Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/19
GAHC040018722025
2026:GAU-AP:691
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/535/2025
Millo Tali
Son of Shri Millo Halley, permanent resident of Tajang Village, PO and PS Ziro,
Lower Subansri District, Arunachal Pradesh 791120
VERSUS
The State of AP and 4 Ors
represented by the Chief Secretary, Govt of Arunachal Pradesh, Itanagar 791111
2:The Principal Secretary (Home)
Age: 0
Occupation :
Govt of Arunachal Pradesh
Itanagar 791111
3:The Director General of Police
Age: 0
Occupation :
Arunachal Pradesh
PHQ
Itanagar 791113
4:The Assistant Inspector General (E)
Age: 0
Occupation :
Arunachal Pradesh
PHQ
Itanagar 791113
5:The Assistant Inspector General (I)
Age: 0
Occupation :
Arunachal Pradesh
PHQ
Page No.# 2/19
Itanagar 79111
Advocate for the Petitioner
: A Timung, Dipanjan Bhuyan,Kuldeep Baishya,K Gogoi
Advocate for the Respondent : GA (AP),
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KARDAK ETE
Date on which judgment is reserved
:
N/A
Date of pronouncement of judgment :
27.07.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
Operative part of the judgment
:
No
Whether the full judgment has been
Pronounced
:
Yes
JUDGMENT & ORDER (Oral)
Heard Mr. K. Gogoi, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. S.
Tapin, learned Senior Government Advocate for the State respondents.
2.
Challenge made in this writ petition is to the speaking order dated
27.09.2024 issued by the Principal Secretary (Home), Government of Arunachal
Pradesh, whereby the representation submitted by the petitioner seeking
inclusion of his name in the final seniority list of Inspectors (Civil Police) by
taking into account his past service rendered as Inspector (GD) in the Border
Security Force (BSF) came to be rejected. The petitioner has also put to
challenge the order dated 24.02.2023 insofar as it permanently absorbs him in
the Arunachal Pradesh Police to the extent against an Ex-Cadre post of
Inspector (Civil), as well as the final seniority list dated 13.09.2023 wherein, his
Page No.# 3/19
name has not been included therein.
3.
The petitioner is presently serving as Inspector (Civil Police) under the
Arunachal Pradesh Police and is posted in the Security Cell, Police Headquarters,
Itanagar. Prior to his induction into the Arunachal Pradesh Police, the petitioner
was
selected
through
the
Central
Police
Organisation
(Sub-Inspector)
Examination, 2003 conducted by the Staff Selection Commission and was
appointed as Sub-Inspector (Direct Entry) in the Border Security Force (BSF)
pursuant to letter dated 29.10.2004. The petitioner joined the Border Security
Force on 01.01.2005.
4.
While serving in the BSF, the petitioner was deputed to the Special
Protection Group (SPG) in the year 2010 as Security Officer-II. During the period
of such deputation, the Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India, vide
order dated 31.05.2010, promoted 337 Sub-Inspectors to the rank of Inspector
(GD), wherein the name of the petitioner also figured. According to the
petitioner, though he was then on deputation with the Special Protection Group,
he was granted proforma promotion to the rank of Inspector (GD) with effect
from 31.05.2010 and, consequent thereto, he was promoted in the Special
Protection Group to the rank of Security Officer-I with effect from 21.02.2011. It
is stated that his pay was accordingly re-fixed by granting him all consequential
financial benefits. Subsequently, in the year 2016, the petitioner was repatriated
to his parent department, namely, the Border Security Force, and was attached
to the Office of the Minister of State for Home Affairs, Government of India,
New Delhi.
5.
While serving as Inspector (GD) in the Border Security Force, the petitioner
was offered appointment on deputation as Inspector (Civil Police) under the
Arunachal Pradesh Police for a period of three years vide offer letter dated
Page No.# 4/19
03.10.2018 issued by the Government of Arunachal Pradesh. Pursuant thereto,
the competent authority in the Border Security Force relieved the petitioner for
joining the Arunachal Pradesh Police, and the petitioner accordingly joined the
office of the Director General of Police, Arunachal Pradesh, on 01.12.2018.
6.
