Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
CRIMINAL MISCELLANEOUS No.3780 of 2019
Arising Out of PS. Case No.-785 Year-2018 Thana- BHAGALPUR COMPLAINT CASE
District- Bhagalpur
1.
2.
======================================================
Minakshi Kumari, D/o Parmanand Gupta, Resident of Village- Gudhatta
Chowk, Panna Mill Road, P.S.- Mouzahidpur, District- Bhagalpur.
... ... Petitioner
Versus
The State Of Bihar
Onkar prasad, S/o Saryug Singh, Resident of Village- Jaishiv Bigha, P.O.Habibpur, P.S.- Parbalpur, District- Nalanda, Present Address Executive
Director, Technoculture Building Centre Pvt. Ltd. , Ganpati Complex,
Second Floor, Patel Babu Road, P.S.- Kotwali (Tilka Manjhi) Bhagalpur.
... ... Opposite Parties
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner
For the O.P. No. 2
For the State
:
:
:
:
:
:
:
Mr. Jagjit Roshan, Adv.
Mr. Anjani Kumar, Adv.
Mr. Shashank Shekhar, Adv.
Mr. Jayant Kumar Ray, Adv.
Mr. Apul, Adv.
Mr. Surendra Kishore Thakur, Adv.
Mr. Navin Kumar Pandey, APP
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE CHANDRA SHEKHAR JHA
CAV JUDGMENT
Date : 29-08-2026
1. Heard the parties.
2. The present application has been
led for
quashing the order dated 27.06.2018 passed in Complaint
Case No. 785 of 2018 by the learned Chief Judicial
Magistrate, Bhagalpur, whereby cognizance has been taken
against the petitioner for the o*ences punishable under
Sections 406 and 420 of the Indian Penal Code and
summons has been directed to be issued.
3. The prosecution, in brief, arises out of
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
2/29
allegations made by the complainant, who was associated
with the company under the name and style of Vastu
Vihar/Technoculture Building Centre Pvt. Ltd. According to
the complainant, the petitioner was working as a Marketing
Executive and, in the course of such engagement, was
required to deal with customers and to receive certain
amounts from them in connection with the business of the
company.
4. It is the case of the complainant that complaints
were received from customers regarding payment of money
and non-completion of the consequential formalities. Upon
inquiry, it allegedly came to light that certain amounts
received from customers had not been deposited or
accounted for in the manner required. It is further alleged
that, on inquiry, the petitioner admitted receipt of an amount
of Rs. 25,70,500/- and agreed to return the same in
instalments.
According
to
the
complainant,
further
complaints subsequently came to light and the alleged
amount increased to Rs. 34,49,900/-.
5. The complaint further contains allegations
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
3/29
concerning subsequent events between the parties and their
family members. The petitioner, however, is the person
against whom the learned court below ultimately found a
prima facie case under Sections 406 and 420 of the Indian
Penal Code. Cognizance was not taken against all the
persons named in the complaint.
6. It is the speci c case of the petitioner that the
entire prosecution is false and has been instituted as a
counterblast to an earlier criminal case instituted at the
instance of the petitioner against certain o;cers of the
company. It is also the case of the petitioner that she had
been working merely as a Marketing Executive; that her
function was to contact customers and provide them
information regarding the schemes of the company; and that
she had no responsibility with regard to registration or
completion of the transactions undertaken by the company.
7.
The
petitioner
has
further
pleaded
that
whenever any amount was received from a customer, a
receipt was issued and the amount was handed over to the
concerned persons of the company. According to the
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
4/29
petitioner, the company, instead of taking action against its
own o;cers and employees responsible for the alleged
irregularities, has falsely attributed the entire liability to the
petitioner.
8. The petitioner has also referred to the previous
criminal litigation between the parties and has asserted that
the present complaint is retaliatory in nature. It is further
contended that the complainant did not institute any civil
proceeding for recovery of the alleged amount and that the
circumstances in which the complaint came to be instituted
demonstrate its mala de character.
