Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 22
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 133 of 2024
Date of Decision: 20.05.2024
Megindia Medical Supplier
Through its Proprietor (i.e., Mr. Rakesh Giri),
having its registered address at Fancy Valley,
Tura, West Garo Hills, Meghalaya,
PIN: 794 001
-Vs1.State of Meghalaya
Represented by its Commissioner and
Secretary, Department of Health Shillong,
Meghalaya
2.Tura Civil Hospital
Through its Superintendent
Tura, West Garo Hills, Meghalaya
3.Department of Health Services (M.I)
Through its Director,
Shillong, Meghalaya
4.The Tender Committee
Through its Member(s)
Tura Civil Hospital, Tura,
West Garo Hills, Meghalaya
5.The Deputy Commissioner
Tura, West Garo Hills District,
Meghalaya
:::Petitioner
6.Arengh Medical Supplier
Tura, West Garo Hills District,
Meghalaya
:::Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :Mr. K. Paul, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. C. Garg, Adv.
Mr. S. Chanda, Adv.
Ms. K. Decruse, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:Mr. A. Kumar, AG with
Mr. A. Kharwanlang,Addl.Sr.GA(ForR 1-5)
Dr. N. Mozika, Sr. Adv. with
Ms. K. Goyal, Adv.
Mr. V. Kapoor, Adv.
Mr. S. Datta, Adv.
Mr. A. Sharda, Adv.
Mr. M.L. Nongpiur, Adv. (For R 6).
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL)
1.
This application under Article 226 of the Constitution has been
preferred questioning the action of the respondents No. 1-5, in awarding
the tender dated 03.10.2023, to the respondent No. 6 for supply and
installation of a 1.5 TESLA MRI Machine on Turnkey basis at Tura Civil
Hospital, inspite of the tender committee having approved the bid of the
petitioner.
2.
The brief facts necessary are that the respondent No. 2
(Superintendent of Tura Civil Hospital), on 03.10.2023, had floated a
tender inviting bids from eligible and qualified bidders for supply and
installation of a 1.5 TESLA MRI Machine on Turnkey basis at Tura Civil
Hospital. In response to the tender, only two bids were submitted, one by
the petitioner and the other by the respondent No. 6, and the said bids were
opened on 08.11.2023. A Tender Committee or Purchase Committee in this
case, which had been duly constituted as per the directions of the Head
Department, through the Executive Committee of the Tura Civil Hospital
Management Society (HMS), then approved the purchase of the MRI
machine to be supplied by the petitioner. However, it appears thereafter,
the matter was then re-examined by the Hospital Management Committee,
who then awarded the supply order to the respondent No. 6, on the primary
ground that the price quoted by the respondent No. 6, was lower than that
of the petitioner. The petitioner being aggrieved thereby, is seeking
cancellation and recall of the impugned work order.
3.
Mr. K. Paul, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. C. Garg, learned
counsel for the petitioner has at the outset referred to clause – 15 of the bid
document, and submits that as per this condition, the decision of technical
suitability by the committee was not to be opened for discussion, and that
clause – 12 has also provided that, the respondent Hospital was not bound
to accept the lowest quoted rate. In the instant case he submits, after the
technical aspects had been satisfied, and the MRI machine to be supplied
by the petitioner, which was of a reputed company, had been approved by
the purchase committee, on an expert evaluation, it was not open to the
respondents to reverse the decision and award the said work to the
respondent No. 6. The learned Senior counsel has taken this Court to
Annexure – 2 to the writ petition, which is a letter dated 20.11.2023,
whereby the respondent No. 2, on the selection of the petitioner’s machine
had requested for additional grant of funds, to meet necessary expenditure
to establish the fact that the tender evaluation had already been completed
and that the petitioner was a successful bidder.
4.
Learned Senior counsel then submits that on a letter dated
08.11.2023,
from
the
respondent
No.
6,
the
respondent
No.
2(Superintendent of Tura Civil Hospital) by letter dated 19.12.2023, on the
directions of the Deputy Commissioner (respondent No. 5), who was not a
member of the Purchase Committee, called for a meeting on 21.12.2023, to
discuss the matter with regard to the MRI tender. Strangely he submits, a
reappraisal was conducted under the Chairmanship of the Deputy
Commissioner, and a decision was arrived at to award the work to
respondent No. 6, due to lower cost. The learned Senior counsel submits
that, in the meeting that was held on 21.12.2023, all the members present
were part of the Hospital Management Society of Tura Civil Hospital,
which was not the duly constituted Purchase Committee, as an independent
expert, who was a member of the purchase committee was not present. He
contends that the Deputy Commissioner, who was not a member of the
purchase committee, after the evaluation had been done, by calling for the
meeting and overturning the decision, is absolutely illegal. He further
contends that, the petitioner’s offered product being found to be better
suited, and the price not being a factor, as it was not a case of the
settlement of the tender being given to the lowest bidder, the action of the
respondent No. 5(Deputy Commissioner) as an appellate authority over a
duly constituted purchase committee, is liable to be interfered with by this
Court.