It is the case of the petitioner that while he was serving on deputation in
the Arunachal Pradesh Police, the Police Headquarters recommended his
permanent absorption, taking into consideration his experience in the Special
Protection Group and VIP Security. Thereafter, a No Objection Certificate was
obtained from the Border Security Force, and vide order dated 24.02.2023, the
petitioner came to be permanently absorbed in the Arunachal Pradesh Police
with effect from the said date as Inspector purportedly against an Ex-Cadre
post. Consequent thereto, the petitioner tendered technical resignation from the
Border Security Force and was struck off the strength of his parent department
with effect from 23.02.2023.
7.
The petitioner contends that his deputation to the Arunachal Pradesh Police
was made under the 25% quota earmarked for deputation under the Inspector
of Police (Group-C Post) Recruitment Rules, 1988, as amended from time to
time, and therefore his permanent absorption ought to have been against a
regular cadre post and not against an Ex-Cadre post.
8.
The petitioner states that the respondent authorities published the final
seniority list of Inspectors (Civil Police), Inspectors (IRBn) and Inspectors
(AAPBn) vide order dated 13.09.2023, wherein his name was not included
notwithstanding his permanent absorption in the Arunachal Pradesh Police.
Being aggrieved, the petitioner submitted a representation dated 20.09.2023
requesting the authorities to include his name in the seniority list by taking into
account the past service rendered by him in the equivalent post of Inspector
Page No.# 5/19
(GD) in the Border Security Force. Since no decision was taken on the said
representation, the petitioner approached this Court by filing W.P. (C) No. 168 of
2024.
9.
This Court, by order dated 12.04.2024 passed in W.P. (C) No. 168 of 2024,
directed the petitioner to submit a fresh representation before the Principal
Secretary (Home), Government of Arunachal Pradesh, and further directed the
said authority to consider and dispose of the same in accordance with law.
Pursuant thereto, the petitioner submitted a fresh representation dated
15.04.2024.
10.
Thereafter, the Principal Secretary (Home), Government of Arunachal
Pradesh, passed the impugned speaking order dated 27.09.2024 holding, inter
alia, that the petitioner had been taken on deputation and subsequently
absorbed against an Ex-Cadre post and that the Recruitment Rules governing
the post of Inspector (Civil Police) did not contain any provision for absorption
against the regular cadre. It was further observed that since the petitioner stood
absorbed against an Ex-Cadre post, his name could not be included in the
seniority list maintained for the regular cadre of Inspectors (Civil Police).
Consequently, the representation submitted by the petitioner came to be
rejected.
11. The petitioner contends that it was only upon receipt of the impugned
speaking order that he became aware that his absorption had been made
against an Ex-Cadre post. The petitioner thereafter sought information under
the Right to Information Act regarding the existence of such Ex-Cadre post and
claims to have been informed that no sanctioned Ex-Cadre post of Inspector
(Civil Police) existed in the Arunachal Pradesh Police.
Page No.# 6/19
12. The petitioner has further contended that the original offer of appointment
dated 03.10.2018 specifically stipulated that he was being appointed on
deputation against one of the existing deputation vacancies in the cadre of
Inspector (Civil Police). According to him, the respondent authorities are
therefore estopped from subsequently treating his appointment as one against
an Ex-Cadre post, particularly after he had altered his position by accepting the
offer and severing his lien with the Border Security Force.
13. Mr. K. Gogoi, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that the petitioner
had been holding the substantive post of Inspector (GD) in the BSF with effect
from 31.05.2010 and that the post of Inspector (GD) in the Border Security
Force is equivalent to the post of Inspector (Civil Police) in the Arunachal
Pradesh Police. It is therefore contended that upon his permanent absorption in
the Arunachal Pradesh Police, his past substantive service in the equivalent post
ought to have been taken into consideration while determining his seniority.
14. Learned counsel submits that the action of the respondent authorities in
excluding the petitioner's name from the final seniority list dated 13.09.2023
and in rejecting his claim by the speaking order dated 27.09.2024 is arbitrary,
discriminatory and contrary to the settled principles governing deputation and
permanent absorption in service jurisprudence. It is submitted that once the
petitioner had been permanently absorbed in an equivalent post, the
respondents could not have deprived him of the benefit of his past substantive
service rendered in the Border Security Force.
