Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/12
GAHC010212562025
2026:GAU-AS:7410
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/7479/2025
MD NUR ISLAM ALI AND 2 ORS.
S/O LATE NACHIM ALI
RESIDENT OF GARIGAON
FANCIPARA
P.S. - JALUKBARI
GUWAHATI- 781037 DISTRICT - KAMRUP M
ASSAM. EX- DRIVER CONSTABLE /57 PHONE NO 7099522161
2: SRI BHUPEN BORA
S/O LATE GOLAP BORA
R/O VILLAGE MELENG DOLAIGAON
P. S. - TEOK
DISTRICT - JORHAT
ASSAM. EX-UB CONSTABLE /741
3: SRI SRINATH PATHAK
S/O LATE RAMASHIS PATHAK
R/O VILLAGE DULHIGANJ
P. S. - JAGDISHPUR
DISTRICT - BHOJPUR
BIHAR. EX- UB CONSTABLE /695
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 3 ORS.
REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE
GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM
HOME AND POLITICAL DEPARTMENT
DISPUR
GUWAHATI781006
2:THE DIRECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE
Page No.# 2/12
ASSAM
ULUBARI
GUWAHATI-781007.
3:THE INSPECTOR GENERAL OF POLICE
EASTERN RANGE
JORHAT
ASSAM.
4:THE SENIOR SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE
JORHAT
ASSAM.
-----------Advocate for : MR. D C C PHUKAN
Advocate for : GA
ASSAM appearing for THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 3 ORS.
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE N. UNNI KRISHNAN NAIR
ORDER
Date : 25.05.2026
None appears for the petitioners on call.
Also heard Mr. D. Borah, learned Government Advocate, appearing for the respondent
nos.1, 2, 3 and 4.
2.
The petitioners have joined together in the present writ petition to assail orders
dated 31.07.2025 and 18.08.2025 issued in their respective cases upholding the order of
dismissal from service imposed upon them.
3.
The facts in brief requisite for adjudication of the issue arising in the present writ
petition is noticed, as under;
Page No.# 3/12
In pursuance to a custodial death of one Shariful Hussain, who was taken into
custody in connection with a theft case on 26.08.1994, a case of unnatural death was
registered. Thereafter, an enquiry was held and on the basis of materials coming on record
in the said enquiry, an FIR came to be lodged against the petitioners and others on
18.02.1995, alleging therein, that the death of the victim was caused on account of the
negligence on the part of the petitioners, herein. The said FIR was registered as Mariani P.S.
Case No.17/1995.
In the meantime, the respondent authorities instituted a Departmental proceedings
against each of the petitioners involved in the present proceedings. Against the petitioner
no.1 DP No.04/2000 was instituted, while DP No.03/2000 was instituted against the
petitioner no.2 and DP No.05/2000 was so instituted against the petitioner no.3.
On conclusion of the said Departmental proceedings, the petitioner no.1 was
discharged from the charges framed against him, therein. With regard to petitioner nos.2
and 3, a penalty of withholding of 02 (two) increments with cumulative effect came to be so
imposed.
On conclusion of the Trial, the Trial Court proceeded vide Judgment dated 30.04.2011, to
convict the petitioners, herein, under Section 201 IPC and sentenced them to undergo
Rigorous Imprisonment for 2 (two) years along with fine of Rs.1000/- (Rupees One
Thousand) each, in default to undergo further Simple Imprisonment for 1 (one) month for
the offence under Section 201 IPC. The conviction of the petitioners, having come to the
knowledge of the Disciplinary Authority of the petitioners, the Disciplinary Authority
proceeded vide order dated 27.05.2011, to impose upon the petitioners a penalty of
Page No.# 4/12
dismissal from service w.e.f. 02.05.2011. The said penalty imposed upon the petitioners was
so imposed basing on the conviction of the petitioners by the learned Trial Court. The
petitioners being aggrieved by their conviction and sentencing by the learned Trial Court,
assailed the same before this Court by way of filing an appeal being Criminal Appeal
No.103/2011. This Court vide order dated 21.05.2025, proceeded to dispose of the said
appeal by interfering with the conviction and sentencing of the petitioners so effected vide
Judgment & Order dated 30.04.2011, passed by the learned Trial Court in Sessions Case
No.93 (JJ)/2000. The petitioners accordingly, were acquitted from the Criminal charges
framed against them.
