Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A
RSA. No. 28 of 2017
***In compliance to Hon‟ble Courts order dated
01.09.2020 passed in I.A. 02 of 2020 in RSA. 28 of 2017,
the legal heirs of the sole appellant Sri Amal Ch. Nath has
been incorporated as follows:
Smt. Minati Nath, wife of late Amal Ch. Nath.
2.
Sri Amarjit Nath (minor) son of late Amal Ch. Nath.
Appellant No.2 being minor represented by his natural
guardian, the mother, the appellant No.1
Both residents of West Panisagar, P.O. & P.S. Panisagar,
District: North Tripura.
…..Appellants
-V E R S U Sas per the Hon‟ble Courts order dated 15.02.2020 passed
in connected I.A. No. 03 of 2022, the name of deceased
respondent No.1 is deleted.
2.
Smt. Tapati Rani Nath, wife of Moti Nath daughter of late
Adaitya Charan Nath, resident of Village & P.O. Rowa,
P.O. & P.S. Panisagar, District: North Tripura.
3.
Sri Brajendra Nath, son of late Barna Charan Nath, Village
& P.O. Deochara, P.S. Panisagar, District: North Tripura.
4.
Sri Sanjoy Das, son of Sri Samarendra Das resident of
West Panisagar P.O. & P.S. Panisagar, District: North
Tripura.
5.
Sri Samarendra Das, son of late Naba Kumar Das,
resident of West Panisagar, P.O. & P.S. Panisagar,
District: North Tripura.
6.
Sri Bipul Nath, son of not known, deed writer,
Dharmanagar Deed Writer Association, P.O. P.S. & SubDivision: Dharmanagar, District: North Tripura.
7.
Sri Animesh Sarkar, son of not known, Deed Writer,
Dharmanagar Deed Writer Association, P.O. P.S. & SubDivision: Dharmanagar, District: North Tripura.
..... Respondents
8.
Sri Bimal Chandra Nath, son of late Adaitya Charan Nath,
resident of Vill-Uricharra (Subhash Nagar), P.O. & P.S.
Kanchanpur, District: North Tripura.
......Pro-forma-respondent.
B_E_F_O_R_E
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
For Appellant(s)
For Respondent(s)
:
:
Date of hearing
:
Date of delivery of
judgment and order
:
Whether fit for reporting :
Mr. K. Saha, Advocate.
Mr. S. Deb, Sr. Advocate.
Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, Advocate.
18.02.2022
22.02.2022
YES
JUDGMENT & ORDER
Heard Mr. K. Saha, learned counsel appearing on behalf of
Mr. S. Lodh, learned counsel for the appellants. Also heard Mr. S. Deb,
learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. S. Bhattacharjee, learned counsel
appearing for the respondents.
[2]
This is an appeal under Section 100 of the CPC against the
judgment and decree dated 11.07.2017 passed by the learned District
Judge, North Tripura, Dharmanagar in Title Appeal No.14 of 2016,
whereby and whereunder, the learned District Judge, North Tripura
affirmed the judgment and decree dated 05.03.2016 and 16.03.2016
respectively, passed by the learned Civil Judge, Sr. Division,
Dharmanagar, North Tripura in Title Suit No.15 of 2014, by which the
learned Civil Judge, Sr. Division decreed the suit filed by the respondent
No.1. At the time of admitting the appeal, the following substantial
question of law was formulated by this Court:
“Whether the presumption as drawn by the first appellate Court can
be sustained or the assumed foundations have their roots in
evidence?”
[3]
Before starting with this appeal, it is pertinent to mention here
that the present appellants are the legal heirs of the defendant-1 in the
original suit filed by the mother of the defendant No.1. But, both the
parties are not alive at present. As such, the legal heirs of the defendant
No.1 filed this appeal before this Court for the reliefs as prayed for.
[4]
The facts that would essentially be required for appreciating
the substantial questions of law may be introduced at the beginning. The
factual background of the plaintiff‟s case, in a nutshell, is that the plaintiff
Smt. Renu Bala Nath (since deceased) and her younger son Amar Ch. Nath
(since deceased) were the joint owners and possessors of the A-schedule
land measuring total 0.62 acre under khatian No.1031 comprising of R.S.
Plot No.3322 of 0.45 acre, 3323/8942 of 0.12 acre and R.S. Plot
No.3398/8943 of 0.050 acre. Deceased Amar Ch. Nath who died on
16.07.2013 was the absolute owner and possessor of the schedule-B land
measuring 0.25 acre under khatian No. 1335 of Mouza Panisagar. The
husband of the plaintiff died 35 years ago leaving behind the plaintiff,
three sons, defendant No.1, pro-defendant No.9 and deceased Amar Ch.
