Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
TUESDAY,THE THIRD DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K.LAKSHMAN
AND
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE VAKITI RAMAKRISHNA REDDY
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO: 1183 OF 2019
Crl.Appeal Under Section 374 (21 of Crl.P.C., 1973 aggrieved by the
Judgment dated 29-11-2019 passed in S.C.No. 56 of 2019 on the file of the
Court of the Principal District and Sessions Judge at Nalgonda.
Between:
Mekala Saidulu, S/o.Chinna @ Chinna Aged about 35 years, Occ. Car Mechanic
R/o.H.No.2-6, Thugathurthy Village of Kethapally [/landal, Nalgonda District,
Telangana State.
...APPELLANTS/
Accused No.1
AND
The State of Telangana, Through Rep. by its Public Prosecutor High Court of
Judicature For the state of Telangana at Hyderabad.
...RESPONDENT, Complainant
lA NO: 1 OF 2025
Petition under Section 430 (1) of BNSS praying that in the circumstances
stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be
pleased to suspend the execution of sentance passed in SC.No.56 of 2q'19
dated 2911112019 on the file of the Hon'ble Principal District and Sessions Judge
Nalgonda for offence U/s. 302, 506 of IPC and to release the Petitioner/Accused
No.1 on Bail pending disposal of Crl.A.No. 1183 of 2019.
Gounsel for the Appellant: Smt. G. JAYA REDDY
Counsel for the Respondent : SRI SYED YASAR MAMOON ,
ADDL. PUBLIC PROSECUTOR
The Court delivered the following Judgment :
IN THE HTGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT: HYDERABAD
HON'BLE SRI JUSTTCE K. LAKSHMAN
AND
HOI\{'BLE SRI JUSTICE VAKITI RAMAKRISHNA REDDY
CRIMINAL APP EAL No.l183 OF 2019
DATE: 03-02-2026
Betweeg:
Mekala Saidulu S/o Chinna @ Chinnaiah
Appellant - Accused No.l
Vs.
The State of Telangana, rep.by its
Public f'rosecutor, High Court at Hyd.
.. Respondent - Complainant
l'his Court delivered the following:
JUDGIWENT: (Per Hon'ble SriJustice I(. Lakstunan)
F[eard Mrs. G. Jaya Reddy, learned counser for the appellant accusec No.1 and Mr. Syed Yasar Mamoon, learned Additional public
Prosecutor appearing on behalf of the respondent.
2. this appeal is filed challenging rhe judgment dated
29.11.2r)19 in S.c. No.56 of 2019 passed by learned principal &
Sessionrs Judge, Nalgonda (hereinafter referred to ,trial court,).
3 vide the aforesaid judgment, the trial court convicted the
appellarrt - accused No.l for the charges under Section! - 302 and 506
Z
KL,J & VRKR,J
Crl.A. No.l 183 of 2019
of IpC and accordingly sentenced him to undergo life imprisonment
and to pay fine of Rs.10,000 (Rupees Ten Thousand Only) and in
default to undergo simple imprisonment for a period of three (03)
months for the charge under Section - 302 of IPC. He was further
sentenced to undergo simple imprisonment for two (02) years for the
charge under Section - 506 of IPC. However, learned trial Court
acquitted him and accused No.2 for charges Section - 302 read with
34 ofIPC and Section - 506 read with 34 of IPC.
4. The case of the prosecution is as follows:
i) Mekala Ramaswamy - deceased belongs to Mala by caste
and resident of Thungathurthy Village of Kethepally Mandal. He is
eking out his livelihood by doing agriculture. He is also caste elder in
the village. He has two (02) wives, namely Prameela and Rakela,
respectively. LW.l - complainant is the son of first wife.
ii) Accused No.1 was addicted to bad habits and used to quarrel
with his wife - Kalamma, as such, his wife was living separately with
her parents since last six (06) years. The deceased being caste elder
conducted mediation between them. Pursuant to the mediation,
accused No.1 and his wife started living together.
