Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/15
GAHC010218032025
2026:GAU-AS:10287
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : CRP/136/2025
MD. SHERMAN ALI AHMED AND 4 ORS
S/O LATE ROUSHAN ALI AHMED, R/O HOUSE NO. 421, WARD NO. 54, P.S.NOONMATI, SATGAON, GUWAHATI-37, DIST- KAMRUP (M), ASSAM
2: MRS. MEHERUN NESSA
W/O HAAJI MOULANA ABBAS ALI
R/O VILL- KHANDAKARPARA
MOUZA- GHILAZARI
DIST- BARPETA
ASSAM
PIN-781316
3: MRS. MARJINA AHMED
W/O MAJNUT ALI AHMED
R/O VILL- ITARBHITHA
MOUZA- GHILAZARI
DIST- BARPETA
ASSAM-781329
4: MRS. SHAHNAZ AHMED
W/O JULFIKAR ALI
R/O VILL- MOURIGAAON
MOUZA- MANDIA
DIST- BARPETA
ASSAM-781309
5: MISS MACHOOMA AHMED
S/O LATE MOHSIN ALI AHMED
R/O VILL- MANDIA
MOUZA- MANDIA
DIST- BARPETA
ASSAM-78130
VERSUS
Page No.# 2/15
ZADID SAROWAR ALAM AND 17 ORS
S/O NUR MAHAMMAD, R/O VILL- DANGARKUCHI, MOUZA- GHILAZARI,
PIN-781314, DIST- BARPETA, ASSAM
2:ZADID IQBAL ALAM
S/O NUR MAHAMMAD
R/O VILL- DANGARKUCHI
MOUZA- GHILAZARI
PIN-781314
DIST- BARPETA
ASSAM
3:ZADID SHAHIDUL ALAM
S/O NUR MAHAMMAD
R/O VILL- DANGARKUCHI
MOUZA- GHILAZARI
PIN-781314
DIST- BARPETA
ASSAM
4:HEIRS OF LATE JADAB CHANDRA DAS
A) AKHIL CH. DAS
B) NIKHIL CH. DAS
C) SUNIL KUMAR DAAS
D) KHAGEN CH. DAS
E) PRASENJIT DAS
F) PRADIP KUMAR DAS
ALL ARE S/O LATE JADAV CHANDRA DAS
R/O VILL- HOWLY TOWN
MOUZA- GHILAZARI
DIST- BARPETA
ASSAM-781316
5:HEIRS OF LATE AMULYA KANTA DEV ADHIKARI
A) KARUNAKANTA ADHIKARI (SON)
B) BHUPENDRA NARAYAN ADHIKARI (SON)
C) PRANKANTA ADHIKARI (SON)
D) SHUBHAKANTA ADHIKARI (SON)
R/O VILL- DANGARKUCHI
MOUZA- GHILAZARI
DIST- BARPETA
ASSAM-781314
6:HEIRS OF PRAHLAD CH. DAS
A) NATARAJ DAS (SON)
B) PUNYALAL DAS (SON)
C) MUKHYARAJ DAS (SON)
Page No.# 3/15
D) DAKHYARAJ DAS (SON)
ALL ARE R/O VILL- DANGARKUCHI
MOUZA- GHILAZARI
DIST- BARPETA
ASSAM-781314
7:KHAGENDRA NATH DAS
S/O LATE MUKUNDARAM DAS
R/O VILL- GANAKKUCHI GAON
MOUZA- GHILAZARI
DIST- BARPETA
ASSAM-781314
8:ABDUL MAJID
S/O LATE ABU TALEB
R/O VILL- DANGARKUCHI
MOUZA- GHILAZARI
DIST- BARPETA
ASSAM-781314
9:ABDUL MALEK
S/O LATE ABU TALEB
R/O VILL- DANGARKUCHI
MOUZA- GHILAZARI
DIST- BARPETA
ASSAM-781314
10:ABDUL MAHMUD
S/O LATE ABU TALEB
R/O VILL- DANGARKUCHI
MOUZA- GHILAZARI
DIST- BARPETA
ASSAM-781314
11:MARIAM BEGUM
W/O LATE MATIAR RAHMAN
R/O VILL- DANGARKUCHI
MOUZA- GHILAZARI
DIST- BARPETA
