Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
*
IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI
Judgment Reserved on: 11.02.2026
Judgment pronounced on: 17.02.2026
%
+
CRL.A. 398/2016
MD. RIZAUDDIN @ PINTU
.....Appellant
Through: Mr. S.K. Santoshi and Mr. C.D. Rai,
Advocates.
versus
THE STATE (GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI)
Through:
.....Respondent
Mr. Utkarsh, APP for the State.
JUDGMENT
CHANDRASEKHARAN SUDHA, J.
1. In this appeal filed under Section 374(2) Cr.P.C., the
sole accused in Sessions Case No.95/2012 on the file of the
Special Judge (NDPS-02), Central District, Tis Hazari Courts,
Delhi, challenges the judgement dated 06.02.2016 and order on
sentence dated 12.02.2016, as per which he has beenconvicted and
sentenced for the offence punishable under Section 21(c) of the
Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 (the NDPS
Act).
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
2. The prosecution case is that on 24.07.2012at 12:45
P.M., the accused was found in possession of 275 grams of heroin
in front of Bishnoi Dharamshala, Bela Road, Delhi. Hence, as per
the chargesheet/final report dated 02.09.2012, the accused is
alleged to have committed the offence punishable under Section 21
of the NDPS Act.
3. On appearance of the accused before the trial court,
copies of all the prosecution documents were supplied to him in
compliance with Section 207 Cr.P.C. On 12.12.2012, Charge
under Section 21 of the NDPS Act was framed against the accused,
which was read over and explained to the accused, to which he
pleaded not guilty.
4. In order to prove its case, the prosecution examined
PWs. 1 to 9 and marked Exhibits PW1/A-C, PW1/H, PW2/A-E,
PW3/A-C, PW4/A, PW6/A-F, PW8/A-C, PW9/Z and PA. Nodal
officers from Cellular companies, namely, CWs. 1 to 4 were
examined as Court Witnesses.
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
5. After the close of the prosecution evidence, the accused
was questioned under Section 313(1)(b) Cr.P.C. with regard to the
incriminating circumstances appearing against him in the
prosecution evidence. The accused denied all those circumstances
and maintained his innocence. He stated that he had been falsely
implicated. According to him, nothing was recovered from his
possession and that all the proceedings were conducted at the
police station where his signatures were forcibly taken on blank or
semi-printed papers. On 24.07.2012, PW2 Om Prakash, Head
Constable, called him to Shastri Park at about 12:00 to 12:30 P.M.
When he reached there, PW7 Kheta Ram, Constable and PW6
Mukesh, Head Constable came. After about 2 to 3 minutes, PW8
Sunil Jain, Sub-Inspector, arrived in his car and told him that "tu
mere aadmi namely Rehmat ko fasana chahta he , vo mera khas
aadmi he, ab me tujhe maja chakhata hu". Thereafter, he was
taken to the police station. The police switched off his mobile
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
(9711801221) and implicated him in this false case. The police
also called his wife and demanded money.
6. After questioning the accused persons under Section
313(1)(b) Cr.P.C, compliance of Section 232 Cr.P.C was
mandatory. In the case on hand, no hearing as contemplated under
Section 232 Cr.P.C is seen made by the trial court. However, noncompliance of the said provision does not, ipso facto vitiate the
proceedings, unless omission to comply with the same is shown to
have resulted in serious and substantial prejudice to the accused
(See Moidu K. vs. State of Kerala, 2009 (3)KHC 89 : 2009 SCC
OnLine Ker 2888). Here, the accused persons have no case that
non-compliance of Section 232 Cr.P.C has caused any prejudice to
him.
7. In support of the defence case, DWs. 1 to 7 were
examined on behalf of the accused and marked Exhibits DW4/AD, DW6/A-B, DW7/A-C and Mark A were marked.
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
8. The trial court, after hearing both sides and on a
consideration of the oral and documentary evidence, vide
judgment dated 06.02.2016 convicted the accused for the offence
punishable under Section 21(c) of the NDPC Act and vide order on
sentence dated 12.02.2016 sentenced him to undergo rigorous
imprisonment for 15 years and to pay a fine of ₹1,50,000/-, and in
default of payment of fine, to undergo simple imprisonment for
one year. Aggrieved, the accused has preferred this appeal.
9. The
learned
counsel
for
the
appellant/accused
submitted that although the prosecution alleged that the raiding
party remained at the spot for nearly ten hours and that
independent witnesses were available and many public offices
were situated nearby, no such witness has been examined in the
case. It was submitted that no written notice was served upon any
person(s) who is/are alleged to have refused to join, nor were their
particulars recorded, thereby casting serious doubt on the
genuineness of the alleged recovery.
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
9.1. It was further submitted by the learned counsel that the
prosecution had failed to place on record the log book of the
government vehicle allegedly used by the raiding party. The driver
of the said vehicle, was not examined, and such non-examination
deprived the case of material corroboration regarding the
movement of the raiding party and transportation of the accused
and case property.
9.2. It was also submitted that no photography or
videography of the alleged recovery was conducted despite
sufficient time and opportunity. The learned counsel argued that,
particularly in a case involving commercial quantity, the absence
of any electronic record of the search and seizure proceedings
assumes significance and renders the prosecution version doubtful.
9.3. The learned counsel further submitted that none of the
members of the raiding party was carrying a mobile phone, as
admitted in evidence. The learned counsel contended that such a
claim was inherently improbable in present-day circumstances and
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
cast doubt on the prosecution version regarding communication
with superior officers and compliance with statutory requirements.
