Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/20
GAHC010317582019
2026:GAU-AS:11494
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/9544/2019
MD. SAHIDUL RAHMAN @ SAHIDUL HAQUE
S/O FAJRUL RAHMAN @ FAJRUL SHEIKH @ FAZARA SHEIKH, R/O VILLDEBOTTAR HASDAHA, PART-V, P.O.-DEBOTTAR HASDAHA, P.S.GOLAKGANJ, DIST-DHUBRI, ASSAM, PIN-783334
VERSUS
UNION OF INDIA AND 4 ORS.
REPRESENTED BY THE MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS, NEW DELHI
2:STATE OF ASSAM
REPRESENTED BY THE MINISTRY OF HOME
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-6
3:DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF POLICE (BORDER)
GUWAHATI
ASSAM
4:NATIONAL REGISTRATION OF CITIZENS
REPRESENTED BY ITS STATE COORDINATOR
ACHYUT PLAZA
BHANGAGARH
GUWAHATI-5
5:ELECTION COMMISSION OF INDIA
NIRVACHAN SADAN
ASHOKA ROAD
NEW DELHI-11000
Page No.# 2/20
-BEFOREHON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KALYAN RAI SURANA
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE PRANJAL DAS
Advocate for the petitioner
: Mr. S.K.Ghosh, Adv.
Advocate for the respondent No. 1
: Mr. I. Borthakur, CGC
Advocate for the respondent No. 5
: Mr. A.I. Ali, Standing Counsel,
ECI.
: Ms. R. B. Bora, Govt. Adv.
: Mr. J. Payeng, SC, FT & Border
Matters
Advocate for the State respondents
Advocate for the respondent Nos. 3 and 4
Date on which judgment is reserved
: 20.07.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 13.08.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
operative part of the judgment ?
: N/A
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
: Yes
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
(Pranjal Das, J)
Heard Mr. S. K. Ghosh, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also
heard Mr. J. Payeng, learned Standing counsel, F.T. and Border matters;
Mr. A. I. Ali, learned Standing counsel, ECI and Mr. I. Borthakur, learned
CGC and Ms. R. B. Bora, learned Junior Government Advocate.
2.
Invoking the jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, the petitioner, Md. Sahidul Rahman @ Sahidul Haque, has assailed
the judgment and opinion dated 23.10.2019 passed by the learned
Member of the Foreigners' Tribunal, Kamrup (M), No. 2, Guwahati, in
Page No.# 3/20
the FT Case No. 355/2018, whereby the petitioner, as proceedee, was
declared to be a foreign national who had illegally entered India, after
24.03.1971.
3.
The facts in brief are that a reference was made by the Senior
Superintendent of Police (B), Guwahati, against Md. Sahidul Rahman @
Sahidul Haque, son of Fajrul Sheikh, suspecting him to be a foreigner
who had illegally come from Bangladesh and the opinion of the
Foreigners Tribunal was sought for. Thereupon, FT Case No. 355/2018, as
mentioned above was registered and notice was issued to the petitioner
as proceedee, whereupon, on 05.08.2019, he appeared and filed a
written statement, claiming that he was an Indian citizen and denied that
he was a foreigner who had illegally come from Bangladesh after the cutoff date.
4.
During the proceedings, the petitioner, as proceedee, adduced
evidence of 2 (two) witnesses, being himself as DW-1 and his projected
father, Fajrul Sheikh as DW-2. As part of his evidence, the petitioner, as
proceedee, exhibited as many as 19 (nineteen) documents. However, the
Tribunal could not be persuaded by the petitioner through his evidence
and documents to return an opinion in his favour. And the Tribunal
answered the reference against the petitioner, holding him to be a
foreigner post the cut-off date.
5.
Mr. Ghosh, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that Md.
