Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2016:SHC:162
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Criminal Appellate Jurisdiction)
DATED : 25th OCTOBER, 2016
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------S.B. : HON’BLE MRS. JUSTICE MEENAKSHI MADAN RAI, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Crl.A. No.09 of 2016
Appellant
:
Mingur Dorjee Tamang,
Aged about 29 years,
S/o Shri Pratap Singh Tamang,
R/o 6th Mile,
Below Entel Motors,
P.O. & P.S. Ranipool,
East Sikkim.
versus
Respondent
:
State of Sikkim
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance
Mr. Ajay Rathi, Legal Aid Cousel for the Appellant.
Mr. Karma Thinlay Namgyal, Additional Public Prosecutor with
Mrs. Pollin Rai, Assistant Public Prosecutor for the State.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
JUDGMENT
Meenakshi Madan Rai, J.
1.
This Appeal has been filed assailing the Judgment and
Order on Sentence of the Court of the Learned Sessions Judge, Special
Division – II, East Sikkim, at Gangtok, both dated 19-12-2015, in Sessions
Trial Case No.14 of 2013, convicting the Appellant under Section 326 of
2016:SHC:162
Crl.A. No.09 of 2016
Mingur Dorjee Tamang
vs.
State of Sikkim
the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (for short the “IPC”) and sentencing him to
undergo rigorous imprisonment for a period of three years and to pay a
fine of Rs.25,000/- (Rupees twenty five thousand) only, with a default
stipulation.
2.
Although the appeal assailed the above, however, when the
verbal arguments were advanced by Learned Counsel for the Appellant,
he urged that he only sought to assail the sentence imposed by the
Learned Trial Court and had no quarrel with the decision on merits.
According to him, the convict is a young unmarried man about 29 years
and has no criminal antecedents. That, the offence committed by the
Appellant was his first and done on the spur of the moment in a fit of
rage. That, if he is incarcerated in jail, his future would be completely
ruined, as he would be languishing therein with hardened criminals,
making it difficult for him to rehabilitate in society due to the stigma
attached to such persons and also ruining his prospects for marriage. It
was also prayed that this Court may extend a reformative approach
towards the convict instead of incarcerating him. It is thus prayed that
the sentence of three years rigorous imprisonment imposed on the
Appellant be set off against the period of imprisonment already
undergone by him.
3.
On the other hand, the arguments of Learned Additional
Public Prosecutor were that, the conviction handed out by the Learned
Trial Court, warrants no interference inasmuch as the Charge was
2016:SHC:162
Crl.A. No.09 of 2016
Mingur Dorjee Tamang
vs.
State of Sikkim
initially framed under Section 307 of the IPC and thereafter, the Learned
Trial Court on analysing the evidence on record, came to a finding that
the offence committed instead amounted to one under Section 326 of the
IPC. Thus, the imprisonment is commensurate with the offence and the
sentence imposed ought not to be disturbed.
4.
I have heard Learned Counsel for the parties and given due
consideration to their submissions. Consideration has also been taken of
the entire records of the case including the evidence of the witnesses. I
have also perused the impugned Judgment and Order on Sentence.
5.
What arises for consideration before this Court is, whether
the prayer of the Appellant seeking setting off of the sentence by the
period already undergone by him as an under-trial prisoner against the
period of imprisonment imposed on him, i.e., three years rigorous
imprisonment, can be considered and allowed.
6.
In order to gauge this, we may briefly walk through the
facts of the case. On 22-04-2013, at about 15.20 hours, at Namnang View
Point, locally known as “Hurhuray Dara”, near Assembly House,
Gangtok, the Appellant assaulted the victim with a sharp cutting
weapon over her body and face. An FIR was lodged by P.W.4 Dr. Maya
Shilal, the Medical Officer on duty in the Emergency Ward of the STNM
Hospital, where the victim was first evacuated following the assault.
Based on the FIR, Sadar Police Station Case No.77 of 2013 dated 22-04-
2016:SHC:162
Crl.A. No.09 of 2016
Mingur Dorjee Tamang
vs.