9.4. It was also submitted that the second investigating
officer (IO), Sub-Inspector (SI) Devender Singh, who is alleged to
have prepared the site plan, recorded statements of witnesses, sent
the samples to the FSL, conducted further investigation and
submittedthe charge sheet, was never examined. The learned
counsel contended that non-examination of this material witness
caused serious prejudice to the appellant and left gaps in the chain
of investigation.
9.5. It was lastly submitted by the learned counsel that there
had been non-compliance with Sections 52 and 53 of the NDPS
Act. The learned counsel contended that the seized contraband and
the accused were required to be produced before the Station House
Officer without unnecessary delay; however, there is no cogent
evidence to show that the same were produced before PW4, the
SHO, in strict adherence to the statutory mandate. The learned
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
counsel further submitted that the appellant had lodged a
complaint against PW7 and PW8 before the Anti-Corruption
Branch in February 2013, which, according to him, probabilised
the defence plea of false implication.
10. Per contra, the learned Additional Public Prosecutor
submitted that the defence plea of false implication is wholly
unsubstantiated. Referring to the cross-examination of PW8, it was
contended that the very suggestion put by the defence presupposed
the presence and apprehension of the accused at the spot along
with contraband, thereby undermining the stand of total
fabrication.
10.1. It was further submitted that the non-joining of
independent witnesses was not fatal to the prosecution case.
Placing reliance upon the judgment of the Apex Court in Surinder
Kumar v. State of Punjab, (2020) 2 SCC 563, the learned
prosecutor contended that it is common knowledge that members
of the public are reluctant to associate themselves with police
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
proceedings and that the mere absence of independent witnesses
does not render the testimony of official witnesses unreliable. It
was argued that in the present case the police officials consistently
deposed that efforts were made to bring in independent witnesses,
but they declined.
10.2. The learned prosecutor also contended that there
was due compliance with Section 52(3) of the NDPS Act. It was
submitted that the seized articles as well as the accused were
produced before PW4, the SHO. Reference was made to the
testimony of PW9, who deposed that ASI Devender Singh
produced the accused before him at about 12:30 midnight and that
he made enquiries. It was thus argued that the statutory
requirement stood duly satisfied. With regard to Section 53 of the
NDPS Act, the learned prosecutor submitted that the said provision
applies to officers of departments such as Customs, DRI or NCB,
who are specially empowered with the powers of an officer-incharge of a police station. It was contended that in the present case
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
the investigation was conducted by regular police officials of a
police station where the SHO was available, and therefore the
argument of violation of Section 53 was misconceived.
10.3. It was further submitted that the chain of custody
of the seized contraband remained intact and was duly established.
The learned prosecutor pointed out that no serious challenge was
raised in cross-examination regarding the handling or transmission
of the sample. Reliance was placed upon Exhibit PZ FSL report ,
which confirmed that the seized substance was in fact heroin,
thereby corroborating the prosecution case. The learned prosecutor
also referred to Exhibit PW6/E personal search memo to submit
that notice under Section 50 of the NDPS Act had been duly
served upon the accused prior to search. On search, two articles,
were seized, one is a currency note of the denomination of ₹500/and Exhibit PW6/A notice issued under Section 50 of the NDPS
Act. Further, the accused declined the offer to be searched before a
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
Gazetted Officer or Magistrate, after which the search was
lawfully conducted.
10.4. In response to the argument concerning mobile
phones, the summoning of the accused over phone, the demand for
the money from the wife of the accused, etc., the learned
prosecutor submitted that once the defence sets up a specific plea
that the accused was called to the spot by the police and that a
demand of money was made, it was incumbent upon the defence to
substantiate the same by producing call detail records or
examining the service providers concerned. It was argued that no
such evidence was led and that the Court can adjudicate only on
the basis of evidence brought on record, not on unproved
allegations.
11. Heard both sides and perused the records.
12. The only point that arises for consideration in this
appeal is whether there is any infirmity in the impugned
judgement, calling for an interference by this Court
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
13. Before proceeding further, I shall briefly refer to the
evidence led in this case. PW8, Sub-Inspector,Narcotics Cell,
Shakarpur deposed that on 24.07.2012, at about 11:00 A.M., he
received information that a person named Pintu, resident of Narela,
along with his associate, namely, Ibrahim, was engaged in largescale supply of heroin in Delhi, procuring the contraband from U.P
and that on the saidday between 12:30 P.M. and 1:00 P.M., the
accused would come in front of Bishnoi Dharamshala, Bela Road,
Delhi, to deliver heroin to a lady, namely, Anita. After making
preliminary inquiries and satisfying himself about the credibility of
the information, heproduced the informer before PW9, Inspectorin-Charge, Narcotics Cell, who inturn informed the ACP Bir Singh
over phone, whereupon directions were received from the ACP to
conduct a raid. He thenreduced the secret information into writing
vide DD No. 16 at about 11:30 A.M., i.e., Exhibit PW2/A, and the
samewas produced before PW9 in compliance with Section 42 of
the NDPS Act. Thereafter, he constituted a raiding party consisting
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
of himself, PW6, PW7 and Rani Reddy, Woman Head
Constable.The team along with the secret informer left his office at
about 11:45 A.M. vide Exhibit PW8/A DD No. 17 Departure Entry
in Government Vehicle No. DL-1CM-4228, driven by a constable.