9. It is further the case of the petitioner that
several persons were arrayed as accused in the complaint,
including family members of the petitioner, although they
had no concern with the a*airs of the company. According to
the petitioner, the fact that cognizance was ultimately taken
only against the petitioner itself demonstrates that the
allegations
against
the
other
accused
persons
were
exaggerated and that the complaint was instituted with an
ulterior motive.
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
5/29
10. The supplementary a;davit brought on record
by the petitioner also refers to the subsequent stage of the
complaint proceeding, including recording of evidence before
charge and the ling of an application under Section 245 of
the Code of Criminal Procedure. The petitioner has relied
upon such subsequent developments to contend that the
criminal proceeding ought not to be permitted to continue.
11. Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner
submits that the impugned order has been passed in a
mechanical manner and without proper application of judicial
mind. It is submitted that the essential ingredients of either
criminal breach of trust or cheating are not disclosed from
the complaint and that continuation of the proceeding would
amount to an abuse of the process of the Court.
12. Learned counsel further submits that there is
no speci c material to establish dishonest intention on the
part of the petitioner. It is argued that the allegations are
essentially based upon an internal dispute concerning the
functioning of the company and the alleged liability of
di*erent employees and o;cers.
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
6/29
13. Learned counsel for the petitioner has placed
reliance upon S.N. Vijayalakshmi and Ors. v. State of
Karnataka and Anr. [2025 SCC OnLine SC 1575] to
contend that criminal proceedings cannot be permitted to
continue merely because allegations are couched in the
language of criminal law, unless the basic ingredients of the
o*ence are disclosed. It would also be apposite to reproduce
the relevant paragraph nos.37, 38 and 42 of S.N.
Vijayalakshmi Case (supra) which reads as under:“37. Purely from a legal lens, it is now
settled that the same person cannot be simultaneously
charged for o*ences punishable under Sections 406 and
420 of the IPC with regard to one particular transaction,
as per the decision rendered in Delhi Race Club (1940)
Limited (supra). In this regard, reference may also be
made to a subsequent decision by us in V D Raveesha v.
State of Karnataka, 2024 INSC 1060 (penned by
Ahsanuddin Amanullah, J.), which noticed the exposition
in Delhi Race Club (1940) Limited (supra). In V D
Raveesha (supra), the distinction between Sections 406
and 420 of the IPC was duly taken note of, but charges
under Sections 406 and 420 of the IPC against the
same person were upheld, not being part of a single
transaction and committed against di*erent persons.
The relevant passage from V D Raveesha (supra) reads
thus: ‘21. Though, having regard to the aforeenumerated position of law, on an overall conspectus of
the factual aspects juxtaposed with the evidence on
record, as regards ful lment of the ingredients of
Sections 406 and 420 of the IPC, at rst sight, it may
appear that the petitioner cannot be convicted both
under Sections 406 and 420 of the IPC, but, in the
present case, on a proper consideration of the issue in
its entirety, there is a ne distinction inasmuch as, there
are two di*erent persons against whom the petitioner
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
7/29
has committed the respective o*ences under the
Sections supra : rst, the Company and second,
Mallikarjuna (PW4 and husband of purchaser
Savithramma). Thus, in the facts and circumstances of
the present case, evidently the petitioner is guilty of
o*ence committed against the Company punishable
under Section 406 of the IPC and also, of o*ence
committed against Mallikarjuna (PW4 and husband of
purchaser Savithramma) punishable under Section 420
of the IPC.’
38. Section 406 deals with punishment for
criminal breach of trust, which itself has been de ned
under Section 405 of the IPC. Section 420 of the IPC
deals with cheating and dishonestly inducing delivery of
property, the substantive o*ence of cheating has been
de ned in Section 415 of the IPC. We now apply the
ingredients to the factual position.
42. Coming to the second question i.e.,
whether civil and criminal proceedings both can be
maintained on the very same set of allegations qua the
same person(s), the answer stricto sensu, is that there
is no bar to simultaneous civil and criminal proceedings.
