The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
13. Accordingly, WP (C) No.485 of 2018 is disposed of by dismissing the principal challenge therein to the recommendations of the Fifth State Pay Commission and the State’s decision to implement the same. However, to the extent that excess payment may have been made to the members of the writ petitioner association or other personnel of the Meghalaya Treasury Accounts Service prior to the cut-off date fixed for implementation of the recommendations of the Fifth Meghalaya Pay Commission, the same may not be recovered by the State.
14. As a consequence, MC (WPC) No.253/2018 stands disposed of.
15. There will be no order as to costs. (W. Diengdoh) Judge (Sanjib Banerjee) Chief Justice Meghalaya
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No.01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP (C) No.485/2018 with
MC (WPC) No.253/2018
Date of Order: 21.04.2022
Meghalaya Treasury Accounts
Services Association (MTASA)
Coram:
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & ors
Hon’ble Mr. Justice Sanjib Banerjee, Chief Justice
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner
: Mr. Philemon Nongbri, Adv
For the Respondents
: Mr. K. Khan, Sr.GA with
Mr. S. Sengupta, Add.Sr.GA
Mr. A.H. Kharwanlang, GA
i) Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii) Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes
Yes/No
JUDGMENT: (per the Hon’ble, the Chief Justice) (Oral)
The challenge here is to the acceptance by the State of the
recommendations of the Fifth State Pay Commission pertaining to the
scales of pay of personnel in the Meghalaya Treasury Accounts Service.
2.
The principal ground of challenge is that it was only in 2014
that the State had recognised that the cadre structure of the Meghalaya
Treasury Accounts Service was comparable to that of the Meghalaya
Accounts Service as, in both the cases, the minimum educational
qualifications at the entry-level, the in-service training and the nature of
works were similar. Further, the relevant notification of July 1, 2014
acknowledged that an additional qualification was mandatory for
entrants in the Meghalaya Treasury Accounts Service as the candidates
had to be adept at the use of computers.
3.
Pursuant to the notification of July 1, 2014, the pay-scales of
the three posts under the Meghalaya Treasury Accounts Service were
upgraded for Accountants, Senior Accounts Assistants and Junior
Accounts Assistants such that they were at par with the comparable posts
in the Meghalaya Accounts Service. In its report of July 31, 2017 the
Fifth Meghalaya Pay Commission noticed several anomalies arising as a
result of the upgradation in the pay-scales pertaining to the Meghalaya
Treasury Accounts Service. The Commission noted that earlier State Pay
Commissions had maintained the pay-scales of the Meghalaya
Secretariat Subordinate Service, which is the premier subordinate service
in the State, at a higher level than that of the Meghalaya Subordinate
Treasury Accounts Service. The difference in the pay-scales was noticed
and the Commission observed that “an anomalous position has arisen out
of the State Government decision to sharply increase the pay scales of
the Meghalaya Subordinate Treasury Accounts Service, as indicated
above”.
4.
Upon considering the matter, the Fifth Pay Commission
recommended as follows at paragraph 14.1.5 of its report:
“14.1.5 Having considered all aspects of the matter, the Commission
recommends(a) Status quo in respect of the levels of pay scales of the UDAs
and LDAs under the Meghalaya Secretariat Subordinate Services, as
fixed by the Meghalaya Revision Pay Rules, 2009;
(b) Re-fixation of the pay levels of the Meghalaya Subordinate
Treasury Accounts Service, with effect from the date of
implementation of the Commission’s recommendations, as follows–
Accountant : Level – 12 (starting at Rs 39400)
Senior Accounts Assistant: Level – 11 (starting at Rs 37800)
Junior Accounts Assistant: Level – 8 (starting at Rs 30300)
(c) The pay of the affected Members of the Meghalaya Subordinate
Treasury Accounts Service may be protected in the Pay levels as
recommended above with reference to the actual amount drawn as
Pay and DA on the effective date, under the relevant provisions of
the Meghalaya F.Rs and S.Rs.”
5.
The writ petitioner association complains that when the State
government perceived as recently as in 2014, that the duties discharged
by the personnel in the two branches were the same or comparable and
when the State acknowledged that an additional technical qualification
was necessary to be recruited into the Meghalaya Treasury Accounts
Service, the Fifth Pay Commission could not have undone the same,
particularly without specifically disagreeing with the reason for the
upgradation indicated in the notification
of July 1, 2014.
The
underlying submission is that the mere resentment of the other group of
employees would not be a relevant consideration for, in effect,
downgrading another cadre of State employees.
