Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/11
GAHC010210702022
2026:GAU-AS:1361DB
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/7297/2022
MD REZZAK ALI @ REZZAK KHAN AND 3 ORS
S/O. NABU KHAN (FATHER OF VICTIM SAIDUL ISLAM @ SAIDUR KHAN),
VILL. AMGURI, P.O. AND P.S. KALGASIA, DIST. BARPETA, ASSAM, PIN781319.
2: MD. OMAR ALI @ OMAR KHAN
S/O. MAHAMMAD (FATHER OF VICTIM ABDUL RASID) VILL. AMGURI
P.O. AND P.S. KALGASIA
DIST. BARPETA
ASSAM
PIN-781319.
3: MD. MANOWAR HUSSAIN @ MANOWAR KHAN
S/O. MUGBUL (FATHER OF VICTIM ABDUL HALIM @ HALIM KHAN)
VILL. AMGURI
P.O. AND P.S. KALGASIA
DIST. BARPETA
ASSAM
PIN-781319.
4: JANGSHER ALI @ JANGSHER KHAN
S/O. MOHAMMAD ALI (FATHER OF VICTIM RAKIBUL ISALM @ RAKIBUL
HUSSAI)
VILL. AMGURI
P.O. AND P.S. KALGASIA
DIST. BARPETA
ASSAM
PIN-781319
VERSUS
THE PRINCIPAL SECRETARY / COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE
Page No.# 2/11
GOVT OF ASSAM AND 7 ORS
DEPTT. OF POWER (ELECTRIC), DISPUR, GUWAHATI-781006.
2:ASSAM POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY LTD. (APDCL)
REP. BY CHAIRMAN
BIJULIEE BHAWAN
PALTAN BAZAR
GUWAHATI-781001.
3:THE DIRECTOR
ASSAM ELECTRICITY REGULATORY COMMISSION
A.S.E.B. CAMPUS
DWARANDHAR
G.S. ROAD
SIXTH MILE
GUWAHATI-781001.
4:THE CHIEF GENERAL MANAGER
(D)
LAR
ASSAM POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY LTD. (APDCL)
BIJULIEE BHAWAN
PALTAN BAZAR GUWAHATI-781001.
5:THE DEPUTY GENERAL MANAGER (LAW)
ASSAM POWER DISTRIBUTION COMPANY LTD. (APDCL)
BIJULIEE BHAWAN
PALTAN BAZAR GUWAHATI-781001.
6:THE ASSTT. GENERAL MANAGER
BARPETA
ELECTRIC DIVISION
ASSAM POWER DISTRIBUTION CO. LTD. (APDCL)
BARPETA.
7:THE CHIEF EXECUTIVE OFFICER
BARPETA
ELECTRIC CIRCLE
ASSAM POWER DISTRIBUTION CO. LTD. (APDCL)
BARPETA.
8:THE CHIEF ELECTRICAL INSPECTOR/ELECTRICAL INSPECTORS
Page No.# 3/11
ASSAM INSPECTORATE OF ELECTRICITY
WEST END BLOCK
1ST FLOOR
HOUSEFED COMPLEX
DISPUR
GUWAHATI
PIN-781006
Advocate for the Petitioner
: G UDDIN, MR. A UDDIN,MS. P ADHIKARI
Advocate for the Respondent : SC, APDCL, MR. P N GOSWAMI, ADDL. ADVOCATE GENERAL,
ASSAM,MR S P DAS
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE MICHAEL ZOTHANKHUMA
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE KAUSHIK GOSWAMI
ORDER
03.02.2026
(K. Goswami, J)
Heard Mr. G Uddin, learned counsel for the petitioners. Also heard Mr. P. N.
Goswami, learned Additional Advocate General, Assam and Mr. S P Das, learned
Standing counsel, Assam Electricity Regulatory Commission (AERC) for the
respondents.
2.