Nath with one daughter defendant No.3.
Defendant No.9 stayed
separately. The plaintiff in the suit used to stay with her son Amar Ch.
Nath in the schedule-B land. Amar Ch. Nath who was suffering from
paranoid schizophrenia since his childhood, died on 16.07.2013. The
plaintiff being poor is looked after by her elder son Bimal Ch. Nath. It is
also asserted that in the year 2012 the plaintiff requested defendant No.1(
since deceased) to manage money for treatment of her ailing and insane
son by mortgaging 05 satak land as his condition became worse.
Thereafter, on repeated request, the defendant No.1 gave Rs.10,000/- to the
plaintiff on condition to execute document regarding mortgage
[5]
It has been also pleaded that in the month of March, 2012
Amar Ch. Nath was treated in Agartala but, he was not recovered. Then
after, 4/5 months later, defendant No.1 asked the plaintiff to sign some
documents while in good faith and believing her son, defendant No.1
without any doubt put her signature as per advice and suggestion of
defendant No.1 though their contents were not read over to her.
Subsequently, after 2/3 months the deceased plaintiff observed change in
the attitude of the defendant No.1 as he asked to vacate her residential
house where she was living with her insane son and on this issue dispute
arose.
[6]
Thereafter, the plaintiff having ascertained came to know that
the defendant No.1 managed to execute three registered sale deeds in
favour of defendant No.5 Sri Sanjoy Das, defendant No.6 Sri Samarendra
Das and in favour of the defendant No.1 himself in respect of the landed
properties of the plaintiff and her insane son Amar Ch. Nath.
Subsequently, the plaintiff obtained the certified copies of the sale deeds
bearing No.1-1305 dated 24.08.2012 being executed purportedly by her for
0.45 acre land, sale deed No.1-1306 dated 24.08.2012 purportedly
executed by her and her son Amar Ch. Nath for land measuring 0.12 acre
in favour of the defendant Nos. 6 and 5 respectively. The plaintiff also
obtained the certified copy of another sale deed No.1-01304 dated
28.04.2012 in respect of the land measuring 0.25 acre purportedly
executed by Amar Ch. Nath in favour of defendant No.1.
[7]
Thereafter, getting their certified copies, the plaintiff realized
that the defendant No.1 in collusion with deed writers had fraudulently
managed and obtained the sale deeds using fraud and mis-representation to
grab all the landed property of plaintiff. The plaintiff was a rustic, illiterate
having capacity to put signature only while her deceased son was suffering
from insanity. The defendant No.1 being her son, she had good faith
without any imagination about any practice of fraud and misrepresentation
by him. The plaintiff had no question to dispose of all the landed property
and became shelterless as actually she agreed to mortgage 05 statk land for
treatment of her ailing son while she was made understood that mortgage
of 05 satak land was actually executed but, taking the advantage of
simplicity
and
good
faith
of
plaintiff
and
using
fraud
and
misrepresentation, the defendant No.1 managed to have the registered sale
deed in respect of almost all the landed property i.e. 82 satak out of 87
satak of land belonging to plaintiff and her ailing son.
[8]
According to the plaintiff, those three registered sale deeds
are forged and false documents as defendant obtained the deeds by
misrepresentation with belief that she was executing mortgage deed in
respect of a small portion of a land. There was no question to execute any
sale deed in respect of the homestead land of plaintiff and her son Amar
Ch. Nath was not able to understand anything regarding any sale deeds nor
he had capacity to put signature or thumb impression as he was not in
sound state of mind at the relevant point of time of allegedly executed sale
deed in respect of his land.
[9]
The next plea of the plaintiff is that on 16.07.2013, Amar Ch.
Nath died leaving behind the plaintiff as his legal heir and she became the
owner and possessor of the schedule B suit land. It is further alleged that
the plaintiff has been dispossessed from the schedule-A land on
15.08.2014 forcefully by the defendant Nos.5 and 6 while, the plaintiff
occupied the schedule B suit land and on 01.08.2014 the defendant No.1
tried to dispossess her by giving threat to cause dire consequence unless
the schedule B land is vacated. With the above contentions, the plaintiff
since deceased sought for declaration of nullity of the three alleged sale
deeds on the ground of fraud, collusion and not binding upon the plaintiff
with the declaratory relief of her right, title and interest on the A and B
schedule suit land and consequential reliefs.
[10]
In response to the summons issued upon the defendants, all
the defendants appeared and contested the suit by filing written statement
wherein they categorically denied all the assertions of the plaintiff
particularly, that the plaintiff has got any right, title and interest over the A
and B schedule land consequent to execution of the 3 registered sale deeds.
