Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH : AMARAVATI
****
A.S.Nos.527, 530, 623, 646 & 656 of 2013
A.S.No.527 of 2013
Between:
1. THOTA GOPAL, Died by LRs.4 & 5, S/o. Chennaiah, R/o. Thotaveedi,
Atmakur Village ampMandal, SPSR Nellore District.
2. Thota Lalithamma @ Lalitha,, W/o. Gopal, R/o. Thotaveedi, Atmakur
Village & Mandal, SPSR Nellore District.
3. Thota Sameera,, D/o. Gopal, R/o Thotaveedi, Atmakur Village & Mandal,
SPSR Nellore District.
4. Thota Sravanthi, W/o Singarapu Vijaya Chandrudu, Aged about 34
years,Occ Home Maker R/o Thota Street, Atmakur Town, Spsr Nellore
District, Andhra Pradesh.
5. Thota Sumar, S/o lat Gopal Gopaiah, Aged about 33 years, Occ
Employee, R/o Thota Street, Atmakur Town, SPSR Nellore District, Andhra
Pradesh
Appellant Nos. 4 and 5 are brought on record as LRs of
deceased petitioner No. 1 vide Court order dated 22.11.2024 in I.A.No.4 of
2023 in A.S.No.527 of 2013.
...Appellant/s
AND
1. Pandipati Gopal Reddy, S/o. Ramana Reddy, R/o. Madarajuguduru
Village, Nellore Rural Mandal, SPSR Nellore District.
2. Mekala Chandrasekhar Reddy, S/o. Venkatasubba Reddy, R/o. Tekya
Street, Atmakur Village & Mandal, SPSR Nellore District.
3. Mekala Venkatasuba Reddy, S/o. Penchala Reddy, R/o. Tekya Street,
Atmakur Village & Mandal, SPSR Nellore District.
4. Mekala Siva Prathap Reddy, S/o. Venkatasubba Reddy, R/o. Tekya Street,
Atmakur Village & Mandal, SPSR Nellore District.
...Respondents
A.S.No.530 of 2013
Between:
1. Mekala Chandrasekhar Reddy, S/o. M.Venkatasubba Reddy, Private
Employee, House No. 13/64, Tekya Street, Atmakoor Village, ATmakoor
Mandal, Nellore District.
2. Mekala Venkatasubba Reddy, S/o. P. Menchala Reddy, Agriculture, House
No. 13/64, Tekya Street, atmakoor Village, Atmakoor Mandal, Nellore District.
3. Mekala Sivaprathap Reddy,, S/o. M.Venkatasubba Reddy, Private
Employee, House No. 13/64, Tekya Street, atmakoor Village, atmakoor
Mandal, Nellore District.
... Appellant/s
AND
1. Pandipati Gopal Reddy, S/o. P.Ramana Reddy, AGriculture,
MAdarajugudur Village, Nellore MAndal, Nellore District.
2. Thota Gopal, S/o. T.Chenchaiah, AGriculture,
aTmakoor Village, atmakoor Mandal, Nellore District.
R/o.
R/o. Thota Veedhi,
3. Thota Lalithamma Lalitha, W/o. T.Gopal, Household R/o. THota Veedhi,
Atmakoor Village, Atmakoor Mandal, Nellore District.
4. Thota Sameera, D/o. T.Gopal, Household, R/o. Thota Veedhi, Atmakoor
Village, Atmakoor Mandal, Nellore District.
...Respondents
A.S.No.623 of 2013
Between:
1. Mekala Sivaprathap Reddy, S/o M.Venkatasubba Reddy, Occ: Private
Employee, R/o House No. 13/64, Tekya Street, Atmakoor Village, Atmakoor
Mandal, Nellore District
... Appellant/s
AND
1. Thota Lalithamma @ Lalitha, W/o T.Gopal, Occ: Household, R/o Thota
Veedhi, Atmakoor Village, Atmakoor Mandal, Nellore District
2. Pandipati Gopal Reddy, S/o P.Ramana Reddy, Occ: Agriculture, R/o
Madarajugudur Village, Nellore Mandal, Nellore District
...Respondents
A.S.No.646 of 2013
Between:
1. Mekala Venkata Subba Reddy, S/o.P.Menchala Reddy Occ: Agriculture
R/o.H.No.13/64, Tekya Street, Atmakoor [V] & [M], Nellore District.
... Appellant/s
AND
1. Thota Gopal, S/o.T.Chenchaiah Occ: Agriculture R/o.Thota Veedhi,
Atmakoor [V] & [M], Nellore District.
2. Pandipati Gopal Reddy, S/o.P.Ramana Reddy
R/o.Madarajugudur [V], Nellore Mandal and District.
Occ:
Agriculture
...Respondents
A.S.No.656 of 2013
Between:
1. Mekala Chandrasekhar Reddy,, S/o. M Venkatasubba Reddy, Occ: Private
Employee, R/o. H.No. 13/64, Tekya Street, Atmakoor Village, Atmakoor
Mandal, Nellore District.
... Appellant/s
AND
1. Thota Gopal Gopalaiah, S/o. T Chenchaiah, Occ: Agriculture, R/o. Thota
Veedhi, Atmakoor Village, Atmakoor Mandal, Nellore District.
2. Pandipati Gopal Reddy, S/o. P. Ramana Reddy, Occ: Agriculture, R/o.
Madarajugudur Village, Nellore Mandal, Nellore District.
...Respondents
DATE OF JUDGMENT PRONOUNCED: 16.10.2026
SUBMITTED FOR APPROVAL:
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE D. RAMESH
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE ALAPATI GIRIDHAR
1. Whether Reporters of Local Newspapers
may be allowed to see the judgment?
Yes / No
2. Whether the copies of judgment may be
marked to Law Reporters / Journals?
Yes / No
3. Whether His Lordship wish to
see the fair copy of the Judgment?
Yes / No
________________________
JUSTICE D. RAMESH
______________________________
JUSTICE ALAPATI GIRIDHAR
* THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE D. RAMESH
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE ALAPATI GIRIDHAR
+ A.S.Nos.527, 530, 623, 646 & 656 of 2013
% 16.10.2026
A.S.No.527 of 2013
Between:
1. THOTA GOPAL, Died by LRs.4 & 5, S/o. Chennaiah, R/o. Thotaveedi,
Atmakur Village ampMandal, SPSR Nellore District.
2. Thota Lalithamma @ Lalitha,, W/o. Gopal, R/o. Thotaveedi, Atmakur
Village & Mandal, SPSR Nellore District.
3. Thota Sameera,, D/o. Gopal, R/o Thotaveedi, Atmakur Village & Mandal,
SPSR Nellore District.
4. Thota Sravanthi, W/o Singarapu Vijaya Chandrudu, Aged about 34
years,Occ Home Maker R/o Thota Street, Atmakur Town, Spsr Nellore
District, Andhra Pradesh.
5. Thota Sumar, S/o lat Gopal Gopaiah, Aged about 33 years, Occ
Employee, R/o Thota Street, Atmakur Town, SPSR Nellore District, Andhra
Pradesh
Appellant Nos. 4 and 5 are brought on record as LRs of
deceased petitioner No. 1 vide Court order dated 22.11.2024 in I.A.No.4 of
2023 in A.S.No.527 of 2013.
...Petitioners
AND
1. Pandipati Gopal Reddy, S/o. Ramana Reddy, R/o. Madarajuguduru
Village, Nellore Rural Mandal, SPSR Nellore District.
2. Mekala Chandrasekhar Reddy, S/o. Venkatasubba Reddy, R/o. Tekya
Street, Atmakur Village & Mandal, SPSR Nellore District.
3. Mekala Venkatasuba Reddy, S/o. Penchala Reddy, R/o. Tekya Street,
Atmakur Village & Mandal, SPSR Nellore District.
4. Mekala Siva Prathap Reddy, S/o. Venkatasubba Reddy, R/o. Tekya Street,
Atmakur Village & Mandal, SPSR Nellore District.
...Respondents
A.S.No.530 of 2013
Between:
1. Mekala Chandrasekhar Reddy, S/o. M.Venkatasubba Reddy, Private
Employee, House No. 13/64, Tekya Street, Atmakoor Village, ATmakoor
Mandal, Nellore District.
2. Mekala Venkatasubba Reddy, S/o. P. Menchala Reddy, Agriculture, House
No. 13/64, Tekya Street, atmakoor Village, Atmakoor Mandal, Nellore District.
3. Mekala Sivaprathap Reddy,, S/o. M.Venkatasubba Reddy, Private
Employee, House No. 13/64, Tekya Street, atmakoor Village, atmakoor
Mandal, Nellore District.
...Petitioners
AND
1. Pandipati Gopal Reddy, S/o. P.Ramana Reddy, AGriculture,
MAdarajugudur Village, Nellore MAndal, Nellore District.
2. Thota Gopal, S/o. T.Chenchaiah, AGriculture,
aTmakoor Village, atmakoor Mandal, Nellore District.
R/o.
R/o. Thota Veedhi,
3. Thota Lalithamma Lalitha, W/o. T.Gopal, Household R/o. THota Veedhi,
Atmakoor Village, Atmakoor Mandal, Nellore District.
4. Thota Sameera, D/o. T.Gopal, Household, R/o. Thota Veedhi, Atmakoor
Village, Atmakoor Mandal, Nellore District.
...Respondents
A.S.No.623 of 2013
Between:
1. Mekala Sivaprathap Reddy, S/o M.Venkatasubba Reddy, Occ: Private
Employee, R/o House No. 13/64, Tekya Street, Atmakoor Village, Atmakoor
Mandal, Nellore District
...Petitioner
AND
1. Thota Lalithamma @ Lalitha, W/o T.Gopal, Occ: Household, R/o Thota
Veedhi, Atmakoor Village, Atmakoor Mandal, Nellore District
2. Pandipati Gopal Reddy, S/o P.Ramana Reddy, Occ: Agriculture, R/o
Madarajugudur Village, Nellore Mandal, Nellore District
...Respondents
A.S.No.646 of 2013
Between:
1. Mekala Venkata Subba Reddy, S/o.P.Menchala Reddy Occ: Agriculture
R/o.H.No.13/64, Tekya Street, Atmakoor [V] & [M], Nellore District.
...Petitioner
AND
1. Thota Gopal, S/o.T.Chenchaiah Occ: Agriculture R/o.Thota Veedhi,
Atmakoor [V] & [M], Nellore District.
2. Pandipati Gopal Reddy, S/o.P.Ramana Reddy
R/o.Madarajugudur [V], Nellore Mandal and District.
Occ:
Agriculture
...Respondents
A.S.No.656 of 2013
Between:
1. Mekala Chandrasekhar Reddy,, S/o. M Venkatasubba Reddy, Occ: Private
Employee, R/o. H.No. 13/64, Tekya Street, Atmakoor Village, Atmakoor
Mandal, Nellore District.
...Petitioner
AND
1. Thota Gopal Gopalaiah, S/o. T Chenchaiah, Occ: Agriculture, R/o. Thota
Veedhi, Atmakoor Village, Atmakoor Mandal, Nellore District.
2. Pandipati Gopal Reddy, S/o. P. Ramana Reddy, Occ: Agriculture, R/o.
Madarajugudur Village, Nellore Mandal, Nellore District.
...Respondents
! Counsel for Appellant/s
: Sri P. Rajasekhar, learned counsel for the Appellants
^ Counsel for
spondent/s
: Sri O. Manohar Reddy, learned Senior Counsel
representing Sri C. Subodh, learned counsel for
the Respondents.
< Gist:
> Head Note:
? Cases referred:
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.
12.
13.
14.
15.
16.
17.
18.
19.
20.
21.
22.
23.
24.
25.
26.
27.
28.
29.
30.
Re-
(2009) 2 SCC 582
(1990) 3 SCC 1
AIR 2024 SC 3242 & (2024) 7 SCC 515
AIR 2006 Mad 242 & (2006) SCC OnLine Mad 406
(2006) SCC OnLine AP 34
(2005) SCC OnLine AP 289
(2020) 3 SCC 280
2010 SCC OnLine AP 931
(2023) 11 SCC 775
AIR 2005 AP 260 & (2004) SCC OnLine AP 1004
AIR 2022 SUPREME COURT 3361 & (2023) 11 SCC 775
(1996) 4 SCC 526
(1998) 4 SCC 539
1976 AP 243 & (1975) SCC OnLine AP 139
(2024) 4 SCC 247
(2005) 4 SCC 370
(1998) 2 SCC 391
(2011) 8 SCC 249
(1977) 4 SCC 467
(2001) 5 SCC 289
(2005) 6 SCC 344
2024 Supreme SC 1187
(1994) 1 SCC 1
2025 SCC OnLine SC 1501
(2024) 20 SCC 140
(2010) 8 SCC 1
(2023) 13 SCC 1
(2012) 7 SCC 738
(2008) 7 SCC 144
(2005) 9 SCC 568
31.
(2004) 8 SCC 488
Date of reserved for orders : 23.07.2026
Date of pronouncement
: 16.10.2026
Date of uploading
:
16.10.2026
APHC010576122013
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH
AT AMARAVATI
FRIDAY, THE 16th DAY OF OCTOBER 2026
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE D RAMESH
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE ALAPATI GIRIDHAR
A.S.Nos.527, 530, 623, 646 & 656 of 2013
A.S.No.527 of 2013
Between:
1. THOTA GOPAL, Died by LRs.4 & 5, S/o. Chennaiah, R/o. Thotaveedi,
Atmakur Village ampMandal, SPSR Nellore District.
2. Thota Lalithamma @ Lalitha,, W/o. Gopal, R/o. Thotaveedi, Atmakur
Village & Mandal, SPSR Nellore District.
3. Thota Sameera,, D/o. Gopal, R/o Thotaveedi, Atmakur Village & Mandal,
SPSR Nellore District.
4. Thota Sravanthi, W/o Singarapu Vijaya Chandrudu, Aged about 34
years,Occ Home Maker R/o Thota Street, Atmakur Town, Spsr Nellore
District, Andhra Pradesh.
5. Thota Sumar, S/o lat Gopal Gopaiah, Aged about 33 years, Occ
Employee, R/o Thota Street, Atmakur Town, SPSR Nellore District, Andhra
Pradesh
Appellant Nos. 4 and 5 are brought on record as LRs of
deceased petitioner No. 1 vide Court order dated 22.11.2024 in I.A.No.4 of
2023 in A.S.No.527 of 2013.
... Appellant/s
AND
1. Pandipati Gopal Reddy, S/o. Ramana Reddy, R/o. Madarajuguduru
Village, Nellore Rural Mandal, SPSR Nellore District.
2. Mekala Chandrasekhar Reddy, S/o. Venkatasubba Reddy, R/o. Tekya
Street, Atmakur Village & Mandal, SPSR Nellore District.