The petitioners are the fathers of four minor children, namely, (i) Saidul
Islam @ Saidur Khan, (ii) Abdul Rasid, (iii) Abdul Halim @ Halim Khan and (iv)
Rakibul Isalm @ Rakibul Hussain, all residents of village-Amgurigaon, DistrictBarpeta who died on 17.07.2016 due to electrocution when an 11 KV live
electric line snapped and fell over while the children were crossing the Mora
Beki River by a bhur (boat made up from banana tree). All the four children
Page No.# 4/11
were brought to the Barpeta Civil Hospital, Kalgachia, where the doctor declared
them dead. The tragic occurrence is not in dispute. It is stated that an amount
of Rs. 3,00,000/- each has already been paid in phases to the families.
3.
The present writ petition challenges the quantum of compensation fixed
under the Assam Electricity Regulatory Commission (Compensation to Victims of
Electrical Accidents) Regulations, 2019 [hereinafter referred to as the AERC
Regulations], framed by the Assam Electricity Regulatory Commission. Under
the Regulations, compensation for loss of human life in an electrical accident is
prescribed at Rs. 4,00,000/- per person.
4.
The sole contention of the petitioners is that the said amount is
inadequate, arbitrary and unreasonable, particularly when compared with
compensation awarded in other forms of fatal accidents. A prayer is made for
enhancement to Rs. 50 lakhs per victim. In support of the aforesaid prayer, the
learned counsel for the petitioners has submitted a chart before this Court
showing the compensation amount provided by various States in respect of
fatalities resulting from electrical accidents to the extent of Rs. 10,00,000/-.
5.
The respondents on the other hand, submit that the impugned
Regulations are statutory in character, framed under powers conferred by the
Electricity Act, 2003 [hereinafter referred to as the said 2003 Act], and cannot
be struck down merely on the ground that the compensation amount appears
low or inadequate.
6.
The only issue requiring determination is whether the writ court can
invalidate or modify a statutory Regulation solely on the ground that the
quantum of compensation fixed therein is inadequate or unreasonable.
7.
At the outset, it is apposite to notice the relevant provisions of the said
Page No.# 5/11
2003 Act, which form the legislative foundation of the impugned Regulations.
8.
Section 2(4) of the said 2003 Act defines “Appropriate Commission” to
mean the Central Regulatory Commission under Section 76, the State
Regulatory Commission under Section 82, or a Joint Commission under Section
83. Section 82 mandates that every State Government shall constitute a State
Electricity Regulatory Commission.
9.
It is an admitted position that the State Government has constituted the
Assam Electricity Regulatory Commission (AERC) under Section 82 of the said
2003 Act.
10.
Section 2(39) of the said 2003 Act defines “licensee” as a person granted
a licence under Section 14. Section 14 empowers the Appropriate Commission
to grant licences for transmission, distribution, or trading of electricity. It is also
not in dispute that Assam Power Distribution Company Limited (hereinafter
referred to as APDCL), respondent No. 2, is the State distribution utility and a
licensee under the said 2003 Act.
11.
Section 57 of the said 2003 Act, which is central to the present
controversy, provides: “57. Standards of performance of licensee.—
(1) The Appropriate Commission may specify standards of performance of a
licensee.
(2) If a licensee fails to meet the standards, he shall be liable to pay such
compensation to the person affected as may be determined by the Appropriate
Commission.
(3) Such compensation shall be paid within ninety days .”
This provision confers statutory authority upon the Regulatory Commission to
determine compensation.
Page No.# 6/11
12.
In exercise of its statutory powers, the AERC framed the AERC
Regulations, applicable throughout Assam.
12A.
Regulation 5 provides that a licensee/generating company shall be liable
to pay compensation where the electrical accident is attributable to its fault or
negligence.
12B.
Regulation 6 stipulates that the quantum of compensation is provided in
Schedule–B, which prescribes:
“The compensation payable for loss of human life as a result of an electrical
accident: Rs. 4.00 lakhs per person.”