According to PW8, he requested several persons, both enroute and
at the spot, to join the raiding team. However, none agreed and
they left without disclosing their particulars. The vehicle was
parked approximately 50 meters away, and the team took positions
near the gate of the Dharamshala.
13.1. At about 12:40 P.M., a person wearing black jeans and
a white striped shirt, carrying a black polythene bag in his left
hand, came on foot, The person was identified as Pintu (the
accused) by the secret informer, who thereafter left the spot. The
accused then waited there for some time. After about 3 to 4
minutes by about 12:45P.M., when the accused was about to go
back, he apprehended the accused. He identified himself and team
and on questioning, the accused revealed his name and address. He
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
then appraised the accused of his right to be searched in the
presence of a Gazetted Officer or a Magistrate. He also informed
the accused that he could take the search of the police officials and
the government vehicle before his own search was conducted. The
meaning of “Gazetted Officer” and “Magistrate” was also
explained to him. He thenprepared Exhibit PW6/Anotice under
Section 50 of the NDPS Act and served its carbon copy on the
accused. As the accused was illiterate, the contents were read over
to him. The accused declined to avail his legal rights. Thereply of
the accused, recorded at his dictation on the said notice, is Exhibit
PW6/B, bearing the signatures of PW8 and the accused. PW8
further deposed that he again requested 7 to 8 persons who had
gatheredat the spot to join the proceedings.But none agreed.
Thereafter, he conducted a search of the accused and recovered a
black polythene bag from the left hand of the latter, which
contained a transparent polythene, tied with a rubber band and
filled with soil coloured powder. The substance was tested with a
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
field testing kit. The same tested positive for heroin. The total
weight of the recovered substance was found to be 275 grams,
which included the weight of the transparent polythene.
13.2. Two samples of 5 grams each were drawn from the
substance. Each sample was placed in separate transparent
polyethene, tied with rubber bands, converted into cloth parcels
and marked A and B. The remaining 265 grams was kept in the
same transparent polythene, then placed inside the black
polythene, converted into a cloth parcel and marked C. He
thenfilled up the FSL Form and affixed his seal “3C PS NB
DELHI” on parcels A, B and C, as well as on the FSL Form as
sample seal. The contraband along with the FSL Form was seized
vide Exhibit PW6/C Seizure Memo. He then prepared Exhibit
PW8/B Tehrir and handed over the same to PW7, along with the
sealed parcels, FSL Form and carbon copy of the seizure memo,
for registration of the crime and deposit with the SHO.
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
13.3. At about 8:00 P.M., the second Investigating Officer
(IO), namely, ASI Devinder Singh reached the spot. He appraised
the ASI regarding the facts and handed over the documents and the
accused. The site plan was prepared by the ASI at his instance,
i.e., Exhibit PW8/C site plan. ASI then interrogated the accused
and arrested himvide Exhibit PW6/D arrest memo. ASI conducted
the personal search of the accused vide Exhibit PW6/E Personal
Search Memo, On a personal search, a carbon copy of the notice
under Section 50 NDPS Act and ₹500/- were recovered.They left
the spot along with the accused by about 10:15P.M. and reached
the Crime Branch police station at about 11:15P.M., where the
personal search articles of the accused were deposited. Thereafter,
they left the said police station and went to the Narcotics Cell,
Shakarpur, where they reached byabout 12:30A.M. The accused
was produced before PW9 Inspector by ASI Devender Singh. He
then prepared a special report under Section 57 of the NDPS Act
regarding recovery and seizure vide Exhibit PW2/B Special Report
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
and submitted it to PW9 for forwarding it to the Senior Officer.
The special report regarding arrest, prepared by the ASI Devender
Singh, is Exhibit PW2/C. The FSL report was marked as Exhibit
PW9/Z. PW8 identified the material objects in Court and there was
marked as Exhibits P1to P3.
13.4. PW8, in his cross-examination, denied the suggestion
that in the year 2014, when the accused was released on interim
bail, he along with, PW7 and PW2 had threatened the accused.
According to PW8, Crime no. 49/2014 registered under Section 7
of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 is a false case. He
further deposed that the accused is aconvict in Crime No. 80/2009
under Section 21 of the NDPS Act and due to the conviction in the
said case, the accused had lodged a false case against him.PW8
admitted that there was a government office near the Narcotics
Cell, Shakarpur, but he did not take any efforts to call anyone from
the office to join the raiding party due to shortage of time. He also
did not inform the local police station regarding the raid. PW8
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
admitted that a trauma hospital, namely, Sushruta Trauma Centre
and an office of the Anti-Corruption Branch are situated near the
scene of occurrence. But, he did not send any of team members to
call any officer from the Anti-Corruption Branch as accused did
not wish to be searched in presence of a Gazetted Officer. PW8
admitted that the date of incident was a working day.PW8 further
admitted that the proceedings were not video graphed or
photographed as there was no provision of still camera or video
camera at the Narcotics Cell.
13.5. PW8 denied the suggestion that after the arrest of the
accused, he had gone to the house of the latter and taken ₹17,500/and keys of EECO Vehicle, Maruti car, from the latter’s house.
PW8 further denied the suggestion that he had called DW2, the
wife of the accused on the same day from the crime scene or that
he had asked for any money. He deposed that personal search of
the accused was taken in front of Dharamshala outside the official
vehicle and during the proceedings, there was no traffic jam and no
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
notice had been given to any passerby who refused to join the
investigation. PW8 further denied the suggestion that on the day of
occurrence, he had called the accused to Shastri Park near Metro
Station or that there is a CDR showing hislocation at Shastri Park.