[11]
In response to the statements made by the plaintiff in the
plaint, the defendants in support of their case have categorically stated that
the plaintiff and her deceased son executed the registered sale deed in
favour of the defendant No.6 with full state of mind in respect of 0.45 acre
land of khatian No.1031 and registered sale deed No.1-1306
dated
24.08.2012 for land of 0.12 acre in favour of the defendant No.5 by
receiving due consideration amount from them and observing all legal
formalities in presence of the executants while the defendant Nos. 5 and 6
have been possessing their respective purchased land as bona fide
purchaser. According to the defendants, two registered sale deeds of the
defendant Nos. 5 and 6 are genuine deeds while the executants
relinquished their right, title and interest and possession in their favour and
so the plaintiff is not entitled to get the declaration of her title and recovery
of possession for such sold out land.
[12]
It has been pleaded that the schedule B land was originally a
government khash land being allotted in the name of Amar Ch. Nath since
the deceased and after getting allotment he applied for mutation with his
full state of mind and his name has been recorded in the record of right.
Subsequently, Amar Ch. Nath during his life time, with his allotted land of
0.25 acre observing all legal formalities has taken possession of that suit
land without any hindrance as bond fide purchaser. This registered sale
deed No.1-01-304 dated 24.08.2012 is relinquished his title and possession
to the defendant No.1. According to the defendants, the deed writers i.e.
the defendant Nos.7 and 8 made no wrong at the time of writing of the sale
deeds. It is also noted that earlier the defendant No.1 instituted suit No.
T.S.60 of 2013 in the Court of learned Civil Judge (Jr.) Division, North
Tripura for perpetual injunction against pro-defendant No.9, Bimal Ch.
Nath and principal defendant No.3 Smt. Tapati Rani Nath in respect of
schedule B land which was ultimately disposed of on compromise. The
defendants also pleaded that by misleading the Court the plaintiff wanted
to grab the property of defendant Nos.1, 5 and 6 and as such, the plaintiff
is not entitled to any relief as prayed for.
[13]
After hearing both the parties, the learned trial Court, had
observed as under:
“In the result, it hereby held that the plaintiff has succeeded to
establish the cause of action for the suit and consequently the suit is
allowed and decreed with declaration that plaintiff has right, title
and interest over the A schedule land measuring total 0.57 acre
(0.45 acre +0.12 acre) under khatian No.1031 vide Exbt.1.
It is also declared that the plaintiff has right, title and interest and
possession over the B schedule land measuring 0.25 acre under
khatian No.1335 vide Exbt.2.
It is also hereby declared that the three sale deeds of schedule C viz
(a) registered sale deed No.1-01304 dated 24.08.2012 (b) registered
sale deed vide No.1-01305 dated 24.08.2012 and (c) the registered
sale deed vide No.1-1306 dated 24.08.2012 are fraudulent, collusive,
void and not binding upon plaintiff. Consequently these three
registered sale deeds are hereby cancelled as per Section-31 of the
Specific Relief Act.
Plaintiff is also entitled to get recovery of vacant possession of the
entire A schedule land by removing all constructions therefrom.
Defendants No.1, 5 and 6 or their men or agent are directed to hand
over the vacant possession of the A schedule suit land in favour of
plaintiff within 30 days from the date of decree removing all
constructions therefrom.
Defendant No.1 or his men or agent or any other person claiming
under him are hereby perpetually restrained from entering into B
schedule suit land and from disturbing the peaceful possession of
plaintiff on this land in any manner.
Inform sub-registrar, sub Registry Office, Dharmanagar, North
Tripura about cancellation of the three suit deeds of schedule „C‟
viz (a) registered sale deed No.1-01304 dated 24.08.2012 (b)
registered sale deed vide No.1-01305 dated 24.08.2012 and (c) the
registered sale deed vide No.1-1306 dated 24.08.2012 by sending a
copy of decree for doing the needful as per Section-31(2) of the
Specific Relief Act.
It is also observed in this case that the plaintiff being an aged
woman of 78 years old has suffered the pain of cheating and fraud
by her own blooded son defendant No.1(Amal Ch. Nath) in
disposing of her lawful properties. So it is made clear that in case
plaintiff wishes to transfer or alienate her landed property of
Schedule A and Schedule B , she can take the resort and service of
the legal services institution (SDLSC, Dharmanagar, North
Tripura) at free of cost for such purpose so as to avoid any
fraudulent practice on her by any cheat or in maintaining her
landed property.”