Sahidul Rahman and Sahidul Haque are one and the same person and
that the judgment of the Tribunal is perverse. It is submitted that no FT
case is pending against other family members. It is submitted that the
particulars of the birth certificate, adduced in evidence by the petitioner,
Page No.# 4/20
have matched with that of the voters list. It is submitted that there is no
information in the reference that he had migrated from the specified
territory. It is further contended that when the father of the petitioner
has not been doubted, then how can his son be declared as a foreigner,
and that the fact that the petitioner is the son of the said Fajrul Sheikh is
not disputed. It is submitted that a residency certificate has also been
issued by the panchayat and the concerned person from the panchayat
had also appeared as witness.
6.
On the other hand, Mr. J. Payeng, learned counsel for respondent
Nos. 2 and 4, submits that in all the voters lists, the projected father of
the petitioner is mentioned as Fajrul Sheikh and there is discrepancy in
the birth certificate. It is further submitted that the projected father and
grandfather are not together in any document and that from 1989 voters
list onwards, there has been a different set of people. It is submitted that
there is no linkage evidence between the projected father and
grandfather of the petitioner.
7. Referring to relevant case laws, the learned counsel submits that the
certificate issued by the panchayat is valid only with regard to shifting of
married women. In support of his contentions, the learned counsel for
respondent Nos. 2 and 4 relies on the following decision:(i) Rupajan Begum Vs. Union of India and Ors reported in (2018) 1 SSC
579.
8.
We have perused the pleadings of the writ petition, the written
statement, the evidence on affidavit adduced from the side of the
petitioner, the exhibited documents and other relevant materials. We
Page No.# 5/20
have considered the submissions of the learned counsels on both the
sides and perused the decisions cited at the Bar.
9.
In the written statement, the petitioner as proceedee claimed that
he was a citizen of India by birth, having been born on 20.03.1992, at
village Debottar Hasdaha Part-V within the jurisdiction of Golakganj Police
Station of district Dhubri. And that in this connection, the Registrar of
Birth & Death, Golakganj P.H.C, issued a birth certificate vide Registration
No. 1085, dated 31.07.1992. However, it is stated in the written
statement that in the birth certificate, the name of the petitioner's father
was recorded mistakenly as Fajlur Rahman instead of Fajrul Sheikh.
10. In this context, the petitioner in the written statement has pleaded
that the actual and correct name of the petitioner's father is Fajrul Sheikh
and therefore Fajrul Sheikh and the aforementioned Fajlur Rahman are
one and the same person and father of the petitioner. The petitioner
denied in the written statement that he is a foreign national. He also
stated that in the notice sent by the Tribunal, in the proceeding, his
name was reflected as Sahidul Rahman @ Bhutta but his actual and
correct name is Sahidul Haque. It is also stated that in the notice, the
petitioner's father's name was reflected as Fajrul Rahman but actual and
correct name is Fajrul Sheikh. The petitioner further pleaded in the
written statement - that even his parents, grandparents and other
members of the family are citizens of India.
11. He stated the name of the father of his great-grandfather as Turu
Sheikh, name of his great-grandfather as Kado Sheikh, name of his greatgrandmother as Sendur Bibi and his grandfather being Josen Ali. He
further
stated
that
his
grandmother's
name
was
Joribhan
Page No.# 6/20
Bibi, grandfather's brother's name is Husen Ali and the name of his father
is Fajrul Sheikh @ Fajlur Rahman and his mother is Sahida Bibi. He stated
about the siblings of his father being 8 (eight) in number and he also
stated about his own siblings being 8 (eight) in number.
12.
The petitioner stated in the written statement that the name of his
great-grandfather,
great-grandmother,
grandfather and
grandmother
were enlisted in the voters list of 1966 with regard to No. 34 Gauripur
LAC. The petitioner also filed an additional written statement reiterating
that he is a citizen of India by birth. Regarding voters list, he stated that
in the voters list of 1989 with regard to the said LAC, the name of his
father and ancestors were enlisted and that in 2015 of the said LAC, his
name was also reflected along with that of his father and mother.
However, it is stated that his father's name was again wrongly
reflected as Fazar Sheikh instead of Fajrul Sheikh.
