Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3168 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
FRIDAY, THE TWENTIETH DAY OF FEBRUARY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K.LAKSHMAN
CONTEMPT CASE NO: 1654OF 2024
Contempt Case under Sections 1O lo 12 of Contempt of Courts Act 1971 to
punish the respondent herein for the willful and deliberate disobedience of the order
dated 12.06.2024 passed in W.P No. 14669 of 2024.
Between:
't. Mekala Krishnaveni @ Sumangali, Wo Srrdhar, Aged about 49 years, Occu.
Housewife, R/o 9 - 137, It/ekalapeta, leeja Mandal, Jogulamba Gadwal
District, Telangana.
2. Mekala Sridhar, S/o M Laxmaiah, Aged about 52 years, Occu. Agriculture,
R/o 9-'137, Mekalapeta, lee;a l/landal, Jogulamba Gadwal District, Telangana.
...PETITIONERS
AND
1. Mr. B.M. Santosh, The Distnct Collector, Jogulamba Gadwal District.
2. Mrs. Jyothi, The Tahsrldar, leeja lvlandal, Jogulamba Gadwal District.
3. Mr. Ram Chandar, The Assistant Directori lnspector of Survey, Survey and
Land Records, Jogulamba Gadwal.
4. Mr. K. Govind, The Deputy lnspector of Survey, Jogulamba Gadwal District.
...RESPONDENTS
Counsel for the Petitioners: Sri T.P.S. Harsha
Counsel for the Respondents: Ms. Tekuru Swetcha, Assistant GP for Revenue
The Court made the following: ORDER
THE STA-TE OF TELANGANA
IN TTIE HIGII COURT FOR
AT: HYDERABAD
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K'
CO
LAKSTIMAN
MP T CAS ENo .165 40F
DA TE:2 0- 02-2026
Retween:
,r*du Krishnaveni @ Sumangali
il-t. -r.
.. Petitioners
& another'
Vs
Collector'
Mr. B.M. Santosh, District
& others'
i"g"f"rnU" - Gadwal District
. Respondents
This Courl made the fol[owing:
ORDER:
Heard Mr. T.P.S' Harsha'
Ms.
learned counsel for the
petitioners and
Assistant Govemment
Tekuru Swetcha' learned
Revenue appeartng for
Pleader for
the resPondents
2. This Contempt Case is filed alteging
violation of order dated 12'06'2024
willful and deliberate
in W P' No'14669 of 2024'
3. Vide the aforesaid order' this
Court passed the following
order
"5. ln the light of the above discussion'
05'2023 and
endorseurents dated 26
aforesaid
19 01'2024 of
asidc and thc matter is
respondcnl No 5 arc sct
No'5 rvith the
remandecl back ttl respontlcnt
follorving direotions:
KL,J
C.C. No 1654 of202J
Respondent No.5 shall
re_consider the appcal
-b)' thc petitioners vide
filed
"
N.,. A 01 ) o, i i obGr
r r r.' I
" I ;,,1i;i,; ",,;l
condlrcting survey ollhe
",.?'
subject land;
resnondenr Nos.4
and 5 are of rhc view
llt^;aye,
if
tnat subdivision
numbcrs is rcquired to
bc done
and.arrl lurther fee is
rcquired
i" n" ,.ij irin"
of rhe circulars "r"i.r.;o,,o"
lill,."r":,:^,,
l"rms
.,,1,,r.
rrc same
shall
.
be irrtimated to
the
and on receipr of suctr
inr;mat;orr
11:,]:i:.:
from
responder)t Nos.4 and
5, the petirioner;;;il.;;;
may be required' by rh"
:y.n,,*".a_s
,esponali,t
t'los.4
and 5:
.r:h payment
of fee by rhe peritioners.
