Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:632
Serial No. 01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 133 of 2021
Date of Decision: 15.07.2024
MeECL Progressive Workers’ Union
Represented by its General Secretary
Mrs. Angelina M. Hynniewta
W/o (L) John. C. Ryntathiang
R/o Mawpat, Shillong, East Khasi Hills District,
Meghalaya
……Petitioners
-VERSUS1. The State of Meghalaya
Represented by the Chief Secretary, Government of Meghalaya,
Shillong
2. The Director Corporate Affairs
Government of Meghalaya
Lum Jingshai, Short Round Road, Shillong, East Khasi Hills,
Meghalaya-793001.
3. The Chairman-cum-Managing Director
Meghalaya Energy Corporation
Lum Jingshai, Short Round Road, Shillong, East Khasi Hills,
Meghalaya-793001.
…..Respondents
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
2024:MLHC:632
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. P. Yobin, Adv.
Mr. S. Singpho, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. N.D. Chullai, AAG with
Mr. E.R. Chyne, GA (For R 1)
Mr. A.S. Pandey, Adv. with
Ms. R. Colney, Adv. (For R 2 and 3)
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT
1.
The petitioner MeECL Progressive Workers’ Union espousing the
cause of the regular casual/contractual workers, such Union duly
registered under the Indian Trade Union Act, 1926, has approached this
Court with this instant application under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India on behalf of its members who are employees working under the
respondent/ Meghalaya Energy Corporation Limited (MeECL), inter alia
with a prayer that this Court be pleased to issue a writ of mandamus
directing the respondents to pay the members of the petitioner who are
appointed as regular casual/contractual employees to Grade-III and IV
posts with minimum pay scale revised from time to time, with permissible
allowances such as dearness allowance as are being paid to similarly
placed regular employees with arrears of pay.
2.
Heard Mr. P. Yobin, learned counsel for the petitioner/Union who
2024:MLHC:632
has submitted that the members of the petitioner/Union are appointed in
the sanctioned posts which posts are also available in the regular cadre,
however they were appointed on a casual/contractual basis, having been in
service for about two decades or so. Some of these posts includes the post
of Mali, Sweeper, Cleaner, Pump Operators, Chowkidar, Peon, Teacher,
Carpenter etc.
3.
The learned counsel has also submitted that the members of the
Union are appointed against the posts available in the regular cadre and
are also performing similar duties as was discharged by regular employees
holding the same/corresponding posts.
4.
Again, para 6 of this petition was referred to wherein a chart was
presented to show a comparison of the pay as per the Meghalaya Energy
Corporation Limited (Revision of Pay) Regulations, 2020 between the
members of the Union and regular employees performing the same nature
of work. Extract of a few entries, that is Sl. No. 1, 2 and 3 made in the
chart is reproduced herein below:
Sl.
Designati Existing
No
on
Revised Pay Matrix
Monthly salaries
Scales
paid
.
(ROP
member of the
Cleaner,
2105)
Rs.
Union
Rs 20900 - 21500 Unskilled
Mali,
13000-
-22100-22800-23500-
343/day x 30 =
Sweeper,
290(4)-
24200-24900-25600-
10,290+Increme
to
the
2024:MLHC:632
Khalasi,
14160-
26400-27200-28000-
nt
Chowkid
380(9)-
28800-29700-30600-
5% for 5 years
ar, Peon
17580-
31500-32400-33400-
10%
530(15)-
34000-35400-36500-
years
25530/-
37600-38700-39900-
15%
41100-42300-43600-
years
for
for
44900-46200-476002
Jugali
Rs.
49000/- (30 years)
Rs.
21900-22600- Skilled
13620-
23300-24000-24700-
435/day x 30 =
310(4)-
25400-26200-27000-
13050
14860-
27800-28600-29500-
+Increment
400(9)-
30400-31300-32200-
5% for 5 years
18460-
33200-34200-35200-
10%
550(15)-
36300-37400-38500-
years
26710
39700-40900-42100-
15%
43400-44700-46000-
years
for
for
47400-48800-503003
Pump
Rs.