13. In his evidence on affidavit as DW-1, the petitioner stated some of
the statements as referred to above from the written statement. DW-1
deposed that he is a citizen of India by birth, having been born on
20.03.1996 at village Debottar Hasdaha Part-V within the jurisdiction of
Golakganj Police Station of District Dhubri and that he was issued a birth
certificate vide Registration No. 1085 dated 31.07.1992. However, his
father's name was mistakenly written as Fajlur Rahman instead of Fajrul
Sheikh and that petitioner's father's correct name is Fajrul Sheikh. DW1
denied the allegations of being a foreign national stating that in the
notice his name is reflected as Sahidul Rahman @ Bhutta but his correct
name is Sahidul Haque.
Similarly, his father's name was reflected as
Fajrul Rahman instead of the correct name of Fajrul Sheikh. DW1 stated
Page No.# 7/20
about his grandparents, parents and other family members being citizens
of India. DW-1 deposed about the names of his great-grandfather and
father of great-grandfather and great-grandmother as already mentioned
above from the written statement.
14. In his testimony also, DW-1 deposed about his siblings. DW-1 also
deposed about the voters list of 1966 of Gouripur LAC wherein the names
of
his
great-grandfather,
great-grandmother,
grandfather
and
grandmother were stated to be enlisted. He also stated about the
enlisting of the names of his great-grandparents and grandmother in the
voters list of 1970 of the same LAC. DW-1 in para 8 of the evidence
affidavit stated that in the voters list of 1977 of Gouripur LAC, the names
of his grandfather, grandmother, brother of his grandfather were
recorded. Similarly, in the voters list of 1989 of Gouripur LAC the names
of his father and uncles were recorded. Similarly, DW1 testified about the
names of his father and mother being recorded in the voters list of 1997,
2005, 2010 with regard to No. 34 Gouripur LAC and their address was
given as Debottar Hasdaha Part-V within the jurisdiction of Golakganj
Police Station of district Dhubri.
15. DW1 stated about his name figuring along with his parents in the
voters list of 2015 of the same constituency, but it is stated that his
father's name was wrongly reflected as Fazar Sheikh instead of Fajrul
Sheikh. With regard to the voters list of 2019, DW-1 testified about the
names of his parents, sister, himself and his wife being recorded.
However, in the voters list of 2019 also, father's name was recorded as
Fajrul Rahman. In para 15, DW1 stated that the Election Commission
issued a voters ID card in the name of his father as Fajrul Sheikh. He
Page No.# 8/20
exhibited the same as Exhibit-K. It may be mentioned herein that the
voters lists mentioned above were exhibited by the petitioner as Exhibit-
B,C,D,E,F,G,H,I,J. The birth certificate has been exhibited as Exhibit A.
DW1 also deposed that the ECI issued voters ID in the name of his
mother as Sahida Bibi, wife of Fajrul Sheikh. He was also given a voter ID
card as Sahidul Haque, son of Fajrul Sheikh. He said that PAN card was
also issued in his name as Sahidul Haque, son of Fajrul Sheikh. He
exhibited his voter ID card and PAN card as Exhibit L and M respectively.
16. As part of his testimony, DW-1 also exhibited a certificate issued by
the Secretary and President of Dhedhepi Gaon Panchayat. The certificate
was issued in the name of Sahidul Haque, son of Fajrul Sheikh, inhabitant
of village Debottar Hasdaha P
art-V, Golakganj, Dhubri. DW-1 also
exhibited the certificate issued by the Secretary of Dhedhepi Gaon
Panchayat, in the name of his father as Fajrul Sheikh. He deposed that
his grandparents have landed property in that village and so also his
father. He deposed that they also have landed property and in 1972, his
grandfather and his grandfather's brother purchased land. And the said
deed was exhibited at Exhibit-P.