He further denied the suggestion that he had pressurised the
accused to become an informer. PW8 denied having any
knowledge regarding telephonic calls made by PW2 to the accused
from June till the date of occurrence.
14. PW1, the then Duty Officer, Crime BranchPolice
Station, deposed that on 24.07.2012, he received Exhibit PW8/B
Tehrir from PW7, on the basis of which he got registeredthe crime.
PW1, in cross-examination, deposed after registering the crime,
further investigation was marked to ASI Devender on oral
instructions of PW8 via telephone. He denied the suggestion that
the entire documents pertaining to the FIR were false, fabricated
and manipulated. PW1 denied the suggestion that FIR was ante-
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
timed or ante-dated or prepared at the instance of higher police
officials.
15. PW2, the then Reader to ACP, Narcotics and Crime
Prevention, Shakarpur, Delhi, deposed that on 24.07.2012 Exhibit
PW2/A DD No. 16 in original was received in the ACP office. He
made entry of the same at Exhibit PW2/D Correspondence Diary
at Serial No. 1733. On 25.07.2012, a report under Section 57 of the
NDPS Act regarding seizure of contraband was received in the
ACP office. He made entry of the same in the records, i.e., Exhibit
PW2/E Correspondence Diary at Serial No. 1781. On the same
day, Exhibit PW2/B special report regarding arrest of the accused
was received in the office of the ACP. He made entry of the
samevide Exhibit PW2/E Correspondence Diary at Serial No.
1782. PW2, in cross-examination, denied the suggestion that the
entries were fabricated or entered later on the instructions of higher
officials. He denied the suggestion that he was deposing falsely at
the instance of higher officials.
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
16. PW3, the then MHC(M), Crime Branch,Police Station,
deposed that on 24.07.2012, PW4 had handed over three pullandas
marked A, B and C, along with the FSL Form duly sealed with the
seal of 3CPSNB Delhi and CRM, and that the carbon copy of
seizure memo isExhibit PW6/C. He made the corresponding entry
in Register No. 19 videExhibit PW3/A at Serial No. 1599. On the
same day, ASI Devender produced the personal search articles of
the accused and the carbon copy of notice under Section 50 of the
NDPS Act, whereupon hemade an entry in Register No. 19 at the
same serial number. On 30.07.2012, on the directions of PW4, one
cloth parcel Mark A was sent to FSL Rohini through PW5 vide RC
No. 474/21/12, the photocopy of which is Exhibit PW3/B. In
cross-examination, PW3 denied the suggestion that he had given a
false statement or manipulated the malkhana entries.
17. PW4, the then SHO, Crime BranchPolice Station,
deposed that on 24.07.2012 at about 5:05 p.m., PW7 of Narcotics
Cell handed over to him three pullandas marked A, B and C, all
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
sealed with the seal of 3CPS NB Delhi, along with the FSL Form
and carbon copy of seizure memo, the FSL Form also bearing the
same seal. He affixed his seal “CRM” on all three pullandas and
the FSL Form, inquired from the Duty Officer about FIR No.
200/12, mentioned the FIR number on the pullandas and FSL
Form, and signed the pullandas, FSL Form and carbon copy of
seizure memo. At about 5:20 p.m., he called PW3, the then
MHC(M), with Register No. 19, deposited the case property and
documents in the malkhana, whereupon PW3 made the entry and
he signed the relevant column. He recorded DD No. 22 (Exhibit
PW4/A) at about 5:40 p.m. regarding the deposit. At about 11:30
p.m., ASI Devender Singh and HC Charan Singh came to his
office, and between 11:30 p.m. and 11:45 p.m., he recorded the
statement in the handwriting of HC Charan Singh at the dictation
of ASI Devender Singh. On 30.07.2012, he orally instructed PW3
to send the sample pullanda along with the FSL Form and
documents to FSL Rohini through PW5.
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
17.1. PW4, in cross-examination, admitted that the pullandas
did not bear the signatures of the accused, nor did he inquire from
the IO regarding the absence of such signatures. He denied the
suggestions that he was deposing falsely or that his statement was
ante-timed or ante-dated.
18. PW5 deposed that on 30.07.2012, as per the directions
of PW4, received over phone, he took sealed pullanda Mark A
with FSL Form and documents to FSL Rohini, deposited it.
19. PW6 and PW7, Head Constables, also members of the
raid party supported the version of PW8.
20. PW9, Inspector, Narcotics Cell, Shakarpur, Delhi,
deposed that on 24.07.2012 at about 11:15 AM, PW8 along with
the informer came to his office and conveyed the information
received.On his directions, PW8 constituted a raiding team, and
left for the place by about 11:45A.M. On 25.07.2012, by about
12:30A.M., ASI Devender Singh came to his office along with the
accused. On the same day, PW8 and ASI Devender Singh
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
produced report under Section 57 of the NDPS Act, which he
forwarded to ACP, N&CP.PW9, in his cross-examination,
deposedthat the case property had not beenproduced before him
and therefore he did not sign them. He admitted that no
government official was called from nearby offices as a witness
and that no attendance register is maintained at the Narcotic Cell,
Shakarpur.
21. On behalf of the accused, DWs. 1 to 7 were examined.
The accused offered himself as a witness and hence was examined
as DW5. He deposed that on 23.07.2012 and 24.07.2012, PW2,
called from his mobile 99990242969 to his mobile no.
