Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
AGARTALA
B.A.No.41 of 2025
Smt. Minu Rani Das,
W/o: Sri Narayan Ch. Das, resident of Unnayan Sangha,
Near Unnayan Sangha, Howrah, P.S.-A.D. Nagar, West Tripura
….. Applicant
For/on behalf of
Sri Suman Das,
S/o: Sri Narayan Chandra Das, resident of North Badharghat,
Near Unnayan Sangha, P.S.: A.D. Nagar, West Tripura.
----Accused Person(s)
Versus
The State of Tripura
----Respondent(s)
____________________________________________________________
For Applicant(s)
:
Mr. Bibhal Nandi Majumder, Sr. Adv.
Mr. Dhruba Jyoti Saha, Adv.
[---
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Raju Datta, P.P.
_____________________________________________________________
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BISWAJIT PALIT
Order
27/06/2025
This bail application under Section 483 of BNSS, 2023 is filed for
granting bail to the accused person in custody namely, Sri Suman Das in
connection
with
R.K.
Pur
PS
case
No.21
of
under
Sections
318(4)/318(3)/61(2)(a) of BNS with added Sections 316(5)/336/340(2) of
BNS, 2023.
Heard Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. Bibhal Nandi Majumder
assisted by Learned Counsel, Mr. Dhruba Jyoti Saha appearing on behalf of
the accused in custody. Also heard Learned P.P., Mr. Raju Datta appearing
on behalf of the State-respondent.
As ordered earlier, Learned P.P. has produced the case diary
today.
(2)
In course of hearing of argument, Learned Senior counsel for the
accused in custody first of all drawn the attention of this Court referring the
contents of the F.I.R. and submitted that there is no dispute on record that
the money of the informant was misappropriated from her respective
accounts. Learned Senior Counsel thereafter drawn the attention of this
Court to the fact that investigation of this case is completed and by this time
the I.O. has submitted charge-sheet against the present accused in custody
and the other accused persons and from the report of the I.O. it only
transpires that the present accused in custody only misappropriated
Rs.20,000/- which is also subjected to proof. Furthermore, Learned Senior
Counsel submitted that the accused is lodging in custody on and from
27.03.2025. So, considering the period of his detention in custody the
accused person may be released on bail in any condition. Learned Senior
Counsel at the time of hearing of argument made two different submissions.
Firstly, Learned Senior Counsel submitted that there is/are no materials on
record justifying the detention of the present accused and secondly,
referring the order passed by a co-ordinate bench of this Court in AB No.31
of 2019 dated 07.05.2019 and the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court
of India in Criminal Appeal No.818 of 2025 dated 18.02.2025[Subhelal
@ Sushil Sahu vs. The State of Chhattisgarh reported in (2025) 5 SCC
140] he submitted that a direction may be given to deposit a portion of
amount by the accused in custody.
In the first phase of his submission Learned Senior Counsel
relied upon one citation of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Sanjay
Chandra vs. Central Bureau of Investigation reported in (2011) AIR
SCW 6838 wherein in para Nos.25 and 26, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed
as under:“25. Coming back to the facts of the present case, both the
Courts have refused the request for grant of bail on two
grounds:- The primary ground is that offence alleged
against the accused persons is very serious involving deep
rooted planning in which, huge financial loss is caused to
the State Exchequer; the secondary ground is that the
(3)
possibility of the accused persons tempering with the
witness. In the present case, the charge is that of cheating
and dishonestly inducing delivery of property, forgery for
the purpose of cheating using as genuine a forged
document. The punishment of the offence is punishment for
a term which may extend to seven years. It is, no doubt,
true that the nature of the charge may be relevant, but at
the same time, the punishment to which the party may be
liable, if convicted, also bears upon the issue. Therefore, in
determining whether to grant bail, both the seriousness of
the charge and the severity of the punishment should be
taken into consideration. The grant or refusal to grant bail
lies within the discretion of the Court. The grant or denial is
regulated, to a large extent, by the facts and circumstances
of each particular case. But at the same time, right to bail is
not to be denied merely because of the sentiments of the
community against the accused. The primary purposes of
bail in a criminal case are to relieve the accused of
imprisonment, to relieve the State of the burden of keeping
him, pending the trial, and at the same time, to keep the
accused constructively in the custody of the Court, whether
before or after conviction, to assure that he will submit to
the jurisdiction of the Court and be in attendance thereon
whenever his presence is required. This Court in Gurcharan
Singh and Ors. v. State, AIR 1978 SC 179, observed that
two paramount considerations, while considering petition
for grant of bail in non-bailable offence, apart from the
seriousness of the offence, are the likelihood of the accused
fleeing from justice and his tampering with the prosecution
witnesses. Both of them relate to ensure of the fair trial of
the case. Though, this aspect is dealt by the High Court in
its impugned order, in our view, the same is not convincing.
