The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
10. The expression Grama kantam is defined as a spot of ground in a village for building huts upon. It is not the case of the plaintiffs that the land is not a gramakantam land nor have they filed any documentary evidence that the plaint schedule property is private ancestral property. Except filing of Exs.A1 to A5 office copies of legal notices and acknowledgements, the plaintiffs did not file any oral or documentary evidence to prove that the plaint schedule property belonged to their ancestors. Plaintiffs have not discharged their burden to prove their case. The case of the appellants is that suit schedule property is an ancestral property. But the appellants have not adduced any evidence relating to that extent. Both the Courts have concurrently dismissed the suit filed for declaration of title and for recovery of possession. This Court does not find any substantial questions of law. Therefore, this Court has not seen any reason to interdict or intervene with the concurrent findings arrived by both the trial Court as well as Appellate Court.
11. Accordingly, the Second Appeal is dismissed. However, there shall be no order as to costs. As a sequel, interlocutory applications, if any, pending in this writ petition shall stand closed. Harin THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE TARLADA RAJASEKHAR RAO S.A.No. 219 OF 2026 Harin
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
APHC010699002025
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
[3330]
(Special Original Jurisdiction)
MONDAY, THE THIRTIETH DAY OF MARCH
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE TARLADA RAJASEKHAR RAO
SECOND APPEAL No. 219/2026
BETWEEN:
1. METLA VENKATA KAMESWARARAO, S/o. LATE POLARAO,
AGED 52 YEARS, DOOR NO. 44
44-37-2/A,
2/A, SRINIVASANAGAR,
AKKAYYAPALEM, VISAKHAPATNAM
VISAKHAPATNAM-16.
2. METLA VENKATA VARAHA NARASIMHA RAO, S/o. LATE
POLARAO, AGED 50 YEARS, LIG 356 H.B. COLONY,
SEETHASMMADHARA VISAKHAPATNAM.
3. METLA SATYA SAI BHASKARARAO, S/o. LATE POLA
POLARAO,
AGED 39 YRS, DOOR No. 44
44-37-2/A,
2/A, SRINIVASANAGAR,
AKKAYYAPALEM, VISAKHAPATNAM
VISAKHAPATNAM-16.
4. METLA ROSHAN KUMAR, S/
S/o.. LATE POLARAO, 43 YRS,
DOOR NO. 44-37
37-2/A, SRINIVASANAGAR, AKKAYYAPALEM,
KAYYAPALEM,
VISAKHAPATNAM
VISAKHAPATNAM-16.
5. METLA SURYA KANTHAM, W/
W/o.. LATE POLLARAO, 71 YRS,
(DIED)
DOOR
N
No.44-37-2/A,
2/A,
SRINIVASANAGAR,
AKKAYYAPALEM, VISAKHAPATNAM
VISAKHAPATNAM- 16.
6. CHIRUGUDU KALYANI, W/
W/o.. GOVINDARAO, AGED 48 YRS
NEAR SIVALAYAM,
SANTHAMAMIDI, KURMANNAPALEM,
VISAKHAPATNAM
...APPELLANT(S)
AND
1. BANDARU PRASAD, s/o. Late Suryanarayana, Hindu, aged 48
years. Street Hawker, residing at M.Venkatapuram village in
Gajapathinagaram mandal in Vizianagaram district.
...RESPONDENT
Appeal under Section 100 r/w Order XLII of CPC is filed to set
aside the decree and judgment dt. 29.04.2025 in Appeal Suit 45/2019
on the file of the Principal District Judge Court at Vizianagaram which
confirms the decree and judgment dt. 09.04.2019 in O.S. 51/2013 on
the file of the Senior Civil Judge Court at Vizianagaram and pass such
other order or orders.
Counsel for the Appellant(S):
1. VENKATA SAKETH ROY VYDYULA
The Court made the following:
JUDGMENT:
The appellants are plaintiffs in the suit and respondent is the defendent
in the suit. For the sake of convenience, in this judgment, the parties will be
referred to, as per their array in the suit. Plaintiffs filed suit for declaration of
title and recovery of possession of the suit schedule property i.e., hut on the
ground that the schedule property is ancestral property of Metla Polarao, on
his demise, the same was devolved upon the plaintiffs who are the class one
legal heirs of the deceased Metla Polarao, and it is the specific case of the
plaintiffs that one Tupakula Satya Rao who is the relative of the plaintiffs,
introduced the defendant as caste person and requested Metla Polarao, to
provide shelter to the defendant in the plaint schedule property for making a
hutment temporarily.
Accordingly, on the request and advice of Tupakula
Satya Rao, the defendant was permitted to lay a hutment on the condition
that he will be the custodian of the property of the plaintiffs, as they are not
dwelling in the village at M. Venkatapuram.
2.
The suit was filed, inter alia, when the defendant was asked to vacate
the premises by the father of the plaintiffs Nos. 1 to 4; instead, the defendant
started abusing the 5th plaintiff, who is the wife of Metla Polarao, and her
family members in filthy language and also tried to assault the said Polarao.
The plaintiffs got issued a legal notice dated 02.02.2011 to the defendant
calling upon the defendant to vacate the hut and deliver vacant possession of
the site to the plaintiffs. Under the above circumstances, the plaintiffs are
constrained to file the suit for declaration and for recovery of vacant
possession after evicting the defendant from the suit schedule property.
3.