9711801221, which was in the name of his sister-in-law Noor
Jahan. PW2 called him on 23.07.2012 and asked him to meet the
former. On 24.07.2012, PW2 again called him to meet the former
at Shastri Park, Metro Station, trans Yamuna. So, on 24.07.2012,
he left his house by about 11:00 A.M. on his motorcycle (No. DL1S-V-1586), reached Shastri Park, where he parked the motorcycle
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
near his friend Kaushal’s shop and handed over the keys to the
former. On the said day, he received 4 to 5 calls from PW2. He
reached Shastri Park Metro Station byabout 12:30P.M. There he
met PW2, PW6 and PW7, all working in Narcotics Branch,
Shakarpur. After sometime, PW8 arrived in his personal vehicle
and directed the constables to make him sit inside the car.
According to DW5, PW8 took his mobile phone and removed its
battery. This exercise was done on the mobile phones of PW8,
PW2, PW6 and PW7 also. PW8 then questioned him as to why he
had implicated, one Rahmat, said to be an informer of the former
in an NDPS case. Thereafter, he was taken to the Crime Branch
office at Shakarpur, beaten and threatened with false implication in
a NDPS case of commercial quantity. He further deposed that
PW8 threatened to implicate his wife and demanded money. On
25.07.2012 his wife paid ₹1,30,000/- to PW8 and PW7. On the
same day, he was produced before the Court and police custody
was obtained. They again beat him up and called his wife and
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
demanded money. His wife arranged ₹70,000/- and paid them.
Thereafter, during the period of police custody on 26.07.2012, they
went to his home, took the keys of his car and ₹17,500/-.
DW5maintained that nothing had beenrecovered from his
possession and that he was falsely implicated due to some
difference of opinion between PW8 and SI Bhagwan Singh.
21.1. DW5, in his cross-examination, denied the suggestion
that in Crime No. 80/09, Crime Branch, PS Malviya Nagar, 100
grams of heroin had been recovered from his possession. He
further denied that he had pleaded guilty in the saidcase andthat he
had been sentenced to the period already undergone by
him.However, he admitted that, apart from the present case, he had
been involved in three other cases, namely, Crime No. 257/04
under Section 25 Arms Act, Turkman Gate, Police Station; Crime
No. 50/2001 under Sections 356, 379, and 411 IPC Civil Lines
Police Station, and Crime No. 80/2009 of Crime Branch, Police
Station. He deposed that on 24.07.2012 he had gone on a
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
motorcycle bearing registration No. DL-1S-V-1586. The distance
between the place where he parked his motorcycle and place where
he had gone is one kilometre. He reached the place by foot within
30 minutes. DW5 could not assign any specific reason as to why,
despite having the motorcycle, he travelled about one kilometre on
foot to the place of occurrence. DW5 admitted that he did not
make any complaint to any authority against the acts of PW8 and
the other police constables. According to DW5, the police officials
had threatened him not to lodge any complaint. DW5 expressed
inability to state the registration number, make or colour of the
vehicle in which PW8 came to the sceneon 24.07.2012. DW5
deposed that he had made a complaint in Court in the year 2012
itself regarding the taking away of his Maruti EECO vehicle and
₹17,500/- by the police officials.
22. DW1 deposed that on 24.07.2012 between 12:00–
12:30 P.M., the accused came to his shop at A-27, Shastri Park.
The accused parked his motorcycle in front of the shop, handed
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
over the keys to him and stated that he was going to Shastri Park
Metro Station to meet some police officials. Thereafter, the
accused did not return. According to DW1, when he tried calling
the accused, his mobile phone was switched off. On the next day,
the brother of the accused came and informed him that the accused
had been apprehended by the police. He then handed over the
motorcycle keys to the brother of the accused.
22.1. DW1, in cross-examination, admitted that he did not
lodge any complaint regarding the incident, DW1 further deposed
that he could not tell the registration number of the motorcycle
parked by the accused in front of his shop.
23. DW2, the wife of the accused, deposed that on
24.07.2012 her husband left the house byabout 10:45A.M. to
11:00A.M., telling herthat he was going to meet PW2 at Shastri
Park. Thereafter, at about 2:30 P.M. she called him from her
mobile, but found his phone switched off. At about 7:00 P.M. to
8:00 P.M. she received a call from an unknown number, the caller
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
claiming to be a police official, who demanded ₹6 lakhs and
threatened that her husband would be falsely implicated in case of
non-payment. She was allowed to speak to her husband, who asked
her to arrange the amount. Thereafter, the police officials asked her
to visit the Shakarpur, Police Station, but she expressed her
inability to visit the police station during night hours. According to
DW2, on 25.07.2012, she arranged ₹1,30,000/- from her family
members and handed over the same to three police officials of
Shakarpur Police Station, whose names she does not know. PW2
further deposed that on the same day, after her husband was taken
intopolice custody, she received another call from some police
official, during which she heard the voice of her husband being
beaten by the police.The police officials demanded a further sum
of ₹2 to 3 lakhs, pursuant to which she arranged ₹70,000/- on
interest and handed over the amount to 3 to 4 police officials,
whose names she is unaware of. She also alleged that on
26.07.2012, 10 to 11 police officials came to her residence and
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
took ₹17,500/- kept in almirah along with the keys and documents
of their EECO vehicle.
