Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP (C) No.8/2021 with
MC (WPC) No.5/2021
Date of Order: 13.05.2024
Smti. Meralysha Byrsaw
..... Petitioner
Vs.
1. State of Meghalaya through the Commissioner and Secretary to the
Govt. of Meghalaya, Education Department, Shillong.
2. The Director of School Education and Literacy, Government of
Meghalaya, Shillong.
3. District School Education Officer, East Khasi Hills District, Shillong,
Meghalaya.
4. Sub-Divisional School Education Officer, East Khasi Hills District,
Meghalaya.
5. Managing Committee, Domksong L.P. School, Mawsynram, East
Khasi Hills District, Meghalaya represented by its Secretary.
..... Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice S. Vaidyanathan, Chief Justice
Appearance:
For the Petitioner
: Mr. P. Nongbri, Adv with
Mr. M.L. Nongpiur, Adv
For the Respondents
: Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Mr. H. Abraham, GA for R/1-4
Mr. S. Kumar, Adv for R/5
ORDER
The present writ petition has been filed, challenging the letter
dated 01.12.2020, and by which, the petitioner has been terminated from
the post of Assistant Teacher.
2. It is the case of the petitioner that she had completed
Bachelor of Arts, Diploma in Elementary Education and thereafter
Master of Arts in Sociology and also cleared the MTET. Pursuant to the
advertisement dated 23.09.2016 (Annexure-5), the petitioner applied for
the post of Assistant Teacher and came out successful in the written
examination as also in the interview. It is further case of the petitioner
that she was given appointment order, which was later approved vide
order dated 30.03.2017 by the respondent No.4. It is her grievance that
to her shock and surprise, she was terminated from service on
01.12.2020 and according to her, she had appointed against a sanctioned
post, which has been approved by the Government.
3. It is her stand that though the respondent No.5 is empowered
to take disciplinary action on the basis of a complaint received against
her, due process of law should be followed before disengaging the
services of the petitioner and she cannot be simply terminated from
service, thereby divesting of her duties on one fine morning.
4. She has referred to Section 9(2) of the Meghalaya School
Education Act, 1981 (in short „the Act, 1981‟) to state that no employee
of a school shall be dismissed, removed or reduced in rank except with
the prior approval of the competent authority.
5. Per contra, the main contention of the respondent No.5 is
that it is true that the petitioner was selected and appointed after
following due procedures. However, on account of complaints received
from the parents and others, the petitioner was disengaged from her
services. In terms of Section 9(4), more so, 2nd Proviso, the order of
termination will be in force for a period of thirty days and after the
expiry of thirty days, the petitioner is not entitled to any relief. It is
further contended by the learned counsel for the respondent No.5 that in
terms of Section 9(3) of the Act of 1981, the petitioner has got a right to
appeal before the Appellate Authority and bypassing the same, the
present writ petition has been filed and therefore the same is not
maintainable.
6. Learned counsel for R5 pointed out that during Covid-19,
the operation of the school has been suspended / closed and that there are
no teachers and the Managing Committee has also been dissolved. Of
course, though the Managing Committee has been subsequently revived,
pursuant to the orders of this Court, as on date, there are no teachers and
no students. When there are no students, appointing a teacher in the
school will not serve any purpose. He further pointed out that the post of
teacher is a transferable one and the Government can transfer the
petitioner to some other school.
7. Learned AAG appearing for the State submitted that he will
have to seek instructions with regard to the possibility of transfer of the
petitioner from one school to another. He further submitted that as there
is a misconduct alleged to have been committed by the petitioner, unless
a detailed inquiry is conducted, it may not be feasible for the
Government to effect transfer of petitioner to other school for the simple
reasons that the school, to which she is transferred, may be forced to face
problems. Moreover, the Government is not aware about the actual
reason for issuance of show cause notice by the Managing Committee
against the petitioner and her disengagement from service.
8. Heard all the respective parties.
9. Admittedly, the petitioner had acquired qualification in
Master of Arts (Sociology) and in addition to the above, had also passed
MTET. Consequent to her fulfillment of eligibility criteria, she had
applied for the post of Assistant Teacher in Domskong L.P. School and
having come out successful in the written examination and interview,
she was appointed as Assistant Teacher in the respondent-school and
thereafter due approval was also granted by the competent authority. It is
no doubt true that for the alleged misconduct, a show cause notice was
issued to the petitioner and the petitioner stated that she was not able to
give a reply. Even without a reply, it is mandate on the part of the
Managing Committee to hold an inquiry by appointing an Enquiry
Officer and in case the charges are proved, the Managing Committee
could have very well dismissed the petitioner from service.
10. The Act, 1981 is applicable to the teachers in terms of
Section 3 (xxiii). For the sake of convenience, the relevant provisions of
Sections 3(xxiii) and 9 of the Act of 1981, are reproduced below:
“3(xxiii) “Teachers” includes the Head of School.