26. When the under-trial prisoners are detained in jail
custody to an indefinite period, Article 21 of the
Constitution is violated. Every person, detained or arrested,
is entitled to speedy trial, the question is: whether the same
is possible in the present case. There are seventeen
accused persons. Statement of the witnesses runs to
several hundred pages and the documents on which
reliance is placed by the prosecution, is voluminous. The
trial may take considerable time and it looks to us that the
appellants, who are in jail, have to remain in jail longer
than the period of detention, had they been convicted. It is
not in the interest of justice that accused should be in jail
for an indefinite period. No doubt, the offence alleged
against the appellants is a serious one in terms of alleged
huge loss to the State Exchequer, that, by itself, should not
deter us from enlarging the appellants on bail when there is
no serious contention of the respondent that the accused, if
released on bail, would interfere with the trial or tamper
with evidence. We do not see any good reason to detain the
accused in custody, that too, after the completion of the
investigation and filing of the charge-sheet. This Court, in
the case of State of Kerala v. Raneef (2011) 1 SCC 784:
(AIR 2011 SC 340), has stated :"15. In deciding bail applications an important factor
which should certainly be taken into consideration by
the court is the delay in concluding the trial. Often this
takes several years, and if the accused is denied bail
but is ultimately acquitted, who will restore so many
years of his life spent in custody? Is Article 21 of the
Constitution, which is the most basic of all the
fundamental rights in our Constitution, not violated in
such a case? Of course this is not the only factor, but it
is certainly one of the important factors in deciding
whether to grant bail. In the present case the
respondent has already spent 66 days in custody (as
stated in Para 2 of his counter-affidavit), and we see
no reason why he should be denied bail. A doctor
(4)
incarcerated for a long period may end up like Dr.
Manette in Charles Dicken's novel A Tale of Two Cities,
who forgot his profession and even his name in the
Bastille."”
Referring the same Learned Senior Counsel submitted that in
view of the law laid down by Hon’ble the Apex Court, the accused in custody
may be released on bail in any condition.
Learned Senior Counsel, Mr. Majumder referred another citation
of Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in P. Chidambaram vs. Directorate of
Enforcement reported in AIR 2020 SC 1699 wherein in Para Nos.21 and
22, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:“21. Thus from cumulative perusal of the judgments cited
on either side including the one rendered by the
Constitution Bench of this Court, it could be deduced that
the basic jurisprudence relating to bail remains the same
inasmuch as the grant of bail is the rule and refusal is the
exception so as to ensure that the accused has the
opportunity of securing fair trial. However, while
considering the same the gravity of the offence is an aspect
which is required to be kept in view by the Court. The
gravity for the said purpose will have to be gathered from
the facts and circumstances arising in each case. Keeping in
view the consequences that would befall on the society in
cases of financial irregularities, it has been held that even
economic offences would fall under the category of "grave
offence" and in such circumstance while considering the
application for bail in such matters, the Court will have to
deal with the same, being sensitive to the nature of
allegation made against the accused. One of the
circumstances to consider the gravity of the offence is also
the term of sentence that is prescribed for the offence the
accused is alleged to have committed. Such consideration
with regard to the gravity of offence is a factor which is in
addition to the triple test or the tripod test that would be
normally applied. In that regard what is also to be kept in
perspective is that even if the allegation is one of grave
economic offence, it is not a rule that bail should be denied
in every case since there is no such bar created in the
relevant enactment passed by the legislature nor does the
bail jurisprudence provides so. Therefore, the underlining
conclusion is that irrespective of the nature and gravity of
charge, the precedent if another case alone will not be the
basis for either grant or refusal of bail though it may have a
bearing on principle. But ultimately the consideration will
have to be on case to case basis on the facts involved
therein and securing the presence of the accused to stand
trial.
22. In the above circumstance it would be clear that even
after concluding the triple test in favour of the appellant the
learned Judge of the High Court was certainly justified in
adverting to the issue relating to the gravity of the offence.