51800/- (30 years)
Rs.
22900-23600- Skilled
Operator
14240-
24300-25000-25800-
435/day x 30 =
330(4)-
26600-27400-28200-
13,050
15560-
29000-29900-30800-
Increment
420(9)-
31700-32700-33700-
5% for 5 years
19340-
34700-35700-36800-
10%
+
for
2024:MLHC:632
570(15)-
37900-39000-40200-
years
27890/-
41400-42600-43900-
15%
45200-46600-48000-
years
for
49400-50900-5240054000/- (30 years)
5.
The learned counsel has further submitted that the members of the
Union though appointed as casual employees, the terms and conditions of
the Service Rules were made applicable to them and even in matters of
transfer the same rules which is in place for regular employees is also
made applicable to them.
6.
In this backdrop, the petitioner/Union has placed a charter of
demands before the respondent authorities, the implementation of “equal
pay for equal work” prominently figuring in such demands. To the dismay
of the members of the petitioner/Union, though the demand of equal pay
for equal work is legitimate, the same situation being present in other
Government Departments such as Education Department and Meghalaya
Urban Development Agency (MUDA) where the pay scale to the
temporary employees are at par with those of the regular employees, the
same being denied to the members of the petitioner/Union, there is
therefore a clear violation of the rights under Article 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India and is contrary to the Directive Principles envisaged
under Article 38(1) of the Constitution of India.
2024:MLHC:632
7.
The learned counsel has also pointed out to this Court that the
respondent authority vide Office Order dated 11.06.2020 had appointed
twenty of such temporary employees as regular employees with a given
scale of pay, thus depriving the other members of the petitioner/Union of
being treated equally under such circumstances.
8.
It is also the submission of the learned counsel that in this case, the
authority of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of State of Punjab &
Ors. v. Jagjit Singh & Ors., reported in (2017) 1 SCC 148, particularly
para 42, 42.1, 42.2, 42.3, 42.5, 43, 44, 44.1, 44.2, 44.3, 44.4, 44.7, 54, 5661are squarely applicable to the case of the petitioner/Union.
9.
It is therefore the prayer of the petitioner/Union that the relevant
respondent authorities be directed to pay to the members of the Union the
minimum pay scale revised from time to time with permissible allowances
as is being paid to those workers who are similarly situated regular
employees.
10.
Per
contra,
Mr.
A.S.
Pandey,
learned
counsel
for
the
respondent/MeECL would submit that the first preliminary objection
raised herein is that this petition is not maintainable in its present form
wherein it is noticed that this petition has been filed on behalf of a number
of petitioners albeit being members of the petitioner/Union but with
different causes of action where each member would seek relief to
specific set of facts and situation and which facts cannot be clubbed
together in a single writ petition.
2024:MLHC:632
11.
To clarify this position, the learned counsel has led this Court to
para 5 of the petition where an averment has been made that the members,
meaning many members of the petitioner/Union were appointed in the
sanctioned posts which was also available in the regular cadre, the nature
and responsibility of the work of both posts being the same. A
comprehensive table listing the name of the posts held by the members of
the Union and also the posts in the regular cadre has also been shown
therein. However, the facts concerning each post is different and cannot be
clubbed together in one single writ petition, the individual members of the
petitioner/Union
has
a
distinct
cause
of
action
against
the
respondent/MeECL.
12.