17. Perhaps in the absence of the government Pleader, questions were
put
by
the
Tribunal
to
DW-1,
regarding
his
evidence
on
affidavit. Answering those questions, DW-1 stated that his name is
Sahidul Haque and father's name is Fajrul Sheikh; mother is Sahida Bibi
and paternal grandparents are Joshen Ali and Jori. He stated about his
wife Sofia Bibi, his siblings and also the siblings of his father. DW-1
reiterated in such questions by Tribunal that he and his family reside in
village Debottar Hasdaha Part-V under Golakganj PS, Dhubri. And that he
Page No.# 9/20
was born in that village and cast vote there for the first time in the year
2016. He stated that apart from his case, no other proceeding is pending
against his family members regarding citizenship status. He stated about
exhibiting 19 documents.
18.
The petitioner's projected father, Fajrul Sheikh has adduced
evidence on his behalf as DW-2 on affidavit. In the affidavit he has
mentioned his name as Fajrul Sheikh @ Fajlur Rahman @ Fazar Sheikh ,
son of Joshen Ali, a resident village Debottar Hasdaha Part-V under
Golakganj PS, Dhubri. DW2 stated that he is also a citizen of India and
residing in village Debottar Hasdaha Part-V under Golakganj PS, Dhubri
and father of the petitioner, Sahidul Haque. He stated that the petitioner
was born on 20.03.1992 at Debottar Hasdaha Part-V and brought up
there.
19. DW-2 also testified about the birth certificate dated 31.07.1992 and
also stated like DW-1 that his name was wrongly written there as Fajlur
Rahman instead of Fajrul Sheikh. Like DW-1, DW-2 also stated about the
correct name of his son being Sahidul Haque though it is mentioned as
Sahidul Rahman in the notice and about his name also wrongly written as
Fajrul Rahman in the notice instead of Fajrul Sheikh. DW2 also stated
about his ancestors on the lines stated by DW-1. He has deposed on
identical lines regarding the enlisting of his ancestors in the voter lists of
1966, 1970, 1977. He stated about his name and that of his brothers
being reflected in the voters' list of 1989 which has already been
executed by DW1.
20.
He has stated about enlisting the name of himself and his wife in
the voter lists of 1997, 2005, 2010 and 2015. With regard to 2015 voters
Page No.# 10/20
list, DW-2 has deposed that the name of the petitioner also was
reflected, with regard to the aforementioned village Debottar Hasdaha
Part-V under Golakganj PS, Dhubri. He has also stated about his name
being wrongly reflected as Fajrul Sheikh in the voters list of
2015. Regarding the list of 2019, he has stated on identical lines as DW1. The voter ID card mentioned by DW-1 with regard to his projected
father is also testified to by DW-2 and that ID card was issued in his
name as Fajrul Sheikh, son of Josen Ali. The said document has been
exhibited already by DW1. DW2 also stated about the voter ID card in
the name of his wife and the petitioner. He stated that in his son's voter's
ID, his name is mentioned as Sahidul Haque, son of Fajrul Sheikh of
village Debottar Hasdaha Part-V under Golakganj PS, Dhubri.
21.
He has stated about the PAN card on identical lines as DW-1. He
has also stated about the certificates issued by the panchayat which have
already been narrated above. DW-2 has also stated about their landed
property in the village and about his father and uncle purchasing land in
that area in 1972 itself, the relevant document of which has already been
exhibited. In question put by the Tribunal, DW2 stated that his name is
Fajrul Sheikh and the petitioner, Sahidul Rahman is his son. He stated
about his residence in the same village where he was born and also cast
his vote.
22. The Secretary of Dhepdhepi Gaon Panchayat, had adduced evidence
as DW-3. He was examined in chief orally before the Tribunal in which he
stated that his name is Haran Ch. Karmakar and he is the Secretary of
Dhepdhepi Gaon Panchayat. He stated about Exhibit N and identified his
signature there on. He also identified the signature of the President of
Page No.# 11/20
Dhepdhepi Gaon Panchayat, B. Das, stating that he is known to him. He
further stated that the full name of the President is Binota Mala
Das. DW3 stated that Sahidul Hoque, son of Fajrul Sheikh of the Debottar
Hasdaha Part-V under Golakganj PS, Dhubri, filed an application before
the President for a residency certificate which was issued after
verification of the voters list. In this context, he testified that in the
voters list of 2018, with regard to Dhepdhepi Gaon Panchayat electoral
roll the names of Sahidul Hoque and Fajrul Sheikh are recorded.
