Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
1 / 13
CGHC010337582026
2026:CGHC:40324-DB
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
ALFIZA
BAIG
Digitally signed
by ALFIZA BAIG
Date: 2026.09.21
11:05:57 +0530
WA No. 849 of 2026
Meena Sahu W/o Raghuwar Sahu, Aged About 53 Years Posted And Working
As Assistant Teacher (L.B.) At Govt. Primary School Khora, Block Bhanupratappur, District - North Bastar Kanker (C.G.)
... Appellant
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through Its Secretary, School Education
Department, Mahanadi Bhawan, Atal Nagar, Nawa Raipur, District - Raipur
(C.G.)
2 - State Of Chhattisgarh, Through Its Secretary, Panchayat And Rural
Development Department, Mahanadi Bhawan, Atal Nagar, Nawa Raipur,
District - Raipur (C.G.)
3 - Director, Directorate Of Public Instruction, Indrawati Bhawan, Atal Nagar,
Naya Raipur, District Raipur (C.G.)
4 - Chief Execitive Officer Zila Panchayat Zila Panchayat Rajnandgaon,
District Rajnandgaon (C.G.)
5 - Chief Executive Officer Zila Panchayat, Zila Panchayat Jashpur, District
Jashpur (C.G.)
6 - Chief Executive Officer Janpad Panchayat, Janpad Panchayat
Rajnandgaon, District Rajnandgaon (C.G.)
2 / 13
7 - Chief Executive Officer Janpad Panchayat, Janpad Panchayat
Pathalgaon, District Jashpur (C.G.)
8 - Chief Executive Officer Zila Panchayat Kanker, District North Bastar
Kanker (C.G.)
9 - Chief Executive Officer Janpad Panchayat Bhanupratappur, District North
Bastar Kanker
10 - Chief Executive Officer Janpad Panchayat Dongargarh, District
Rajnandgaon (C.G.)
11 - Chief Executive Officer Zila Panchayat Mohla, District Mohla-ManpurAmbagarh Chowki (C.G.)
12 - Chief Executive Officer Janpad Panchayat Mohla, District Mohla-ManpurAmbagarh Chowki (C.G.)
13 - Chief Executive Officer Zila Panchayat Korba, District Korba (C.G.)
14 - Chief Executive Officer Janpad Panchayat Katghora, District Korba
(C.G.)
15 - Chetanand Khuntia S/o Kumarmani Khuntia Aged About 43 Years Posted
And Working As Lecturer (L.B.) At Govt. H.S. School Gharjiyabathan, Block Pathalgaon, District – Jashpur
16 - Vinita James W/o Late Jai Raj James Aged About 61 Years Posted And
Working As Assistant Teacher (L.B.) At Govt. Primary School Parikala, Block Rajnandgaon, District - Rajnandgaon (C.G.)
17 - Smt. Chandrawati Yadav W/o Ashish Kumar Yadav, Aged About 39 Years
Posted And Working As Head Master At Govt. Primary School Dhara, Block Dongargarh, District - Rajnandgaon (C.G.)
3 / 13
18 - Dhaneshwari Kodape D/o Lakhan Lal Ghawade Aged About 45 Years
Posted And Working As Teacher (L.B.) At Govt. Middle School Dumartola,
Block - Mohla, District - Mohla-Manpur-Ambagarh Chowki (C.G.)
19 - Kamal Singh Kanwar S/o Pawan Singh Kanwar, Aged About 40 Years
Posted And Working As Assistant Teacher (L.B.) At Govt. Primary School
Sirbida, Block - Katghora, District - Korba (C.G.)
... Respondents
For Appellant
:
Mr. Ankush Soni, Advocate
For State
:
Mr. Prasoon Bhaduri, Deputy Advocate General
Division Bench
Hon'ble Shri Parth Prateem Sahu, Judge &
Hon’ble Smt Sushma Sawant, Judge
Order on Board
15.09.2026
Parth Prateem Sahu, Judge
1) Learned counsel for the State submits that the issue which is raised in
this appeal has already been considered and decided by Co-ordinate
Bench of this Court in writ appeals bearing WA No. 191 of 2026 and
WA No. 193 of 2026. He submits that there is inordinate delay of 223
days in filing of this writ appeal and no acceptable explanation has
been offered.