J
KL.J & VRKR,J
Crl.A. No.l 183 of 2019
iii) Even then, accused No.l did not change his attitude and,
therefor:e, his wife started living separately, whereas accused No.l was
residin6i at Hyderabad by doing mechanic work.
i'r) while So, accused No.l approached the deceased and
requestr:d to mediate between him and his wife, for which the
deceased refused by saying that he would not change his auitude.
Due to such refusal, accused No.l developed enmity towards the
deceased.
vl In pursuance of such enmity, on 10.10.2017 at about 10.30
hours, rvhile the deceased was at the house of Merugu Narsamma
(Pw.4), accused No.l and his Aunt's son - Mr.Nama Kotaiah
(accusecl No.2) came on a motorcycle and called the deceased on the
road. T'hen, accused No.l attackecl with a big knife, while accused
No.2 attrecked with a small knife on the deceased and inflicted injuries
inhumar.ly on the hands, face, ribs, due to which, the deceased died on
the spot.
5. on receipt of reporl (Ex.p15) from LW.r, son of the
deceasecl, Pw.15 - Sub-Inspector of police, Kethepally police
Station
registered a case in crime No.t44 of 2017 on 10.10.2017 for
{
I
the
KL,J & VRKR,J
Crl.A. No.l183 of 2019
I
I
offences under Sections - 302 and 506 read with 34 of IPC and
issued
Ex.P14 - FIR.
i) Lw.18 - the doctor conducted autopsy over the dead body of
the deceased in the presence of PW.12 and LW.15. On
completion of
investigation, PW.16 - Inspector of Police filed a charge sheet
the appetlant herein and accused No.2. Since the offences
against
are triable
by Court of Sessions, learned Magistrate committed the same
':
t
Sessions Court which was taken on file as S.C. No.56
to the
of 2019 and
?
t
i
i
proceeded with trial.
t,
ii!
li
t'
i:
6. The triat Court framed charges for the offences under
il
ji
il
rl
:l
i
i.
I
Sections - 302,302 read with 34, 506 and 506 read
with 34 of IPC
against both the accused.
7. During trial, PWs.l to [8 rvere examined, Exs.Pl to P17
were marked and MOs.l to 14 were also exhibited' The accused
neither let in oral evidence nor exhibited any documents
on his behalf'
8. After completion of evidence on behalf of the prosecution,
the accused were examined under Section - 3 13 of Cr'P'C'
Thereafter'
upon hearing both sides, the trial Court recorded conviction
against
KLJ & VRKR,J
Crl.A. No. ll83 of 2019
?
the appellant herein for the charges under Sections - 302 and 506
of
IPC and accordingly imposed sentence of imprisonment upon him in
the manner stated above. However, the appellant was acquitted of
the
charges tmder Section - 302 read with 34 of Ipc and Secrion -
read with 34 of IPC.
9. challenging the said conviction and sentence of
imprisonrnent, the appellant herein preferred the present appeal.
10. Learned counsel for the appellant - accused No.l contended
as followl;:
i.
Pw.1, who gave the report to the police, is not an eye-witness
to the incident.
ii.
Pw.2 said to be an eye witness and said to have informed with
regard to the incident to pw.l, did not depose the date of
incident and specific overt acts of the appellant.
iii.
Iderrtification of Mos.l and 2 - knifes by pw.2 is also doubtful
for the reasons that he deposed that the same were covered with
cloth.
iv. Pw.3 and pw.4 said to be an eye-witness and pw.7, wife of
accused No.1 did not support the prosecution
is not trustworthy witness.
case, while pw.5
KL,J & VRKR,J
Crl.A. No.l183 of 2019
v
PW.8 is not an eye-witness and motive part is not proved
through her. Thus, motive was not proved by the prosecution.
vl
No weight can be given to the evidence of PW.9 and l0 and so
also PW.1 l.
vlt.
Evidence of PW.12 - pancft witness for seizure of MOs.3 to 9
does not carry much weight.
vlll.
Without considering all the aforesaid aspects, the trial Court
convicted the accused.