State of Sikkim
2013, under Section 326 of the IPC was registered against the Appellant
and the matter taken up for investigation.
7.
During investigation, it transpired that the victim and the
Appellant were childhood friends and their families were known to
each other. From the year 2011, the victim and the Appellant were in a
relationship, she was a Librarian in the Army Public School, Libing,
Gangtok, while the Appellant was unemployed and often used to visit
the victim’s school and bother her. In March, 2013, due to his harassive
behaviour, the victim ended their relationship. In the month of April,
however, the Appellant again went to the work place of the victim and
created nuisance, on which the victim fled from the school.
The
Appellant again went there on 22-04-2013, on which, the victim decided
to complain about the matter to the Appellant’s parents both of whom
worked in the Sikkim Legislative Assembly and were aware of their
relations. The victim and the Appellant boarded a taxi together and the
victim met the Appellant’s mother in her Office who suggested that they
all go to “Hurhuray Dara” for a talk. There the victim requested her to
counsel the Appellant to leave her alone. She also told the Appellant
that she did not want to continue the relationship on which the
Appellant in a fit of rage assaulted the victim repeatedly over her body
with a sharp surgical blade which he was carrying with him.
8.
The Charge-Sheet was submitted under Section 307 of the
IPC against the Appellant.
Subsequently, a re-investigation was
2016:SHC:162
Crl.A. No.09 of 2016
Mingur Dorjee Tamang
vs.
State of Sikkim
ordered based on a representation made by the victim to the Director
General of Police in August, 2013.
The representation included a
Discharge Certificate issued to her by the Medical Officer of the STNM
Hospital and Orthopaedic and Physiotherapy Centre, Pradhan Nagar,
Siliguri.
The Discharge Certificate mentioned that multiple injuries
have been sustained by the victim which were not reflected in the
Medico Legal Examination Report submitted by P.W.4 Dr. Maya Shilal.
After re-investigation, the Charge-Sheet remained as one under Section
307 of the IPC.
9.
The Learned Trial Court after hearing the parties, framed
Charge against the Appellant under Section 307 of the IPC and the
Prosecution duly furnished twenty-five witnesses to establish its case
beyond a reasonable doubt.
10.
Of prime importance is the evidence of P.Ws 4, 5, 6, 7, 17
(also examined as P.W.22) and 20, the Doctors who examined the victim,
besides the evidence of the victim, P.W.2 herself. The victim testified
that, she and the Appellant came to know each other through their
respective fathers, thereafter, they met on several occasions as they
attended the same functions.
In the year 2012, she joined the Army
School as a Librarian where the Appellant started frequently stalking
her. His visits to her school grew more frequent as did his obsession
with her and she had to ask the employees of the school to remove him
from her classroom. On 22-04-2013 also, the Appellant came to her
2016:SHC:162
Crl.A. No.09 of 2016
Mingur Dorjee Tamang
vs.
State of Sikkim
school and she tried to reason with him, but he became enraged and
tried to push her to a cliff near the Libing Helipad. Consequently, she
decided to inform the Appellant’s mother on which, she and the
Appellant boarded the same taxi and reached the Sikkim Legislative
Assembly where she met the Appellant’s mother who invited her to go
outside where they could discuss the matter freely and both of them
walked towards “Hurhurey Dara” near the Sikkim Legislative
Assembly. All of a sudden, the Appellant held her face from behind
and started assaulting her by cutting her face. He then pushed her to
the ground and started assaulting her on her face, the nape of her neck,
left forearm and legs (around the shin and ankles) with a sharp cutting
weapon on which she became unconscious. His mother did not assist
the victim.
The Police personnel during investigation recorded her
Dying Declaration and she remained in hospital for 16-17 days, after
which she was discharged. Due to the continuous swelling in her legs
for about two weeks while she remained at home, she was taken to
Siliguri to an Orthopaedic Clinic by her parents, where she was
admitted and remained there for about twenty-four days. None of the
above facts could be demolished in her cross-examination.