If the element of criminality is there, a civil case can coexist with a criminal case on the same facts. The fact
that a civil remedy has already been availed of by a
complainant, ipso facto, is not su;cient ground to quash
an FIR, as pointed out, inter alia, in P Swaroopa Rani v.
M Hari Narayana, (2008) 5 SCC 765 and Syed Aksari
Hadi Ali Augustine Imam v. State (Delhi Admn.), (2009)
5 SCC 528. The obvious caveat being that the
allegations, even if having a civil Havour to them, must
prima facie disclose an overwhelming element of
criminality. In the absence of the element of criminality,
if both civil and criminal cases are allowed to continue, it
will de nitely amount to abuse of the process of the
Court, which the Courts have always tried to prevent by
putting a stop to any such criminal proceeding, where
civil proceedings have already been instituted with
regard to the same issue, and the element of criminality
is absent. If such element is absent, the prosecution in
question would have to be quashed. In this connection,
Paramjeet Batra v. State of Uttarakhand, (2013) 11
SCC 673 can be referred to:
‘12. … Whether a complaint discloses a
criminal o*ence or not depends upon the nature of facts
alleged therein. Whether essential ingredients of criminal
o*ence are present or not has to be judged by the High
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
8/29
Court. A complaint disclosing civil transactions may also
have a criminal texture. But the High Court must see
whether a dispute which is essentially of a civil nature is
given a cloak of criminal o*ence. In such a situation, if a
civil remedy is available and is, in fact, adopted as has
happened in this case, the High Court should not
hesitate to quash the criminal proceedings to prevent
abuse of process of the court.”
14. Reliance has also been placed upon Arshad
Neyaz Khan v. State of Jharkhand and Anr. [2025 SCC
OnLine SC 2058], in support of the submission that the
High Court, while exercising jurisdiction for quashing, is
required to examine whether the allegations, taken at their
face value, disclose the necessary ingredients of the o*ences
alleged and whether the continuation of the prosecution
would amount to an abuse of the process of the Court. It
would also be appropriate to reproduce the paragraph no.21
of Arshad Neyaz Khan Case (supra), which reads as
under:“21. Furthermore, it is pertinent to mention
that if it is the case of the complainant/respondent No.
2 that the o*ence of criminal breach of trust as de ned
under Section 405 IPC, punishable under Section 406
IPC, is committed by the accused, then in the same
breath it cannot be said that the accused has also
committed the o*ence of cheating as de ned in Section
415, punishable under Section 420 IPC. This Court in
Delhi Race Club (1940) Limited v. State of Uttar
Pradesh, (2024) 10 SCC 690 observed that there is a
distinction between criminal breach of trust and
cheating. For cheating, criminal intention is necessary
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
9/29
at the time of making false or misleading
representation i.e. since inception. In criminal breach of
trust, mere proof of entrustment is su;cient. Thus, in
case of criminal breach of trust, the o*ender is lawfully
entrusted with the property, and he dishonestly
misappropriates the same. Whereas, in case of
cheating, the o*ender fraudulently or dishonestly
induces a person by deceiving him to deliver a
property. In such a situation, both o*ences cannot coexist simultaneously. Consequently, the complaint
cannot contain both the o*ences that are independent
and distinct. The said o*ences cannot co-exist
simultaneously in the same set of facts as they are
antithetical to each other.”
15. It is further submitted that the ingredients of
Sections 406 and 420 of the Indian Penal Code are distinct
and that the allegations, as made, do not establish the
foundational requirements of entrustment and dishonest
misappropriation, nor do they disclose fraudulent or
dishonest intention at the inception.
16. Learned counsel for the petitioner further
submits that the circumstances in which the present
complaint came to be instituted assume signi cance in view
of the fact that the petitioner had already set the criminal
law in motion against three persons, namely, Abhishek
Mishra, Hemlal Mahto and Santu Patel, by lodging P.S. Case
No. 199 of 2018, the First Information Report whereof has
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
10/29
been brought on record as Annexure-3 to the present
application.