ASSAM-781314
12:MEHBOOBA RAHMAN
W/O LATE IDDRIS ALI
R/O VILL- DANGARKUCHI
MOUZA- GHILAZARI
DIST- BARPETA
ASSAM-781314
Page No.# 4/15
13:NUR MAHAMMAD
S/O LATE NAJESH ALI
R/O VILL- DANGARKUCHI
MOUZA- GHILAZARI
DIST- BARPETA
ASSAM-781314
14:HEIRS OF LATE RUNUWARA BEGUM
A) NAUSHAD ALI (HUSBAND)
B) JENIFA BEGUM (DAUGHTER)
C) ARSHAD ALI (SON)
D) IRSHAD ALI (SON)
A MINOR REPRESENTED BY HIS FATHER NAAUSHAD ALI
R/O VILL- DANGARKUCHI
MOUZA- GHILAZARI
DIST- BARPETA
ASSAM-781314
15:RATNA KANTA DAS
S/O LATE GHANA KANTA DAS
R/O VILL- RANGPURHATI
MOUZA AND DIST- BARPETA
ASSAM-781318
16:SMTI. SABITRIBALA DAS
W/O RATNA KANTA DAS
R/O VILL- RANGPURHATI
MOUZA AND DIST- BARPETA
ASSAM-781318
17:HEIRS OF LATE MATIAR RAHMAN
A) MOMINUR RAHMAN (SON)
B) MUSTAFIZUR RAHMAN (SON)
R/O VILL- DANGARKUCHI
MOUZA- GHILAZARI
DIST- BARPETA
ASSAM-781314
18:MUSTT. JURUTAN NESSA
W/O LATE ASHAD ALI
R/O VILL- DANGARKUCHI
MOUZA- GHILAZARI
DIST- BARPETA
ASSAM-78131
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR. A SATTAR, S CHOUDHURY
Advocate for the Respondent : MR. N ALAM(R-1,2,3), MR K JAIN(R-1,2,3)
Page No.# 5/15
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ROBIN PHUKAN
ORDER
Date : 23.07.2026
Heard Mr. A. Sattar, learned counsel for the petitioners. Also heard Mr. N.
Alam, learned counsel for the respondent Nos. 1, 2 and 3.
2.
In this petition, under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, the
petitioners have challenged the order dated 30.07.2025, passed by the learned
Civil Judge (Senior Division), Barpeta, in Misc. (J) Case No. 49/2025, arising out
of Misc. (J) Case No. 159/2024, of Title Appeal No. 72/2024.
3.
Notably, vide impugned order dated 30.07.2025, the learned Civil Judge
(Senior Division), Barpeta (‘Appellate Court’, for short) had rejected the
application filed by the petitioners, under Order 1 Rule 10(2), read with Section
151 CPC, to strike off the names of the proforma respondent Nos. 10, 12 and
13, and to add one Kaustov Jyoti Das as proforma respondent in place of
proforma respondent Nos. 10, 12 and 13, and that the legal heirs of proforma
respondent No. 10 are already on record.
4.
Mr. Sattar, learned counsel for the petitioners submits that the respondent
Nos. 1, 2 and 3 herein as plaintiffs, had instituted a title suit, being Title Suit No.