15. Mr. Gogoi submits that the impugned speaking order proceeds entirely on
the erroneous premise that the petitioner had been appointed against an ExCadre post. He submits that the offer of appointment itself clearly stipulated
that the petitioner was being appointed against one of the existing deputation
Page No.# 7/19
vacancies under the Recruitment Rules. It is contended that the respondents
cannot now be permitted to resile from the terms of the offer by contending
that the petitioner was serving against an Ex-Cadre post, particularly when the
petitioner had acted upon the representation made by the State Government
and had tendered technical resignation from his parent department.
16. It is submitted that the Recruitment Rules governing the post of Inspector
(Civil Police) contemplate appointment by deputation against the prescribed
quota and do not envisage permanent absorption against an Ex-Cadre post.
According to the petitioner, once his initial deputation was made against a
sanctioned cadre vacancy, the subsequent order absorbing him against an ExCadre post is dehors the Recruitment Rules and is therefore liable to be
interfered with.
17. Learned counsel for the petitioner also contends that the impugned action
of the respondents is hit by the Doctrine of Promissory Estoppel inasmuch as
the petitioner accepted the offer of deputation on the clear representation that
he would be appointed against an existing deputation vacancy. Having acted
upon such representation and relinquished his substantive position in the Border
Security Force, the respondents are estopped from taking a contrary stand to
his prejudice.
18. Mr. Gogoi, learned counsel, places reliance upon the decision of the Hon'ble
Supreme Court in S. I. Rooplal & Anr. v. Lt. Governor through Chief
Secretary, Delhi & Ors., reported in (2000) 1 SCC 644, to contend that
where a Government servant holding an equivalent post is transferred on
deputation and subsequently absorbed in the transferee department, the
substantive service rendered by him in the parent department is liable to be
counted while determining his seniority in the absorbed post. It is submitted
Page No.# 8/19
that the ratio laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court squarely applies to the
facts of the present case, inasmuch as the petitioner had already been holding
the equivalent post of Inspector (GD) in the Border Security Force on a regular
basis prior to his permanent absorption in the Arunachal Pradesh Police. The
relevant paragraphs of the said judgment is quoted hereinbelow:
“15. We will now take up the question whether the appellants are entitled to
count their service rendered by them as Sub-Inspector in the BSF for the
purpose of their seniority after absorption as Sub-Inspector (Executive) in Delhi
Police or not. We have already noticed the fact that it is pursuant to the needs
of Delhi Police that these officials were deputed to Delhi Police from the BSF
following the procedure laid down in Rule 5(h) of the Rules and subsequently
absorbed as contemplated under the said Rules. It is also not in dispute that at
some point of time in the BSF, the appellants services were regularised in the
post of Sub-Inspector and they were transferred as regularly appointed SubInspectors to Delhi Police Force. Therefore, on being absorbed in an equivalent
cadre in the transferred post, we find no reason why these transferred officials
should not be permitted to count their service in the parent department. At any
rate, this question is not res integra and is squarely covered by the ratio of
judgments of this Court is more than one case. Since the earlier Bench of the
tribunal relied upon Madhavan s case to give relief to the deputationists, we
will first consider the law laid down by this Court in Madhavan s case (supra).
This Court in that case while considering a similar question, came to the
following conclusion:
"We may examine the question from a different point of view. There is not
much difference between deputation and transfer. Indeed, when a deputationist
is permanently absorbed in the CBI, he is under the rules appointed on transfer.
In other words, deputation may be regarded as a transfer from one government
department to another. It will be against all rules of service jurisprudence, if a
government servant holding a particular post is transferred to the same or an
equivalent post in another government department, the period of his service in
the post before his transfer is not taken into consideration in computing his
seniority in the transferred post. The transfer cannot wipe out his length of
service in the post from which he has been transferred. It has been observed by
this Court that it is a just and by this Court that it is a just and wholesome
principle commonly applied where persons from different sources are drafted to
serve in a new service that their pre-existing total length of service in the
parent department should be respected and presented by taking the same into
Page No.# 9/19
account in determining their ranking in the new service cadre.
17. In law, it is necessary that if the previous service of a transferred official is
to be counted for seniority in the transferred post then the two posts should be
equivalent. One of the objections raised by the respondents in this case as well
as in the earlier case of Antony Mathew is that the post of a Sub-Inspector in the
BSF is not equivalent to the post of a Sub-Inspector (Executive) in Delhi Police.
