Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
HIGH COURT OF TRIPURA
_A_G_A_R_T_A_L_A_
IA No.01 of 2023 IN Review Petition No.44 of 2023
Md. Mufazzul Hussain and others
...... Applicant(s)
VERSUS
The State of Tripura and others
......Respondent(s)
For Applicant(s)
:
Mr. A. Bhowmik, Advocate,
Mr. S. Dey, Advocate.
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. D. Sharma, Addl. G.A.
HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. APARESH KUMAR SINGH
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE T. AMARNATH GOUD
_O_ R_ D_ E_ R_
21/08/2023
The instant review petition is directed against the impugned
judgment dated 16.11.2021 passed by the Coordinate Bench of this Court in
WA No.256 of 2021 which reads as under :
“[1] By means of filing this writ appeal, appellants have challenged the
judgment dated 26.02.2021 passed by the learned Single Judge in WP(C)
No.1266 of 2019.
[2] Factual background of the case is as under: By an office order dated
09.11.1987 appellants were appointed in the post of Khalasi in Public Works
Department (PWD), Government of Tripura which carried a pay scale of
Rs.370/--650/- plus admissible allowances under Tripura Civil
Services(revised pay)Rules, 1982(“ROP,1988”) which were introduced
w.e.f. 01.01.1996. Subsequent to their joining the service, the said post of
Khalasi was redesignated as Sr. Helper which carried the pre-revised scale of
Rs.400/-- 775/- plus admissible allowances which upon revision was fitted in
grade scale No.12 with revised scale of Rs.850/--2,130/-. The pay of the
appellants was accordingly fixed, relying on the clarification issued by the
State Government from time to time, by first placing them in the pre revised
scale of Rs.400/--775/- meant for the senior helper and thereafter granting
them corresponding scale in the revised scale of pay.
[3] Pursuant to government policy, the appellants were given the benefits of
Assured Career Progression (ACP) and in the course of WA256 of 2021
time they were given 3rd ACP on 01.01.2014 and placed in the scale of pay
of Rs.4,530/--13,000/- with a grade pay of Rs.1,700/-. Subsequently by the
impugned office orders dated 14.12.2018 and 06.08.2019, this benefit of 3rd
ACP was withdrawn by the State Government. Since the appellants had
retired since then, recoveries of the excess pay and allowances were ordered
to be made from their pension.
[4] The appellants being petitioners challenged the said recovery orders by
filing WP(C) 1266 contending that they were rightly given the benefit which
was arbitrarily withdrawn by the State Government without affording any
opportunity of hearing to them. In the said writ petition they claimed the
following reliefs:
“i. Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a writ in the
nature of Mandamus and / or order/ orders and / or direction / directions of
like nature shall not be issued quashing the Office Order, dated, 06.08.2019,
issued by the Engineering Officer to the Chief Engineer, PWD(R&B),
Agartala, Tripura.
ii. Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a writ in the
nature of Mandamus and / or order/ orders and / or direction / directions of
like nature shall not be issued quashing the Office Order, dated, 14.12.2018,
issued by the Executive Engineer, Internal Electrification Division, PWD,
Udaipur, Tripura.
iii. Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a writ in the
nature of Mandamus and / or order/ orders and / or direction / directions of
like nature shall not be issued directing the respondents to release the
pensionary benefits of the Petitioners including regular monthly pension,
gratuity etc. with interest.
iv. Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a writ in the
nature of Mandamus and / or order/ orders and / or direction / directions of
like nature shall not be issued directing the Respondents to determine the
pensionary benefit of the petitioners ignoring the Office order, dated
06.08.2019, issued by the Engineering Officer to the Chief Engineer,
PWD(R&B), Agartala, Tripura and Office order dated 14.12.2018 issued by
the Executive Engineer, Internal Electrification Division, PWD, Udaipur ,
Tripura.
v. Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a writ in the
nature of Mandamus and / or order/ orders and / or direction / directions of
like nature shall not be issued directing the Respondents to refund
Rs.1,01,294/-, illegally recovered from the salary of the Petitioner No.02 in
terms of Office order dated 14.12.2018 issued by the Executive Engineer,
Internal Electrification Division, PWD, Udaipur , Tripura.
vi. Issue Rule upon the Respondents to show cause as to why a writ in the
nature of Mandamus and/or order/ orders and/or direction/ directions of like
nature shall not be issued quashing the letter No.F.1(4)-FIN(PC)/09,dated
07.08.2009 issued by the Dy. Secretary to the Govt. of Tripura, Finance
Department.”