3. Mekala Venkatasuba Reddy, S/o. Penchala Reddy, R/o. Tekya Street,
Atmakur Village & Mandal, SPSR Nellore District.
4. Mekala Siva Prathap Reddy, S/o. Venkatasubba Reddy, R/o. Tekya Street,
Atmakur Village & Mandal, SPSR Nellore District.
...Respondents
Counsel for the Petitioners: P RAJASEKHAR,YADLAPALLI VENKATA
KALYANA CHAKRAVARTHI,.
Counsel for the Respondents: C SUBODH
A.S.No.530 of 2013
Between:
1. Mekala Chandrasekhar Reddy, S/o. M.Venkatasubba Reddy, Private
Employee, House No. 13/64, Tekya Street, Atmakoor Village, ATmakoor
Mandal, Nellore District.
2. Mekala Venkatasubba Reddy, S/o. P. Menchala Reddy, Agriculture, House
No. 13/64, Tekya Street, atmakoor Village, Atmakoor Mandal, Nellore District.
3. Mekala Sivaprathap Reddy,, S/o. M.Venkatasubba Reddy, Private
Employee, House No. 13/64, Tekya Street, atmakoor Village, atmakoor
Mandal, Nellore District.
... Appellant/s
AND
1. Pandipati Gopal Reddy, S/o. P.Ramana Reddy, AGriculture,
MAdarajugudur Village, Nellore MAndal, Nellore District.
2. Thota Gopal, S/o. T.Chenchaiah, AGriculture,
aTmakoor Village, atmakoor Mandal, Nellore District.
R/o.
R/o. Thota Veedhi,
3. Thota Lalithamma Lalitha, W/o. T.Gopal, Household R/o. THota Veedhi,
Atmakoor Village, Atmakoor Mandal, Nellore District.
4. Thota Sameera, D/o. T.Gopal, Household, R/o. Thota Veedhi, Atmakoor
Village, Atmakoor Mandal, Nellore District.
...Respondents
Counsel for the Petitioners: SIVAPRASAD REDDY VENATI
Counsel for the Respondents:
A.S.No.623 of 2013
Between:
1. Mekala Sivaprathap Reddy, S/o M.Venkatasubba Reddy, Occ: Private
Employee, R/o House No. 13/64, Tekya Street, Atmakoor Village, Atmakoor
Mandal, Nellore District
... Appellant/s
AND
1. Thota Lalithamma @ Lalitha, W/o T.Gopal, Occ: Household, R/o Thota
Veedhi, Atmakoor Village, Atmakoor Mandal, Nellore District
2. Pandipati Gopal Reddy, S/o P.Ramana Reddy, Occ: Agriculture, R/o
Madarajugudur Village, Nellore Mandal, Nellore District
...Respondents
Counsel for the Petitioner: SIVAPRASAD REDDY VENATI
Counsel for the Respondents:
A.S.No.646 of 2013
Between:
1. Mekala Venkata Subba Reddy, S/o.P.Menchala Reddy Occ: Agriculture
R/o.H.No.13/64, Tekya Street, Atmakoor [V] & [M], Nellore District.
... Appellant/s
AND
1. Thota Gopal, S/o.T.Chenchaiah Occ: Agriculture R/o.Thota Veedhi,
Atmakoor [V] & [M], Nellore District.
2. Pandipati Gopal Reddy, S/o.P.Ramana Reddy
R/o.Madarajugudur [V], Nellore Mandal and District.
Occ:
Agriculture
...Respondents
Counsel for the Petitioner: SIVAPRASAD REDDY VENATI
Counsel for the Respondents: C SUBODH
A.S.No.656 of 2013
Between:
1. Mekala Chandrasekhar Reddy,, S/o. M Venkatasubba Reddy, Occ: Private
Employee, R/o. H.No. 13/64, Tekya Street, Atmakoor Village, Atmakoor
Mandal, Nellore District.
... Appellant/s
AND
1. Thota Gopal Gopalaiah, S/o. T Chenchaiah, Occ: Agriculture, R/o. Thota
Veedhi, Atmakoor Village, Atmakoor Mandal, Nellore District.
2. Pandipati Gopal Reddy, S/o. P. Ramana Reddy, Occ: Agriculture, R/o.
Madarajugudur Village, Nellore Mandal, Nellore District.
...Respondents
Counsel for the Petitioner: SIVAPRASAD REDDY VENATI
Counsel for the Respondents:
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE D RAMESH
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE ALAPATI GIRIDHAR
A.S.Nos.527, 530, 623, 646 & 656 of 2013
The Court made the following COMMON JUDGMENT:
(per Hon’ble Sri Justice Alapati Giridhar)
1. The Appeals are filed by the Defendants challenging the Common
Judgment of the learned Principal District Judge, Nellore, dated 01.03.2013 in
O.S.Nos.49, 59, 62 and 78 of 2007, wherein the Suit in O.S.No.49 of 2007
filed for specific performance by Pandipati Gopal Reddy is decreed with costs
against the 1st to 3rd Defendants and the other three Suits in O.S.Nos.59, 62
& 78 of 2007 filed for specific performance are dismissed with costs.
2. For brevity, the plaintiff in O.S.No.49 of 2007 is referred to as the
Plaintiff. The 1st to 6th Defendants in this Suit are referred to as Defendants.
The 4th to 6th Defendants also filed Suits, O.S.Nos.59, 62 & 78 of 2007 for
specific performance, they are also referred to as 4th to 6th Defendants
respectively.
I. BRIEF CONTENTIONS
3. Heard Sri P. Rajasekhar, learned counsel for Appellant No.2, 4 and
5 in A.S.No.527 of 2013, Sri Siva Prasad Reddy Venati, learned counsel for
Appellants in A.S.Nos.530, 623, 646 & 656 of 2013 and Sri O. Manohar
Reddy, learned Senior Counsel representing Sri C. Subodh, learned counsel
for Respondent in all the Appeals, who is the Plaintiff in O.S.No.49 of 2007.
4. The learned counsel for the 2nd, 4th & 5th Appellants in A.S.No.527 of
2013, contends that the Trial Court erred in decreeing the Suit for specific
performance based on the Agreement of Sale though the same is not a valid
and enforceable agreement. That the Plaintiff paid a paltry amount of
Rs.2,00,000/- only, that even the agreement recitals show that there is a
condition to measure the property and to arrive at the balance of sale
consideration for the suit schedule property/Ac.31.28¼ cents @ Rs.2,10,000/per acre. That the agreement did not contain the boundaries but contains only
survey numbers, the Plaintiff issued a paper publication, which also did not
contain boundaries but strangely in the plaint he mentioned the boundaries,
which casts serious doubt on the case of the Plaintiff. That the evidence of
Scribe/PW.4 is not consistent, at one point he stated that the 1st Defendant
informed him about the case and asked him not to come to the Court, at the
other point, he says that the Court Staff informed him that he was summoned
by the Court and he accordingly attended the Court.
5. Sri P. Rajasekhar, learned counsel submits that the O.S.No.49 of
2007 was filed for specific performance against the 1st to 3rd Defendants,
though the 1st and 2nd Defendants are the owners of the suit schedule
property, the Plaintiff could not prove the Suit agreement of sale and that he
wasready and willingness to perform his obligation under the agreement.
Further, the case of the 1st and 2nd Defendants is that they executed three
agreements in favour of the 4th to 6th Defendants, but the Trial Court failed to
appreciate the same and dismissed the Suits/O.S.Nos.59, 62 & 78 of 2007
and prays to allow the Appeals and to decree the Suits.
6. The learned Counsel fairly submits that they are not disputing the
agreement of sale/Ex.P.1, but contends that the Plaintiff could not prove that
he is ready and willing to perform his part of the contract with the balance
sale consideration, but the Trial Court did not appreciate the evidence in this
regard and prays to allow the Appeals and dismiss the Suit filed by the
Plaintiff in O.S.No.49 of 2007.
7. The learned Counsel fairly submits that in the other three Suits, two
stamps contained the agreements of Sale in two Suits were ante dated i.e
prior to issuing of the stamps by the Registrar.
supporting the three agreements.
These Appellants are
8. The learned counsel placed reliance on i) Veeramareddy
Nagabhushana Rao Vs. Jyothula Venkateswara Rao, ii) Mayawanti Vs.
Kaushalya Devi, iii) Pydi Ramana Vs. Davarasetty Manmadha Rao, iv) P.
Panneerselvan Vs.. A. Baylis, v) Penumatsa Narasimha Raju Vs. Valluri Jaya
Prakasa Babu, vi) Kota Rama Rao Vs. Kolli Rajeswaramma vii) U.N.
KrishnaMurthy (Since Deceased) through Legal Representatives Vs. A.M.
Krishnamurthy, viii) B. Rajamani Vs. Mrs. Azhar Sultana and others, ix) U.N.
KrishnaMurthy (Since Deceased) through Legal Representatives Vs. A.M.
Krishnamurthy, x) Punjab Urban Planning & Development Authority Vs. Shiv
Saraswti Iron & Steel Re-Rolling Mills, xi) Pudi Lazarus Vs. Rev. Johnson
Edward and others and HIS Holiness Acharya Swami Ganesh Dassji Vs. Sita
Ram Thapar.
9. Sri Siva Prasad Reddy Venati, learned Counsel for the Appellants in
A.S.Nos.530, 623, 646 and 656 of 2013 adopted the arguments of Sri P.
Rajasekhar and prayed to allow their Appeals duly setting aside the Common
Judgment and Decree and sought to decree the Suits in O.S.Nos.59, 62 and
78 of 2007.
10. Sri O. Manohar Reddy, the learned Senior Counsel, assisted by Sri
C. Subodh, learned Counsel for the Respondent (who is Plaintiff in O.S.No.49
of 2007 and the 2nd Defendant in O.S.Nos.59, 62 and 78 of 2007), contends
that the Counsel for the 2nd, 4th and 5th Appellants in A.S.No.527 of 2013, did
not dispute the agreement/Ex.A1, which is also adopted by the other
Appellants, but only disputing the Plaintiff’s readiness and willingness with
balance sale consideration to perform his part under the agreement.
He
submits that the 1st and 2nd Defendant are husband and wife and the 3rd
Defendant is their daughter, they all agreed to sell the plaint schedule
property of Ac.31.28 ¼ cents, per acre @ Rs.2,10,000/-, the Plaintiff paid
Rs.2,00,000/- to them on 20.01.2007 as advance and they jointly executed an
Agreement of Sale on the same day i.e on 20.01.2007/Ex.A.1 in his favour
and agreed to receive balance sale consideration on or before 15.04.2007,
duly measuring the property and execute a registered sale deed. The
properties are in a village and that the Defendants are villagers. The Plaintiff
is also from the same village, there is no dispute in identity of the property
either in the pleadings or throughout the trial though the boundaries are not
mentioned in the Agreement of Sale and paper publication, it is not of
significance. Thus the contention that non-mentioning of boundaries in the
plaint is insignificant in the circumstances of the case. The Plaintiff also filed
copies of the bank statements to show the balance sale consideration, the
Plaintiff could prove the Agreement and that he has been ready and willing to
perform his part under the Agreement with the balance consideration, the
Trial Court rightly appreciated the oral and documentary evidence and rightly
decreed the Suit, whereas the 1st and 2nd Defendants fabricated the
Agreements of Sale in favour of 4th to 6th Defendants after filing the Suit only
to evade his Agreement/Ex.A1. The Trial Court rightly recorded the collusion
between all the Defendants including the Agreement of sale/Ex’s.B.1, B.15 &
B.20, two of them are shown executed much prior to their issuance by the
Registrar’s Office, which clearly shows the collusion and fabrication of the
agreements, prayed to dismiss the Appeals.
11. The learned Senior Counsel also contends that this Court order is
violated and the Defendants have colluded and alienated the suit schedule
property and sought to take action as per law and that he will file a memo with
the registered sale deeds, for which the learned Counsel for the Appellant
No.2, 4 and 5 fairly submitted that the property is alienated.
12. The learned counsel placed reliance on C.S. Venkatesh Vs. A.S.C.
Murthy (Dead) By Legal Representatives and Others and ii) Thangam and
Another Vs. Navamani Ammal.
13. Initially, A.S.No.527 of 2007 was filed by the 1st to 3rd Appellants/1st
to 3rd Defendants by engaging a Counsel, during pendency of the Appeal, the
1st Appellant died, an application was filed and allowed impleading the 4th and
5th Appellants and the present counsel filed the Vakalat.
II. BRIEF PLEADINGS:
14. O.S.No.49 of 2007 was filed by P. Gopal Reddy/Plaintiff who is one
of the Respondents in A.S.No.527 of 2013 & A.S.No.530 of 2013. O.S.No.62
of 2007 filed by Mekala Siva Prathap Reddy who is the Appellant in
A.S.No.623 of 2013. O.S.No.78 of 2007 was filed by Mekala Venkatasubba
Reddy who is the Appellant in A.S.No.646 of 2013. O.S.No.59 of 2007 was
filed by Mekala Chandrasekhar Reddy, who is the Appellant in A.S.No.656 of
2013.
i) Plaint in O.S.No.49 of 2007
15. The brief case of the Plaintiff is that 1st to 3rd Defendants (Couple
and daughter) are the owners of the suit schedule property/Ac.31.28 ¼ cents
and they finally offered to sell the property for Rs.2,10,000/- per acre and he
agreed and paid Rs.2,00,000/- as an advance on 20.01.2007 and the 1st to
3rd Defendants executed the Agreement of Sale in his favour agreeing to
execute the registered Sale Deed by receiving the balance sale consideration
on or before 15.04.2007 by duly measuring the property. That the Plaintiff
has been always ready and willing to pay the balance sale consideration of
Rs.63,68,525/-, he also filed bank statements. The Plaintiff has been asking
them to receive the balance sale consideration and execute the registered
sale deed, but they are postponing the same with dishonest intention and
failed to perform their part. That the Plaintiff issued a paper publication on
27.01.2007 in Eenadu Daily News Paper as abundant caution. As they were
postponing to receive the balance sale consideration and to execute the
registered sale deed, so he issued a legal notice to them on 02.04.2007,
calling them to receive the balance sale consideration and execute the
registered sale deed within 7 days from the date of receipt of the notice,
they/1st to 3rd Defendants received the notice but they did not perform their
part of contract but the 3rd Defendant issued reply notice stating that she is
not the owner of the property and she did not execute the Agreement of Sale.
