Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2026:CGHC:805-DB
NAFR
ROHIT
KUMAR
CHANDRA
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
Digitally signed
by ROHIT
KUMAR
CHANDRA
WA No. 964 of 2025
1 - Minketan Chandra S/o Late Lakhan Lal Chandra Aged About 26
Years Ex. Subordinate Engineer, South Eastern Coal Fields Limited, R/o
M I G- I/115 Pt. Ravi Shankar Shukla Nagar, Korba Chhattisgarh
2 - Neelam Chandra W/o Late Lakhan Lal Chandra Aged About 51
Years Ex. Subordinate Engineer, South Eastern Coal Fields Limited, R/o
M I G- I/115 Pt. Ravi Shankar Shukla Nagar, Korba Chhattisgarh
... Appellants
versus
1 - South Eastern Coalfields Limited, Through Its Chairman Cum
Managing Director, Seepat Road, Bilaspur (C.G.)
2 - General Manager South Eastern Coal Fields Limited, General
Workshop, Korba, P.O. Korba Colliery, District Korba (C.G.)
3 - Regional Personal Manager Personal Department Central
Workshop, Korba, South Eastern Coalfields Limited, Bilaspur (C.G.)
... Respondents
(Cause-title taken from Case Information System)
For Appellants
For Respondents/SECL
: Mr. Yogesh Kumar Chandra, Advocate
: Mr. Vaibhav Shukla, Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
Hon'ble Shri Arvind Kumar Verma, Judge
Judgment on Board
Per Ramesh Sinha, Chief Justice
07.01.2026
1.
Heard Mr. Yogesh Kumar Chandra, learned counsel for the
appellants as well as Mr. Vaibhav Shukla, learned counsel,
appearing for the respondents/SECL.
2.
By way of present writ appeal under Section 2 of Sub-Section (1)
of the Chhattisgarh High Court (Appeal to Division Bench Act,
2006, the appellants, who were writ petitioners in the writ petition,
have challenged the order dated 09.10.2025 passed by learned
Single Judge in WPS No.4746/2020 (Minketan Chandra Vs.
South Eastern Coalfields Ltd. & Others) , by which the writ
petition filed by the writ petitioners/appellants herein has been
dismissed by the learned Single Judge.
3.
Brief facts necessary for disposal of this appeal are that the father
of appellant No.1 and husband of the appellant No.2, namely late
Lakhan Lal Chandra, while working as a Subordinate Engineer in
the establishment of the SECL, died due to a sudden illness on
26.12.2018. He was survived by appellant No.2 (wife), appellant
No.1 (son) and another son namely Bhushan Chandra. The name
of dependent appellant No.1 was proposed for employment on the
ground that his mother i.e. appellant No.2 is working as a
temporary employee i.e. Teacher in Vidyut Gruh Higher
Secondary School No.1, Korba in the Pay Scale of Rs.930038800 + 4200/- Grade Pay, drawing a salary of Rs.42,304/- and
also receiving pension emoluments to the tune of Rs.12,228/-.
The claim of the appellants was denied vide communication dated
20.8.2020 on the ground that the deceased employee’s wife (one
of the dependents) is already in service, therefore, the
employment of an additional dependent will not be considered.
Being aggrieved by the same, the appellant have preferred Writ
Petition bearing WPS No. 4746 of 2020, which was dismissed by
the learned Single Judge vide impugned order dated 09.10.2025.
Hence, this appeal.
4.
Learned counsel for the appellants vehemently argued that the
learned Single Judge, while passing the impugned order, failed to
properly appreciate the amended Circular/Memorandum dated
25.06.2024 issued by the Respondents. Particular emphasis was
placed on Clause 1.6(vii) thereof, which expressly provides for
consideration of compassionate appointment to an additional
dependent even in cases where another dependent is already in
service. It was submitted that the said circular is an amendment
and in addition to the earlier circulars, and therefore the learned
Single Judge ought to have directed the Respondent authorities to
consider the claim of the Appellants in the light of the amended
policy dated 25.06.2024. It was further argued that the
Respondents
erroneously
relied
upon
the
circular
dated
13.03.1981, particularly Clause (vii) thereof, to reject the claim of
compassionate appointment on the ground that one dependent of
the deceased employee was already in service. Learned counsel
submitted that Petitioner No.2, the mother of Petitioner No.1, is
only a temporary teacher in Vidyut Grih Higher Secondary School
No.1, Korba, and such employment is neither permanent nor
under SECL. Hence, the circular dated 13.03.1981 has been
wrongly applied and misinterpreted to deprive Petitioner No.1 of
compassionate appointment.