This argument is solely based on the fact that the pay-scales of the two posts
are not equal. Though the original Bench of the tribunal rejected this argument
of the respondent, which was confirmed at the stage of SLP by this Court, this
argument found favour with the subsequent Bench of the same tribunal whose
order is in appeal before us in these cases. Hence, we will proceed to deal with
this argument now. Equivalency of two posts is not judged by the sole fact of
equal pay. While determining the equation of twoposts many factors other than
Pay will have to be taken into consideration, like the nature of duties,
responsibilities, minimum qualification etc. It is so held by this Court as far back
as in the year 1968 in the case of Union of India &Anr. v. P.K. Roy & Ors.3. In the
said judgment, this Court accepted the factors laid down by the Committee of
Chief Secretaries which was constituted for settling the disputes regarding
equation of posts arising out of the States Reorganisation Act, 1956. These four
factors are: (i) the nature and duties of a post; (ii) the responsibilities and
powers exercised by the officer holding a post; the extent of territorial or other
charge held as responsibilities discharged; (iii) the minimum qualifications, if
any, prescribed for recruitment to the post; and (iv) the salary of the post. It is
seen that the salary of a post for the purpose of finding out the equivalency of
posts is the last of the criterion. If the earlier three criteria mentioned above are
fulfilled then the fact that the salaries of the two posts are different, would not
in any way make the post not equivalent . In the instant case, it is not the case of
the respondents that the first three criteria mentioned hereinabove are in any
manner different between the two posts concerned. Therefore, it should be held
that the view taken by the tribunal is the impugned order that the two posts of
Sub-Inspector in the BSF and the Sub-Inspector (Executive) in Delhi Police are
not equivalent merely on the ground that the two posts did not carry the same
pay-scale, is necessarily to be rejected. We are further supported in this view of
ours by another judgment of this Court in the case of Vice-Chancellor, L.N.
Mithila University v. Dayanand Jha4 wherein at para 8 of the judgment, this
Court held: "Learned counsel for the respondent is therefore right in contending
that equivalence of the pay-scale is not the only factor in judging whether the
post of Principal and that of Reader are equivalent posts. We are inclined to
agree with him that the real criterion to adopt is whether they could be
regarded of equal status and responsibility. xxx The true criterion for
Page No.# 10/19
equivalence is the status and the nature and responsibility of the duties
attached to the two posts. xxx".
23. It is clear from the ratio laid down in the above case that any Rule,
Regulation or Executive Instruction which has the effect of taking away the
service rendered by a deputationist in an equivalent cadre in the parent
department while counting his seniority in the deputed post would be violative
of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution. Hence, liable to be struck down. Since
the impugned Memorandum in its entirety does not take away the above right
of the deputationists and by striking down the offending part of the
Memorandum, as has been prayed in the writ petition, the rights of the
appellants could be preserved, we agree with the prayer of the
petitioners/appellants and the offending words in the Memorandum
"whichever is later" are held to be violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution, hence, those words are quashed from the text of the impugned
Memorandum. Consequently, the right of the petitioners/appellants to count
their service from the date of their regular appointment in the post of SubInspector in BSF, while computing their seniority in the cadre of Sub-Inspector
(Executive) in the Delhi Police, is restored.”
19. The learned counsel for the petitioner prays that the impugned speaking
order dated 27.09.2024, the order of absorption dated 24.02.2023 to the extent
it absorbs the petitioner against an Ex-Cadre post, and the final seniority list
dated 13.09.2023 insofar as it excludes the name of the petitioner, be set aside
and appropriate directions may be issued to the respondent authorities to
absorb the petitioner against a regular cadre post and to determine his seniority
by taking into account the past substantive service rendered by him as
Inspector (GD) in the BSF.
20. Per contra, Mr. S. Tapin, learned Senior Government Advocate, appearing
for the respondent authorities, referring to the affidavit-in-opposition filed on
behalf of the respondents, submits that the petitioner’s entire claim for inclusion
of his name in the seniority list of Inspectors (Civil Police), Arunachal Pradesh
Police, proceeds on the assertion that he was absorbed against a regular cadre
post of Inspector. However, the records clearly demonstrate that the petitioner
Page No.# 11/19
was permanently absorbed only against an isolated Ex-Cadre post created for
the said purpose vide order dated 24.02.2023 issued by the Director General of
Police, Arunachal Pradesh.
