Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[ 34e41
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR T+IE.STATE
AT HYDERABAD
OF TELANGANA
DAY OF, JANUARY
.FRIDAY,
".- THE TWENTY THIRD
SIX
TWOTHOUSAND AND TWENTY
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE
THE HoNouRABLE sRl 'rusrrtE"vlrlrl
K'LAKSHMAN
RAMAKRISHNA REDDY
WRI T APPE AL NO : 1637 OF
against the order
the Letters Patent preferred
Writ Appeal under clause 15 of
High Court'
9 ot 2017 ' on the file of the
dt.23-08-2017 in WP No 1181
Between:
Pocket
of lndia' Through its Secretary'
I lvledical Council007
14' Sector 8' Dwarka'
New Delhi-1 10
,Ira3:T'a*",'3"!i:y"l?i'^i"li)'L,Hi',",1"f#:ill"lrrffi -rl
AND
'Viii#',i#i,':"r'*'fi 1?"8?:R1il"1g"3,3ii"Y:f
:'#3:'d"'No2-6'Venkirara
..'RESPONDENT'PETITlONER
3Yilii,.{ilx,"a$Ii":7fJ#:ix[[1fi iJif '3"31FJ3{}\?['%1]l'
...RESPONDENTS'RESPONOENTS
l.A. NO: 10F 2017
(wA MP. NO:3 117 0F 20 171
circumsta nces stated in
to
High Court may be pleased
CPC praying that in the
Petition under Section 151
the affidavit filed in support
of the petition' the
Judge Passed
Order of the Learned Single
lmpugned
the
of
suspend the operation
APPeal.
pending disposal of th e Writ
24'08'2017
dated
of
in W.P. No. 11819
IA NO :1OF 2025
Between:
Mr. Jan
Village, 'g#i,':"r"*,fi
Dist.) Telangana
i?;?:R?**g's ,3P3Y: &?JSs,{i v? Jl3,','3rY,iJ,fi'"''
...PEflflONER/RESPONDENT
NO.l
AND
Delhi The
New
of lnd a, Ministry of Health, Aep gy rli Secretary' Derhi
1.
New
' Union
it3
Director'
n'ep dv
il:iil;;i iil;i ;i Ei;'r.iii""
Hep bv its Director' New Delhi
Ed;iinatofi,
2. iruftaiio1;i'eo;'d
"r
...RESPONDENTS/RESPONDENTS
3. Medical Cortncil of lndia, Through its Secretary' Pocket 14' Sector
8' Dwarka'
New Delhi-'10 007
Pocket - 4'
Assistant Secretary (Eligibility), .V.tat".q] ^Crcuncil of lndia'
The
4.
seltor - 8, I)warka Phase - 1, New Delhi '.]iB'PLLLONTS/RESPONDENTS
'
PetitionunderSectionl5lcPcprayingthatinthecircumstancesstatedin
theaffidavitfiledinsupportofthepetition'theHighcourtmaybep|easedto
vacate the interinr orders passed by this Hon'ble Court
in WAMP No' 3117 of 2017
inWANo.163Tlf2olT,Dl.og.ll.2olTandordersmaybepassedaccordinglyin
the interest of jut;tice.
PUJITHA
Counsel for the Appellants: Ms. GORANTLA SRI RANGA
C.r.""f for the Rlipondent No.1: SRI DEVULAPALLI BRAHMAM
lNolA
for the Responueni rlo.z: DEPUTY soLlclroR GENERAL oF
Counsel for the ResPondent No'3:
a;;;;i
-
The Court made the following: JUDGMENT
{:t
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE K. LAKSHMAN
AND
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE VAKITI RAMAKRISHNA REDDY
o
DATE:23-01-2026.
Between:
. Appellants -
Medical Council of lndia, New Delhi & another
Respondents
Vs.
Mr. Jangam Mallesh & others
Respondents
Petitioncr &
Respondents
This Court made the following:
JUDGMENT: (Per Hon'ble Sri Justice K' Lakshman)
Heard Mrs. Gorantla Sri Ranga Pujitha, learned Standing
Counsel for the appellant and Mr. Pasham t('ishna Reddy,
learned
counsel representing Mr. Devulapatli Brahmam, learned counsel
for
respondent No.1.
2.Feetingaggrievedanddissatisfiedwiththeorderdated
23.08.2017 in w.P. No. I t 819 of 2Ol7 passed by learned
the appeltants preferred the present Intra-court Appeal
Single Judge'
under clause -
l5 of the Letters Patent'
-l-
,)
KLJ & VRKR,J
W.A. No.l637 of 2017
3. ltespondent No.l has filed the aforesaid writ petition to
declare the action of appellant No.1 herein - respondent No.2 therein
in rejectinll to issue eligibility certificate to his daughter - Ms. Janga
Shirisha fcrr Bachelor of Medicine and Bachelor of Surgery (MBBS)
Course vide proceedings dated 26.12.2016, as illegal, and for a
consequer,tial direction to the appellants herein to issue eligibility
certificate to his daughter for MBBS Degree for the purpose of
attending Screening Test conducted by respondent No.3 herein.
4. Respondent No.l herein contended that his daughter - Ms.
Janga Shirisha was born on 04.03.2000. She attended her SSC final
examinations in the month of March, 2014, though the minimum age
required to complete 10th Class was fifteen (15) years. Concerned
authoriti,:s have permitted his daughter to attend SSC Examination
though fter age was less. On completion of her SCC, she joined
lnterme<liate Course in Bi.P.C., and completed the said Course in
March, 2016. Though she was less than required age for appearing
lnterme,Jiate examinations, the authorities accorded permission for her
to write Intermediate examination as well.