11.
P.W.4 as already stated, was the Doctor in the Emergency
Ward at the STNM Hospital, where the victim was brought at 3.50 p.m.
on 22-04-2013, with a history of assault with a sharp weapon over her
body. The witness admitted that although in her Medical Report she
2016:SHC:162
Crl.A. No.09 of 2016
Mingur Dorjee Tamang
vs.
State of Sikkim
had stated that there were multiple lacerated wounds, however, in
actuality, the wounds were multiple incised wounds, which were found
on the victim’s face, left forearm, both legs and right ankle.
After
examination of the victim, she referred her to the General Surgeon as
she was of the opinion that the wounds had to be sutured. She also
referred her to the Orthopaedic Surgeon as she suspected that there was
a tendon tear in her ankle. Besides the above, P.W.4 referred her to the
Dental Surgeon since there were several oral injuries and bleeding in the
mouth. On examining the Appellant, she found bruises over left thumb
and middle finger. Her evidence remained untouched by the crossexamination.
12.
P.W.5 was the Consultant Orthodontist who examined the
victim.
According to him, “On my examination I found the following
injuries:
1. A clean cut injury over left cheek. 2. Cut injury over lower
border of mandible. The injuries were grievous because it was in the facial
region which included disfigurement of the face. I along with the Maxillo
Facial
Surgeon, Dr. Norden Lepcha sutured the said cut injuries.
…....…………”
13.
Dr. Tashi Hoesar Bhutia, the Junior Orthopaedic Surgeon,
at STNM Hospital was examined as P.W.6. As per this witness, the
victim was forwarded to him for the repair of her ankle tendons. He
accordingly examined her on 23-04-2013 when she was transferred to his
Department and on that day, he prescribed antibiotics and painkillers.
2016:SHC:162
Crl.A. No.09 of 2016
Mingur Dorjee Tamang
vs.
State of Sikkim
He further stated that on 25-04-2013 the patient was taken to O.T. under
spinal anaesthesia to repair the injured tendons which was found
completely severed, namely, “extensor hallicious longus”, “tibialis
anterior”, “extensor digitorum longus”. All these tendons were repaired
using 2-0 Prolene (a kind of suture material). He conducted thorough
wound toileting (washing of wounds). The wound was closed using 2-0
silk for skin suturing. The leg was then immobilised under plaster of
paris slab and the patient was transferred to the Ward.
14.
Dr. Pemba T. Bhutia, P.W.7 the Chief Consultant and Head
of Department of Orthopaedics, STNM Hospital in his evidence
deposed that, the victim aged 27 years was brought to the Emergency
Ward of the STNM Hospital on 22-04-2013 and kept in the Emergency
Ward for one day. On 23-04-2013, she was shifted to the Orthopaedic
Ward where he examined her and found that she had multiple cut
wounds over her face and cut injury over her right ankle where she had
extensor tendon injuries. Thereafter, on 25-04-2013, he along with his
Junior Doctor repaired the injured tendons.
15.
P.W.17, the Medico Legal Specialist who was later again
examined as P.W.22 also vouched for the evidence of the other Doctors
stated hereinabove.
That, on 22-04-2013, he was present at the
Emergency Ward at STNM Hospital at 3.45 p.m. to 3.50 p.m., when the
victim was brought there with the history of assault.
She was
immediately taken to the Trauma O.T. for further management. Since
2016:SHC:162
Crl.A. No.09 of 2016
Mingur Dorjee Tamang
vs.
State of Sikkim
there was many other patients at that time, he went over to the Trauma
O.T. and found that the victim was conscious and was responding and
had multiple injuries on her face, hand and lower trunk which were all
bleeding profusely. The Surgeon had arrived there and had started
working on her vitals and her wounds which were in plenty and mostly
on the left side of her face, hand and lower limbs. The margins of
wounds were clean cut with no sign of any contusions and abrasions,
neither did the wounds have signs of any bridging and were all
bleeding. On his examination, he formed an opinion to the extent that
the injuries caused by light sharp edged weapon and all the injuries
were grievous in nature. In cross-examination, the witness has opined
that the injury would have caused death had there not been timely
medical intervention.
