Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supp. List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C). No. 320 of 2021
Date of Decision: 17.06.2022
Md. Sulaiman
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H.S.Thangkhiew, Judge.
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. S.Jindal, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. K.P.Bhattacharjee, GA for R 1.
Mr. S.A.Sheikh, Adv. for R 2.
Mr. T.T.Diengdoh, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. C.C.T.Sangma, Adv. for R 3.
Mr. K.Khan, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. S.K.Hassan, Adv. for R 4.
i)
ii)
:
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc:
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The petitioner who is stated to be a Joint Mutawalli of Haji Elahi
Baksh Waqf Estate is before this Court being aggrieved with the
appointment of respondent No. 3 as the other Joint Mutawalli of the said
Waqf Estate by the respondent No. 4 vide the impugned letter dated 12-101
2021. Though the petitioner has not raised the issue of right, entitlement or
fitness of the respondent No. 3 to be appointed as Joint Mutawalli,
challenge to the impugned order has been made basically on two grounds,
first that the impugned order has been issued contrary to the provisions of
the Waqf Act and second that the petitioner was not heard before issuance
of the impugned order.
2.
When this instant matter was taken up for consideration, the
respondents herein had raised the question of the maintainability of the writ
petition. The locus of the petitioner was questioned, and the fact of
availability of alternate remedy under Section 83 (2) of the Waqf Act of
1995, in such matters, was highlighted. It has also been contended that no
cause of action has been disclosed; that there has been no violation of the
rights of the petitioner; that the writ petitioner has filed the instant writ
petition only to espouse the cause of his own nephew; and that the
petitioner had no role to play in the appointment of the respondent No. 3
as Joint Mutawalli. It has also been brought to the notice of the Court that
the matter has a long-standing history of litigation and had travelled up to
the Hon’ble Supreme Court, which by order dated 26-09-2019, set in
motion the process for appointment of a Joint Mutawalli. The writ
petitioner, it is contended at that point of time in the said proceedings
before the Supreme Court had shown his disinclination to nominate the
Joint Mutawalli as provided under the terms of the Waqf Deed.
3.
In this backdrop, it would therefore be more expedient if the
challenge to maintainability is taken up first, before embarking upon the
main matter. However, as it has been pointed out to this Court that there
has been a long history of litigation, wherein orders have been passed by
the Hon’ble Supreme Court and this High Court, this aspect and the purport
and impact of those orders would necessarily also have to be looked into.
4.
The subject matter is with regard to a Waqf, which was established
by Late Haji Elahi Baksh on 09-11-1936 and formalized through a Waqf
Deed dated 11-11-1936. It appears that with regard to appointment as a
Joint Mutawalli for the said Waqf, from the line or descendants of one
Kammu Mia, one Md. Taiyab had instituted a case being Waqf Case No. 1
of 2002, before the Hon’ble Waqf Tribunal, Shillong, and in this was joined
by the respondent No. 3 herein, as an intervenor with a similar prayer that
he be appointed as Joint Mutawalli. Both these petitions were rejected by
the Waqf Tribunal by judgment dated 19-07-2006, and this order was then
taken before the High Court by way of Writ Petition and Civil Revision
Petition respectively. By a common order dated 25-07-2007 the High Court
upheld the orders of the Waqf Tribunal, which in turn was appealed again
before the Hon’ble Supreme Court by way of an SLP. The Hon’ble
Supreme Court dismissed the said SLP by order dated 13-12-2007,
however, with an observation that the question of law is left open.
Subsequent to the dismissal of the SLP, one Md. Abrar, a descendant of
Kammu Mia, then approached the Waqf Tribunal with a prayer for
appointment as Mutawalli of the Waqf. The petition came to be dismissed
and the order of dismissal was put to challenge before this Court in CRP.
No. 15 (SH) of 2008. The said civil revision then was dismissed by this
Court vide order dated 28-01-2009.
5.