The petitioner nos.1 and 2, thereafter submitted individual representations before the
respondent no.3, inter alia, praying for service benefit w.e.f. 02.05.2011, along with arrear
salaries and other benefit. The representation submitted by the petitioner no.1 was
registered as Appeal Case No.06/2025, while the representation preferred by petitioner no.2
was registered as Appeal Case No.05/2025. The representation submitted by petitioner no.3
on similar lines before the respondent no.2, was disposed of by the Disciplinary Authority by
directing, therein, that he may prefer an appeal to the Appellate Authority. The appeal filed
by the petitioner nos.1 and 2 thereafter, was considered and rejected by the respondent
no.3 vide orders dated 18.08.2025.
Being aggrieved the petitioners have instituted the present writ petition.
4.
Mr. D. Borah, learned Government Advocate, appearing for the State Respondent
Nos.1, 2, 3 and 4, submits that mere acquittal of the petitioners would not have an
automatic effect of rendering the orders dated 27.05.2011, imposing upon the petitioners
Page No.# 5/12
the penalty of dismissal from service, to be not maintainable. It is submitted that the
petitioners would not be entitled to any service benefits, inasmuch as, this Court vide
Judgment & Order dated 21.05.2025, passed in Criminal Appeal No.103/2011, while
proceeding to interfere with the conviction and sentencing of the petitioners as ordered by
the learned Trial Court vide the Judgment & Order dated 30.04.2011 in Sessions Case
No.93(JJ)/2000, had not made any observation with regard to the service status of the
petitioners after they were acquitted from the charges framed against them in the
connected criminal proceedings. Mr. D. Borah, submits that the respondent authorities after
considering all aspects of the matter had passed a reasoned order vide the orders dated
18.08.2025 in respect of the petitioner nos.1 and 2, and the same would not mandate an
interference from this Court.
In so far as the petitioner no.3 is concerned, it is submitted by Mr. D. Borah, that he
having not preferred any appeal against the order dated 27.05.2011, the order of dismissal
as effected in this case has attained its finality.
5.
I have heard the learned counsel for the respondents and also perused the
materials available on record.
6.
The factual position noticed, hereinabove, are not in dispute.
After the petitioners were involved in a criminal proceedings, a Departmental
proceedings is also found to have been instituted against them. The said Departmental
proceedings had concluded with no penalty being imposed upon the petitioner no.1, while
with regard to the petitioner nos.2 and 3, a penalty of withholding of 02 (two) increments
with cumulative effect came to be so leveled.
Page No.# 6/12
7.
From the materials available on record, it is evident that the penalty so imposed
upon the petitioners was basing on allegation which also formed the allegation in the
criminal proceedings instituted against the petitioners. However, what is to be noticed,
herein, is that the penalty as imposed upon the petitioner nos.1 and 2 were on account of
the negligence on the part of the petitioners in not taking due care and caution to save the
life of the accused who were in police custody. The orders dated 27.05.2011 were however,
not assailed by the petitioner nos.1 and2 either by way of filing an appeal and/or by
instituting proceeding. The said orders dated 27.05.2011 are also not assailed in the present
proceeding by the petitioner nos.1 and 2.
8.
Having drawn the said conclusions, this Court finds that the petitioners were
convicted vide Judgment & Order dated 30.04.2011, by the learned Trial Court in Sessions
Case No.93(JJ)/2000, under Section 201 read with Section 34 IPC. Thereafter, vide order
dated 30.04.2011, the petitioners were sentenced to undergo Rigorous Imprisonment for 2
(two) years with a fine of Rs.1000/- (Rupees One Thousand), in default, Simple
Imprisonment for 1 (one) month for the offence under Section 201 IPC.
The petitioners upon being convicted and sentenced by the learned Trial Court, the said
decision having been brought to the knowledge of the Disciplinary Authority of the
petitioners, the Disciplinary Authority of the petitioners vide orders dated 27.05.2011,
proceeded to impose upon the petitioners the penalty of dismissal from service w.e.f
02.05.2011.
9.
