Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:SHC:98
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Civil Extra Ordinary Jurisdiction)
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH: THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P. (C) No. 13 of 2020
Smt. Meena Jha,
Aged about 54 years,
W/o Mr. Kashi Kant Jha,
R/o Daragaon, Tadong,
Gangtok, East Sikkim-737102.
…..
Petitioner
Versus
1.
State Bank of India,
A body corporate constituted
under the State Bank of India
Act, 1955; having its central office
at Madame Cama Road,
Mumbai-400021, represented by its CEO.
2.
The Chief Manager-cum-Branch Manager,
State Bank of India,
Gangtok (Main) Branch, M.G. Marg,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
3.
The Recovery Officer-I,
Debts Recovery Tribunal,
Guwahati, 1st Floor, Apsara
Building Dr. B. Baruah Road, Guwahati 781007,
Kamrup, Assam.
4.
Shri Akhileshwar Prasad @
Akleswar Prasad,
C/o M/s Akhilesh Enterprise,
Son of Late Ramnath Prasad,
R/o Daragaon, Tadong,
P.O. Tadong, Gangtok,
East Sikkim-737102.
5.
Laxmi Devi,
W/o Shri Akhileshwar Prasad @
Akleswar Prasad,
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
C/o M/s Akhilesh Enterprise,
R/o Daragaon, Tadong,
P.O. Tadong, Gangtok,
East Sikkim-737102.
6.
The District Collector,
Registrar of Land, District Collectorate,
Sichey, P.O. Sichey, Gangtok.
East Sikkim.
7.
State of Sikkim,
Represented by and through
The Chief Secretary,
Government of Sikkim,
Gangtok, East Sikkim.
….. Respondents
Application under Articles 226, 227 of the Constitution of
India.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------Appearance:
Mr. Abhinav Kant Jha, Ms. Preeti Basnett, Mr. Anish
Byahut and Ms. Punam Rai, Advocates for the
Petitioner.
Mr. J. K. Chandak, Advocate for Respondent Nos.1 and
2.
None for Respondent Nos. 3 to 5.
Mr. Thinlay Dorjee Bhutia, Government Advocate for
Respondent Nos. 6 and 7.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------Date of Hearing
:
03.07.2025
Date of Judgment
:
14.08.2025
JUDGMENT
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J.
The moot question
1.
The question that falls for determination is whether the
writ petition filed in the year 2020 by the auction purchaser
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
who had participated in an auction sale of the immovable
property of the secured creditor under the Securitisation
and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of
Security Interest Act, 2002 (the SARFAESI Act) in the year
2011 but failed to pay the deposit of 25% of the sale price as
required under Rule 9(3) or pay the balance within the time
frame under Rule 9(4) of the Security Interest (Enforcement)
Rules, 2002 (the SI Rules), should be allowed?
The parties
2.
Meena Jha (the petitioner) was the auction purchaser
who has sought to invoke the writ jurisdiction of this Court
against the State Bank of India (respondent no.1) the
secured creditor, its Chief Manager-cum-Branch Manager
(respondent no.2), the Recovery Officer-I, Debts Recovery
Tribunal (respondent no.3), Akhileshwar Prasad (respondent
no.4)-the borrower, his wife Laxmi Devi (respondent no.5),
the District Collector (respondent no.6) and the State of
Sikkim (respondent no.7).
Facts
3.
Before this Court examines the legal issues arising in
the present writ petition it would be important to set out the
relevant sequence of events:
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
(i) On 26.11.2007 the respondent no.4 was sanctioned a
housing loan by the respondent no.1. The property was
mortgaged with the respondent no.1. The property was in
fact a leasehold property owned by one Shirshak Gurung.
The lease deed dated 29.03.2008 granted lease of the
property to the respondent no.4 as the lessee. The lease
deed permitted mortgage of the property and allowed the
respondent no.4 to avail loan from any bank/financial
institution on the condition that the respondent no.4
shall repay such loan. It further permitted the respondent
no.4 to transfer/mortgage the property i.e. the land and
the
building
constructed
thereon.
The
lease
deed
specifically provided that if the respondent no.4 failed to
repay the loan with interest the same could be recovered
by disposal of the property and in such an event even the
lessor shall not raise any objection at all.