_?1,
Nos.4 and 5 shall tai<e
.rl,tlrorO"nt
lakrng
up.tl)e srrrvey as requestcd
U, ,f,r" p",iii
,"li,h
and conclude the same
in acco.darrc"
;r_;
,r"il;ri;;;i;
*.rl
Iv
exercise. as directed
ahuve. shall bc
f[_:r] r: wilhin
a period of i"nr -li_.-',,r5,
::]:!,_.j,.q
rrom the darc or reccipr
i;[:i::,qlr,
",:.;n,';i
.1. It is rhe specific
respondcnts had
contention of the petitioners
not intjmated to them with
paid b1 thern for conducring
pl'eserlt contempt'
15.07.2024 ro conduct
Accordin-ul-v. respondent
but did not conduct
regard to fi-rfther fee
survey of the subject land
However, respondent
Nos.3,4 and others visited
the survey on the ground
not compl)/ing rvith the
dated
at I 1.00 A.M
the subject land,
of alleged disturbances
they have disobeyed the
contempt. I..ven the respondents
to be
till tiling of rhe
No.4 had issued notice
rhe survey on 23.07.2O24
in the \/illage and thereby
herein that the
order under.
did not communicate the
order under contempt.
reasons fbr
If survel. conducts.
KI-,J
C C. No.l654 of2024
in the village
disturbarice may be caused
compliance of the order under
is not a ground for non-
contempt' Therefore' the respondents
disobedience
are liable to be punished for
5. Respondent No'3 filed counter
ofthe order under contempt'
denying the said allegations
and contended that:
i.
contempt'
Pursuant to the order under
initiated process ot 15 '07 '2024
petitioners and surrounding
demarcation as 23 '0'7 '2024
after issuing notices to the
neighbours fixing F-Line
and also informed the Sub-lnspector
of Police, Ieeja Mandal and
survey
respondent Nos'5 and 6
the Tahsildar' Ieeja Mandal'
to start
SurveY No.62,
work in respect of the land in
admeasuring Acs'16'13
guntas' situated at Bingi Doddi
Village
of Ieeja Mandal '
demarcate
The petitioners requested to
part of the land to an
extentofAcs'3.l6guntas.But'tlrerequestmadebythe
petitioners with regard to Survey
No'62A3/A is not having any
are not ln
MaP' The petitioners
Vittage
the
in
sub-division
of tand in Survey
possession of the said extent
Vitlage MaP.
No 62 as per
On 23.07.2024, the respondents
lt l.
and Deputy hspector
KI-,J
C C. No 1654 ot2o24
along with Mandal Surveyor
of Survey attended the field
and neighbouring Survey
demarcation work stafted
Nos.6l. 54,
survey No.62
63 and ll2 and
in the presence of the petitioners
and
concemed pattadars.
Iv
Alier conducting survey of
pattadars in Sun,ey
No.62lpart i.e., If4r. Natti
tz\cs. L I.1 gunras),
tlre u,or-k subntitted a
guntas) and others, objected
letter to respondent Nos.3
no[ co-opcril[e r,r.rth the
dernarcation and obstructed
alirresaid reasons, lhey
Mr.Uppari
and to stop
publishcd in
(Andhra Jyothi) on 23.07.2024.
havc restricted the respondents
pressed to contplete
I4
and 5 and did
survey. The same was also
elugu Dail-r Nervspspgl
to conduct
the vehicles by Mr. Sridhar
the survey work. But, in
and
view of the
stopped the survey work.
6. I{espondent No.3 filed additional
counter. alrcad;. filed
Venkat Ramulu
Narsimulu (Acs.1.l 5 guntas),
I{ari Krishna (Acs. l.l5
'['he petitioners
major part of
Mr. Uppari Chinna Ramudu (Acs.l.
guntas), Mr. Uppari
'l
the land in Sy.No.62,
contending that:
counter apart fi.or}r the
KI-,J
C.C. No.l654 of2021
As per report dated 24'07 '2024
is not in
Survey, petitioner No't
of the Deputy Inspector of
possession of the land
to an
extent of Acs.3 ' l6 guntas'
applicants' Golla Laxmanna'
the
Even prior to the said report'
lt.
who are opposite pattadars
Jayanna'
Golla Hanmanna, Chakali
submitted
of their land'
an aPPlication for demarcation
survey conducted on
22.12.2020 and the Panchanama
conducted, the said applicants
l.