However, we disapprove the manner in which the
conclusions are recorded in paragraphs 57 to 62 wherein
the observations are reflected to be in the nature of finding
relating to the alleged offence. The learned senior counsel
for the appellant with specific reference to certain
observations contained in the above noted paragraphs has
(5)
pointed out that the very contentions to that effect as
contained in paragraphs 17, 20 and 24 of the counter
affidavit has been incorporated as if, it is the findings of the
Court. The learned Solicitor General while seeking to
controvert such contention would however contend that in
addition to the counter affidavit the respondent had also
furnished the documents in a sealed cover which was taken
note by the learned Judge and conclusion has been
reached.”
Referring the same Learned Senior Counsel submitted that
considering the nature of allegation against the accused in custody he may
be released on bail.
Again, Learned Senior Counsel referred another citation of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Satender Kumar Antil vs. Central
Bureau of Investigation & Anr. reported in AIR 2022 SC 3386 wherein
in para Nos.66 and 68 Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:“ECONOMIC OFFENCES (CATEGORY D)
66. What is left for us now to discuss are the economic
offences. The question for consideration is whether it
should be treated as a class of its own or otherwise. This
issue has already been dealt with by this Court in the case
of P. Chidambaram v. Directorate of Enforcement, (2020)
13 SCC 791: (AIR 2020 SC 1699), after taking note of the
earlier decisions governing the field. The gravity of the
offence, the object of the Special Act, and the attending
circumstances are a few of the factors to be taken note of,
along with the period of sentence. After all, an economic
offence cannot be classified as such, as it may involve
various activities and may differ from one case to another.
Therefore, it is not advisable on the part of the court to
categorise all the offences into one group and deny bail on
that basis. Suffice it to state that law, as laid down in the
following judgements, will govern the field:Precedents
P. Chidambaram v. Directorate of Enforcement, (2020)
13 SCC 791 : (AIR 2020 SC 1699):
23. Thus, from cumulative perusal of the judgments
cited on either side including the one rendered by the
Constitution Bench of this Court, it could be deduced
that the basic jurisprudence relating to bail remains
the same inasmuch as the grant of bail is the rule and
refusal is the exception so as to ensure that the
accused has the opportunity of securing fair trial.
However, while considering the same the gravity of
the offence is an aspect which is required to be kept in
view by the Court. The gravity for the said purpose will
have to be gathered from the facts and circumstances
arising in each case. Keeping in view the consequences
that would befall on the society in cases of financial
irregularities, it has been held that even economic
offences would fall under the category of "grave
offence" and in such circumstance while considering
the application for bail in such matters, the Court will
have to deal with the same, being sensitive to the
nature of allegation made against the accused. One of
the circumstances to consider the gravity of the
offence is also the term of sentence that is prescribed
for the offence the accused is alleged to have
(6)
committed. Such consideration with regard to the
gravity of offence is a factor which is in addition to the
triple test or the tripod test that would be normally
applied. In that regard what is also to be kept in
perspective is that even if the allegation is one of
grave economic offence, it is not a rule that bail should
be denied in every case since there is no such bar
created in the relevant enactment passed by the
legislature nor does the bail jurisprudence provide so.
Therefore,
the
underlining
conclusion
is
that
irrespective of the nature and gravity of charge, the
precedent of another case alone will not be the basis
for either grant or refusal of bail though it may have a
bearing on principle. But ultimately the consideration
will have to be on case-to-case basis on the facts
involved therein and securing the presence of the
accused to stand trial.
Sanjay Chandra v. CBI (2012) 1 SCC 40: (AIR 2012 SC
830):
"39. Coming back to the facts of the present case, both
the courts have refused the request for grant of bail on
two grounds: the primary ground is that the offence
alleged against the accused persons is very serious
involving deep-rooted planning in which, huge
financial loss is caused to the State exchequer; the
secondary ground is that of the possibility of the
accused persons tampering with the witnesses. In the
present case, the charge is that of cheating and
dishonestly inducing delivery of property and forgery
for the purpose of cheating using as genuine a forged
document. The punishment for the offence is
imprisonment for a term which may extend to seven
years. It is, no doubt, true that the nature of the
charge may be relevant, but at the same time, the
punishment to which the party may be liable, if
convicted, also bears upon the issue. Therefore, in
determining whether to grant bail, both the
seriousness of the charge and the severity of the
punishment should be taken into consideration.
