Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/11
GAHC010275292025
2026:GAU-AS:14088
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/17/2026
MD. ROUCHAN ALI @ UBC NO. 224 ROUCHAN ALI
S/O MR. MOMIRUDDIN MUNCHI, R/O VILLAGE- 270, 2 PAIKAN PT II,
MATIA, KRISHNAI, P.O.- KRISHNAI, P.S.- DUDHNAI, DISTRICT- GOALPARA,
PIN- 783126, ASSAM.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 6 ORS.
REPRESENTED BY CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM, DISPUR,
GUWAHATI- 6.
2:THE COMISSIONER AND SECRETARY
DEPARTMENT OF HOME
GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM
ASSAM SACHIVALAYA
DISPUR-781006
ASSAM.
3:THE DIRECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE
OFFICE OF THE DGP
ULUBARI
GUWAHATI-781007
ASSAM.
4:SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE
SOUTH SALMARA MANKACHAR DISTRICT
ASSAM.
5:THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE
GOALPARA
DIST- GOALPARA
ASSAM
Page No.# 2/11
6:THE ADDITIONAL SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE
SOUTH SALMARA DISTRICT
ASSAM
7:THE INSPECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE
WESTERN RANGE
ASSAM
BONGAIGAO
Advocate for the Petitioner
DEKA
: MR S P DAS, MS. S BAISHYA,MS C BORA,MR. ANGSHUMAN
Advocate for the Respondent : GA, ASSAM, MR. T C CHUTIA, SR. GA
:::BEFORE:::
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KARDAK ETE
Date on which judgment is reserved : 10.09.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment : 23.09.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of
the operative of the judgment?
: No
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
: Yes
JUDGEMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. S. P. Das, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. T. C.
Chutia, learned Senior Counsel, assisted by Mr. B. Bishaya, learned counsel for
the State respondents.
2.
By filing this writ petition, the petitioner has put to challenge the order
Page No.# 3/11
dated 03.07.2023, passed by the Superintendent of Police, South Salmara,
Mankachar District, whereby the petitioner has been dismissed from service, as
well as the appellate order dated 29.02.2024, passed by the Inspector General
of Police, Western Range, Bongaigaon, Assam, whereby the appeal preferred by
the petitioner against the order of dismissal has been rejected. The petitioner
further seeks a direction upon the respondents to reinstate him in service with
full pay and arrear salaries and also to furnish all the documents relating to
Departmental Proceeding No. 03/2017 arising out of both the enquiries.
3.
The facts of the case in brief are that the petitioner was appointed as a
Constable (AB) in the Assam Police with effect from 04.01.1994. On 01.02.2017,
one Shri Jagadish Debnath lodged an FIR alleging, inter alia, that four persons
in police uniform had entered a hotel and after assaulting him, had snatched
away an amount of Rs.1,70,000/-. The said FIR was registered as Agia P.S. Case
No. 17/2017, under Section 394 of the Indian Penal Code. In connection with
the said case, the petitioner was arrested on 06.02.2017 and was subsequently
released on bail on 08.05.2017. In the meantime, the petitioner was placed
under suspension with effect from 06.02.2017.
4.
A departmental proceeding was thereafter initiated against the petitioner
by issuance of a show-cause notice dated 19.07.2017, under Section 65 of the
Assam Police Act, 2007 read with Rule 66 of the Assam Police Manual Part-II,
Article 311 of the Constitution of India and Rule 7 of the Assam Services
(Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1964. The petitioner submitted his written
statement denying the allegations and asserting, inter alia, that he had no
involvement in the alleged occurrence. He also relied upon the Command
Certificate dated 28.01.2017 to contend that he had been detailed for Assembly
duty at Guwahati on the day of occurrence.
Page No.# 4/11
5.
In the meantime, pending completion of the Departmental Enquiry, the
suspension of the petitioner was subsequently revoked by order dated
05.11.2017, without prejudice to the Departmental Proceedings. It is the case of
the petitioner that the first enquiry conducted pursuant to the departmental
proceeding suffered from certain procedural deficiencies and the enquiry report
submitted therein was not accepted by the Disciplinary Authority. Thereafter, by
order dated 23.08.2018, a de-novo enquiry was directed in respect of the same
charges, with a fresh Enquiry Officer and Presenting Officer being appointed.
6.
It is the contention of the petitioner that he was never served with any
notice of the said de-novo enquiry and was, therefore, deprived of an
opportunity to participate in the enquiry, cross-examine the departmental
witnesses and otherwise defend himself. The de-novo enquiry was accordingly
conducted behind his back and the findings therein were recorded without
affording him a reasonable opportunity of hearing. It is further contended that
the earlier enquiry report was also never furnished to him.
7.
It is the further case of the petitioner that during the pendency of the
departmental proceedings, the Enquiry Officer was subsequently changed and
by order dated 19.07.2021, another Enquiry Officer and Presenting Officer were
appointed. The petitioner was also transferred from Goalpara D.E.F. to South
Salmara-Mancachar D.E.F. by order dated 19.04.2022 and continued to serve
there until the order of dismissal.