5. tt is further contended that on completion of Intermediate
examiqation, she took admission in MBBS Course at General
J
KL.J & VRKR,J
W.A. No.l637 of 2017
Medicine Faculty of Astana Medical Univeisity (Kazakhstan) for the
academic year 2016-1,7 Batch. She joined in the said Course and
completed her first year course in the said University. She has
submitted a representation on 13.10.2016 to the appellants seeking
permission to join medical course on relaxing her age in terms of
Section - l3 of the Indian Medical Council Act, 1956 (For shon'Act,
1956'). She has also enclosed exemptions granted by the State
Government permitting her to appear SSC and lntermediate
Examinations though she is less than required age along with the said
representation. On26.12.2016, after her joining into medical course,
the appellants herein issued impugned letter rejecting the request
made by her for issuance of eligibility certificate on the ground that
she was less than [7 years.
6. Challenging the said proceedings, respondent No.1 filed the
aforesaid writ petition contending that in similar circumstances vide
order dated 22.08.2016 in W.P. No.36316 of 2015 this Court and a
Division Bench of Allahabad High Court in Ankit Chaturvedi v.
Union of Indiar, though students were less than the required age of 17
'. 2otq uwTufflRttl st+
KL,J & VRKR,J
W.A. No.1617 of20l7
years, directed the Medical Council of India (MCI) - appellant No.1
herein to is:;ue eligibility certihcate.
7. fhe appellants herein filed counter contending that the
judgment i n W.P. No.363 16 of 20 15 does not apply to the facts of the
present case and the MCI Regulations are statutory in nature. The
daughter of respondent No.l herein is not eligible for issuance of
eligibility certificate. Thus, the appellants sought to dismiss the said
writ petition.
8. Tide impugned order dated 23.08.2017,leamed Single Judge
placing reliance on the order in W.P. No.36316 of 2015 directed MCI
to issue eligibility certificate to the daughter of respondent No.
1.
Challenging the said order, MCI filed the present Intra-Cowt Appeal.
9. Mrs. Gorantla Sri Ranga Pujitha, leamed Standing Counsel
for the appellants and Mr. Pasham Krishna Reddy, learned counsel
represenl
ing Mr. Devulapalli Brahmam, leamed counsel for
responde,nt No.l made their submissions extensively.
l(t. Mrs. Gorantla Sri Ranga Pujitha, leamed Standing Counsel
placed rr:liance on the following decisions:
KI-,J & VRKR,J
W.A. No.l637 of 2017
i) Jishalakshi Embrandiri v. I\rtedical Council of India2'
ii) Akshanjali Morya v. Union of India3'
iii) Ankit Chaturvedt.
iv) Rithika Monika v. Union of Indiaa'
v) w.P. No.31337 of 2016 & batch, decided on 21.09.2016.
vi)Tekuta Samhitha Reddy v. Union of Indias'
u.
whereas, Mr. Pasham Krishna Reddy, learned counsel
v'
placed reliance on the decision in National Medical Commission
Lottongbam Bimolchandra Singh6'
12. In the light of the aforesaid rival submissions, it is relevant
to deal with the provisions of Act, 1956 and the Regulations made
by
it.
13. Section - 13 (4A) of the Act, 1956 envisages that a person
who is a citizen of India and obtains medical qualification granted
by
any medical institution in any country outside India recognised
for
enrolment as medical practitioner in that country after such date
may be specified by the Central Govemment under sub-section
. 2006 SCC Online Del. 1659
. 2013 SCC OnLine Raj 1698
W.P. No.l263 5 of 2024,decided on 03'05'2024
W.P.No.6265 & 7O4l of 2017, decided on l3'07'2017
Ciriul epp"ul No.l2l8-1219 of 2022, decided on08'02'2022
as
(3),
KL,J & VRKR,J
W.A. No.1637 of 2017
sha[ not be entitted to be enrolled on any Medical Register
maintained by a State Medical Council or to have his name entered in
the Indian Irdedical Register unless he qualifred the screening test in
India presoribed for such purpose and such foreign medical
qualificatiol after such person qualifies that said screening test shall
be deemed to be the recognised medical qualification for the purposes
of the Act lbr that Person.
14. secrion - 13 (4B) of the Act, 1956 envisages that a person
who is a cfiizen of India shall not, after such date as may be specified
by the Central Government under sub-section (3), be eligible to get
admission to obtain medical qualification granted by any medical
institutior in any foreign country without obtaining an eligibility
certificatr; issued to him by the Council and in case any such person
obtains sgch qualification without obtaining such eligibility certificate,
he shall not be eligible to appear in the screening test referred to in
sub-section ( A).
1-';. In exercise of the powers conferred by Section - 33 of the
Act, I9:i6, the Eligibility Requirement for Taking Admission in an
Undergraduate Medical Course in a Foreign Medical Institution
\ .\_
1r
KLJ& VRKR,J
W.A. No.l637 of 2017
r
Regulations, 2002 (for short Regulations, 2002') were framed and
were notified in the Gazette of India on 18.02.2002.
16. Regulation - 8 of the Regulations, 2002 requires that the
Council to consider the application for eligibility certificate and veri$
the details mentioned in Clauses - (i) to (iii) therein as per the
Regulations of the Council. Clause - (i) of the Regulation - 8 requires
the Council to ascertain whether the candidate fulfills the age criterion
prescribed by the Council.
17. Age criteria stipulated in Regulation - 4 of the Medical
Council of lndia Regulations on Graduate Medical Education 1997 is
that candidate should complete 17 years of age on or before 31"
December of the year of admission into the MBBS Course. The said
Regulations are statutory in nature.
18. The fixation of said age limit fell for consideration before a
Division Bench of Rajasthan High Court in Akshanjali Morya3.
Paragraph Nso.8 to 12 of the said judgment are relevant and the same
are extracted as under:
"8. Thus, a bare perusal of the Regulations
extracted hereinabove would reveal that in fact, the
age limit of 17 years has been fixed by an expert
ri
KLJ & VRKR,J
W.A. No.l637 of 2017
committee consisting of experts in the medical
fir:ld and other related fields and we are afraid that
the subject matter would, if at all' fall for
crrnsideration of this Court under Article 226 of
C.onstitution of tndia, within the ambit of
the
judicial
r3vlew.