40. The grant or refusal to grant bail lies within the
discretion of the court. The grant or denial is
regulated, to a large extent, by the facts and
circumstances of each particular case. But at the same
time, right to bail is not to be denied merely because
of the sentiments of the community against the
accused. The primary purposes of bail in a criminal
case are to relieve the accused of imprisonment, to
relieve the State of the burden of keeping him, pending
the trial, and at the same time, to keep the accused
constructively in the custody of the court, whether
before or after conviction, to assure that he will submit
to the jurisdiction of the court and be in attendance
thereon whenever his presence is required.
xxx xxx xxx
46. We are conscious of the fact that the accused are
charged with economic offences of huge magnitude.
We are also conscious of the fact that the offences
alleged, if proved, may jeopardise the economy of the
country. At the same time, we cannot lose sight of the
fact that the investigating agency has already
completed investigation and the charge-sheet is
already filed before the Special Judge, CBI, New Delhi.
Therefore, their presence in the custody may not be
necessary for further investigation. We are of the view
that the appellants are entitled to the grant of bail
pending trial on stringent conditions in order to ally
the apprehension expressed by CBI."
(7)
68. Criminal courts in general with the trial court in
particular are the guardian angels of liberty. Liberty, as
embedded in the Code, has to be preserved, protected, and
enforced by the Criminal Courts. Any conscious failure by
the Criminal Courts would constitute an affront to liberty. It
is the pious duty of the Criminal Court to zealously guard
and keep a consistent vision in safeguarding the
constitutional values and ethos. A criminal court must
uphold the constitutional thrust with responsibility
mandated on them by acting akin to a high priest. This
Court in Arnab Manoranjan Goswami v. State of
Maharashtra, (2021) 2 SCC 427: (AIR 2021 SC 1), has
observed that:
"67. Human liberty is a precious constitutional value,
which is undoubtedly subject to regulation by validly
enacted legislation. As such, the citizen is subject to
the edicts of criminal law and procedure. Section 482
recognises the inherent power of the High Court to
make such orders as are necessary to give effect to the
provisions of CrPC "or prevent abuse of the process of
any court or otherwise to secure the ends of justice".
Decisions of this Court require the High Courts, in
exercising the jurisdiction entrusted to them under
Section
482,
to
act
with
circumspection.
In
emphasising that the High Court must exercise this
power with a sense of restraint, the decisions of this
Court are founded on the basic principle that the due
enforcement of criminal law should not be obstructed
by the accused taking recourse to artifices and
strategies. The public interest in ensuring the due
investigation of crime is protected by ensuring that the
inherent power of the High Court is exercised with
caution. That indeed is one-and a significant-end of the
spectrum. The other end of the spectrum is equally
important: the recognition by Section 482 of the power
inhering in the High Court to prevent the abuse of
process or to secure the ends of justice is a valuable
safeguard for protecting liberty. The Code of Criminal
Procedure, 1898 was enacted by a legislature which
was not subject to constitutional rights and
limitations; yet it recognised the inherent power in
Section 561-A. Post-Independence, the recognition by
Parliament [Section 482 CrPC, 1973] of the inherent
power of the High Court must be construed as an aid to
preserve the constitutional value of liberty. The writ of
liberty runs through the fabric of the Constitution. The
need to ensure the fair investigation of crime is
undoubtedly important in itself, because it protects at
one level the rights of the victim and, at a more
fundamental level, the societal interest in ensuring
that crime is investigated and dealt with in accordance
with law. On the other hand, the misuse of the criminal
law is a matter of which the High Court and the lower
courts in this country must be alive. In the present
case, the High Court could not but have been cognizant
of the specific ground which was raised before it by
the appellant that he was being made a target as a
part of a series of occurrences which have been taking
place since April 2020. The specific case of the
appellant is that he has been targeted because his
opinions on his television channel are unpalatable to
authority. Whether the appellant has established a
case for quashing the FIR is something on which the
High Court will take a final view when the proceedings
are listed before it but we are clearly of the view that
in failing to make even a prima facie evaluation of the
FIR, the High Court abdicated its constitutional duty
and function as a protector of liberty. Courts must be
alive to the need to safeguard the public interest in
ensuring that the due enforcement of criminal law is
(8)
not obstructed. The fair investigation of crime is an aid
to it. Equally it is the duty of courts across the
spectrum-the district judiciary, the High Courts and
the Supreme Court-to ensure that the criminal law
does not become a weapon for the selective
harassment of citizens. Courts should be alive to both
ends of the spectrum-the need to ensure the proper
enforcement of criminal law on the one hand and the
need, on the other, of ensuring that the law does not
become a ruse for targeted harassment. Liberty across
human eras is as tenuous as tenuous can be. Liberty
survives by the vigilance of her citizens, on the
cacophony of the media and in the dusty corridors of
courts alive to the rule of (and not by) law. Yet, much
too often, liberty is a casualty when one of these
components is found wanting."