It is the further submission of the learned counsel that it is
incumbent upon the petitioner/Union or for that matter the individual
employees involved, that for making out a case of parity between two
posts there must be a “wholesome/wholesale identity between the holders
of two posts” for which the respective person is required to demonstrate
the source of entry, the qualifications possessed, the manner of
recruitment etc. which is lacking in this petition as only an omnibus
statement has been given by the petitioner/Union. On this singular issue
where there is clubbing of multiple causes of action into one single writ
petition, the same would render this instant petition to be not
maintainable. In support of this contention, the learned counsel has cited
the case of Binod Kumar & Ors. v. State of Jharkhand through the Chief
Secretary, Govt. of Jharkhand & Ors., 2022 SCC Online Jhar 107, para
2024:MLHC:632
16, P. Radhakrishna Naidu & Ors. v. Government of Andhra Pradesh &
Ors., (1977) 1 SCC 561, para 14 and also the case of Mota Singh & Ors.
v. State of Haryna & Ors., 1980 (Supp) SCC 600, para 2 and 3.
13.
Another limb of argument advanced by the learned counsel is that
the petitioner/Union in preferring this petition has failed to present the
correct factual matrix of the case of the members of the petitioner/Union,
who were appointed beyond the number of sanctioned posts on need
basis, example of such posts being the post of Electrician, Meter Reader
cum Bill Clerk and Jugali whose mode of appointment was on the basis of
a contract agreement, the pay of which are being fixed on the basis of the
notification issued by the Labour Department, Government of Meghalaya
in line with the Minimum Wages Act, 1948 depending on their skill and
ability. In fact, in addition to the said payment the corporation has also
extended a number of facilities which includes the following:
“a. Enhancement/Increment in the Salary w.e.f. 2018, based on the
experience/tenure of service of the Casual employee in MeECL and
its subsidiaries as below:
i. The percentage of enhancement of wages of the employee
whose tenure of service is above 5 years but below 10
years is fixed at 5% of the total amount of monthly wages.
ii. The percentage of enhancement of wages of the employee
whose tenure of service is above 10 years but below 15
years is fixed at 10% of the total amount of monthly
wages.
iii. The percentage of enhancement of wages of the employee
whose tenure of service is above 15 years but below 20
years is fixed at 15% of the total amount of monthly
wages.
2024:MLHC:632
b. Furthermore, additional benefits have also been extended for the
welfare of the Employees which are as mentioned below:Provident Fund coverage as per the Terms and Conditions
defined under the EPF Act, 1952
i. Casual Leave
ii. Earned Leave
iii. Maternity Leave
iv. Payment of overtime to the casual/contract employee.”
14.
The learned counsel has again submitted that when it comes to
drawing parity between two posts for the purpose of determination of
equal pay for equal work, the same would require a detail analysis which
only an administrative exercise can achieve wherein various factors like
the nature of appointment, qualifications, quality of work, quantity of
work, responsibility and accountability attached to such work has to be
determined which is not possible to be brought out in a writ petition. To
buttress this contention the case of Union of India v. Indian Navy Civilian
Design Officers Association & Anr., 2023 SCC Online SC 173, para 5, 9,
10, 11, 12, 13, 14 and the case of State of Madhya Pradesh. v. R.D.
Sharma & Anr., (2022) 13 SCC 320, para 17 was cited by the learned
counsel.
15.
The learned counsel has reiterated that the petitioner/Union has not
been able to present concrete evidence and cogent materials to show that
all the 31 posts indicated in this petition are equal to any post held by the
regular employees. In view of the presence of disputed questions of facts
determination of which is best left to the Executive, a writ court
exercising its extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
2024:MLHC:632
Constitution of India would not adjudicate on such disputed questions of
facts. The case of Subhas Jain v. Rajeshwari Shivam & Ors., (2021) 20
SCC 454, para 25 and State of Punjab v. Jagjit Singh(supra), para 9, 9.1,
9.2, 9.3, 10, 10.1, 10.2, 10.3, 42, 42.1, 42.5, 42.6, 42.8, 42.14 and 42.15
have been referred to in this regard.
16.