[14]
Being aggrieved by the impugned judgment and decree dated
05.03.2016 and 16.03.2016 respectively, passed by the learned Civil
Judge, Sr. Division, Dharmanagar, North Tripura in Title Suit No.15 of
2014, the defendant in the suit has preferred and appeal before the learned
District Judge, North Tripura, Dharmanagar in Title Appeal No.14 of
2016, whereby and whereunder, the learned District Judge, North Tripura
affirmed the judgment and decree dated 05.03.2016 and 16.03.2016
respectively, observing thus:
“In the result, the appeal is dismissed being devoid of merit. The
judgment and decree dated 05.03.2016 and 16.03.2016 respectively,
passed by the learned Civil Judge, Sr. Division, Dharmanagar,
North Tripura in Title Suit No.15 of 2014 wherein the Ld. Trial
Court decreed the suit on contest is hereby upheld.
Both the appeals bearing No. Title Appeal No.14 of 2016 and Title
Appeal No.20 of 2016 are hereby dismissed on contest without cost,
keep a copy of this judgment in the connected appeal. Also prepare
the decree accordingly. Send back the L.C. Record along with a
copy of this judgment.”
[15]
Being seriously aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the
concurrent findings of both the Courts below, the present second appeal
has been preferred.
[16]
Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and after
considering the observations made by both the Courts below, this Court
thinks it necessary to discuss the issues framed by the courts below for
proper adjudication.
[17]
Here, it is to be considered whether the three registered sale
deeds are illegal and fraudulent instruments and liable to be cancelled.
With reference to this issue, this Court meticulously gone through the
evidence on record in the light of the oral arguments of both parties. The
plaintiff in the OS has stated that the three sale deeds are the result of fraud
and misrepresentation practiced by the defendant No.1 in the OS on whom
plaintiff being the mother had fully believed and relied upon him but, her
son taking the advantage of her innocence and unconditional belief and
faith on him, he practiced fraud by misrepresenting that one mortgaged
deed was to be executed by her. According to the plaintiff she never
thought to dispose of her all landed property by sale to defendant Nos.5
and 6 and besides her younger son Amar Ch. Nath (since deceased) was
suffering from paranoid schizophrenia who had no capacity to sign or put
thumb impression on the sale deed. It has also been stated that the plaintiff
told the defendant No.1 to arrange for money for the treatment of her ailing
son by mortgaging a portion of her land but, the defendant No.1 in
collusion with others managed to create forged sale deeds where, as per his
asking and believing him fully without thinking of any fraud the plaintiff
put the signature.
[18]
On the other hand, the defendant in support of their
contentions has stated that the plaintiff cannot be accepted as she and her
deceased son knowing fully and with their full state of mind and in
presence of witnesses put their signature and thumb impression on the
respective sale deeds. There was no iota of any fraud or misrepresentation
or any undue influence practiced upon plaintiff and her son. The
defendants have further stated that the medical documents regarding her
deceased son‟s un-soudedness, were not examined.
[19]
It is admitted position that the plaintiff Smt. Renubala Nath
(since deceased) and her son Amar Ch. Nath (since deceased) were the
joint owners of total land measuring 0.620 acres under khatian No.11335,
sabek Dag No.2181/6371 corresponding to R.S. Plot No.4222/9043 vide
Exbt.2. There is also no dispute that Amar Ch. Nath was the absolute
owner of schedule B land measuring 0.25 acre appertaining to khatian
No.1335
sabek
Dag
No.2181/6371
corresponding
to
R.S.
Plot
No.4222/9043 vide Exbt.2. It is also undisputed that Amar Ch. Nath died
on 16.07.2013 leaving behind his mother plaintiff, defendant No.1 Amar
Ch. Nath pro-defendant No.9 Bimal Ch. Nath as brothers while defendant
No.3 Smt. Tapati Rani Nath as his sister.
[20]
The case of the plaintiff is that the registered sale deed vide
No.01350 dated 24.08.2012 vide Exbt.B in respect of land measuring 0.45
acre and the resitered sale deed No.1-01306 dated 24.08.2012 vide Exbt.C
in respect of 0.12 acre land of khatian No.1031 purportedly executed by
the plaintiff and her Amar Ch. Nath, were fraudulently made and obtained
by misrepresentation.
[21]
PW-1 deposed in her affidavit in chief that in the year 2012
the plaintiff requested defendant No.1 to manage money for treatment of
her ailing and insane son by mortgaging 05 satak land as his condition
became worse. PW-1 also deposed that then after repeated request the
defendant No.1gave Rs.10,000/- to her on condition to execute document
regarding mortgage within few days while in the month of March 2012
Amar Ch. Nath was treated in Agartala but he was not recovered and after
4/5 months later, the defendant No.1 asked the plaintiff to sign some
documents while in good faith and believing her son without any doubt she
put her signature as per advice and suggestion of the defendant No.1.