As per
are doing agriculture'
13'07'2007' the
As per Circular dated
possession on
subject to the actual
sub-division will be done
ground tallying with the
documents mentioned'
7. The petitioners hled rejoinder
to the counters filed by
allegations made in
respondents refuting the
the
the counter and
additional counter'
8.
As discussed above' the
absolute
that petitioner No' 1 is the
petitioners herein are claiming
owner of the land admeasuring
No'62A3/A'
Acs.3.16 guntas in Survey
- Gadwal
Ieeja Mandal, Jogulamba
situated at Bingidoddi
Viltage'
District' which is hereinafter
ln the atfidavit fited by
land''
'subject
as
to
referred
have contended
of W.P. No'14669 of 2024'they
theur in suppo(
that lhe said property
1-..
---
KL,J
C.C No. t654 of2021
is their ancestral propcr-ty
rvere in posscssion
The family members of petitioner
ol. the land admeasuring
Surv*, No 62.{ ol Bingidoddi
have flled pahanies.
Iand irr No.62.,\ adrncasuring
Acs. 10.35 guntas of
No.? 3n6 lris lhrnily rncrrbers
srruared ar ISingi<roddi
Bingidoddi Village
have been in peaceful possession
r
and
that petitioner No.2 transferred
.e., Acs.3. I 6 guntas in
viirage in the name of
I hcrein. .Accordin.qJr,. petitioner
Survey No.62A3lA,
his wife i.e., petitioner
No.l,s name was mutated
latest pattadar passbook
In prool-of tltc sanre, they
the said aIl idavir
09. 10. 1995, the
llropeftv.
the suh icct l)rope 11\
pleaded as to sale
1996 which was
No.2. Upon such partition, petitioner
9 TItc,r. har..e ft1r111g1 contended
passbook alonq rvith
properties amongst
No.4g7 of 1996,dated
fcil to thr' shar.c o[-pcritioner
revenue records and
In proof of the same, they
petitioner No.2 in the year
duly rcgistered by docurnenr
No.
Acs. 10.35 guntas in
Alter partition of the family
the farnilv rnerlbers of
enjoy nrcnr ol-the saicl
Village.
No.2
was issued in her favour.
have filed copies of
old and latest pattadar
tire u,rit petition. However,
ol balance land and the
in
they have not
names of the purchasers
in
KL,I
C.C. No.l654 0f2024
have filed report dated
petitioners
10. It is apt to note that the
of leeja
22.07.2021of Additional Girdavar
Mandal submitted to the
Perusal of the same
Tahsitdar of Ieeja Mandal'
an application
petitioner No.1 had submitted
dated 05'07'2021 to the
mutate her name
Tahsildar, with a request to
guntas in Survey
admeasuring Acs'3'16
Village and issue
in respect ol the land
No'62A3/A of Bingidoddi
e-pattadat Passbook'
On receiPt of the said
07'07'2021' the
application, vide letterdated
sought report from the Additional
would reveal that
Tahsitdar' teeja Mandal
Girdavar of leeja Mandal
submitted
to the same, the Additional Girdavar
the Additional
22.07.2021. In the said report'
it is mentioned
guntas. But, in Dharani Pahani'
No 62 is Acs' 16 l3
as Acs' 16'26 guntas'
recorded in Dharani'
Acs'10'35 guntas
flurther stated that out of
the
Ac.7.l9 guntas was sold and
his repoft on
Girdavar stated that as
extent in Suwey
pcr Khasra Pahani, the total
Ac'0'13 guntas
Thus, there is excess of
Pursuant
of land' an extent of
balance land is Acs 3'16
or the
petitioner No. r is not in physicar possession
Venkatramulu'
Acs.3.16 guntas' Mr' Natti
guntas'
said land ol
Mr' Natti Chinna Ramultr'
Harikrishna' all sons
Mr. Nani Narasimhlu' Mr' Natti
land admeasuring
Buddanna, purchased the
It is
ol Natti
Acs'5'18 guntas in Survey
No.62AA fronr Mr. Vittal
documenr bear.ing Nos.6l96
6199 of 2001 . Our of
aforesaid persons and
...,[1*oorroro
Rao S/o Sanjeeva Rao under
of 2007, 6t97 of 2007, 619g
rhe said exrent of Acs.5.
persons and peritiorer.
