Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM : GANGTOK
(Civil Extraordinary Jurisdiction)
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai,
Aged about 49 years,
W/o Shri Mani Kumar Bhattarai,
R/o: Luing Busty,
P.O. Luing & P.S. Sadar Thana,
East Sikkim.
…
Petitioners
…
Respondents
Versus
1.
State of Sikkim,
Represented by and through
Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Tashiling, Gangtok.
2.
Tourism and Civil Aviation Department
Represented by and through the Secretary,
Tourism & Civil Aviation Department,
Government of Sikkim,
Tadong, Gangtok.
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ARUP KUMAR GOSWAMI, CJ.
For the Petitioners
:
Mr. J.B. Pradhan, Sr. Advocate with Mr. D.K.
Siwakoti, Advocate.
For the Respondent
Nos. 1 & 2
:
Dr. Doma T. Bhutia, Additional Advocate General,
Sikkim
Dates of hearing
:
22.11.2019 & 30.11.2019
Date of judgment
:
14.12.2019
JUDGMENT
Heard Mr. J.B. Pradhan, learned Senior Counsel as well as Mr. D.K.
Siwakoti, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Dr. Doma T. Bhutia,
learned Additional Advocate General, Sikkim for the respondents.
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
2.
The case of the petitioner, as presented in the writ petition, is that in
the year 2004, respondent no. 2, i.e., Tourism and Civil Aviation Department
purchased a plot of land belonging to the father-in-law and husband of the
petitioner as well as a few others for the purpose of construction of
Banjhakri Falls Energy Park, hereinafter referred to as the Park. A Notice
Inviting Tender (for short, „NIT‟) was issued on 14.06.2016, inviting sealed
tenders for taking the Park on lease. Tenders were opened on 09.07.2016
and bid of the petitioner having been found to be the highest, a lease
agreement was entered into on 01.09.2016 and the Park was handed over to
the petitioner. It is stated that the petitioner was not given any opportunity
to examine the document or to consult any other person and besides, the
petitioner having studied only up to Class VIII in a Nepali School, she had to
sign and execute the deed without understanding the terms and conditions
of the lease deed. In terms of Clause 3.2 of the agreement she had paid
advance rent for three months amounting to Rs.51,00,000.00 (Rupees Fiftyone Lakhs) and she had also deposited a sum of Rs.20,00,000.00 (Rupees
Twenty Lakhs) as interest free refundable security deposit. As the Park did
not have proper infrastructure like swimming pool, adventure sports,
restaurant, etc., the petitioner apprised the officers of respondent no.2 to
create such infrastructure indicating that if such infrastructure is not
provided, it would be difficult for her to raise revenue to pay the lease
amount. Respondent no.2 informed her that for construction of additional
facilities and infrastructure a Memorandum of Understanding, for short,
„MoU‟, has to be entered into and accordingly, an MoU was prepared by
respondent no.2. The said MoU was executed on 12.11.2016 and an order
dated 12.11.2016 was issued granting permission to the petitioner for
construction
of
infrastructure
as
indicated
therein,
besides
permission for revenue collection from the shops within the Park.
granting
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
3.
It is pleaded by the petitioner that she informed the authorities that
when the lease period was only for five years it would not be possible for her
to make investment for establishment of such infrastructure which may run
into a few crores of rupees and in response, the petitioner was given to
understand that in view of a Circular dated 25.02.2013, her lease period will
be extended to 20 years from 5 years. Relying on the said assurance as well
as on the assurance that she would be compensated at a reasonable market
rate for investment made for creation of permanent immovable assets, she
started to make investments for creating additional infrastructure and she
completed the construction of swimming pool, fish pond, traditional food
court and eco hut at a cost of about rupees three crores. In addition, some
construction for adventure sports was still continuing. It is further pleaded
that there was an indefinite shut-down including many cases of arson from
the month of June, 2017 in view of protests raised by Gorkha Janmukti
Morcha in the wake of Government of West Bengal declaring that „Bengali‟
subject would be a compulsory subject from Class I to X in the entire State
of West Bengal including in the hill district of Darjeeling. Such violent
protests disrupted vehicular movement in the National Highway connecting
Sikkim and during the “bandh” period, which was called off on 27.09.2017,
spanning about 100 days, not even a single tourist visited the Park. In view
of the aforesaid circumstances, the petitioner submitted a representation on
28.11.2017 to the Chief Minister, which was endorsed by the Member of
Legislative Assembly (MLA) of the constituency. However, instead of fulfilling
the given assurances, a termination order dated 22.07.2019 came to be
issued terminating the lease of the Park. It is pleaded that the petitioner did
not receive any letter/order other than the termination order and that the
petitioner was neither heard personally nor granted an opportunity to justify
her case before issuing the termination order, which was issued only to
bestow undue favour to a blue-eyed person. It is pleaded that Clause 6.24 of
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
the lease deed and Clauses 4 and 5 of the MoU are arbitrary, unjust and
unconscionable. The petitioner had submitted a notice through her advocate
but the same having failed to evoke any response, the writ petition was
filed.
4.
In the counter affidavit filed on behalf of the respondents, it is stated
that the petitioner was declared successful as she was the highest bidder
amongst seven tenderers and she had executed the lease deed voluntarily
without there being any coercion or deception. The petitioner being a
politically influential person, she had submitted a representation to the
Minister, Tourism and Civil Aviation, Government of Sikkim for allotment of
shops and permission for construction of various infrastructures which was
forwarded for consideration of respondent no.2 and, accordingly, in terms of
Clause 5.4 of the lease deed, a MoU dated 12.11.2016 was executed after
the terms of the same were explained in Nepali language to the petitioner.
In the said MoU, it was made clear that the construction or renovation of
additional infrastructure as indicated therein would have to be made at her
own expense for which no claim for compensation at the time of
surrendering
possession
after
expiry
of
the
lease
period
would
be
entertained, though moveable assets belonging to the petitioner in the
nature of removable fittings, fixtures, furniture and other moveable
installations as laid down in the agreement would be allowed to be removed
and taken away. It is stated that request made by the petitioner vide letter
dated 14.06.2017 for relaxation of payment of quarterly rent in respect of
the Park was declined by a letter dated 26.07.2017 and by the said letter,
the petitioner was also asked to pay due rent as stipulated in the lease deed.