[5] In their counter affidavit the State respondents pleaded that after availing
the revised pay scale corresponding to the pre revised pay WA256 of 2021
of Rs.2,900/--5,660/-, petitioners (appellants herein) were not entitled to any
further financial benefit. The department due to bonafide mistake granted
higher pay scale to them and therefore, by the impugned office orders they
were reinstated in the pre revised scale of pay of Rs.2,900/-- 5,660/- and
order was passed for recovery of excess pay and allowances from them.
[6] In the given factual context, the learned Single Judge held that upon redesignation of their post from Khalasi to Senior Helper the petitioners
(appellants herein) clearly availed a scale advancement and if including that
upward move, the petitioners had already availed 03 scale advancements,
they did not have a right for further ACP benefits. The relevant extract of the
judgment of the learned Single Judge is as under :
“[5] Having heard learned counsel for the parties and having perused
documents on record, I do not find any error in the view of the
Government. As noted, at the time of introduction of ROP 1988, the
post of Khalasi carried a prerevised scale of Rs.370-650/-. This scale
would have been revised as provided under the ROP, 1988 and
without the aid of upgradation, the incumbents would be placed in
the revised scale of Rs.800-1,520/-. However, the department desired
to upgrade the entire cadre and therefore, redesignated the post as
Senior Helper which carried the prerevised scale of Rs.400-775/corresponding revised scale of this pre-revised scale was Rs.8502,130/-. This in clear terms was a scale upgradation. We may also
refer to a clarification of Finance Department dated 30th November,
1988 in which it has been provided that on account of re-designation
of the post of Khalasi as Senior Helpers, the pay of improvements
WA256 of 2021 will be first notionally fixed in the modified scale of
Rs.400- 775/- and then to the revised scale of Rs.850-2,130/-.
[6] Under ROP 1999, Assured Carrier Progression Scheme has been
framed by the Rule 10 which essentially provides that a State
Government employee will have scale advancement by way of
promotion, failing which by time bound movement in a higher scale
after entry into service in whole service life after 10 years, 7 years
and 7 years of continuous and satisfactory service unless he gets
promoted to a post of higher scale before such period. The proviso (i)
of the said Rule provides that if scale advancement takes place by
way of promotion prior to the period mentioned above, no further
advancement would be admissible at the end of the appropriate stage.
“
[7] The movement of the petitioners from a pre-revised scale of
Rs.370-650/- to 400-775/- at the time of implementation of ROP
1988 upon re-designation of their post from Khalasi to Sr. Helper,
was thus clearly an availment of scale advancement. If, including
such upward movement the petitioners had already availed 3 scale
advancements by the time ROP 1999 were promulgated, they did not
have a right for further ACP benefit under ROP 1999.”
[7] Viewing thus, the learned Single Judge dismissed the Writ Petition
which has been challenged in this appeal.
[8] Appearing for the petitioners Mr. S.Bhattacharjee, learned advocate
contends that the learned Single Judge should not have treated the redesignation of the appellants from the post of Khalasi to Senior Helper as
career advancement and therefore, finding of the learned Single Judge that
including said re-designation of the post they already availed 03 career
advancements is unfounded. Counsel submits that they were rightly given
the benefit of 3rd ACP which were arbitrarily recalled by the State
Government without affording any opportunity of hearing to the appellants.
Counsel contends that the appellants were poor paid employees and recovery
of excess pay and allowances from them caused serious hardship to them.