The aforesaid judgment was then taken on appeal by Md. Abrar
before the Hon’ble Supreme Court which was numbered as Civil Appeal
No. 4025 of 2010, and the same was disposed of by judgment dated 26-092019. It appears that with this judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court, the
path for appointment of a Joint Mutawalli from the line of Kammu Mia
was opened, as it was directed in the said order that the respondent No. 1
(therein) i.e., Meghalaya Board of Waqf, was to appoint a competent
person from the descendants of the said Kammu Mia, to succeed to the
office of Joint Mutawalli. This was also in view of the fact that the
respondent No.2 (therein) i.e., writ petitioner herein, had shown a
disinclination to nominate a successor as provided under the terms of the
Waqf Deed. That meanwhile, one Md. Zakaria who has been arrayed as
respondent No. 3 herein, had also approached this Court by way of WP(C).
No. 294 of 2015, with a prayer that the Waqf Board provide an opportunity
of hearing to him and also to consider his name along with other
descendants of Late Kammu Mia while making appointment of Mutawalli.
This Court on such terms as submitted, allowed the prayer and disposed of
the said writ petition by order dated 28-11-2019.
6.
The respondent No.3 on being aggrieved on non-compliance of the
order dated 28-11-2019 passed in WP(C). No. 294 of 2015 again came
before this Court by way of writ petition being WP(C). No. 236 of 2021.
This Court on hearing the parties by order dated 20-09-2021, then directed
at paragraphs 5 & 6 which are quoted hereinbelow as follows:
“5. In the above facts and circumstances, I dispose
of this writ petition with direction to the respondent to
hear the petitioner and comply with the order dated
28-11-2019 passed by learned Single Judge in WP(C).
No. 294/2015, if not complied with earlier.
6.
The petitioner is directed to remain present
before the Chief Executive Officer of the respondent
Meghalaya State Wakf Board along with a copy of
this order as well as the order dated 28-11-2019
passed in WP(C). No. 294/2015, on 27-09-2021 at 11
am to enable the respondent to comply with this
order.”
7.
In WP(C). No. 236 of 2021, the writ petitioner was not a party to the
proceedings, as the relief claimed was only against the Waqf Board.
Apparently, being aware about the said order dated 20-09-2021, and the
directions contained therein for appearance of Md. Zakaria, the respondent
No.3, (petitioner in WP(C). No. 236 of 2021) on 27-09-2021, before the
Chief Executive Officer (respondent No.4), the petitioner on that day itself,
filed a representation before the respondent No.4 that he too be heard, to
oppose any move to appoint respondent No. 3 as Joint Mutawalli.
8.
In this scenario and in the backdrop of the multiple proceedings and
orders passed by the various Courts and Tribunal, the respondent No. 3
then came to be appointed as Joint Mutawalli of the Waqf Estate from Haji
Kammu Mia descendants vide Order/Notice dated 12-10-2021 issued by
the respondent No.4. The writ petitioner though belonging to the other line
of descendants, being aggrieved with the impugned order, is therefore
before this Court by way of the instant writ petition.
9.
As noted earlier, the question of maintainability is to be first decided
before proceeding on the other aspects and merits of the case.
10.
Mr. T.T.Diengdoh, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr.
C.C.T.Sangma, learned counsel for respondent No. 3, has submitted that
the writ petition does not disclose any cause of action, and the petitioner
has no locus to maintain the prayers made in the instant case as it is
nowhere to be seen as to in what manner his legal and fundamental rights
have been infringed. It is also submitted that the petitioner who is a Joint
Mutawalli is in favour of appointing one Imitiaz Ahmed as the other Joint
Mutawalli, and it is evident that the instant application has been filed only
to espouse the cause of his nephew. The writ petitioner it is contended, has
no role to play in the appointment of the respondent No.3 as a Joint
Mutawalli, apart from the fact the petitioner by his own accord, had waived
his right to nominate a successor from the descendants of Kammu Mia as
provided in the Waqf Deed. The learned Senior counsel submits that this
has been observed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in its judgment dated 2609-2019, and the writ petitioner therefore by way of the instant writ petition
is attempting to reopen an issue which has already been set at rest by the
Hon’ble Supreme Court.