(emphasis supplied)
Referring the same Learned Senior Counsel again submitted that
there is no reason to disallow the present bail application of the accused in
custody considering the materials on record so far collected by the I.O.
during the investigation. Finally, Learned Senior Counsel referred to a
judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Criminal Appeal
No.818 of 2025 dated 18.02.2025[Subhelal @ Sushil Sahu vs. The
State of Chhattisgarh reported in (2025) 5 SCC 140] wherein in para
Nos.19 and 22, 23, 24 and 25, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“19. This Court is of a considered view that
applications under Section 437(6) have to be given a
liberal approach and it would be a sound and judicious
exercise of discretion in favour of the accused by the
court concerned more particularly where there is no
chance of tampering of evidence e.g. where the case
depends on documentary evidence which is already
collected; where there is no fault on part of the
accused in causing of delay; where there are no
chances of any abscondence by the accused; where
there is little scope for conclusion of trial in near
future; where the period for which accused has been in
jail is substantial in comparison to the sentence
prescribed for the offence for which he is tried. Normal
parameters for deciding bail application would also be
relevant while deciding application under Section
437(6) of the Code, but not with that rigour as they
might have been at the time of application for regular
bail.
22. In the overall view of the matter, we are convinced
that the appellant deserves to be released on bail,
subject to certain terms and conditions as may be
imposed by the trial court. It is ordered accordingly.
23. However, we on our own would like to impose one
condition.
24. According to the learned counsel appearing for the
appellant herein, the total amount involved in the
alleged scam is approximately Rs 4 crores but he
attributes about Rs 35 lakhs to the appellant herein.
(9)
25. For the purpose of bail and in the peculiar facts
and circumstances of the case, we direct the appellant
herein to deposit an amount of Rs 35,00,000 (Rupees
35 lakhs) with the trial court within a period of six
months from today.”
Referring the same, Learned Senior Counsel submitted that in
view of the above citations of Hon’ble the Apex Court a direction may be
given to the accused in custody to deposit the required amount in the event
of his release on bail.
On the other hand, Learned P.P. taking part in the hearing
submitted that in this case allegation against the accused in custody and
others were very serious in nature. They by their act and conduct damaged
the reputation of the Bank in the eyes of the customers specifically the
present informant who was defrauded by their alleged activities. Learned
P.P. further submitted that although charge-sheet is submitted in this case,
there is still prayer from the side of I.O. for holding custody trial of the
accused and there is likelihood of submitting supplementary charge-sheet.
Further, since it is a case of economic offence so at this stage, for proper
trial of the case, the bail application be rejected.
In this regard, Learned P.P. relied upon one citation of the High
Court of Orissa reported in Ashwini Kumar Patra vs. Republic of India
reported in 2021 SCC OnLine Ori 439 wherein Hon’ble the High Court of
Orissa in para Nos.8 and 9 has been pleased to observe as under:
“8. The accusation against the petitioner relates to
commission
of
economic
offences
which
are
considered to be grave offences and are to be viewed
seriously. Such offences affect the economy of the
country as a whole and it involves deep-rooted
conspiracy and huge loss of public fund. It is
committed with cool calculation and deliberate design
solely with an eye on personal profit regardless of the
consequence to the community. In such type of
offences, while granting bail, the Court has to keep in
mind, inter alia, the larger interest of public and State.
The nature and seriousness of an economic offence
and its impact on the society are always important
considerations in such a case and those aspects must
squarely be dealt with by the Court while passing an
order on bail applications. (Ref : - Y.S. Jagan Mohan
Reddy v. C.B.I. reported in (2013) 7 SCC 439, State of
Gujarat v. Mohanlal Jitamalji Porwal reported in
(1987) 2 SCC 364).
(10)
9. In the case of Y.S. Jagan Mohan Reddy (supra), it is
held as follows:—
“34. Economic offences constitute a class apart
and need to be visited with a different approach
in the matter of bail. The economic offence having
deep-rooted conspiracies and involving huge loss
of public funds need to be viewed seriously and
considered as grave offences affecting the
economy of the country as a whole and thereby
posing serious threat to the financial health of the
country.