5.
Though it was pointed out that the petitioner was present at the time
the reappraisal of the products was conducted on 21.12.2023, it has been
submitted that the presence of the petitioner in the said meeting cannot in
any manner be taken to mean that the tender process could be re-opened in
the manner in which it was done. He lastly submits that, the impugned
settlement of the tender with the respondent No. 6, being vitiated, the same
is also liable to be recalled or set aside.
6.
In support of his submissions, apart from other citations, the learned
Senior counsel has relied upon the judgment Bharat Cuisine Services
Institute & Anr. vs. State of H.P. & Ors. reported in 2024 SCC OnLine
HP 8, on the point that a technical evaluation committee, after evaluating
technical bids becomes functus officio and as such, there can be no
question of re-evaluation of tenders by other committee.
7.
Mr. A. Kumar, learned Advocate General assisted by Mr. A.
Kharwanlang, learned Addl. Senior Government Advocate on behalf of the
State respondents No. 1-5 has submitted that the NIT was issued by the
Hospital Management Society, of which the respondent No. 5, is the
Chairman, which therefore makes the society, the decision-making
authority, with regard to the acquisition of the MRI machine for Tura Civil
Hospital. It is further submitted that, it is undisputed that, both the
machines offered by the petitioner and by the respondent No. 6, met the
technical specifications, and as the price of the MRI offered by the
petitioner exceeded the price of the MRI, offered by the respondent No. 6,
by over 1 crore, a conscious decision was taken to opt for the MRI, that
cost less. It has also been submitted that, the letter referred to and relied
upon by the petitioner dated 20.11.2023, whereby the Superintendent of
Tura Civil Hospital, requested for additional funds, to acquire the MRI
offered by the petitioner, was unauthorized, and no reliance could be
placed on the same.
8.
The learned Advocate General then submits that, the writ petitioner
though very much present in the meeting held on 21.12.2023, has
suppressed the same and has not made any mention of the same in the writ
petition. He submits that the petitioner having participated in the said
meeting, wherein the appraisal of both the machines was conducted and
thereafter, the supply of the MRI awarded to the respondent No. 6, cannot
at this stage turn around and challenge the same. The learned Advocate
General then contends that the respondents being the owners of the project,
should have the liberty to decide what is best for the State, especially in
this case, where for an equivalent product, the same was being settled with
the lowest bidder. The learned Advocate General has in its affidavit set out
a series of judgments, with regard to judicial review in such matters. He
finally submits that the petitioner having suppressed the fact that, it has
participated in the meetings dated 22.11.2023 and 21.12.2023, and being
aware that the machine offered by the respondent No. 6, was better in
features and also of lesser price, no interference is called for by this Court,
as the present case does not fall within the narrow jurisdiction exercised by
Courts in respect of tender matters.
9.
Dr. N. Mozika, learned Senior counsel assisted by Ms. K. Goyal,
learned counsel for the respondent No. 6, while supporting the submissions
of the learned Advocate General, has however advanced the argument that
the opening of bids on 08.11.2023, did not conclude the tender process,
inasmuch as thereafter, meetings were held of the bidders and the Tender
Committee on two occasions i.e. on 22.11.2023 and 21.12.2023,
whereafter, the final settlement of the tender was arrived at. The petitioner,
he contends, has misrepresented and concealed materials before this Court
when in fact it is not disputed, that the MRI offered by the respondent No.
6, apart from meeting all the technical specifications, was also much
cheaper than the MRI offered by the petitioner. As such, he submits on
both counts, the offer of the respondent No. 6 being more feasible, no
vested right has accrued to the petitioner to assail the tender process.
Learned Senior counsel then reiterates the submissions that the petitioner
having participated in the meetings after the initial bid opening, cannot
insist that the tender process had concluded on 08.11.2023 when the bids
were opened, when in fact it was a continuous process which culminated in
the settlement of the work with the respondent No. 6. It is lastly submitted
that the respondent No. 6, has already commenced civil works for
installation of the MRI and as the project is in public interest, the same can
brook no delay. Reliance has also been placed on various decisions on the
scope of judicial review in such matters.