[22]
According to PW-1, after 2/3 the defendant asked to vacate
her residential house where she was living with her insane son and on this
issue dispute arose and then the plaintiff came to know that the defendant
No.1 managed to execute three registered sale deeds in favour of
defendants No.5 and 6 and in favour of the defendant No.1. PW-1 also
narrated that the defendant No.1 being her son she had good faith without
any imagination about any practice of fraud and misrepresentation by him.
PW-1 further stated that the plaintiff actually agreed to mortgage 05 satak
land for the treatment of her ailing son but, subsequently she could
understand that mortgage of 05 satak land was actually executed by the
defendant No.1.
[23]
PW-2 Bimal Ch. Nath also narrated the above relevant facts in
his evidence particularly that there was fraud and misrepresentation
practiced in obtaining the three alleged sale deeds. PW-3 Smt. Binodini
Mahishya Das also deposed that the plaintiff was staying in her residential
house with her son Amar Ch. Nath who was suffering from paranoid
schizophrenia since his childhood till his death i.e. on 16.07.2013. In her
cross-examination, PW-1 denied the suggestion of defendants that the
three registered sale deed are genuine and true documents. PW-1 admitted
that she put her signature on the sale deed but Amar Ch. Nath did not put
his signature or thumb impression on the sale deeds. PW-1 also narrated in
cross that abnormal behaviour of Amar Ch. N ath used to happen by
interval and he used to stay without wearing his usual garments and he
used to stay almost naked. PW-1 admitted that Amar Ch. Nath was sound
state of mind when land was allotted in his name. PW-2 narrated in his
cross that he cannot exactly mention whether the three sale deeds of this
fuit are genuine or not but, he deposed that he has been residing at
Kanchanpur for last 20/25 years. PW-3 deposed in her cross that some land
was allotted in favour of Amar Ch. Nath by the Government and he got
some land from their ancestral property and that no land is allotted to an
insane person by the government.
[24]
Thus, the plea and evidence of the plaintiff is that she told the
defendant No.1 to mortgage 05 satak land out of her property to obtain
money for treatment of her son who was suffering from certain decease
namely paranoid schizophrenia since his childhood but, instead of that she
was made to believe that mortgage deed was being made and so defendant
No.1 asked her to put signature on the document and accordingly she
signed on the deed fully believing and in good faith that mortgage deed
was made.
[25]
Admittedly, Exbt.A contains the thumb impressions of Amar
Ch. Nath while Exbt. B and Exbt.C both contained the signature of
plaintiff Renubala Naht (plaintiff in the OS) and thumb impression of
Amar Ch. Nath being the joint executants. Signatures on the registered sale
deed being marked as Exbt.B/1 and Exbt.C/1 respectively. Signature on
the Exbt. A was also identified as attesting witness being marked as
Exbt.A/1. The plea and evidence of DW-1 is that both the executants
kinowing fully and having full state of mind signed on the sale deeds and
put the thumb impression and they received the consideration money
without any sort of fraud.
[26]
It is settled principle of law that sale of immovable property is
a contract and to make a valid contract one of the requirement is that the
person executing the contract must have free consent in executing the
instrument. Section-14 of the Indian Contract Act defines the word “free
consent” and it speaks that consent is said to be free when it is not caused
by coercion or fraud or undue influence or fraud or misrepresentation or
mistake. Consent is said to be so caused when it would not have been given
but for the existence of such coercion, undue influence, fraud,
misrepresentation or mistake. Section-12 of the Contract Act provides the
principle regarding the point of sound mind for the purpose of contract.
This provision speaks a person is said to be of sound mind for the purpose
of making a contract if, at the time when he makes it, he is capable of
understanding it and of forming a rational judgment as to its effect upon
his interests.
[27]
Thus, in view of the above provisions, it can be said that when
the consent of a person in executing an instrument has been caused by
coercion, undue influence, fraud or misrepresentation, such consent cannot
be treated as free consent so as to validate the contract. Besides, the
executants of any contract must possess sound mind and he is capable of
understanding the nature of the document including the capacity of
judgment as to consequence of such contract upon his interest. So, one of
the essential ingredients of a valid contract is that the executants must be
of sound mind while the fact of his unsound mind or incapability of his
understanding at the relevant time of making of contract can affect the
legality of such contract.
[28]
Now, in the present case, this Court finds that the defendant
No.1 is one of the sons of plaintiff and she being a rustic village with no
adequate literacy, in the prudence of human conduct of an ordinary person,
she will have full faith and belief on her blooded son and such mother will
definitely rely on her son being the most nearest person to her both for her
maintenance as well as in getting the succession to her property after her
death. So, it is natural that a mother would have full faith on her son that
he will not put her mother in trouble or in any disadvantageous position
and even she never thought of any practice of any fraud upon her. In that
view it is highly probable that in the persent case plaintiff put her signature
on the alleged two sale deeds vide Exbt. B and Exbt. C in good faith and
believing the saying of her son defendant No.1, which she was going to
execute mortgage deed, but, not sale deed of her joint property.