12C.
It requires emphasis that this amount is a statutory prescription forming
part of subordinate legislation, traceable to Section 57(2) of the said 2003 Act.
It is not an executive or administrative figure.
12D.
Regulation 9 clarifies that compensation under the Regulations does not
affect other legal remedies.
12E. Regulation 11 expressly empowers the Commission to revise the quantum
of compensation by notification after due process. This demonstrates that the
amount is a policy determination and that the legislature has provided an inbuilt
revision mechanism and enhancement of compensation is within the regulatory
domain.
12F.
That apart, Regulation 21 provides that disputes regarding entitlement or
quantum may be raised before the Ombudsman under consumer grievance
regulations. Crucially, it further clarifies that:
“Notwithstanding the above, the aggrieved person may approach a civil
Page No.# 7/11
court”.
Thus, the Regulatory scheme itself preserves civil remedy.
13.
Upon analyzing the provisions of the said 2003 Act and the AERC
Regulations, it is evident that the said Regulations have been created by a
statutory Regulatory Commission through an enabling Act. Hence, the said
Regulations are subordinate legislation. Therefore, the said quantum of
compensation forming part of the Schedule to the said Regulations is statutory
in nature. That being so, determination of compensation in matters of failure of
performance standards is a statutorily entrusted function of the Regulatory
Commission.
14.
Viewed thus, the amount of Rs. 4,00,000/- prescribed in the impugned
Regulations for loss of human life is not an administrative or executive
determination, but a statutory prescription forming part of subordinate
legislation. Once such determination is incorporated into the duly framed
Regulations, the amount assumes statutory force and stands on the same
footing as any other binding norm under delegated legislation.
15.
The parameters for judicial review of a statute or subordinate legislation
are extremely limited. The Court’s exercising judicial review cannot substitute
such legislatively determined quantum with an alternative figure based on
perceived adequacy. In other words, the Court does not sit in appeal over
legislative wisdom.
16.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in State of A.P. -Vs.- McDowell & Co.,
reported in (1996) 3 SCC 709, held that a law can be struck down only on
two grounds, i.e., (i) lack of legislative competence; or (ii) Violation of
fundamental rights or constitutional provisions.
Page No.# 8/11
Relevant paragraphs of the aforesaid judgment read as under –
“………………………... In India, the position is similar to the United States
of America. The power of Parliament or for that matter, the State
Legislatures is restricted in two ways. A law made by Parliament or the
legislature can be struck down by courts on two grounds and two
grounds alone, viz., (1) lack of legislative competence and (2) violation of
any of the fundamental rights guaranteed in Part III of the Constitution or
of any other constitutional provision. There is no third ground. We do not
wish to enter into a discussion of the concepts of procedural
unreasonableness and substantive unreasonableness concepts inspired
by the decisions of United States Supreme Court. Even in U.S.A., these
concepts and in particular the concept of substantive due process have
proved to be of unending controversy, the latest thinking tending towards
a severe curtailment of this ground (substantive due process). The main
criticism against the ground of substantive due process being that it
seeks to set up the courts as arbiters of the wisdom of the legislature in
enacting the particular piece of legislation. It is enough for us to say that
by whatever name it is characterised, the ground of invalidation must fall
within the four corners of the two grounds mentioned above. In other
words, say, if an enactment is challenged as violative of Article 14, it can
be struck down only if it is found that it is violative of the equality
clause/equal protection clause enshrined therein. Similarly, if an
enactment is challenged as violative of any of the fundamental rights
guaranteed by sub-clauses (a) to (g) of Article 19(1), it can be struck down
only if it is found not saved by any of the clauses (2) to (6) of Article 19
and so on. No enactment can be struck down by just saying that it is
arbitrary or unreasonable. Some or other constitutional infirmity has to be
found before invalidating an Act. An enactment cannot be struck down on