Hence, the suit is filed for specific performance.
ii) Written Statement dated 07.09.2007
16. The 1st Defendant initially filed the written statement dated
07.09.2007, and the 1st Defendant admitted that 1st and 2nd Defendant are
the absolute owners of the property, but denied that 3rd Defendant is owner of
the property, also denied offering the property and agreeing for Rs.2,10,000/per acre, the Plaintiff paying Rs.2,00,000/- as an advance on 20.01.2007 and
they jointly executing the Agreement of Sale and its conditions including to
register the property on or before 15.04.2007, and also that the Plaintiff is
always ready and willing to pay the balance sale consideration of
Rs.63,68,525/- and they denied postponing the registration.
The 1st
Defendant admitted issuing of legal notice and reply by the 3rd Defendant.
The 1st Defendant specifically pleaded that at first instance, the Plaintiff
approached the 1st and 2nd Defendants and expressed willingness to
purchase the property but the negotiations failed regarding the fixation of sale
price and other aspects. The Plaintiff is unable to satisfy the 1st and 2nd
Defendants to show the capacity to pay such huge amount of the sale
consideration, and they refused to sell. The Plaintiff proclaimed that, if the
property is not sold to him, he will make false litigation and involve the
property in litigation and that nobody will come forward to purchase the
property and he threatened. The Plaintiff fabricated the Agreement of Sale
and filed the Suit. That the Plaintiff has no capacity to pay such huge amount
and that the Agreement of Sale is not binding on the Defendants and there is
no need to execute any registered sale deed in favour of the Plaintiff and that
the Suit is vexatious and prayed to dismiss the suit with costs.
iii) Adoption Memo by the 2nd and 3rd Defendants
17. A memo is filed by the 2nd and 3rd Defendants adopting the written
statement filed by the 1st Defendant.
iv) Additional Written Statement by 1st Defendant dated 26.04.2010
18. The 1st Defendant filed this additional written statement, pleading
that on 25.11.2006, he sold an extent of Ac.7.67 Cents under Agreement of
Sale in favour of one Mekala Chandra Sekhar Reddy for consideration of
Rs.11,50,500/- and received an advance of Rs.50,000/- from him. The said
Mekala Chandra Sekhar Reddy failed to pay the balance sale consideration
and failed to get the register sale deed, hence he filed the Suit O.S.No.59 of
2007 and the same is pending. That on 06.01.2007 he also sold an extent of
Ac.13.55 cents to one Mekala Venkata Subba Reddy under Agreement of
Sale for consideration of Rs.23,71,250/- and received an advance of
Rs.50,000/- from him. The said Mekala Venkata Subba Reddy failed to pay
the balance sale consideration and filed the Suit in O.S.No.78 of 2007 and
same is pending.
v) Additional Written Statement by 2nd Defendant dated 26.04.2010
19. The 2nd Defendant filed this additional written statement, pleading
that on 29.11.2006 she sold part of the plaint schedule property to one
Mekala Siva Pratap Reddy under Agreement of Sale Rs.14,14,400/- and
received an advance of Rs.50,000/-. The said Mekala Siva Pratap Reddy
failed to pay the balance sale consideration, he filed the Suit O.S.No.62 of
2007 and the same is pending.
vi) Written Statement of the 4th Defendant dated 26.04.2010
20. The 4th Defendant filed the written statement, pleading that the 2nd
and 3rd Defendants are wife and daughter and they are the absolute owners
of the schedule property. Denied the agreement of sale dated 20.01.2007,
agreeing to sell the schedule property for Rs.2,10,000/- per acre in favour of
the Plaintiff/Pandipati Gopal Reddy and receiving advance of Rs.2,00,000/from him and executing the Agreement of Sale and its terms and conditions,
with stipulation on or before 15.04.2007 to receive the balance sale
consideration and register the property. Also denied that the Plaintiff is ready
and willing to pay the balance sale consideration of Rs.63,68,525/-, the
Plaintiff requesting to 1st to 3rd Defendants to receive the balance sale
consideration and execute the registered sale deed, but they dishonestly
postponing, filing of Copies of the S.B accounts pass books in the name of
his family members issued by the Indian Bank. That this Defendant is not
aware of the of paper publication in Eenadu Daily News paper dated
27.01.2007. Denied that the Plaintiff got issuing a legal notice to the 1st to 3rd
Defendants on 02.07.2007, calling the 1st to 3rd Defendants to receive the
balance sale consideration and execute registered sale deed, serving of the
legal notice on the 1st to 3rd Defendants and issuing a reply notice by the 3rd
Defendant.
21. The 4th Defendant specifically pleaded that on 25.11.2006, he
approached 1st Defendant to purchase the part of the plaint schedule
property, claiming that 1st Defendant is absolute owner and agreed to sell.
After bargain, it was settled and 1st Defendant sold the property for
Rs.11,50,500/, as the property valued @ Rs.1,50,000/- per acre, aggregating
to Rs.11,50,500/- and 1st Defendant received earnest money of Rs.50,000/-,
agreed to pay the balance sale consideration within 3 months i.e., by
24.02.2007, he has to execute registered sale deed, but the 1st Defendant did
not come forward to receive the balance sale consideration of Rs.11,00,500/and execute the registered sale deed. That the 4th Defendant is ready and
willing to pay the balance sale consideration but the 1st Defendant did not
come forward to perform his part of contract on some pretext or the others,
hence he issued legal notice on 17.02.2007 to receive the balance sale
consideration of Rs.11,00,500/- and to execute a registered sale deed, he
received the notice but did not perform his part of contract, that he came to
know that 1st Defendant is going to sell the property to third parties, he gave
paper publication in Prajashakthi Daily News Paper on 13.04.2007 stating
that the 1st Defendant executed Agreement of Sale in his favour.
22. That his father/Mekala Venkata Subba Reddy purchased an extent
of Ac.13.55 cents from the 1st Defendant under Agreement of Sale dated
06.01.2007 and his brother/Mekala Siva Pratap Reddy purchased an extent
of Ac.8.85 ¼ cents from 2nd Defendant under Agreement of Sale dated
29.11.2006, but they did not come forward to execute registered sale deeds
by receiving the balance sale consideration, hence he filed O.S.No.59 of
2007, his father filed O.S.No.78/2007 and his brother filed O.S.No.62/2007 for
specific performance. That even prior to execution of the alleged agreement
of sale in this suit dated 20.01.2007 by the 1st to 3rd Defendants in favour of
the Plaintiff, the 1st and 2nd Defendant already sold the property to the 4th
Defendant to 6th Defendant under the three agreements and that the
agreement dated 20.01.2007 is fabricated.
vii) Written Statement of the 5th Defendant dated 26.04.2010
23. The 5th Defendant also filed his written statement on the same lines
of the 4th Defendant as stated supra, denying including the agreement of the
Plaintiff dated 20.01.2007 and the Plaintiff is always ready and willing to
perform his part under the agreement with the balance sale consideration.
Pleading that he and his 2 sons purchased the schedule property from the 1st
and 2nd Defendants on 06.01.2007, 25.11.2006, 29.11.2006 under three
agreements, issuing of paper publication and legal notice, they are always
ready and willing to perform their part under the agreements with balance
sale consideration but the 1st and 2nd Defendants did not come forward to
receive the balance sale consideration and execute the registered sale deeds
and they filed three suits for specific performance, on the same lines as
pleaded by the 4th Defendant as stated supra.
viii) Written Statement of the 6th Defendant dated 26.04.2010
24. The 6th Defendant also filed his written statement on the same lines
of the 4th Defendant as stated supra, denying the agreement of the Plaintiff
dated 20.01.2007 and the Plaintiff is always ready and willing to perform his
part under the agreement with the balance sale consideration. Pleading that
he, his father and his brother purchased the schedule property from the 1st
and 2nd Defendants on 06.01.2007, 25.11.2006, 29.11.2006 under three
agreements, issuing of paper publication and legal notice, they are always
ready and willing to perform their part under the agreements with balance
sale consideration but the 1st and 2nd Defendants did not come forward to
receive the balance sale consideration and execute the registered sale deeds
and they filed three suits for specific performance, on the same lines as
pleaded by the 4th Defendant as stated supra.
ix) Plaint and Written Statements in O.S.No.59 of 2007 (filed by the
4th Defendant in OS.49 of 2007)
25. The Plaintiff initially filed the suit against Thota Gopal for specific
performance of the agreement of sale dated 25.11.2006, subsequently on
19.04.2010 added Pandipati Gopal Reddy as the 2nd Defendant (who was the
Plaintiff in O.S.No.49 of 2007).
x) Plaint and Written Statements in O.S.No.78 of 2007 (filed by the
5thDefendant in OS.49 of 2007)
26. The Plaintiff initially filed the suit against Thota Gopal for specific
performance of the agreement of sale dated 06.01.2007, subsequently on
17.06.2010 added Pandipati Gopal Reddy as 2nd Defendant (who was the
Plaintiff in O.S.No.49 of 2007).
xi) Plaint and Written Statements in O.S.No.62 of 2007 (filed by the
6th Defendant in OS.49 of 2007)
27. The Plaintiff initially filed the suit against Thota Lalithamma for
specific
performance
of
the
agreement
of sale
dated
29.11.2006,
subsequently on 17.06.2010 added Pandipati Gopal Reddy as the 2nd
Defendant (who was the Plaintiff in O.S.No.49 of 2007).
III. ISSUES:
28. The record reveals that as the case is not settled, the Trial Court
has initially framed the following issues;
i. Whether the agreement of sale, dated 20.1.2007 and payment of
Rs.2,00,000/- is true?
ii. Whether the plaintiff is ready and willing to perform the contract?
iii. Whether the plaintiff is entitled for specific performance of the
contract?
iv. To what relief?
29. It appears, after adding of the 4th to 6th Defendants, filing of their
written statements, the Trial Court framed these Additional issues on
17.6.2010 :i.
Whether the agreement of sale, dated 25.11.2006 alleged to have
been executed by the 1st Defendant in favour of 4th Defendant is
true, valid and binding on the plaintiff?
ii.
Whether the agreement of sale, dated 06.1.2007 alleged to have
been executed by the 1st Defendant in favour of 5th Defendant is
true, valid and binding on the plaintiff?
iii.
Whether the agreement of sale, dated 29.11.2006 alleged to have
been executed by the 1st Defendant in favour of 6th Defendant is
true, valid and binding on the plaintiff?
iv.
To what relief?
On 17.6.2010, Additional Issue No.3, was recasted as follows :
Whether the agreement of sale, dated 29.11.2006 alleged to
have been executed by the 2nd Defendant in favour of 6th
Defendant is true, valid and binding on the plaintiff ?
30. The material on record reveals that the Trial Court recorded the
evidence of PWs.1 to 5 i.e., PW-1/Pandipati Gopal Reddy, PW-2/Mettu
Surendra Reddy, PW-3/P.Siva Kumar Reddy, PW-4/Gulam G.K.Nazeer and
PW-5/Gattupalli Srinivasa Murali and exhibited A-1 to A-8 on behalf of the
Plaintiff and also exhibited X-1, X-2 and Z-1 to Z-5 through PW.5. Recorded
the evidence of DWs.1 to 7 i.e., DW-1/Thota Gopal,DW-2/Mekala
Venkatasubba Reddy, DW-3/Mekala Sivaprathap Reddy, DW-4/Mekala
Chandrasekhar Reddy, DW-5/Challa Srinivaslu, DW-6/Giddaluru Narayana &
DW-7/Pasupuleti Vinaya and exhibited B-1 to B-24 on behalf of the
Defendants. Ex.X-1 is the certificate given by the Sub Treasury Officer, Kovur,
Ex.X-2 is the relevant entry at page No.21, dated 16-12-2006 relating to the
stamp issue register of Sub Registrar's Office exhibited through PW-5. Exs.Z1 to Z-5 are exhibited in the evidence of DW-7 relating to sale of the stamps
by the stamp vendor M. Balaji Singh to the Defendants 4, 6 and 5
respectively in respect of the agreements of sales said to have been
executed in favour of the Defendants 4 to 6 who are the plaintiffs in O.S.59,
62 and 78 of 2007.
IV. DOCUMENTS EXHIBITED BY THE PLAINTIFF:
31. Ex.A-1/ Sale agreement dt:20-01-2007, Ex.A-2/ Relevant portion of
Eenadu daily news paper dt:27-1-07, Ex.A-3/ Office copy of lawyer notice
dt:2-4-07 with postal receipts, Ex.A-4/ Postal acknowledgment of 1st
Defendant, Ex.A-5/ Postal acknowledgment of 2nd Defendant, Ex.A-6/ Postal
acknowledgment of 3rd Defendant, Ex.A-7/ Reply notice dt:9-04-2007, Ex.A-8/
Postal acknowledgment dt:6-6-07.
Documents exhibited through PW-5
:Ex.X-1/ In the letter Dt:7-4-2012 issued by STO Office, Kovur, Ex.X-2/ In the
relevant entry at page 21 dt:16-12-06 relating to M.Balaji Singh.
V. DOCUMENTS EXHIBITED BY THE DEFENDANTS:
32. Ex.B-1/ Un-registered agreement of sale dated 6-1-2007, Ex.B-2/
Office copy of lawyer notice dated 17-2-2007, Ex.B-3/ Postal receipt dated
17-2-2007, Ex.B-4/ Served acknowledgment card on the 1st Defendant, Ex.B5/ News item published in the Praja Sakthi daily news paper dt:30-4-2007,
Ex.B-6/ Relevant entry in pattadar pass book of Chavate Bhimesvaran, Ex.B7/ Pattadar pass book of Chavate Bhimesvaran, Ex.B-8/ Relevant entry in
pattadar pass book, Ex.B-9/ Memo filed by Defendant in OS.62/07 to refer the
matter to Lok-Adalath, Ex.B-10/ Adangal copy relating to Survey No:279-1
issued by Tahasildar Athmakur, Padakandla, Ex.B-11/ Adangal copy issued
by Tahasildar A.S.Pet dt:21-1-12 in Survey no:21-2-2 of Kondameda, Ex.B12/ Adangal Copy in survey no:20-3-1 of Kondameda Kondur Village, Ex.B13/ Adangal copy http://S.No:21-1-2 of Kondameda Konduru (V), Ex.B-14/
Adangal copy issued by Tahasildar Atmakur in S.No:240-1 of Nuvvurpadu
Village, Ex.B-15/ Agreement of sale dated 29-11-2006 in OS.62/07, Ex.B-16/
Office copy of notice dated:17-2-2007, Ex.B-17/ Postal receipt, Ex.B-18/
Served acknowledgment, Ex.B-19/ Publication in Prajasakthi, Ex.B-20/
Agreement of sale dt:25-11-2006, Ex.B-21/ Office copy of notice dt:17-22007, Ex.B-22/ Postal receipt of Ex.B.21, Ex.B-23/ Acknowledgment Card &
Ex.B-24/ Paper Publication.