!). By now it is well settled that it is' not the
lunction of the Courts to go into the question of
prescription of age, unless, it seems to be so absurd
prudence
and unreasonable that a man of ordinary
would not accept such a prescription' Even
any
otherwise, the Courts are not equipped with
would
expertise to come to a conclusion as to what
be the proper age for a student to enter the
M.B.B.S. Course- It is for the policy makers to
consider the various factors which are relevant
to
the issue, before fixing the age limit for admission
to the medical courses-
l0.Further,thereisarationalebehindthef,rxingof
the date on which a candidate must attain the age
of 17 years. [t is intended to apply uniformly
throughout the country. The Medical Council of
India has chosen to fix the date as 31't of
Decembeg of the concerned year, in which a
candidate is admitted to the M'B'B'S' Course' The
qualiffing examinations are conducted by the
various Boards, Universities etc', at different
points of time in a year. Similarly, the entrance
KL,J & VRKR,J
w.A No.1637 of 2017
examinations for the admission to M.B.B.S.
Course are conducted on different dates.
I l. Moreover, the first year M.B.B.S. Course may
commence at different points of time in a year.
Therefore, with a view to have uniformity, the
Medical Council has chosen 31'tof December of
the examination, as the date on which the
candidate should attain the age of 17 years, in the
year in which the admission to the M.B.B.S.
Course is made. In the existing pattern of
education in the country, normally, a candidate
passes the qualifying the examination at the age of
16 or 17 years of age. The Medical Council in its
wisdom had come to the conclusion that, for
proper understanding and comprehension of
medical education, a candidate must possess
certain level of maturity, which comes with age.
The prescription of the minimum age is on account
of studied deliberations made by the Medical
Council and is a manifestation of an informed
decision taken by the Medical Council in
association with the Central Government, for
prescribing the minimum standards and
qualifications. The said decision has been taken in
pursuance of the discussions, consultations and
deliberations, made by an expert academic body
and is made for the furtherance and maintenance of
minimum standards for medical education.
l0
KL,J& VRKR,J
W.A. No.l637 of 2017
Therefore, such a regulation cannot be
characterised as arbitrary-
12.lt has also been submitted that though Section
33 of the Act of 1956 empowers the Medical
(louncil of India to fix the standard of education,
trut prescription of minimum age by the Medical
rlouncil of India cannot be construed to be within
';he power. We fail to understand how and on what
grounds, such powers can be ousted from the
ambit of powers conferred by virtue Section 33 of
the Act of 1956. Even if the candidate concerned
had been permitted to write the 10ft standard and
the plus two examinations by granting an
exemption, with regard to the minimum required
age of the candidate, it cannot be a good reason for
the granting of such an exemption, in respect of the
age limit fixed, under Condition Number (ii) of the
Eligibility Criterion of the prospectus/admission
form, issued by the third respondent, for the
M.B.B.S./B.D.S. admissions, for the academic
session 2Ol3'2014. Except for the fact that Section
33 of the Act, 1956 empowers the Medical Council
of India to fix the standard of education, no
apparent arbitrariness, illegality, irrationality or
unreasonableness, in the stipulation for minimum
age of 17 years, which must have been attained by
a candidate on or before 31't December of the
concerned year, is discernible to characterize the
ll
KL,J & VRKR,J
W.A. No.1637 of 2017
same as unconstitutional or ultra-vires of Article
14 of the Constitution of India. Therefore, the
relief(s) sought for by the petitioner in the present
writ petition is devoid of merits."
The Division Bench of Rajasthan High Court on examination of facts
of the said case wherein the petitioner therein would not be
completing 17 years of age, on or before 31.12.2013, she is not
qualified to appty for the MBBS/BDS Courses, for the academic
sessions 2Ol3-14. Merely for the reason that the petitioner had been
permitted to write the 10th standard and the plus two examinations, it
cannot be a ground for granting the exemption in favour of the
petitioner, in respect of the age limit prescribed under condition
No.(ii) of the Eligibility Criterion of the prospectus/admission form
issued by the CBSE. Paragraph Nos.15 and 16 of the said judgment
are also relevant and the same are extracted hereunder:
"15. Wisdom is the quatity of being wise or the
capability of taking wise decisions. Wisdom is
something which generally comes with experience
and old age. An elderly person is supposed to be
more wise and mature when it comes to taking
decisions. People possessing a great sense of
wisdom are sagacious people, who are skilled and
experts when it comes to making and executing
t2
KL.J & VRKR,J
W.A. No.l637 of 2017
their plans and decisions. According to Moliere,
"A wise man is superior to any insults which can
be put upon him, and the best reply to unseemly
behaviour is patience and moderation." Expecting
someone young to have the capability of making
wise and just decisions is quite foolhardy. Wisdom
is a quality that comes with several experiences in
life and is associated generally with people who
have come off age. Wisdom tooth appears at the
age of 18 in mature adults. Confucius, "By three
methods we may leam wisdom: First, by
reflection, which is noblest; second, by imitation,
which is easiest; and third by experience, which is
the bitterest."
16. The purpose of the "Regulations on Graduate
Medical Education, 1997" is to ensure uniform
standards for medical courses in view of the nature
of the studies which are undertaken for such
courses. The essential qualifications are even hxed
for admission to M.B.B.S./B.D.S. Courses by
CIISE. The relevant provisions for eligibility for
entrance examination to the M.B.B.S./B.D.S.Courses as stipulated under condition Number (ii)
of the Eligibility Criterion of
rhe
prospectus/admission form, issued by the third
respondent, including others, is as follows:
(ii) He/she has attained or will attain the age of
seventeen (17) years as on 31st December of the
l3
KL,J & VRKR,J
W.A. No.l637 of 2017
yeff of the admission to the MBBS/BDSCourses."