23.
In questions by the Tribunal, DW3 stated that he had brought the
counter folio of the Residency certificate issued in favour of the
petitioner, and that it was issued from Book No. 5, at Sl. No. 460 dated
24.04.2019. And that he, as Secretary, and the said B. B. Das, as
President, put their signatures. Thus, apart from examining himself and
his projected father, the petitioner side adduced evidence of Dhepdhepi
Gaon Panchayat Secretary as DW3. Apart from 3 (three) witnesses, the
petitioner, as proceedee, before the Tribunal exhibited 19 (nineteen)
documents as referred to earlier.
24. From the materials narrated above, we find that the petitioner
claims to be a citizen of India by birth. Not only that, the petitioner's
contention is that his father, grandfather and other ancestors are also
from India. In this respect, one of the main documents relied upon by
the petitioner in support of his claim of citizenship by birth is Exhibit A
(birth certificate). Apart from this, in his written statement as well as in
his evidence also, the petitioner has stated about being born in India in
1992. His father, who has adduced evidence as DW2, has also testified
about the citizen having been born in the concerned village in the district
Page No.# 12/20
of Dhubri, Assam, India.
25. It is well settled by several decisions of this Court that the burden
under section 9 of the Foreigners Act 1946 has to be discharged by the
proceedee by
adducing
cogent
evidence,
including
essentially
documentary evidence. Therefore, Exhibit A is the document adduced by
the petitioner before the learned Tribunal in support of his contention of
citizenship by birth. In this respect, upon perusing the impugned
judgment and opinion passed by the learned Tribunal, we have not found
discussion as to why the birth certificate (Exhibit A) adduced in evidence
has been discarded.
26. Now, going back to the said document, Exhibit A, we find that it is
mentioned there in that Sahidul Haque was born in village Debottar
Hasdaha Part-V within the jurisdiction of Golakganj Police Station of
district Dhubri on 20-03-1992. His father's name has been mentioned
as Fajlur Rahman. It may be mentioned herein that the reference was
made in the name of Sahidul Rahman, son of Fajrul Sheikh. Though the
petitioner has stated in his written statement as well as in his evidence
that his father's name has been wrongly mentioned as Fajlur Rahman in
the birth certificate, but no materials have been have been adduced as to
any steps taken by the family of the petitioner to correct the same in the
birth certificate. Even in the evidence, it has been stated that the name
has been wrongly mentioned as Fajlur Rahman instead of Fajrul Sheikh.
Therefore, the question is whether it can be automatically assumed that
the name of the petitioner's father mentioned in the birth certificate as
Fajlur Rahman is the same person as Fajrul Sheikh, who is the projected
father of the petitioner.
Page No.# 13/20
27. The petitioner has has exhibited several voters' lists starting from the
year 1966. In the voters' list of 1966 (Exhibit B), Kado Sk mentioned
against Serial No. 491 is stated to be his great-grandfather; Joshan Ali Sk
mentioned at Serial No. 493 is stated to be his grandfather. It may
be mentioned herein that the said Joshan Ali Sk has been indicated as a
son of Kado. In the voters list of 1970 (Exhibit C), Joshan Ali Sk has been
indicated as son of Kado and so also in voters list of 1977 pertaining to
No. 24 Gauripur LAC.
28. The name of the petitioner's projected father, Fazurul Sk, appears for
the first time in the voters list of 1989 ( Exhibit E). Fazurul Sk is indicated
as the son of Josan. In the voters' list of 1997, Fojrul Sk is indicated as
the son of Joshen Ali. In the voters list of 2005, Fojrul Sk is indicated as
son of Joshan Ali. The same is the case in the voters list of 2010.
29. In the written statement and his evidence as DW-1, the petitioner
has mentioned the correct name of his father as Fajrul Sheikh. In his own
evidence also, the petitioner's projected father adducing evidence as
DW2 has mentioned his correct name to be Fajrul Sheikh. In the voters
ID exhibited during the proceeding, the name of the petitioner's father is
mentioned in the voters ID as Fajrul Sheikh.