That, on 22-04-2013, Dr. Kinchok Bhutia
examined the victim and found severe ENT bleeding with multiple
incised injury over different parts of her body and the patient was in a
state of shock. He started his treatment and also sent urgent calls to the
Orthopaedic and Oral Maxillo Facial Surgeon to attend to the patient.
To a suggestion, under cross-examination that, the injuries could be selfinflicted, the Doctor opined that all the injuries on the body of the victim
could not be self-inflicted as the injuries were deep and multiple.
16.
The evidence of P.W.20, Dr. Norden Lepcha, also assumes
importance as he was the Maxillo Facial Surgeon to whom Dr. Sandeep
Pradhan P.W.5 had referred the victim for medical examination. On
2016:SHC:162
Crl.A. No.09 of 2016
vs.
Mingur Dorjee Tamang
State of Sikkim
examining the patient, he found multiple sutured laceration over pan
facial region and upper and lower extremities (legs and hands). The patient
was responding, but in hypovolemic shock due to injuries. No bony
facial injuries were detected.
He then shifted the patient to the
Orthopaedic Section and repaired the wounds by step sutures by giving
layer
wise
closure
followed
by
subcutaneous sutures with 5.0
prolene.
17.
None of the evidence of the witnesses given in chief were
demolished despite the gruelling cross-examination each of them were
subjected to. All of the above evidence would indicate the culpability of
the Appellant. The evidence of each witness has supported the evidence
of the other with regard to the injuries on the victim which without a
shred of doubt were grievous.
The evidence of P.W.2 is duly
corroborated by the evidence of all the Doctors as discussed
hereinabove.
18.
Since the challenge is only to the sentence, I do not deem it
essential to embark on a protracted discussion on the merits of the case.
The penalty imposed is a consequence of the horrific act of an adult
male on a hapless female merely because she sought to end her
relationship with him. It is indeed outrageous that a man can physically
attack a female with a weapon merely because she has a mind of her
own and decided to exert it.
The attack commenced as an act of
cowardice when the Appellant attacked her from behind rendering her
2016:SHC:162
Crl.A. No.09 of 2016
Mingur Dorjee Tamang
completely defenceless.
vs.
State of Sikkim
He has disfigured her, scarring her not only
physically, but mentally as well. Contrary to his apprehension that his
marriage prospects could be ruined by incarceration, I find that his
entire intention when he inflicted the injuries pivoted around ruining
her marriage prospects.
From a consideration of the totality of the
circumstances and evidence, I find that the sentence handed out by the
Learned Trial Court is indeed commensurate to the offence and,
therefore, brooks no disturbance.
19.
Consequently,
the
Appeal
fails
and
is
accordingly
dismissed.
20.
The Appellant shall surrender forthwith before the Court of
the Learned Sessions Judge, Special Division – II, East Sikkim, at
Gangtok, to undergo the sentence imposed on him by the impugned
Order
on
Sentence,
duly setting off the period of imprisonment
already undergone by him during investigation and as an under-trial
prisoner.
21.
In terms of The Sikkim Compensation to Victims or
his Dependents Schemes, 2011, as amended in 2013, a sum of
Rs.3,00,000/- (Rupees three lakhs) only, be made over to the victim by
the Sikkim State Legal Services Authority (for short “SSLSA”).
22.
No order as to costs.
2016:SHC:162
Crl.A. No.09 of 2016
Mingur Dorjee Tamang
23.
vs.
State of Sikkim
Copy of this Judgment be sent to the Learned Trial Court
along with Records of the Court, and to the Member Secretary, SSLSA,
forthwith for information and compliance.
Sd/( Meenakshi Madan Rai )
Judge
25-10-2016
Approved for reporting : Yes
Internet : Yes
ds
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review