With the aforesaid submissions, learned counsel sought to set aside
the conviction and sentence imposed on the appellant.
11. On the other hand, leamed Additional Public Prosecutor
would submit as under:
There is clear evidence from the prosecution witnesses to
connect the guilt of the accused in commission of offence.
ll
There is direct evidence through PWs. l, 2 and 5 to prove the
guilt of the accused.
lll.
There was motive on the part of the appellant and the same was
proved by the prosecution beyond reasonable doubt'
\
KL,J & VRKR,J
Crl.A. No.l183 of 2019
.,
-
iv. Having considered all the aforesaid aspects, the trial court
convicted the appellant and, therefore, there is no error in it.
With tht: aforesaid submissions, learned Additional Public Prosecutor
sought to dismiss the appeal.
li'.. In the view of above rival submissions, the point that falls
for consideration by this Court is:
whether the conviction and sentence of imprisonment
recorded by the trial court for the charges under Sections -
302 and 506 of IPC against the appellant herein - accused
No.l are sustainable, both on facts and in law?
13. In this case, Pw.l is the second wife of the deceased.
Though Pw.2 to PW.6 and PW.l8 are eye-witnesses to the incident,
PWs.3 and 4 turned hostile. Pw.7 - wife of accused No.l is a
circumstantial witness and she did not support the prosecution case.
Pw.8 - first wife of the deceased is also circumstantial witness. pw.g
and PW. l0 are also circumstantial witnesses. pw.l I - younger
brother c,f the deceased is also circumstantial witness. pw. 12 is a
panch for scene of offence-cum-seizure and inquest panchanama.
Pw.13 is also panch witness for confession-cum-seizure panchanama
of accused Nos. I and 2. pw.l4 is the doctor, who conducted autopsy
over the ,Jead body of the deceased. pw.l5 is the Sub-Inspector of
!,
KL,J & VRKR,J
Crl.A. No.l183 of 2019
Police, who received Ex.P15 - report from LW.l and issued Ex.P14 -
FIR. PW.16 is the Investigating Officer, who examined and recorded
the statements of witnesses. PW.17 is the lnvestigating Officer who
laid charge after receipt of Ex.P17 - Forensic Science Laboratory
Report.
14. In the light of the afore-stated rival contentions, it is apt to
discuss the depositions of the prosecution witnesses.
15. PW.l - second wife of the deceased, deposed that at the
time of incident she was in the agricultural fields. PW.2 informed her
over telephone that her husband was murdered and asked her to come
quickly. By the time she reached the spot, her husband died. The
deceased had hacking injuries on the side head, face, hands and waist'
upon seeing blood, she fell unconscious. Her son (LW.l) gave
Ex.Pl5 - report with PW.15. She also deposed with regard to the
matrimoniat disputes between accused No.l and his wife and the
deceased acted as mediator.
i)
She specifically deposed that accused No.l killed her
husband for refusing to accompany him to bring his wife back home'
Accused No.l is responsible for the death of her husband.
L
KL,J & VRKR,J
Crl.A. No.l183 of 2019
,-}
ii)
During cross-examination, she admitted that being
comrnunity elder, her husband participated in several panchayats. In
the course of the panchayat, one par:ty will gain and the other party
will [ose. The persons who lose in the panchayat may feel aggrieved
at her husband. She volunteered that the grievance will not be such as
to kill him.
16. Pw.2 - eye-witness deposed that on the date of incident he
started from his village on his motorcycle to go to Nakrekal for having
his motor pump repaired. while proceeding, he saw the deceased and
accused No.l fighting. He stopped his motorcycle and shouted at
accused No.l to stop. By the time he put the stand of the motorcycle;
accused No.l had taken a knife from his motorcycle, hacked three
times at the deceased, got on his motorcycle and went away towards
uppa,Lapadu. The deceased suffered injuries on the head, neck and
hands. At that time, Pw.3, Pw.4 and Pw.6 were present, who had
also vritnessed the incident apart from him.
