Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 3405 ]
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
FRIDAY, THE TENTH DAY OF JULY
TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
ARBITRATION APPLICATION No: 118 ot 2025
Between:
Meka Gopala Krishna, S/o Meka Raja Rao Aged about 63 years
Occ. Retd.employee R/o Flat No.501 SS Grandeur, Phase-V K.P.H B.Colony,
Kukatpally Medchal-Malkajgiri Dist
...Applicant
AND
Dirishala Naresh Chowdary, S/o Dirishala Kannaiah Aged about 33,
Occ: Business and R/o H.No.'1-6211 , 4th floor Kavuri Hills, Jubilee Hilts
Hyderabad-500 033.
... Respondent
Arbitration Application under Section 1 1(5) & (6) of the Arbitration and
Conciliation Act, 1996 praying that the High Court may be pleased to Appoint Sole
Arbitrator, viz. Sri. K.Sangareddy, Retired Districl Judge, R/o H.No.1-'l 12lSY03/RAE/711, Rasun-Ace Elysion, Hanuman Nagar, Raghavendra Colony, Kondapur,
Hyderabad-S0O 084 for resolving the disputes between the Applicant and the
Respondent-
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI N NAVEEN KUMAR
Counsel for the Respondent: SRI CHEKURI YADAGIRI
The Gourt made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD
THE HON'BLE JUSTICE MOUSHUMI BHATTACHARYA
ARBITRATION APPLI CA TION No. 118 of2O2S
DATE: 10.07.2026
BETWEEN:
Mt l<a Gop.rla Krishna
.
..Applicant
AND
Dir-isha NiLresh ('hou'cliLn'
.. .Ilesponclent
\,lr \ \a\('cn KLlirit. lear lLr'(l coLlnsci appearing for the apJ)llcant'
Mr Chek,.rri Yadagiri, learned counsel appearing for the respondent'
ORDER
t.
Tho dispr-rtc frctu'ecn the partres arist's out ol' an
Agrcemenr of Sale cxccuted befit'een the parties on 24 04 '2024 '
'i'hc responder'tL is tll(' r'cntior' and the applicanr he rein is the
'prrrchasCt'' in tlrt: Aqr ct'ment ol Salc.
2.
Clause 13 of the Agrr-'emenl of Sale states that any
disputes rtrisit-ts. belut cn thc parties \r'iLh regard to the tcrms
an(l condrtions stior-rlirted irr the Agreement oi Sale shall, at l.he
iirsr instance bL' setriccl bl' the re pre sen tiltives of the parties and
upor-r l'ailure to reacfr a resolution shall thereafter, be relerred
MB,J
Arb.Appl._.l 18 2025
to an Arbitrator and lhc Award passed shall be linal and
binding upon both the parties
3.
The case of the applicant (purchaser) is that he paid an
amount of Rs.2,60,OO,000/- to Lhe respondent (vcndor) for
purchasing of Vill No.A-17, Plot No.A 17 in Survey No.3l4 (Part)
and Survey No.317 (Part) situated at RK-CPR Bellavista Phase-t
& II of Nallagandla Village, Serilingampally Mandal, Ranga
I?eddy District ('the Property'). The applicant however had a
balance of Rs.10,00,000/- to be paid to the rcspondent at rhe
rimc oI registraLion or thrcc months lrom the date of the
Agreement o[ Sale. 'l'he tabular statcmcnt show.s that the total
amount of Rs.2,60,00,000/ - paid by the applicant to the
respondent as on the date of the Agreement of Sale i.e.,
24.04.2024 , forms part ol the Agreement of Sale.
4.
The grievance of the applicant is that despite the
rcspondent receiving Rs.2,60,O0,0O0/-, the respondent failed ro
register thc sale dccd in rcspect of the propcrtv purchased by
the applicant till dare . The applicant was hence constrained to
invoke the Arbrtration Agreement and suggest the name of the
Arbitrator by way of a Notice dated 24 ,O4.2025.
5.