9. Terms and conditions of service of employees of
recognised private schools.– (1) The State Government may
make rules regulating the minimum qualifications for
recruitment and the conditions of service of employees of
recognised schools:
Provided that neither the salary nor the service conditions of an
employee in the employment of an existing recognised school at
the commencement of this Act shall be varied to the
disadvantage of such employee.
(2) Subject to any rule that may be made in this behalf no
employee of a recognised private school shall be dismissed
removed or reduced in rank nor shall his service be otherwise
terminated except with the prior approval of the competent
authority.
(3) Any employee of a recognised private school who is
dismissed, removed or reduced in rank may, within three
months from the date of communication to him of the order of
such dismissal, removal or reduction in rank, appeal against
such order to the prescribed authority.
(4) Where the managing Committee of a recognised private
school intends to suspend any of its employees, such intention
shall be communicated to the competent authority and so such
suspension shall be made except with the prior approval of the
competent authority:
Provided that the managing committee may suspend an
employee with immediate effect and without the prior approval
of the competent authority if it is satisfied that such immediate
suspension is necessary by reason of gross misconduct, within
the meaning of the code of conduct prescribed under Section 10
of the Act;
Provided further that no such immediate suspension shall
remain in force for more than a period of thirty days from the
date of suspension unless it has been communicated to the
competent authority and approved by it before the expiry of the
said period.”
11. The plea taken by the 5th respondent that the termination
order will be valid for a period of thirty days and thereafter, the
petitioner has no locus to raise any issue cannot be accepted. A glance at
the Proviso to Section 9(4) would make it very clear that the suspension
shall remain in force for a period of thirty days, unless it is duly
communicated to the competent authority and approved by it before the
expiry of the said period and this provision will not be applicable to
suspension. There is a lot of difference between termination and
suspension. The relationship between the employee and employer will
exist till the period of suspension, whereas insofar as divesting of duties
is concerned, the employer-employee relationship will cease to exist.
That part, the contention that the dismissal order is valid for 30 days and
thereafter, it cannot be questioned, cannot be accepted.
12. The next plea raised by the learned counsel appearing for
the Managing Committee with reference to Section 9(3) of the Act of
1981, though appears to be sound at the first instance, after a period of
four years, asking the petitioner to file an appeal before the Appellate
Authority will not inure to the benefit of anyone, much less the
Managing Committee. The reason being that the Appellate Authority
will have to remand the matter to the Disciplinary Authority to conduct
an inquiry, as there are no materials available to ascertain as to whether
the charges are proved or not.
13. It is pertinent to mention here that a detailed enquiry should
be conducted to find out the genesis of the charges levelled against the
petitioner, without which, relegating the matter before the Appellate
Authority is merely a stone dropped in the well, as the Appellate
Authority cannot take any decision without any basic material. Hence,
this Court is of the view that the matter needs to remitted back to the
Managing Committee to follow the procedures adumbrated in the Act of
1981.
14. At this juncture, it is brought to the attention of this Court
that there was an interim order passed as early as on 18.01.2021,
pursuant to which the salary had been paid to the petitioner till
November, 2023 and thereafter, in view of the abolition of the old
Managing Committee, the payment of salary has been stopped.
15. On a reading of the order dated 18.01.2021, it is obvious
that the interim order had not been restricted for a particular period or till
the Managing Committee is dissolved. Till completion of inquiry by
following due process of law and imposition of punishment (in case the
charges are held to be proved), the Managing Committee shall have to
pay the salary to the petitioner.
16. In the result, WP (C) No.8 of 2021 and MC (WPC) No.5 of
2021 are disposed of. The order of termination dated 01.12.2020 is set
aside and the matter is remitted to the Managing Committee to conduct a
detailed inquiry. It is needless to state here that in case the charges are
proved, it is open to the Managing Committee to impose appropriate
punishment. This Court expects the petitioner to cooperate with the
inquiry and the inquiry shall be conducted on a day-to- day basis without
adjourning the same beyond five working days at any point of time and
the inquiry shall be completed within a period of three months from the
date of receipt of this order.
17. At this point of time, learned counsel for the petitioner has
stated that the petitioner had already given a representation dated
21.09.2022 for transferring her from one school to another and that the
said representation may be considered by the Government. It is made
clear that the order of this Court will not preclude either the Managing
Committee or the competent authority to decide in respect of transfer of
the petitioner, as requested by her, as, at this distance of time, it is highly
doubtful as to whether the parents and others, who had given the
complaint against the petitioner will come forward to tender evidence
against her by spending their valuable time for the purpose of
establishing the charges in the inquiry. It is further made clear that in
case the Government is willing to induct the petitioner, she has to give
up her back wages from December, 2023 till June, 2024. No costs.
(S.Vaidyanathan)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
13.05.2024
“Lam DR-PS”
W.P.(C) No.8/2021
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review