With the said findings, the Division Bench of Rajasthan High Court
declined to grant relief sought by the petitioner to grant eligibility
certificate on the ground that she has not completed 17 years of age as
on 31 .12.2013.
19. tn Ankit Chaturvedir, a Division Bench of Allahabad
High Court in paragraph Nos.l0 and 12 held as under:
"10. Undoubtedly, education is a constitutional
right and constitutes an essential part of life. But
this does not foreclose the statutory powers of an
expert academic authority to prescribe reasonable
conditions for the pursuit of education in areas
over which it has been vested with jurisdiction by
Parliament. The requirement that a candidate
should have completed 17 years of age on the 3lst
day of December of the year in which admission is
taken to the MBBS Degree Course is based on a
rational foundation.
11. The matter can
be looked at from two
perspectives. The first perspective of the
requirement is related to the age at which a
candidate would be ordinarily expected to have
completed the qualiffing examination. The
qualiffing examination being higher secondary or
I
t
l4
KL,J & VRKR,J
W.A. No.1637 of 2017
Class-XII examination, oidinarily, a student would
not have completed the examination before
completing the age of 17. That proceeds on the
basis that even if admission is taken at the age of
five (though, in the present age, admission to
primary classes is granted at the age of six),
students would thereafter pursue 12 years of
education. [n other words, ordinarily speaking, the
age requirement is so structured as to allow a
student to have completed a full 12 years of study
for the purpose of completing the higher secondary
education."
20. With the said observations and on examination of the facts
of the said case, the Division Bench of Allahabad High Court
dismissed the petition filed by the petitioner therein seeking issuance
of eligibility certificate on the ground that he has not compteted l7
years of age as on the date of 3l't December of the said admission
year.
21. It is apt to note that Ankit Chaturvedi filed SLp vrde
Special l-eave to Appeal (c) No.13843 of 2016 (arising out of
impugnerl final judgment and order dated 05.02.2016 in s.A. No.248
of 2015) befbre the Apex Court. Vide order dated 31.07.2017, the
Apex Court considering the fact that the petitioner therein has already
l5
KL,J & VRKR,J
W.A. No.l637 of 2017
in the Screening
passed the MBBS examination and.also quatified
Test, granted relief Sought by the petitioner and
directed the MCI to
register him as a Medical Practitioner. However,
observed that the said order is passed keeping
the Apex court
in view the special
as an order passed under
features of the case, and it has to be treated
Article - 142 of the Constitution of India'
22. InJishalakshi Embrandiri2, learned Single
High Court in paragraph Nos'7 and 8 held as
"7. The challenge to the legality
Judge of Delhi
follows:
of the 17 yeat
in
criteria has been rejected by the Division Bench
CWP No. 4353 of 2OO3 titled Mohit Kumar
Arora v. University of Delhi by
a detailed
Judgment on llth July, 2003' After discussing
well as
numerous precedents of the Apex Court as
other High Courts the Division Bench had
opined
that the requirement of age, both minimum and
maximum, is mandatory and not directory' [n
professional courses the authorities thought it
proper to have proper maturity and understanding
course by the candidate and have the
of the
requirement to prescribe the age and it is
based on
intelligibte differentia. There is an objective
achieved. The classification of 17 years
to be
is based on
rational aspect- A Full Bench presided over
Chief Justice J-S. Verma (as the Learned Chief
by
l6
KI,.J & VRKR,J
w.A. No. 1637 of 2017
Iustice of India then wls) has, in similar vein,
observed in Gautam Kapoor v. State of Rajasthan,
AIR 1987 Rajasthan 1,74 that the minimum age of
17 1,ears for entry into a Medical College cannot
be called unreasonable or arbitrary.
8. Anxiety over possible stumbling blocks to the
future of students aspiring to practice as Doctors in
lndia after pursuing medical studies in foreign
Universities has been assuaged in large measure by
the requirement of obtaining an Eligibility
Certificate prior to the commencement of studies
abroad post 15.3.2002. The MCI would now be
expected and empowered to issue these
Certificates only if the applicant has (a) attained
the age of seventeen years, (b) has passed 10+2 in
the prescribed subjects with the required minimum
percentage (50 per cent) and (c) intends to pursue
studies in a foreign University which has been duly
mentioned and recognized in the IMC Act. I am
unable to accept the contention of learned counsel
appearing for the Petitioners that the prescription
of 17 years had been introduced only in 1997 and
is, therefore, not binding on persons who had
commenced their studies prior thereto. Learned
counsel for the MCI has filed Recommendations
adopted by the MCI has filed Recommendations
adopted by the MCI in February, 1971 onwards,
and Regulations from October, 1978 onwards
"."...4Y..
,/
,r'
,/
l7
.,.7
.,1
KL,J & VRKR,J
W.A. No.l637 of 2017
'i
explicitly requiring that a candidate should have
completed the age of 17 years at the time of
admission or should have completed that age on or
before 3lst December of the year of his
admission."
with the said findings, Delhi High Court dismissed the writ petition
filed by the petitioner therein seeking
lssuance
of eligibility
certification on the ground that he has not completed [7 years of age
at the relevant point of time.
23. In W.P. No.31337 of 2016 & batch, a Division Bench of
erstwhile High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad for the States of
Telangana and Andhra Pradesh held as under:
"3. [t appears that Regulation 4 of Medical Council
of India Regulations on Graduate Medical
Education, 1,997, which prescribes the completion
of 17 years of age as on the 31't December of the
calendar year, for admission to undergraduate
medical courses came under challenge before a
Division Bench of this Court in Master Alli Sai
Deepak Vs. Government of Andhra Pradesh
(W.P.No.l7l62 of 2009). The petitioner in the
said case fell short only by two months and 23
days. As a matter of fact, the Government issued
an order granting exemption to the petitioner
KL,J & VRKRJ
W.A. No.l637of 2017
t.herein. But this Court not only upheld
Regulation 4 but also frowned upon the State
Government fbr granting exemption. Therefore,
the petitioners in these cases, are not entitled to the
reliefs that they seek, in view of the said decision
of another coordinate bench of this Court. [t is true
that in two or three cases on hand, the petitioners
fall short by the required age, only by a few days.