(ii) The respondent no.4 failed to repay the loan and the
respondent no.1 initiated recovery measures under the
SARFAESI Act. O.A. No.144 of 2010 was filed by the
respondent no.1 against the respondent no.4 and others
before the Debts Recovery Tribunal.
(iii) The petitioner participated in the auction sale
conducted by the respondent no.1 for sale of the property
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
of
the
respondent
no.4
vide
notice
published
on
09.09.2011. The petitioner was declared the successful
bidder in the auction which was held on 13.10.2011.
(iv) The petitioner deposited the earnest amount of
Rs.6,50,000/-
vide
bank
draft
No.701975
dated
11.10.2011 which was not encashed.
(v) However, admittedly the petitioner did not pay the
deposit of 25% of the amount of sale price immediately as
required by Rule 9(3) of the SI Rules. The balance amount
of sale price payable which was to be paid on or before
the 15th day of confirmation of the sale of the property
was also not paid. Instead on 24.10.2011 the petitioner
addressed a letter to the Assistant General Manager of
respondent no.1 seeking further time of one month to
deposit
the
remaining
money.
According
to
the
respondent no.1 time was not granted. On this letter
there is a hand written endorsement showing receipt of
Rs.3,60,000/- dated 24.11.2011. It is through this
endorsement that the petitioner claims of having made
part payment of the amount. The respondent no.2
contends in his reply dated 14.06.2025 to the additional
affidavit
of
the
petitioner
that
this
Rs.3,60,000/- has not been received by them.
amount
of
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
(vi) The petitioner also did not pay the balance amount
within the period of one month sought for by him vide
letter dated 24.10.2011.
(vii) Admittedly, the petitioner did not have the necessary
financial resources to pay the sale price amount and
therefore she sought a loan of Rs.50,00,000/- from the
respondent
no.1.
Although
the
respondent
no.1
sanctioned this amount on 15.12.2011 the loan was not
disbursed. The security for the sanctioned loan to the
petitioner was the same property. According to the
respondent
no.1
the
petitioner
failed
to
fulfil
the
obligations of execution of loan documents and to furnish
immovable property as security and therefore, did not
disburse the loan.
(viii) On 26.07.2012 the Chief Manager (the respondent
no.2) of the respondent no.1 issued a letter to the
respondent no.6 requesting for registration of the property
in the name of the petitioner.
(ix) On 17.08.2012 the Sub-Divisional Magistrate sent a
letter
to
the
communication
respondent
dated
no.2
in
26.07.2012
response
stating
to
his
that
on
examination of the documents it was seen that the
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
petitioner was not in possession of Sikkim Subject
Certificate or Certificate of Identification and as per the old
laws of Sikkim she was not entitled to purchase the said
property. In view of the contradictory position of laws visa-vis section 13(6) of the SARFAESI Act and the old laws
of Sikkim the case was forwarded to the Land Revenue
and Disaster Management Department for seeking legal
opinion from the Law Department and it was stated that
after receipt thereof appropriate action would be taken.
(x) On 16.01.2013 the respondent no.2 issued a letter to
the respondent no.6 stating that they are in possession of
the property which is occupied by two tenants who are
denying ownership and disturbing their possession. It was
also informed that the property is also occupied by the
petitioner
who
had
purchased
the
property
under
SARFAESI Act through auction held on 13.10.2011,
registration of which is in process in the office of the
respondent no.6. It was stated that the tenants were
creating disturbance to the petitioner who are frequently
reporting it to them. The respondent no.2 therefore
requested the respondent no.6 to issue eviction notice to
the tenants.
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
(xi) On 18.01.2013 the Manager of respondent no.1 wrote
to the petitioner stating that the issue of transfer of
ownership of the property is under consideration with the
registering authority and on completion of the formality
she
would be
called
for completing the
remaining
formalities after which they would provide her with
peaceful possession free from all encumbrances.
(xii) On 10.09.2013 the Sub-Registrar addressed a
communication to the respondent no.2 stating that the file
pertaining to the sale deed was misplaced and therefore,
fresh sale deed duly filled was to be submitted.
(xiii) On 19.09.2013 the respondent no.2 forwarded the
duly filled sale deed for necessary action to the SubRegistrar. The sale deed was dated 19.09.2013 in favour of
the petitioner.