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
11/29
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
12/29
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
13/29
17.
It is submitted that the aforesaid three
persons are themselves witnesses in the present complaint
instituted against the petitioner. Learned counsel submits
that the petitioner had made allegations against the said
persons prior in point of time and had already lodged the
aforesaid FIR against them. It is, therefore, contended that
the subsequent prosecution of the petitioner, in which the
very persons against whom she had earlier lodged the FIR
have gured as witnesses, cannot be viewed in isolation and
furnishes a relevant circumstance supporting the petitioner's
plea that the present proceeding has been initiated as a
counterblast and with an ulterior motive to pressurise the
petitioner.
18.
from
the
Learned counsel further submits that, apart
aforesaid
circumstance,
the
petitioner
had
speci cally alleged that owing to the nancial liability sought
to be fastened upon her, she was subjected to pressure and
was compelled to have an illicit sexual relationship with
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
14/29
Abhishek Mishra, who, according to the petitioner, was her
reporting boss in the company. It is submitted that the
petitioner had thereaLer lodged P.S. Case No. 199 of 2018
against Abhishek Mishra, Hemlal Mahto and Santu Patel, and
that the fact that these very persons subsequently gure as
witnesses in the complaint against the petitioner is a
circumstance which lends substantial support to her plea of
retaliatory prosecution.
19. It is also submitted that the present complaint
was subsequently instituted to create pressure upon the
petitioner and to protect the company and its o;cers from
the consequences of the earlier allegations made by the
petitioner.
20. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the
opposite party no. 2 submits that the prayer made by the
petitioner requires this Court to enter into disputed questions
of fact and to accept the defence of the accused at the
threshold. It is submitted that such an exercise is
impermissible while considering a petition for quashing.
21. Learned counsel submits that the complaint
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
15/29
speci cally alleges that the petitioner, while acting in
connection with the a*airs of the company and dealing with
customers, received money which was required to be
accounted for and deposited. The further allegation is that,
upon inquiry, the petitioner admitted receipt of a substantial
amount and undertook to return the same in installments.
22. Learned counsel for the opposite party no. 2
has referred to Vishwa Mitter v. O.P. Poddar and Ors.
[(1983) 4 SCC 701], to support the submission that,
unless a statutory provision prescribes otherwise, criminal
law may be set in motion by a person placing before the
competent court facts constituting an o*ence. It would also
be apposite to reproduce the paragraph no.5 of Vishwa
Mitter Case (supra), which reads as under:“5. It is thus crystal clear that anyone can
set the criminal law in motion by ling a complaint of
facts constituting an o*ence before a Magistrate entitled
to take cognizance under Section 190 and unless any
statutory provision prescribes any special quali cation or
eligibility criteria for putting the criminal law in motion,
no court can decline to take cognizance on the sole
ground that the complainant was not competent to le
the complaint. Section 190 of the Code of Criminal
Procedure clearly indicates that the quali cation of the
complainant to le a complaint is not relevant. But
where any special statute prescribes o*ences and makes
any special provision for taking cognizance of such
o*ences under the statute, the complainant requesting
the Magistrate to take cognizance of the o*ence must
satisfy the eligibility criterion prescribed by the statute.
Even with regard to o*ences under the Penal Code,
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
16/29
1860, ordinarily, anyone can set the criminal law in
motion but the various provisions in Chapter XIV
prescribe the quali cation of the complainant which
would enable him or her to le a complaint in respect of
speci ed o*ences and no court can take cognizance of
such o*ence unless the complainant satis es the
eligibility criterion, but in the absence of any such
speci cation, no court can throw out the complaint or
decline to take the cognizance on the sole ground that
the complainant was not competent to le the
complaint.”
23. Learned counsel further submits that the
subsequent developments relied upon by the petitioner
cannot retrospectively render the cognizance order illegal.
The legality of the order has to be tested primarily with
reference to the complaint and the material available to the
Magistrate at the relevant stage.