6.
The other contention of the writ petitioner association is that as
a consequence of the recommendations of the Fifth Pay Commission and
its acceptance and implementation by the State, there is a possibility of
the State seeking to recover the additional pay that may have been
released to the members of the writ petitioner association and others of
their ilk in line with the pay-scales applicable to similar posts in the
Meghalaya Accounts Service.
7.
As far as the first aspect of the matter is concerned, it must be
said that the scope of judicial review is limited when it comes to a
decision for upgrading or refusing to upgrade the pay or emoluments of
a cadre of employees and, ordinarily, it is the prerogative of the
executive that prevails. However, if the decision is found to be
outlandish or crass irrational, the Court may intervene.
8.
In the present case, the State has merely accepted the
recommendations in such regard by a specialised body which was set up
for the purpose of determining the pay-scales of different cadres of State
employees. Once such specialised body has indicated a semblance of
reasoning upon applying its mind to the matters in issue and the State, in
its discretion, has accepted the same, the Court will not, in its
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, interfere
therewith. At the end of the day, in this jurisdiction the Court is more
concerned with the decision-making process rather than the decision
itself, unless the decision shocks the conscience of the Court or appears
to be grossly disproportionate.
9.
The matter would have been different if the pay-scales had
been lowered. Under the general rules of pay protection that have
developed in the service jurisprudence in this country, once a pay-scale
is granted to a person or a cadre, it cannot be subsequently altered to the
detriment or prejudice of the individual or the cadre. In the present case,
pursuant to the notification of July 1, 2014, the highest levels of the payscales for Accountants, Senior Accounts Assistants and Junior Accounts
Assistants in the Meghalaya Treasury Accounts Service were pegged at
Rs.30,610/-, Rs.28,780/-, Rs.27,510/-, respectively. Pursuant to the
recommendations of the Fifth Pay Commission, the Accountants, Senior
Accounts Assistants and Junior Accounts Assistants in the Meghalaya
Treasury Account Service start at the levels of Rs.39,400/-, Rs.37,800/Page 5 of 8
and Rs.30,300/-, respectively. This is not a case of any pay being
lowered.
10.
The real grievance of the writ petitioner is that its members
could not keep up with the Joneses in the Meghalaya Accounts Service
and there may have been some loss of face in their upgraded status under
the notification of July 1, 2014 not being retained in the
recommendations of the Fifth Pay Commission.
11.
There is, however, merit in the second ground canvassed. It is
possible that the pay-scales recommended by the Fifth Pay Commission
are to be implemented with retrospective effect and till the date when the
actual implementation starts, personnel in the Meghalaya Treasury
Accounts Service may have been paid at par with the personnel holding
similar posts in the Meghalaya Accounts Service. To such extent, there
is a possibility that the excess amount paid to personnel of the
Meghalaya Treasury Accounts Service may be attempted to be recovered
by the State on the ground of excess payment.
12.
That would be clearly impermissible. Once an employee or a
group of employees has been paid at a particular level pursuant to a
considered decision, even if erroneously, the additional or excess
payment made may not be recovered unless the additional payment was
made as a result of some fraud perpetrated by the employee or the
employees concerned or the additional payment was induced by such
employee or employees.
In the present case, it was a government
notification of July 1, 2014 that placed the personnel in the Meghalaya
Treasury Accounts Service at par with those occupying comparable
posts in the Meghalaya Accounts Service. The payments that have been
made to the personnel in the Meghalaya Treasury Accounts Service till
the date of implementation of the recommendations of the Fifth State
Pay Commission, even if higher than what has been recommended by
the Pay Commission, cannot be recovered since the additional payment
was not fraudulently obtained by the personnel of the Treasury cadre nor
otherwise induced by such personnel.
13.
Accordingly, WP (C) No.485 of 2018 is disposed of by
dismissing the principal challenge therein to the recommendations of the
Fifth State Pay Commission and the State’s decision to implement the
same. However, to the extent that excess payment may have been made
to the members of the writ petitioner association or other personnel of
the Meghalaya Treasury Accounts Service prior to the cut-off date fixed
for implementation of the recommendations of the Fifth Meghalaya Pay
Commission, the same may not be recovered by the State.
14.
As a consequence, MC (WPC) No.253/2018 stands disposed of.
15.
There will be no order as to costs.
(W. Diengdoh)
Judge
(Sanjib Banerjee)
Chief Justice
Meghalaya
21.04.2022
“Lam DR-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review