One of the petitioners has secured more than 982
marks out of 1000 and he has fallen short only by
three days."
With the aforesaid observations, the Division Bench dismissed the
aforesaid batch of writ petitions.
24. ln Tekula Samhitha Reddys, another Division Bench of
erstwhile High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad for the States of
Telangana and Andhra Pradesh reiterating the said principle also
dismissec the writ petitions on the same ground
25. In the order dated 22.08.2016 in W.P. No.36316 of 2015,
the petitioner therein was born on 13.09.1992, he has submitted an
applicati,rn on 28.04.2010 seeking issuance of eligibility certificate,
the same was rejected by the MCI vide order dated 10.09.2015. The
l9
/.
KL,J & VRKR,J
W.A. No.1637 of 2017
petitioner therein filed writ petition challenging the said rejection
proceedingi.
26. Learned Single Judge relying on the judgment of Delhi
High Court in Jishalakshi Embrandiri2 observed as follows:
"The guidelines/ regulations are of the year
1997. During that period, the Mobile phones
started coming to our country. The Internet
and other advanced electrical gadgets were not
in active force. We are moving towards ecourts, paperless courts and appreciating any of
the citizen of this country, who does some out
of the routine or anti-stream. Even in Sports,
16 years 17 years boys and girls are
participating and bagging medals for their
respective countries. In that case, we
appreciate and celebrate that at such a younger
age, he/she has attained this much of position.
Now we are moving through the advancement
and one to move with the supersonic speed. [n
such a situation, age of 17 years and that his
eligibility certificate, I feel has no meaning."
With the said observations, learned Single Judge of erstwhile High
Court of Judicature at Hyderabad for the States of Telangana and
KL,J & VRKR,J
W.A. No.l637 of 2017
Andhra Pradesh directed the MCI to issue eligibility certificate to the
petitioner therein.
27. l-eamed Single Judge also observed as follows:
"[n view of the opinion rendered in this petition, I
hereby suggest the Central Government and
Medical Council of lndia to revisit the regulations
and say good bye to minimum age i.e., 17 years,
which is made compulsory before entering into
MBBS course."
However, the MCI filed Intra Court Appeal challenging the aforesaid
order vide W.A. No.989 of 2016. However, the said writ appeal was
dismissed vide order dated 24.09.2024 holding that the issues raised in
the said vrit appeal shall remain open to be decided in an appropriate
case
28. In Rithika Monika v. Union of IndiaT, the petitioner
therein iri less than [ 7 years of age, sought a direction to National
Testing Agency, to enable her to submit online application and
subseque,ntly allow her to appear for NEET EXAM-2024 which is
suppose<l to be held on 05.05.2024 and ro set aside Clause - 5.1.1 of
the Infc,rmation Bulletin issued by the National Eligibility-cum'. w.P. No I2635 0f 2024,decided 03.05.2024
i
2t
KL,J & VRKR,J
W.A. No 1637 of 2017
Entrance Test (uG)-2024, which prescribes the minimum quali$ring
age for appearing in NEET (UG) accordingly. A Division Bench of
this Court held that it is wetl settled in law that a writ of mandamus
cannot be issued in contravention of a statutory provision. Regulation
- 11 of the Regulations, 2023 framed in exercise of powers under
Section - 57 of the Act, 2019 inter alta provides that a candidate has
to complete 17 years of age as on 31" January of the year when the
examination has to be held. The validity of the aforesaid Regulation
is not under challenge in the writ petition. The Division Bench also
considered that validity of prescription for minimum age for the
candidates appearing in the NEET Examination has already been
upheld by a Division Bench of Dethi High Court in Master Akash
Yadav Minor v. union of Indias and a Division Bench of Madras
High Court in National resting Agency v. Minor Sp. Shree Harinie.
The Division Bench also held that in the absence of challenge to
Regulation I 1 of the 2023 Regulations, it is not necessary for it to deal
with the issue raised in the said writ petition elaborately. With the
said findings, the Division Bench dismissed the said writ petition.
t. 2ozl SCC Online Del 4 t 14
'. zo2t SCC online Mad 5077
,
KL,J & VRKR,J
W.A. No.l637 of 2017
2l). In Lottongbam Bimolchandra SinghT, the student apptied
for eligibility cenificate by way of misrepresentation with regard to
his age. On notification the said misrepresentation, the MCI rejected
the application submitted by him for grant of eligibility certificate
Challenging the said rejection, the student filed a writ petition, and the
High Court allowed the said writ petition on the ground that the
student would face hardship if the eligibility certificate is not issued.
The Alrex Court held that the practice adopted by the father of the
studenl. in getting his son admitted in the medical course in a foreign
University without an eligibility certificate is deprecated. Further,
furnistring false information to the authorities for the purpose of
issuan,;e of eligibility certificate is an attempt to hoodwink the
authorities. In view of the admission of the student being contrary to
the re1;ulations and in view of the false information given by the father
of the student in the application filed for eligibility certificate, in the
normal course, the Apex Court would have set aside the judgment of
the High Court and allowed the appeal filed by the National Medical
Comtnission. However, in the peculiar facts and circumstances of the
case, taking into account the future of the student, who has completed
his nre{ical course in June, 2020 and that he was not responsible for
.\\
i
KL,J & VRKR,J
W.A. No.l637 of 2017
whatever was done by his father, the Apex Court declined to interfere
with the order passed by the High Court. Howevdr, the Apex Court
imposed Rs.10.00 lakhs as costs on the father of the'student therein.
The Apex Coum also directed the student to perform charitable service
by working with the Government for a period of two (02) years after
his successful completion of FMG Screening Test.