2) Heard IA No. 01/2026, which is an application for condonation of delay
in filing of this writ appeal.
3) On due consideration of the submission made by learned counsel for
the parties as also the reasons assigned in the application, IA No.
01/2026 is allowed. Delay of 223 days in filing of this appeal is hereby
condoned.
4 / 13
4) Also heard on admission.
5) Challenge in this appeal is to the impugned order dated 28.11.2025
(Annexure A/1) passed by learned Singh Judge in a writ petition
bearing WPS No. 13393 of 2025, whereby the writ petition filed by the
appellant (herein) came to be dismissed in the terms of the order dated
24.11.2025 passed in WPS No. 11009 of 2025 between Smt. Abha
Namdeo And Others Vs. State of Chhattisgarh and others.
6) Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the impugned order
passed by the learned Single Judge is erroneous. He submits that the
learned Single Judge while disposing of the writ petition have failed to
take into consideration the decision of Division Bench in case of Smt.
Sona Sahu Vs. State of Chhattisgarh decided on 28.05.2024
in a
writ appeal bearing WA No. 261 of 2023.
7) He further submits that in above referred case, Co-ordinate bench of
this Court in case of Smt. Sona Sahu (supra) has observed that the
circular dated 10.03.2017 is still operative and teachers who have
completed ten years of service without promotion is entitled for
Kramonnati Vetanmaan / Time pay scale, irrespective of initial
appointing authority. The finding recorded by the learned Single Judge
in case of Smt. Abha Namdeo and Others (supra) with respect to the
Shiksha Karmi to be governed by the separate rules is wholly
erroneous and contrary to the policy dated 30.06.2018.
8) He also submits that the circular dated 10.03.2017 nowhere restrict the
benefit only to “regular teachers of School Education Department”.
Para 2 of the circular uses the word “teachers” in the widest sense and
the benefit was extended precisely to remove stagnation of Panchayat
5 / 13
teachers who had no promotional avenue. The Sona Sahu judgment
has categorically held that the circular applies to such teachers.
9)
Learned counsel for the State would oppose the submission made by
learned counsel for the appellant and submit that the Co-ordinate
Bench of this Court has considered similar arguments as advanced by
learned counsel for the appellant (therein), the arguments as raised by
the learned counsel for the appellant with regard to the order passed in
writ appeal bearing WA No. 261 of 2023 dated 23.07.2024, the order
passed in review petition and further the order dismissing the SLP(c) by
Hon’ble Supreme Court and have dismissed the appeal in case of
Pushpalata Manikpuri and others Vs. State of Chhattisgarh and
others and in case of Jeewan Lal Banjare and others Vs. State of
Chhattisgarh and others. He also submits that the issue raised in the
writ petition came up for hearing before the learned Single Judge in
case of Smt. Abha Namdeo (supra) and was decided on 24.11.2025
observing that petitioners (therein) were working as Siksha Karmi in
schools under the control of Panchayat and their services were
governed by separate rules framed under the Panchayat Raj Adiniyam,
1993. Their designation were also different i.e. they were Assistant
Teachers (Panchayat)/teachers (Panchayat).
10) When the question is posed to learned counsel for the appellant that as
to whether the issue raised in this appeal is identical to that of
considered by Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in Writ Appeal no. 193
of 2026 and Writ Appeal No. 191 of 2026, he submits that he is not
disputing the submission in this regard as advanced by learned counsel
for the State.
6 / 13
11) The submission advanced by learned counsel for the State in that
appeal are as under:14. The Hon'ble Supreme Court dismissed the SLP filed by the
State Government against the order passed in Writ Appeal No.
261/2023 and Review Petition No. 147/2024, under the peculiar
facts of the case of Smt. Sona Sahu. Consequently, this Court
is competent to independently examine the entitlement of the
petitioners to Kramonnati Vetanman under the Circular dated
10.03.2017.