33. Documents exhibited through LW-7 : Ex.Z-1/Stamp issuance
register of M.Balaji Singh stamps vendor of Kovur for the year 2006, Ex.Z-2/
Stamp issuance register of M.Balaji Singh relating to the Kovur Subregistrar's office for the year 2007, Ex.Z-3/ Relevant entry dt:25-11-06 in
Ex.Z-1, stamp issuance register relating to selling of hundred rupee stamp in
the stamp vendor Balaji Singh, Ex.Z-4/ Relevant entry dt:29-11-06 in Ex.Z-1
stamp issuance register evidencing the selling of the hundred rupee stamp
number B714594, Ex.Z-5/ Relevant entry dt:6-1-07 in Ex.Z-2 stamp issuance
register evidencing the selling of hundred rupee NJ stamp bearing C625169
to Mekala Subbareddy (D-6).
VI. Issues and findings of the Trial Court in the Common Judgment
34. The Trial Court answered Issues Nos.1 to 4 in favour of the Plaintiff
in O.S.No.49 of 2007, but all other issues pertaining to O.S.No’s.59, 62 and
78 of 2007 are answered against the Plaintiffs in their respective suits and 4th
to 6th Defendants in OS.49 of 2007.
35. The Trial Court held that the Plaintiff in O.S.No.49 of 2007 could
prove the agreement of sale/Ex.A1 and also that the Plaintiff has been always
ready and willing to perform his part of contract with balance sale
consideration, decreed the suit for specific performance with costs.
36. The Trial Court held that the 1st to 6th Defendants in collusion with
attestors and scribe fabricated the suit agreements with ante-dates and
dismissed the suits in O.S.No’s.59, 62 and 78 of 2007 with costs, which are
filed for specific performance.
VII. Issues framed by this Court:
37. Thus, this Court, in view of the submissions, inclined to frame the
following issues for consideration;
i) Whether the Plaintiff in O.S.No.49 of 2007 could prove the agreement
of sale/Ex.A.1, if so whether he could prove that he has been always
ready and willing to perform his part under the agreement with balance
sale consideration? If so to what relief ?
ii) If not, whether the Plaintiffs in O.S.No’s.59, 62 and 78 of 2007 could
prove the agreements of sale/Ex.B1, B.15 and B.20 for the same
schedule property, if so, whether they could prove that they have been
always ready and willing to perform their part under the agreements
with balance sale consideration? If so, to what relief ?
iii) If not, whether these agreements/Ex.B.1, B.15 and B.20 are
fabricated by Plaintiffs in OS.59, 62 and 78 of 2007 in collusion with
parties, attestors and scribe of the agreements to defraud the Plaintiff in
OS.49 of 2007 ? if so, what is the legal consequence ?
iv) Whether the Defendants sold the schedule property despite
undertaking dated 29.04.2022 before this Court, if so, what is the legal
consequence ?
VIII. ANALYSIS
38. The material on record reveals that the Plaintiff was resident of
Atmakur, the 1st to 6th Defendants are residents of Atmakur, the 3rd Defendant
is the daughter of the 1st and 2nd Defendants and the 5th Defendant is the
father of the 4th and 6th Defendants, which are not in dispute.
i) On the agreement/Ex.A1 dated 02.04.2007
39. The Trial Court relied on the evidence of PW.1 and PW.2 &
3/Attestors,
and
PW.4/Scribe,
also
the
agreement/Ex.A1,
Paper
Publication/Ex.A2, the legal notice/Ex.A.3 and reply notice/Ex.A.7, recorded a
finding in favour of the Plaintiff that he could prove the agreement/Ex.A1.
40. The Plaintiff and the Defendants are from the same village.
Further, DW.1 in his cross examination admitted that the plaintiff belongs to
his village and he did not have any disputes with PW.2 to 4.
41. The Court perused the agreement/Ex.A.1. It contains name of the
Plaintiff, 1st to 3rd Defendant signatures in first and second pages, also three
attestors signatures and scribe’s signature. It contains survey numbers for
Ac.31.28 ¼ cents in Peramana village, Atmakur Mandal, mentioning that they
have agreed rate @ Rs.2,10,000/- per acre, that the Defendants received
advance of Rs.2,00,000/- and the plaintiff has to pay the balance sale
consideration and got for register sale deed on or before 15.04.2007.
42. The Court also perused their evidence, which is consistent on the
execution of the agreement/Ex.A1, though the Defendants cross examined
them at length, they could not elicit any material to discredit their version on
the execution of the agreement. Further, the 1st to 3rd Defendants did not
specifically deny their signatures on the Agreement/Ex.A.1, so also they did
not prefer to send their signatures on the agreement/Ex.A1 to hand writing
expert for examination.
43. The contention of the Appellants is that the evidence of
Scribe/PW.4 is not consistent, at one point he stated that the 1st Defendant
informed him about the case and asked him not to come to the Court, at
another point, he says that the Court Staff informed him that he was
summoned by the Court and he accordingly attended before the Court. This
is not inconsistent, these two events might have happened. Further, even if
this evidence is termed as inconsistent, still the case of the Plaintiff is not
effected, as the Appellants admitted about execution of the agreement/Ex.A1.
Thus, this evidence is no away effecting the case of the Plaintiff.
44. The learned Counsel for the 2nd, 4th and 5th Appellants in the
arguments fairly conceded that they are not disputing the execution of the
agreement, but they are disputing on the ready and willingness and other
aspects. This argument is also adopted by the other Appellants. Thus, this
Court need not dwell more on the execution of the agreement/Ex.A1 in these
circumstances. Thus, the Court inclined to hold that the Plaintiff could prove
the agreement/Ex.A1.
ii) Non-mentioning of boundaries in the agreement/Ex.A1
45. The case of the 2, 4 and 5th Appellants is that in the agreement,
there is no mentioning of the boundaries but contains only survey numbers,
also no boundaries were mentioned in the paper publication, but strangely in
the plaint the Plaintiff has mentioned the boundaries, which casts serious
doubt on the case of the Plaintiff.
46. As per the Plaintiff, the properties are in Atmakur village, all the
Defendants are villagers, the Plaintiff is also from the same village, there is no
dispute in identity of the schedule property either in the pleadings or
throughout the trial or before this Court, though the boundaries are not
mentioned in the Agreement of Sale and paper publication, this is insignificant
in the circumstances of the case.
47. The law is well settled that even oral agreement is also enforceable
(see Aloka Bose v. Parmatma Devi & Others) 1. The Court perused the
agreement/Ex.A.1. It contains signatures of the 1st to 3rd Defendants.
It
contains survey numbers for Ac.31.28 ¼ cents in Peramana village, Atmakur
Mandal. The Paper publication also contains survey numbers and other
particulars, village name.
48. The Defendants did not plead even either remotely disputing the
identification of the schedule property, what they disputed is non-mentioning
of boundaries in the agreement/Ex.A1, when there is no dispute on
identification of the property, then non-mentioning of boundaries will not effect
the case of the Plaintiff in any manner in these circumstances.
49. Further, the 1st Defendant in his evidence affidavit stated that he
and his wife separately sold the schedule property in favour of 4th to 5th
Defendants under three agreements.
50. Further, the 1st, 2nd, 4th to 6th Defendants in their written statements
and evidence, specifically stated that the 1st and 2nd Defendants sold, the 3rd
to 4th Defendants purchased the parts of the schedule property on different
dates under three agreements. Thus, these circumstances are also
supporting the case of the Plaintiff that the survey numbers mentioned in the
Agreement/Ex.A1 and in the Plaint tally with the schedule property and the
(2009) 2 SCC 582
same is clearly identifiable by all the parties before the Trial Court and even
before this Court. The Trial Court rightly rejected this contention. Thus, this
contention of the Defendants is liable to be rejected in these circumstances.
iii) On non-measuring the land
51. The case of the 2nd, 4th and 5th Appellants is that there is specific
mentioning in the agreement/Ex.A1 that the rate is fixed at Rs.2,10,000/- per
acre, the land to be measured and the balance is to be arrived as to proceed
with the agreement, whereas the Plaintiff disputed this contention on the
ground that though there is a clause for measurement, even in the absence of
the measurements, the agreement is enforceable.
52. The Court pursued the Agreement/Ex.A1, admittedly there is
mentioning of rate @ Rs.2,10,000/- per acre, the land is to be measured, the
balance is to be paid. But in the next para, there is schedule, where all the
survey numbers, village name and Mandal, total extent of 31.28 ¼ Acres and
the motors etc mentioned. The Plaintiff also issued a Paper Publication, a
Legal Notice and also mentioned in the Plaint on specific extent of 31.28 ¼ as
mentioned in the schedule of the Agreement/Ex.A1, thus the measurement of
the land is not mandatory to enforce the agreement in view of specific
mentioning of extent in the schedule of the agreement, paper publication and
legal notice. Further, the schedule of the agreement is in the conclusion para
of the agreement/Ex.A1.
53. The 2nd, 4th and 5th Appellants relied on Mayawanti Vs. Kaushalya
Devi 2, contending that there was no valid and enforceable contract and no
consensus ad idem. Wherein the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, dealing
with Section 9 of Specific Relief Act, held that Ex.PW-11/A, there are various
aspects of uncertainty, render the terms specifically unenforceable. But in
(1990) 3 SCC 1
this case the Defendants could not show any uncertainty in the
agreement/Ex.A.1 to apply the Judgment.
54. Also relied on Pydi Ramana Vs. Davarasetty Manmadha Rao 3,
contending that when there is no demand for survey and measure the
schedule land, the case for specific performance is not maintainable, wherein
the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, while examining Section 16 (c) of The
Specific Relief Act, 1963, observed that, where the date is fixed for execution
was for one year, but the plaintiff has not taken steps for three years, the suit
is filed at the fag end of expiration of limitation and also held that recital in the
agreement to survey the land, as such the total consideration was agreed to
be settled after survey. But in this case, the facts are distinguishable, further,
the Plaintiff sought for specific performance of agreement, wherein it is
specifically mentioned the extent as Ac.31.28 ¼ cents, thus, the Defendants
cannot avail the Judgments in the circumstances of the case.
55. Also relied on P. Panneerselvan Vs. A. Baylis 4, contending that
agreement cannot be enforced for want of material particulars, wherein the
Hon’ble Division Bench of Madras High Court, while dealing with the rate per
cent, fixed earlier in draft agreement was struck off and words ‘rate mutually
agreed upon individual integrity’ were substituted, no consensus between the
parties on rate per cent and extent of land agreed to be sold. But in this case
as stated supra, rate and extent is specifically agreed and mentioned in the
schedule of the agreement, thus there is no ambiguity on the rate and extent,
thus the Defendants cannot avail the Judgment in these circumstances.
56. Also relied in Penumatsa Narasimha Raju Vs. Valluri Jaya
Prakasa Babu
, contending that the plaintiff must approach with clean
AIR 2024 SC 3242 & (2024) 7 SCC 515
AIR 2006 Mad 242 & (2006) SCC OnLine Mad 406
(2006) SCC OnLine AP 34
hands, wherein, the erstwhile High Court of A.P, held a party shall come to
Court with clean hands, the party who make false allegations and does not
come with clean hands is not entitled to equitable relief. But in this case, the
Defendants could not even specifically plead or establish what are the false
contents taken by the plaintiff to show that he did not come with clean hands.
Thus, the Defendants cannot avail this Judgment.
57. Also relied on Kota Rama Rao Vs. Kolli Rajeswaramma 6 ,
contending that no responsibility fixed under the agreement for fixation of
boundaries. The erstwhile High Court of A.P, while dealing with the
agreement, nowhere mentioned it is the responsibility of the Defendants after
land demarcated, to inform the plaintiff about the fixation of boundaries and
on such fixation, the plaintiff has to pay the amount, the plaintiff did not reply
to the notice and suppressed the receipt of Ex.B.1 notice in the Suit. That
Ex.A.1/agreement indicates that the plaintiff took a plea that the Defendants
fail to get the land measured is to cover up his laches, but in this case no
such facts are there including suppression, the facts are distinguishable,
hence the Defendants cannot avail the Judgment.
58. Per contra, the Plaintiff placed reliance on C.S. Venkatesh Vs.
A.S.C. Murthy (Dead) By Legal Representatives and Others 7, contending
that there is no para-wise specific reply by the Defendants pleading that in the
absence of measurement, the extent cannot be ascertained. However, in the
present case, the agreement/Ex.A1 specifically contains specific extent of
Ac.31.28 ¼ cents as stated supra. Further, argued that there is no denial of
the bank statements with balance amount in the Bank. A general or evasive
denial is not to be treated as sufficient, but the denial must be made in a
separate line or a paragraph. The general rule is that the facts admitted need
(2005) SCC OnLine AP 289
(2020) 3 SCC 280
not be proved. In this case also, the learned counsel for the 2nd, 4th and 5th
Appellants fairly agreed on the agreement, but disputed the agreement on the
ground that plaintiff has to prove his case including boundaries, his readiness
and willingness.
59. The Court, in view of the pleadings, evidence and the law as stated
supra, is inclined to hold that even without measurement of the land, the
Plaintiff could enforce the agreement/Ex.A1 as in the agreement there is a
specific extent of 31.29 ¼ as mentioned in the schedule of the
Agreement/Ex.A1, which is in the conclusion para of the agreement, thus, the
measurement of the land is not mandatory to enforce the agreement in view
of specific mentioning of the extent and rate per acre in the schedule of the
agreement. Further, the Plaintiff also issued the Paper Publication and Legal
Notice with specific extent of land and the Plaintiff also mentioned the specific
extent of the land in the Plaint in terms of the Agreement. Thus, this
contention of the Appellants/Defendants is without merits in these
circumstances.
iv. On readiness and willingness of the Plaintiff
60. As per the Plaintiff, he has been always ready and willing to
perform his part of under the agreement/Ex.A1 with the balance sale
consideration of Rs.63,68,525/-, he also specifically pleaded and filed copies
of his and his family members Bank Statements and Pass Books/Document
No.3 to 9 along with the Plaint to show his case, which are not even disputed
by the Defendants. The Plaintiff further submits that as the Defendants did
not dispute these Bank Statements, deemed as admitted, thus, he did not
summon the Bank Manager.
61. Whereas the Defendants contend that the Plaintiff only filed copies
of Bank Statements with the Plaint, he did not exhibit the bank statements in
his evidence and did not summon the Bank Manager to prove that he is ready
and willing to perform his part under the agreement with balance sale
consideration.
62. The Trial Court relied on the evidence of PW.1 and PW.2 &
3/Attestors,
and
PW.4/Scribe,
also
the
agreement/Ex.A1,
Paper
Publication/Ex.A.2 and the legal notice/Ex.A.3 recorded a finding in favour of
the Plaintiff that he could prove that he has been always ready and willing to
perform his part under the agreement/Ex.A.1 with balance sale consideration.