30. In view of the aforesaid provisions of the Act, the
Regulations and the principle laid down in the aforesaid decisions, the
following are undisPuted facts:
(i) A person, who is Citizen of India and obtains medical
{,
qualification granted by any Medical Institution in any
fi
country outside tndia recognized for enrolment as
1r\
a,
Medical Practitioner in that Country after such date, has
to qualiff in the Screening Test in India and after
qualifuing in the screening test, he/she shall be deemed to
be the recognized rnedical qualification for the said
purposes in rerms of Section - 13(44) ofthe Act, 1956.
(ii) He has to obtain eligibility certificate issued by the MCI.
(iii) He is not eligible to appear in the Screening Test in terms
of Section - 13 (48) of the Act, 1956'
KL,J & VRKR,J
W.A. No.l637 of 2017
(iu) Regulations were issued by the Central Government in
exercise of its powers under Section - 33 of the Act,
19s6.
(r)
As per Regulation - 8 of the Regulations, 2002, MCI has
to consider the application submitted by any person for
eligibility certificate, veriff the details mentioned therein
and ascertain whether the candidate fulfills the age
criterion prescribed by the Council-
(ui) As per Regulation - 4 of the Medical Council of tndia
Regulations on Graduate Medical Education 1997,
candidate should complete 17 years of age on or before
3l't December of the year of admission into the MBBS
Course.
In the present case, the daughter of respondent No.l was born on
04.03.2000. She joined in Undergraduate Medical Cour':e in Astana
Medical University (Kazakhstan) for the year 2016-17 and batch. On
13.10.2016, respondent No.1 made an application on behalf of his
daughter to MCI for grant of eligibility certificate. Vide proceedings
dated '.26.12.20t6, the MCI rejected the said request made by
responclent No.1 on the ground that she has not completed [ 7 years of
\-
\
-'"''
KL,J & VRKR,J
W.A. No.1637of20l7
age. Challenging the said proceedings, respondent No.1 approached
this Court by way of filing a writ petition.
31. Vide impugned order dated 23.08.2017 in W.P. No.ll8l9
of 2017, learned Single Judge directed the MCI to issue eligibility
certificate placing reliance on the order in W.P. No.36316 of 2015.
32. It is apt to note that vide order dated 22.08.2016 in W.P.
No.36316 of 2015,learned Single Judge of erstwhile High Court of
Judicature at Hyderabad for the States of Telangana and Andhra
Pradesh, placing reliance on the order of the Delhi High Court in
Jishalakshi Embrandiri2 and Ankit Chaturvedir directed the MCI
to issue eligibility certificate.
33. Challenging the said order, the MCI preferred the present
writ appeal. Vide order dated 09.11 .2017 in W.A.M.P. No.31l7 of
2017 in W.A. No.1637 of 2017, this Court suspended the impugned
order. However, this Court made clear that if the daughter of
respondent No.l continues to pursue her Undergraduate Medical
Course in Kazakhstan, it shall be at her risk and she shall not be
entitled to claim equities when the writ appeal is finatly heard. Even
then, she pursued her MBBS Course at General Medicine Faculty of
KL.J & VRKR,J
W.A. No.l637 of 2017
Astana Medical university (Kazakhstan). It is also apt to note that
respondent
'r{o.l herein has fited I.A. }Jo.2 of 2025 in the present
appeal seeking a direction to MCI to issue eligibility certificate within
one week to attend the exam pending disposal of the writ appeat by
modifuing the stay granted in wAMP No.3117 of 2017 in the present
appeal. Vide order dated 23.06.2025, this Court dismissed the said
application.
34. Thus, this court made it clear that the daughter of
respondent No.l cannot claim any equities and that she is pursuing the
medical cc)urse in Kazakhstan at her own risk. Even then, she pursued
her MBBI; Course. In the light of the same, the contention of Mr.
Pasham l.iishna Reddy, learned counsel appearing for respondent
No.l that the daughter of respondent No.l has completed medical
course in 2021 itself and, therefore, the same may be considered and
dismiss the present writ appeal filed by the MCI directing the MCI to
issue eligibility certificate cannot be accepted.
35. Mr. Pasham Krishna Reddy, learned counsel, has also
placed rr:liance on the order dated 22.08.2016 passed by a learned
Single Judge of erstwhile High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad for
the Statr:s of Telangana and Andhra Pradesh in W.P. No.36316 of
KL.J & VRKR,J
w.A. No.1637 of 2017
2015, to contend that the MCI is showing discrimination. In the light
of the said submission, it is relevant to note that in the said order,
learned Single Judge placed reliance on the order passed by the
Division Bench of Allahabad High Court in Ankit Chaturvedir and
also the order passed by the Delhi High Court in Jishalakshi
Embrandiri2.
36. As discussed above, in Ankit chaturvedit the Division
Bench of Allahabad High court dismissed the writ petition filed by
the petitioner. It is also apt to note that Ankit Chaturvedi filed a Civil
Miscellaneous W.P. No.50073 of 2014 challenging the rejection order
issued by the MCI. vide order dated t6.04.2015, leamed Single Judge
of Allahabad High Court dismissed the said writ petition. Thereafter
he has filed another C.M.W.P. No.28261 of 2015 quesrioning the
constitutional validity of the provisions contained in Regulation - 4 (l)
of the Regulations on Graduate Medical Education, 1997 read with
Regulation 8 of the eligibility Requirement for taking Admission in an
Undergraduate Medical Course in a Foreign Medical Institution
Regulations, 2002. Vide order dated 05.02.20[6, the Division Bench
of Allahabad High Court dismissed the said writ petition. As against
the said order, Ankit Chaturvedi filed SLP vide Special Leave to
-'
L.*__
'z-J
t
KL,J & VRKR,J
W.A. No.l637 of 2017
Appeal (c) No.13843 of 2016, and the Apex court considering the
fact that Ankit Chaturvedi has already passed the MBBS examination,
qualified ir the Screening I'est, as a special features of the case and in
exercise of its power under Article - 142 of the Constitution of India
granted relief to him. Learned Single Judge of erstwhile High Court
did not consider the said aspect in the order dated 22.0g.2016 in
W.P.No.3(;316 of 2015.