35. While granting bail, the Court has to keep in
mind the nature of accusations, the nature of
evidence in support thereof, the severity of the
punishment which conviction will entail, the
character of the accused, circumstances which
are peculiar to the accused, reasonable possibility
of securing the presence of the accused at the
trial, reasonable apprehension of the witnesses
being tampered with, the larger interests of
public/State and other similar considerations.”
Learned P.P. also referred to another citation of Hon’ble the
Supreme Court of India in Nimmagadda Prasad vs. Central Bureau of
Investigation reported in (2013) 7 SCC 466 wherein in para Nos. 23, 24
and 25, Hon’ble the Apex Court as under:
“23. Unfortunately, in the last few years, the
country has been seeing an alarming rise in
white-collar crimes, which has affected the fibre
of
the
country's
economic
structure.
Incontrovertibly, economic offences have serious
repercussions on the development of the country
as a whole. In State of Gujarat v. Mohanlal
Jitamalji Porwal [(1987) 2 SCC 364 : 1987 SCC
(Cri) 364] this Court, while considering a request
of the prosecution for adducing additional
evidence, inter alia, observed as under: (SCC p.
371, para 5)
“5. … The entire community is aggrieved if
the economic offenders who ruin the
economy of the State are not brought to
book. A murder may be committed in the
heat of moment upon passions being
aroused. An economic offence is committed
with cool calculation and deliberate design
with an eye on personal profit regardless of
the consequence to the community. A
disregard for the interest of the community
can be manifested only at the cost of
forfeiting the trust and faith of the
community in the system to administer
justice in an even-handed manner without
fear of criticism from the quarters which
view white-collar crimes with a permissive
eye unmindful of the damage done to the
national economy and national interest.”
24. While granting bail, the court has to keep in
mind the nature of accusations, the nature of
evidence in support thereof, the severity of the
(11)
punishment which conviction will entail, the
character of the accused, circumstances which
are peculiar to the accused, reasonable possibility
of securing the presence of the accused at the
trial, reasonable apprehension of the witnesses
being tampered with, the larger interests of the
public/State and other similar considerations. It
has also to be kept in mind that for the purpose of
granting bail, the legislature has used the words
“reasonable grounds for believing” instead of
“the evidence” which means the court dealing
with the grant of bail can only satisfy itself as to
whether there is a genuine case against the
accused and that the prosecution will be able to
produce prima facie evidence in support of the
charge. It is not expected, at this stage, to have
the evidence establishing the guilt of the accused
beyond reasonable doubt.
25. Economic offences constitute a class apart
and need to be visited with a different approach
in the matter of bail. The economic offence having
deep-rooted conspiracies and involving huge loss
of public funds needs to be viewed seriously and
considered as a grave offence affecting the
economy of the country as a whole and thereby
posing serious threat to the financial health of the
country.”
Referring those citations Learned P.P. drawn the attention of this
Court that considering the nature and gravity of the offence there is no
scope to grant bail to the accused person. Learned P.P. further referred
another citation of Hon’ble the Supreme Court of India in State of Bihar &
Anr. vs. Amit Kumar alias Bachcha Rai reported in (2017) 13 SCC 751
wherein in para No.13 Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:
“13. We are also conscious that if undeserving
candidates are allowed to top exams by corrupt
means, not only will the society be deprived of
deserving candidates, but it will be unfair for those
students who have honestly worked hard for one
whole year and are ultimately disentitled to a good
rank by fraudulent practices prevalent in those
examinations. It is well settled that socioeconomic offences constitute a class apart and
need to be visited with a different approach in the
matter of bail:(2013) 7 SCC 466. Usually socioeconomic offence has deep rooted conspiracies
affecting the moral fiber of the society and causing
irreparable
harm,
needs
to
be
considered
seriously.”
Finally, Learned P.P. referred another citation of Hon’ble the
Apex Court in Tarun Kumar vs. Assistant Director Directorate of
Enforcement reported in 2023 SC OnLine 1486 wherein in para Nos.22
and 23, Hon’ble the Apex Court observed as under:
(12)
“22. Lastly, it may be noted that as held in catena of
decisions, the economic offences constitute a class
apart and need to be visited with a different
approach in the matter of bail. The economic
offences having deep-rooted conspiracies and
involving huge loss of public funds need to be
viewed seriously and considered as grave offences
affecting the economy of the country as a whole and
thereby posing serious threat to the financial health
of the country. Undoubtedly, economic offences
have serious repercussions on the development of
the country as a whole. To cite a few judgments in
this regard are Y.S. Jagan Mohan Reddy v. Central
Bureau of Investigation8, Nimmagadda Prasad v.