A number of reminders were issued asking the petitioner to pay due rent but
the petitioner did not pay any heed and did not pay rent causing huge loss
to the respondents and resulting in difficulty in making payment of salaries
to the staff engaged in the Park. A letter dated 27.06.2019 was issued
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
asking the petitioner to deposit arrear rent amounting to Rs.4,25,00,000.00
with effect from May, 2017 to May, 2019 within 7 days from the date of
receipt of the letter failing which it was indicated that legal action would be
initiated as per the lease deed. Even thereafter, the petitioner did not pay
any rent as a result of which the notice of termination dated 22.07.2019 was
issued.
5.
It is stated in the affidavit that land of the Park was not acquired by
respondent
no.2
but
by
the
Rural
Management
and
Development
Department and the same was handed over to respondent no.2 on
29.08.2011. The allegation of not having proper infrastructure is denied and
it is stated that the infrastructure such as swimming pool, adventures sports,
fish pond and restaurant were already in existence but they needed
additional repair works, improvements, alterations, modifications, etc.
Statements made by the petitioner that assurances were given by the
authorities that compensation would be paid for the investment made and
lease period would be extended are denied. It is also stated that the Park is
the main tourist spot and being close to Gangtok, a large number of tourists
visit the Park throughout the year and the petitioner had earned huge
income running the Park but despite opportunities being granted, the
petitioner failed to pay outstanding arrears of rent. It is stated that once the
possession is taken back of the leased out property, fresh tender notice will
be issued. It is denied that the terms of the lease agreement and MoU are
unconscionable as pleaded by the petitioner.
6.
A reply affidavit is filed by the petitioner reiterating the assertions
made in the writ petition but conceding that the land in question was
acquired by the Rural Management and Development Department.
7.
Mr. J.B. Pradhan, learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner submits
that the petitioner is not a businesswoman in the real sense of the term and
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
she and her husband were farmers before venturing into the present
contract. She is barely illiterate having read up to Class VIII and she was not
even granted an opportunity to consult any person before executing the
lease deed. It is contended by him that the petitioner does not raise any
issue relating to breach of contract or interpretation of terms of the contract
for the purpose of determining the rights and liabilities of the petitioner
under the lease deed. He, however, submits that Clause 6.24 of the lease
deed and Clauses 4 and 5 of the MoU are unjust and unconscionable and,
therefore, same are not enforceable in law. It is contended that the
petitioner made investment for creation of permanent immovable assets
only on the assurance that the lease term would be extended to 20 years in
terms of Government Circular dated 25.02.2013 and that she would be
compensated at a reasonable market rate for the investment made.
However, assurances were not fulfilled leaving the petitioner high and dry.
He strenuously argued that in the circumstances of the case where the
petitioner had made huge investments, the petitioner was entitled to a show
cause notice as well as an opportunity of personal hearing and the same
having not been granted the impugned termination order cannot withstand
the scrutiny in law. According to him, apart from the fact that the impugned
order had been passed in violation of principles of natural justice, action of
the state is also in violation of Articles 14, 19(1)(g), 21 and 300-A of the
Constitution of India. In support of his submissions, learned Senior Counsel
relies on the judgments in the cases of Union of India and Anr. Vs.
Tulsiram Patel, reported in (1985) 3 SCC 398, Express Newspapers
Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. Vs. Union of India & Ors., reported in (1986) 1 SCC
133, Central Inland Water Transport Corporation Limited and Anr.
Vs. Brojo Nath Ganguly & Anr., reported in (1986) 3 SCC 156, State of
U.P and Ors. Vs. Maharaja Dharmander Prasad Singh & Ors., reported
in (1989) 2 SCC 505, Kumari Shrilekha Vidyarthi & Ors. Vs. State of
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
U.P & Ors., reported in (1991) 1 SCC 212, Janab Salehbhai Saheb
Safiyuddin Vs. The Municipal Corporation of Greater Bombay And
Ors., reported in (1993) SCC OnLine Bom 74, Canara Bank & Ors. Vs.
Debasis Das & Ors., reported in (2003) 4 SCC 557, Joshi Technologies
International Inc. Vs. Union of India & Ors., reported in (2015) 7 SCC
728 and Indian Oil Corporation Limited Vs. Nilofer Siddiqui & Ors.,
reported in (2015) 16 SCC 125.
8.
Dr. Bhutia, learned Additional Advocate General, submits that
petitioner was also the earlier lessee of the Park and therefore, the
submission of Mr. Pradhan that the petitioner is a lay person in the business
arena is not correct. Being fully aware, she had executed the lease deed and
had also initially followed the terms and conditions of the lease deed. It was
only at the instance of the petitioner that permission for repair, addition,
etc., of permanent structures was allowed and in that regard an MoU was
entered into between the parties. It is not correct that the petitioner had
made new constructions and had created assets but she had only made
improvements and undertaken repair works in already existing assets. The
petitioner had undertaken such work as an experienced businesswoman in
order to generate more revenue and the plea that she had incurred huge
investments in this regard only on the assurance that lease would be
extended for a period of 20 years and that reasonable compensation at
market rate shall be paid is wholly without any basis. The request made by
the petitioner for reduction of rent was also not permissible and therefore,
the same was also rejected. Yet, the petitioner, while continuing to run the
business of the Park and earning handsome revenue, had not paid rent from
May 2017 till date, which is more than two and a half years and therefore,
on the face of it, the petitioner is not entitled to any discretionary relief in
the equitable jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. The
petitioner is bound by the terms and conditions incorporated in the lease
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
deed and the MoU and the submission that Clause 6.24 of the lease deed
and Clauses 4 and 5 of the MoU are unconscionable and unjust has no merit.