15. The Circular dated 10.03.2017 specifically applies to
teachers of the School Education Department or State
Government employees, and not to Panchayat employees,
including Shiksha Karmi. Therefore, reliance placed by the
petitioners on the Circular dated 10.03.2017 is misconceived. It
is further submitted that under settled principles of service
jurisprudence, any person claiming parity must establish that
they are similarly situated in all material aspects. Since the
petitioners have failed to demonstrate such similarity with the
case of Smt. Sona Sahu (Writ Appeal No. 261/2023), they are
not entitled to the relief sought, and therefore, the writ petition
has rightly been dismissed by the learned Single Judge, and
there is no merit in the writ appeal, and the same is also liable
to be dismissed.
12) We have heard learned counsel for the respective parties, perused the
record of the writ appeal and the decision of Co-ordinate Bench of this
Court in case of Jeewan lal Banjare (supra) and Pushpalata
Manikpuri (supra).
13) Upon considering, entirety of the facts and circumstances of the case
and the issue raised by learned counsel for appellant, we are of the
considered view that this appeal is covered with the decision in case of
Pushpalata Manikpuri (supra) decided on 13.03.2026 by the Coordinate Bench of this Court in writ appeal bearing WA No. 193 of 2026
which were disposed of in following terms:-
7 / 13
17. The entire controversy revolved around the Circular dated
10.03.2017 issued by the State Government with respect to the
grant of Kramonnati Vetanman to the Assistant Teachers. It is
necessary to notice here the circular dated 10.03.2017, which
reads as under:छत्तीसगढ़ शासन
सामान्य प्रशासन विभाग
मंत्रालय
महानदी भवन, नया रायप्र
क्रमांक एफ 10-1/2008/1-3
नया रायपुर दिनांक 10/03/2017
प्रति,
शासन के समस्त विभाग,
अध्यक्ष, छत्तीसगढ़ राजस्व मण्डल, बिलासपुर
समस्त विभागाध्यक्ष,
समस्त संभागायुक्त
समस्त कलेक्टर्स,
छत्तीसगढ़
विषय :- सहायक शिक्षकों को कमोन्नति वेतनमान प्रदाय किए जाने
बाबत्।
संदर्भ :- इस विभाग का समसंख्यक परिपत्र दिनांक 24.04.2006.
इस विभाग के संदर्भित परिपत्र द्वारा शिक्षक संवर्ग में सहायक
शिक्षक, शिक्षक तथा व्याख्याता को सामान्य प्रशासन विभाग के परिपत्र
कमांक एफ 1-1/1/वेआप्र/99, दिनांक 17.03.1999/19.04.1999 में
निहित शर्तों के अध्यधीन प्रथन कमोन्नति 12 वर्ष बाद तथा द्वितीय
क्रमोन्नति 24 वर्ष बाद प्रदान किया गया है। वित्त विभाग के ज्ञापन कमांक
216/सी- 2802/10/वित्त/नियम/धार, दिनांक 04.08.2010 (वित्त
निर्देश 32/2010) द्वारा क्रमोन्नति योजना को संशोधित कर शिक्षक तथा
व्याख्याता संवर्ग को प्रथम उच्चतर समयमान वेतनमान 10 वर्ष बाद एवं
द्वितीय उच्चतर समयमान वेतनमान 20 वर्ष बाद देने का निर्णय लिया
गया है।
2/अतएव उपरोक्त निर्णय के परिप्रेक्ष्य में राज्य शासन द्वारा निर्णय लिया
गया है कि इस विभाग के संदर्भित परिपत्र दिनांक 24.04.2006 की
कं डिका-2 में "सहायक शिक्षक" को प्रथम कमोन्नति 10 वर्ष बाद एवं
द्वितीय क्रमोन्नति 20 वर्ष बाद प्रदान की जाए।
8 / 13
3/ उपरोक्त निर्णय के संबंध में यह स्पष्ट किया जाता है कि कमोन्नति की
देयता तिथि के अनुसार के वल काल्पनिक वेतन निर्धारण किया जाएगा
एवं किसी प्रकार के एरियर्स देय नहीं होंगे।
4/ यह आदेश वित्त विभाग के कम्प्यूटर कमांक एफ-2017-01-01093
दिनांक 09.02.2017 द्वारा दी गई सहमति के आधार पर जारी किया
गया है।
छत्तीसगढ़ के राज्यपाल के नाम से
तथा आदेशानुसार,
(एम.आर. ठोकू र) अवर सचिव,
छत्तीसगढ़ शासन
सामान्य प्रशासन विभाग
18. From perusal of the contents of the circular dated
10.03.2017, it is quite vivid that the Assistant Teachers, who
were in Government service, are to be granted first Kramonnati
Vetanman after 10 years of their service and second
Kromonnati Vetanman after 20 years of their service, and the
teachers and lecturers are to be granted first time- bound pay
scale after 10 years of service and second time-bound pay
scale after 20 years of service.