i) He further deposed with regard to cause of murder, accused
No.l':s wife was niece of the deceased. She left accused No.1, who
asked the deceased to bring her back. Earlier the deceased had
I
l0
KL,J & VRKR,J
Crl.A. No.l183 of 2019
brought her back, she had left accused No.l. The deceased told
accused No.l that she was not listening to him and that deceased
brought her to accused No.l twice. tn this regard, accused No.l
attacked the deceased while he was alone. Accused No.1 dragged the
deceased out of his house and used two knives, which were identified
by PW. 2 as MOs.l and 2. He also identified the accused in the Court
Hall. He was also examined by the police, who conducted inquiry in
the village.
ii) During cross-examination, he admitted that MOs. I and 2
were covered in cloth. And was questioned regarding how could he
identifo MOs.l and 2 when they are covered with cloth, he answered
that he identified them from their handles. Except that, nothing useful
was elicited from this witness.
17. PW.3 and PW.4 are also eye-witness to the incident, and
deposed that the deceased had died on the road near the house of
PW.4. But, they did not support the case of prosecution and, therefore,
they were declared hostile and learned Additional Public Prosecutor
cross-examined them. In their cross-examination also, nothing useful
\
ll
KL,J & VRKR,J
Crl.A. No.l t83 of 2019
-
was elicited from them. Therefore, their evidence is
not helpful to the
prosecution
18. Pw.5, one of the eye-witnesses deposed that her house
is
abutting the road near the house of pw. l0 and four houses
away from
the house of PW.4. on the date of incident i.e., r0.r0.20
17 atabout
9.30 A.M., she had gone to collect ration rice and
deceased oame to her house and asked him to
returned home. The
lend Rs. r,000/- and she
told him that she did not have money. Then he went to
the house of
Pw. 10. She heard a quarrel. She went outside the house
and saw that
the deceased died. euarrel was over by the time
place. She saw accused No. r giving the last blow
she reached the
with a knife. Upon
seeing that. she went back to her house.
i) tlurinB cross-examination, pw.5 specifically admitted that
she saw the last blow. Nothing useful was
elicited from her.
19- Pw.6, one of the eye-witnesses, arso deposed that her
house is in New colony. pw.3's house is abutting
the house o; PW.4. The house of pw.5 is
the road, beside
about 50 feet away from her
house. The distance between her house and house
of pw.4 is about
l0 or 20 fee:. She identified the accused in the court
Hall.
)
t2
KL,J & VRKR,J
Crl.A. No.l183 of 2019
20. PW.6 further deposed that the deceased died on the road in
front of the house of PW.4 at about 10.00 A.M. At that time, she was
standing near the house of PW.4. She and PW.4 alone were present
there tatking. The deceased came out of the house of PW.4. Accused
Nos. 1 and 2 came there. The deceased and accused No.1 greeted each
other and were talking. Then, accused No.l started quarreling with
deceased. On seeing that, she became afraid and ran away from that
place. While running away, she fell down and caused injury to her
knees. She returned to that place after the deceased died. The
deceased had injuries on his neck.
i) During cross-examination, she admitted that the police told
her to depose as above. She did not know anything about this case.
She has not seen anything on that day.
21. PW.7, wife of accused No.l, deposed that there were no
marital disputes between her and accused'No.l and on the date of
incident, accused No.1 was in Hyderabad.
i) Since this witness did not support the case of prosecution,
learned Additional Public Prosecutor declared her hostile and crossexamined her.
.\
\
,-l
t3
KL,J & VRKR,J
Crl.A. No.l183 of 2019
I
i:,
22. Pw.8, wife of the deceased, deposed that her house is at a
distance of 2 or 3 furlongs from the house of pw.4. The house of
:
Pw.5 is separated from the house of pw.3 by one house. The house
of f'w.6 is beside the house of pw.5. She also identified the accused
,i
:i
in the Court Hall. Accused No.l is the son of her Father in law,s
younger brother. The deceased is the maternal uncle of accused
No.1's wife. The deceased arranged the marriage between her and
acctsed No. 1. she also deposed with regard to marital disputes
betvreen accused No. I and his wife on account of accused No.l
developing illicit intimacy with some other woman.