In a case of the present nature, the principles of natural justice is not
attracted and when the termination order was issued on the basis of the
lease deed, no interference with the order of termination order dated
22.07.2019 is called for in this writ petition. In support of her submissions,
learned counsel places reliance on the judgments in the cases of M/s
Radhakrishna Agarwal & Ors. Vs. State of Bihar & Ors., reported in
(1977) 3 SCC 457, Bareilly Development Authority & Anr. Vs. Ajai Pal
Singh & Ors., reported in (1989) 2 SCC 116, State of Gujarat & Ors.
Vs. Meghji Pethraj Shah Charitable Trust & Ors., reported in (1994) 3
SCC 552, State of Orissa & Ors. vs. Narain Prasad & Ors., reported in
(1996) 5 SCC 740, State of M.P & Ors. Vs. M.V Vyavsaya & Co.,
reported in (1997) 1 SCC 156, and State of Bihar & Ors. Vs. Jain
Plastics and Chemicals Ltd., reported in (2002) 1 SCC 216.
9.
I have considered the submissions of the learned counsel appearing
for the parties and have perused the materials on record.
10.
A perusal of the NIT dated 14.06.2016 goes to show that the
tenders were invited for taking the Park on lease on “As is where is basis”.
The terms and conditions of the NIT, amongst others, lay down that the
lease deed shall be valid for a period of 5 years which is extendable by
another 5 years based on the performance of the lease holder and timely
payment of lease rental. The entry fees to the Park for the visitors as well as
vehicles are indicated. It is also indicated that the successful bidder shall not
be permitted to construct any commercial or recreational assets within the
premises during the period of lease and all existing shops and commercial
units shall not be covered in the lease deed of the successful bidder.
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
11.
The petitioner was the highest tenderer with bid amount of
Rs.2,04,00,000/- (Rupees two crores four lakhs) only per annum. The lease
deed dated 01.09.2016 reflects that the lease commenced from 01.09.2016
and that the same shall remain in force for a period of 5 years i.e. till
31.08.2021. Clause 4.1 prescribes quarterly payment of rent for the first
three years of the lease at the rate of Rs.51,00,000/- per quarter and for the
last two years at the rate of Rs.53,55,000/-. Four quarters are divided from
1st September to 30th November, 1st December to 28th February, 1st March
to 31st May and 1st June to 31st August. The rent is payable on 10th of next
month of each quarter i.e. 10th December, 10th March, 10th June and 10th
September.
12.
It is considered appropriate to reproduce Clauses 5.2, 5.3, 5.4, 6.5,
6.12, 6.16, 6.24, 6.32, 9.1, 10 and 13.1 of the lease deed herein below as
under:
“5.2. The Lessee shall have the right to renovate and reorganize
the “BANJHAKRI FALLS ENERGY PARK” at his own cost and
expenses, so as to run the said premises in the best
possible manner, however, prior permission has to been
obtained
by
the
Lessee
from
the
Lessor
for
such
renovation and reorganization.
5.3
The Lessee shall have the right to bring in any new/
additional moveable assets and or to replace any such
moveable assets in the said leasehold premises at his own
costs, and such assets shall at all times be the properties
and belong to the Lessee and she shall have the right to
deal with the same in any manner. On the expiry of the
lease period or earlier determination thereof, the Lessee
shall have the right to take away such moveable assets.
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
5.4
In case, the Lessee makes any improvements, additions,
alterations in the leasehold premises, summing up to a
valuation of Rs.5 lakhs and below per year, all such
improvements, additions, alterations shall always be the
absolute properties of the Lessor and the Lessee shall not
be entitled to claim any cost or expenses for such
improvements, additions, alterations, relocations nor shall
the Lessee claim any return in the yearly rentals payable
or the interest free refundable security deposit. For any
improvements, additions, alterations above the sum of
Rs.5 lakhs per year the lessee shall take prior permission
and approval in writing of the lessor before undertaking
the works, for which a separate agreement shall be drawn
on the modalities of payment and execution of works.
x
6.5
x
x
The Lessee shall not erect, built or permit to be erected to
built any permanent structure in the premises “BANJHAKRI
FALLS ENERGY PARK”, situated at Lower Sichey, East
Sikkim nor make any addition or alteration thereto save
and except with the permission and approval in writing
from the Lessor. Excluding repair/s and renovation/s to the
existing structure, the costs of which shall be responsibility
of the Lessee, all civil works involving alteration/s to the
existing structures, must have the prior written approval
and consent of the Lessor.
x
x
x
6.12 The lessee shall not collect rent from the existing shops of
commercial unit as the same is not covered in the lease
deed. The rent so collected shall be deposited to the
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
Department under the revenue head 1452/TD 105/- Rent
& Catering.
x
x
x
6.16 The lessee shall fix the tariff as per the rates prescribed in
the tender documents which are as follows:
(Sl. No. 3.9) The entry fee of Asset chargeable to visitors
of the asset shall be as follows:
Sl.
No.
ENTRY FEE
Amount in INR
Single Adult
Group of 10
Group of 20
Group of 20 or more
Students with ID
Children below 4 years
Rs.40
Rs.300
Rs.600
Multiple of Sl no 3
Rs.10
Exempted
PARKING FEE
Two Wheeler/small vehicle
Medium Vehicle (Passenger)
Large Vehicle
Night Parking charges for all
types of vehicles
Amount in INR
Rs.10 for 3 hours
Rs.20 for 3 hours
Rs.40 for 3 hours
Rs.50 per night
(The lessee shall have to provide for automation and
dispensation of ticket through a ticketing machine only and
ensure CCTV surveillance at the entrance and main
locations of the complex and the footage shall be produced
to the Government of Sikkim as and when asked for).
x
x
x
6.24 The Lessee shall not claim any title to the superstructure
already put up or claim any compensation at the time of
surrendering possession after the expiration of the Lease
period.
x
x
x
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
6.32 That in the event of failure of the Lessee to vacate the said
leasehold premises and hand over the possession thereof
to
the
Lessor
determination
upon
expiry
of
the
thereof,
the
Lessee
lease
shall
or
earlier
pay
mesne
profit/compensation to the Lessor as per the prevailing
market rate at the point of time.