No.
recomrnended lb. re'icctio'
belongs to petitioner
guntas of land was acquired
of laying R&B ltoad. Balance
of 2007 and,
1g guntas belongs to the
the land of Acs.3.l6 guntas
No.l , an extenr of.A.c. l. i0
registered
for the purpose
land is in possession of
the aforesaid
I. Therefore, the Additional Girdavari
or the apprication submitted
by petitioner
No.l.
I
l. Relbrring ro rhc repoft dated 04.04.2022
Ieeja Mandal, Iler errue
repoft dared 06.04.1011
I)ivisionai Olficer (RDO),
to lhc Distr.ict Collcctor,
District. In the sricl r.cporl
having toral exrenr ol.Acs.
which, petitioner No. i
RSR, the roral extenr in
I0.35 guntas in Survey
petitioner No.l is
No.621431,4. out of
of Acs.7.l9 guntas
ol Acs.3.l6 guntas, D.S. to
Dharani, an extent of Acs.
RSR variation is Ac.(t.l3
identified and erlrered in
also, it is mentioned that
Survey No.62 is Acs. 16.
Gadwal senr a
Jogulamba _ Gadwal
has soid out to an extent
and for. relnarning cxtcnt
of theTahsildar,
be done. As per
13 guntas. Now, in
16.26 gutnas is shown
in Survey No.62.
guntas excess. Iixcess
extent has been
E.rcess Register. In
Survey No.62, 100 feet
KI.-.J
C.C No.1654 of2024
an extent of around
R&B Road was formed in
Acs'l'l0 guntas' The
whose land was
off among the farmers
road extent would be cut
when correction
acquired for R&B as and
option is provided in
said report, the RDo
Dharani Portal. With the
acceptance of the application
recommended lor
submitted by petitioner
No' t '
that latest/e-pattadar
12. It is also apt to note
No'1 to an extent
issued in lavour of petitioner
of Acs'3' 16 guntas in
Bingidoddi Village on
Survey No.62A3lA of the
petitioners
also apt to note that the
passbook was
09'04'2022' It is
have filed copies of latest
passbook'
passbook and old pattadar
patadar
In the old pattadar passbook'
in SurveyNo'62/A
extent of Ac.10'35 guntas
an
of Bingidoddi Vitlage is
rnentioned.
13. Vide endorsement dated 26'05'2023'
receipt
herein has stated that on
of the application submitted
notices were issued
petitioner No' I seeking survey'
all the interested parties including
No'3 and his
the said survey' Respondent
Petitioner
and Vitlagers attended
staff tried to conduct survey
Tippon in respect of Sunuey
Mr. N. Narsimulu, Mr' Harikrishna,
by
on I 3 '05 '2023 to
the petitioners herein'
the adjacent land
No.2 atong with owners of
and
with the help of Village Map
respondent No'i
No 62'
Mrs' JaYalaxnrt' Mr. Pedda
l0
..
^.flJ,oo,or.
Ramudu, Mr. pala Bazari,
Mr.Golla Maddileti and
Mrs. U.
Parvathamma, farmers
s[rbmitted objections
to respondent No.3
requesting hirn not to
conduct survey saying
not in physical possession
of the subject land. Though
is having revenue pattadar
possession ol- the
subject property. Therefore,
demarcation o. the sub-icct
23.11.2023 vide Application
No.AOD022300058333.
on
The same was
19.01.2024.
respondent No.3 has
lbcts and inlormed the
petitioners that
is not possible.
thc afor.esaid writ petition
action ol thc respondents
survey under F-l'ine Application
to
dated
liled an appeal on demarcation
j yile proceedings dated
15. TLte pcririoners filcd
2024, to declare the
and
hc has requesred the petitioners
I4 rn thc proceedings dated 19.01.2024,
reiterated the afbr.esaiii
Thus,
not possible.
chalre,ging the said endorsement,
26.05.2023, thc petitroncrs
No.
and the aloresaid persons.
on Circular No.N2/1741/2010
Nl/1408/2007, and ar:cor.di,gl1..