In reply to the contention of the petitioner/Union that the authorities
concerned has occasioned discrimination in appointment inasmuch as 20
contractual employees were in due course regularized in their respective
post disregarding the other similarly situated contractual employees, the
learned counsel has submitted that the said 20 contractual employees
whose posts have been regularised are the land owners or relatives of the
land owners who have donated their land situated at Umtru, Brynihat, Ri
Bhoi District for construction of new Umtru Hydel Project. This has been
done at the strength of office memorandum No.PER(AR).49/2012/67
dated 30.08.2017 issued by the Personnel & Admv.Reforms(B)
Department, Government of Meghalaya which provides for regular
appointment to be confirmed to such personnel.
17.
Upon hearing the argument advanced by the respective learned
counsels for the parties and on perusal of the pleadings on record, this
Court is made to understand that the dispute is essentially centered on the
allegation of the petitioner/Union that its members are being discriminated
as far as their just dues are concerned, particularly in the area of equal pay
for equal work.
2024:MLHC:632
18.
There is no dispute by the respondent authorities with regard to the
status of the members of the petitioner/Union as far as their employment
is concerned. In fact, the respondents would assert that the said members
of the petitioner/Union are the contractual employees of the respondent/
MeECL, appointed on a need basis for a period of one year with fixed pay
paid in line with the Minimum Wages Act, 1948 and with certain
additional financial facilities as has been elaborated at para 13
hereinabove.
19.
The respondent/MeECL would however contend that the claim for
equal pay for equal work would exist only when there is a
wholesome/wholesale identity between the holders of two posts as was
held in the case of Steel Authority of India Limited & Ors. v. Dibyendu
Bhattacharya, (2011) 11 SCC 122 and further that even if the designation
of the job is same, difference in educational or technical qualifications as
was observed in the case of State of Haryana & Ors. v. Jasmer Singh &
Ors., (1996) 11 SCC 77 has also to be taken into account. Reliance was
also placed in the case of Indian Navy Civilian Design Officers
Association (supra), particularly para 5, 9, 10, 11, 12, and 13 to say that
the concept of equal pay for equal work cannot be applied to unequal or
distinct classes and as such, daily workers cannot be equated with regular
workers.
20.
The said respondent has further emphasized the point that equation
of posts and determination of pay scales is the primary function of the
2024:MLHC:632
Executive and not of the Judiciary, such function requiring consideration
of a host of factors such as qualifications, the method of recruitment and
the nature of the duties and courts would generally not enter upon the task
of job evaluation which is generally left to the expert bodies like the pay
commission etc. These propositions are present in the case of Delhi
Transport Corporation Security Staff Union (Regd.) v. Delhi Transport
Corporation & Anr., (2018) 16 SCC 619 as well as in the case of R.D.
Sharma (supra) relied upon by the respondent/MeECL to bring home the
point that this instant petition has been preferred in a case where no writ is
maintainable and no fundamental or legal rights of the members of the
petitioner/Union have been violated.
21.
On
consideration
of
the
proposition
propounded
by
the
respondent/MeECL as above, where stress is laid on the aspect of
equation of posts and determination of pay scales thereof, which requires
proper classification best left to be done by an expert body or committee,
this Court is made aware that the case of the petitioner/Union is not for
equation of posts or determination of pay scale connected thereto, but that
there already exist same category of posts, for example, the post of
Cleaner or Mali, some manned by employees who have been recruited
through the regular process and some by employees appointed on
contractual basis for a period of one year, the same being renewed from
time to time. What is evident is that there are now two classes of
employees, one regular and another temporary, performing the same
nature of work by the same designation and drawing two different sets of
2024:MLHC:632
pay scales as is evident from the chart drawn up by the petitioner/Union at
para 6 of this petition. The authorities cited by the respondent/MeECL are
therefore found to be not relevant to the case in hand.
22.