21. Learned Senior Government Advocate submits that the petitioner was
initially appointed in the Arunachal Pradesh Police on deputation basis pursuant
to the offer letter dated 03.10.2018. The said appointment was purely on
deputation for a period of three years and was adjusted against one of the two
existing deputation vacancies in the post of Inspector. However, such deputation
did not confer upon the petitioner any right to seek absorption against a regular
cadre post.
22. It is submitted that at the stage of considering permanent absorption of
the petitioner, the matter was examined by the competent authorities. The
Department of Administrative Reforms, after considering the Recruitment Rules
governing the post of Inspector of Police (Group-C Post), observed that the said
Rules did not contain any provision for permanent absorption of deputationists
against the regular cadre strength. Accordingly, approval was granted for
creation of one isolated Ex-Cadre post of Inspector and the petitioner was
permanently absorbed against the said post.
23.
Learned Senior Government Advocate submits that the order dated
24.02.2023 issued by the DGP, Arunachal Pradesh, clearly mentions that the
petitioner was permanently absorbed as Inspector (Civil Police) against an ExCadre post. Therefore, the subsequent contention of the petitioner that he was
not aware of the nature of his absorption is unacceptable.
24. Learned Senior Government Advocate submits that the final seniority list
dated 13.09.2023 was issued by the Home Department, Government of
Page No.# 12/19
Arunachal Pradesh, after following due procedure. The provisional seniority list
was circulated on 06.12.2022 inviting objections and claims from all concerned.
However, no objection or claim was submitted by the petitioner within the
stipulated period. Therefore, the petitioner cannot now seek interference with
the final seniority list.
25.
Learned Senior Government Advocate submits that the representation
submitted by the petitioner pursuant to the order passed by this Hon’ble Court
was duly considered by the competent authority. After consultation with the
concerned departments, particularly the Department of Administrative Reforms,
it was clarified that the petitioner was absorbed against an Ex-Cadre post and
that the Recruitment Rules did not provide for absorption of deputationists in
the regular cadre of Inspector (Civil Police). Consequently, the petitioner’s claim
for fixation of seniority by taking into account his past service in BSF was
rejected by a speaking order dated 27.09.2024.
26. Learned Senior Government Advocate submits that the petitioner cannot
claim seniority in the regular cadre of Arunachal Pradesh Police on the basis of
his earlier service rendered in BSF. Seniority is always determined with reference
to the cadre in which an employee is appointed or absorbed. Since the
petitioner’s absorption was against an Ex-Cadre post, his claim for inclusion in
the regular seniority list of Inspectors (Civil Police) is untenable.
27. Learned Senior Government Advocate submits that the speaking order
dated 27.09.2024 passed by the Principal Secretary (Home), Government of
Arunachal Pradesh, is a reasoned order passed after considering all relevant
aspects. The petitioner has failed to establish any violation of his legal or
fundamental rights warranting interference by this Court. Learned Senior
Government Advocate, therefore, submits that the writ petition deserves to be
Page No.# 13/19
dismissed.
28. Rejoining his submissions, Mr. K. Gogoi, learned counsel appearing for the
petitioner, submits that the respondents themselves have admitted that the
petitioner was initially brought into the Arunachal Pradesh Police against one of
the existing deputation vacancies under the applicable Recruitment Rules.
According to the learned counsel, the subsequent creation of an Ex-Cadre post
at the stage of absorption cannot retrospectively alter the character of the
petitioner’s original appointment or deprive him of the benefits flowing from his
service in the equivalent post of Inspector (GD) in the BSF.
29. Learned counsel submits that the respondents have taken inconsistent
stands inasmuch as, while acknowledging that the petitioner was appointed
against an existing deputation vacancy, they simultaneously contend that the
petitioner was deputed against an Ex-Cadre post. Such contradictory positions,
according to the learned counsel, cannot be relied upon to deny the petitioner
his legitimate service benefits.