23. Pw.8 further deposed that on the date of incident, accused
No.I came to her house and insisted the deceased to help him
(accrrsed No.l ) to get his wife back, for which the deceased told
accused No. I to bring some caste elcters, but accused No.l did not
respond. Then, the deceased chastised him saying that he should not
remain sitting in the house and he should go and get the elders. Then,
accur;ed No.1 left the house by saying that he would see the end
of the
dece,sed. Thereafter she became ill and she went to Hyderabad for
treatrnent. Nine (09) days thereafter, she received a phone call
from
Laxmaiah that her husband died and asked her to come to the village.
/
,/
/
,
I
t4
IC,J & VRKR,J
Crl.A. No.l183 of 2019
She reached the village by night and there she was informed that both
the accused had hacked down her husband and killed him. Accused
No.l is responsible for the death of her husband as he killed the
deceased out of grudge.
i) During cross-examination, nothing useful was elicited from
PW.8.
24. PW.9 is a circumstantial witness. He deposed that his
house is beside the house of deceased. He saw accused No.l going
into the house of deceased some days prior to the death of the
deceased. The dead body was lying on the road in front of the house
of PW.4. He informed the same to LW.1 over phone
i) During cross-examination nothing useful was elicited from
PW.9.
25. PW.IO deposed that the house of deceased is onebazaar
away from her house. on 10. 10.2017 , the deceased came to her house
at about 10.00 A.M. and borrowed Rs.1,000/- from her and then he
went away. Later, she came to know that the deceased died near the
house of PW.4.
\
\
\
\
\
I
l5
KL,J & VRKR,J
Crl.A. No. I 183 of 2019
-
i) t)uring cross-examination, nothing useful was elicited from
PW.10.
26" PW. I 1, younger brother of the deceased, also deposed with
regard to the marital disputes between accused No.l and his wife on
account oi' accused No.l developed illicit intimacy with another
woman. The deceased died in front of house of PW.4
i) D,uring cross-examination, nothing useful was elicited from
PW.11
27. PWl8, villager of Thungathurty village identified accused
No.l in the Court hall. on the date of incident, when he reached near
the house of PW.4, he saw many people gathered there. on his
enquiry, th,:y informed him that accused No.l and one other person
attacked thr: deceased and went away
28. PW.12, Village Revenue Officer is the panch witness,
deposed with regard to preparing the scene of observation and seizure
panchanama as in Ex.PS, drawing of rough sketch as in Ex.p6 and
seizure of clothes of the deceasedpanchanama as in Ex.P7. Mo.3 is a
white colotrred empty plastic tin, Mo.4 is the blood stained earth,
I
A
l6
KL,J & VRKR,J
Crl.A No.llE3 of20l9
MO.5 is control earth, Mo.6 is blood stained towel, Mo.7 is a blood
stained shirt, MO.8 is Lungi, MO.9 is underwear'
i) During cross-examination, nothing useful was elicited from
PW.12.
29. PW.t3, another village Revenue officer, is the panch
witness for confession of both the accused with regard to hiding of
MOs.l and 2 - knives in the house of accused No.2 at
Gayamvarigudem, recovery thereof and its seizure. MO.10 is the
blood stained white and black coloured lining cotton fu|l shirt, MO.11
is the blood stained ash coloured pant, MO.12 is the blood stained
blue coloured jeans pant, MO.l3 is the btood stained white coloured
full cotton shirt. The Hero Honda motorcycle bearing registration
No.AP tlQ2847 was also seized as in Mo.14. Exs.Pl0 and P11 are
the seizure panchanamas
i) During cross-examination, nothing useful was elicited from
PW.13.