The respondent/MeECL has also further contended that this petition
filed in a representative capacity is not maintainable inasmuch as it is
evident that the members of the petitioner/Union have separate causes of
action with each members having a distinct cause of action against the
action of the respondent. Again, in matters of demand of equal pay for
equal work, it is required to demonstrate the source of entry, the
qualifications possessed and the manner of recruitment etc. of each
individual as against their counterparts holding the same post who are
regular employees. The case of Binod Kumar (supra) and that of P.
Radhakrishna Naidu (supra) as well of that of Mota Singh (supra) was
also relied upon by the respondent in this regard.
23.
The reliance of the respondent/MeECL on the case of Binod Kumar
(supra), P. Radhakrishna Naidu (supra) and Mota Singh (supra) wherein it
is noticed that in each of these cases, a joint petition was filed by several
petitioners seeking common relief but pursuing their individual interest
and therefore, such petitioners were called upon to pursue their respective
individual case or even if allowed to join together, to pay the required
court fees as individuals, cannot be equated with the case in hand as in
this case, a recognized registered Union has taken up the common cause
of all its members as regard the demand of equal pay for equal work.
2024:MLHC:632
24.
Therefore, the objection of the respondent/MeECL as regard the
maintainability of this petition on the ground that it could not have been
filed by the petitioner/Union on behalf of its members collectively as
separate cause of action exists pertaining to individual claims against
respective posts occupied by the said members cannot be accepted by this
Court inasmuch as the petitioner/Union through its General Secretary,
duly authorised by the resolution, annexed as Annexure-A/3 is
representing its members who are all contractual employees of the
respondent/MeECL. They all have a common cause, that is, a demand for
grant of equal pay for equal work. The basis of the grievance of the
members of the petitioner/Union is the alleged unequal treatment to them
in the matter of service vis-à-vis their counterparts in the same
organisation who are regular employees. On this score, this Court is of the
considered opinion that this petition is maintainable.
25.
The case of the petitioner/Union could best be understood on the
authority relied upon in this regard, that is, the case of Jagjit Singh (supra)
and the relevant paras cited, which are self-explanatory on perusal of the
same and thus are required to be reproduced herein as:
“42. All the judgments noticed in paras 7 to 24 hereinabove,
pertain to employees engaged on regular basis, who were claiming
higher wages, under the principle of “equal pay for equal work”.
The claim raised by such employees was premised on the ground,
that the duties and responsibilities rendered by them were against
the same post for which a higher pay scale was being allowed in
other government departments. Or alternatively, their duties and
responsibilities were the same as of other posts with different
2024:MLHC:632
designations, but they were placed in a lower scale. Having been
painstakingly taken through the parameters laid down by this
Court, wherein the principle of “equal pay for equal work” was
invoked and considered, it would be just and appropriate to
delineate the parameters laid down by this Court. In recording the
said parameters, we have also adverted to some other judgments
pertaining to temporary employees (also dealt with, in the instant
judgment), wherein also, this Court had the occasion to express the
legal position with reference to the principle of “equal pay for
equal work”. Our consideration, has led us to the following
deductions:42.3. The principle of “equal pay for equal work”, applies to cases
of unequal scales of pay, based on no classification or irrational
classification, Randhir Singh v. Union of India, (1982) 1 SCC 618.
For equal pay, the employees concerned with whom equation is
sought, should be performing work, which besides being
functionally equal, should be of the same quality and sensitivity,
Federation of All India Customs and Central Excise Stenographers
v. Union of India (1988) 3 SCC 91, Mewa Ram Kanojia v. All
India Institute of Medical Sciences, (1989) 2 SCC 235, Grih
Kalyan Kendra Workers' Union of India, (1991) 1 SCC 619 and
the S.C. Chandra v. State of Jharkhand (2007) 8 SCC 279.