The respondent rcplicd to the Notice on 16.0S.202S
stating that the respondent had availed a loan of
MB,J
Arb.Appl. I 18 2025
Rs.I ,90,00,0001- from the applicant and tltal the applicant had
made thc respondcnt srgn on blank u'hite papers as s'el1 as
rmprint tht'ir thurrb imprcssions on other papers and handed
o\ cr the ,-rriginal rcsisicrccl sale dced of tlrc schedule propert-v
to*'ards sccuritr' for thc repayment of the t ntire loan amount to
thr: applii ant. Tht respondenr also dcnied executing lhe
Ailrcemcnt ol' Saic Lrctrveen thc parties and lhc e:xistcncc of an1'
dispure bet$'ccn rhc pitrties uhich 'lould lvarrant lhc
al)pointmcnt of an Arbitralor.
(t.
I hitvc ht:artl submissions madc on behalf of lhc parties
7.
Lr:arncd colrnsel appcaring for the allplicant submits that
the respondent hzLs recc-ivecl an amount of Rs 2,60,00,000/ - and
rhar a balance cf Rs.1O.OO,O00/- rcmalns to be paid Llorvcver,
thr: respt-rndenl rcl'LISes to rcgisLer thc salc deed in favour ol the
:rpplicanL ciespire rcceiving a substantial sum of thc total sale
considertrtiot'i.
l-c:rrtted t'ortttsel appcaring ior thc respondenl opposcs
the app()intment oI an Arbitrator on the ground that Lhe
Arbitration Agret'ment is a forged docltment and that the
rcsponcicrri haci ortlv Lakt'rt a loan ol lRs. I,90,00,000/- from lhe
altplicant Cciuttst l also rrtakes claboraLc submissitlns on the
errors cronLained rn the order dated 17.Oa;.2024 passed by lhe
MB,J
Arb.Appl._1 18-2025
learned XIV Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad
("lrial Court'), in Arb. O.P. No.50 oI 2024 llled under Section 9 of
the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (A & C Act'), by the
applicant for seeking perpetual injunction.
9.
First and foremost, thc question of adjudicating an].
allegcd crror containcd rn thc ordcr passcd by rhe Trial Court in
Arb. O.P. No.50 o[ 2024 does not arise since the present
Arbitration Application has been Illed under sections 1 1(5) and
1 1(6)
ol the A & C Act, solely for the purpose of the appointment
of an Arbitrator. The respondent has a statutory recourse
available to him for challenging the order passed by the Trial
Court. This Court is neilher the forum nor is the Arbitration
Application the proper route for such a challenge.
10. It is evident from the respondent's reply dated 16.05.2025
to the Notice sent by the applicant, that there are substantial
disputes existing bctr,",ccn the parties as on date. The hrst
dispute including the quantum of money received by the
respondent from the applicant and the purpose for which the
respondent received an amount of Rs. 1 ,90,00,0O0/ - as alleged
by the respondent or lls.2,60,00,00O/ - as alleged by rhe
applicant. The second dispute is with regard to whether the
Agreement of Sale /Arbitration Agreement is a forged document.
-
MB,,J
Arb.AppL._1 18_2025
The Agreement of Sale contains a rabulatecl statement of
arnounts ,,r hich r,r't: r c paid bv thc applic.ril to [hc rcsponclcnt
i.t., Rs.l.o0,O().00O, as on the date ol Agreement o[ Sale i.e.,
24 .O4.2A24 . There rs also a third dispute with regard to the
possession ol-lhe subJict propert\,. While the applicant contends
fhzrt hc rs in posst:ssion since 24.O4.2O24, the respondent
conLends that he is in possr:ssion of the subject Dropertv. These
t,h rce dispures are sLrlficient for the Court to flnd that the matter
sqr-iarelr lalls r,rr-rder sccLions 1 1(5) and I 116) of the A & C Act,
and is zrlso coverecl lrv r:lausc 13 ol' thc Aqrecmenr of Salc
1.