30. In the background of such names, when we go back to the birth
certificate, it is found that though the petitioner's name is mentioned as
Sahidul Haque, but his father's name therein is mentioned as Fajlur
Rahman. In other words, in the birth certificate produced in evidence by
the petitioner before the Tribunal, the first name of the petitioner's father
is mentioned as Fajlur instead of Fajrul.
Page No.# 14/20
As the learned Tribunal has not discussed the crucial document by
way of birth certificate exhibited as Exhibit A, the limits of certiorari
jurisdiction would come in the way of this court in re-appreciating that
piece of documentary evidence, like a court exercising first appellate
jurisdiction.
31. In this regard, a reference may be made to the following
decisions and the relevant paragraphs gainfully reproduced herein
below:(i) T.C. Basappa v. T. Nagappa reported in (1954) 1 SCC 905;
“7. One of the fundamental principles in regard to the issuing of a writ of
certiorari, is, that the writ can be availed of only to remove or adjudicate on
the validity of judicial acts. The expression “judicial acts” includes the
exercise of quasi-judicial functions by administrative bodies or other
authorities or persons obliged to exercise such functions and is used in
contrast with what are purely ministerial acts. Atkin, L.J. thus summed up
the law on this point in R. v. Electricity Commissioners, ex p London
Electricity Joint Committee Co. (1920) Ltd. [R. v. Electricity Commissioners,
ex p London Electricity Joint Committee Co. (1920) Ltd., (1924) 1 KB 171 at
p. 205 (CA)] : (KB p. 205)
“… Whenever anybody or persons having legal authority to determine
questions affecting the rights of subjects, and having the duty to act
judicially, act in excess of their legal authority they are subject to the
controlling jurisdiction of the King's Bench Division exercised in these writs.”
8. The second essential feature of a writ of certiorari is that the control
which is exercised through it over judicial or quasi-judicial tribunals or
bodies is not in an appellate but supervisory capacity. In granting a writ of
certiorari the superior court does not exercise the powers of an Appellate
Tribunal. It does not review or reweigh the evidence upon which the
Page No.# 15/20
determination of the inferior tribunal purports to be based. It demolishes
the order which it considers to be without jurisdiction or palpably erroneous
but does not substitute its own views for those of the inferior tribunal. The
offending order or proceeding so to say is put out of the way as one which
should not be used to the detriment of any person [ Per Lord Cairns in
Walsall's Overseers v. London & North Western Railway Co., (1878) LR 4 AC
30 at p. 39 (HL)].(emphasis added)”
(ii) South Indian Bank Ltd. v. Naveen Mathew Philip reported in
(2023) 17 SCC 311;
“13. A writ of certiorari is to be issued over a decision when the court finds
that the process does not conform to the law or statute. In other words,
courts are not expected to substitute themselves with the decision-making
authority while finding fault with the process along with the reasons
assigned. Such a writ is not expected to be issued to remedy all violations.
When a tribunal is constituted, it is expected to go into the issues of fact
and law, including a statutory violation. A question as to whether such a
violation would be over a mandatory prescription as against a discretionary
one is primarily within the domain of the Tribunal. So also, the issue
governing waiver, acquiescence, and estoppel. We wish to place reliance on
the decision of this Court in Hari Vishnu Kamath v. Syed Ahmad Ishaque
[Hari Vishnu Kamath v. Syed Ahmad Ishaque, (1954) 2 SCC 881 : (1955) 1
SCR 1104] : (SCC pp. 898-900, paras 24-27).
“24. Then the question is whether there are proper grounds for the
issue of certiorari in the present case. There was considerable
argument before us as to the character and scope of the writ of
certiorari and the conditions under which it could be issued. The
question has been considered by this Court in Parry & Co. Ltd. v.