[29]
Section-16 of the Contract Act also defines the term „undue
influence‟ in the following words:
“(1) A contract is said to be induced by „undue influence‟ where the
relations subsisting between the parties are such that one of the parties is
in a position to dominate the will of the other and uses that position to
obtain an unfair advantage over the other.
(2) In particular and without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing
principle, a person is deemed to be in a position to dominate the will of
another(a) Where he holds a real or apparent authority over the other or where he
stands in a fiduciary relation to the other, or
(b) Where he makes a contract with a person whose mental capacity is
temporarily or permanently affected by reason of age, illness, or mental or
bodily distress.
(c) Where a person who is in a position to dominate the will of another,
enters into a contract with him, and the transaction appears on the face of
it or on evidence adduced, to be unconscionable, the burden of proving
that such contract was not induced by undue influence shall lie upon the
person in a position to dominate the will of the other.”
[30]
In Tandonbi Devi and Others v. Kalamu Singha and
Another, reported in (2010) 5 GLR 367, the Hon‟ble Gauhati High Court
held in para-19 of the judgment relating to a similar case where the validity
of a sale deed was challenged on the ground of fraud that “When fraud,
misrepresentation or undue influence is alleged by a party in a suit
normally, the burden is on him to prove such fraud, misrepresentation or
undue influence. However, when a person is in a fiduciary relationship
with another and the latter is in a position of active confidence, the burden
of proving the absence of fraud, misrepresentation or undue influence is
upon the person in the dominating position, and he has to prove that there
was fair play in the transaction and the apparent is the real.
[31]
According to Section-111 of the Evidence Act, where there is
a question as to the good faith of a transaction between parties, one of
whom stands to the other in a position of active confidence, the burden of
proving the good faith of the transaction is on the party who is in a position
of active confidence. Thus, in the present case the burden now shifted upon
the defendants to prove that there was no undue influence or any
misrepresentation or collusion in executing the sale deeds.
[32]
In this context, this Court finds that according to the plaintiff
her son Amar Ch. Nath was suffering from some ailment and she also
exhibited one medical certificate dated 20.03.2012 issued by the concerned
doctor which was marked as Exbt.7. The defendants raised objection in its
admissibility as the author of this medical evidence was not examined.
There may be force on such objection because unless the medical officer or
doctor who examined and made treatment of Amar Ch. Nath is examined
and confronted the rigour of cross-examination, such medical certificate
cannot be fully relied upon.
[33]
However, it is also revealed in the cross-examination of DW-
2 Animesh Sarkar that Amar Ch. Nath was suffering from illness and he
was unable to move and he also heard that subsequently Amar Ch. Nath
died. The fact of death of Amar Ch. Nath at very young age is an admitted
position. It naturally follows that when a person is seen to be naked with
abnormal behaviour it indicates towards the fact that he lacks capacity of
proper understanding and judgment in his conduct. Therefore, in my
opinion, it can be held that Amar Ch. Nath was not in fit state of body and
mind due to his illness and consequent to such ailment he also died very
soon on 16.07.2013.
[34]
Besides the evidence of PW-1 that some misrepresentation
was made and fraud practiced upon her by the defendant No.1 as he by
telling about execution of mortgage of her 05 satak land obtained her
signature on the deeds, can be believed because it is quiet unconscionable
to dispose of all the property of deceased Amar Ch. Nath along with the
share of the plaintiff on the sole pretext that money was required for the
treatment of Amar Ch. Nath. DW-1 also admitted in his cross-examination
that earlier prior to 2012 his brother was also treated at Dharmanagar
hospital at the cost of his own expenses but DW-1 did not produce the
medical documents including cash memo of medicines to show as to how
much money was borne by him in course of treatment in order to assess
consideration money of Rs.1,40,000/- being paid by the defendant No.1 in
favour of Amar Ch. Nath. Exbt. B indicates the payment of consideration
money of Rs.1,40,000/- by Samarendra Das, defendant No.5 in favour of
the plaintiff and her son while Exbt. C shows about the consideration
money of RS.90,000/- being paid by the defendant No.6 in favour of the
plaintiff.
[35]
Admittedly, the three deeds were registered on the same dated
i.e. on 24.08.2012 which forms part of same transaction of collusion
amongst the defendants. Except plaintiff the other witnesses of the sale
deeds vide Exbt. A, B. and C is Bipul Nath and the other witness of Exbt.