24. It is further submitted by learned counsel for
O.P No. 2 that upon facial perusal of Tilka Manjhi P.S. Case
No. 199/2018, by petitioner, it can be gathered safely that
same was lodged only when petitioner was asked to deposit
defalcated amount with company. It also failed to explain
that why petitioner was given Rs. 2,38,000(Two lakh thirty
eight thousand) by co-accused Abhishek Mishra to deposit
with bank account of the company, when loan was advanced
by co-accused Hemlal Mahto in his personal capacity.
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
17/29
25. Having heard the parties and upon perusal of
the materials available on record, this Court nds that the
controversy raised in the present application lies within a
narrow compass.
26. The jurisdiction of this Court to prevent abuse
of the process of any Court and to secure the ends of justice
is undoubtedly wide. At the same time, the width of the
jurisdiction is not a warrant for substituting a proceeding for
quashing with a full-Hedged adjudication of the defence of
the accused.
27. Where the allegations, even if accepted in their
entirety, do not disclose the commission of any o*ence,
interference
would
be
justi ed.
Equally,
where
proceeding is manifestly attended with mala
the
de and
continuation of the prosecution would amount to abuse of
the process of the Court, the High Court is not powerless to
interfere. At the same time, the inherent jurisdiction is not
intended to enable the Court to weigh the reliability of rival
versions, determine the truthfulness of a defence or
undertake a mini-trial.
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
18/29
28. The Constitution guarantees that no person
shall be deprived of personal liberty except according to
procedure established by law. The protection of personal
liberty under Article 21 necessarily requires that criminal law
cannot be permitted to operate arbitrarily or oppressively.
However, the constitutional guarantee of fairness does not
justify termination of a prosecution which, on its face,
discloses a prima-facie o*ence merely because the accused
has placed a competing factual version before the Court.
29. The presumption of innocence and the right to
a fair trial are cardinal principles of criminal jurisprudence.
They protect the accused against conviction except upon
proof in accordance with law. They do not, however,
authorise the High Court to accept the defence as
established
and to terminate proceedings
where the
prosecution allegations require adjudication upon evidence.
30.
The
constitutional
requirement
of
fair
procedure therefore requires a balance between protection
against an unjusti ed prosecution and the requirement that a
prima facie criminal accusation should not be terminated by
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
19/29
a premature judicial evaluation of disputed evidence.
31. In State of Haryana v. Bhajan Lal, 1992
Supp (1) SCC 335, the Supreme Court illustrated the
categories in which the extraordinary jurisdiction may be
exercised. The categories are not exhaustive and were never
intended to authorise the High Court to conduct a meticulous
examination of evidence.
32. The principles of judicial restraint at the
threshold
have
also
been
reiterated
in
Neeharika
Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. v. State of Maharashtra,
(2021) 19 SCC 401. Disputed questions of fact are
ordinarily not to be adjudicated in proceedings seeking
quashing.
33. The defence of the petitioner substantially
proceeds on the assertion that she was only a Marketing
Executive; that she had no responsibility in relation to
registration or completion of the customers' transactions;
that all money received by her was handed over to the
company; and that the present complaint is a counterblast to
earlier litigation.
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
20/29
34. These submissions cannot be rejected as
irrelevant. However, relevance of a defence is entirely
di*erent from its conclusiveness at the stage of quashing.
35. The complaint, on the other hand, proceeds on
the allegation that the petitioner received money from
customers in connection with the a*airs of the company and
that such amounts were not properly accounted for. The
further allegation regarding admission of receipt of a
substantial amount and an undertaking to return the same is
also part of the prosecution case.
36. Whether such admission was in fact made,
whether the alleged amounts were actually received by the
petitioner, whether they were deposited or handed over to
the company, and whether the petitioner acted dishonestly
are questions which cannot be answered by accepting the
petitioner's explanation as established truth.