dismissed by respondent
in physical
there are serious
la'd and parl denlarcation is
He lras also placcd rcliancc
approach the ('iril (lourr
petitioner No.2
passbook, they are not
disputes betu,een lhe pctirioner.s
conducting of sun,ey
that the petitioners are
No.14669 of
in not conducting the
submitted by the petitioner
dated
1l
KL.J
C'C' No l654 of2024
lg.Ol.zlzzwith
survey ofthe
a request to conduct
subject land' Vide
said writ petttton
order dated
disposed of the
l2'06'2024'this Court
setting aside
26'05'2023 and
the endorsements dated
to respondent No'3
remanded the matter back
19'01'2024 and
herein with the
fotlowing directions:
Resp ondent No.5 shall
by the Petitioners
re-consider the appeal
fited
;t".^*T'T,ffi;":;
No.AOD02230005833
the subject land;
conducting survey of
and 5 are of the view
In case' if respondent Nos'4
is required to be done
that subdivision numbers
by the
required to be paid
and any funhcr tbe is
to
the Circulars referred
of
terurs
in
petitioncrs
be intimated to the
ll
ubou", ,t.,. same shall
petitioners and on receipt
of such intimation from
the petitioners shall
pay
,".pond.nt Nos'4 and 5'
by the respondent
such fce as may be required
Nos.4 and 5;
lll.
lv.
On such payment of fee
by the petitioners'
for
5 shall take further steps
rcspondent Nos 4 and
petitioners
as requested by the
taking up the survey
and
in accordance with law;
and conclude the same
above' shall be
directed
The entirc exercise' as
forty five (45)
of
period
a
within
completed
of
date of receipt of copy
working days lrom the
this order."
KL,J
16. In cornpliance with
Sur-vey, Jogulamba
15.07.2024, fixing
thc survey on 23.07.2024.
surve)
submitted objections
They have also objected
respondent No.3
and his teatr werc
The same was reported
No.3 has filed copy
Tlreref<rre, respondenr
Nlll408/2007. Along
notice dated
The aforesaid lr.{r. N.
dated 17.07.2024 to the
for the survey.
Therefore,
not in a position to conduct
in Local Newspaper.
Respondent
of the said nei,r.s item along
with counter.
No.4 has submittcd a
respondent No.3 informing
possibre He has again
r.rr,r;;;:':;
- Gadr.val District, has issued
Narsimulu and others
said notice
the said order, the
r.eport 24.07.2024 to
hirn rhat corrducting of
rericd upo, Circurar
survey is not
Nos.N2/r 741/2010 and
u,ith cou,rer, rhey ha'c
also filed location
sketch map.
17. Learned counsel
respondents rejected
the request rnade by
sun/ey on the grounds
dated 26.05.2023
lor thc petitioners u.ould
contend that the
the petitioners to conduct
rvhich were mentioned
in the endorsernent
and t9.()1.2024.
I8. Vide order undcr
conterilpt,
the order dated 28.08.20t2
ll1
this Coun placing reliance
W.P. No.i27g5 of 2022,
on
w.herein
vanous Circulars includirrg
the Cilcle R.No.N
t/t408/2007, dated
13.07 .2007 were mentioned,
KL.J
C.C. No.l654 of 2024
set aside the aforesaid endorsements
This Court
dated26.05'2023 and lg'Ol'2024'
herein
back to respondent No'3
remanded the matter
with the aforesaid directions'
19. As discussed above' there
are serious disputes
of the petitioners over the
to physical possession
with regard
subject property i'e''
No'62A3/A of Bingidoddi
Survey
in
guntas
Acs.3.16
However,
reliance on the
the petitioners are placing
As discussed
passbook issued on Og'04'2022'
mention about
two repofts, there is specitrc
of the land
guntas of land ttom out
lor the
aforesaid persons/t.anners'
acquisition of Acs'l'10
held by the petitioners and
pulpose of formation of
2l -
R&B Road'
that e-pattadar passbook
was issued
on verification of
petitioners'
would reveal
The aforesaid discussion
to possession of the petitioners
disputes with regard
the
property. They have not mentioned
of tand for
the details of acquisition
that there are
over the subject
details of Acs'7'19
to third parlies.