A perusal of the said order would go to reveal that the same were solely passed
basing on the conviction of the petitioners and not on the basis of any conclusions arrived
Page No.# 7/12
at in a Departmental proceedings instituted against the petitioners in the matter. The
Departmental proceedings instituted against the petitioners in the matter were already
closed. The petitioners being aggrieved by their conviction and sentencing by the learned
Trial Court assailed the same before this Court by way of instituting an appeal being
Criminal Appeal No.103/2011. This Court vide Judgment & Order dated 21.05.2025, upon
appreciating the materials coming on record were pleased to set aside the Judgment &
Order dated 30.04.2011, passed by the learned Trial Court in Sessions Case No.93(JJ)/2000.
The petitioners, herein, were accordingly, acquitted from the charges framed against them,
in the criminal case instituted against them along with the other co-accused. The petitioners
on their acquittal from the criminal proceedings instituted against them had approached
their Disciplinary Authority by way of filing representations, praying for being authorized
their pension and pensionary benefits. The representation submitted by the petitioner nos.1
and 2 came to be placed before the Appellate Authority on 06.06.2025. The Appellate
Authority considered the said representations submitted by the petitioner nos.1 and 2 to be
an appeal against the order of dismissal. On such consideration being made, the Appellate
Authority vide order dated 18.08.2025, proceeded to draw the following conclusions in
respect of the petitioner no.1;
“(i) A criminal case was registered at Mariani PS vide Case No. 17/1995 U/S
302 IPC against D-Const. 57 Nur Islam Ali and others. He was arrested during
investigation on 12.01.2000 and remanded to judicial custody.
(ii) Departmental Proceeding No. 04/2000 was drawn up against him vide DO
No. 934 dated 28.03.2000.
Page No.# 8/12
(iii) The said DP was disposed of vide DO No. 2148 dated 03.10.2007,
imposing the punishment discharged of the charges.
(iv) Following his conviction under Section 201 IPC in the same matter, he
was dismissed from service w.e.f. 02.05.2011.
(v) As per this office Letter No. DER/JHT/Appeal/590 dated 24.08.2012, the
then DIGP (ER), Assam, Jorhat, rejected his earlier appeal for reinstatement
owing to his conviction.
(vi) The Hon'ble Gauhati High Court, vide Order No. GAHC010006232011
dated 21.05.2025, set aside the judgment dated 30.04.2011 passed by the
learned Sessions Judge, Jorhat, thereby acquitting the appellant. However, the
Hon'ble High Court's order does not contain any direction regarding servicerelated benefits.”
10.
In so far as the petitioner no.2 is concerned, the Appellate Authority vide an order
dated 18.08.2025, had drawn the following conclusions;
“(i) A criminal case was registered at Mariani PS vide Case No. 17/1995 U/S
302 IPC against Constable Bhupen Borah and others. He was arrested during
investigation on 12.01.2000 and remanded to judicial custody.
(ii) Departmental Proceeding No. 03/2000 was drawn up against him vide DO
No. 934 dated 28.03.2000.
(iii) The said DP was disposed of vide DO No. 2327 dated 25.10.2007,
imposing the punishment of withholding two increments with cumulative effect.
Page No.# 9/12
(iv) Following his conviction under Section 201 IPC in the same matter, he was
dismissed from service w.e.f. 02.05.2011.
(v) As per this office Letter No. DER/JHT/Appeal/590 dated 24.08.2012, the
then DIGP (ER), Assam, Jorhat, rejected his earlier appeal for reinstatement
owing to his conviction.
(vi) The Hon'ble Gauhati High Court, vide Order No. GAHC010006232011
dated 21.05.2025, set aside the judgment dated 30.04.2011 passed by the
learned Sessions Judge, Jorhat, thereby acquitting the appellant. However, the
Hon'ble High Court's order does not contain any direction regarding servicerelated benefits.”
11.
Basing on the said conclusions drawn, the Appellate Authority further proceeded to
hold that in terms of the Rules holding the field, dismissal from service having entailed
forfeiture of all consequential benefits unless otherwise directed, held that this Court in the
order passed in the criminal appeal being silent on the restoration of service benefits to the
petitioners, the orders of dismissal from service were affirmed.
12.