11.
It has also been strenuously argued that no cause has been made out
for exercise of powers under Article 226 of the Constitution of India by
this Court, inasmuch as, Section 83 (2) of the Waqf Act, 1995 can be
availed for redressal if any, of the petitioner’s grievances and as such
therefore, the availability of efficacious alternative remedy makes the writ
petition incompetent. The learned Senior counsel has placed reliance on
the case of Union of India v. Major General Shri. Kant Sharma & Anr.
(2015) 6 SCC 773 para 36 and United Bank of India v. Satyawati Tondon,
(2010) 8 SCC 110 para 45 on the non-exhaustion of effective alternative
remedies. In conclusion, the learned Senior counsel submits that by filing
the instant writ application, the petitioner is attempting to oust the
respondent No. 3 from the office of Joint Mutawalli in order to retain sole
management of the Waqf Estate, which is very valuable and which
generates a considerable amount of income every month. It is lastly
submitted that the appointment of respondent No.3 is as per directions and
orders of this Court.
12.
Mr. K.Khan, learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. S.K.Hassan,
learned counsel for respondent No.4 apart from supporting the submissions
made by the learned Senior counsel for respondent No. 3, submits that by
the order dated 20-09-2021 in WP(C). No. 236 of 2021, this Court had
directed the respondent No.3 to remain present before respondent No. 4 for
compliance of the said order, and this order he submits has not been put to
challenge either by the petitioner nor the Waqf Board (respondent No.2).
He submits that the exercise of powers by respondent No. 4 in complying
with the order of this Court, is not a case of being delegated by the
respondent No.2 under Section 32 (g) of the Waqf Act, nor is it the case of
respondent No.4 that respondent No.2 had assigned or delegated duties
under Section 25 (3), but that Section 25 (3) in itself, gives plenary powers
to the respondent No.4. to perform such duties as may be assigned, and
there is no bar to the respondent No.4 to perform duties as assigned under
25 (3) either by the Board or by the Court. He further submits that in the
present case, there is a direction from this Court to perform certain duties
which was accordingly performed by respondent No.4 and in the absence
of any specific stand from the respondent No.2 (Waqf Board), it was
immaterial to go into the aspect as to whether the order dated 20-09-2021,
meant that it is only the respondent No.2 who was to comply with the
direction and not respondent No.4.
13.
It is also contended by the learned Senior counsel that there is only
one cause of action that had been set in motion by the Hon’ble Supreme
Court vide order dated 26-09-2019, which culminated in the issuance of
the impugned notice dated 12-10-2021. It is submitted that it is an
undisputed fact that the writ petitioner had shown his disinclination to
nominate a successor from the line of Kammu Mia which had been
recorded by the Hon’ble Supreme Court and though the writ petitioner
sought a review against the order dated 26-09-2019, the same was
dismissed. It is then further contended that, as the petitioner is already
occupying the office of Mutawalli from the other line i.e., from the line of
Md. Shafi, and having shown his disinclination to nominate a successor
from the other line of Kammu Mia, he has waived his right to nominate
and is also estopped from raising any issue with regard to Joint
Mutawalliship after the order of the Hon’ble Supreme Court. The learned
Senior counsel finally submits the right of the writ petitioner to be heard
either before the respondents No. 2 or 4, stood extinguished under the Waqf
Deed on the principles of waiver and estoppel, and in view of these facts,
in the absence of any fresh cause of action, the writ petitioner has no locus
standi to seek directions to be heard before respondents No. 2 and 4.
14.