10.
After hearing the learned counsels for the parties, to the mind of this
Court, in exercise of limited jurisdiction as far as judicial review of such
tender matters are concerned, the only issue to be examined is the decisionmaking process adopted by the respondents in settling the tender with the
respondent No. 6, after having found the petitioner’s product to be more
suitable.
11.
In this regard therefore, it would be useful to scrutinize the materials
that have been placed for consideration, from the initial stage that is the
floating of the tender and the constitution of the Purchase or Tender
Committee, hereinafter referred to as the Committee. The NIT was issued
on 03.10.2023, by the Hospital Management Society, Tura Civil Hospital,
for supply and installation of a 1.5 TESLA MRI machine, and conditions
were given therein which is to be noted, at clause – 12 and 15, of the
General Conditions and clause – 10, with regard to Bid Evaluation, which
are very relevant for the purposes of this discussion, and are reproduced
herein below.
“12. The Hospital Management Society, Tura Civil Hospital
is not bound to accept the lowest quoted rates and reserves
the right to reject any tender or part thereof without
assigning any reason and without any liability or liquidated
damages.
15. The decision of the committee on technical suitability
and quality shall not be opened for discussion. Every bidder
must go through the terms and conditions of bid carefully
and understand them before submitting the bid. No excuse
that the conditions have not been read or understood will be
entertained later.
10) BID EVALUATION
Awarding of tender will be based upon the following:
Price
Functionality
Value added benefits
Vendor performance
Upgradability
Patient comfort and safety
Service and support
Clinical applications
Training and technical support of assigned personnel
till they are fully equipped to handle the Equipment.
The evaluation shall be done on total cost of the entire
supply including warranty services, whenever applicable,
as per the bid document and after technical evaluation
and suggestion by a committee of technical expert. Lowest
rate is not the criteria for evaluation, rather the contract
will be awarded to the bidder who can provide the best
quality products and services including training, Bidders
are to submit copies of supply orders or installation
reports of similar items as quoted by them, bidders
quoting on behalf of their principal manufacturers.”
12.
Thereafter, vide letter dated 12.10.2023, the Joint Secretary, Health
and Family Welfare Department, instructed the respondent No. 3, to direct
the respondent No. 2, to constitute a Purchase Committee, through the
Executive Committee of the Tura Civil Hospital Management Society, for
procurement of the said MRI machine, and that the said committee was to
include at least one member for technical expertise in the relevant field. It
is seen thereafter that the respondent No. 2, on the bids being received,
issued a notice on 07.11.2023, for opening of the tenders by the Tender
Committee on 08.11.2023, and as per the minutes of the meeting, which
was chaired by the Additional Deputy Commissioner, who was the
Chairperson of the Tender Committee, it was unanimously decided to
approve and purchase the MRI machine, to be supplied by the petitioner. It
is noteworthy to mention herein that, the approval was arrived at on the
products having met the technical specifications as desired, as is evidenced
by a document annexed at Page – 64 of the affidavit-in-opposition filed by
the respondent No. 5. From the materials, it is seen that on the decision
being finalized, the respondent No. 2, vide letter dated 20.11.2023, had also
requested for placement of additional funds for procurement of the MRI
machine, to be supplied by the petitioner.
13.
From the narrative as given above of the events that had occurred, it
would seem that the tender process in the normal course of business would
have stood concluded, with the selection of the product of the petitioner,
notwithstanding the cost, for which provision had been made in the bid
document itself, that the lowest rate was not to be the criteria for evaluation
rather more consideration would be given to the bidder, who could provide
the better product and services. However, it is seen that the respondent No.
6, by a letter dated 18.11.2023, addressed a letter to the respondent No. 5,
the Deputy Commissioner, requesting his attention to their bids, on the
ground that they were the lowest bidder. Thereafter, vide letter dated
19.12.2023, the respondent No. 2, on a direction of the respondent No. 5,
invited the tender and technical expert committee and others, to attend a
meeting on 21.12.2023.
14.
What unfolded thereafter, as can be seen from the minutes of the
meeting dated 21.12.2023, is that, the respondent No. 5, chaired the said
meeting in his capacity as the Chairman of the Hospital Management
Society, and embarked upon the exercise of examining the comparative
statements and presentations of the products against the required
specifications, and thereafter as the Chairman concluded that the
respondent No. 6, being the lowest bidder was preferred for procurement of
the MRI machine. This decision thereafter culminated in the issuance of the
work order dated 09.03.2024, in favour of the respondent No. 6. From the
proceedings, it can easily be discerned that the decision of a duly
constituted tender committee with expert members, had been superseded by
the decision of the Hospital Management Society, under the chairmanship
of the respondent No. 5. From the recorded minutes, it is also relevant to
note that, an expert one Shri. Amitabh Dutta, who was a member of the
tender committee, who had given his expert opinion as to the suitability of
the petitioner’s MRI, in the tender opening meeting dated 08.11.2023, was
not present.