8.
Eventually, by order dated 03.07.2023, the petitioner was dismissed from
service. However, according to the petitioner, before passing the said order of
dismissal, neither a copy of the enquiry report nor any notice affording him an
opportunity to submit his representation against the findings of the Enquiry
Officer was furnished to him. Thereafter, the petitioner preferred an appeal
Page No.# 5/11
dated 22.09.2023, before the Director General of Police, Assam, which was
subsequently rejected by the Inspector General of Police, Western Range,
Assam, Bongaigaon, vide order bearing R.O. No. 58 dated 29.02.2024.
9.
Mr. S. P. Das, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that the impugned
order of dismissal is vitiated by serious procedural irregularities and violation of
the principles of natural justice, as the petitioner was neither given notice of the
de-novo enquiry nor afforded an opportunity to participate therein and crossexamine the departmental witnesses. He submits that the report of the earlier
enquiry was also not furnished to the petitioner, thereby depriving him of an
opportunity to point out the deficiencies, if any, in the earlier proceedings and to
effectively defend himself in the subsequent proceeding.
10. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that apart from the aforesaid
infirmities, before imposition of the major penalty of dismissal, the enquiry
report on the basis of which the Disciplinary Authority proceeded to pass the
impugned order was not furnished to the petitioner, nor was he afforded an
opportunity to submit his representation against the findings recorded therein,
which is in violation of Article 311 of the Constitution of India and the procedure
prescribed under Rule 66 of the Assam Police Manual, Part-II. In support of his
submission, learned counsel relies upon the decision of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in Managing Director, ECIL, Hyderabad & Ors. Vs. B. Karunakar &
Ors., reported in (1993) 4 SCC 727, to contend that furnishing the enquiry
report to the delinquent employee is an essential component of a reasonable
opportunity of defence and the principle of natural justice and that the
employee must be afforded an opportunity to make a representation against the
findings recorded therein before the disciplinary authority arrives at its
conclusion.
Page No.# 6/11
11.
Mr. Das, learned counsel, further submits that the petitioner has been
subjected to discriminatory and disproportionate treatment vis-à-vis the coaccused, Md. Samir Jalal, who was proceeded against in connection with the
same occurrence and was imposed the penalty of stoppage of two annual
increments with cumulative effect by order dated 15.05.2023. In this regard,
learned counsel for the petitioner relies upon the decision of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in Rajendra Yadav Vs. State of Madhya Pradesh & Ors.,
reported in (2013) 3 SCC 73, to project that the doctrine of equality applies
even amongst persons found guilty of the same misconduct and the parity in
punishment amongst co-delinquents similarly placed is required to be
maintained.
12. He submits that despite the criminal case arising out of the same FIR still
being pending and the petitioner having consistently denied his involvement in
the alleged occurrence, the Department proceeded to impose the extreme
penalty of dismissal without awaiting the outcome of the criminal case.
Therefore, he submits that having regard to the aforesaid circumstances and the
failure of the appellate authority to properly consider the procedural infirmities
raised in the appeal, the impugned order of dismissal dated 03.07.2023 and the
appellate order dated 29.02.2024 warrant interference by this Court.
13. On the other hand, Mr. T. C. Chutia, learned Senior Counsel for the State
respondents, submits that the departmental proceedings have been conducted
in accordance with the prescribed procedure and sufficient opportunity was
afforded to the petitioner to defend himself. He submits that no de-novo enquiry
was initiated against the petitioner; rather, the same departmental proceeding
was continued by the subsequent Enquiry Officer, with the earlier findings,
statement of allegations and list of witnesses being retained.
Page No.# 7/11
14. Learned Senior Counsel further submits that the materials collected during
the investigation disclosed sufficient evidence of the petitioner’s involvement in
the alleged offence and the complainant had identified the petitioner at the
place of occurrence. He submits that considering the petitioner’s position as a
member of the police force and the serious nature of the misconduct alleged
against him, the Disciplinary Authority, upon consideration of the findings of the
departmental proceedings, rightly imposed the penalty of dismissal from service.
15. As regards the petitioner’s reliance on the pendency of the criminal case,
learned Senior Counsel submits that the criminal proceeding and the
departmental
proceeding
operate
in
distinct
fields
and
may
proceed
simultaneously. He submits that the allegation of discriminatory treatment is not
sustainable, as another co-delinquent, UBC/92 Ashraful Alom, was also imposed
the major penalty of dismissal from service.
16. Learned Senior Counsel further submits that although no separate notice
was formally issued to the petitioner before passing the order of dismissal, the
petitioner had been afforded sufficient opportunity to defend himself during the
departmental proceeding. He submits that the enquiry was conducted with due
care and diligence and there was no violation of Articles 14 and 311 of the
Constitution of India or the provisions of the Assam Police Act, 2007 and the
Assam Police Manual, Part-II. Therefore, he submits that the impugned order of
dismissal dated 03.07.2023 and the appellate order dated 29.02.2024 do not
warrant interference by this Court.
17.