23.1. DW2, in her cross-examination, deposed her mobile
number to be 9899903819 and the mobile number of her husband
to be 9711801221. She further deposed that at about7:00 P.M. to
8:00P.M., police officials called her number from some other
mobile number and not from the mobile of her husband. She does
not remember the number of the mobile but the last two digits
were “15”. She admitted that she did not lodge any complaint with
any authority regarding the alleged demand of ₹6 lakhs, the
handing over of ₹1,30,000/- or ₹70,000/-, or the alleged taking of
₹17,500/- and vehicle documents. Her husband was produced
before Court No. 221, Tis Hazari Courts after 11:00A.M. She
along with her brother and mother were present. But she did not
inform the Court on 25.07.2012 about the illegal demands, as she
had been threatened by the police with false implication. PW2
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
further deposed that at about2:00 to 2:30 P.M., she again received
a call from the same mobile number having last two digits “15”.
24. DW3, Nodal Officer, Idea Cellular Company, was
summoned to produce the CDR and location chart of mobile
number 8585979838 for the relevant period. DW3 deposed in his
examination that the said mobile number does not pertain to Idea
Cellular, and he deposed that, from the first four digits of the
number, it appears that the said mobile number belongs to Airtel,
Kolkata circle.
25. DW4, Alternate Nodal Officer, Vodafone, deposed that
he had brought the original CAF of mobile no. 9711801221
registered in the name of Noor Jahan w/o Shoukat Ali, along with
a photocopy of her election I-card, the copy of which is Exhibit
DW4/A. He also produced the CDR of the said mobile for the
period 01.07.2012 to 31.07.2012, exhibited as Exhibit DW4/B,
along with a certificate under Section 65B of the Evidence Act,
1872. He further produced the Cell ID chart of Vodafone Delhi
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
Circle, running into 118 pages, exhibited as Exhibit PW4/D. As
per the CDR, there was no call at 12:40 P.M. on 24.07.2012; the
last call was at 12:32 P.M. for 26 seconds (outgoing), and at that
time the location reflected was Khasra No. 88, D-40, Shastri Park,
Delhi. DW4, in cross-examination, clarified that Khasra No. 88, D40, Shastri Park was the location of the tower and not the exact
location of the mobile number. He stated that a tower normally
covers an area of approximately 400–500 meters and that the
precise location of the mobile cannot be ascertained within that
radius.
26. DW6 Sh. Pradeep Singh, Alternate Nodal Officer,
Vodafone, deposed that he had brought the record pertaining to
mobile no. 7838829568, which was registered in the name of
Ratnesh Thakur. The attested copy of the CAF along with the
photocopy of the driving licence was exhibited as Exhibit DW6/A
(colly). As per the CAF and driving licence, the father’s name of
the subscriber was R.K. Thakur, resident of 39-G, Number 2, Sena
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
Sadan, Mandawali, Delhi. He further produced the CDR of the
said mobile for the period 01.07.2012 to 31.07.2012, exhibited as
Exhibit DW6/B, along with the certificate under Section 65B of
the Evidence Act, exhibited as Exhibit PW6/C. The Cell ID chart
was exhibited as Exhibit DW6/D. As per the CDR read with the
Cell ID chart, the location of the said mobile on 24.07.2012 at
12:33 P.M. was shown as Main Road, Kailash Nagar. In crossexamination, he stated that the Cell ID chart had been provided by
the networking team and that the data produced remained in the
control of the Nodal Officers. He was unable to state when the data
was last updated. He admitted that no separate certificate under
Section 65B of the Evidence Act was issued specifically for the
Cell ID chart. He further clarified that the location reflected in the
CDR read with the Cell ID chart indicates the location of the
mobile handset and not the person using it.
27. DW7, Nodal Officer, Idea Cellular Ltd., deposed that
he had brought the record pertaining to mobile no. 9990242969,
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
which was registered in the name of Pankaj Jain. The copy of the
CAF along with the photocopy of the driving licence of Pankaj
Jain was exhibited as Exhibit DW7/A. As per the CAF and driving
licence, the father’s name of the subscriber was O.P. Jain, resident
of Rajapur Village, Sector 9, Rohini, Delhi. He stated that he had
not brought the CDR from the system as the same was not
available being older than one year; however, he produced the Cell
ID chart, exhibited as Exhibit DW7/B. Upon being shown the
CDR already on record, he identified the same as pertaining to
mobile no. 9990242969 and bearing his signatures; the same was
exhibited as Exhibit DW7/C. As per the CDR, in respect of a call
between mobile no. 9990242969 and mobile no. 9711801221 on
24.07.2012 at about 12:25 P.M., the location of mobile no.
9990242969 was reflected as Noida. In cross-examination, he
stated that he does not personally maintain the CDR, though he
denied that the certificate under Section 65B of the Evidence Act
was not in accordance with law. He admitted that the particulars
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
mentioned in the original CAF had not been independently verified
by him. He denied the suggestion that the documents produced by
him were false or fabricated or that he was deposing falsely.
28. The appellant stands convicted for the offence
punishable under Section 21(c) of the NDPS Act. To sustain a
conviction under the said provision, the prosecution is required to
establish (i) recovery of a narcotic drug or psychotropic substance;
(ii) that such recovery was from the conscious possession of the
accused; and (iii) that the quantity involved constitutes commercial
quantity. Upon proof of possession, the statutory presumption
under Sections 35 and 54 of the NDPS Act operates, unless
rebutted by the accused. In the present case, the recovery alleged is
of 275 grams of heroin. Exhibit PW9/Z FSL report confirms that
the substance examined was diacetylmorphine. The quantity of
275 grams is undisputedly commercial quantity. The first and third
ingredients of the offence, therefore, stand established.