15.
In this scenario, this Court need not go far, to arrive at a conclusion,
as to whether the impugned action of the respondents in reversing the
decision is sustainable in law. From the conditions of the NIT itself, which
had been quoted above, firstly it has been provided that, the lowest bid
would not be the only consideration for acceptance, which is further
reinforced by the clause, with regard to Bid Evaluation. Secondly, clause –
15, has categorically provided that, the decision of the committee, on
technical suitability shall not be opened for discussion. What has transpired
however, is that the respondent No. 5, as Chairman of the Hospital
Management Society has literally re-opened the technical evaluation and
awarded the tender to the respondent No. 6, and has even gone to the extent
of recording his opinion as to the virtues of the MRI offered by the
respondent No. 6, in his affidavit at Para – 19. As held in the celebrated
case of Tata Cellular vs. Union of India reported in (1994) 6 SCC 651, in
such matters, the Supreme Court at Para – 77 thereof, which is relevant had
held as under.
“77. The duty of the court is to confine itself to the question of
legality. Its concern should be:
1. Whether a decision-making authority exceeded its powers?
2. Committed an error of law,
3. committed a breach of the rules of natural justice,
4. reached a decision which no reasonable tribunal would have
reached or,
5. abused its powers.
Therefore, it is not for the court to determine whether a particular
policy or particular decision taken in the fulfilment of that policy is
fair. It is only concerned with the manner in which those decisions
have been taken. The extent of the duty to act fairly will vary from
case to case. Shortly put, the grounds upon which an administrative
action is subject to control by judicial review can be classified as
under:
(i) Illegality : This means the decision-maker must understand
correctly the law that regulates his decision-making power and
must give effect to it.
(ii) Irrationality, namely, Wednesbury unreasonableness.
(iii) Procedural impropriety.
The above are only the broad grounds but it does not rule out
addition of further grounds in course of time. As a matter of fact,
in R. v. Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex Brind, Lord
Diplock refers specifically to one development, namely, the possible
recognition of the principle of proportionality. In all these cases the
test to be adopted is that the court should, “consider whether
something has gone wrong of a nature and degree which requires
its intervention”.
16.
Placing the facts of the instant case in its proper perspective and by
application of the principles in the afore quoted judgment, the impugned
action of the respondents, is such a case that warrants judicial review of the
decision-making process. What strikes at the very root of the matter is that,
inspite of the stipulations or conditions of the NIT, and the findings of the
tender committee, the respondent No. 5, had opened the tender for reevaluation, despite the fact that he was not a constituent of, or a member of
the duly constituted tender committee, and further on a ground that had
been specifically addressed in the NIT, that the lowest bidder was not the
criteria for selection, had selected the respondent No. 6, on this
consideration. Though submissions have been advanced that, the petitioner
had participated in the re-evaluation process, and had also suppressed the
same before this Court, though the same is deprecated, in the larger picture
considering the actions of the respondent No. 5, the same is of no
consequence.
17.
The contention of the respondent No. 6, that the tender process had
not concluded with the opening of the bids on 08.11.2023, and the same
was continuous is not accepted, in view of the facts and circumstances of
the case.
18.
The authorities placed by the respondents with regard to the
restrictions in the interference in tender matters, and that the respondents be
given latitude and that there be fair play in the joints, are of no assistance in
the facts and circumstances of the present case, and as such are not
discussed.
19.
Accordingly, the award of the contract for supply and installation of
a 1.5 TESLA MRI machine at Tura Civil Hospital, in favour of the
respondent No. 6, is quashed and set aside, as also the consequential work
order dated 09.03.2024.
20.
This Court in setting aside the award of the contract is not oblivious
to the fact that, an MRI machine once installed at Tura, will be a boon to
the populace of the several districts in Garo Hills, and any further
unaccounted delay will severely impact the health care situation. As such,
it is also directed that, the concerned respondents take immediate steps, to
ensure that an MRI machine is installed at the Tura Civil Hospital, at the
earliest through a transparent and fair process.
21.
Writ petition accordingly stands allowed and is disposed of.
22.
No order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
20.05.2024
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review