95/2012, before the Court of learned Civil Judge (Junior Division) No. 1, Barpeta
(‘Trial Court’, for short), and that the petitioners herein, as defendants, entered
appearance and contested the suit. Thereafter, hearing the learned counsel for
both the parties, and also considering the evidence on record, the learned Trial
Court, vide judgment dated 25.04.2024 and decree dated 04.05.2024, had
decreed the suit. Mr. Sattar also submits that being aggrieved, the petitioners
herein had preferred an appeal, being Title Appeal No. 72/2024, along with an
Page No.# 6/15
application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963, for condoning the delay
of 170 days before the learned Appellate Court, and upon the said delay
condonation application, Misc. (J) Case No. 159/2024, was registered and the
said application is yet to be disposed of, and that the appeal is yet to be
admitted for disposal of delay condonation application. Mr. Sattar further
submits that the respondent Nos. 1, 2 and 3 herein as plaintiffs, while filing Title
Suit No. 95/2012, had included the co-pattadars as proforma defendants as they
had filed the suit for partition, and as such, the petitioners while preferring the
appeal, had also included them as parties in Title Appeal No. 72/2024 as well as
in Misc. (J) Case No. 159/2024, even though they did not contest the suit and
the suit proceeded ex-parte against them. Mr. Sattar also submits that the
petitioners herein took steps and notice upon the proforma respondent No. 10
returned unserved and on enquiry, the petitioners came to know that the
proforma respondent No. 10, namely, Nur Mohammad had died before filing of
the appeal, leaving behind the opposite parties/respondents as his legal heirs
and successors, and that from the report of the process server, the petitioners
came to know that the proforma respondent Nos. 12 and 13, i.e. the original
sellers also suffered demise before filing of the appal, leaving behind one
Kaustov Jyoti Das as their only legal heir, and as such, the petitioners had filed
one petition, bearing No. 421/2025, dated 21.02.2025, under Order 1 Rule
10(2), read with Section 151 CPC, to strike off the names of proforma
respondent Nos. 10, 12 and 13 and to add Kaustov Jyoti Das as proforma
respondent in place of proforma respondent Nos. 10, 12 and 13, in Misc. (J)
Case No. 159/2024, and the said petition was registered as Misc. (J) Case No.
49/2025. Mr. Sattar further submits that the opposite parties had raised no
objection against the Misc. (J) Case No. 49/2025, yet the learned Appellate
Page No.# 7/15
Court, by quoting a phrase from a decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court, had
rejected the petition and accordingly, Misc. (J) Case No. 49/2025 was disposed
of on contest, vide impugned order dated 30.07.2025. Being aggrieved, the
petitioners have approached this Court by filing the present petition, challenging
the impugned order dated 30.07.2025.
4.1. According to Mr. Sattar, learned counsel for the petitioners, the impugned
order suffers from illegally and material irregularity and therefore, he has
contended to interfere with the same and to remand the matter to the learned
Appellate Court.
5.
Per contra, Mr. Alam, learned counsel for the respondent Nos. 1, 2 and 3
has opposed the petition and supported the impugned order dated 30.07.2025.
According to him, the impugned order suffers from no infirmity or irregularity
requiring any interference of this Court. And as such, he has contended to
dismiss the petition.
6.
Having heard the submissions of learned counsel for both the parties, this
Court has carefully gone through the petition and the documents placed on
record and also perused the impugned order dated 30.07.2025.
7.
The basic facts, herein this case, are not in dispute. The petitioners herein
had preferred one title appeal, challenging the judgment and decree, passed by
the learned Trial Court, and in filing the title appeal, there was a delay of 170
days, for which they had filed an application for condonation of delay, under
Section 5 of the Limitation Act, upon which Misc. (J) Case No. 159/2024, was
registered. While notice was issued to the opposite parties in the said
application, it had come to light that the proforma respondent Nos. 10, 12 and
13 suffered demise as per report of the process server. Thereafter, the
Page No.# 8/15
petitioners had preferred one application, under Order 1 Rule 10(2), read with
Section 151 CPC, for striking off the names of deceased proforma respondent
Nos. 10, 12 and 13, and also for addition of legal heirs of proforma respondent
Nos. 12 and 13, in Misc. (J) Case No. 159/2024.