Till the Lessee hands
over possession of the leasehold premises to the Lessor,
notwithstanding
the
right
of
the
Lessor
to
recover
possession of the said premises through due process of law
at the cost of the Lessee, deductible from the interest free
refundable security deposit, and the payment of such
mesne profit/compensation will not in any way dilute the
Lessor‟s right to recover possession of the same.
x
9.1
x
x
That in the event of the quarterly rent remaining arrears
for one month after the due date or that there has been a
breach of any of the covenants herein contained or that if
there has been violation of any of the terms of this lease
deed by the Lessee, the Lessor by giving one month‟s
notice in writing to the Lessee may cancel the lease deed
and
re-enter
the
demised
premises/property
i.e.
“BANJHAKRI FALLS ENERGY PARK”, situated at Lower
Sichey, East Sikkim.
10.
TERMINATION
10.1 In the event of the Lessee committing breach of this Lease
Deed Agreement, the Lessor shall have the right in case of
default/delay or of breach of any of the terms, conditions
and stipulations of this Lease to impose and levy the
penalties in accordance with the terms contained herein or
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
to terminate this Lease Deed Agreement within two weeks
from the date of giving such notice of such breach in
writing by the Lessor to the Lessee and the Lessee does
not make good the breach complained of.
x
13.
x
x
Waiver
13.1 No waiver of any default of Lessor or Lessee hereunder
shall be implied from any omission to take any action on
account of such default if such default persists or is
repeated, and no express waiver shall affect any default
other than the default specified in the express waiver and
that only for the time and to the extent therein stated.”
13.
The last page of the lease deed is not annexed with the writ petition.
However, the same was produced before this Court by Dr. Bhutia.
14.
Though NIT was issued on “As is where is basis”, barely after one
month from the date of taking possession, on 03.10.2016, the petitioner
made a request to the Minister, Tourism and Civil Aviation for permitting her
to collect revenue from the shops of the Park as was allowed in the previous
term, so as to enable her to make payment of rent to the Department.
Though contention was advanced by Mr. Pradhan that the petitioner was
new in business, such a claim is, ex facie, not correct as demonstrated by
petitioner‟s own assertion that she be allowed to collect revenue from the
shops of the Park as was allowed in the previous term. The petitioner also
wanted to undertake construction of swimming pool with restaurant and bar,
eco huts, rock climbing and traversing and Brahma Bridge, musical hall
(traditional song & music), traditional dress & photography stalls, traditional
food court, kids playing kingdom, fishing pond, etc. Though not stated so in
the letter dated 03.10.2016, the petitioner in the writ petition had made a
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
categorical statement that unless the facilities and infrastructure as indicated
by her were not provided or created it would be difficult for her to pay the
lease amount. A request was also made to approve the rates of entry and
parking fees as indicated in the said letter. The petitioner being the previous
lessee, it is reasonable to hold that the petitioner was aware of the potential
of the Park and accordingly, had submitted her tender and therefore, the
stand taken by the petitioner barely one month after the lease period had
commenced raises many questions.
15.
Pursuant to the above request made by the petitioner, having regard
to Clauses 5.2, 5.4 and 6.5, MoU dated 12.11.2016 was executed on
12.11.2016. Clauses 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 and 7 are relevant for the purpose of the
case and as such the same are quoted herein below:
“2.
That the First Party has granted the allotment and revenue
collection of shops to the Second Party.
3.
That the First Party has granted permission to the Second
Party
for
construction/renovation/addition
of
various
infrastructures at the premises of Banjhakri Falls Energy
Park as per clause (6.5) of the Lease Deed Agreement
dated 01.09.2016 which is as under:-
4.
1.
Swimming Pool with Restaurant Bar.
2.
Eco Huts.
3.
Rock Climbing & Traversing, Brahma Bridge.
4.
Musical Hall (traditional song & music).
5.
Traditional dress and Photography.
6.
Traditional Food court.
7.
Kids playing kingdom.
8.
Fishing pond.
That the Second Party shall undertake the construction/
renovation/addition of the following infrastructures at her
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
own expense within the premises of Banjhakri Falls Energy
Park.
5.
That the Second Party shall not claim any right, title or
interest in the leasehold property (said premises) and shall
not
claim
any
compensation
renovation/addition
of
various
for
the
construction/
infrastructures
at
the
premises of Banjhakri Falls Energy Park as mentioned in
clause-2
of
this
MOU
at
the
time
of
surrendering
possession after the expiry of the lease period/term.
6.
That the Second Party shall collect/charge the rates of
Entry and Parking Fees till the expiry of lease period as
under:
1.
Entry fee-Rs.50 per head.
2.
Parking fees – Small vehicle Rs.20/- per vehicle.
3.
Medium vehicle- Rs.30/- per vehicle.
4.
Larger vehicle – Rs.40/- per vehicle.
5.
Two wheeler-Rs.10/
6.
Entry for students with School Uniform and ID card
Rs.10/- per head.
7.
Camera charge Rs.10/-
8.
For shooting extra charge as per the duration.
9.
Installation of Transformer for smooth supply of
electricity.
10.
7.
Water supply.
That after the expiry of the Lease Period, the Second Party
may be allowed to remove and take away all other
moveable assets belonging to her in the nature of
removable fittings, fixtures, furniture and other moveable
installations as laid down in the Lease Deed Agreement.‟‟
16.
A perusal of the MoU would go to show that despite a clear
stipulation in the terms and conditions of the NIT that all existing shops and
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
commercial units shall not be covered in the lease deed and despite rates of
entry fees, etc. being fixed, the revenue collection from the shops was
allowed in favour of the petitioner, besides increasing the entry and parking
fee in respect of some categories such as single adult, small vehicle, medium
vehicle, etc.
17.
Though pleas are taken in the writ petition that petitioner was
unaware of the contents of the lease deed, it is to be remembered, as is
evident from the letter dated 03.10.2016, the petitioner was also the lessee
in the previous term. Contents of the letter dated 03.10.2016 also belies the
contention of the petitioner that she was unaware of the terms and
conditions of the lease. It cannot be countenanced that the petitioner was
not aware of the requirement of payment of lease rent in terms of lease
deed inasmuch as the petitioner had paid an amount of Rs.51.00 lakhs as
advance rent for one quarter. Even otherwise, such a contention cannot be
accepted in a writ proceeding in respect of a commercial contract entered
into by the petitioner with the State, the same being a disputed question of
fact.