(xiv) It is unclear from the pleadings as to when the
respondent no.1 approached the Debts Recovery Tribunal
once again. However, it is noted that Recovery Certificate
No.1249 of 27.01.2014 was issued by the learned
Presiding Officer of the Debts Recovery Tribunal in Case
No.O.A.144 of 2010 in the matter of State Bank of India,
Gangtok Branch vs. Shri Akleswar Prasad & Ors. This
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
indicates
that
the
respondent
no.1
may
have
re-
approached the Debts Recovery Tribunal sometime in the
year 2014 pursuant to which the Recovery Certificate
dated 27.01.2014 was issued.
(xv) On 08.02.2015 the Sub-Registrar wrote to the
respondent no.2 stating that the Law Department has
categorically pointed out that registration of sale deed of
the property cannot be permitted in favour of the
petitioner
as
she
did
not
have
a
Certificate
of
Identification.
(xvi) On 28.05.2016 the Land Revenue and Disaster
Management
Department
wrote
to
the
Manager
of
respondent no.1 stating that the issue of registration of
the property is under its consideration.
(xvii) On 20.07.2016 the Debts Recovery Tribunal issued
an order of attachment prohibiting respondent no.4 and
his wife-respondent no.5 from transferring or changing the
property in any way and further prohibiting all other
persons from taking any benefit under such transfer or
charge.
(xviii) On 14.09.2016 the respondent no.2 wrote to the
respondent no.6 stating that they were treating the
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
auction dated 13.10.2011 as failed and requesting him not
to proceed further in future in the matter of transfer of the
property in the name of the petitioner.
(xix)
On the same day i.e. 14.09.2016 the respondent
no.2 issued a letter to the petitioner referring to its
communication dated 14.09.2016 to the respondent no.6
and
returning
the
demand
draft
No.701975
dated
11.10.2011 for Rs.6,50,000/-.
(xx) On 10.10.2016 the petitioner wrote to the respondent
no.2 protesting the return of the earnest money and for
various other acts of the respondent no.1.
(xxi)
The matter was thereafter placed before the Cabinet
vide Cabinet Memorandum dated 14.11.2016.
It was
recorded in the draft of the Cabinet Meeting that the
Cabinet meeting held on 11.11.2016 however, deferred the
proposal of registration of the property in favour of the
petitioner.
(xxii) On 29.12.2016 the Debts Recovery Tribunal issued
sale notice of the property by e-auction and scheduled the
date as 10.03.2017 for the said purpose. The last date of
registration of bidders was on or before 03.03.2017.
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
(xxiii) The petitioner thereafter, approached the Guwahati
High Court by filing Writ Petition (C) No.807 of 2017 (the
writ petition) with prayers to set aside the attachment
order dated 20.07.2016, notice of attachment dated
13.08.2016 and sale notice dated 29.12.2016 issued by
the respondent no.3 in connection with D.R.P.C. No.1249
dated 27.01.2014 arising out of O.A. No.144 of 2010.
(xxiv)
It transpires that on 10.02.2017 the Division
Bench of the Guwahati High Court took up the writ
petition. The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted
that the petitioner was willing to deposit the entire
amount with interest outstanding against her with the
respondent no.1 within two weeks. As such, notice was
issued to the respondents and it was made clear that if
the petitioner intends to deposit the entire amount with
interest due against her, the respondent no.1 will be at
liberty to accept the same. The Division Bench also
directed that the re-auction of the property shall remain
stayed.
(xxv)
From the affidavit dated 03.03.2017 filed by the
petitioner before the Guwahati High Court it seems that
thereafter the petitioner on 21.02.2017 approached the
respondent no.1 along with two drafts bearing No.256189
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
dated 20.02.2017 and No.701975 dated 11.10.2011 both
drawn on the State Bank of India for an amount of
Rs.58,69,005/- and Rs.6,50,000/- towards deposit of the
total
amount
of
Rs.65,19,005/-
vide
letter
dated
21.02.2017 which however, was not accepted by the
respondent no.1 taking the option granted by the
Guwahati High Court.
(xxvi)
On
22.05.2017
the
Guwahati
High
Court
dismissed the writ petition as withdrawn with liberty to
the petitioner to file a fresh petition before this Court.
Pursuant to this liberty the petitioner approached this
Court by filing Writ Petition (C) No 39 of 2017 which was
also withdrawn and thereafter the present writ petition
was filed on 06.06.2020.