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
29. The crucial question that falls for determination is
whether the prosecution has proved that the said contraband was
recovered from the conscious possession of the appellant and
whether the mandatory procedural safeguards were complied with.
30. The testimony of PW8, detecting officer finds, material
corroboration from PW6 and PW7, who were also members of the
raiding party. The evidence of these witnesses is consistent on
material particulars, namely, the place and time of apprehension,
the manner of recovery, the quantity seized and the sealing
process. Nothing substantial has been brought out in crossexamination to discredit the core of the recovery. The notice under
Section 50 (Exhibit PW6/A) and the reply of the appellant (Exhibit
PW6/B) bear the signatures of the appellant. The appellant
declined the offer to be searched before a Gazetted Officer or
Magistrate. The evidence does not indicate that the notice was
fabricated or that the refusal was involuntary. Compliance of
Section 50 of the NDPS Act stands established.
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
31. As regards the custody of the case property, PW4 has
deposed that the sealed parcels were produced before him, that he
affixed his seal “CRM” on the parcels and the FSL form,
mentioned the FIR number and caused the same to be deposited in
the malkhana. PW3, the MHC(M), also produced Exhibit PW3/A
Register No.19, bearing the relevant entry regarding the same.
PW5 deposed with respect to the dispatch of the sample to FSL
Rohini and produced Exhibit PW3/B Road certificate. Exhibit PZ
FSL report records that the seals were intact and tallied with the
specimen seal. The chain of custody thus stands proved and there
is no material suggesting tampering.
32. The testimonyof PW8, PW6 and PW7 indicate that
attempts were made to associate independent witnesses both while
proceeding to the spot and after reaching there, though none
agreed to join the proceedings. The mere absence of independent
witnesses does not, in all circumstances, render the prosecution
case doubtful. As observed in Surinder Kumar(supra), the
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
testimony of a witness cannot be discarded merely on the ground
that he is an official witness; what is required is careful scrutiny of
such evidence to test its credibility. In the present case, the official
witnesses have been subjected to cross-examination at length and
nothing material has been elicited so as to discredit the core of the
recovery. Their version remains consistent on material particulars
and inspires confidence. In such circumstances, the absence of
independent witnesses, by itself, does not dent the prosecution
case.
33. The movement of the raiding party is reflected in
contemporaneous DD entries and has been uniformly spoken to by
the prosecution witnesses. The non-production of the vehicle log
book or non-examination of the driver does not create any material
inconsistency as to the place or timing of apprehension. No
contradiction of such nature has been demonstrated so as to render
the recovery doubtful.
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
34. It was further argued by the learned counsel for the
appellant/ accused that the second investigating officer, namely,
ASI Devender Singh, who prepared the site plan, recorded the
statement of some witnesses and had completed the further
investigation, had not been examined and hence, the same is fatal
to the prosecution case. The trial court in paragraph 31 of the
impugned judgment has referred to the reason why the said witness
could not be examined before the Court. The said witness was
reported to be laid up and hence, it was not possible for him to
appear before the Court. Therefore, the documents that were
prepared by him were proved through PW8, who was familiar with
his handwriting and signatures. The accused got ample opportunity
to cross-examine PW8 on these aspects also. The recovery,
seizure, sealing and deposit of the material objects have been duly
proved through the testimony of PW8, PW6, PW7, PW4 and PW3.
The chain of custody remained intact and no material contradiction
affecting the recovery has been demonstrated. No specific
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
prejudice has been shown to have caused to the appellant on
account of such non-examination of the aforesaid witness. That
being the position, the omission to examine the second
investigating officer, in the absence of any demonstrative prejudice
cannot be treated as fatal.
35. It was further argued that the version of PW8, the
detecting officer, that neither he nor the other members of his team
were in possession of mobile phones is quite unbelievable. It was
submitted that this stand has been taken deliberately by the
prosecution witnesses because had they revealed the same, the
documents would have shown their location which would have
disproved the prosecution case. To prevent such evidence coming
on record, PW8 and other witnesses have falsely deposed before
the Court that at the time of the alleged raid, they were not in
possession of any mobile phones and that the mobile phone of the
accused had also not been seized by them.
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
36. The burden is always on the prosecution to establish a
case against the accused beyond reasonable doubt. The accused
has the right to besilent and merely because he does not adduce
any evidence or takes an inconsistent stand, is no ground to draw
an adverse inference against him. The presumption contemplated
under Sections 35 and 54 of the NDPS Act would come into place
only when the prosecution establishes the foundational facts. (See
Gorakh Nath Prasad v. State of Bihar, (2018) 2 SCC 305and
Naresh Kumar v. State of H.P., (2017) 15 SCC 684).However, if
the accused takes up a specific defence, then the burden would be
on him to establish his defence version. But he need not establish
his defence version beyond reasonable doubt. It would be
sufficient for the accused to show a preponderance of probabilities.