Counsel therefore, urged for allowing the appeal.
[9] Mr. D.Bhattacharjee, learned GA, on the other hand, contended that the
appellants had already availed 03(three) career advancements including the
upward move consequent to the redesignation of their post and due to
bonafide mistake, the benefit of 3rd ACP was given to them beyond their
entitlement and there was no wrong in the action of the State respondent in
issuing recovery order for recovery of the excess pay and allowances.
[10] We have perused the entire record and considered the submissions
made at the bar. We agree with the findings of the learned Single Judge that
upon re-designation of the post from Khalasi to senior helper, the appellants
moved to a higher scale of pay which clearly amounted to their availing of a
scale advancement. Therefore, the learned Single Judge rightly held that if
including such upward move, the appellants had already availed 03 scale
advancements by the time WA256 of 2021 ROP, 1999 were promulgated,
they were not entitled to further ACP benefit under ROP, 1999.
[11] But insofar as the recovery of excess pay and allowances is concerned,
we are of the view that such recovery would be improper and unfair. It will
cause serious hardship to the appellants all of whom are stated to have
retired from Group-D posts. In the case of STATE OF PUNJAB AND
OTHERS VS. RAFIQ MASIH (WHITE WASHER) AND OTHERS
reported in (2015) 4 SCC 334, the Apex Court examined similar issue where
the employees were beneficiaries of a mistake committed by their employer
and on account of such unintentional mistake, the employees were in receipt
of some monetary benefits beyond their due. After examining the earlier
decisions rendered on the said issue, the following parameters were laid
down by the Apex Court which would govern the issue of recovery where
payments have mistakenly been made by the employer. Observation of the
Apex Court in paragraph 18 of the judgment is as under :
“18. It is not possible to postulate all situations of hardship, which would
govern employees on the issue of recovery, where payments have mistakenly
been made by the employer, in excess of their entitlement. Be that as it may,
based on the decisions referred to herein above, we may, as a ready
reference, summarise the following few situations, wherein recoveries by the
employers, would be impermissible in law: (i) Recovery from employees
belonging to Class-III and ClassIV service (or Group 'C' and Group 'D'
service). (ii) Recovery from retired employees, or employees who are due to
retire within one year, of the order of recovery. (iii) Recovery from
employees, when the excess payment has been made for a period in excess
of five years, before the order of recovery is issued. (iv) Recovery in cases
where an employee has wrongfully been required to discharge duties of a
higher post, and has been paid accordingly, even though he should have
rightfully been required to work against an inferior post. (v) In any other
case, where the Court arrives at the conclusion, that recovery if made from
the employee, would be iniquitous or harsh or arbitrary to such an extent, as
would far outweigh the equitable balance of the employer's right to recover.”
[12] We have considered the instant case in the light of the said judgment of
the Apex Court and in our considered view, the impugned order for recovery
of excess pay and allowances mistakenly paid to the appellants would
amount to a harsh and arbitrary action against the appellants who are stated
to have retired from Group-D posts and therefore the impugned order of
recovery is hereby quashed. Amount already recovered from the appellants
under the said order, shall be refunded to them within a period of 03 months
from today and further recovery, if any, shall be stopped. It is however,
made clear that their pension and other retiral benefits shall be calculated on
the basis of the pay they were actually entitled to at the time of their
retirement. In other words, the pay mistakenly granted to them shall not be
taken as the basis for determination of their pension and retiral benefits.
In terms of the above, the Writ Appeal is disposed of.
Pending application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.”
The instant review petition suffers from a delay of 416 days for
condonation of which IA No.01 of 2023 has been preferred. Petitioner has
furnished the following explanation for condonation of delay.
It is submitted by learned counsel for the petitioners that the
impugned judgment was delivered on 16.11.2021. Petitioners got informed
regarding dismissal of the appeal from their earlier appointed counsel in the
first week of December, 2021 but the petitioners came to know that this
Court was on winter vacation at the relevant point of time. Thereafter, the
petitioners discussed the issue with their family members and came to know
that after dismissal of the appeal by the Division Bench of this Court, the
only remedy available to them was to approach the Hon’ble Apex Court.