44.3. In Bhagwan Dass case, (1987) 4 SCC 634 this Court
recorded that in a claim for equal wages, the duration for which an
employee would remain (or had remained) engaged, would not
make any difference. So also, the manner of selection and
appointment would make no difference. And therefore, whether
the selection was made on the basis of open competition or was
limited to a cluster of villages, was considered inconsequential,
insofar as the applicability of the principle is concerned. And
likewise, whether the appointment was for a fixed limited duration
(six months, or one year), or for an unlimited duration, was also
considered inconsequential, insofar as the applicability of the
principle of “equal pay for equal work” is concerned. It was held
that the claim for equal wages would be sustainable, where an
2024:MLHC:632
employee is required to discharge similar duties and
responsibilities as regular employees, and the employee concerned
possesses the qualifications prescribed for the post. In the above
case, this Court rejected the contention advanced on behalf of the
Government, that the plea of equal wages by the employees in
question, was not sustainable because the employees concerned
were engaged in a temporary scheme, and against posts which
were sanctioned on a year-to-year basis.
44.4. In Daily Rated Casual Labour case, (1988) 1 SCC 122 this
Court held, that under the principle flowing from Article 38(2) of
the Constitution, the Government could not deny a temporary
employee, at least the minimum wage being paid to an employee
in the corresponding regular cadre, alongwith dearness allowance
and additional dearness allowance, as well as, all the other benefits
which were being extended to casual workers. It was also held,
that the classification of workers (as unskilled, semi-skilled and
skilled), doing the same work, into different categories for
payment of wages at different rates, was not tenable. It was also
held, that such an act of an employer would amount to
exploitation. And further that the same would be arbitrary and
discriminatory, and therefore, violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution.
44.5. In State of Punjab v. Devinder Singh, (1998) 9 SCC 595 this
Court held that daily wagers were entitled to be placed in the
minimum of the pay scale of regular employees working against
the same post. The above direction was issued after accepting that
the employees concerned were doing the same work as regular
incumbents holding the same post by applying the principle of
"equal pay for equal work".
44.6. In State of Karnataka case, (2006) 4 SCC 1, a Constitution
Bench of this Court, set aside the judgment of the High Court, and
directed that daily wagers be paid salary equal to the lowest grade
of salary and allowances being paid to regular employees.
Importantly, in this case, this Court made a very important
2024:MLHC:632
distinction between pay parity and regularisation. It was held that
the concept of equality would not be applicable to issues of
absorption/regularisation. But, the concept was held as applicable,
and was indeed applied, to the issue of pay parity – if the work
component was the same. The judgment rendered by the High
Court was modified by this Court, and the daily-wage employees
concerned were directed to be paid wages equal to the salary at the
lowest grade of the cadre concerned.
58. In our considered view, it is fallacious to determine artificial
parameters to deny fruits of labour. An employee engaged for the
same work cannot be paid less than another who performs the
same duties and responsibilities. Certainly not, in a welfare state.
Such an action besides being demeaning, strikes at the very
foundation of human dignity. Anyone, who is compelled to work
at a lesser wage does not do so voluntarily. He does so to provide
food and shelter to his family, at the cost of his self-respect and
dignity, at the cost of his self-worth, and at the cost of his integrity.
For he knows that his dependents would suffer immensely, if he
does not accept the lesser wage. Any act of paying less wages as
compared to others similarly situate constitutes an act of
exploitative enslavement, emerging out of a domineering position.
Undoubtedly, the action is oppressive, suppressive and coercive,
as it compels involuntary subjugation.