7.1. However, the learned Appellate Court had dismissed the said application on
the ground that the appeal was filed against dead persons i.e. proforma
respondent Nos. 10, 12 and 13, and that the application for addition of legal
heirs for substitution could not be allowed. And in arriving at such a finding, it
had relied upon a decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Gurcharan
Singh Vs. Surjit Singh and Anr., reported in (2012) 13 SCC 530,
Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that:
"Thus the aforesaid authorities are clear that where a
party has been impleaded as respondent in an appeal but
such respondent was dead before filing of the appeal,
the remedy of the appellant is not to file an
application for substitution of legal representatives
of such respondent, but to file an application for an
amendment of the appeal memorandum and in a case where
such application is filed beyond the limitation
prescribed for filing the appeal, the appellant must
also file an application under section 5 of the
Limitation Act for condonation of delay in filing the
application for amendment and if the court is satisfied
with the explanation given by the appellant for the
delay, the court can condone the delay and allow the
amendment of the appeal memorandum.”
7.2. Thus, though not in express word, the learned Court below had stated
about the petition for substitution not being accompanied by a petition for
condonation of delay, since the pro-forma respondent No.10, 12 and 13 died
Page No.# 9/15
long back, weighed it in rejection of the application, yet from a close perusal of
the impugned order and the decision relied upon by it, goes to show that the
same is also a ground for rejection of the application.
8.
However, it appears that in the instant case, the appeal is yet to be
admitted as there was delay and the application for condonation of delay had
been filed, upon which Misc. (J) Case No. 159/2024, was registered, and when
notice was issued to the proforma respondent Nos. 10, 12 and 13 returned
unserved, only then the petitioners came to know that they had suffered
demise. The process server had also submitted a report on 27.12.2024, and the
application in the Misc(J) Case No. 159/2024, under Order 1 Rule 10(2), read
with Section 151 CPC, was filed on 21.02.2025, upon which Misc(J) Case No.
49/2025 was registerd.
9.
It is the contention of Mr. Sattar, learned counsel for the petitioners that
even if there is delay in filing the application, the same came to the knowledge
of the petitioners from report of the Process Server, dated 27.12.2024, and that
the limitation for filing an application under Order 1 Rule 10(2), read with
Section 151 CPC, was 150 days from the date of death and since herein this
case the exact date of death is not known, the limitation has to be counted from
the date of knowledge i.e. from the report of the Process Server, who had
furnished the report on 27.12.2024. He also pointed it out that the petitioners
herein had filed the application on 21.02.2025. And as such, an application has
to be filed after 150 days (90 + 60).
10. It is also to be noted here that while dealing with the issue of limitation in
filing an application for substitution, Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Om
Prakash Gupta Alias Lalloowa (Now Deceased) Through Lrs. & Ors.
vs. Satish Chandra (Now Deceased) Through Lrs., reported in
Page No.# 10/15
(2025) 2 SCR 937, especially in paragraph No. 11; held that the total time
frame for filing an application for substitution and for setting aside abatement,
as outlined in Articles 120 and 121 of the Limitation Act, is 150 (90+60) days
and the question of condonation of delay through an application under Section 5
of the Limitation Act arises only after this period and not on the 91st day, when
the suit/appeal abates.
11. In the instant case, the application was filed after 56 days, and as such, by
no stretch of imagination, it can be said that the appeal against the proforma
respondent Nos. 10, 12 and 13 stands abated.
Relevant
Decision
of
Supreme
Court
presently
occupying
the
field:12. There are three decisions of Supreme Court which together form the core
jurisprudence on the issue. These are:(i) Ram Prasad Dagaduram vs. Vijaykumar Motilal Hirakhanwala and
Ors., reported in AIR 1967 SC 278.