(xxvii) On 29.04.2023 the Sub-Divisional Magistrate
wrote to the respondent no.2 in response to their letter
dated 26.07.2012 informing them about the approval of
the Competent Authority that had been obtained and
requesting the respondent no.2 to depute an officer to be
present in their office for further necessary action.
(xxviii)
On 11.06.2024, the Land Revenue and Disaster
Management Department wrote to the respondent no.6
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
stating that the registration of sale deed is kept in
abeyance as the matter is sub judice.
Consideration
4.
As per the dicta of the Supreme Court in Authorised
Officer, State Bank of India vs. C. Natarajan1 having regard to
the terms of Rule 9 of the SI Rules the notice for auction
dated 09.09.2011 constitutes the “invitation to offer”; the
bids submitted by the petitioner on 13.10.2011 constitutes
the “offer” and upon confirmation of sale in favour of the
highest bidder i.e. the petitioner on 13.10.2011 under subrule (2) of Rule 9, the contract came into existence. As per
the opinion of the Supreme Court once the contract came
into existence, the petitioner who was the bidder was bound
to honour the terms of the statute under which the auction
was conducted and suffer consequences for breach, if any,
as stipulated.
5.
Therefore, the contract having come into existence on
13.10.2011 between the respondent no.1 and the petitioner,
she was bound to honour the terms of the SARFAESI Act
and the SI Rules. The petitioner is to suffer the consequence
for breach thereof.
1 (2024) 2 SCC 637
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
6.
At this juncture it would be important to examine Rule
9 of the SI Rules as it existed during the relevant period. It
reads as under:
“9.
Time of sale, issue of sale certificate and
delivery of possession, etc.
(1).
No sale of immovable property under these
rules shall take place before the expiry of thirty days
from the date on which public notice of sale is
published in newspapers as referred to in the proviso
to sub-rule (6) or notice of sale has been served to the
borrower.
(2).
The sale shall be confirmed in favour of the
purchaser who had offered the highest sale price in
his bid or tender or quotation or offer to the
authorised officer and shall be subject to confirmation
by the secured creditor:
Provided that no sale under this rule shall be
confirmed, if the amount offered by sale price is less
than the reserve price, specified under sub rule (5) of
Rule 9.
Provided further that if the authorised officer
fails to obtain a price higher than the reserve price,
he may, with the consent of the borrower and the
secured creditor effect the sale at such price.
(3). On every sale of immovable property, the
purchaser shall immediately pay a deposit of twentyfive per cent of the amount of the sale price, to the
authorised officer conducting the sale and in default
of such deposit, the property shall forthwith be sold
again.
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
(4).
The balance amount of purchase price payable
shall be paid by the purchaser to the authorised
officer on or before the fifteenth day of confirmation of
sale of the immovable property or such extended
period.
(5).
In default of
payment within the period
mention in sub rule (4), the deposit shall be forfeited
and the property shall be resold and the defaulting
purchaser shall forfeit all claim to the property or to
any part of the sum for which it may be subsequently
sold.
(6).
On confirmation of sale by the secured creditor
and if the terms of payment have been complied with,
the authorised officer exercising the power of sale
shall issue a certificate of sale of the immovable
property in favour of the purchaser in the form given
in Appendix V to these rules.
(7). Where the immovable property sold is subject to
any encumbrances, the authorised officer may, if he
thinks fit, allow the purchaser to deposit with him the
money required to discharge the encumbrances and
any interest due thereon with such additional
amount
that
may
be
sufficient
to
meet
the
contingencies or further cost, expenses and interest
as may be determine by him:
Provided that if after meeting the cost of
removing encumbrances and contingencies there is
any surplus available out of the money deposited by
the purchaser such surplus shall be paid to the
purchaser within fifteen days from the date of
finalisation of the sale.
(8).
On such deposit of money for discharge of the
encumbrances, the authorised officer shall issue or
cause the purchaser to issue notices to the persons
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
interested in or entitled to the money deposited with
him and take steps to make the payment accordingly.
(9).
The authorised officer shall deliver the property
to the purchaser free from encumbrances none to the
secured creditor on deposit of money as specified in
sub-rule (7) above.
(10). The certificate of sale issued under sub-rule (6)
shall specifically mention that whether the purchaser
has purchased the immovable secured asset free
from any encumbrances known to the secured
creditor or not.”
7.
