci 1373/2024=2024 (15)scAl.E 769
i
\
\
interest strictly in accordance with Section aA(3)(a) of the Act. The
Tribunal, therefore, had no authority to restrict the award of interest
for certain periods.
19. The restriction imposed by the Tribunal is thus contrary to law
and cannot be upheld.
20. [n view of the clear findings recorded by the commissioner with
regard to employment, occurrence of accident of the appellant, this
Court finds no reason to interfere with the quantum of compensation.
However, the appellant is entitled to receive the compensation along
with interest @ 9o/o per annum from the date of accident till realization.
2L. Accordingly, this civil Miscellaneous Appeal is disposed. of. There
shall be no order as to costs.
As a sequel, pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shall
stand closed.
,r
SD'. T.KRISHNA KUMAR
JOINT REGISTRAR
'I
I:I
I
ti
,i
:t
/TRUE COPY//
ii
SECTION OFFICER
To,
I
I
1. The Commissioner , for Employees' Compensation and Assistant
commissioner of Labour-lV, T. Anjaiah Karmika samkshema Bhavanam,
i
I
]
a
I
Hyderabad.(with records, if anY)
2. Ohe CC to Sri C. Mohan Prakash, Advocate [OPUC]
3. One CC to Smt. P. Satya Manjula, Advocate IOPUC]
4. Two CD Copies
Kam/PSL
I
i
HIGH COT'RT
)
DATED:09/01 12026
r,,,rt J.Ia d€
,i
1[ llll\R
JUDGMEINT
*
CMA.N o.,l20 of 2020
DISPOSilNG THE CMA
\
il a,6
zUIfi
t
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review