This is an older decision prior to enactment of Limitation Act, 1963. In
this decision, Hon’ble Supreme Court has recognised that legal
representatives can be added under Order I Rule 10 CPC. But, under
the then-applicable law (Section 22 of the Limitation Act, 1908), the
suit against the newly added parties was held to be instituted only on
the date of impleadment, and on facts it was barred by limitation.
(ii) Karuppaswamy and Others v. C. Ramamurthy, reported in (1993) 4
SCC 41.
In this case the suit was filed against a person who had already died
(unknown to the plaintiff). And when the fact of death came to light,
Page No.# 11/15
the plaintiff applied to bring the LRs on record (initially under Order
XXII Rule 4, later sought to be treated under inherent powers /
Sections 151 & 153 CPC). Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that the
omission was a mistake made in good faith. Therefore, under the
proviso to Section 21(1) of the Limitation Act, the Court could direct
that the suit shall be deemed to have been instituted against the LRs
on the original date of filing of the plaint (i.e., the impleadment relates
back). The Court permitted the conversion of the application and
allowed the LRs to be brought on record with the benefit of relation
back. This is the leading earlier decision on the “good faith” aspect
under the proviso to Section 21(1) of the Limitation Act.
(iii)
Pankajbhai
Rameshbhai
Zalavadiya
v.
Jethabhai
Kalabhai
Zalavadiya, reported in (2017) 9 SCC 700, Hon’ble Supreme Court held
as under while dealing with the issue: “10. Order 1 Rule 10 of the Code enables the court to add
any person as a party at any stage of the proceedings, if
the person whose presence in court is necessary in order
to enable the court to effectively and completely
adjudicate upon and settle all the questions involved in
the suit. Avoidance of multiplicity of proceedings is
also one of the objects of the said provision. Order 1
Rule 10 of the Code empowers the court to substitute a
party in the suit who is a wrong person with a right
person. If the court is satisfied that the suit has been
instituted through a bona fide mistake, and also that it
is necessary for the determination of the real matter in
controversy to substitute a party in the suit, it may
direct it to be done. When the court finds that in the
absence of the persons sought to be impleaded as a party
Page No.# 12/15
to the suit, the controversy raised in the suit cannot be
effectively and completely settled, the court would do
justice by impleading such persons. Order 1 Rule 10(2) of
the Code gives wide discretion to the court to deal with
such a situation which may result in prejudicing the
interests of the affected party if not impleaded in the
suit, and where the impleadment of the said party is
necessary and vital for the decision of the suit.
………………….
………………………………..
19. As mentioned supra, it is only if a defendant dies
during the pendency of the suit that the provisions of
Order 22 Rule 4 of the Code can be invoked. Since one of
the defendants i.e. Defendant 7 has expired prior to the
filing of the suit, there is no legal impediment in
impleading the legal representatives of the deceased
Defendant 7 under Order 1 Rule 10 of the Code, for the
simple reason that the plaintiff in any case could have
instituted
a
fresh
suit
against
these
legal
representatives on the date he moved an application for
making them parties, subject of course to the law of
limitation. Normally, if the plaintiff had known about
the death of one of the defendants at the time of
institution of the suit, he would have filed a suit in
the
first
instance
against
his
heirs
or
legal
representatives. The difficulty that the High Court
experienced in granting the application filed by the
plaintiff under Order 1 Rule 10 of the Code discloses,
with great respect, a hypertechnical approach which may
result in the miscarriage of justice. As the heirs of the
deceased Defendant 7 were the persons with vital interest
in the outcome of the suit, such applications have to be
approached keeping in mind that the courts are meant to
do substantial justice between the parties and that
technical rules or procedures should not be given
Page No.# 13/15
precedence over doing substantial justice. Undoubtedly,
justice according to the law does not merely mean
technical justice but means that law is to be
administered to advance justice.”