Under Rule 9(2) of the SI Rules the sale is required to
be confirmed in favour of the purchaser who had offered the
highest sale price in his bid which is subject to confirmation
by the secured creditor.
8.
Rule 9(3) of the SI Rules makes it mandatory for the
purchaser to immediately pay a deposit of 25% of the sale
price to the authorised officer conducting the sale; and in
default of such deposit the property shall forthwith be sold
again. The deposit as contemplated in Rule 9(3) of the SI
Rules serves as a commitment from the purchaser and
insures a serious bid.
9.
Rule 9(4) of the SI Rules provides that the balance
amount of sale price (i.e. the remainder of the sale price
minus the deposit of 25% of the sale price) shall be
paid to the
authorised
officer by the
purchaser on or
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
before the fifteenth day of confirmation of sale of the
property or such extended period. Rule 9(3) and 9(4) of the
SI Rules read together makes the intention of the legislature
clear. It clearly sets out outer limits for payment of the
deposit of the 25% of the sale price and the payment of the
balance amount of the sale price. The word “or such
extended period” appearing in Rule 9(4) of the SI Rules must
be read along with the words “on or before the fifteenth day
of confirmation of sale” appearing before it. So read the word
“or such extended period” cannot be stretched to mean
indefinite period. It is also clear that “or such extended
period” would imply that the period must be extended by
agreement and consent of the secured creditor. It would also
mean that this extension cannot be understood in a way
that would completely destroy the object and purpose of the
said Rule.
10. Rule 9(5) of the SI Rules provides for the consequence
of default of payment within the period mentioned in Rule
9(4) of the SI Rules. The consequence is forfeiture of the
property
and
resale
thereof.
Further,
the
defaulting
purchaser shall forfeit all claims to the property or to any
part of the sum for which it may be subsequently sold.
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
11. Rule 9(6) of the SI Rules envisages the issuance of a
certificate of sale of the property in favour of the purchaser
only upon confirmation of sale by the secured creditor and if
the terms of payment have been complied with.
12.
Rule 9(9) of the SI Rules provides that the authorised
officer shall deliver the property to the purchaser free from
encumbrances known to the secured creditor on deposit of
money as specified in sub-rule 9(7). Under Rule 9(7) if the
property sold is subject to any encumbrances the authorised
officer may allow the purchaser to deposit with him the
money required to discharge the encumbrances and any
interest due thereon together with such additional amount
that may be sufficient to meet the contingencies or further
costs, expenses and interest as may be determined by him.
13. The petitioner admittedly failed to pay the deposit of
25% of the amount of sale price (which is inclusive of
earnest money) which was to be deposited immediately to
the authorised officer conducting the sale in terms of Rule
9(3) of the SI Rules. The consequence of the failure to
deposit the 25% of the sale price in terms of Rule 9 (3) of the
SI Rules was that the property was to be sold again
forthwith by the respondent no.1.
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
14. The extension of period for payment of the balance
amount under Rule 9(4) of the SI Rules is limited for the
said purpose only and cannot be used for seeking extension
of payment of the 25% of the sale price required to be
mandatorily paid immediately under Rule 9(3) of the SI
Rules. Further, this Court is also of the view that the
petitioner has forfeited all claims to the property in terms of
Rule 9(5) of the SI Rules.
15. However, the record of the present case paints a grim
picture. The actions of some officers of respondent nos. 1
including respondent no. 2 reflects total non-application of
mind to the provisions of the SARFAESI Act or the SI Rules.
The respondent nos. 1 and 2 were duty bound to follow the
provisions of the law under the SARFAESI Act and the SI
Rules. They could not have acted in a manner contrary to
law. The SARFAESI Act and the SI Rules were enacted for
speedy recovery and for benefiting the public at large and
does not give any liberty to the bank officers to act dehors
the laws. It is settled law that when there is a breach of
mandatory requirement the sale is to be treated as null and
void.
16. The
SARFAESI
Act
was
enacted
to
regulate
securitisation and reconstruction of financial assets and
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
enforcement of security interest. Section 13 of the SARFAESI
Act deals with enforcement of security interest and provides
that notwithstanding anything contained in section 69 or
section 69A of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882 any
security interest created in favour of any secured creditor
may be enforced, without the intervention of the court or
tribunal, by such creditor in accordance with the provisions
of the SARFAESI Act.