19. From pleadings made in Para-8.8 of the writ petition,
undisputedly the petitioners have been appointed to the post of
Shiksha Karmi Grade-III/Grade-II between the period of 1998
and 2008. It is also relevant to notice here paragraph 8.8 of the
writ petition, which reads as follows:
"8.8 Between 1998-2008, the Chief Executive Officer of Janpad
Panchayat appointed the Petitioners in the post of Assistant
Teacher Shikshakarmi Grade- 3/Teacher- Shikshakarmi Grade
2. After completion of 2 years from the date of joining, the
Petitioners who were appointed as Assistant Teachers were
regularized by the Chief Executive Officer of Janpad Panchayat
and Teachers were regularised by the Chief Executive Officer of
Zila Panchayat."
20. When the petitioners in the present writ petition were
appointed between 2008 and 2013, they had not completed 10
years of the service on the date when the Circular dated
10.03.2017 was issued.
9 / 13
21. From a bare perusal of the Circular dated 10.03.2017, it
abundantly clear that the said circular does not deal with or
extend benefits to the Teachers belonging to the Panchayat
Cadre, including Shiksha Karmi. The circular specifically
provides for the grant of first-time-bound pay scale and secondtime-bound pay scale to regular Government employees, in
accordance with the earlier circulars issued by the State
Government dated 17.03.1999/19.04.1999.
22. In the present case, the petitioners were working as
Shiksha Karmi under the Panchayat Department, and the
Shiksha Karmi were not the employees of the State
Government until their absorption into the School Education
Department pursuant to the policy decision of the State
Government dated 30.06.2018. Before such absorption, their
appointment, service conditions, and other benefits were
governed by the statutory framework applicable to Panchayat
employees, and not by the rules or circulars applicable to State
Government employees.
23. Therefore, since the petitioners were admittedly the
employees of the Panchayat Department before the absorption
policy came into force, they cannot claim the status of a
Government Servant for the purpose of seeking the benefit of
time-bound pay scale or Kramonnati Vetanman under the
Circular dated 10.03.2017. Their service conditions were
governed by the Chhattisgarh Panchayat Shiksha Karmi
(Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 2007, the Rules
of 2012, or any other rules framed under Section 95 of the
Chhattisgarh Panchayat Raj Adhiniyam, 1993, which regulate
the service conditions of Panchayat employees.
24. Thus, in view of the clear distinction between State
Government employees and Panchayat cadre employees, the
petitioners cannot derive any benefit from the Circular dated
10.03.2017
or
the
earlier
circulars
dated
17.03.1999/19.04.1999, as those circular apply solely to
Government servants of the State, and not to employees
appointed under the Panchayat department.