B and C is Amal Ch. Nath. DW-1 in his cross explained that photograph
of his brother Amar Ch. Nath was taken by a cameraman and the
cameraman was brought by the staffs of the Sub-Registrar Office while at
the time of taking of photographs his brother had pant and shirt in this
wearing.
[36]
DW-2 also deposed that he knows Sanjoy Das but he had no
communication with him from last 1 & ½ years. DW-2 also deposed that
he along with Sub-Registrar along with his two staffs and his sister
Advocate Sankari Sarkar went to the house of Amar Ch. Nath about two
years back and no other witness accompanied them. There is thumb
impression of Amar Ch. Nath on the sale deeds but it not clearly legible as
to who obtained such thumb impression of Amar Ch. Nath and as such, his
thumb impression is not identified by any independent witness apart from
DW-1. DW-1 has deposed that the thumb impression of his brother on the
two sale deeds were taken by the staff of Sub-Registry Office in his house
creates doubt in the transaction because in case such official obtained the
thumb impression his name could have been surely disclosed legibly so as
to ascertain his identity.
[37]
Though, it is mentioned in the back of sale deeds vide sale
deed No.1-01304 Exbt. A that Amar Ch. Nath presented the sale deed to
the Sub-Registrar, Dharmanagar while the plaintiff presented the rest two
sale deeds vide Exbt. B and C on 24.08.2012 at Sub-Registry Office,
Dharmangaar, then there was no justification to issue commission to verify
the identity of executants. Such issuance of commission also suggests that
executants did not actually appear before the Sub-Registrar on the relevant
date of execution and it is quiet improbable how the deeds could have been
registered on 24.08.2012 when they were directed to be verified by visiting
the house of the executants situated at Panisagar.
[38]
Apart this, though sale deeds vide Exbt. B and C are
purportedly shown to have been made in favour of Samarendra Das and
Sanjoy Das but, in fact they did not appear in the evidence to depose in
favour of their case. The statement of DW-1 that he had no communication
with defendant No.5 Sanjoy Das for last one yar and the statement of DW2 that he had also no communication with Sanjoy Das for last 1 and half
year clearly suggests that defendant No.1 is actually representing them in
the trial though defendant Nos.5 and 6 were supposed to appear and
adduce evidence about their respective sale deeds and as such they being
the purchasers, they could have much interest in the suit for their deeds
were challenged.
[39]
Thus, in the light of what has been discussed above, analysis
made and reasonings cited, this Court is of the considered opinion that
defendants could not discharge their burden of proof that there was no
collusion amongst the defendants in obtaining the three registered sale
deeds or that there was no misrepresentation or fraud practiced upon the
plaintiff and her son Amar Ch. Nath. Upon scanning of all the relevant
factors and circumstances in the evidence, this Court finds that
preponderance of probability in believing the fact of existence of
misrepresentation, undue influence and collusion in the execution of the
three alleged sale deeds lies in favour of the case of plaintiff who duly
discharged her onus of proof that Exbt. A, B and C are the result of
misrepresentation, undue influence and collusion at the instance of
defendant No.1.
[40]
A suit for cancellation of instruments is based on the
provision of Section-31 of the Specific Relief Act, which reads as under:
“31. When cancellation may be ordered: (1) any person against whom a
written instrument is void or void able, and who has reasonable
apprehension that such instrument, if left outstanding may cause him
serious injury, may sue to have it adjudged void or void able; and the
court may, in its discretion, so adjudge it and order it to be delivered up
and cancelled.
(2) If the instrument has been registered under the Indian Registration
Act, 1908, the court shall also send a copy of its decree to the officer in
whose officer the instrument has been so registered; and such officer
shall note on the copy of the instrument contained in his book the fact of
its cancellation”.
[41]
Therefore, keeping in view of the above provision in my
view, since the plaintiff asserted to avoid the effect of three registered sale
deeds as their existence may affect her right and title on the suit land, these
three instruments are liable to be declared void in view of Section-31 of
the Specific Relief Act. Hence, the three registered sale deeds vide No.103105 dated 24.08.2012, 1-01306 dated 24.08.2012 and 1-01304 dated
24.08.2012 are hereby declared void, illegal and fraudulent instruments
and accordingly they are cancelled.
[42]
Having regard to the above discussion that three registered
sale deeds vide Exbt. A, B and C in respect of the A and B schedule land
are void and illegal instruments and they are not binding on the plaintiff, in
my opinion, the right, title and interest of the plaintiff on the schedule A
land will be sustained as she was its joint owner. Since, the plaintiff is the
class owner of the schedule B land after the death of her son (Amar Ch.