the ground that court thinks it unjustified. Parliament and the
legislatures, composed as they are of the representatives of the people,
are supposed to know and be aware of the needs of the people and what
is good and bad for them. The court cannot sit in judgment over their
wisdom. In this connection. it should be remembered that even in the case
of administrative action, the scope of judicial review is limited to three
grounds. viz.. (1) unreasonableness, which can more appropriately be
called irrationality, (7) illegality and (iii) procedural impropriety (see
Council of Civil Service Unions v. Minister for Civil Services which decision
has been accepted by this Court as well). The applicability of doctrine of
proportionality even in administrative law sphere is yet a debatable
issue. (See the opinions of Lords Lowry and Ackner in R. v. Secv. of State
Page No.# 9/11
for Home Deptt., ex p Brind AC at 766-67 and 762.) It would be rather
odd if an enactment were to be struck down by applying the said
principle when its applicability even in administrative law sphere is not
fully and finally settled. It is one thing to say that a restriction imposed
upon a fundamental right can be struck down if it is disproportionate,
excessive or unreasonable and quite another thing to say that the court
can strike down enactment if it thinks it unreasonable. unnecessary or
unwarranted."
As a corollary to the above, it is apparent that a law cannot be invalidated
merely on the ground that it is unreasonable or arbitrary in the abstract sense.
Courts cannot rewrite or reframe a statutory provision because a different policy
choice appears preferable. It is well settled law that subordinate legislation has,
if validly made, the full force and effect of a statute (Refer: Sukhdev Singh &
Ors. -Vs- Bhagatram Sardar Singh Raghuvanshi & Anr, (1975) 1 SCC
421). The doctrine of ultra virus as applied to statutes applies equally to
Regulations framed under the statutory provisions.
17.
We are thus of the unhesitant view that the AERC Regulations have the
force of law. In the present case, legislative competence of AERC is not
challenged, no violation of fundamental rights is pleaded or established and no
procedural illegality in framing the Regulations is shown. The entire challenge
rests solely on the ground of inadequacy of compensation.
18.
Determination of the quantum of compensation under a regulatory
scheme involves the financial capacity of the utility, uniformity of application,
actuarial and administrative considerations and balancing of public interest with
fiscal sustainability. These are policy matters within the domain of the regulator.
19.
The chart produced by the petitioners themselves shows that
compensation in various States ranges from Rs. 4 to Rs. 10 lakhs. Variation in
policy across States does not render one State’s Regulations unconstitutional. In
Page No.# 10/11
other words, variation of compensation across States does not render the
Assam Regulations unconstitutional. This Court cannot assume the role of the
regulator and fix a different compensation figure. Such an exercise would
amount to judicial legislation, which is impermissible. Compassion for the
bereaved families cannot justify transgressing constitutional limits on judicial
power.
20.
In view of the above, this Court finds that the AERC Regulations are
statutory in nature and no constitutional infirmity is demonstrated. Further,
mere inadequacy of the compensation amount is not a ground to strike down or
modify the Regulations.
21.
Accordingly, the writ petition fails and is dismissed.
22.
No order as to costs.
23.
However, it is noted that the prescribed compensation under the
Regulations is Rs. 4,00,000/- per deceased person. To the extent that such
amount has not been fully disbursed to the petitioners, the competent authority
shall ensure that the balance, if any, is paid within one month from the date of
receipt of a certified copy of this order.
24.
It is needless to be clarified that the statutory compensation under the
impugned Regulations does not bar a civil suit for damages. The amount under
the Regulations shall not operate as a ceiling. If negligence or breach of
statutory duty is established, a competent civil court may determine damages
independently and the amount of compensation already paid under the
impugned AERC Regulations shall be liable to be duly adjusted and deducted
from the compensation that may be awarded so as to avoid double payment in
terms of the regulatory scheme.
Page No.# 11/11
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review