(See Harbhajan Singh v. State of Punjab, AIR 1966 SC 97,
V.D. Jhingan v. State of U.P., AIR 1966 SC 1762 and Munshi
Ram v. Delhi Administration, AIR 1968 SC 702)
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
37. In the case on hand, I have already referred to in detail
the defence taken up by the appellant/ accused as well as the
evidence adduced by him in support of his version. DW3, DW4,
DW6 and DW7 had apparently been examined to prove the call
detail records of the officials involved in the raid, namely, PW2,
PW6, PW7 and PW8. However, the materials on record do not in
any way connect them to the prosecution witnesses. In fact, the
trial court in paragraph 44 of the impugned judgment referred to
the testimony of the court witnesses, namely, CW1 to CW4 which
witnesses were also examined to prove the CDR of the mobile
phones of the officials concerned. Though no reference was made
by the defence counsel to the testimony of the said witnesses, the
trial court has examined the evidence adduced by the said
witnesses also. The testimonyof the said witnesses orthe
documents produced by them, also does not in any way connect
them to the prosecution witnesses. Therefore, there is nothing to
substantiate the defence version from the materials on record
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
relating to the calls alleged to have been made by PW8 or the other
members of his team to the accused and his wife demanding
money or such other aspects that has been spoken to by the
accused and DW2 while they were examined before the Court.
38. Further, the accused in his statement under Section 313
(1)(b) Cr.P.C., as well as when he was examined before the Court
as DW5 has a case that pursuant to the repeated calls made by
PW2 on 24.07.2012 and 25.07.2012 asking him to be present at
Shastri Park, he had gone to the place, on his motorcycle. After he
reached Shastri Park, he parked his motorcycle near his friend
Kaushal’s shop. The keys of the motorcycle were handed over to
Kaushal and then he had proceeded to the place where he had been
asked to appear by the police officials. However, DW1, deposed
that the accused had come to his shop on 24.07.2012, parked his
vehicle in front of his shop, handed over the keys to him and had
proceeded to Shastri Park. DW1 is one Hira Bahadur Thapa, S/o
Lok Bahadur Thapa, R/o A-27, Shastri Park, Main Road, Delhi.
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
The accused neither in his Section 313 (Cr.P.C.) statement nor in
his testimony before the Court as DW5 has a case that hisfriend
Kaushal and DW1 are one and the same person.
39. Another argument that was advanced was that there is
violation of the provisions of Section 52(3) of the NDPS Act. As
per Section 52(3) of the NDPS Act, every person arrested and
article seized under Sub-section (2) of Sections 41, 42, 43 and 44
shall be forwarded without unnecessary delay to the Officer-inCharge of the nearest police station or to the officer empowered
under Section 53 of the NDPS Act. Here I again refer to testimony
of PW4, the then Station House Officer, Crime Branch Police
Station. He deposed that on 24.07.2012, at about 05:05 PM, PW7,
Narcotics Cell, handed over to him the material objects in the case
along with the documents prepared contemporaneously. He
summoned PW3, the then MHC(M), who made necessary entries
in the relevant registerand the material objects were deposited in
the malkhana. Exhibit PW4/A is the entry made regarding the
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
deposit. PW4 also deposed that he had orally instructed PW3 to
send the material objects to the FSL through PW5 for their
examination. The testimony of PW4 has not been discredited in
any way. Therefore, there has been compliance of Section 52(3) of
the NDPS Act also.
40. As far as the allegation of illegal gratification is
concerned, apart from the oral testimony of DW2 and DW5, there
are no material(s) to substantiate it. It is not shown that any
complaint was made at the time the accused was produced before
the Magistrate Court for the remand proceedings, or immediately
thereafter, before any authority. The subsequent lodging of a
complaint before the Anti-Corruption authorities does not, by
itself, render the recovery doubtful. When tested against the
consistent prosecution evidence and intact chain of custody, the
allegation remains unsubstantiated. The learned counsel for the
appellant was unable to refer to anystatutory provision that
mandates
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
photography
or
videography
of
the
recovery
proceedings. The absence of such recording does not, in the
circumstances of this case, undermine the otherwise cogent oral
and documentary evidence.
41. The DD entries and the reports under Section 57 of the
NDPS Act demonstrate communication tosuperior officers. The
recovery of 275 grams of heroin from the possession of the
appellant having been established, the presumption under Sections
35 and 54 of the NDPS Act comes into operation. The appellant
has not rebutted the presumption even on a preponderance of
probabilities. It is well settled that the safeguards embodied in
Chapter V of the NDPS Act are required to be strictly adhered to
before the statutory presumption can be invoked. The presumption
under Section 54 of the NDPS Act arises only after the prosecution
establishes, beyond reasonable doubt, that the contraband was
recovered from the conscious possession of the accused and that
the mandatory procedural requirements under the NDPS Act were
duly complied with. The initial burden upon the prosecution is,
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
therefore, a rigorous one. It is only upon discharge of this burden
that the onus shifts to the accused to rebut the presumption. (See
Madan Lal And Anr vs State Of Himachal Pradesh, AIR 2003
SC 3642).
42. In the light of overall re-appreciation of the oral and
documentary evidence, this Court finds that the prosecution has
proved beyond reasonable doubt that the appellant was found in
conscious possession of 275 grams of heroin, a commercial
quantity, and thereby committed the offence punishable under
Section 21(c) of the NDPS Act. Thus, I do not find any infirmity in
the findings of the trial court, calling for an interference by this
Court.
43. In the result, the appeal sans merit is thus dismissed.
Application(s), if any, pending, shall stand closed.
CHANDRASEKHARAN SUDHA
(Judge)
FEBRUARY 17, 2026/RN
CRL.A. 398/2016
Signed By:KOMAL
DHAWAN
10:44:04
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review