63. As stated supra, the Plaintiff and the 1st Defendant know each
other, they are also from the same village. The 1st Defendant specifically
pleaded in his written statement that at first instance, that the Plaintiff
approached him and his wife/1st and 2nd Defendants, he has expressed his
willingness to purchase the property but the negotiations failed regarding the
fixation of sale price and other aspects. Also pleaded that the Plaintiff was
unable to satisfy them to show his capacity to pay such huge amount of the
sale consideration and they refused to sell.
64. This version of the 1st and 2nd Defendants show that there were
negotiations to purchase the schedule property, but the later version of 1st
and 2nd Defendants is that the negotiations were failed on sale price and
other aspects, also that the Plaintiff has no capacity to pay such huge amount
of the sale consideration, so they refused to sell. Thus, as they are known to
each other, who are from the same locality, generally after knowing the
capacity only, the negotiations will start. The execution of the agreement is
also admitted as stated supra.
65. The Plaintiff placed reliance on C.S. Venkatesh case supra,
contending that there is no para-wise specific reply by the Defendants on the
bank statements on balance amount in the Bank Accounts filed along with the
Plaint. A general or evasive denial has not to be treated as sufficient. The
denial must be made in a separate line or a paragraph. The general rule is
that the facts admitted need not be proved. In this case also the learned
counsel for the 2, 4 and 5th Appellants fairly agreed on the agreement as
stated supra but disputes the Plaintiff’s readiness and willingness with
balance sale consideration.
66. The 1st to 3rd Defendants did not specifically deny in the Written
Statement on the Bank Statements and the balance amount with the Plaintiff
by those Bank Statements, except evasive denial.
67. The evidence of PW.1, PW.2 and PW.3/Attestors, PW.5/Scribe is
consistent that the Plaintiff has been ready and willing to perform his part
under the agreement with balance sale consideration.
68. The Court perused the cross examination of PW.1 to PW.4, where
the Defendants put a general suggestion that he/Plaintiff is not ready and
willing to perform his part under the agreement with balance sale
consideration, which is denied.
The Defendants cross examined them at
length but could not elicit any material remotely to discredit their version. The
Defendants also did not cross examine PW.1 to PW.4 either on the Bank
Statements or on his properties or on his resources to discredit his version
either on his capacity or not ready and willing to perform his part with the
balance sale consideration..
69. The 2nd, 4th and 5th Appellants
relied
on
Veeramareddy
Nagabhushana Rao Vs. Jyothula Venkateswara Rao 8 , wherein, the
Hon’ble Coordinate Bench of this Court, observed that the Defendant in the
written statement denied the plaint averments agreeing to sell the schedule
property and never executed the agreement and the Defendant has failed to
prove the suit agreement of sale and same is fabricated and all other
defences taken by him such as readiness and willingness, the suit cannot be
refused and it is otherwise legal and justified to do so. It relied on Sheikh
2010 SCC OnLine AP 931
Abdual Satta Vs. Union of India, it was held that specific denial of the plaint
averments will not be necessary if the plaint averments are adequately dealt
within the additional pleadings.
70. The proposition of law is not applicable to the present facts of the
case, as the facts are distinguishable, and in the arguments, the execution of
the agreement is admitted, there is no specific denial by the Defendants on
the balance amount in the bank statements, which are filed along with the
Plaint.
71. Also relied on U.N. KrishnaMurthy (Since Deceased) through
Legal Representatives Vs. A.M. Krishnamurthy 9, contending that plaintiff
has to prove sufficient funds or in a position to raise the funds in time to
discharge the obligation under the contract. Wherein the Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India, observed that the plaintiff has to make specific averments in
the plaint and to adduce evidence and to show the availability of funds to
make payments in terms of the contract.
Further, it is observed that the
plaintiff’s balance sheet did not have sufficient funds to discharge his part of
contract, deposit of balance consideration after lapse of seven years would
not establish that he is ready to discharge his part of contract and observed
that the plaintiff was possible to buy the time to discharge his part of contract.
72. Also relied on B. Rajamani Vs. Mrs. Azhar Sultana and others 10,
contending that mere mentioning of words readiness and willingness in a
mechanical manner would not be sufficient. Wherein, the erstwhile High Court
of A.P, held that the discretion is to be exercised in reasonable and inarbitrary
manner and further observed that plaintiff choose to issue legal notice on or
about completion of three years from the date of agreement. But the
(2023) 11 SCC 775
AIR 2005 AP 260 & (2004) SCC OnLine AP 1004
Defendant purchased the property under the Ex.B.1 on 31.10.1981 and he is
in possession and enjoyment of the property for the last more than 20 years.
73. Also relied on U.N. KrishnaMurthy (Since Deceased) through
Legal Representatives Vs. A.M. Krishnamurthy
, contending that
payment of insignificant advance and readiness and willingness shall be
proved by the plaintiff. Wherein, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India,
considered the payment of Rs.10,001 out of sale consideration of
Rs.15,10,000/-, depositing the balance sale consideration after seven years.
That the Plaintiff’s balance sheet showing that he did not have sufficient funds
to discharge his part of contract. But the facts are distinguishable. In this
case, plaintiff also filed bank statement along with the plaint which are not
disputed by the Defendants.
74. Also relied on HIS Holiness Acharya Swami Ganesh Dassji Vs.
Sita Ram Thapar 12 , contending distinction between readiness and
willingness.
75. The proposition of law as cited supra is not applicable to the
present facts of the case, as the facts are distinguishable, further, the Plaintiff
could prove his case, and further in the arguments, the execution of the
agreement is admitted, the Plaintiff’s case is consistent on ready and willing
to perform his part with balance sale consideration and further there is no
specific denial by the Defendants on the balance amount in the bank
statements filed along with the Plaint.
Further, the Plaintiff immediately
issued paper publication and issued the legal notice and filed the suit. All
these took place within months from the date of the agreement. So, the facts
are entirely different in the present case. Thus the Defendants cannot avail
the law stated supra in facts and circumstances of the case.
AIR 2022 SUPREME COURT 3361 & (2023) 11 SCC 775
(1996) 4 SCC 526
76. Also relied on Punjab Urban Planning & Development Authority
Vs. Shiv Saraswti Iron & Steel Re-Rolling Mills 13 , contending that the
plaintiff must succeed or fail in his own case, and cannot take advantage of
weakness in the Defendants case to get a decree. The Hon’ble Supreme
Court of India while dealing with Section 7 of Specific Relief Act, observed
that no effort has been made to explain what according to business
terminology was meant by supply of the steel weight to weight.
77. In this case, the Defendants could not demonstrate that the Plaintiff
relied on weakness of the case of the Defendants, the facts are
distinguishable. Thus, the Defendants cannot avail the said Judgment.
78. Also relied on Pudi Lazarus Vs. Rev. Johnson Edward and
others 14, contending that wrongful repudiation of contract by Defendant and
that the plaintiff not absolved from performing conditions precedent. But in
this case, no such repudiation taken place, the facts situation is entirely
different in the present case.
79. The Respondent relied on Thangam and Another Vs. Navamani
Ammal 15, contending that the words ready and willingness implies that the
plaintiff was ready to carry out those parts of contract to their logical end. The
Court must take into consideration the conduct of the plaintiff prior and
subsequent to filing of the suit along with attending circumstances. From the
date of execution of contract till the date of decree, he must prove that he is
ready and willing to perform his part of contract.
80. The Court, in view of the pleadings, evidence and the law as stated
supra, inclined to hold that the evidence of the Plaintiff as stated supra is
consistent, he could prove that he has been always ready and willing to
perform his part under the agreement with balance sale consideration. Thus
(1998) 4 SCC 539
AIR 1976 AP 243 & (1975) SCC OnLine AP 139
(2024) 4 SCC 247
this contention of the Appellants/Defendants is without merit in these
circumstances.
IX. O.S.Nos.59, 62 and 78 of 2007, suits for Specific Performance
81. The case of the Plaintiffs in these 3 suits (who are the 4th to 6th
Defendants in O.S.No.49 of 2007), that they purchased the schedule property
by three agreements much prior to the agreement of the Plaintiff in O.S.No.49
of 2007, they are always ready and willing to perform part of their contract
with balance sale consideration, they also issued Paper Publication and legal
notice to the 1st& 2ndDefendants in the three suits.
82. The case of the 2nd Defendant (who is the Plaintiff in O.S.No.49 of
2007) that after his agreement of the sale/Ex.A.1 with the 1st to 3rd
Defendants, the 1st to 6th Defendants, colluded and got fabricated three
agreements i.e., the 1st Defendant fabricated two agreements in favour of the
4th and 6th Defendants and the 2nd Defendant fabricated an agreement in
favour of the 5th Defendant, as to deprive his rights under the
agreement/Ex.A1.
83. The 1st and 2nd Defendants filed Written Statements initially on
07.09.2007 wherein they did not allege even remotely about alienation of the
schedule property in favour of the 4th to 6th Defendants.
84. But the 1st and 2nd Defendants in O.S.No.49 of 2007, filed
Additional Written Statements dated 26.04.2010, wherein the 1st Defendant,
first time stated that on 25.11.2006 he executed an agreement of sale for an
extent of Ac.7.67 Cents in favour of one Mekala Chandra Sekhar Reddy for
consideration of Rs.11,50,500/- and he received an advance of Rs.50,000/from him. That the said Mekala Chandra Sekhar Reddy failed to pay the
balance sale consideration and failed to get the register sale deed, he also
filed the Suit O.S.No.59 of 2007 and the same is pending. The 1st Defendant
also pleaded that on 06.01.2007, he executed another agreement of sale for
an extent of Ac.13.55 cents in favour of one Mekala Venkata Subba Reddy
for consideration of Rs.23,71,250/- and he received an advance of
Rs.50,000/- from him. The said Mekala Venkata Subba Reddy failed to pay
the balance sale consideration and he also filed the Suit in O.S.No.78 of 2007
and same is pending.
85. The 2nd Defendant filed the additional written statement on
26.04.2010, wherein the 2ndDefendant, first time pleaded that on 29.11.2006,
she executed an agreement of sale for part of the schedule property in favour
of one Mekala Siva Pratap Reddy for Rs.14,14,400/- and received an
advance of Rs.50,000/-. The said Mekala Siva Pratap Reddy failed to pay the
balance sale consideration, he filed the Suit O.S.No.62 of 2007 and the same
is pending.
X. On date of execution of the agreements and issuance of Stamps
86. The Plaintiff got examined, PW.5/Gattupalli Srinivasa Murali, the
Senior Account, Sub Treasury Office, he deposed that he received summons,
he can identify signature of Sub Treasury Officer in Ex.A.1. M. Balaji Singh is
the Stamp Vendor of Kovvur. He brought the Issuance Register of
16.12.2006. The Office sold 300 stamps to M. Balaji Singh from C-625001 to
C-625300 pertaining to Ex.B.15. Ex.X.2 is the relevant entry in Page No.21
dated 16.12.2006 in the name of M. Balaji Singh. The denomination of
stamps issue watch register from pages 1 to 100 is certificated by the Sub
Treasury Office, Kovur. The 1st to 3rd defendant cross examined, he deposed
that he has not connection with the branch of Sharabu and stamps issuance
register. The 4th to 6th Defendants cross examined him and he stated that he
brought the petition filed by the Plaintiff under Right to Information Act but he
did not bring the indent as it was not summoned.
87. This evidence is very crucial, which is not even denied by the 1st to
6th Defendants. But their version is that agreement is dated 06.01.2007 on
stamp paper No.C625169/Ex.B.1, another agreement is dated 29.11.2006 on
stamp paper No.C625097/Ex.B.15 and agreement is dated 25.11.2006 on
stamp paper No.B714597/Ex.B.20. But as per the evidence of PW.5 and
Ex.X.1 and Ex.X.2, Ex.B.15 and B.20 are ante dated 29.11.2006 and
25.11.2006 respectively i.e., prior to issuance of the stamps to the Stamp
Vendor on 16.12.2006 in the Registrar’s Office.
88. As per Ex.X.1/RTI information, Rs.100 stamps, C625169 &
C625097 is issued on 16.12.2006 and B714597 is issued on 14.09.2006,
infavour of M Balaji Singh, Stamp Vendor. As per Ex.X.2, relevant entry in
the register, on 14.09.2006 stamps from B714001 to B714600, 600 stamps
and on 16.12.2006 stamps from C625001 to 625300, 300 stamps, are issued
to M Balaji Singh. The Defenants did not seriously dispute issuance of the
stamps from the Registrar’s Office on the said dates.
89. The Defendants examined DW.7/P. Vinaya Gopal, Senior
Assistant, Sub Registrar Office, Nellore District. He was summoned and he
was authorized to give evidence on behalf of Sub Registrar. Ex.Z.1 is the
stamp issuance of registrar relating to M. Balaji Singh, Stamps Vendor of
Kovur for the year 2006. Ex.Z.2 is the stamp issuance register relating to M.
Balaji Singh, Stamps Vendor of Kovur for the year 2007. Ex.Z.3 is the
relevant entry dated 25.11.2006 in Ex.Z.1, stamp issuance register relating to
selling of hundred rupee stamp by the stamp vendor Balaji Singh to Makala
Chandra Sekhar Reddy (4th Defendant), contains the signature of 4th
Defendant in Ex.Z.3. The said stamp number B 714597 which tallies with
Ex.B.20 stamp number. Ex.Z.4 is the relevant entry dated 29.11.2006 in
Ex.Z.1 register evidencing the selling of stamp number B 714594 to Mekala
Siva Pratap Reddy/5th Defendant. It contains the signature of the 5th
defendant. Ex.Z.5 is the relevant entry dated 06.01.2007 in Ex.Z.2, stamp
register selling of N.J stamp C 625169 to Mekala Venkata Subba Reddy/6th
Defendant. Ex.B.1 number date, name of the purchaser are tallying with
Ex.Z.5 entries.
90. In his/DW.7 cross examination, he stated that the above registers
are submitted by the M. Balaji Singh, stamp vendor, but Ex.Z.1 and Z.2
Registers did not contain his signature, also no endorsement evidencing
receipt of the registers. Also stated that on Ex.B.1, B.15 & B.20, there is no
seal, license number and stamp vendor name.
91. This evidence clearly show that Ex.B.15 and B.20dated 29.11.2006
and 25.11.2006 respectively, they are ante dated i.e., prior to issuing of the
stamps in the Registrar’s Office on 16.12.2006, which is also fairly conceded
by the learned Appellant Nos.2, 4 and 5 in the arguments in A.S.No.527 of
2013, this argument is also adopted by the learned counsel for the Appellants
in other 4 appeals.
92. Further, the Defendants summoned DW.7, summoned on the
registers said to be submitted by the said M. Balaji Singh, Stamp Vendor,
which is self serving and will not have authenticity in view of Ex.X.2 Register,
maintained in the Registrar’s Office, the same will have authenticity and the
same shall be taken into consideration in these circumstanes, further the
same is not disputed by the Defendants in their cross examination as stated
supra.