of Acs.r0.35 guntas sold
\
the
leamed Assistant
ol revenue records' but not
basing on veriftcation
physical possession of the
latest pattadar
above' in the aforesaid
of
20. lt is the specific contention
Revenue
Govemment Pleader for
Village'
guntas out
They have not mentioned
the purpose of formation
of R&B
t4
KI-,J
Road. Even there are
were not brought 1o
C C No. t 654 of2o24
several disputed questions
the notice of this Court
aforesaid writ petition
petition was disposed
of at the admission stage.
respondents to Ille
aforesaid facts.
22. 'fo punish the respondents
l2 of the Contempt of
be willful and deliberate
--)
conrempr j urisdiction
Thcrefore, there was
counter narrating the
- contenl.tors in terms of
CoLrrts Act, 197 l, there
of proceedings to refer
Court Bar Association v.
the Constitution Bench
shall
elucidating on the
held thus:
olCoun rs a special.f urisdictio
to be exercised sparingly
n
and rvith cau tion
whencver an act
advcrsely allects
administration ofjusticc
Its coursc or tcnds to
be exercised when
allbcts the majesty
the
or which tends to irnpcde
shake public confid
the judicial insritutions.
a lso
oi. advcrsclv
ol larv or dignity ol t he
Thc purpose of contcmpt
cncc tn
This.jurisdiction nr ay
the act complained
to the
[lni6n of Indial wherein
of the Apex Court whilc
"42. The contL,mpr
(1998)4 s( C 409
The said writ
violation of the order..
It is apposire at this junclure
case in Supreme
while disposing of the
vide order under contempt.
no opportunit), to the
Sectrons - l0 and
of fact. The same
Courts.
jurisdiction is to uphold
l5
KL,J
C.C. No.l654 of2024
the Courts of law' lt is
jurisdiction combining "the
the majesty and dignity of
an unusual type of
it is so
jury, the judge and the hangman" and
any
the Court is not adjudicating upon
because
This jurisdictiolr
claim between titigating parties
of an
is not exercised to protect the dignity
the administration
individuat judge but to prolect
[n the general
of justice frorn being maligned'
it is imperative that the
interest of the community
not be imperilted and
authority oI Courts should
interference in the
there should be no unjustifiable
administration ol justicc'
It is a matter between the
third parties cannot
Court and the contemncr and
in a sutntnary manner in
intervcne. lt is exerciscd
justice' the majesty of
aid ol the administration ol
No such act can
law and the dignity ol'the Courts'
the tcndency to
be permitted thich rnay havc
in the lairness and
shake thc public corrfidence
of iustice'"
impartiality oithe administration
24. In Niaz Mohammad v' State
of HarYana2, the APex Court
and the
elucidated on willful disobedience
relevant paragraph is
extracted herein below:
"9. Section 2(b) of the Contempt
of Courts Act'
I (hereinafter ref'erred to as 'the Act')
defines
,,civil contempt" to mean "rvitlul disobedience to
'?.
(r994) 6 scc 3i2
L6
KI-,J
CC No.l654 of202{
an), judgment, decree,
direction
order, rvrit or
olher process ol'a Court.,,
Whcre the contempt consists
with or carry out an order
lavour ofa party, it is a
has lteen lnade can move
such order or dircction
the Court for initiatins
procceding for contempt
contemner. with a view
partl in u,hose favour an
against the allegei
orl]i:H [J:::
But such a procceding is
pr-occcding under Codc
not like an execution
of Civil proccdure. .l.he
order has been passetl, is
cntitled to rhe benefit of
such order. l.he Court
l4rilc considering the issue
allegcd conrernner should
hai,ing cornplied with
of a Court madc in
civil contetnpt. The person
or porsons in u,hose favour
florving rrom the order
in [ailurc to cornpl1,.