Commercial Employees' Assn. [Parry & Co. Ltd. v. Commercial
Employees' Assn., (1952) 1 SCC 449] , G. Veerappa Pillai v. Raman &
Page No.# 16/20
Raman Ltd. [G. Veerappa Pillai v. Raman & Raman Ltd., (1952) 1 SCC
334] , Ebrahim Aboobakar v. Custodian of Evacuee Property [Ebrahim
Aboobakar v. Custodian of Evacuee Property, (1952) 1 SCC 798] and
quite recently in T.C. Basappa v. T. Nagappa [T.C. Basappa v. T.
Nagappa, (1954) 1 SCC 905] . On these authorities, the following
propositions may be taken as established:
24.1. Certiorari will be issued for correcting errors of jurisdiction, as
when an inferior court or Tribunal acts without jurisdiction or in excess
of it, or fails to exercise it.
24.2. Certiorari will also be issued when the Court or Tribunal acts
illegally in the exercise of its undoubted jurisdiction, as when it decides
without giving an opportunity to the parties to be heard, or violates
the principles of natural justice.
24.3. The Court issuing a writ of certiorari acts in exercise of a
supervisory and not appellate jurisdiction. One consequence of this is
that the Court will not review findings of fact reached by the inferior
court or Tribunal, even if they be erroneous. This is on the principle
that a Court which has jurisdiction over a subject-matter has
jurisdiction to decide wrong as well as right, and when the legislature
does not choose to confer a right of appeal against that decision, it
would be defeating its purpose and policy, if a superior court were to
rehear the case on the evidence, and substitute its own findings in
certiorari. These propositions are well-settled and are not in dispute.
25. The further question on which there has been some controversy is
whether a writ can be issued, when the decision of the inferior court
or Tribunal is erroneous in law. This question came up for
consideration in R. v. Northumberland Compensation Appeal Tribunal,
ex p Shaw [R. v. Northumberland Compensation Appeal Tribunal, ex p
Shaw, (1951) 1 KB 711] , and it was held that when a tribunal made a
Page No.# 17/20
“speaking order” and the reasons given in that order in support of the
decision were bad in law, certiorari could be granted. It was pointed
out by Lord Goddard, C.J. that that had always been understood to be
the true scope of the power. Walsall Overseers v. London & North
Western Rly. Co. [Walsall Overseers v. London & North Western Rly.
Co., (1878) LR 4 AC 30 (HL)] and R. v. Nat Bell Liquors Ltd. [R. v. Nat
Bell Liquors Ltd., (1922) 2 AC 28] were quoted in support of this view.
In Walsall Overseers v. London & North Western Rly. Co. [Walsall
Overseers v. London & North Western Rly. Co., (1878) LR 4 AC 30
(HL)] Lord Cairns, L.C. observed as follows : (Walsall Overseers case
[Walsall Overseers v. London & North Western Rly. Co., (1878) LR 4 AC
30 (HL)] , AC p. 39)
‘… if there was upon the face of the order of the court of quarter
sessions anything which showed that order was erroneous, the
Court of Queen's Bench might be asked to have the order brought
into it, and to look at the order, and view it upon the face of it,
and if the court found error upon the face of it, to put an end to its
existence by quashing it.…’
In R. v. Nat Bell Liquors Ltd. [R. v. Nat Bell Liquors Ltd., (1922) 2
AC 28] Lord Sumner said : (AC p. 156)
‘… That supervision goes to two points : one is the area of the
inferior jurisdiction and the qualifications and conditions of its
exercise; the other is the observance of the law in the course of its
exercise.’
26. The decision in R. v. Northumberland Compensation Appeal
Tribunal, ex p Shaw [R. v. Northumberland Compensation Appeal
Tribunal, ex p Shaw, (1951) 1 KB 711] was taken in appeal, and was
affirmed by the Court of Appeal in R. v. Northumberland Compensation
Appeal Tribunal, ex p Shaw [R. v. Northumberland Compensation
Page No.# 18/20
Appeal Tribunal, ex p Shaw, (1952) 1 KB 338 (CA)]. In laying down
that an error of law was a ground for granting certiorari, the learned
Judges emphasised that it must be apparent on the face of the record.