93. The 1st Defendant/DW.1 in his cross examination by the Plaintiff,
stated that the 4th to 6th Defendants are from his village and they are one
family. This showsthat they are all from the same village. Further, DW.1
admitted in his cross examination that the 4th Defendant used to attend the
Court along with him and that he and the 4th Defendant/Chandra Sekhar
Reddy were present before his/1st Defendant Advocate while preparing his
written statement. This shows that the 4th Defendant not only accompanied
the 1st Defendant but also he was present before his/DW.1’s Advocate while
preparation of his/DW.1’s written statement.
Further DW.1 his evidence
stated that the 4th to 6th Defendants also saw the paper publication, which are
not even disputed by the 4th to 6th Defendants in their cross examination of
DW.1. When the Paper Publication of the Plaintiff was seen by the 4th to 6th
Defendants, the question of entering into agreements by them makes the
case of the Defendants is highly improbale. Further, this part of evidence of
the 1st Defendant show that all the Defendants colluded and conducted the
suits.
94. Further, DW.1 in his cross examination stated that the stamp
vendor of the three agreements belongs to their village. Also the attestors and
scribe of the three agreements in favour of 4th to 6th Defendant are also from
same. Further, DW.2 in his cross examination admitted that all the attestors
in Ex.B.1 and other two agreements in favour of the 4th and 6th Defendants
are the same persons. This circumstance also supporting the case of the
Plaintiff.
95. DW.2/Mekala Venakata Subba Reddy/5th defendant filed evidence
affidavit, denying the agreement/Ex.A.1 of the plaintiff in O.S.No.49 of 2007,
stating that on 06.01.2007, he purchased Ac.13.55 cents under the
agreement of sale from Thota Gopal @ Gopalaiah/1st Defendant, for
Rs.23,71,250/-, rate per acre at Rs.1,75,000/-, he paid Rs.50,000/- as earnest
money, the balance to be paid within three months, he is ready and willing to
pay the balance and he also demanded the 1st Defendant, but he did not
come forward and he got issued legal notice on 17.02.2007 demanding him
to receive the balance of sale consideration and to execute the registered
sale deed but he did not respond. He came to know that 1st Defendant was
going to sell the property, on 30.04.2007 he issued paper publication in
Prajashakthi daily newspaper. His son/Mekala Chandra Sekhar Reddy/4th
Defendant also purchased an extent of Ac.7.67 cents from the 1st Defendant
by an agreement of sale dated 25.11.2006 and his younger son/Mekala Siva
Prathap Reddy/6th Defendant purchased Ac.8.85 ¼ cents from the 2nd
Defendant by agreement of sale dated 29.11.2006. They filed three suits for
specific performance. That prior to the execution of agreement dated
20.01.2007/Ex.A.1 in favour of the Plaintiff by 1st to 3rd Defendants, the 1st
and 2nd Defendants sold the schedule property to him and his two sons. DW.4
and DW.5 also filed evidence affidavits on the same lines.
96. The 1st to 3rd Defendants cross examined DW.2 just with a
suggestion, suggesting that he did not have balance sale consideration to go
for registration, he denied the same. Thus, this also suggests collusion.
97. The Plaintiff in OS.49 of 2007 cross examined him/DW.2, he stated
that Ex.B.1 stamp was purchased on in his name on 06.01.2007 and he
purchased the stamps in the name of his son (5th defendant) dated
29.11.2006. He did not know whether the case was registered against Balaji
Singh, Stamp Vendor for selling stamps with anti date and the case also
covered stamps under their agreements.
This version of DW.2 also
supporting the case of the Plaintiff.
98. DW.3/6th Defendant, who was doing Engineering Job, in his cross
examination stated that he did not know the writings in Ex.B.1, B.15 and
agreement/Ex.B20 dated 25.11.2006 are with one pen and executed at the
same time. This part of admitting in his cross examination is supporting the
case of the Plaintiff in O.S.No.49 of 2007 that on collusion, the three
agreements are executed at one point of time.
99. DW.3/6th Defendant in his cross examination admitted that he and
2nd defendant filed compromise memo to refer the matter to Lok Adalath. He
denied the suggestion that he, his brother and father colluded with 1st to 3rd
defendant and got fabricated Ex.B.1, B.15 and agreement of sale dated
29.11.2006 subsequent to paper publication to defeat the plaintiff rights.
This compromise memo also suggests the collusion theory of the Plaintiff in
O.S.No.49 of 2007, when all these matters are pending, going for
compromise of this suit generally not permissible.
100. DW.3 in his cross examination stated that he was working as
Junior Engineer in the Central Public Works Department of Central
Government during 2005 to 2008. He is an income tax assessee and he did
not show purchase of lands in his I.T returns.
Also he did not inform
purchase of lands under Ex.B.20 to his employer. Generally, when he was a
public servant, he would take permission, the purchase and payment will also
reflect in his IT returns. But he did not explain, why he did not show the
transaction to his employeer and in his I.T returns. This part of evidence is
also supporting the case of the Plaintiff in OS.49 of 2007 on collusion.
101. DW.3 in his cross examination stated that he was on leave on
25.11.2006 but he cannot produce any evidence to show that he was on
leave.
This circumstances also suggesting in favour of the Plaintiff on
collusion theory.
102. DW.4/4th Defendant in his cross examination stated that he
purchased the land at the rate of Rs.1,50,000/- per acre, his brother Siva
Prasad Reddy purchased at the rate of Rs.1,60,000/- per acre, his father
purchased at the rate of Rs.1,70,000/- per acre. This part of evidence is also
supporting the case of the Plaintiff in OS.49 of 2007 as his evidence is that he
purchased the land at Rs.2,10,000/- per acre, but under the alleged three
agreements, the sale consideration per acre is low, this circumstances is also
not explained by the Defendants.
103. DW.5/Challa Sreenivasulu Reddy and DW.6/Giddaluri Narayana
Rao, said to be attestor and scribe, they filed evidence affidavit stating that on
25.11.2006, the 1stDefendant executed the agreement in favour of the 4th
defendant. That on 29.11.2006, the 2nd defendant sold a part of the schedule
property in favour of 6th defendant. That on 06.01.2007, the 1st defendant sold
part of the schedule property to the 5th defendant.
That during these
transactions, they, the Defendants and G Krishna Reddy were present. The
evidence on record clearly suggests that these agreements are executed with
the same attestors and scribe on the same day with the same pen.
104. Thus, the evidence on record reveals that the agreements under
Ex.B15 and B.15 are fabricated with ante-dates of 29.11.2006 and
25.11.2006 respectively by the 1st and 2nd Defendant in the name of 4th and
6th Defendants respectively i.e., much prior to even issuance of the stamps to
the Stamp Vendor on 16.12.2006 in the Registrar’s Office. The same is also
fairly conceded by the learned counsel for Appellants as stated supra.
Further these three agreements/Ex.B1, B15 and B20 are attested and scribed
by the same persons. The Plaintiff’s case is that these three agreements are
executed on the same day written with the same pen, as the DW.3/6th
Defendant, who was doing a high profile job as stated supra, in his cross
examination specifically stated that he did not know the writings in Ex.B.1,
B.15, agreement/Ex.B20 dated 25.11.2006 are with one pen and executed at
the same point in time. This version also supporting the theory of the Plaintiff.
105. Further, the evidence on record clearly shows as stated supra that
the 4th Defendant not only accompanied the 1st Defendant, but also he was
present before his/DW.1’s Advocate while preparing DW.1’s written
statement, that the 4th to 6th Defendants also saw the paper publication, these
are not even disputed by the 4th to 6th Defendants in their cross examination
of DW.1. These show that the Defendants, attestors and scribe are colluded
and fabricated the agreements as stated supra.
106. Thus, the suits in OS.Nos.59, 62 and 78 of 2007, suits for Specific
Performance are filed with false pleadings and fabricated agreements/Ex.B1,
15 and B20 as stated supra. Thus the suits are liable to be dismissed. The
Trial Court, rightly observed all the above circumstances and dismissed the
suits.
107. Thus, A.S.Nos.527 of 2013 and A.S.No.623 of 2013 are liable to
be dismissed with costs.
108. The Appellants in AS.Nos.530, 646 & 656 of 2013 did not take
steps to implead the legal representatives of 1st Defendant/T Gopal, who died
during pendency of the Appeal, as impleaded in A.S.No.527 of 2003, thus
they are liable to be dismissed as abated in these circumstances.
v. Law on making a false document etc.,
109. Section 464 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (Sec.335 of BNS),
which provides an illustration, to cover the issue of ante dating of an
instrument/document, which is extracted hereunder: “464. Making a false document: A person is said to make a
false document or false electronic record……….
(h) A sells and conveys an estate to Z. A afterwards, in order
to defraud Z of his estate, executes a conveyance of the
same estate to B, dated six months earlier than the date of
the conveyance to Z, intending it to
be believed that he
had conveyed the estate to B before he conveyed it to Z. A
has committed forgery.”
110. Section 467 of IPC, provides imprisonment for life or term which
may extend upto 10 years and fine, for forging valuable security (agreement,
deed etc), a Will, authority to adopt a son, transfer any valuable security, an
acquittance or receipt acknowledging the payment of money or acquittance or
receipt for the delivery of any movable property or valuable security etc..
111. The Hon’ble Constitution Bench of Hon’ble Supreme Court of
India in Iqbal Singh Marwah & another Vs Meenakshi Marwah 16, held that
if any agreement, sale deed, Will, Valuable Security etc., is out of forgery or
forged document, the bar created by Section 195(1)(b)(ii) Cr.P.C would not
(2005) 4 SCC 370
come into play and there is no embargo on the power of the Court to take
cognizance of the offence on the basis of the Report by Police/Complaint filed
by the Respondents.
112. The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in State of Punjab Vs Raj
Singh and Another 17, while examining powers of Court and Police, under
Section 154 and 195 of Criminal Procedure Code, held that statutory power of
police to investigate under the Code is not controlled or circumscribed by
Section 195 Cr.P.C which operates at a stage when a Court intends to take
cognizance of offence under section 190(1) Cr.P.C, the Hon’ble Supreme
Court accordingly quashed the Order of High Court for quashing F.I.R
registered under Sections 419, 420, 467 and 468, I.P.C.
113. Thus, the Plaintiff in O.S.No.49 of 2007 is at liberty to prosecute all
the
conspirators
under
Section
of
IPC
for
fabricating
the
agreements/Ex.B.15 and Ex.B.20 with ante dates, by lodging a report with
jurisdiction Police.
vi. The law on fling of suits with fabricated agreement and false
pleas:
114. The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Ramrameshwari Devi &
others Vs Nirmala Devi & others 18 , dealing with suits for Partition and
Mandatory Injunction & mesne profits, held that the existing system can be
drastically changed or improved if the following steps are taken by the Trial
Courts while dealing with the civil trials, also held how unscrupulous litigants
are harassing the innocent parties, extracted hereunder:
“This is a classic example which abundantly depicts the
picture of how the civil litigation moves in our Courts and how
unscrupulous litigants (appellants in this case) can till eternity
(1998) 2 SCC 391
(2011) 8 SCC 249
harass the respondents and their children by abusing the
judicial system.
52. C. Imposition of actual, realistic or proper costs and/or
ordering prosecution would go a long way in controlling the
tendency of introducing false pleadings and forged and
fabricated documents by the litigants. Imposition of heavy
costs would also control unnecessary adjournments by the
parties. In appropriate cases the Courts may consider
ordering prosecution otherwise it may not be possible to
maintain purity and sanctity of judicial proceedings.”
115. The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in T. Arivandandam v.
T.V. Satyapal & Anr 19, while dealing with exercise power under order VII
Rule 11 of the CPC, if clever drafting has created the illusion of a cause of
action, nip it in the bud, that an activist judge is the answer to irresponsible
law suits, that Chapter – XI of IPC (Chapter – XI, of false evidence and
offences against public justice, which include Giving or fabricating false
evidence. Fraudulent removal, concealment, transfer of property to prevent its
seizure as forfeited or in execution. Fraudulent claim to property to prevent its
seizure as forfeited or in execution. Fraudulently suffering decree for sum not
due. Dishonestly making false claim in Court, and Fraudulently obtaining
decree for sum not due etc), is resourceful to meet such men and must be
triggered, that a Judge who succumbs to ex parte pressure in unmerited
cases helps devalue the judicial process, which are extracted hereunder: “5. We have not the slightest hesitation in condemning the
petitioner for the gross
abuse of the process of the court
repeatedly and unrepentently resorted to. From the
statement of the facts found in the judgment of the High
Court, it is perfectly plain that the suit now pending before
the First Munsif's Court, Bangalore, is a flagrant misuse of
the mercies of the law in receiving plaints. The learned
Munsif must remember that if on a meaningful — not formal
— reading of the plaint it is manifestly vexatious, and
meritless, in the sense of not disclosing a clear right to sue,
he should exercise his power under Order 7, Rule 11 CPC
(1977) 4 SCC 467
taking care to see that the ground mentioned therein is
fulfilled. And, if clever drafting
has created the illusion of
a cause of action, nip it in the bud at the first hearing by
examining the party searchingly under Order 10, CPC. An
activist Judge is the answer to irresponsible law suits. The
trial courts would insist imperatively on examining the party
at the first hearing so that bogus litigation can be shot down
at the earliest stage. The Penal Code is also resourceful
enough to meet such men, (Cr. XI) and must be triggered
against them. In this case, the learned Judge to his cost
realised what George Bernard Shaw remarked on the
assassination of Mahatma Gandhi: “It is dangerous to be too
good.”
116. The Hon’ble three Judge bench of Hon’ble Supreme Court of
India in Re: suo moto proceedings against Mr. R. Karuppan, Advocate 20,
while dealing with an affidavit with false averments in support of Writ Petition.
The Hon’ble Court observed the menace of perjury and ordered to file
Complaint U/s.193 of IPC, the same is extracted here under: “.............Courts are entrusted with the powers of
dispensation and adjudication of justice of the rival claims of
the parties besides determining the criminal liability of the
offenders for offences committed against the society. The
courts are further expected to do justice quickly and
impartially not being biased by any extraneous
considerations. Justice dispensation system would bewrecked if statutory restrictions are hot imposed upon the
litigants, who attempt to mislead the court by filing and
relying upon the false evidence particularly in cases, the
adjudication of which is dependent upon the statement of
facts. If the result of the proceedings are to be respected,
these issues before the courts must be resolved to the
extent possible in accordance with the truth: The purity of
proceedings of the court cannot be permitted to be sullied by
a party on frivolous, vexatious or insufficient grounds or
relying upon false evidence inspired by extraneous
considerations or revengeful desire to harass or spite his
opponent. Sanctity of the affidavits has to be preserved and
protected discouraging the filing of irresponsible statements,
without any regard to accuracy.