18.
to
Contention is advanced by the petitioner that an assurance was given
her
that
investment
made
by
her
towards
making
permanent
constructions would be compensated and that the lease deed would be
extended to 20 years on the basis of the Circular dated 25.02.2013. It is to
be noted that NIT was issued on 14.06.2016 inviting tenders for grant of
lease for five years, despite the aforesaid Circular holding the field. The
Circular reads as follows:
“CIRCULAR
Whereas, the Department has notified that the properties
valued at an annual basic price of Rs.10.00 lakhs and above are
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
unable to be leased out due to short lease term and publicity of
the newly created properties.
Now in order to overcome this, the Government has been
pleased to fix the lease term as under:
Valuation of Property
Lease term
1.
Upto 30.00 lakhs
5 years
„D‟
2.
From Rs.30 lakhs to
10 years
„C‟
Rs.90 lakhs
15 years
„B‟
Above Rs. 1 crore
20 years
„A‟
Rs.60 lakhs
3.
4.
Category
From Rs.60 lakhs to
The above is in partial supersession of circular No. 10(351)08/TD
dated 17.01.2009.”
19.
Perusal of the Circular goes to show that the properties valued at an
annual basic price of Rs.10.00 lakhs and above was difficult to be leased out
due to short term of lease and lack of publicity of the newly created
properties. Valuation of property up to Rs.30.00 lakhs is placed at category
„D‟ and lease term is fixed at 5 years. The NIT goes to show that offered
lease rent per annum, which is to be taken as the annual basic price, is
Rs.24,70,000/- in respect of the Park. It is the considered opinion of the
Court that annual basic price being less than Rs.30.00 lakhs, the lease term
conforms to the Circular dated 25.02.2013.
20.
The assertion of the petitioner is that the petitioner was given to
understand that lease rent would be lowered in view of her request made in
the letter/representation to the Chief Minister praying for reduction of lease
rent at the rate of “Rs.1.20 lakhs”. The letter is undated but there is an
endorsement of the Chief Minister dated 28.11.2017 to consider the request
as per norms. It is to be noted that the Department had already rejected the
prayer for relaxation of payment of rent by letter dated 26.07.2017 in
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
response to the letter of the petitioner dated 14.06.2017, about which the
petitioner made no mention in the writ petition. The petitioner submits that
she had not received the aforesaid letter dated 26.07.2017. It will be
unrealistic to proceed on the assumption that the petitioner never enquired
about the outcome of the request for relaxation of payment of rent even if it
is assumed that the petitioner had not received the letter dated 26.07.2017.
It was the responsibility of the petitioner to make payment of rent in terms
of lease deed.
21.
The Park was handed over to the Tourism Department by the Rural
Management and Development Department on 29.03.2011 and a perusal of
the document evidencing handing and taking over goes to show that the
cost of the project of the Park in 3 phases amounted to Rs.3.82 crores. On
the date of such handing over, the petitioner was the lessee and 29 assets, a
list of which was enclosed, were already created. A list of renewable energy
exhibits mentioning 36 items is also enclosed.
22.
In the letter dated 14.06.2017 and the representation to the Chief
Minister, the petitioner had not indicated that any assurance was given by
any
authority
that
for
the
improvement
or
for
new
construction,
compensation would be paid to her. Even the assurance stated to have been
given as indicated in paragraph 24 of the writ petition was not specific : the
investment could be adjusted against the rent or compensation may be paid
at the time of determination of the lease after verification and Government
approval. Except for self-serving statements of the petitioner, there is no
material on record to suggest even remotely that any such assurance was
given. There is no document on record evidencing any assurance being given
by the authorities that the lease term would be extended to 20 years. There
was no compulsion for the petitioner to have undertaken such constructions.
It was on the own volition of the petitioner that such construction works
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
were taken up on her own initiative and therefore, it must be understood
that the plea of assurance given by the authorities for payment of
compensation as canvassed by the petitioner is a hollow claim with no
foundation, either in law or in equity, and a ruse contrived for the purpose of
the case. Therefore, not to pay rent in terms of the lease deed on the plea
that a request was pending or an assurance was given cannot be accepted in
a matter of the present nature.
23.
In Central Inland Water Transport Corporation Ltd. (supra), the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court had held that right to terminate the employment of a
permanent employee by giving him three months‟ notice, or pay in lieu of
the notice as contained in the Service Rules, is unconscionable, unfair,
unreasonable and opposed to public policy and void under Section 23 of the
Contract Act, 1872. It was held that the Rules formed part of the contract
between the corporation and its employees, but the employees had no voice
in the framing of the Rules and they had to accept the Rules as part of their
contractual employment. It had been entered into between the parties
between whom there is gross inequality of bargaining power. The Supreme
Court further held that such a contract of employment between a powerful
employer and a weak employee cannot be equated with a mercantile
transaction between two businessmen.
24.
In Kumari Shrilekha Vidyarthi (supra), the Government of State of
Uttar Pradesh had terminated by a general order the appointments of all
Government Counsel by resorting to the spoils system and directed
preparation of fresh panels to make appointment in place of the existing
incumbents. The question that had fallen for consideration before the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court was as to whether the impugned circular was
amenable to judicial review and, if so, whether it was liable to be quashed as
violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India. In the aforesaid context,
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
the Hon‟ble Supreme Court held that the requirement of Article 14 should
extend even in the sphere of contractual matter for regulating the conduct of
the state activity, as Article 14 casts a duty on the state to act fairly, justly
and reasonably. It was held that every state action, in order to survive, must
not be susceptible to the vice of arbitrariness which is the crux of Article 14
of the Constitution and basic to the rule of law. The Hon‟ble Supreme Court
further held that bringing the state activity in contractual matters also within
the purview of judicial review is inevitable and it was found that arbitrariness
was writ large in the impugned circular.
25.