25. The distinguishable feature of the case of Smt. Sona Sahu
(Writ Appeal No. 261/2023) are that she was appointed to the
10 / 13
post of Assistant Teacher vide order dated 29.07.2005 and was
posted at Government Primary School, Narayanpur. On
01.07.2011, the State Government, Department of Finance and
Planning issued a Circular regarding Kramonnati Vetanman to
the employees. The Department of Panchayat and Rural
Department, Chhattisgarh, Raipur, also issued a Circular dated
02.11.2011 regarding Kramonnati Vetanman after completion of
10 years of service. On 17.05.2013, the department of
Panchayat and Rural Development, Chhattisgarh, Raipur
issued another circular with respect to the equalisation of pay
scale between Government Teachers and Teacher Panchayat
after completion of 08 years of their services. Further, vide
circular dated 14.11.2014, the earlier circular dated 02.11.2011
was cancelled with effect from 01.05.2013. The petitioner was
granted the benefit of Kramonnati Vetanman vide order dated
15.01.2020, but the said order was cancelled vide order dated
29.02.2020 on the ground that the Circular dated 02.11.2011
has already been cancelled with effect from 01.05.2013 vide
order dated 14.11.2014, and since the petitioner, who has not
completed 10 years of her service in the cadre, was not entitled
to Kramonnati Vetanman. While passing the order dated
15.01.2020, the authorities had considered the circulars dated
07.03.2019, 06.04.2019, and granted Kramonnati Vetanman to
Sona Sahu with effect from 01.08.2015 and thereafter the
concerned authority sou motu re-considered the order dated
15.01.2020 and passed the order on 29.02.2020, by which the
benefit granted to Smt. Sona Sahu was cancelled. While
considering the matter, the concerned authority had not
consider the circular dated 10.03.2017 and 07.03.2019. In the
peculiar facts of the case of Smt. Sona Sahu (Writ Appeal No.
261/2023) was granted the benefit of Kramonnati Vetanman,
vide order dated 28.02.2024, passed in Writ Appeal No.
261/2023. The challenge of the order dated 28.02.2024 passed
in Writ Appeal No. 261/2023, and Review Petition No. 147/2024
is dismissed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court vide order dated
17.03.2025, passed in SLP (C) Diary No. 58525/2024, by
observing that in the peculiar facts of the case of Smt. Sona
Sahu, no interference is called for, and accordingly, the SLP(C)
was dismissed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.
11 / 13
26. In the present case, the petitioners are appointed to the
post of Shiksha Karmi by the Panchayat Department. They
were not government employees till 2018, when their services
were absorbed by the school education department. Therefore,
they cannot claim parity and benefit at par as has been
granted to Smt. Sona Sahu (Writ Appeal No. 261/2023).
27. Further, Clauses 4 and 5 of the absorption order
dated 30.06.2018 clearly restrict the grant of any benefit
to the employees of the Panchayat Department whose
services have been absorbed with the school education
department for the benefit of arrears prior to 01.07.2018.
Clause 4 and 5 of the absorption order dated reads as
under:
“4/ शिक्षक (एल.बी.) संवर्ग को देय समस्त लाभ के लिये सेवा
की गणना संविलियन दिनाँक 01 जुलाई 2018 से की जायेगी।
5/ दिनाँक 01 जुलाई 2018 के पूर्व की अवधि के लिये किसी
भी प्रकार के एरियर्स की पात्रता नहीं होगी।"
28. On 06.04.2019, the State Government School Education
Department issued another Circular with respect to the
further proceedings under the Rules of 2019, in which it has
been provided that:
"इस विभाग द्वारा जारी संविलियन निर्देश कमांक एक दिनांक
30.06.2018 की कं डिका 5 में स्पष्ट उल्लेखित है, कि दिनांक
01.07.2018 के पूर्व की अवधि के लिए किसी भी प्रकार के
एरियर्स की पात्रता नही होगी अर्थात पूर्व के एरियर्स स्कू ल शिक्षा
विभाग द्वारा देय नहीं होंगे। पूर्व में शिक्षक (पंचायत/नगरीय
निकाय) संवर्ग के कर्मचारी, जो वर्तमान में शिक्षक एल.बी. संवर्ग
के रूप में कार्यरत हैं, के संविलियन पूर्व की अवधि के लंबित
स्वत्वों का भुगतान पात्रतानुसार संबंधित विभाग द्वारा ही किया
जायेगा।"
29. The present writ appeal has been filed by the
appellants/petitioners seeking the benefit of Kramonnati
under the Circular dated 10.03.2017, claiming parity with the
case of Smt. Sona Sahu (Writ Appeal No. 261/2023). The
petitioners were initially appointed as Shiksha Karmi under
the Panchayat Department between 1998 and 2008, and
their services were regularized by the order passed by the
Chief Executive Officer of the respective Janpad and Zila
12 / 13
Panchayats. They continued to serve under the Panchayat
department till 2018, when they were absorbed into the
School Education Department pursuant to the State
Government policy dated 30.06.2018. Their service prior to
absorption was governed by the Chhattisgarh Panchayat
Shiksha Karmi Rules, 2007, and subsequent rules framed
under the Panchayat Raj Adhiniyam, 1993.