In India, law relating to the Offence of perjury is given a
statutory definition under Section 191 and Chapter XI of the
(2001) 5 SCC 289
Indian Penal Code, incorporated to deal with the offences
relating to giving false evidence against public justice. The
offences incorporated under this Chapter are based upon
recognition of the decline of moral values and erosion of
sanctity of oath. Unscrupulous litigants are found daily
resorting to utter blatant falsehood in the courts which has, to
some extent, resulted in polluting the judicial system. It is a
fact, though unfortunate, that a general impression is created
that most of the witnesses coming in the courts despite
taking oath make false statements to suit the interests of the
parties calling them. Effective and stern action is required to
be taken for preventing the evil of perjury, conceitedly let
loose by vested interest and professional litigants. The mere
existence of the penal provisions to deal with perjury would
be a cruel joke with the society unless the courts stop to take
an evasive recourse despite proof of the commission of the
offence under Chapter XI of the Indian Penal Code. If the
system is to survive, effective action is the need of the
time...”
117.The Hon’ble three Judge bench of Hon’ble Supreme Court of
India in Salem Advocate Bar Association, Tamil Nadu Vs. Union of
India 21while dealing with amendments to Code of Civil Procedure, observed
on initiation of perjury in appropriate cases, they were extracted here under: “9. Proceedings for Perjury :
If the Trial Judge, while delivering the judgment, is of the view
that any of the parties or witnesses have willfully and
deliberately uttered blatant falsehoods, he shall consider (at
least in some grave cases) whether it is a fit case where
prosecution should be initiated for perjury and order
prosecution accordingly.”
118.Thus, when a Party or witness, who filed a forged or fabricated
document and makes a false statement or declaration or gives false evidence
or fabricates false evidence, they are liable under Section 193 of IPC (which
(2005) 6 SCC 344
provides punishment, which may extend to seven years, and shall also be
liable to fine) r/w 191 or 192 of IPC as per law depending on the facts of the
case.
119.In view of the material and law as stated supra, the Court is
opinion, that the 1st, 2nd, 4th to 6th Defendants, DW.5 and DW.6 have
fabricated the agreements/Ex.B15 and B20 and submitted false pleas and
evidence. Thus, it is expedient in the interest of justice that they are liable for
prosecution for committing the Offence for producing the agreements and
giving false evidence in the Suits and also asserting them in these Appeals.
Thus, they are liable for prosecution under Section 193 of IPC. As the 1st
Defendant died during the pendency of the Appeal, the prosecution against
him is abated.
vii.The Appellants undertaking before this Court
120. The record shows that on 29.04.2022, the learned Senior Counsel
for the Appellants has submitted that the person who had executed the
mortgage is no more alive. However, it was submitted that till the next date,
the appellants shall not encumber the property in any manner.
121. The proceeding sheet dated 10.05.2023 shows that there was
undertaking that the property will not be alienated. However, it is admitted in
the affidavit that Document Nos.4821 of 2022 and 4800 of 2022 were already
executed.
122.The Memo filed by the Plaintiff along with the registered sale
deeds show, that the sale deed vide Doc.No.4800 of 2022 dated 12.12.2022
was executed by Thota Lalitha @ Lalithamma and Thota Sravanthi in favour
of Paidala Thirupathi Reddy and Paidala Balaram Reddy. Another registered
sale deed vide Document No.4821 of 2022 dated 12.12.2022 was executed
by Thota Lalitha @ Lalithamma and Thota Sravanthi in favour of Paidala
Thirupathi Reddy and Paidala Balaram Reddy.
123. This Memo shows that the 2nd Defendant along with her son and
daughter sold the property, which is in violation of the Order. But the
proceeding sheet dated 10.05.2023 also shows that the Co-ordinate Bench,
observed that the issue of contempt is left out.
124. Still the issue survives in the final adjudication in the Appeal, as
the undertaking by the Appellants is that they shall not encumber the
property, which is breached as they sold the schedule property during
pendency of these Appeals, will be discussed and answered herein after.
viii. Law on fraud on the Court and lis pendency
125.The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India inCELIR LLP Vs MR.
SUMATI PRASAD BAFNA & others 22 , relied on Sanjay Verma v. Manik
Roy, (2006) 13 SCC 608, while dealing with contempt, observed that the
Contempt Petitioner was auction purchaser in SARFAESI proceedings by
Union Bank of India, later the Borrower filed Writ and the same is allowed to
redeem the mortgage of the secured asset, aggrieved by the Writ order the
Auction purchaser filed SLP, the Borrower redeemed the mortgage, created
second charge over the secured asset in favour of TATA Motors Financial
Solutions Ltd for 15 crore, the Borrower also entered into an Agreement of
Assignment of Leasehold Rights with a third-party viz. M/s Greenscape I.T.
Park LLP i.e. the Subsequent Transferee herein for the transfer of leasehold
rights in the Secured Asset. Held that no party can claim exemption of
doctrine of lis pendens on the ground of bona fide or good faith. Also relied
on Thomson Press (India) Limited v. Nanak Builders and Investors Private
Limited & others, (2013) 5 SCC 397, transfers not render void, the transfer
remains valid subject, of course, to the result of the suit. The pendente lite
purchaser would be entitled to or suffer the same legal rights and obligations
2024 Supreme SC 1187
of his vendor as may be eventually determined by the Court. The Court held
in contempt jurisdiction, Court can reverse the transaction or to proceed to
pass appropriate directions to the concerned Authorities to ensure the
Contemnor or anyone claiming under him does not continue to ensure the
advantage. Also held the Assignment Agreement dated 28.08.2023 is hit by
lis pendens and declared void, directed the Subsequent Transferee to hand
over the peaceful physical possession of the Secured Asset along with its
original title deeds to the Bank within a period of one week, also directed the
Bank shall take assistance of Police in the event of any further hindrance or
any obstruction that may be caused by the Borrower or the Subsequent
Transferee while taking over the possession of the property etc. and the
Subsequent Transferee is at liberty to recover the amount paid by it towards
the Assignment Agreement dated 28.08.2023 and any other amount from the
Borrower by availing appropriate legal remedy as may be available under the
law, they are extracted hereunder: “180.Thus, although Section 52 of the Act 1882 does not
render a transfer pendente lite void yet the court while
exercising contempt jurisdiction may be justified to pass
directions either for reversal of the transactions in question
by declaring the said transactions to be void or proceed to
pass appropriate directions to the concerned authorities to
ensure that the contumacious conduct on the part of the
contemnor does not continue to enure to the advantage of
the contemnor or anyone claiming under him.
181.Since in the present case, the Assignment Agreement
dated 28.08.2023 whereby the Secured
Asset
was
transferred in favour of Greenscape / the Subsequent
Transferee herein was effected by the Borrower on the
strength of its right of redemption pursuant to the High
Court’s impugned order which was ultimately set-aside by
this Court in its judgment and order dated 21.09.2023 in the
Main Appeals, the same rendered Borrower’s right to transfer
the Secured Asset non-est and by extension the Assignment
Agreement void.
222.Similarly, a Three-Judge Bench of this Court in the case
of State Bank of India & Ors. v. Dr. Vijay Mallya reported in
2022 SCC Online SC 826, in clear terms said that apart from
punishing the contemnor for his contumacious conduct, the
majesty of law may demand that appropriate directions be
issued by the Court so that any advantage secured as a
result of such contumacious conduct is completely nullified.
The approach may require the Court to issue directions
either for reversal of the transactions in question by declaring
said transactions to be void or passing appropriate directions
to the concerned authorities to see that the contumacious
conduct on the part of the contemnor does not continue to
enure to the advantage of the contemnor or anyone claiming
under him.
223. In view of the aforesaid, we pass the following orders
and directions:
…………………………………………………………………….
iv) The Assignment Agreement dated 28.08.2023 is hit by lis
pendens and hereby declared
void. The Subsequent
Transferee shall hand over the peaceful physical possession
of the Secured Asset along with its original title deeds to the
Bank within a period of one week from the date of
pronouncement of this judgment. In the event of any further
hindrance or any obstruction that may be caused by the
Borrower or the Subsequent Transferee while taking over the
possession of the property then in such circumstances the
Bank shall take the assistance of police.
(v) The Subsequent Transferee shall also withdraw the
police complaint dated 17.01.2024 lodged by it within a
period of one week from the date of pronouncement of this
judgment.
(vi) We clarify that the Subsequent Transferee is not entitled
to recover the amount paid by it towards redeeming the
second charge over the Secured Asset or any other dues or
amount paid in respect of the same from the petitioner
herein.
(vii) The Bank shall refund the amount of Rs. 129 crore paid
by the Borrower towards the redemption of mortgage without
any interest only after the aforesaid directions have been
complied to the letter and spirit.
(viii) The Subsequent Transferee is at liberty to recover the
amount paid by it towards the
Assignment
Agreement
dated 28.08.2023 and any other amount from the Borrower
by availing appropriate legal remedy as may be available
under the law.”
126. The Hon’ble Supreme Court of Inida in S.P. Chengalvaraya
Naidu (dead) & others Vs Jagannath (dead) By L.Rs. and another 23,
(1994) 1 SCC 1,while setting aside the preliminary decree in a partition suit,
held the decree obtained by fraud on the Court is nullity, has to be treated as
a nullity by every court, can be challenged even in a collateral proceeding,
withholding a vital document amounts to playing fraud on the Court as well as
on the opposite party, observed how the Court process is abused by various
fraudsters, they are extracted hereunder: “1. "Fraud-avoids all judicial acts, ecclesiastical or temporal"
observed Chief Justice Edward Coke of England about three
centuries ago. It is the settled proposition of law that a
judgment or decree obtained by playing fraud on the court is
a nullity and honest in the eyes of law. Such a
judgment/decree - by the first court or by the highest court has to be treated as a nullity by every court, whether superior
or inferior. It can be challenged in any court even in collateral
proceedings.
7………………………………………….We do not agree with
the High Court that "there is no legal duty cast upon the
plaintiff to come
to court with a true case and prove it by
true evidence". The principle of "finality of litigation" cannot
be pressed to the extent of such an absurdity that it becomes
an engine of fraud in the hands of dishonest litigants. The
courts of law are meant for imparting justice between the
parties. One who comes to the court, must come with cleanhands. We are constrained to say that more often than not,
process of the court is being abused. Property-grabbers, taxevaders, bank-loan-dodgers and other unscrupulous persons
from all walks of life find the court - process a convenient
lever to retain the illegal-gains indefinitely. We have no
hesitation to say that a person, who's case is based on
falsehood, has no right to approach the court. He can be
summarily thrown out at any stage of the litigation.
8…………………………..A litigant, who approaches the
court, is
bound to produce all the documents executed
by him which are relevant to the litigation. If he withholds a
vital document in order to gain advantage on the other side
(1994) 1 SCC 1
then he would he guilty of playing fraud on the court as well
as on the opposite party.”
127. The Hon’ble Full Bench of Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in
Vishnu Vardhan @ vishnu Pradhan Vs The State of Uttar Pradesh &
others 24, relied on Nidhi Kaim Vs. State of Madhya Pradesh (2017) 4 SCC 1
and S.P. Chengalvaraya Naidu case supra, observed nothing, obtained by
fraud, can be sustained, as fraud unravels everything, the growing trend of
abuse of the process of law by dishonest litigants playing fraud on courts, set
aside the impugned order of the High Court in Writ as vitiated by the fraud,
remanded the matter to High Court, direction to implead the Appellant and
another as Respondents and directed to dispose the Writ afresh. Also set
aside the judgment and order in Civil Appeal, observing obtained by fraud
and recalled in exercise of inherent powers. Also recalled the order in MA in
the Civil Appeal in exercise of inherent powers.
128. Thus, in view of the law as stated supra, if any party fraudulently
alienates the property, violating the injunction order, status quo order, stay
order or undertaking etc, the mischievous party, not only liable for prosecution
including Section 206 of IPC (243 of BNS), (the scope and ambit of Section
206 of IPC (243 of BNS) is discussed herein after) for the fraudulent
alienation, in appropriate cases, the transaction may also be liable to be
canceled/reversed as per the law stated supra.
129. It is needless to mention, in the light of the law as referred to
supra, the other party has a duty to move an appropriate application through
their Counsel to attack the fraudulent transaction, the Counsel has a duty to
assist the Court in a comprehensive way to address the issues in the suit
including the fraud if any, by placing all relevant factual position/authorities.
Even in the absence of the application or assistance by the Counsel, the
2025 SCC OnLine SC 1501
Court has a duty to address the issues including the fraud if any, to render
justice to the victim/opposite party and to curb the recurring of frauds by
sending the deterrence of the law, which is seldom invoked, thereby the
fraudsters could do with their acts undeterred, which shall be handled with
iron hands.
ix. The law on the principle of Lis pendens and allied aspects:
Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act is extracted hereunder: “52. Transfer of property pending suit relating thereto.—
During the [pendency] in any Court having authority [within
the limits of India excluding the State of Jammu and Kashmir]
or established beyond such limits] by
[the Central
Government] of [any] suit or proceeding [which is not
collusive and] in which any right to immovable property is
directly and specifically in question, the property cannot be
transferred or otherwise dealt with by any party to the suit or
proceeding so as to affect the rights of any other party thereto
under any decree or order which may be made therein,
except under the authority of the Court and on such terms as
it may impose.
[Explanation.—For the purposes of this section, the
pendency of a suit or proceeding shall be deemed to
commence from the date of the presentation of the plaint or
the institution of the proceeding in a Court of competent
jurisdiction, and to continue until the suit or proceeding has
been disposed of by a final decree or order and complete
satisfaction or discharge of such decree or order has been
obtained, or has become unobtainable by reason of the
expiration of any period of limitation prescribed for the
execution thereof by any law for the time being in force.]”
130. The Hon’ble Full Bench of Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in
M/s Siddamsetty Infra Projects Pvt. Ltd. Vs. Katta Sujatha Reddy &
others 25, relied on Bellamy Vs. Sabine of Privy Counsel and on Jayaram
Mudaliar Vs. Ayyaswamiof Hon’ble Supreme Court of India, held that
Sec.52 bars transfer of property during pendency of litigation, exception is
(2024) 20 SCC 140
under the authority of the Court on terms, that the alienation defeats the
purpose of the suit, which is extracted hereunder: “47. In short, the doctrine of lis pendens that Section 52 of
the Transfer of Property Act encapsulates, bars the
transfer of a suit property during the pendency of litigation.
The only exception to the principle is when it is
transferred under the authority of the Court and on terms
imposed by it…….