In Nilofer Siddiqui (Supra), the respondents 2 and 3 before the
Supreme Court started their business without standard agreement being
signed by both of them and therefore, the said standard agreement in
question was held to be not a completed contract between the parties in law
and thus, it was held that the same cannot be made binding upon the
allottees of distributorship of Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. (IOCL). Condition
No.8 of the letter of allotment was held to be unconscionable as it gave IOCL
an unfettered right to terminate the distributorship without assigning any
reason and it was also noted that the respondent 2 was far weaker in
economic strength and had no bargaining power with the IOCL. In the
aforesaid context, Condition No.8 of the letter of allotment providing for
unilateral termination of distributorship without assigning any reason was
read down in the light of Article 14 of the Constitution of India as well as
observations of the Supreme Court in Central Inland Water Transport
Corpn. Ltd. (supra), as made in paragraph 89, essentially mandating that
the Courts will not enforce and will, when called upon to do so, strike down
an unfair and unreasonable contract, or an unfair and unreasonable clause in
a contract entered into between parties who are not equal in bargaining
power.
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
26.
Though Mr. J.B. Pradhan had contended that Clause 6.24 and Clauses
4 and 5 of the MoU are unconscionable, such argument does not have any
merit. Clause 6.24 of the lease deed provides that the lessee shall not claim
any title to the superstructures already put up or claim any compensation at
the time of surrendering possession after expiration of the lease period. It is
not understood how any title can be claimed by a lessee in respect of
superstructures already put up by the lessor or a claim can be put up for
compensation within the ambit of Clause 6.24. Clause 5.2 provides that the
lessee shall have the right to renovate and reorganize the Park at her own
cost and expenses by taking prior permission so as to run the premises in
the best possible manner. Clause 5.4 of the lease deed seems to suggest
that improvements, additions, alterations in the leasehold premises up to
Rs.5.00 lakhs would not require any prior permission. However, for any
improvement above Rs.5.00 lakhs per year prior permission and approval in
writing shall be taken and for the said purpose a separate agreement shall
be drawn on the modalities of payment and execution of works. Clause 6.5
also prohibited erection, addition, alteration, or building of any permanent
structure without permission and approval in writing from the lessor. It also
laid down that cost of repair/renovation shall be borne by the lessee. The
modality of payment and execution of works as indicated in Clause 5.4 are
embodied in the MoU in Clauses 4 and 5. Clause 4 of MoU provides that the
petitioner shall undertake construction/ renovation/addition of the following
infrastructures at her own expense. The word “following” at Clause 4 is not
the appropriate word and it must be understood that infrastructure
mentioned at Clause 3 was referred to. Clause 5 of the MoU provides that
the petitioner shall not claim any title or interest on the leasehold property
and shall not claim any compensation for the construction/renovation/
addition of various infrastructures as mentioned in Clause 2 (This is also
wrong. It should have been Clause 3) at the time of surrendering possession
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
after the expiry of lease period. Though Clause 2 is wrongly referred, intent
is explicit that it referred to the infrastructure for which permission was
accorded. It is to be remembered that it was the petitioner, being the
previous lessee and having responded to the NIT issued on “As is where is
basis”, had raised issues within a month of taking the lease that unless
certain infrastructures are created as indicated by her, she will not be able to
pay rent. That begs the question as to why in that circumstance the
petitioner had quoted the rate as she did. Respondents had not asked the
petitioner to make any constructions or improvements and it was at the
instance of the petitioner that the respondents had permitted her to raise
constructions/ improvements on the basis of terms and conditions as
envisaged in the MoU. And as agreed upon and on her volition construction
works were taken up by the petitioner. In the MoU, collection of revenue
from the existing shops within the Park by the petitioner was permitted
though the NIT had specifically laid down that all existing shops and
commercial units shall be outside the purview of the lease. Not only that, at
the request of the petitioner rates of entry and parking fees in respect of
some categories had been changed from what was stated in the NIT to her
advantage by increasing the rates and therefore, it cannot be accepted that
the petitioner was coerced into accepting terms of the MoU or that Clause 4
and 5 had been imposed upon her by the state taking advantage of its
position. In my considered opinion, the ratio of the aforesaid judgments will
not be applicable in the facts of the instant case. In Narain Prasad (supra),
the Hon‟ble Supreme Court laid down that a person who enters into certain
contractual obligations with his eyes open and works the entire contract,
cannot be allowed to turn round and question the validity of those
obligations.
27.
The MoU, however, does not indicate specifically whether the
permission was granted for construction or renovation/ addition of various
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
infrastructures. While in the petition it is asserted that the swimming pool,
fish pond, traditional food court and eco hut were constructed along with the
infrastructure for adventure sports, such assertion is denied in the affidavit
by contending that the swimming pool, fish pond, restaurant and bar were
already in existence but additional work of repair, improvements, additions
and alterations of infrastructure were to be carried out on the existing
infrastructure. Assets created as on 29.03.2011 goes to show that, amongst
others, there was a cafeteria, fish pond with decorative dragon, filtration
pond at catch-pit etc. In absence of any other materials on record, this Court
will not venture into the disputed question as to whether the infrastructures
were newly created or the existing structures/assets were repaired, altered
or improved by the petitioner pursuant to the execution of the MoU.
28.
In the case of Maharaja Dharmander Prasad Singh (supra), the
Hon‟ble Supreme Court had observed that a lessor, with the best of title, has
no right to resume possession extra judicially by use of force, from a lessee,
even after the expiry or earlier termination of the lease by forfeiture or
otherwise and a lessee cannot be dispossessed otherwise than in due course
of law.
29.
In the aforesaid case, by notice dated 19.11.1985, the Government
had cancelled the lease under deed dated 07.10.1961 comprising of 9885
Sq. Metres of Nazool land, which was to expire on 31.03.1991. Another
controversy had arisen out of the order dated 19.04.1986 issued by the
Vice-Chairman, Lucknow Development Authority (LDA) cancelling the earlier
order dated 31.01.1985 granting permission in favour of the respondent
lessees to develop the leasehold property by erecting thereon a multistoreyed building comprising of flats. With regard to the cancellation of lease
in respect of the land, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court held that whether the
purported forfeiture and cancellation of lease deed were valid or not should
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
not have been allowed to be agitated in a proceeding under Article 226 of
the Constitution of India. So far as cancellation of granting permission was
concerned,
though
a
show
cause
notice
was
issued
preceding
the
cancellation, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court held that where the stakes are high
for the lessees who claim to have made large investments on the project and
where a number of grounds required the determination of factual matters of
some complexity, the statutory authority, in the facts of the case, should
have afforded a personal hearing to the lessees.