5.
Learned counsel for the appellants further submitted that the writ
petition clearly pleaded, particularly in paragraph 8.11, that the
family of the deceased employee is undergoing acute financial
hardship. In light of the law laid down by the Hon’ble Division
Bench in Supram Prasad v. State of Chhattisgarh and others ,
(2012) 4 CGLJ 137 (DB), the learned Single Judge ought to have
allowed the petition, as the object of compassionate appointment
is to mitigate the continuing financial hardship of the family, which
persists in the present case. It was contended that the circular
dated 13.03.1981, relied upon by the learned Single Judge, is
contrary to the provisions of the National Coal Wage Agreement
(NCWA), which governs the service conditions of non-executive
employees and does not prohibit compassionate appointment
merely because another dependent is in service. The deceased
employee, Late Lakhan Lal Chandra, was initially appointed on
10.07.1990 as Assistant Foreman (Electrical) and was governed
by the NCWA pay scale, as is evident from the appointment order
dated 10.07.1990 filed as Annexure A-3. Therefore, the claim for
compassionate appointment ought to have been considered
strictly in accordance with the NCWA.
6.
Learned counsel for appellants assailed the finding of the learned
Single Judge that the father of Petitioner No.1 was an executive
employee governed by the memorandum dated 13.03.1981. It
was submitted that such a finding was based solely on the reply
filed by SECL and is factually incorrect. The deceased employee
was only temporarily upgraded from the non-executive cadre to
the executive cadre by orders dated 06.02.2013 and 11.01.2013,
and was subsequently reverted to his substantive post in the nonexecutive cadre by order dated 06/12.09.2013, wherein his name
appears at Sl. No. 151. Thus, at the relevant time, the deceased
was a non-executive employee governed by the NCWA and not
by the executive circular dated 13.03.1981. In support of his
submissions, learned counsel placed reliance on the judgment of
the Division Bench of this Court in South Eastern Coalfields
Limited and others v. Gulshan Prakash (WA No. 89 of 2016,
decided on 11.10.2023), wherein it has been held that under the
NCWA, a co-dependent is entitled to compassionate appointment
even when another co-dependent is already in service.
7.
On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondents/SECL
strongly opposed the submissions advanced on behalf of the
appellants and submitted that the learned Single Judge has
passed a well-reasoned and legally sustainable order, which does
not call for any interference by this Hon’ble Court. At the outset, it
was contended that the Circular/Memorandum dated 25.06.2024,
heavily relied upon by the appellants, has no retrospective
application and cannot govern a claim for compassionate
appointment which had arisen much prior to its issuance. The
cause of action for compassionate appointment crystallizes on the
date of death of the employee, and the policy in force on that date
alone is applicable. Therefore, the learned Single Judge rightly
declined to apply the amended circular dated 25.06.2024 to the
present case. He further submitted that the respondents have
rightly relied upon the Circular/Memorandum dated 13.03.1981,
which
governs
compassionate
appointment
in
respect
of
executive employees. The deceased employee, Late Lakhan Lal
Chandra, was working in the executive cadre at the relevant time,
and therefore his case was squarely covered by the said
memorandum. Merely because the deceased employee was
initially appointed in the non-executive cadre or was subsequently
reverted does not alter the fact that, at the time relevant for
consideration of compassionate appointment, he was treated as
an executive employee as per the records of the RespondentCompany. It was argued that Clause (vii) of the Circular dated
13.03.1981
clearly
bars
consideration
of
compassionate
appointment where one dependent of the deceased employee is
already in employment. The mother of Petitioner No.1 was
admittedly employed as a teacher, and the nature of employment
whether temporary or permanent, or whether under SECL or
elsewhere is wholly irrelevant under the said policy. The object of
compassionate appointment being to relieve immediate financial
distress, the existence of an earning member in the family
disentitles the claimant from such appointment
8.