49. The purpose of lis pendens is to ensure that the
process of the court is not subverted and rendered
infructuous. In the absence of the doctrine of lis pendens, a
defendant could defeat the purpose of the suit by
alienating the suit property…….”
131. The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Vinod Seth Vs.
Devinder Bajaj and another 26 while dealing with a suit for Specific
Performance, referred to Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act and
granted permission to the Defendants under Section 52 of TP Act to deal with
or dispose of the suit property, which are extracted hereunder: “21. The principle underlying section 52 of TP Act is based on
justice and equity. The operation of the bar under section 52 is
however subject to the power of the court to exempt the suit
property from the operation of section 52 subject to such
conditions it may impose. That means that the court in which the
suit is pending, has the power, in appropriate cases, to permit a
party to transfer the property which is the subject-matter of the
suit without being subjected to the rights of any party to the suit,
by imposing such terms as it deems fit. Having regard to the
facts and circumstances, we are of the view that this is a fit case
where the suit property should be exempted from the operation
of Section 52 of the TP Act, subject to a condition relating to
reasonable security, so that the defendants will have the liberty
to deal with the property in any manner they may deem fit,
inspite of the pendency of the suit........
26. In the result, we allow this appeal in part, set aside the
order of the Division Bench and Learned Single Judge
directing the plaintiff-appellant to file an affidavit
undertaking to pay Rs.
lakhs
to
defendantsrespondents in the event of failure in the suit. Instead, we
(2010) 8 SCC 1
permit the defendants-respondents under Section 52 of
TP Act, to deal with or dispose of the suit property in
the manner they deem fit, in spite of the pendency of the
suit by the plaintiff, subject to their furnishing security to
an extent of Rs. Three lakhs to the satisfaction of the
learned Single Judge.”
132. The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Shivshankara &
another Vs. H.P. Vedavyasa Char 27, while dealing with a suit for Permanent
Injunction, referred to Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act and held
section 52 of TP Act prohibits, which are extracted hereunder: “33. …….There
can be no doubt with respect to the
position that the prohibition by application
of
the
principles of the said doctrine would take its effect with the
institution of the suit……”
133. The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in A.Nawab John &
another Vs. V.N.Subramaniyam 28, while referring to Jayaram Mudaliar
case supra, discussed the object of lis pendens and that no alienations
pendente lite be permitted, they are extracted hereunder: “..that it would plainly be impossible that any action or suit
could be brought to a successful termination, if alienations
pendente lite were permitted to prevail. The plaintiff would
be liable in every case to be defeated by the defendants
alienating before the judgment or decree, and would be
driven to commence his proceedings de novo, subject to
be defeated by the same course of proceeding...”
134.The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Usha Sinha Vs. Dina
Ram&Others 29, while dealing with Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act
and Rule 102 of Order XXI of the Code of Civil Procedure, held the object of
Sec.52 of Transfer of Property Act, that prohibits a party from dealing with the
property, that a transferee is presumed to be aware of proceedings, that in
(2023) 13 SCC 1
(2012) 7 SCC 738
(2008) 7 SCC 144
the absence of the principle, a Judgment Debtor or his transferee will go on
transferring the property, new transferee will offer resistance or obstruct
execution, to avoid such a situation, the Rule is enacted and also held that he
cannot seek benefit of Rule 98 or 100 of Order XXI, they are extracted
hereunder: “[12] Bare reading of the rule makes it clear that it is based
on justice, equity and good conscience. A transferee from
a judgment debtor is presumed to be aware of the
proceedings before a Court of law. He should be careful
before he purchases the property, which is the subject
matter of litigation. It recognizes the doctrine of lispendens
recognized by Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act,
1882. Rule 102 of Order XXI of the Code thus takes into
account the ground reality and refuses to extend a helping
hand to purchasers of property in respect of which litigation
is pending. If unfair, inequitable or undeserved protection is
afforded to a transferee pendente lite, a decree holder will
never be able to realize the fruits of his decree. Every time
the decree holder seeks a direction from a Court to
execute the decree, the judgment debtor or his
transferee will transfer the property and the new
transferee will offer resistance or cause obstruction.
To avoid such a situation, the rule has been enacted.
[16] Referring to statutory provisions and case law, the
Court negatived the contention, stating- If such contention
of the learned senior counsel for the appellant is to be
accepted, then we are closing our eyes regarding the
intention of the statute. It is obvious while interpreting the
provisions of the statute, the court must give due weight to
the intention of the statute in order to give effect to the
provisions. If any narrow interpretation is given and thereby
the purpose of the statute is being defeated, the courts
must be careful to avoid such interpretations. If we look at
Section 52 of the Transfer of Property Act and Rule 102 of
Order 21 C.P.C, it is very clear that the intention of the
Parliament with which the statute had been enacted is that
the rights of one of the parties to the proceeding pending
before the court cannot be prejudiced or taken away or
adversely affected by the action of the other party to
the same proceeding. In the absence of such restriction
one party to the proceeding, just to prejudice the other
party, may dispose of the properties which is the subject
matter of the litigation or put any third party in possession
and keep away from the court. By such actions of the party
to the litigation the other party will be put to more hardship
and only to avoid such prejudicial acts by a party to the
litigation these provisions are in existence. When in spite of
such statutory restrictions, for the transfer of the properties,
which are the subject matter of litigation by a party to the
proceeding, the courts are duty bound to give effect to the
provisions of the statute.
[18] It is thus settled law that a purchaser of suit property
during the pendency of litigation has no right to resist or
obstruct execution of decree passed by a competent
Court. The doctrine of 'lispendens' prohibits a party
from dealing with the property which is the subject
matter of suit. 'Lis pendens' itself is treated as
constructive notice to a purchaser that he is bound by a
decree to be entered in the pending suit. Rule 102,
therefore, clarifies that there should not be resistance or
obstruction by a transferee pendente lite. It declares that if
the resistance is caused or obstruction is offered by a
transferee pendente lite of the judgment debtor, he cannot
seek benefit of Rule 98 or 100 of Order XXI.”
135. The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Periyammal (dead)
thorough LR’s & others Vs V Rajamani & another 30, referred to Hon’ble
Full Bench of Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Silverline Forum Pvt.
Ltd. vs. Rajiv Trust and Anr. : 1998 (3) SCC 723, held on lis pendens and
Order XXI Rule 102 of CPC, which is extracted hereunder: “10. ………..No doubt if the resistance was made by a
transferee pendente lite of the judgment debtor, the scope
of the adjudication would be shrunk to the limited question
whether he is such transferee and on a finding in the
affirmative regarding that point the execution court has to
hold that he has no right to resist in view of the clear
language contained in Rule 102. Exclusion of such a
transferee from raising further contentions is based on the
salutary principle adumbrated in Section 52 of the Transfer
of Property Act.”
(2005) 9 SCC 568
136. The Hon’ble Supreme Court of India in Maharwal Khewaji
Trust (Regd.) Faridkot Vs. Baldev Dass 31, while dealing with lis pendens,
held that generally the Court should not permit the nature of the Property
being changed, which includes alienation and transfer of property, the same
is extracted hereunder: “Be that as it may, Mr. Sachhar is right in contending that
unless and until a case of irreparable loss or damage is
made out by a party to the suit, the court should not
permit the nature of the property being changed which
also includes alienation or transfer of the property
which may lead to loss or damage being caused to the
party who may ultimately succeed and may further lead to
multiplicity of proceedings. In the instant case no such case
of irreparable loss is made out except contending that the
legal proceedings are likely to take a long time, therefore,
the respondent should be permitted to put the scheduled
property to better use. We do not think in the facts and
circumstances of this case, the lower appellate court and
the High Court were justified in permitting the respondent
to change the nature of property by putting up construction
as also by permitting the alienation of the property,
whatever may be the condition on which the same is done.
In the event of the appellant's claim being found
baseless ultimately, it is always open to the
respondent to claim damages or, in an appropriate
case, the court may itself award damages for the loss
suffered, if any, in this regard. Since the facts of this
case do not make out any extraordinary ground for
permitting the respondent to put up construction and
alienate the same, we think both the courts below,
namely, the lower appellate court and the High Court
erred in making the impugned orders. The said orders
are set aside and the order of the trial court is restored.
The appeal is allowed.”
137. Thus, in the light of legal principles, it emerges clearly that the Law
prohibits/bars dealing with or alienating the property in any manner, from
presentation of a Plaint to final order or discharge or satisfaction of the
decree, as to effect the rights of the Parties, except under the Authority of the
(2004) 8 SCC 488
Court on terms i.e., with the permission of the Court as envisaged under
Section 52 of the TP Act and the law as referred supra.
138. As the law prohibits/bars the parties transacting with the property
as stated supra while the matter is sub judice before the Court under Section
52 of the TP Act, any party seeking to alienate the property out of necessity
must approach the Court for permission, the Court may accord permission on
such terms or may not accord depending on facts of the case, thus a party
cannot keep on alienating the property at his whims while keeping the other
party and the Court in dark, which is against the object of Section 52 of the
Transfer of Property Act and the law referred supra. Furthermore, the parties
are duty bound to assist the Court in administration of justice by keeping the
property intact for adjudication of the Court, this is least expected from the
parties when the Subject matter is sub judice before the Court.
x.The Law on prosecution for fraudulent transfer etc., by
breaching the principle of Lis pendens
139. Where the Law prohibits/bars dealing with the property under
Section 52 of the TP Act, the question arises whether a party committing such
a prohibited act through a fraudulent transaction incurs any penal
consequences. The answer is affirmative, in view of Section 206 of IPC
(Section 243 of BNS), which penalizes fraudulent or mischievous act in both
civil and criminal proceedings, which is seldom neither agitated nor brought to
the notice of the Courts in the Districts by the parties by moving an
appropriate application for initiating prosec
140. For ready referenceution for doing a prohibited/barred act by a
fraudulent transfer etc.
141. For ready reference, Section 206 of IPC (Section 243 of BNS) is
extracted hereunder: -
“206. Fraudulent removal or concealment of property to
prevent its seizure as forfeited or in execution.
Whoever fraudulently removes, conceals, transfers or
delivers to any person any property or any interest therein,
intending thereby to prevent that property or interest therein
from being taken as a forfeiture or in satisfaction of a fine,
under a sentence which has been pronounced, or which he
knows to be likely to be pronounced, by a Court of Justice or
other competent authority, or from being taken in execution
of a decree or order which has been made, or which he
knows to be likely to be made by a Court of Justice in a civil
suit, shall be punished with imprisonment of either
description for a term which may extend to two years, or with
fine, or with both.”
142. It appears the object of Section 206 of IPC (Section 243 of BNS)
is to prevent fraudulent removal, concealment, transfer, or delivery of any
property, which was or may be subject matter of a Criminal or Civil
proceeding, further as per the second limb of Section 206 of IPC (Section 243
of BNS), even if any Person fraudulently transfers or delivers property
anticipating that a Decree or Order is likely to be passed by a Court of Justice
in a civil suit, such person is liable for imprisonment for a term which may
extent to two years, or with fine or with both.
143. Thus, while Section 52 of Transfer of Property Act applies to
immovable properties in civil proceedings, Section 206 of IPC (Section 243 of
BNS) applies to movable and immovable properties in criminal as well as civil
proceedings, further even when Section 52 of TP Act i.e. lis pendens is not
applicable to a civil case, if there is fraudulent transfer, Section 206 of IPC
(Section 243 of BNS) may attract depending on the facts of the case.
144. However, a party cannot launch prosecution under Section 206 of
IPC (Section 243 of BNS) as it is the duty of the Court to examine the
material on record, record reasons and initiate prosecution under Section 206
of IPC (Section 243 of BNS) for effecting fraudulent transfer while matter is
pending before the Trial Court by breaching the principle of lis pendens and
for harassing the other party in the civil proceeding, either upon an application
or otherwise/suo moto in accordance with the procedure prescribed under
Section 340 read with Section 195(1)(b)(i) of the Code of Criminal Procedure
(Section 379 read with Section 215(1)(b)(i) of BNSS). This is one of the
effective measures to address mischievous parties, fraud in civil cases and
the multiplicity of proceedings in civil litigation. These are seldom invoked in
the Trial Courts, therefore fraud remains unchecked.
145. The principles on lis pendens and allied legal aspects stated
herein above are illustrative but not exhaustive, and are compelled to refer in
the circumstances of the case.
146. It is needless to mention, whether the suit in O.S.No.49 of 2007
survives on the plaintiff’s readiness and willingness or not, the prosecution
still goes against the Parties for fabrication of agreements and false evidence
for the reasons stated supra.
X. RESULT:
147. This Court, on re-appreciating the evidence on record and from
the foregoing discussion, inclined to hold that the Plaintiff in OS.No.49 of
2007 could prove the case as stated supra, Issue No.i is answered in favour
of
the
Plaintiff,
issue
No.ii
to
iv
are
answered
against
the
Appellants/Defendants. The Appellants could not demonstrate any material
infirmity warranting interference in the Decree and Judgment of the Trial
Court.
148. Thus, in view of the material and foregoing discussion, AS.527 of
2013 and AS.623 of 2013 are dismissed with costs. And A.S. Nos. 530, 646 &
656 of 2013 are dismissed as abated.
149. The Plaintiff in O.S. Nos. 49 of 2007 is at liberty to prosecute all
the conspirators under Section 467 of IPC by lodging a report with the
jurisdictional Police.
150. In view of the material and law stated supra, the 1st, 2nd, 4th to 6th
Defendants, DW.5 and DW.6 are liable for prosecution under Section 193 of
IPC for producing the fabricated agreements and for giving false evidence
before the Trial Court as well as asserting the same before this Court. As the
1st Defendant died during the pendency of the Appeal, the prosecution
against him is abated.
151. In view of the material and law stated supra, the 2nd Defendant is
liable for prosecution under Section 206 of IPC for selling the property on
12.12.2022 violating the orders of the Court as stated supra.
152. The Court observed on the prima facie case as stated supra, the
Jurisdictional Trial Court shall proceed as per law.
153. The Registrar (Judicial) shall ensure filing of the Complaint under
Sections 193 and 206 of IPC before the Jurisdictional Magistrate as per law.
154. In view of the material and law stated supra, the District Registrar,
Nellore and Sub-Registrar, Kovur shall ensure cancellation of the
registrations dated 12.12.2022 on the schedule property, also, they shall not
permit any other registrations except under this judgment. If any clarification
is required, they shall move an application before the Court.
155. The Registrar (Judicial) shall communicate the Judgment to the
District Registrar, Nellore and Sub-Registrar, Kovur.
156. This Court, in these compelling circumstances, inclined to issue
the above directions.
As a sequel, the pending Miscellaneous Petitions, if any, shall stand
closed.
_________________________
JUSTICE D. RAMESH, J
__________________________________
JUSTICE ALAPATI GIRIDHAR, J
Dt: 16.10.2026
JKS
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review