as to rvhcther the
bc punishecl Ibr not
and carried out thc direction
ol'the Court, Itas to take into
consideration all lacts
and circumstances ofa particular
case. That is rvhv
thc lramers of the Act while
defining civil
conterlpt. have said that
it rnusr bc rvilful
disobedience to any judgment,
orcler, ivrit or other process
contcmncr is punished
of a Court. Bclore a
for non_compliance of the
dircction of a Court, the
Court must not. only bc
:atisficd rrbout the disobedience
decrce. direction or
oI an1 .judgrnenl.
writ but shoulij also bc
salisfied that such disobedience
intcrrtional. l.hc civil
decree. direction.
was willul and
Court rvhile cxecuting a
KL,.J
C.C. No 1654 o12024
decree against the judgmenrdebtor
is not
the disobedience
concerned and bothered whether
a
to any judgment, or decree, was wilful Once
decree has been passed it is the
duty of the Court
to execute the decree whatever may be
white examining the
consequence thereof' But
invoked the
grievance of the person who has
jurisdiction of the Court to initiate the proceeding
before
for contempt lor disobedience oI its order'
and punished'
any such contemner is held guilty
the Court has to record a l-rnding
that such
intcntional lf lrom
disobedience was willul and
case' brought to
the circumstances ol a particular
is satisfied that
the notice of thc Court, the Court
but such
although there has been a disobedience
disobedience is the rcsult of
circumstanccs under rvhich it
some compelling
rr'as not possible for
order' thc Court
the contemner to comply with the
may not punish the alleged contemner'"
25.Whilereviewingthenatureofcontemptploceedings,itis
important to examine the acts of the
clarified that while the beneficiary
enforcement, the evaluation of
atleged contemnor' The Court
has
o[ a Court order is entitled to its
whether a contemnor should be
punished for non-compliance involves
a comprehensive consideration
The ContemPt of Courts Act
circumstances
and
facts
of all relevant
wittfut
specifies that civil contempt involves
disobedience of Court
t8
KL.J
C C. No 1654 of202.l
order. Consequentl),, before
a contemnor can be penalized,
must asceftain not only that
there has been disobedience
such disobedience was deliberate
that the disobedience was
t'uakc a spccilic finding
a contemnor can be
to punishment, the court has
The Courl must
to this effect. Furthermore, if
the Cour1, upon
disoberlicnce occurred due
of a particular case, concludes that
to extenuating factors, it retains the
discrction to rcll.ain liorn punishing
acknorr ledging lhe anomaly,
Courl in a sinrilar view held
the alleged conternnor despite
il anv.
17. [n Kanwar Singh Saini v.
High Court of Delhir, the Apex
as under:
30. In an appropriate case where
crrcrrrnstances exist, the
exceptional
Court may also resort to
tltc pror isions applicablc in
case of civil contempt,
o[' violation/breach of undertaking/
udslnent/ order or decree.
However. belore
CA SE
passur-s an). final order
on such applicalion, the
corrrl ,lrst satisry itserf that
srrch .iLrtl-enrcnt. dccree,
there is violation or
direction or order and such
disobcdiencc is n,ilful and
'. (l0ll ) J SC(,' r.tr
to satisry
both willful and intentional.
exarlining thc circumstances
IN
but also that
and intentional.
26. In a conternpt proceeding, before
adjudged guirty and subjected
the Court
intentional. Though in a
KI-,J
C C. No.l654 of2024
case of execution of a decree, the executing
Court
ol
may not be bothered whether the disobedience
the decree is wilfut or not and the Court is bound
to execute a decree whatever may be the
consequence thereof. In a contempt
proceeding'
the alleged contemnor may satisfy the Court that
disobedience has been under some compelling
circumstances, and in that situation, no punishment
can be awarded to him."