Central Bureau of Investigation9, Gautam Kundu v.
Directorate of Enforcement (supra), State of Bihar v.
Amit Kumar alias Bachcha Rai10. This court taking a
serious note with regard to the economic offences
had observed as back as in 1987 in case of State of
Gujarat v. Mohanlal Jitamalji Porwal11 as under:—
“5… The entire community is aggrieved
if the economic offenders who ruin the
economy of the State are not brought to
books. A murder may be committed in the
heat of moment upon passions being
aroused. An economic offence is committed
with cool calculation and deliberate design
with an eye on personal profit regardless of
the consequence to the community. A
disregard for the interest of the community
can be manifested only at the cost of
forfeiting the trust and faith of the
community in the system to administer
justice in an even-handed manner without
fear of criticism from the quarters which
view white collar crimes with a permissive
eye unmindful of the damage done to the
National Economy and National Interest…”
23. With the advancement of technology and
Artificial Intelligence, the economic offences like
money laundering have become a real threat to the
functioning of the financial system of the country
and have become a great challenge for the
investigating agencies to detect and comprehend
the intricate nature of transactions, as also the role
of the persons involved therein. Lot of minute
exercise is expected to be undertaken by the
Investigating Agency to see that no innocent person
is wrongly booked and that no culprit escapes from
the clutches of the law. When the detention of the
accused is continued by the Court, the courts are
also expected to conclude the trials within a
reasonable time, further ensuring the right of
speedy trial guaranteed by Article 21 of the
Constitution.”
Referring those citations Learned P.P. drawn the attention of this
Court that due to the conduct of the accused persons the present informant
has been defrauded and the accused persons being the employees of a bank
in discharging their duties have damaged the faith of the common people
who have deposited their moneys to the Bank. So, if in a case of this nature
(13)
if they are released on bail there would be serious implications and also
there would be chance of tampering the evidence on record of the
prosecution. So, Learned P.P. urged for rejection of the bail application.
In reply, Learned Senior Counsel submitted that the accused is
under suspension and there is no chance on his part to handle with the
documentary evidence on record. Furthermore, this case is based on
documentary evidence on record. So, if at this stage bail is granted for
conducting proper defence, there will be no chance of prejudice to the case
of the prosecution.
As ordered earlier, today the State Head (Cluster Head) of HDFC
Bank,
Mr.
Ritesh
Bhosale
appeared
and
submitted
that
police
has
investigated the case and bank on their own also conducted internal
inquiries and further clarified that as per RBI guidelines the bank authority
shall be bound to refund the misappropriated amount to the informant
although some time may be required for conducting the formalities.
Here, in the case at hand the prosecution was set into motion on
the basis of an F.I.R. laid by one Smt. Suniti Datta Sen on 01.02.2025 to
O/C, R.K. Pur PS alleging inter alia that after her retirement and also upon
receiving money from sale of her ancestral property she deposited a sum of
Rs.18,00,000/- in fixed deposits(for short, FD) at HDFC Bank, Udaipur
Branch on different account numbers as mentioned in the F.I.R. and out of
the said FDs one of the FD had a maturity date on 06.01.2025 and the
money was withdrawn. And accordingly, on 07.01.2025 she went to the
HDFC Udaipur Branch when the bank employees told her to come back on
the next date and accordingly on 08.01.2025, she went to the bank. On her
arrival the bank manager told her that she had prematurely withdrawn
money from all her fixed deposits. But she replied that she did not withdraw
any money and thereafter, the branch manager asked her to return after
two days and when, she went back to the bank on 10.01.2025, the bank
staff handed her an account statement of an account number bearing
(14)
No.50100543335395 and told that she had made all the premature
withdrawals of fixed deposits using that account. She further stated that
apart from the fixed deposits mentioned in the F.I.R., she had an SB account
at the HDFC Udaipur branch bearing account number No.50100224928677.
According to her, she never opened account number 50100543335395, nor
did she take any benefit from the said account. Then, she realized that the
branch manager and other employees of HDFC Bank made collusion to
embezzle her money. On 14.01.2025 and 16.01.2025, she wrote two letters
to the branch manager and informed him about the embezzlement of her
funds. Since then, the branch manager has repeatedly visited her house and
assured her that she would receive her money within a couple of days, but
she did not receive it. She again mentioned that she did not receive any
transaction alerts/messages on her mobile for her SB account number
50100224928677. She approached the bank multiple times and in all the
occasions she was assured that she will start receiving the money.