30. PW.14 is the Medical officer working as civil Assistant
Surgeon, Community Health centre, Nakrekat. He conducted
\
I
\
t7
KL,J & VRKR,J
Crl.A. No.l183 of 2019
-,3
postmortem examination over the dead body of the deceased on
10.10.2017 and found the following extemal and internal injuries
(a) 3x2xl cm laceration at fore head;
(b)2x2xl cm laceration at right cheek;
(c) Right orbit laceration 3xlxl cm;
(d) Right cheek to let cheek laceration 7x3x1.65 cm;
(e) Left ring finger was intact with fracture. [t was a defensive
wound
(f) Left wrist laceration 2xlxl cm.
i) According to him, the injuries found on the deceased are
possible with weapons similar to MOs.l and2. He issued Ex.Pi2 postm ortem examination report.
31. PW.l5, the Sub-Inspector of Police, Kethepally Police
Station, deposed with regard to receipt of report (Ex.P15) from LW.1
on 10.10.2017, he issued FIR in Crime No.l44 of 2017 and sent the
same to the Court concerned. Since the offence is grave, he intimated
the same to PW.16, who took up investigation.
32. PW.16, the Inspector of Police, deposed with regard to
conducting investigation, examining the witnesses (LW.1, PWs.l to
.t
I
j
l8
KLJ & VRKR,J
Crl.A. No.l 183 of 2019
6), conducting scene of panchanama and taking steps for conducting
autopsy over the dead body of the deceased and seizure
of material
objects etc.
33. PW. 17, another lnspector of Police, deposed with regard to
filing of charge sheet after receipt of Ex.P17 - Forensic Science
Laboratory RePort.
34. On an overall re-appreciation of evidence of the aforesaid
prosecution witnesses, it is clear that PW.l is the second wife of the
deceased and PW.8 is his first wife. PW.8 has specifically
deposed
that the deceased is the maternal uncle of Mrs. Kalamma, wife of
accused No.l. The deceased arranged the marriage between Kalamma
and accused No.l and they stayed in Thungathurty for one year after
the marriage and then went to Hyderabad. They had two children'
Accused No.l and his wife lived together for about three (03)
years
after their marriage and thereafter disputes arose between them and
she left the company of accused No.l. The deceased pacified her and
asked her to join the company of accused No.1. Thereafter they lived
together for some time after which the accused No.1 developed illicit
intimacy with some other woman. Again disputes arose between
l
)
t
\
\
_i
l9
KL,J & VRKR,J
Crl.A. No.l183 of 2019
accused I{o.l and his wife and she left his company and started living
with her parents. In this regard, accused No.l requested the deceased
to ask his wife joined his (accused No.l ) company, for which the
deceased asked the appellant herein to bring some caste elders, to go
and convince his wife. But the appellant did not bring the caste elders
and on the other hand developed grudge over the deceased. pw.l l,
the younE;er brother of the deceased, has specifically deposed that
accused }.lo.1 informed him twice or thrice that he would kill the
deceased.
35. Thus, there is specific evidence with regard to motive on
the part of the appellant herein to kill the deceased, as deposed by
Pw.8 and PW.l, first and second wives of the deceased respectively
and also t'w.2. Pw.1 has specif,rcally deposed that the wife of the
appellant had left him and the appellant asked the deceased to act as
an elder ard accompany him to bring her back. The deceased told the
appellant to call two or three other elders to accompany thern.
Developinll grudge over the deceased, the appellant killed him for
refusing to accompany him. She also specifically deposed that the
aonell
t herein is responsible for the dea th of her h
band.
;
I
l.
!i
KL,J & VRKR,J
Crl.A. No.l183 of 2019
PW.2 also specifically deposed with regard to motive on the part of
the appellant. He deposed that the appellant asked the deceased to
bring his wife back. Earlier also, the deceased brought her back when
she teft the company of the appellant. The deceased told the appellant
that the wife of appellant is not listening to him as he had brought her
twice. [n this
he was alone by dra
the a
lant had a
deceased while
him out his house.
36. In view of the above, the prosecution has proved motive on
the part of the appellant herein beyond reasonable doubt. Therefore,
the contention of learned counsel for the appellant that prosecution
failed to prove the motive is unsustainable.