The Supreme Court in Rolia Begum u. Bamoli Mttkherjeer
aflirmed thai thc Courts ma]' sidctrack an Arbitration
Agr-eemcnt and lrroccccl s'tth the suit v,'here seriolrs, complicated
allcgatrons of fraud rcquired evidence-bascd adjudication. The
Supreme Court also applied the two tests laid down in Rashid
Rctzct t,. Srdaj'Akhtctr Lo deLermine non ilrbrtrabiiity on grounds
ol lraud and uohe ld rhat thc respondcnt rherein hacl lailcd to
prriduce tJre ongLnal Admission l)ced, and accordingl_.i declined
rntcrim p rotec 1j()n.
12. Thc prest'nt cusc is drfferent as, unlike in Rajict Begum,
rhe responden L herr: has failed to adrluce any evidence
SCC On Line S( l 3.r
"2016
'(2O.,9)8SCC7r0
ArbAppt.
s ir
ircYi;{
bstaritiatin g thc allegation that the Arbitration Agreement was
forged or thc Agreement of Sale lr'as fabricated. In the absence
of such proof, the Arbitration Agreement cannot be sidetracked.
The present case also does not fall within the ambit of nonarbitrability, as envisaged in RajicL Begum.
13. Needless to say, the present case is being considered
under sections 11(5) and 11(6) of the A & C Act, w,hich
empowers the High Court to appoint an Arbitrator when a
dispute arises between the parties. Clause 13 of the Agreement
ol Sale dated 24.04.2024 provides for the appointment of an
ArbiLrator.
14. Sri P. Kalyan Rao, Retired District Judge, residing at Flat
No. 1 007, Shree Kamala Group Luxurio 75 Residency, Narne
Estate Road, Spring Valley, S.No.49, Madeenaguda,
Serilingampally, Kondapur, Ranga Reddy District, Telangana -
500 084, Phone No. 9966372333, is hence appointed as the
Solc Arbitralor to adjudicate the dispute between the parties.
15. The parties shall appear before the Arbitrator on
24.O7.2026 at 11:00 A.M., along wrth a copy of this order. The
Arbitrator shall thereafter proceed with the arbitral proceedings
in accordance rvith lar,'"'.
.-,?--..
-
MB,J
Arb. Appl. l lB 2025
1(). 'l'he ptrrties arc aL libertv to raiso all the contentious
issues be[ort-' the learned Arbitrator. The lee of the Arbitrator as
r.r'cll as orh. r terms ernd conditions shall be settled by the
pzrrtii:s in consultation u'ith thc Arbitrator so appointcd.
17' Arbirratron Applrcation No. 1 18 of 2025, zriong u'ith all
connectecl applications. is drsposcd of. 'lhere shall bc no ordcr
a- :\,\ r5l\.
SD/- M.VIJAYA BHASKER
JOINT REGISTRAR
//TRUE COPY//
,7
(.+
SECTION OFFICER
To,
Flat No 1007
resrding at
.Shree
1. Sri P. Kalyan Rao, Retired District Judge'
-Natne
spring Valley'
Road'
Estate
Resioency,
zs
Luxurio
Kamala Group
Ranga Reddy Drstrict,
S.No.49, Madeenaguda, seritingrrprtty, Kondapur,
(Along
Messenger)
Telangana-50008a Pnone No sdooszzsis (By Special
*itt, Copy of affidavit and material papers) for the State of Telangana'
" Section Officer, OS Section, Uign Court
2. To the
Hyderabad
S. On" CC to Sri N Naveen Kumar, Advocate [OPU-C]
; O;" CC to Sri Chekuri Yadagiri, Advocate IOPUC]
5. Two CD CoPies
4e
BK/KN
HIGH COURT
DATED: 1010712026
-;
\
,
ORDER
ARBAPPL.No.118 ot 2025
rrE
oi\
t).
!ii'
t;.
\,i
2 0 JUt 2m6
1,,.
\L
DISPOSING OF THE ARBAPPL WITHOUT COSTS
I
?e
7 )b
S l"i r' E
r-
lr'
.1,./
'',:'
za/
--ar'
>l
!.
,;
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review