30.
In Express Newspaper Pvt. Ltd. (supra), the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court observed that the lessor must enforce its right of re-entry upon
forfeiture of lease under Clause 5 of the lease deed in question executed by
the parties by filing a suit due to breach of terms of lease and not by taking
law into its own hands.
31.
In the instant case, the termination order itself indicates that if the
possession is not delivered by the petitioner consequent upon termination of
the lease, the authorities will take recourse to filing of a suit for eviction of
the petitioner.
32.
Tulsiram Patel (supra) is a judgment rendered primarily in the
context of the second proviso to Article 311 (2) dealing with dismissal,
removal or reduction in rank in respect of persons employed in civil services
or a civil post and in that context had considered the scope and expanse of
principles of natural justice. In Canara Bank (supra), in a matter arising out
of dismissal from service, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court had laid down that
even an administrative order which involves civil consequences must be
consistent with the rules of natural justice. In Janab Salehbhai Saheb
Safiyuddin (supra), a notice of termination was issued because of a
complaint of alleged malpractices and irregularities in the management of a
cemetery and the Corporation had decided to take over the management of
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
the cemetery departmentally. It was in
view of the above grounds, the
Bombay High Court held that the principles of natural justice required that
complaints and any material in support thereof ought to have been disclosed
to the petitioner and he ought to have been given an opportunity of making
a representation against the proposed termination of licence.
33.
In the instant case, the termination notice was issued on account of
admitted fact of non-payment of lease rent by the petitioner for more than
two years. In M/s Radhakrishna Agarwal (supra), the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court observed that when contract is sought to be terminated by the officers
of the state, under the terms of an agreement between the parties, such
action is not taken in exercise of any statutory power at all and the
limitations imposed by rules of natural justice cannot operate upon powers
which are governed by the terms of an agreement exclusively. The only
action which normally arises in such cases as to whether the action
complained of is or is not in consonance with the terms of the agreement.
34.
In M.P. Shah Charitable Trust (supra), the contention advanced on
behalf of the respondent Trust that the contract between the parties could
not have been terminated unilaterally without observing the principles of
natural justice was found to be without any substance. It was observed that
if the matter is governed by a contract, the writ petition is not maintainable
since it is a public law remedy and is not available in private law field, where
the matter is governed by non-statutory contract.
35.
In Bareilly Development Authority (supra), the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court noted that there is a line of decisions laying down that where the
contract entered into between the State and the persons aggrieved is nonstatutory and purely contractual and the rights are governed only by the
terms of the contract, no writ or order can be issued under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India so as compel the authorities to remedy a breach of
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
contract pure and simple. It was also noted that after voluntarily accepting
the
conditions
imposed
by
the
Bareilly
Development
Authority,
the
respondents had entered into the realm of concluded contract with Bareilly
Development Authority and hence they can only claim the right conferred
upon them by the said contract and were bound by the terms of contract.
36.
In Jain Plastics and Chemicals Ltd. (supra), the Hon‟ble Supreme
Court had laid down that writ is not the remedy for enforcing contractual
obligations and it is always open for the aggrieved party to approach the
court of competent jurisdiction for appropriate relief for breach of contract.
37.
In M.V. Vyavsaya (supra), the Hon‟ble Supreme Court observed
that where there are disputed questions of fact, the High Court does not
normally go into or adjudicate upon the disputed questions of fact and that a
person who solemnly enters into a contract cannot be allowed to wriggle out
of it by resorting to Article 226 of the Constitution.
38.
In Joshi Technologies International Inc. (supra), at paragraphs
69 and 70, the Hon‟ble Supreme Court held as under: “69. The position thus summarised in the aforesaid principles
has to be understood in the context of discussion that preceded
which we have pointed out above. As per this, no doubt, there is
no absolute bar to the maintainability of the writ petition even in
contractual matters or where there are disputed questions of fact
or even when monetary claim is raised. At the same time,
discretion
lies
with
the
High
Court
which
under
certain
circumstances, it can refuse to exercise. It also follows that
under the following circumstances, “normally”, the Court would
not exercise such discretion:
69.1. The Court may not examine the issue unless the action
has some public law character attached to it.
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
69.2. Whenever a particular mode of settlement of dispute is
provided in the contract, the High Court would refuse to exercise
its discretion under Article 226 of the Constitution and relegate
the party to the said mode of settlement, particularly when
settlement of disputes is to be resorted to through the means of
arbitration.
69.3. If there are very serious disputed questions of fact which
are of complex nature and require oral evidence for their
determination.
69.4. Money claims per se particularly arising out of contractual
obligations are normally not to be entertained except in
exceptional circumstances.
70. Further, the legal position which emerges from various
judgments of this Court dealing with different situations/aspects
relating to contracts entered into by the State/public authority
with private parties, can be summarised as under:
70.1. At the stage of entering into a contract, the State acts
purely in its executive capacity and is bound by the obligations
of fairness.
70.2. State in its executive capacity, even in the contractual
field, is under obligation to act fairly and cannot practise some
discriminations.
70.3. Even in cases where question is of choice or consideration
of competing claims before entering into the field of contract,
facts have to be investigated and found before the question of a
violation of Article 14 of the Constitution could arise. If those
facts are disputed and require assessment of evidence the
correctness of which can only be tested satisfactorily by taking
detailed evidence, involving examination and cross-examination
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
of witnesses, the case could not be conveniently or satisfactorily
decided in proceedings under Article 226 of the Constitution. In
such cases the Court can direct the aggrieved party to resort to
alternate remedy of civil suit, etc.