37. The suggestion made by learned Single Judge in the said
order to the Central Government and the MCI to revisit the regulations
and say good bye to minimum age i.e., 17 years, which is made
compulsory before entering into MBBS Course, is also contrary to the
Regulations. Learned Single Judge has no power to suggest the
Central Ciovernment and MCI to revisit the regulations. with due
respect, learned Single Judge has no power or suggest or Advisory
jurisdiction, like the Apex Court under Article - 143 of the
constitution of [ndia. placing reliance on the said order dated
22.08.2016 in w.P. No.36316 of 201,5, vide order dated 23.0g.20t7,
leamed S,ingle Judge of erstwhile High Court allowed w.p. No.1lg19
of 20lT,Jirecting the MCI to issue eligibility certificate. There is no
consideration of the aforesaid judgments of the Apex Court, Rajasthan
KL,J & VRKR,J
W.A. No.l637 of 2017
High Court, Allahabad High Court, Delhi High Court and this Court
in the aforesaid cases.
38. [t is also apt to note that the MCI preferred an appeal vide
W.A. No.989 of 2016 challenging the order dated 22.08.2016 in W.P.
No.36316 of 2015. Vide order dated 13.10.2016 in W.A.M.P.
No.2222 of 2016 in W.A. No.989 of 2016,a Division Bench of this
Court declined to interfere with the order dated 22.08.2016 in W.P.
No.36316 of 2016, however, the issuance of eligibility certificate shall
be subject to the result of the writ appeal. As against the said order
the MCI filed Special Leave to Appeal (C) No.31683 of 2016 and the
same was dismissed by the Apex Court vide order dated ll.ll.2016.
Later, the appeal was disposed of by the Division Bench of the High
Court of Andhra Pradesh vide order dated 24.09.2024 holding that the
issues raised in the said writ appeal shall remain open to be decided in
an appropriate case.
39. The order of learned Single Judge of the Madrash High
Court in D. Sasirekha v. The Assistant Secretarylo is also not on
consideration of the aforesaid orders passed by the Apex Court.
'0. w.P. No.27709 of 2018, decided on 13.03.2020
f.e.-*
Therefore, respondent No.1 -
KL,J & VRKR,J
W.A. No.1637 of 2017
writ petitioner cannot claim
discrimination and equity.
40. Leamed counsel appearing for respondent No.l also
contended that the appellants herein obtained intertm order dated
09.11.201't in W.A.M.P. No.31l7 of 2017 in W.A- No.1637 of 2017
by way of suppression of orders of Division Bench and the Apex
Court in SLP. The said contention of learned counsel is also contrary
to record ;md the aforesaiC discussion.
41,. As observed by the Division Bench of Rajasthan High
Court that it is not the function of the Courts to go into the question of
prescript'on of age, unless, it seems to be so absurd and unreasonable
that a mzm of ordinary prudence would not accept such a prescription.
Even otherwise, the Courts are not equipped with any expertise to
come to a conclusion as to what would be the proper age for a student
to enter the M.B.B.S. Course. It is for the policy makers to consider
the various factors which are relevant to the issue, before fixing the
age lim'rt for admission to the medical courses. The said principle was
also lai,J down by the Division Bench of this Court in W.P. No.31337
of 201t5 & batch (decided on 21.09.2016) and Tekula Samhitha
Reddy'5.
\
3l
KL,J& VRKR,J
W.A. No.1637 of 2017
42. It is also relevant to note that the provisions of the
Regulations fell for consideration before the Full Bench of the
Rajasthan High Court in Gautam Kapoor v. State of Rajasthanrr
The issue before the said Court was whether the prescription of a
minimum age limit of 17 years was unreasonable or arbitrary, with no
rational nexus with the object sought to be achieved by the provision.
The Full Bench held thus:
"[t cannot be doubted that a certain degree of
maturity of body and mind is essential in a student
joining the medical course and it is not unusual to
reckon the same with reference to the age of the
person. Undoubtedly there may be exception to the
general rule, but a general rule is not to be based
on exceptions. The Medical Council of India,
which is constituted under the Medical Council
Act, 1956 and is a body of experts in the field, is
also required to prescribe the minimum standards
of medical education. It is also empowered by the
Act to make Regulations generally to carry out the
purpose of the Act and particularly for the matters
specified expressly in S. 33 of the Act. One of the
recommendations made by the Medical Council of
India in exercise of its statutory power is that the
minimum age limit of L7 years at the time of entry
rr. ArR
l
1987 Raj. 174
t
KL,J & VRKR.J
W.A. No.l637 of 2017
into a Medical College should be prescribed. There
i; no dispute that this minimum age limit is being
Ibtlowed throughout the country and for a long
lime."
i) The Rajasthan High court further that having due regard to
the minimum age of a candidate, ordinarily, at the time of passing the
qualiffing,:xamination, the age requirement specified by MCI was not
unreasonat,le or arbitrary.
ii) fhe same view rvas adopted in Akshanjali Morya3. The
Division []ench of the Rajasthan High Court held that prescribing a
minimum age for admission was a matter of policy on which the Court
would not interfere. [t also further observed as under:
"9. By now it is well settled that it is not the
function of the Courts to go into the question of
prescription of age, unless, it seems to be so absurd
and unreasonable that a man of ordinary prudence
would not accept such a prescription. Even
otherwise, the Courts are not equipped with any
expertise to come to a conclusion as to what would
be the proper age for a student to enter the
M.B.B.S. Course. [t is for the policy makers to
consider the various factors which are relevant to
the issue, before fixing the age limit for admission
to the medical courses."
ti
KL,J & VRKR,J
W.A. No.1637 of 2017
iii) The Division Bench of Rajasthan High Court also further
held that since qualifuing examinations are conducted by various
Boards and Universities at different points of time and entrance
examinations for admission to the MBBS Course are conducted on
different dates, MCI, with a view to ensure uniformity, had chosen
31" December as a date on which a candidate should attain the age of
17 years with reference to the year in which admission to the MBBS
Course is made. In that regard, the Division Bench of the Rajasthan
High Court also observed thus:
"In the existing pattern of education in the country,
normally, a candidate passes the qualiffing the
examination at the age of 16 or 17 years of age.