Denning, L.J. who stated the power in broad and general terms
observed : (KB p. 351)
‘It will have been seen that throughout all the cases there is one
governing rule : certiorari is only available to quash a decision for
error of law if the error appears on the face of the record.’
The position was thus summed up by Morris, L.J. : (R. case [R. v.
Northumberland Compensation Appeal Tribunal, ex p Shaw, (1952) 1
KB 338 (CA)] , KB p. 357)
‘It is plain that certiorari will not issue as the cloak of an appeal in
disguise. It does not lie in order to bring up an order or decision
for rehearing of the issue raised in the proceedings. It exists to
correct error of law where revealed on the face of an order or
decision, or irregularity, or absence of, or excess of, jurisdiction
where shown.’
27. In G. Veerappa Pillai v. Raman & Raman Ltd. [G. Veerappa Pillai v.
Raman & Raman Ltd., (1952) 1 SCC 334] , it was observed by this
Court that under Article 226 the writ should be issued : (SCC p. 341,
para 26)
‘26. … in grave cases where the subordinate tribunals or bodies or
officers act wholly without jurisdiction, or in excess of it, or in
violation of the principles of natural justice, or refuse to exercise a
jurisdiction vested in them, or there is an error apparent on the
face of the record.…’
In T.C. Basappa v. T. Nagappa [T.C. Basappa v. T. Nagappa, (1954)
1 SCC 905] the law was thus stated : (SCC p. 915, para 11)
Page No.# 19/20
‘11. … An error in the decision or determination itself may also be
amenable to a writ of “certiorari” but it must be a manifest error
apparent on the face of the proceedings e.g. when it is based on
clear ignorance or disregard of the provisions of law. In other
words, it is a patent error which can be corrected by “certiorari”
but not a mere wrong decision.’ (emphasis in original)”
32. Another aspect of the matter needs to be referred to. Section 3 of
the Citizenship Act, 1955 lays down the criteria for citizenship by birth.
Thus, as per Section 3(1)(a), all persons born on or after 26.01.1950 and
before 01.07.1987 would be automatically citizens of India by birth. In
terms of section 3(1) (b), those born on or after 01.07.1987, but before
commencement of the Citizenship (Amendment) Act 2003 will be
citizens of India, but either of the parents of such a person have to be a
citizen of India at the time of birth. Finally, under section 3(1)(c), those
born on or after the commencement of the Citizenship (Amendment) Act,
2003, such a person would be citizen of India when both parents are
Indian citizens or one parent is Indian citizen and the other is not an
illegal migrant at the time of his birth.
33. As the petitioner claims to have been born in the year 1992, he
might be governed by the provisions of section 3(1)(b). Thus, such a
person would be required to show that he was born before the
Citizenship (Amendment) Act 2003, and on or after 01.07.1987 and one
of his parents was an Indian citizen at the time of his birth.
34. In the facts and circumstances of this case, we are of the considered
opinion that keeping in mind the limitations of certiorari jurisdiction, the
matter has to be remanded back to the learned Tribunal for a fresh
Page No.# 20/20
decision, after appreciating the documentary evidence (Birth Certificate –
Exhibit A) in the context of the applicable provisions of the Citizenship
Act, 1955 pertaining to citizenship by birth, read with the provisions of
Section 6A of the Act, applicable to the State of Assam.
35. In such view of the matter, the impugned judgment and opinion
dated judgment and opinion dated 23-10-2019 passed by the learned
Member of the Foreigners' Tribunal, Kamrup (M), No. 2, Guwahati, in
the FT Case No. 355/2018 is set aside. The matter is thereby remanded
back to the learned Tribunal for a fresh decision on the lines indicated
above.
36. In the context of the nature of decision passed in this writ petition, it
is directed that till a fresh adjudication is made by the learned Tribunal,
the petitioner shall not be subjected to any coercive action by way of
detention and deportation in connection with the instant reference
proceeding. To that extent, the interim order dated 15.05.2020, stands
modified.
37. The instant writ petition stands disposed of on the aforesaid terms.
38. Return the original case records to the learned Tribunal.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review