The defendant filed the written statement and averred that he
purchased plaint scheduled property from Bandaru Ramamurthy, Bandaru
Pydithalli and others on 28.07.1967 and since then, he has been in
possession and enjoyment of the plaint schedule property. Due to an
enormous increase of land rates, the plaintiffs, with a view to grab the site,
asked the defendant to sell away the land for a paltry amount, for which the
defendant refused and the plaintiffs bore grouse and filed this suit. And the
property that was purchased by the defendant is Gramakantam land. And
further stated that the plaint schedule property is not ancestral property of the
plaintiffs, as they claim. Hence, he prayed to dismiss the suit as there are no
bonafides in the suit.
4.
Basing upon the rival contentions, the trial Court has framed the
following issue for trial.
“Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to decree of declaration and
consequential recovery of possession of the plaint schedule property
from the defendant?”
5.
The plaintiffs have examined PW1 to PW4 in respect of their case and
the Defendant he himself examined as DW1 and he also examined DW 2 and
3. The trial Court has dismissed the suit after considering the evidence of
PW2 and PW3 who stated that the defendant is in long possession of the suit
schedule property, in addition the trial court observed that the plaintiffs
haven’t filed any document to establish their right over the property and not
adduced any evidence or there’s no proof that the property is ancestral
property of Metla Polarao, or, his self acquired property, or, of any one of the
plaintiffs. Except issuing of legal notices, there is no other documentary
evidence to show that the plaintiffs acquired property from Metla Polarao by
rule of inheritance.
6.
Assailing the Judgment and Decree dated 09.04.2019 in O.S. No.51 of
2013 on the file of the Senior Civil Judge, Vizianagaram, the plaintiffs filed
regular appeal under Section 96 CPC on the file of the Principal District
Judge, Vizianagaram. The Principal District Judge has dismissed the appeal
inter alia observing that in a suit for declaration, the Plaintiff must show that
he is having uninterrupted or undisputed title over the plaint schedule
property; though, the Plaintiffs got examined P.Ws. 2 to 4 and all of them
stated in favour of the defendant; and the suggestion of the defendants that
the land is Gramakantam land, why the land is in the name of the defendant,
was not explained by the Plaintiffs; and reinstated the findings of the trial
Court and dismissed the appeal suit filed by the plaintiffs.
7.
Assailing the same, the present Second Appeal is filed under Section
100 CPC, on the following substantial question of law:
A. Whether the Courts below erred in law in dismissing the suit for
declaration by insisting upon strict documentary title, contrary to
the
settled
principles
applicable to
ancestral
and
village
properties?
B. Whether the Courts below misapplied the law relating to
permissive possession and burden of proof, by failing to examine
whether the Respondent discharged the onus of providing an
independent title?
C. Whether the Trial Court erred in law in dismissing the suit on
the ground that the Plaintiffs failed to prove title, when no specific
issue regarding proof of title was framed under Order XIV Rule 1
PC, and whether such omission vitiates the judgment as having
caused prejudice to the Plaintiffs?
D. Whether the concurrent findings suffer from perversity by
ignoring material evidence and admissions, giving rise to
substantial questions of law under Section 100 CPC.
8.
In a suit for declaration of title, the burden lies on the Plaintiffs and they
must establish that they are having title over the plaint schedule property,
however, the plaintiffs have not filed any document or any revenue record
(though revenue record does not confer title) to establish title . It’s the case of
the defendant that suit schedule property is Gramakantam and he has
purchased from vendor for valid sale consideration and the plaintiffs neither
rebutted the said pleading nor filed any document evidence that the property
is private ancestral property, to establish that the land is not a Gramakantam
Land, as pleaded by the defendant.
9.
The Apex Court in the case of the Union of India and others Vs.
Vasavi Co-operative Housing Society Limited and others1 held that “It is
trite law that, in a suit for declaration of title, the burden always lies on the
plaintiff to make out and establish a clear case for granting such a declaration
and the weakness, if any, of the case set up by the defendants would not be a
(2014) 2 SCC 269
ground to grant relief to the plaintiff.” The above said judgment was referred in
the case of Jagdish Prasad Patel (D) through Lrs., Vs Shivnath2.
10.
The expression Grama kantam is defined as a spot of ground in a
village for building huts upon. It is not the case of the plaintiffs that the land is
not a gramakantam land nor have they filed any documentary evidence that
the plaint schedule property is private ancestral property. Except filing of
Exs.A1 to A5 office copies of legal notices and acknowledgements, the
plaintiffs did not file any oral or documentary evidence to prove that the plaint
schedule property belonged to their ancestors. Plaintiffs have not discharged
their burden to prove their case. The case of the appellants is that suit
schedule property is an ancestral property.
But the appellants have not
adduced any evidence relating to that extent.
Both the Courts have
concurrently dismissed the suit filed for declaration of title and for recovery of
possession. This Court does not find any substantial questions of law.
Therefore, this Court has not seen any reason to interdict or intervene with
the concurrent findings arrived by both the trial Court as well as Appellate
Court.
11.
Accordingly, the Second Appeal is dismissed. However, there shall be
no order as to costs.
As a sequel, interlocutory applications, if any, pending in this writ
petition shall stand closed.
__________________________________
JUSTICE TARLADA RAJASEKHAR RAO
Date: 30.03.2026
Harin
(2019) 6 SCC 82
THE HON’BLE SRI JUSTICE TARLADA RAJASEKHAR RAO
S.A.No. 219 OF 2026
Date: 30-03-2026
Harin
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review