12.1. So, from the aforesaid decision it becomes clear that the legal heirs of a
deceased person can be added in the array of parties under Order 1 Rule 10 of
the Code read with Section 151 of the Code, subject to the plea of limitation as
contemplated under Order 7 Rule 6 of the CPC and Section 21 of the Limitation
Act, to be decided during the course of trial. It is a settled proposition of law
that if a suit is filed against a dead person, the legal representatives of the
defendants can be impleaded under Order 1 Rule 10 CPC, provided he did not
have knowledge of the same. So based on the above decision, “knowledge” of
the death becomes the most important component for the purpose of resorting
to the provisions of order 1 rule 10.
12.2. In the instant case, the pro-forma respondent Nos. 10, 12 and 13 died
before the filing of the delay-condonation application and therefore, the appeal
could not be treated as properly instituted against them. The application under
Order 1 Rule 10(2) r/w Section 151 CPC for bringing the legal representatives of
one deceased respondent on record and for deleting the names of the others is,
therefore, maintainable. The learned appellate court herein should have allowed
the application under Order 1 Rule 10(2) CPC and brought the legal
representatives on record or deleted the name of the deceased respondents, as
the case may be, subject, of course, to the question of limitation under Section
21 of the Limitation Act being decided at the appropriate stage and then
proceeded to decide the delay-condonation application on merits after notice to
the newly added legal representatives. And dismissal of the application on the
ground that the appeal was filed against the dead person and that substitution
Page No.# 14/15
was not accompanied by a petition for condonation of delay, appears to be
hyper-technical ground, which is contrary to the law laid down by the Supreme
Court in Pankajbhai Zalavadia(supra) and is therefore not justified and
clearly not sustainable in law.
12.3. Notably, under Section 21 of the Limitation Act, 1963, proceedings against
a newly added defendant are ordinarily deemed to have been instituted only on
the date he is made a party or when summons is served. The proviso, however,
permits the Court to direct that the suit shall be deemed to have been instituted
on an earlier date if the omission to include the party was due to a mistake
made in good faith.
12.4. Ignorance of the death, when the exact date was not known, is treated
as a relevant factor for “good faith.” The application, as such may be allowed
subject to the limitation plea being decided at trial, more often under Order VII
Rule 6 CPC. The practical starting point for computing whether the claim against
the legal representative is within time, is therefore, the date of knowledge of
the death, after which the plaintiff is expected to act diligently.
12.5. In short, when the date of death itself is not known, limitation for the
purpose of the Order I Rule 10(2) application and the consequential claim
against the legal representative is counted from the date the applicant acquired
knowledge of the death with the Court retaining power, under the proviso to
Section 21, to relate the impleadment back to the original filing date, on proof
of good-faith ignorance. This approach prioritizes substantial justice over pure
technicality, while still protecting the legal representative’s limitation rights.
13. Thus, when the exact date of death was not known, the practical starting
point for examining limitation (and good faith) is the date of knowledge of the
Page No.# 15/15
death, after which the plaintiff is expected to act with reasonable diligence. The
limitation plea itself remains open for decision at trial.
14. As discussed in paragraph No.10 above, in the instant case, the application
was filed on 21.02.2025, which was within 56 days from the date of knowledge,
i.e. from the report of the Process Server, who had furnished the report on
27.12.2024.
15. It is worth-mentioning in this context that the respondents herein, had not
opposed the petition before the learned Trial Court. Even then, the learned Trial
Court had not considered the prayer in the petition.
16. In that view of the matter, the impugned order dated 30.07.2025, fails to
withstand the legal scrutiny, and accordingly, the same stands set aside and
quashed.
17.
The matter stands remanded to the learned Appellate Court to consider
the application afresh after giving opportunity of being heard to both the parties
and thereafter it shall proceed to hear the application for condonation of delay
in the appeal, i.e. Misc(J) Case No. 159 of 2024 and in the event of condonation
of delay, to admit the appeal, and thereafter, to proceed with the same in
accordance with law.
18. The parties shall appear before the learned Appellate Court on or before
14.08.2026.
19. In terms of above, this revision petition stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review