Mr. S.Jindal, learned counsel for the petitioner in reply to the
challenge on the maintainability of the writ petition submits that the
petitioner is an existing Mutawalli and if in his estimate an illegality is
being committed against the Waqf Estate, he has all the rights to approach
a Court of law against the perceived illegality. On the question of his
having waived the right as he had shown a disinclination to nominate a
successor to the deceased Kammu Mia, learned counsel argues that the
right to nominate a successor is a specific right that is granted under the
Waqf Deed, and at best the petitioner may be considered to have waived
only the specific right and this waiver cannot amount to the waiver of all
and any other rights that are attached to the position of the Mutawalli. It is
also submitted that if the arguments of the respondents are accepted, it will
lead to the conclusion that the petitioner is estopped from raising any issue
about any aspect of the Waqf, for all time to come which cannot be the
case. It is further submitted that an illegality had been caused, inasmuch as,
the Hon’ble Supreme Court had directed the respondent No. 2 (Waqf
Board) to appoint a Joint Mutawalli but in this case, the respondent No. 4
has stepped in, usurped that power and appointed respondent No.3 as Joint
Mutawalli. Therefore, he submits the petitioner has every right and locus
to maintain the instant writ petition. In support of his submissions on the
point of locus, learned counsel has placed reliance on a judgment in the
case of Jasbhai Motibhai Desai v. Roshan Kumar, AIR 1976 SC 578
wherein he submits it has been held that there are three categories of
persons who have the locus to file a writ petition, namely, those who have
personal or individual right, who have been prejudicially affected by an act
of an authority even though he has no interest in the subject matter and
persons though not a party to the proceedings before the authority who
have substantial and general interest in the proceedings.
15.
On the point of alternate remedy as provided under Section 83 (2) of
the Waqf Act, the learned counsel submits that Section 83 (2) comes with
precondition that to approach the Tribunal, a person must be aggrieved by
an order made under this Act, which he contends is not the case in the
present matter as the impugned order issued by respondent No. 4, is not an
order made under the Act and in fact, is an order made de hors the
provisions of the Act. The learned counsel then submits that, even if it is
assumed that the impugned order is an order made under the Act, the
presence of alternative remedy does not by itself, debar this Court from
entertaining and adjudicating the writ petition. Learned counsel has placed
reliance on the following decisions on this point:(i)
Committee of Management vs. Vice Chancellor, (2009) 2
SCC 630 (paras 22 and 23).
(ii)
Guruvayoor Devaswom vs. C.K.Rajan, (2003) 7 SCC 546
(para 68).
16.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties, and have carefully
considered the submissions advanced and the materials placed before this
Court. It would be worthwhile to note that in the Waqf Estate in question,
the Waqf Deed had provided the scheme of management as follows:
“(i) The settlor’s son Md Shafi and son in law
Kammu Mia, son of late SK Gajnu, shall be joint
Mutwallis during their lifetime.
(ii) On the death of either of the joint mutwallis, the
survivor shall be the sole Mutwalli for the time being,
and shall have power to nominate his successor from
the family line of the settler.
(iii) Each successive Mutwalli thereafter shall have
the right to nominate his successor from the same
source.
(iv) None who does not profess the Sunni form of
Mohammedan faith shall not be entitled to hold the
office of Mutwallis.
(v)
Should a Mutwalli die without nominating a
successor, the senior most member among the lineal
descendants of the said Md Shafi and Kammu Mia, if
otherwise competent shall be entitled to hold the office
of Mutwalli.”
It is thus clear from the recitals of the Waqf Deed that there was to
be two distinct lines from where the Joint Mutawallis were to be appointed,
one from the line of the settlors side namely, Md. Shafi and the other from
the line of the son-in-law namely, Kammu Mia. The petitioner
undisputedly is the Joint Mutawalli from the line of Md. Shafi and
continues to be in office. The entire dispute and question which has resulted
in this large volume of litigation is only with regard to the appointment of
the Joint Mutawalli from the line of Kammu Mia, and not from the line
from which the petitioner is the present Mutawalli.
17.