30. Learned counsel submits that the materials on record demonstrate that the
petitioner’s permanent absorption was not a result of any claim made by him for
an Ex-Cadre post, but was a decision taken by the authorities after considering
his long experience in the SPC and VIP security. The petitioner, having accepted
the decision of the State Government and relinquished his parent cadre in the
BSF, cannot subsequently be placed in a disadvantageous position due to the
manner in which the authorities chose to structure his absorption.
31.
Learned counsel further submits that the reliance placed by the
respondents upon the absence of a specific provision for absorption under the
Recruitment Rules is misconceived. It is submitted that the respondents, having
Page No.# 14/19
exercised their power to permanently absorb the petitioner, cannot deny the
consequential benefits attached to such absorption by taking shelter under the
very Rules which were considered while processing his case.
32. Learned counsel submits that the petitioner’s claim is not based merely on
his past service in the Border Security Force, but on the fact that he was holding
an equivalent post of Inspector (GD) on a substantive basis before joining the
Arunachal Pradesh Police on deputation. Therefore, the petitioner’s past service
is liable to be considered for the purpose of fixation of seniority upon
absorption.
33. Learned counsel further submits that the petitioner was never informed
during his induction or during his service in the Arunachal Pradesh Police that he
was being dealt with against an isolated Ex-Cadre post. Reference is made to
the communication dated 13.05.2024 issued by the Police Headquarters
forwarding the petitioner’s representation, wherein the department itself
expressed uncertainty regarding the petitioner’s cadre position and seniority.
According to the learned counsel, the same demonstrates that the petitioner’s
service status was never clearly determined by the authorities.
34.
I have considered the submissions advanced by the learned counsel
appearing for the parties and have carefully perused the pleadings, documents
and materials available on record.
35. The issue which arises for determination in the present writ petition
essentially relates to the legality of the action of the respondent authorities in
treating the petitioner, who was inducted into the Arunachal Pradesh Police on
deputation from the BSF and subsequently permanently absorbed, as having
been absorbed against an Ex-Cadre post and consequently denying him
Page No.# 15/19
inclusion in the seniority list of Inspectors (Civil Police), Arunachal Pradesh
Police, by refusing to take into account his past substantive service rendered as
Inspector (GD) in the BSF.
36. The undisputed facts emerging from the record reveal that the petitioner
was appointed as Sub-Inspector (Direct Entry) in the BSF pursuant to his
selection through the Central Police Organisation (Sub-Inspector) Examination
conducted by the Staff Selection Commission. During his service in the Border
Security Force, the petitioner was promoted to the rank of Inspector (GD) with
effect from 31.05.2010 and thereafter continued to hold the said substantive
post.
37. While serving as Inspector (GD) in the BSF, the petitioner was offered
appointment as Inspector (Civil Police) under the Arunachal Pradesh Police on
deputation basis vide offer letter dated 03.10.2018 issued by the Government of
Arunachal Pradesh. The said offer letter specifically provided that the petitioner’s
appointment would be on deputation for a period of three years and would be
adjusted against one of the two existing deputation vacancies in the post of
Inspector in Arunachal Pradesh Police.
38. Pursuant thereto, after being relieved from his parent department, the
petitioner joined the Arunachal Pradesh Police on 01.12.2018. During the period
of such deputation, the Police Headquarters recommended his permanent
absorption considering his experience and service rendered in the SPG and VIP
Security. After obtaining necessary approval and NOC from the BSF, the
petitioner was permanently absorbed in the Arunachal Pradesh Police vide order
dated 24.02.2023 as Inspector (Civil Police).
39. From the materials available on record, it is apparent that the petitioner’s
Page No.# 16/19
initial induction into the Arunachal Pradesh Police was not against any Ex-Cadre
post. The offer letter dated 03.10.2018 issued by the Government of Arunachal
Pradesh clearly records that the petitioner was appointed on deputation against
one of the existing deputation vacancies in the post of Inspector. The
respondents have also admitted in their affidavit-in-opposition that the
petitioner was initially taken on deputation against an existing deputation
vacancy.
40. The subsequent decision of the authorities to permanently absorb the
petitioner against an isolated Ex-Cadre post was taken only at the stage of
permanent absorption. Such subsequent arrangement, in the opinion of this
Court, cannot alter the character of the petitioner’s original appointment or
extinguish the benefit of the substantive service already rendered by him in an
equivalent post in his parent department.