This Court has perused the orders dated 27.05.2011. The said orders were not
orders passed by the Disciplinary Authority on conclusion of a Departmental proceedings
instituted against the petitioners. The said orders were so issued only basing on the
conviction of the petitioners in the criminal proceedings pending against them at the
relevant point of time. The conviction of the petitioners having being interfered with
subsequently by this Court in the Criminal Appeal No.103/2011, vide Judgment & Order
dated 21.05.2025, the very basis for the imposition of the penalty of dismissal from service
Page No.# 10/12
of the petitioners vide order dated 27.05.2011, stood removed.
Although there is a delay in the petitioners approaching this Court after the passing
of the order dated 27.05.2011, in the facts and circumstances of the present case, the said
delay cannot be attributed to the petitioners, inasmuch as, the challenge to the said orders
would have been permissible only after the disposal of the appeal preferred in the matter by
the petitioners against the Judgment & Order passed by the learned Trial Court, convicting
and sentencing them. The said criminal proceedings instituted against the petitioners had
resulted in their acquittal only with the passing of the Judgment & Order dated 21.05.2025,
passed by this Court in Criminal Appeal No.103/2011. Accordingly, there is no delay found
on the part of the petitioners in assailing the order of penalty of dismissal as imposed upon
them in the matter.
13.
Accordingly, in view of the said position, this Court would now examine the orders
dated 18.08.2025, passed by the Appellate Authority in respect of the petitioner nos.1 and
2. The Appellate Authority in the said orders after noticing the various facts involved
including the proceedings instituted against the petitioners had proceeded to reject the
prayer of the petitioners for being authorized pension and pensionary benefits only on the
ground that the Judgment & Order dated 21.05.2025, passed by this Court in Criminal
Appeal No.103/2011, while acquitting the petitioners from the criminal charges framed
against them had not passed any direction with regard to their service related benefits. The
said contentions of the Appellate Authority is astonishing, inasmuch as, the Appellate
Authority being a Senior Police Officer is expected to appreciate the jurisdiction of this Court
while considering criminal proceedings. This Court in Criminal Appeal No.103/2011 was not
Page No.# 11/12
considering the order of penalty as imposed upon the petitioners by the Departmental
Authorities, but was only examining the validity of the Judgment & Order dated 30.04.2011,
passed by the learned Trial Court in Sessions Case No.93(JJ)/2000, convicting and
sentencing the petitioners under Section 201/304 (Part II) IPC. It is not expected that this
Court while considering a conviction and sentencing of an accused would also be required
to pass orders with regard to the service related benefits of the said accused person. This
Court having interfered with the Judgment & Order dated 30.04.2011, in Sessions Case
No.93(JJ)/2000 and acquitted the petitioners, the very basis for imposition of penalty upon
the petitioners stood removed with retrospective effect i.e. w.e.f., 02.05.2011. Accordingly,
it was for the Departmental Authorities to examine the matter and pass appropriate order
as would be called for. The Departmental Authority is found to have miserably failed to act
in the matter by applying known principles of law.
14.
Be that as it may, the conviction and sentencing of the petitioners having been
interfered with, this Court proceeds to set aside and quash the orders dated 27.05.2011
passed in respect of all the petitioners, along with the orders of the Appellate Authority
dated 18.08.2025 in so far as it concerns the petitioner nos.1 and 2.
15.
This Court having interfered with the penalty of dismissal from service imposed
upon the petitioners vide the said orders dated 27.05.2011, the present service status of the
petitioners not being disclosed to this Court in the present proceedings, the respondent
authorities are directed to pass consequential orders in the matter.
In the event, any of the petitioners has not superannuated from their services, such
petitioner be re-instated in his service and the pay and allowances of the petitioners w.e.f.
Page No.# 12/12
02.05.2011, be fixed notionally.
In the event, any or all of the petitioners have superannuated from their services
during the pendency of the present proceedings and/or before the institution of the same,
the pay of such petitioners w.e.f., 02.05.2011 be fixed notionally by providing for the annual
increments receivable by the petitioners along with the Revision of Pay, if any, coming into
effect during the said period. The pay of the petitioners on the date of their superannuation
be accordingly fixed and their pension and pensionary benefits be processed and released
to them.
16.
The exercise now mandated to be carried out for compliance of the directions
passed, hereinabove, in respect of each of the petitioners be initiated and concluded, with
release of the consequential benefits to each of the petitioners, within a period of 03 (three)
months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.
17.
With the above observations and directions, the present writ petition stands
disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review