The Medical Council in its wisdom had come to
the conclusion that, for proper understanding and
comprehension of medical education, a candidate
must possess certain level of maturity, which
comes with age. The prescription of the minimum
age is on account of studied deliberations made by
the Medical Council and is a manifestation of an
informed decision taken by the Medical Council in
association with the Central Government, for
prescribing the minimum standards and
qualifications. The said decision has been taken in
pursuance of the discussions, consultations and
?
KT,,J & VRKR,J
W.A. No.1637 of 2017
deliberations, made by an expert academic body
and is made for the furtherance and maintenance of
minimum standards for medical education.
Therefore, such a regulation cannot be
characterised as arbitrary."
In Mohit Kumar Arora v. University of Delhil2, a
Division []ench of Delhi High Court observing that such requirement
was held to be based on a rational foundation held as under:
"The requirement of age, both minimum and
maximum, is mandatory and not directory. In
professionai courses the authorities thought it
proper to have proper maturity and understanding
of the course by the candidate and have the
requirement to prescribe the age and it is based on
intelligible differentia. There is an objective to be
achieved. This classification of 17 years is based
on rational aspect."
44. The aforesaid view was also taken by u learned Single
Judge of erstwhile High Court of Andhra Pradesh at Hyderabad in U.
Anveshini v. Convenor, EAMCET-2000r3.
4:;. The decision of the Apex Court in Maharishi Mahesh
l
I
i
,
I
I
{
li
Yogi \redic Vishwavidyalaya v. State of Madhya Pradeshra,
t'. Civil W.P.No.4353 o2003, decided on I1.07.2003
''. 2oor (6)ALD l80
li
l,
l
I
I
I
I
i
t
i
-Y:-
Y
l
KLJ& VRKR,J
W.A No.l637 of 2017
involved a challenge to an amendment in the provisions of the
Maharishi Mahesh Yogi Vedic Vishwavidyalaya Adhiniyam, 1995.
The following observations contained in paragraph No.23 of the
decision have been emphasised in the submissions of the learned
Senior Counsel:
"...lt is needless to state that education, a
constitutional right, has been explained as an
essential part in every one's life..."
46. Keeping in view the aforesaid discussion and the principle
laid down in the aforesaid decisions, in the present case, the daughter
of respondent No.l is seeking relaxation of age to pursue MBBS
Course in Kazakhstan. Her contention is that she was permitted by
concerned authorities to appear for SSC Examination and Intermediate
Examination though she was below the required age. On the said
grounds, she cannot seek relaxation of the age fixed by the MCI i.e.,
17 years. She is pursuing MBBS Course. It is a professional Course.
On consideration of the said aspects only, the MCI fixed the eligibility
as 17 years as on 31't December of the said admission year.
Admittedly, the daughter of respondent No.l does not possess such
'0. 1zorc; l5 scc677
I
I
KL,J & VRKR,J
W.A. No.l637 of 2017
age as on 31" December of the'said academic vear i.e., 2016-1,7.
Respondent No.l has submitted application on 13.10.2016 on behalf
of his daughter to issue eligibilitl, certificate. Therefore, as on
3r.12.201(i, she was l6 years, g months and27 days. Thus, she is less
than 17 )'ears. on consideration of the said aspects only, vide
impugned order dated 26.L2.2016, the MCI rejected the request made
by responcent No.l. The said regulations are statutory. Therefore,
respondent No.l cannot seek relaxation of the said age fixed by the
MCI, an E,xpert Body.
47. As discussed supra, despite interim suspension of the
impugned order by a Division Bench and despite making it clear that
the daughter of respondent }.ic.l cannot claim equities and that if she
continues to pursue MBBS in Kazakhstan, it shal! be at her own risk,
she is cl;riming equities contending that she has completed MBBS
Course. iShe cannot claim equities.
48, without considering the said aspects and the principle laid
down b:r the Apex court, Division Benches of the aforesaid
judgments, vtde impugned order dated 23.0g.zo|7,learned
single
Judge allowed w.P. No.ll8l9 of 2017 directing rhe MCI ro issue
KL,J& VRKR,J
W.A. No.l637of 2017
eligibility certificate to the daughter of respondent No. 1. As discussed
above, learned Single Judge allowed the said writ petition relying on
the order dated 22.08.2016 in W.P. No.36316 of 2015, which is not on
consideration of the aforesaid principle and provisions of the Act
1956 and the Regulations. Thus, the impugned order dated
23.08.201,7 in W.P. No.l 1819 of 2017 passed by leamed Single Judge
is liable to be set aside and the same is accordingly set aside.
49. The present Writ Appeal is accordingly allowed. In the
circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to costs.
'Ap'u seqirel thereto, miscellaneous applications, if any, pending
in this appeal shall stand closed.
SD/-iJI. RAMANA KRISHNA
JOINT
//TRUE COPY//
To
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8. Two CD Copies
PSK.
BS
dl-
OFFICER
New
4,
I
HIGH COUR
DATED:2310112026
JUDGMENT
WA.No.163,r ot 2017
(-
o
a
rJ
2 7 r[8 2il26
*
ALLOWING THE WRIT APPEAL
ITHOUT COSTS
t{
P \i,
oV
lHE S 14
t
z
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review