60. Having traversed the legal parameters with reference to the
application of the principle of “equal pay for equal work”, in
relation to temporary employees (daily-wage employees, ad hoc
appointees, employees appointed on casual basis, contractual
employees and the like), the sole factor that requires our
determination is, whether the employees concerned (before this
Court), were rendering similar duties and responsibilities, as were
being discharged by regular employees holding the
same/corresponding posts. This exercise would require the
application of the parameters of the principle of “equal pay for
equal work” summarised by us in para 42 above. However, insofar
as the instant aspect of the matter is concerned, it is not difficult
2024:MLHC:632
for us to record the factual position. We say so, because it was
fairly acknowledged by the learned counsel representing the State
of Punjab, that all the temporary employees in the present bunch
of appeals were appointed against posts which were also available
in the regular cadre/establishment. It was also accepted that during
the course of their employment, the temporary employees
concerned were being randomly deputed to discharge duties and
responsibilities which at some point in time were assigned to
regular employees. Likewise, regular employees holding
substantive posts were also posted to discharge the same work
which was assigned to temporary employees from time to time.
There is, therefore, no room for any doubt, that the duties and
responsibilities discharged by the temporary employees in the
present set of appeals were the same as were being discharged by
regular employees. It is not the case of the appellants, that the
respondent employees did not possess the qualifications prescribed
for appointment on regular basis. Furthermore, it is not the case of
the State that any of the temporary employees would not be
entitled to pay parity on any of the principles summarised by us in
para 42 hereinabove. There can be no doubt, that the principle of
“equal pay for equal work” would be applicable to all the
temporary employees concerned, so as to vest in them the right to
claim wages on a par with the minimum of the pay scale of
regularly engaged government employees holding the same post.”
26.
At this juncture, it may be pointed out that the claim of the
petitioner/Union is not for regularisation of its members to the posts they
are appointed to, but for payment of the minimum pay scale as is being
paid to the employees who are drawing the regular pay scale.
27.
As to the contention of the petitioner/Union as regard the alleged
discrimination as far as regularisation is concerned, particularly the
process for regularisation of 20 employees, the explanation offered by the
2024:MLHC:632
respondent/MeECL that the said 20 employees were regularised on the
bases of an agreement made between the MeECL and the land owners,
etc. for appointment of their preferred candidates, the same cannot be
faulted since the policy decision of the Government in this regard would
cover such decision. The said policy is found in the office memorandum
No.PER/(AR).49/2012/67 dated 30.08.2017 (Annexure-R/2 of the
affidavit-in-opposition) wherein the following is noted:
“In case where private land owner(s) have donated land free of cost
for Government purpose, the land proposed to be donated should be
legally handed over through a registered deed to enable the
Government to provide appointment to any person(s) as
recommended by the land owner(s) in a Grade IV/Grade III posts.
Where land is donated by the Nokma/Syiem/Dolloi/Raid/Clan, etc
then the Nokma/Syiem/Dolloi/Raid/Clan/Sardar, as the case may
be, shall identify the appropriate person or persons, in consultation
with the affected families, if any, to whom appointment can be
given. The Deputy Commissioner of the concerned District will
identify the post in consultation with the District Head of the
concerned Department to which the land is being donated.
Appointment under this provision will be outside the purview of the
DSC.”
28.
As was held at para 61 of the Jagjit Singh case, this Court is also of
the view that the members of the petitioner/Union herein are entitled to
the minimum pay scale at the lowest grade in the regular pay scale as was
made applicable to their counterparts. The said para reads as follows:
“61. In view of the position expressed by us in the foregoing
paragraph, we have no hesitation in holding that all the temporary
employees concerned, in the present bunch of cases would be
entitled to draw wages at the minimum of the pay scale (at the
2024:MLHC:632
lowest grade, in the regular pay scale), extended to regular
employees holding the same post.”
29.
In view of the above, to the extent indicated, the prayer made in this
petition is allowed. The relevant respondent authorities in the MeECL are
hereby directed to take necessary action to implement the directions given
herein, that is, to ensure that the members of the petitioner/Union, whose
names can be found at Annexure-A/3 are being paid equal pay for equal
work. The same to be completed preferably within a period of 2(two)
months from the date of receipt of the certified copy of this judgment and
order.
30.
Petition disposed of. No costs.
Judge
TIPRILYNTI KHARKONGOR
Date: 2024.07.15 17:23:59
PDT
Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review