37. The petitioner has emphasised the absence of
independent customer support. The adequacy, credibility and
ultimate evidentiary worth of the prosecution material are
matters for adjudication by the competent court in
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
21/29
accordance with law.
38. The circumstance that cognizance was not
taken against every person named in the complaint does not
automatically lead to the conclusion that the allegation
against the present petitioner must also fail. The role
attributed to each accused is required to be independently
considered.
39. The existence of a prior dispute may provide
material for a defence regarding motive, but motive for
institution of a complaint and the existence of a prima facie
o*ence are not identical questions.
40.
The
petitioner
has
relied
upon
S.N.
Vijayalakshmi Case (supra) and Arshad Neyaz Khan
case (supra). The principle emerging from the authorities
relied upon by the petitioner is that criminal proceedings
cannot be sustained merely by giving a civil or private
dispute the colour of criminality and that the foundational
ingredients of the o*ence must be disclosed. The same
principles, however, require examination of the allegations as
they stand and do not permit acceptance of a disputed
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
22/29
defence at the threshold.
41. This Court has also considered the speci c
submission advanced on behalf of the petitioner regarding
the previous institution of P.S. Case No. 199 of 2018, in
which Abhishek Mishra, Hemlal Mahto and Santu Patel have
been arrayed as accused and which, according to the
petitioner, was lodged prior to the present proceeding. The
First Information Report relating to the said case has been
brought on record as Annexure-3. It is further the speci c
case of the petitioner that the aforesaid three persons are
witnesses in the present complaint instituted against her.
42. The aforesaid circumstance cannot be said to
be wholly irrelevant. The fact that the petitioner had already
instituted a criminal case against persons who subsequently
gure as witnesses in the complaint against her is certainly a
circumstance which may be relied upon by the petitioner in
support of her plea that the present proceeding is retaliatory
in nature. The Court is also conscious of the petitioner's
allegation that she had been subjected to pressure on
account of the nancial liability attributed to her and that she
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
23/29
was allegedly compelled to have an illicit sexual relationship
with Abhishek Mishra, stated to be her reporting boss in the
company.
43. However, the question whether the aforesaid
circumstances, individually or cumulatively, establish that the
present complaint was instituted as a counterblast is
essentially a question of fact. The mere existence of a
previous FIR lodged by the petitioner against persons who
are witnesses in the present case, though a relevant
circumstance, cannot by itself lead this Court to conclude, at
the stage of quashing, that the allegations forming the basis
of the present prosecution are false or that the cognizance
taken
by
the
learned
Magistrate
is
wholly
without
jurisdiction.
44. Equally, this Court cannot, at this stage, enter
into the truth or otherwise of the allegation made by the
petitioner regarding the alleged conduct of Abhishek Mishra.
Such an allegation is undoubtedly serious, but its truth, the
circumstances in which the alleged conduct took place, the
e*ect thereof upon the petitioner and its connection, if any,
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
24/29
with the nancial allegations forming the subject matter of
the present complaint are matters which would require
appreciation of evidence. This Court, while exercising
jurisdiction for quashing, cannot undertake such an exercise
or record a nding on disputed questions of fact.
45. It is accordingly held that, although the
aforesaid circumstances constitute a relevant part of the
defence of the petitioner and may assume signi cance at the
appropriate stage of the criminal proceeding, this Court is
unable to hold, solely on the basis thereof, that the present
prosecution is so manifestly mala
de or inherently
improbable that its continuation would amount to an abuse
of the process of the Court. The petitioner shall, however,
remain at liberty to place on record and rely upon the FIR in
P.S. Case No. 199 of 2018 and all other permissible
materials before the learned court below in accordance with
law.
46. It is clari ed that this Court has not expressed
any opinion regarding the truthfulness of the allegations
contained in P.S. Case No. 199 of 2018, the culpability of
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
25/29
Abhishek Mishra, Hemlal Mahto or Santu Patel, or the
allegation made by the petitioner concerning Abhishek
Mishra. Likewise, no nding is being recorded as to whether
the said FIR was the actual cause or motive for institution of
the present complaint. These matters are leL open for
consideration by the competent forum in accordance with
law.