Nath) there should not be any legal bar in declaring that the plaintiff has
right, title and interest over the schedule B land. Since, the three sale deeds
have been declared void, so consequently the defendants Nos.1, 5 and 6
have no cause or legal backing to oust the plaintiff from her occupied B
schedule land and they have no right to occupy or possess the schedule A
land.
[43]
Therefore, this Court is of the considered view that the
evidence of the plaintiff can be believed and there is cause of action in this
suit as it is proved that they alleged three sale deeds in respect of schedule
A and schedule B land respectively are not valid and binding upon the
plaintiff. Besides plaintiff being the real owner of the A and B schedule
land she is entitled to get the protection of her occupied land as well as
recovery of the land of which she was dispossessed illegally.
[44]
Before parting, for the sake of legality and validity one aspect
should be discussed regarding the relief as prayed for by the present
appellant i.e. widow of the deceased defendant No.1 and his minor son.
This present case starts between the mother and her son who are at present
not alive. At the very beginning mother file suit against one of her sons,
who is not alive at the present. But, it is to be accepted that the husband of
the appellant i.e. the defendant No.1 in the title suit once on request of his
mother has given some money for her brother‟s treatment. His brother was
not mentally sound he as was suffering from paranoid schizophrenia from
his childhood and in return, he has taken over the property of the mentally
retired brother in the form of sale deed. Thereafter, his mother, the
mentally unsounded son visited to the Registrar Office and executed the
sale deed where, their photo and thumb impression were present.
[45]
Now, in the process of litigation, mother passed away and that
mentally unsounded brother also passed away and the most critical fact is
that the elder brother who helped his mother with financial assistance for
the treatment of his younger brother, he also passed away. Now, his widow
wife and minor child are before the Court.
[46]
On that pretext, this Court is of the considered view that there
should be some relief given to the widow wife and the child, the appellants
herein by which justice would be met, as the defendant No.1 at one point
of time funded the old mother for the treatment of his ailing brother. One
legal aspect which needs to be considered holding that Amar Ch. Nath was
suffering from paranoid schizophrenia since his childhood, to prove the
same they produced one medical document but, the issuing doctor was not
examined and hence the same cannot be taken into consideration. Without
proving the ailment of Amar Ch. Nath, conclusion of the Courts below that
he was suffering from paranoid schizophrenia since childhood is totally
erroneous and I find force on to this point raised by the counsel for the
defendants in the OS.
[47]
Having appreciated the evidence on record and over all
analysis, this Court is of the considered opinion that giving some benefit to
the appellants herein as her husband once funded his mother for the
treatment of his younger brother would meet the ends of justice. Therefore,
the registered sale deed vide No.1-01304 dated 24.08.2012 in respect of
the land measuring 0.25 acre which has been registered in favour of the
defendant No.1, the husband of the appellants in the present appeal be
given to the appellants for their future prospect as the appellant No.2 being
minor.
[48]
The paranoid Schizophrenia is characterized especially by
delusions of prosecution, grandiosity, or jealousy and by hallucinations.
An average study on paranoid schizophrenia reflects that man diagnosed in
their late techs to early 20s. It‟s rare before 12 years or after 40 years. The
argument of the plaintiff runs around on the strength of medical certificate
issued by a doctor Exbt. 1 that deceased Mr. Amar Ch. Nath was suffering
with paranoid schizophrenia.
[49]
The doctor has not been examined as witness. There is no
information on record to say from what age he was suffering and his health
conditions and mental ability stage wise is setout. There is no periodical
medical checkup and treatment record and medical files to show the status
of the deceased. As per the evidence of village Pradhan PW-3 in his cross
examination stated that no land will be laid by the government to an insane
person. His statement weakens the contention of the plaintiff. The plaintiff
failed to establish Section-14 of the Contract Act in her favour.
[50]
Mr. S. Deb, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the
defendant No.9 herein who has not filed his written statement or counter.
Defendant No.9 is a pro-forma respondent duly registered in the SubRegistry Office. Doctor certificate cannot have an overriding effect on
registered sale deeds. Admittedly defendant supported the mother and
brother for medical treatment by providing financial assistance. There is
nothing to say others brother shared the responsibility.
[51]
It is always the creditor who has final call in the matter, unless
contrary of law and is provided by lawful agreement. Having observed
thus, the impugned judgment in TA No. 14 of 2016 dated 11.07.2017,
passed by the learned District Judge, North Tripura, Dharmanagar, stands
modified to the extent as indicated above.
[52]
In the result, the appeal stands allowed declaring the right,
title and possession in favour of the appellants over the schedule B land
measuring 0.25 acre. The respondents are directed to vacate and handover
the possession of suit schedule property to the appellants within a period of
two month from today.
[53]
Draw the decree accordingly and send down the LCRs
thereafter.
JUDGE
A.Ghosh
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review