Mr. S. P. Das, learned counsel for the petitioner, while rejoining his
submissions, submits that the respondents have failed to negate the petitioner’s
specific grievance that no notice of the de-novo enquiry was served upon him
and he was denied the opportunity to cross-examine the departmental
Page No.# 8/11
witnesses. He submits that the respondents have also admitted that neither the
enquiry report nor the second show-cause notice was furnished to the petitioner
before imposition of the major penalty of dismissal, in violation of the prescribed
procedure and the principle of natural justice. The respondents have sought to
justify the punishment by referring to the penalty imposed upon another codelinquent, Ashraful Alom, while failing to explain the substantially lesser
punishment imposed upon the co-accused, Md. Samir Jalal, arising out of the
same occurrence and departmental proceedings. Therefore, he submits that the
aforesaid procedural infirmities, coupled with the disparity in punishment,
render the impugned orders unsustainable in law.
18. Due consideration has been extended to the rival submissions of learned
counsel for the parties and also perused the record.
19.
From the pleadings and the rival submissions, it emerges that the
petitioner, while serving as a Constable (AB) in the Assam Police, was proceeded
against departmentally in connection with the allegations arising out of Agia P.S.
Case No. 17/2017. The petitioner was initially subjected to a departmental
enquiry, which was thereafter followed by a further enquiry pursuant to the
order dated 23.08.2018. The petitioner contends that he was not served with
any notice or afforded due opportunity in the subsequent enquiry and the
enquiry report was never furnished to him before the Disciplinary Authority
proceeded to impose the major penalty of dismissal from service.
20.
The respondents, on the other hand, contend that the departmental
proceedings have been duly conducted and the petitioner was afforded
adequate opportunity to defend himself. According to the respondents, there
was no de-novo enquiry, but only continuation of the departmental proceedings
by the subsequent Enquiry Officer. However, the respondents do not dispute
Page No.# 9/11
that the petitioner was not furnished with the enquiry report before the order of
dismissal dated 03.07.2023 was passed.
21.
In the aforesaid backdrop, the issue which arises for consideration is
whether the order of dismissal can be sustained when the enquiry report was
not furnished to the petitioner before the Disciplinary Authority proceeded to
take the final decision.
22.
The law relating to furnishing of the enquiry report to the delinquent
employee before the Disciplinary Authority takes a final decision is no longer res
integra. In B. Karunakar (supra), as relied by the learned counsel for the
petitioner, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held that furnishing of the enquiry
report to the delinquent employee, where the Enquiry Officer is different from
the Disciplinary Authority, forms part of the reasonable opportunity of defence
and the principle of natural justice. The delinquent employee is required to be
afforded an opportunity to submit his representation against the findings
recorded in the enquiry report before the Disciplinary Authority takes its final
decision.
23.
In the present case, it is not in dispute that the enquiry report was not
furnished to the petitioner before the Disciplinary Authority proceeded to pass
the order dated 03.07.2023 dismissing him from service. Therefore, it appears
that the petitioner was denied an opportunity to submit his representation
against the findings recorded by the Enquiry Officer before the Disciplinary
Authority took the final decision, which constitutes violation of the principle of
natural justice and vitiates the decision-making process culminating in the order
of dismissal.
24. In view of above, this Court does not deem it necessary to examine the
Page No.# 10/11
other contentions raised by the petitioner, including the question as to whether
the subsequent enquiry was in the nature of a de-novo enquiry or a
continuation of the earlier proceedings, the alleged disparity in punishment
amongst the co-delinquents, or the effect of the pendency of the criminal
proceeding. This Court also does not deem it appropriate to enter into the
merits of the charges levelled against the petitioner. Accordingly, in view of the
aforesaid procedural infirmity, this Court is of the considered view that the order
dated 03.07.2023, whereby the petitioner has been dismissed from service, as
well as the appellate order dated 29.02.2024, cannot be sustained in law.
25. Consequently, the order dated 03.07.2023, passed by the Superintendent
of Police, South Salmara, Mankachar District, whereby the petitioner has been
dismissed from service, as well as the appellate order dated 29.02.2024, passed
by the Inspector General of Police, Western Range, Bongaigaon, Assam, are
hereby set aside and quashed.
26. The respondent authorities are directed to reinstate the petitioner in service
forthwith. However, the respondent authorities shall be at liberty to proceed
with the departmental proceedings in accordance with law from the stage of
furnishing the enquiry report to the petitioner. Upon furnishing the enquiry
report, the petitioner shall be afforded reasonable opportunity to submit his
representation thereon, whereafter the competent authority shall proceed to
take decision in accordance with law.
27.
It is made clear that this Court has not expressed any opinion on the
merits of the charges levelled against the petitioner. The respondent authorities
shall be at liberty to proceed with the departmental proceedings in accordance
with law from the stage indicated hereinabove and take a fresh decision
uninfluenced by any observation made in this judgment touching upon the
Page No.# 11/11
merits of the charges.
28.
The question of consequential service and monetary benefits shall be
considered by the competent authority in accordance with the applicable rules
and upon conclusion of the departmental proceedings.
29.
With the aforesaid observations and directions, writ petition stands
disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review