17. However, neither the respondent no.4 who was the
borrower of the loan paid the amount of loan to the
respondent no.1 nor has the attempt to secure the amount
through an auction under the SARFAESI Act resulted in sale
of the property and realisation of public debt. The loan was
taken by the respondent no.4 in 2007 and the auction of the
property which was the secured asset was held on
13.10.2011. Although 14 years have gone by the public debt
is still not realised. Now the petitioner who had participated
in the auction but failed to pay even the deposit of the 25%
of the sale price in the year 2011 to prima facie show her
bonafides is attempting to scuttle the attempt of the
respondent nos.1 and 2 to sell the property again through
the Debts Recovery Tribunal by seeking a writ against the
proceeding pending before it.
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
18. Under Rule 9(3) of the SI Rules the respondent nos. 1
and respondent no. 2 did not have any other option but to
sell the property again forthwith. Instead of doing so, with
scant regard to the object of the SARFAESI Act and the
mandate of the SI Rules, the officers of respondent nos. 1 as
well as the respondent no. 2 seem to have indulged the
petitioner by first trying to help her obtain a loan keeping
the same property as security (which was sanctioned but not
disbursed) when she had failed to pay the deposit of 25% of
the sale price. Thereafter even before the issuance of
certificate of sale envisaged under Rule 9(6) of the SI Rules
addressed correspondences to the respondent no.6 as well
as the Sub-Registrar to register the sale deed in favour of
the
petitioner
through
its
correspondences
dated
26.07.2012, 19.09.2013 and 10.09.2013. Admittedly only
the earnest money had been deposited by the petitioner and
due to the failure the petitioner had forfeited her rights on
the property.
19.
It also transpires that while examining the respondent
no.2’s correspondence to register the property in the name
of the peitioner, the Sub-Divisional Magistrate was of the
view that the property could not be registered in favour of
the petitioner. Legal advice was thereafter sought from the
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
Law Department. The matter reached the highest level of the
Government when it was placed before the Cabinet. Initially
the decision was deferred but later a communication dated
29.04.2023 by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate informed the
respondent no.2 that the consent of the competent authority
to register the property in the name of the petitioner had
been obtained. However, yet by another communication
dated 11.06.2024 the Secretary-cum-Relief Commissioner of
the Land Revenue and Disaster Management Department
wrote to the respondent no.6 stating that the registration of
sale deed is kept in abeyance as the matter is sub judice. All
these acts of the State authorities seem to be solely on the
basis of the request made by the respondent no.2 to register
the property in the name of the petitioner oblivious of the
factual position of non payment of the sale price or the legal
implications under the SARFAESI Act and the SI Rules.
20. The acts of some of the officers of the respondent nos.
1 as well as the respondent no. 2 are not only contrary to
the scheme of the SARFAESI Act and the SI Rules but give
an impression that the law was completely ignored for the
cause of the petitioner. The act of the respondent no.2 to
repeatedly correspond with the respondent no.6 requesting
to register the sale deed in favour of the petitioner who had
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
not even paid the deposit of 25% of the sale price shocks the
conscience of this Court.
21. When the respondent no.1 approached the Debts
Recovery Tribunal once again to pursue to realise the public
debt against the respondent no.4 the petitioner rushed to
the Guwahati High Court seeking the setting aside the order
of attachment dated 20.7.2016, notice of attachment dated
13.08.2016 and sale notice dated 29.12.2016 issued by the
Recovery Officer of the Debts Recovery Tribunal against the
respondent no.4. The petitioner sought to do so only in the
year
when
the
respondent
no.1
had
already
approached the Debts Recovery Tribunal for sale of the
property. It is during this proceeding before the Guwahati
High Court (after the petitioner was granted leave to deposit
the entire amount with interest due against her) the
petitioner sought to deposit two drafts for an amount of
Rs.58,69,005/- dated 20.02.2017 and the old draft of
Rs.6,50,000/- dated 11.10.2011 as “full consideration”
which was however not accepted by the respondent no.1.
The option given by the Guwahati High Court to the
petitioner was to pay the “entire amount with interest due”.
However, even in the year 2017 the petitioner did not pay
the entire amount with interest due as the sale price in the
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
year 2011 itself was Rs.65,00,000/-. It was therefore, rightly
rejected by the respondent no.1 exercising the “liberty to
accept the same” granted to it by the Guwahati High Court
in its order dated 10.02.2017.