70.4. Writ jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 226 of the
Constitution
was
not
intended
to
facilitate
avoidance
of
obligation voluntarily incurred.
70.5. Writ petition was not maintainable to avoid contractual
obligation. Occurrence of commercial difficulty, inconvenience or
hardship in performance of the conditions agreed to in the
contract can provide no justification in not complying with the
terms of contract which the parties had accepted with open eyes.
It cannot ever be that a licensee can work out the licence if he
finds it profitable to do so: and he can challenge the conditions
under which he agreed to take the licence, if he finds it
commercially inexpedient to conduct his business.
70.6. Ordinarily, where a breach of contract is complained of,
the party complaining of such breach may sue for specific
performance of the contract, if contract is capable of being
specifically
performed. Otherwise,
the
party
may
sue
for
damages.
70.7. Writ can be issued where there is executive action
unsupported by law or even in respect of a corporation there is
denial of equality before law or equal protection of law or if it can
be shown that action of the public authorities was without giving
any hearing and violation of principles of natural justice after
holding that action could not have been taken without observing
principles of natural justice.
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
70.8. If
the
contract
between
private
party
and
the
State/instrumentality and/or agency of the State is under the
realm of a private law and there is no element of public law, the
normal course for the aggrieved party, is to invoke the remedies
provided under ordinary civil law rather than approaching the
High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India and
invoking its extraordinary jurisdiction.
70.9. The distinction between public law and private law
element in the contract with the State is getting blurred.
However, it has not been totally obliterated and where the
matter falls purely in private field of contract, this Court has
maintained the position that writ petition is not maintainable.
The dichotomy between public law and private law rights and
remedies would depend on the factual matrix of each case and
the distinction between the public law remedies and private law
field, cannot be demarcated with precision. In fact, each case
has to be examined, on its facts whether the contractual
relations between the parties bear insignia of public element.
Once on the facts of a particular case it is found that nature of
the activity or controversy involves public law element, then the
matter can be examined by the High Court in writ petitions
under Article 226 of the Constitution of India to see whether
action of the State and/or instrumentality or agency of the State
is fair, just and equitable or that relevant factors are taken into
consideration and irrelevant factors have not gone into the
decision-making process or that the decision is not arbitrary.
70.10. Mere reasonable or legitimate expectation of a citizen, in
such a situation, may not by itself be a distinct enforceable right,
but failure to consider and give due weight to it may render the
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
decision arbitrary, and this is how the requirements of due
consideration of a legitimate expectation forms part of the
principle of non-arbitrariness.
70.11. The scope of judicial review in respect of disputes falling
within the domain of contractual obligations may be more limited
and
in
doubtful
cases
the
parties
may
be
relegated
to
adjudication of their rights by resort to remedies provided for
adjudication of purely contractual disputes.”
39.
A perusal of the aforesaid judgment goes to show that occurrence of
commercial difficulty, inconvenience or hardship in performance of the
conditions agreed to in the contract can provide no justification in not
complying with the terms of contract which the parties had accepted with
open eyes. It is also laid down that if the contract between the private party
and the state or instrumentally of the state is under the realm of private law
with no element of public law the appropriate remedy for the aggrieved
party is to approach the ordinary civil court and that writ jurisdiction of High
Courts under Article 226 of the Constitution is not intended to facilitate
avoidance of obligations voluntarily incurred.
40.
The controversy in the instant case is purely in the realm of private
law. In the writ petition, averments have been made that advance payment
of rent of three months to the tune of Rs.51.00 lakhs had been paid and the
same has also been admitted by the respondents. Letter dated 14.06.2017
of the petitioner (Annexure R-2 of the affidavit) goes to show that an
amount of Rs.30.00 lakhs for the months of January, 2017 to March, 2017
was also paid. Letter dated 08.09.2017 goes to show that the petitioner had
not paid an amount of Rs.51.00 lakhs being the rent for the period from
April, 2017 to June, 2017 as also Rs. 21.00 lakhs for the months of January,
2017 to March, 2017, thus admitting payment of Rs.30.00 lakhs for the
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
aforesaid period. Letter dated 22.11.2017 also goes to show that apart from
not clearing the dues of Rs.21.00 lakhs, the petitioner had not paid any
amount of rent for the period from April, 2017 to November, 2017. Letter
dated 10.01.2019 goes to show that total dues from May, 2017 to
December, 2018 was Rs.3,40,00,000/-. It appears that in the meantime
defaulted amount of Rs.21.00 lakhs for the period from January, 2017 to
March, 2017 and some payment for the months of April, 2017 was paid.
Letters dated 22.05.2019 and 27.06.2019 were on the subject of payment of
arrears amounting to Rs.4,25,00,000/- for the period from May, 2017 to
May, 2019. By the said letters, the petitioner was directed to make the
payment within seven days from the date of receipt of letter failing which it
was indicated that legal action shall be initiated as per lease deed. In spite of
clear indication in the said notices that legal action shall be initiated on
failure to deposit the arrear rent, the petitioner did not make good the
breach complained of. It was in this background, in terms of the lease deed,
termination order dated 22.07.2019 was issued stating that the lease deed
will stand cancelled within 30 days of receipt of the same. Though the
contention advanced by the petitioner is that the aforesaid letters except
order/letter dated 22.07.2019 was not received, which is denied by
respondents, this Court ought not to go into such disputed fact. The writ
petitioner has continued to run the Park and it is an admitted position that
even during the pendency of the writ petition no amount towards payment
of rent has been paid by the petitioner. Thus, from May 2017 till the date of
hearing spanning over a period of more than 2 years 6 months, no rent has
been paid by the petitioner. In a matter of the present nature, when the
impugned action had been taken in terms of the lease deed, I am of the
considered opinion that the submission advanced by the petitioner that the
impugned order is vitiated as no opportunity of hearing was afforded to the
petitioner is without any merit.
WP (C) No. 27 of 2019
Mrs. Menuka Devi Bhattarai vs. State of Sikkim & Anr.
41.
In view of the above discussions, I find no merit in this writ petition
and, accordingly, the writ petition is dismissed. No costs.
Chief Justice
Approved for reporting: Yes / No
jk/
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review