30. The Circular dated 10.03.2017, on which the petitioners
rely, specifically applies to Assistant Teachers under the
School Education Department who have completed 10 years
of service. In contrast, the petitioners’ service as Shiksha
Karmi under the Panchayat department cannot be treated as
equivalent
to
service
under
the
School
Education
Department. The factual distinction is material, and the
principles of parity require that employees claiming equal
treatment must be similarly situated in all material aspects,
which is not the case here.
31. This has consistently held in WP(S) No. 208/2012,
WP(S) No. 2530/2017, WP(S) No. 10335/2019, WP(S) No.
1021/2021, and WP(S) No. 3369/2021 that the services of
the Shiksha Karmi governed by Panchayat rules are not
entitled to pay scales or other benefits applicable to teachers
of the School Education Department. The learned Single
Judge rightly distinguished the case of Smt. Sona Sahu (Writ
Appeal No. 261/2023), after independently examining the
entitlement of the petitioners, concluded that the Circular
dated 10.03.2017 does not apply to their service.
32. The learned Single Judge after adverting and considering
the entire facts and circumstances of the case, elaborately
considered various judgments passed by Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of Rohan Vijay Nahar and Others v. The
State of Maharashtra and Others 2025 INSC 1296, State
of Punjab and Others vs. Jagjit Singh and Others, 2017
(1) SCC 148, Khoday Distiliaries Limited (Now known as
Khoday
India
Limited)
and
Others
vs.
Shree
Mahadeshwara Shahkara Sakkare Karkhane Limited
Kollegal 2019 (4) SCC 376 and Ravi Prakash Sahu vs.
13 / 13
State of Chhattisgarh order dated 08-09-2025 passed
learned Single Judge of this Court in WPS No. 10335/2019,
decided
the
writ
petition
filed
by
the
writ
appellants/petitioners in which, we do not find perversity or
infirmity. The consideration of the learned Single Judge in the
impugned order is well merited based on a proper
appreciation of the facts and law applicable to the case.
33.Upon perusing the impugned order, we notice that the
same has been rendered by the learned Single Judge with
cogent and justifiable reasons. In an intra-court appeal, no
interference is usually warranted unless palpable infirmities
are noticed. Learned Single Judge while dismissing the writ
petition by the impugned order has adverted to all the facts of
the case. We do not find any fault in the impugned order.
34. In view of the above, the writ appellants/petitioners have
failed to demonstrate that they are similarly situated to the
petitioner in Writ Appeal No. 261/2023 (Smt. Sona Sahu v.
State of Chhattisgarh and Others). Their claim under the
Circular dated 10.03.2017 is, therefore, misconceived, and
the learned Single Judge has rightly dismissed the writ
petition. Accordingly, the present writ appeal is devoid of
merit and is hereby dismissed.”
14) In the above facts of the case, we are of the considered opinion that
this appeal is squarely covered with the case of Pushpalata (supra)
therefore, we do not find any merit in this writ appeal. Accordingly, this
writ appeal is dismissed at admission stage in same terms.
Certified copy as per rules.
Alfiza
Sd/-
Sd/-
(Parth Prateem Sahu)
Judge
(Sushma Sawant)
Judge
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review