47. At this stage, this Court is unable to hold that
the allegations regarding receipt of money in the course of
the petitioner's dealings with customers, failure to account
for the same and the alleged subsequent admission and
undertaking are so inherently improbable or devoid of factual
foundation that no o*ence whatsoever can be said to be
disclosed.
48. The precise nature of entrustment, the
circumstances in which the money was received, the capacity
in which it was retained, the existence or otherwise of
dishonest intention and the alleged inducement are matters
which emerge from the factual matrix and may require
appreciation of evidence.
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
26/29
49. In Vishwa Mitter Case (supra), the
Supreme Court explained that, in the absence of a statutory
restriction, a person can set the criminal law in motion by
placing before the competent court facts constituting an
o*ence. The emphasis is upon the disclosure of facts
constituting the o*ence, and not upon a preliminary
adjudication of whether the complainant would ultimately
succeed in proving every allegation.
50. The absence of a civil proceeding for recovery
of
the
alleged
amount
also
cannot
be
treated
as
determinative. Civil remedies and criminal proceedings
operate in distinct elds, and the absence of a civil action
cannot, by itself, erase allegations which otherwise disclose a
prima facie criminal o*ence.
51. The impugned order is assailed as mechanical.
An order taking cognizance is not required to contain an
elaborate judgment evaluating every conceivable defence of
the accused. The requirement is that the order should reHect
application of judicial mind to the material placed before the
Magistrate.
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
27/29
52. In the present case, cognizance was not taken
against all the persons named in the complaint. The learned
court below found a prima facie case against the petitioner
under Sections 406 and 420 of the Indian Penal Code. This
circumstance, by itself, does not support the contention that
every allegation was mechanically accepted.
53.
The
subsequent
proceedings
and
the
petitioner's application under Section 245 of the Code of
Criminal Procedure do not furnish a ground for substituting
the present jurisdiction for the remedies available before the
competent court. The petitioner remains at liberty to pursue
every remedy available to her in accordance with law.
54. This Court has not expressed any opinion on
the ultimate guilt or innocence of the petitioner. All
observations are con ned to the limited question whether the
impugned cognizance order and the criminal proceeding
warrant interference at this stage.
55.
Upon
an
overall
consideration
of
the
allegations, the nature of the defence raised by the
petitioner and the settled limits of jurisdiction for quashing,
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
28/29
this Court is of the considered view that the present case
does not fall within the exceptional categories warranting
interference.
56. The petitioner seeks, in substance, an
adjudication that the money was never misappropriated by
her, that all amounts received were handed over to the
company and that the present complaint is retaliatory. These
are matters of defence and disputed facts which cannot
appropriately be decided in the present proceeding.
57. The extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court
exists to prevent miscarriage of justice, but it cannot be
exercised
to
pre-empt
the
ordinary
criminal
process
whenever the accused places before the Court a plausible
competing version of the facts.
58. Accordingly, this Court does not nd any good
ground to interfere with the order dated 27.06.2018 passed
in Complaint Case No. 785 of 2018 by the learned Chief
Judicial Magistrate, Bhagalpur.
59. The present application, accordingly, stands
dismissed.
Patna High Court CR. MISC. No.3780 of 2019 dt.29-08-2026
29/29
60. It is, however, made clear that the petitioner
shall be at liberty to raise all permissible factual and legal
pleas before the learned court below at the appropriate
stage. The learned court below shall consider the matter
independently and strictly in accordance with law, without
being inHuenced by any observation made in the present
judgment, which is con ned only to the prayer for quashing
of cognizance order.
61. Any pending interlocutory application shall also
stand disposed of.
62. Let the records, if called for, be transmitted to
the learned trial court forthwith.
(Chandra Shekhar Jha, J.)
Raushan/AFR/NAFR
CAV DATE
Uploading Date
Transmission Date
AFR
20.08.2026
29.08.2026
29.08.2026
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review