37. Even there is specific evidence with regard to witnessing
the incident by PWs.2, 5 and 6. PW.2 has specifically deposed that
when the deceased raised his hands to protect himself, the appellant
hacked him down. At that time, apatt from him, PWs.3, 4 and PW.6
were also present and witnessed the incident. The appellant had
dragged the deceased out of his house. He also identified MOs.l and
2 - knives with which the appellant hacked the deceased. PW.5 has
specifically deposed with regard to witnessing the incident. He
,
I
\
\
\{
\!
'.i
{
2t
KL,J & VRKR,J
Crl.A. No. I I 83 of 20 l9
deposed that on the date of incident, he saw the appellant giving the
last blow with a knife. Pw.6 also deposed that he saw on the date of
incident the appellant started quarrelling with the deceased. Thus, it is
clear frorn the evidence of PWs.2, 5 and 6 that they witnessed the
appellant killing the deceased.
38. Though Pw.3 turned hostile, his evidence to the exrent it is
useful can be considered as held by the Apex court in a catena of
decisions. Pw.3 deposed that when he reached near his house, he saw
the appellant herein and the deceased quarreling. The deceased died
on the roirrJ nssl the house of pw.4. This extent which is useful to the
prosecution can be considered.
39. In view of the aforesaid discussion, it is clear that the
prosecution also proved the commission of offence by the appellant
herein thr.ugh the evidence of pws.2, 5 and 6 beyond reasonable
doubt.
40. In this case, the prosecution also proved that the dead body
of the decr:ased was lying near the house of pw.4 on the date of
incident through the evidence of pws.l to 3,5,6, g,9 and ll
beyond
reasonable doubt. The evidence of Medical officer (pw.14)
I
also
KL,J & VRKR,J
Crl.A. No.l r 83 of 2019
supports the case of prosecution to the effect that the injuries found on
the deceased were possible with weapons similar to that of MOs.l and
2. Pursuant to the confession made by the appellant herein, recovery
of MOs.l and 2 werealso proved through the independent evidence of
PW.l 2 and 13. Thus, the prosecution has adduced reliable and cogent
direct evidence proving that the appellant herein caused the death of
the deceased. The testimony of eyewitnesses is consistent, trustworthy
and inspires confidence. There are no material contradictions affecting
the core of the prosecution case. In view of the direct evidence,
proved motlve and its cause, recovery of material objects, and
corroboration by medical and scientific evidence, the prosecution has
proved the guitt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt and the
appellant failed to disprove the same.
41. The learned trial Ccurt having considered all the aforesaid
aspects only recorded conviction against the appellant herein and
imposition of life imprisonment thereof. There is no error in it.
42. The present Criminal Appeal is accordingly dismissed
confirming the conviction recorded against the appellant - accused
No.1 and imposition of tife sentence thereof by learned Principal &
{
t
\
\
KL,J & VRKR,J
Crl.A. No.l183 of 2019
Sessions ludge, Nalgonda vide judgment dated 29.11.2019 in S.CNo.56 of .2019.
As a sequel thereto, miscellaneous applications, if any, pending
in this appeal shall stand closed.
SD/. N.SRIHARI
DEPUW REGISTRAR
/TRUE COPY'/
ECTION OFFICER
To,
1. The Principal District and Sessions Judge at Nalgonda'
District'
2. The Judicial Magistrate of First class, Nakrekal, Nalgonda
Kethepally'
3. The station House officer, Kethapally Police station,
Nalgonda District.
Reddy District.
4. The Superintendent, Central Prison, Cherlapally, Ranga
of Telangana at
5. 1yy9 Ql}S to Public Prosecutor, High Court for the State
6. One CC to Smt. . G. JAYA REDDY, Advocate [OPUCI
7. Two CiD CoPies
kul/PSL
\$/
HIGH GOURT
DATED:0310212026
r)
JUDGMENT
CRL.APPEAL No.1183 of 2019
DISMISSING THE CRL. APPEAL
I
&(,
10ttBm
*
*
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review