As had been submitted by the parties, the Hon’ble Supreme Court
by its order dated 26-09-2019, set in motion the process for the
appointment of the successor Mutawalli from the line of Kammu Mia. The
petitioner who as per the Waqf Deed being vested with the right to
nominate a successor, as observed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in para
13 of the said judgment, declined to exercise this option, and as such had
waived his right to nominate any further. Added to this fact is in the
subsequent proceedings before this Court i.e., WP(C). No. 294 of 2015 and
WP(C). No. 236 of 2021, the petitioner was neither a party respondent, nor
sought impleadment in the said proceedings, and never challenged the final
orders passed therein. However, pursuant to the knowledge of the order
dated 20-09-2021 passed by this Court in WP(C). No. 236 of 2021,
whereby this Court had directed the respondent No. 3 to appear before the
CEO, Waqf Board (respondent No. 4) to be heard along with other lineal
descendants of Kammu Mia, for consideration of his name for appointment
to Mutawalli, the petitioner preferred a representation before the Chief
Executive Officer of the respondent No. 2 (Waqf Board), on 27-09-2021,
with a request that he too be heard at the time of such consideration.
18.
The petitioner as noted earlier being a Joint Mutawalli from the other
line and not being part of the proceedings after the matter was disposed of
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, infact became a stranger to the events that
took place thereafter and, even with the full knowledge of the same chose
not to participate or to assail any of the orders. It appears it was only when
the matters appeared to be reaching a conclusion as to the appointment of
Joint Mutawalli, that the petitioner chose to pray that he be heard. The locus
therefore becomes suspect, as apart from his legal or other vested rights not
being in any danger of being infringed upon, or that any action or decision
of the Waqf Board in this matter, having any adverse effect on his Joint
Mutawalliship, the perceived grievance of the petitioner by way of the
representation dated 27-09-2021, can be said to have been made without a
cogent ground or a cause of action.
19.
The rule of locus standi contemplates and means that unless an
individual has been directly injured, or is aggrieved by the act he is
challenging, his action will not be upheld by the Court. A person must have
suffered some injury or damage from the said impugned act and it is
essential to demonstrate that the person approaching the Court must have
suffered some injury, or that his legal right has been violated. The right to
bring an action before the Court will therefore, entail the presence of a
nexus between the injury caused and the person approaching the Court. In
the instant case, no injury has been inflicted upon the writ petitioner, nor
his interest affected in any way, and his continuance as Mutawalli is not
under any threat and as such, the impugned order has no impact on his
office.
20.
The decision in Jasbhai Motibhai Desai (supra) relied upon by the
petitioner to buttress his stand on locus, that the categories of persons who
have the locus to file a writ petition are namely, those who have personal
or individual right, who have been prejudicially affected by an act of an
authority even though he has no interest in the subject matter and persons
though not a party to the proceedings before the authority who have
substantial and general interest in the proceedings, will have no application
in the instant case. It is noted that the Hon’ble Supreme Court has indicated
in the said judgment itself, that the expression “ordinarily” indicates that
this is not a cast iron rule. Further, the instant case stands on a different
footing altogether and is not an exceptional case that will be covered by
this ruling, inasmuch as, the petitioner had waived all his rights to
participation, and as noted earlier, the outcome of the proceedings before
the Waqf Board, has had no effect or resulted in the violation of the legal
or fundamental rights of the petitioner in any manner.
21.
On the aspect of the action of the respondent No. 4 not being in
consonance with, or as per the provisions of the Waqf Act, the petitioner
by the very fact that he had sought audience before the respondent No.4,
by way of the representation instead of approaching the Courts of law by
way of appeal, review against the order dated 20-09-2021 passed in WP(C).
No. 236 of 2021, effectively shuts out the contention of the petitioner to
question the procedure adopted in implementation of the Court’s orders.
The entire sequence of events and the actions of the petitioner from the
Supreme Court proceedings itself, where he declined to nominate a
successor, culminating in the last order of this Court dated 20-09-2021,
have clearly estopped the petitioner from seeking any relief by way of the
instant writ application.
22.
The question of availability of alternative remedy need not be gone
into as the petitioner himself lacks locus, as observed above.
23.
For the aforesaid reasons, on the ground of maintainability itself this
writ petition fails and is accordingly dismissed.
24.
No orders as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
17.06.2022
“Samantha PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review