41. The contention of the respondents that the Recruitment Rules governing
the post of Inspector (Civil Police) do not contain any provision for permanent
absorption and therefore the petitioner cannot claim seniority in the regular
cadre, cannot be accepted in view of the fact that the petitioner was inducted
into the Arunachal Pradesh Police on deputation against an existing vacancy, his
services have been utilized for more than four years, and thereafter he was
permanently absorbed by the competent authority. Having accepted his services
and permitted him to sever his lien with the BSF, the respondents cannot deny
him consequential service benefits by relying upon a subsequent classification
made at the stage of absorption.
42. The petitioner had already been holding the substantive post of Inspector
(GD) in the BSF before his deputation to the Arunachal Pradesh Police. The
equivalence of the post held by the petitioner in the BSF and the post of
Page No.# 17/19
Inspector (Civil Police) in the Arunachal Pradesh Police has not been disputed by
the respondents. Thus, the principle laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
S.I. Rooplal (supra), would squarely apply to the facts of the present case.
43. In S.I. Rooplal (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court held that where an
employee holding an equivalent post in the parent department is transferred on
deputation and subsequently absorbed in the transferee department, his past
service rendered in the equivalent post is liable to be counted for the purpose of
determining seniority. The ratio laid down therein is based on the principle that
an employee should not be deprived of his legitimate service benefits merely
because he entered another department through the process of deputation.
44. The reliance placed by the respondents on the Ex-Cadre nature of the post
cannot, in the opinion of this Court, defeat the petitioner’s claim. The Ex-Cadre
arrangement was not the basis of his initial appointment and was introduced
only while effecting permanent absorption. The respondents cannot take
advantage of an administrative arrangement subsequently created by them to
deny the petitioner the benefit of his past substantive service.
45. It is also significant that the petitioner was not informed at the time of his
deputation that his appointment would subsequently be treated in a manner
which would deprive him of cadre seniority. The communication dated
13.05.2024 issued by the Police Headquarters forwarding the petitioner’s
representation itself reflects uncertainty regarding the petitioner’s cadre position
and seniority. Such uncertainty arising out of the actions of the respondents
cannot operate to the prejudice of the petitioner.
46. The submission of the respondents that the petitioner did not submit any
objection to the provisional seniority list also does not advance and support their
Page No.# 18/19
case for the reason that the provisional seniority list was published before his
absorption. Moreso, the petitioner’s grievance is not merely against the seniority
list but against the very basis on which he has been excluded from the cadre
seniority after his permanent absorption. The petitioner approached the
authorities and thereafter this Court within the permissible framework of law.
47. In view of the foregoing discussion, this Court is of the considered opinion
that the action of the respondent authorities in excluding the petitioner from the
final seniority list of Inspectors (Civil Police), Arunachal Pradesh Police, and
rejecting his claim vide speaking order dated 27.09.2024, cannot be sustained.
48. Accordingly, the impugned speaking order dated 27.09.2024 passed by the
Principal Secretary (Home), Government of Arunachal Pradesh, is hereby set
aside. The final seniority list dated 13.09.2023, insofar as it excludes the name
of the petitioner from the seniority list of Inspectors (Civil Police), Arunachal
Pradesh Police, is also set aside to that extent.
49. Consequently, the respondent authorities are directed to determine and
refix the seniority position of the petitioner in the cadre of Inspector (Civil
Police), Arunachal Pradesh Police, by treating his substantive service rendered
as Inspector (GD) in the Border Security Force from 31.05.2010 as qualifying
service for the purpose of fixation of seniority, subject to verification of other
consequential requirements under the applicable service rules. The respondent
authorities shall accordingly revise the seniority list of Inspectors (Civil Police),
Arunachal Pradesh Police, and extend all consequential service benefits, if any,
arising out of such refixation, including consideration of the petitioner’s position
vis-à-vis other similarly situated officers. The aforesaid exercise shall be
completed within a period of three months from the date of receipt of a certified
copy of this judgment.
Page No.# 19/19
50. The writ petition stands allowed and disposed of in terms above. There
shall be no order as to cost(s).
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review