22. Although Rule 9(3) of the SI Rules is mandatory the
petitioner argues that the acts of the respondent no.1
amount to waiver. To constitute waiver there must be an
intentional relinquishment of a known right or the voluntary
relinquishment or abandonment of a known existing legal
right or conduct such as warrants an inference of the
relinquishment of a known right or a privilege. There is no
communication by the respondent no.1 which reflects an
intentional relinquishment of the requirement of Rule 9(3) of
the SI
Rules. There is no communication from the
respondent no.1 or 2 waiving its right to be paid the deposit
of 25% of the sale price immediately. None of the acts of the
respondent nos.1 and 2 amount to conduct such as
warrants and inference of the relinquishment of a known
right or privilege by them. When the petitioner failed to pay
this amount of deposit it was absolutely clear in the year
2011 itself that she was not capable of fulfilling the terms of
the contract and therefore, it was incumbent upon the
respondent nos. 1 and 2 to forthwith sell the property to
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
realize the public debt in right earnest. The failures of the
respondent nos. 1 and 2 to serve the purpose of the
SARFAESI Act and the SI Rules cannot be termed as waiver
to the benefit of the petitioner who is lacking in bonafides.
Waiver being an intentional relinquishment is not to be
inferred by such failures of public duty of the respondent
nos. 1 and 2. Further, when Rule 9 of the SI Rules is
founded on public policy to realize public debts without
delay this Court would be slow to apply the doctrine of
waiver to assist the petitioner in the facts of the present
case. It is well settled that the writ jurisdiction of the High
Court under Article 226 of the Constitution is not intended
to facilitate avoidance of obligations voluntarily incurred.
The petitioner had voluntarily taken part in the auction
proceeding under the SARFAESI Act. This Court is of the
view that giving the interpretation of Rule 9 of the SI Rules
in the manner suggested by the learned counsel for the
petitioner would be doing violence to the provisions of the
SARFAESI Act and the SI Rules.
23. Unlike the facts in IDBI Bank Limited vs. Ramswaroop
Daliya2 referred to by the petitioner the facts of the present
2 (2024) SCC OnLine SC 2878
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
case is different. It is not a case where the petitioner having
paid the 25% of the sale price in terms of Rule 9(3) of the SI
Rules the respondents had not accepted the balance auction
money. This is a case where there is complete and absolute
failure on the part of the petitioner to pay any amount of the
sale price whatsoever although having been declared the
successful bidder on 13.10.2011.
24. The conflicting pleas made in the writ petition coupled
with the petitioner’s conduct during the period between the
auction and now questions her bonafides. The petitioner has
made conflicting pleas regarding payments made by her
without substantiating the same by documentary evidence.
These pleas have been disputed by the respondent no.1.
There are serious disputed questions of facts which arise
due to the inconsistent pleadings of the parties which is
difficult to be gone into in writ jurisdiction. Although
admittedly the petitioner has not made payment of the
deposit of 25% of the sale price or the balance of the sale
price it is noticed that in the writ petition filed before the
Guwahati High Court the petitioner has stated that “..... on
12.12.2011, the petitioner made the entire payment of the
remaining sale amount in respect of purchase of the aforesaid
property and pursuant thereto, the respondent no.2 issued a
2025:SHC:98
W.P. (C). No. 13 of 2020
Meena Jha vs. State Bank of India & Ors.
sale certificate dated 03.01.2012 wherein, it was certified
that the property has been sold out to the petitioner vide
auction held on 13.10.2011 and the petitioner was held to be
the owner of the property w.e.f. 13.10.2011.”
The above
statements are factually false and incorrect. When the
petitioner indulges on falsehood for her cause the writ court
would also hesitate to exercise its discretionary powers in
favour of the petitioner.
25. Furthermore, the petitioner would fall within the
expression “any person” as specified under Section 17(1) of
the SARFAESI Act and hence was entitled to challenge the
action of the respondent no.1 before the Debts Recovery
Tribunal by filing an appropriate application. The petitioner
has not availed this alternative efficacious remedy. The writ
petition is liable to be dismissed on this ground as well.
26. The writ petition is therefore dismissed along with the
interim application.
( Bhaskar Raj Pradhan )
Judge
Approved for reporting :Yes
to
Internet :Yes
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review