xxxx xxxx xxxx
"38. The contempt proceedings bcing quastis
criminal in nature, the standard of proof rcquired
'[he
cascs
crirninal
other
in
as
manner
same
the
in
of
alleged contemnor is entitled to the protoction
all safeguards/rights which are provided in the
criminal jurisprudence, including the bcncfit of
doubt. There must be a clear-out case of
obstruction of administration ofiustice
by a party
ambit
intentionally to bring the matter u'ithin the
only
of the said provision. The case should not rcst
on surmises and conjectures' In Debabrata
Bandhopadhyaya v. State of W B' [AIR 1969
as
189 : 1969 Cri LJ 4011 , this Court observed
SC
under: (AIR P. 193, Para 9)'
"9. A question whether there is contempt of
is
Court or not is a serious one The Court
judge ol the
both. the accuser as well as the
accusation. It behoves the Courl to act with
as
great circumspection as possible making all
KL,J
C C. No. t654 of2021
allowances fbr crrors of judgment
and
dilficulties arising from inveterate practices
Courts irnd tribunals. It is only when
in
a clear
case o f c:outunracious conduct not
explainable
otlrcrwisc. ariscs that the contemnor
must be
punishecl. ... Punislrment under
the law of
conteurpl is called lor when the
lapse is
deiibcralo and in disregard of one,s
duty and
in rletlancc ol'authorit1,. To take action
tunclcar c.rsc is to make the law
in an
of contempt
do llutr lirr other t)teasures and is
not to be
cIc()uraged.' (crtrphasis added),,
Provinp the syrecir)c inrention bchind
Conseclrrentiy. in such an event,
an act or omission is improbabre.
Courts must approach this issue
objcctiiclv. presLirninil intention based
indir iduels are
on the actions taken, AS
gencralll, presumed to intend the
probable
consequcnccs of their ar:tions
28. In I]ahvantbhai Somabhai Bhandari
v. Hiralal
Somabhai Contractor (clcceascd) rep.
by LRs.a, relied on the
principles laid dorln b; Niaz Mohammad2,
Union r" Dharam Gorlha,i Ram Kishan
v. Tarun Bajaj6 and atso
the definition ol .rvillful. lrorn Btack,s
lrdition ar Page 1599 along u,ith the
2013 rNS(' 305
(100 t
S(tC I
(10 tJ ) 16 S( C :0.1
)
Ashok paper Kamgar
Law Dictionary, Sixth
definition o.f .civit contempt,
2l
KI,.J
CC. No l65a ot202{
under Section - 2 (b) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, rhe Apex
Court in paragraph No.56 held as under:
"56. Hence, the expression or word "wilful"
means act or omission which is done voluntarily
or intentionally and with the specific intent ro do
something which the law forbids or with rhc
specific intent to fail to do something the law
requires to be done, that is to say with bad
purpose either Page 44 of 83 to disobey or to
disregard the law. It signifies a deliberate acrion
done with evil intent or with a bad motivc or
purpose."
29. As discussed above, in the present casc, [he respontlcnts
have inlormed the petitioners herein that it is not possible ro conducr
surwe1,. If the petitioners are aggrieved by the repon rlatcd 2:1.07.1024
o f rcspondent No.4 submitted to respondent No.3 hercin, thcv have to
take steps in accordance with law. They can as well filc a suit,
rvhcrein they can seek for appointment of an Advocal.e Cornmissioner
under Order - XXVI, Rule - 9 of CPC for survey ol the subject land
with the assistance of officials of Survey Department. They l-ravc to
avail a loresaid two options.
2)
KI.J
C.C. No 1654 of2024
30. In the light of thc aloresaid discussion, this Court is of the
considered view that therc is no willful and deliberate violation of the
ordcr undcr conternpt. by the respondents
l.
1-hc prescnt Conternpt Case is accordingly dismissed.
There shall be no order as to costs
As a seqircl thereto, rnisccllaneous petitions, if any, pending in
the Contempt Casc ;hall stan<l closed
SD/- P.GOWRI SHANKAR
DEPUTY REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
,)
ECTION OFFICER
To,
1. Two CCs to the Asslstarlt GP for Revenue, High Court
Telangana at liYderabad IOUTI
2. One CC to Srr I t)S Harsha' Advocate [OPUC]
3. Two CD CoPtes
VH/PSIY*-
for the State of
o
HIGH COURT
DATED: 20102t2026
_-,-: -r-_:I::---
iir! SL;N
^a:\
//1
.-l
-)
ORDER
CC.No.1654 of 2024
\'t lr
23,! l,il rtt'ri i ii
t
t
.!PA T
-:_
DISMISSING THE CC
6 ,deA
tu
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review