Learned counsel for respondents/SECL further contended that the
plea of financial hardship has been raised in a vague and bald
manner
without
any
substantive
material
to
demonstrate
indigence. Mere assertions in paragraph 8.11 of the writ petition
cannot substitute for proof of financial crisis. The learned Single
Judge has rightly held that compassionate appointment is not a
matter of right and cannot be granted solely on sympathetic
considerations. With regard to the reliance placed on the NCWA,
learned counsel submitted that the same is misconceived. The
NCWA applies only to non-executive employees, and once the
deceased was categorized as an executive employee, the NCWA
ceased to apply. The Circular dated 13.03.1981 governs executive
employees and was rightly applied in the present case. The
judgment in Gulshan Prakash (supra) is clearly distinguishable
on facts, as it pertained to a case governed by the NCWA and not
by the executive policy. He also submitted that the decision in
Supram Prasad (supra) does not advance the case of the
appellants, as each claim for compassionate appointment has to
be examined strictly in accordance with the applicable policy and
factual matrix. The learned Single Judge has correctly applied the
settled principles of law and arrived at a just conclusion, which
does not warrant interference by this Court.
9.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
impugned order and other documents appended with writ appeal.
10.
The foundational principle governing compassionate appointment
is well settled, namely that such appointment is not a matter of
right but an exception to the general rule of recruitment, intended
solely to mitigate the immediate financial hardship of the family of
a deceased employee. The policy in force on the date of death of
the employee alone governs the claim, and subsequent
amendments or circulars cannot be applied retrospectively unless
expressly so provided.
11.
In the present case, the reliance placed by the appellants on the
Circular dated 25.06.2024 is misconceived. The said circular was
issued much after the death of the employee and does not
provide for retrospective operation. Therefore, the learned Single
Judge was justified in declining to apply the amended circular to
the Appellants’ claim. The learned Single Judge has rightly relied
upon the Circular/Memorandum dated 13.03.1981, which governs
compassionate appointment in respect of executive employees.
From the records placed before the Court and the stand taken by
the respondent-Company, it is evident that the deceased
employee was treated as an executive employee for the purpose
of service benefits and compassionate appointment. The mere
fact that the deceased was initially appointed in the non-executive
cadre or that he was subsequently reverted does not, by itself,
invalidate the application of the executive policy, particularly when
the respondents have consistently treated the case as one
governed by the executive circular.
12.
Clause (vii) of the Circular dated 13.03.1981 clearly stipulates that
compassionate appointment cannot be granted where one
dependent of the deceased employee is already in employment. It
is not in dispute that the mother of Petitioner No.1 was employed
as a teacher. The policy does not draw any distinction between
temporary or permanent employment, nor does it restrict the
embargo only to employment under SECL. The existence of an
earning member in the family disentitles the claimant from
consideration under the compassionate appointment scheme. The
plea of financial hardship has been raised in a general manner
without any cogent material to demonstrate acute indigence
warranting deviation from the applicable policy. Sympathy or
hardship, howsoever genuine, cannot be a ground to direct
compassionate appointment in contravention of the governing
circular. The reliance placed by the appellants on the provisions of
the National Coal Wage Agreement and the judgments in Supram
Prasad (supra) and Gulshan Prakash (supra) is misplaced. The
said decisions were rendered in the context of cases governed by
the NCWA, whereas the present case has been rightly considered
under the executive policy. The said judgments, therefore, do not
advance the case of the appellants.
13.
We find that the learned Single Judge has correctly appreciated
the facts on record, applied the relevant policy, and followed the
settled principles of law governing compassionate appointment.
No perversity, illegality, or jurisdictional error has been pointed out
warranting interference by this Court in exercise of appellate
jurisdiction.
14.
In view of the foregoing discussion, the appeal is devoid of merit
and is accordingly dismissed. No order as to costs.
Sd/(Arvind Kumar Verma)
Judge
Chandra
Sd/(Ramesh Sinha)
Chief Justice
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review