She
checked the two bank passbooks issued for her original bank account
number 50100224928677 and found that the bank had recorded two
different phone numbers-91-8414934520 and 91-8798925718, neither of
which belongs to her. She also purchased an insurance policy from HDFC
Life through the aforementioned bank, and on the premium receipt the
correct phone number is mentioned. Thus, she could realize that the branch
manager and other bank employees of the Bank embezzled Rs.18,00,000/by opening a fake account in her name. Hence, she laid the F.I.R.
Accordingly, on the basis of that F.I.R. the case was registered and the
investigation was started and after conclusion of investigation the I.O. has
laid charge-sheet against the accused persons, namely Sri Abhishek Sarkar,
Sri Suman Das, Sri Jayanta Saha, Smt. Priyanka Paul, Sri Kushal Kanti Saha,
Sri Kanai Saha under Section 318(4)/ 318(3) /316(5) /336(3)/ 340(2)/
112(2)/61(2) of BNS, 2023 before the Court of Learned Jurisdictional
Magistrate. This present accused was produced under arrest before the
(15)
Court of Learned CJM, Gomati District, Udaipur on 27.03.2025 and since
then he is lodging in custody. By this time cognizance of offence is taken by
order dated 04.06.2025.
I have also perused the charge-sheet submitted by the I.O. This
case is entirely based on documentary evidence on record. It is on record
that the present accused in custody was posted at HDFC Udaipur Branch in
the year 2018 till December, 2022 and in course of opening the secondary
account of the informant Suniti Datta Sen bearing No.50100543335395
which is supposed to be forged on 12.07.2022, the accused was posted as
PB Authoriser and Authorized the account opening form mentioning that the
customer signed in his present. According to the I.O. the accused himself
admitted that the customer was not present while authorizing the account
opening form and stated that Abhishek Sarkar and Sagnik Chakroborty gave
him full set of secondary account opening form of said Smt. Suniti Datta Sen
along with cheque of Rs.25,000/- and authorized the account. According to
the I.O. the cheque of Suniti Datta Sen in favour of Kushal Kanti Saha for an
amount of Rs.4,45,000/-, Priyanka Paul, Rs.2,17,000/- and Ranjit Dey
Rs.4,79,000/- was encashed in HDFC Khowai Branch when the accused in
custody was a Branch Manager and the signature of said Smt. Suniti Datta
Sen also found to be forged in these cheques. It was further submitted that
a sum of Rs.20,000/- was credited in the account of Sri Suman Das in
account No.9150100382647744 of Axis Bank Ushabazar Branch. The
investigation of the case is complete. It is also found that a sum of
Rs.88,00,000/- was misappropriated from the said Branch during that
relevant period of time and the other accused persons of this case are also
involved in some other cases in which either investigation is going on or
charge-sheet is filed.
I have also perused the citations referred by both the parties.
The citations as referred by Learned Senior Counsel are relevant but the
principles of the citations cannot be applied in this case at this stage.
(16)
Since the case is pending for trial and there are prima facie
materials on record against him so at this stage there is no scope to give
any observation regarding innocence of the accused.
The cases of economic offences are increasing day by day. How
much amount was misappropriated by the accused in custody that would
come out after conclusion of the trial of the case.
From the charge-sheet also it appears that at HDFC Udaipur
Branch there is evidence of commission of offence by him and also during
his tenure at HDFC Khowai Branch some amount was alleged to be
withdrawn from the accounts belonging to the informant showing some
cheques wherein the signatures of the informant were forged and thus, it
appears that beyond the knowledge of the alleged accused the amount could
not have been withdrawn from HDFC Khowai Branch where the accused was
posted.
I have also seen the prayer of the I.O. regarding filing of
supplementary charge-sheet. However, since the trial of this case has
commenced so it is desired that the Learned Court below shall take all
endeavour to proceed with the trial of this case at an earliest convenience
keeping in mind the fact that the accused persons are lodging in jail.
Hence, at this stage I do not find any scope to release the
accused on bail. So, this bail application filed by the accused applicant
stands rejected.
Send back the record of the Learned Trial Court with a copy of
this order. Send down the CD to I.O. through Learned P.P. along with a copy
of this order
JUDGE
Snigdha
AMRITA
DEB
AMRITA DEB
Date: 2025.06.27
16:50:11 +05'30'
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review