Due to financial constraints, petitioners could not approach the Apex Court
and took some time to think about availing the next legal recourse.
Petitioners came to know that the learned Single Judge of this Court has
allowed the writ petition filed by Sri Dwijen Debnath in WP(C) No.442 of
2020. In the month of July, 2022 the petitioner also came to know that the
respondent has complied with the judgment and order dated 30.11.2021
passed in WP(C) No.442 of 2020. Petitioner engaged his counsel but at the
relevant point of time this Court was on Puja vacation. Thereafter, the
petitioner met his engaged counsel who advised him that before availing the
next legal remedy the entire case records need to be perused. Accordingly,
the petitioner contacted their previously engaged counsel in the month of
January, 2023 and the petitioners were informed that the case file is in the
Chamber of one senior counsel who will be contesting the Assembly
Elections and the petitioners were asked to contact in the month of April,
2023. During this period there was assembly election in the State of Tripura
and the petitioners could not contact his engaged counsel. The remaining
period was consumed in drafting the review petition along with the
interlocutory application. It is further submitted that the petitioner is entitled
to the exclusion of period of limitation till 28.02.2022 in view of the order
passed by the Apex Court in suo motu WP(C) No.03 of 2020. It is further
submitted that in the meanwhile, the applicant handed over the entire brief to
his engaged counsel who took some time to peruse the case record.
Thereafter, the said matter was brought to the notice of his engaged counsel
who took some time to verify the facts and gather information. It is also
submitted that the petitioner had applied for the certified copy of the
judgment and order dated 16.11.2021 on 11.04.2023 and the same was
supplied to them on 17.04.2023. Therefore, 07 days were consumed in
obtaining
the
certified
copy of the
judgment
and
order dated
16.11.2021. Therefore, there was a bona fide delay of 416 days. It is
submitted that the delay is not intentional. Further, since the learned Single
Bench has granted relief in similar circumstances after passing of the
Division Bench judgment of this Court in WA No.256 of 2021 from which
the instant review petition arises, therefore, the impugned judgment requires
review. Delay may be condoned in the interest of justice.
Learned counsel for the State Mr. D. Sharma has strongly
opposed the prayer. He submits that the delay is inordinate and unexplained.
Moreover, the petitioner cannot take the plea that the impugned judgment
rendered by Division Bench of this Court in WA No.256 of 2021 dated
16.11.2021 is per-incuriam as a later judgment was delivered by the learned
Single Bench of this Court by granting relief in similar circumstances to
another employee. It appears that the impugned judgment of this Court was
perhaps not pointed out to the learned Writ Court where he delivered the
judgment on 30.11.2021. In any case, the petitioner cannot seek review of
the impugned judgment on those grounds. As such, both on grounds of delay
and merits, the petition deserve to be dismissed.
We have considered the submissions of learned counsel for the
parties and taken note of the explanation urged by the petitioner for
condonation of delay of 416 days in preferring the instant memo of appeal.
The chronology of facts and events narrated by the petitioner in support of
his explanation need not be repeated. It appears that the impugned judgment
passed by the Coordinate Bench of this Court is of 16.11.2021. Even
excluding the Covid delay as per the order of the Apex Court in suo motu
WP(C) No.03 of 2020 till 28.06.2022, the review petition has been filed only
on 20.07.2023 i.e. after a delay of 416 days for which there is no plausible
explanation as such. The petitioner seems to have been taking leisurely time
in briefing his counsel, obtaining documents, compliance order etc. little
conscious of the huge delay that continued to accrue to his detriment all
along. In such circumstances, this Court is of the view that no sufficient
cause has been shown on the part of the petitioner for seeking a review of
the impugned judgment. It also appears that the basic plea raised by the
petitioner in interlocutory application also is of a later judgment of the
Single Bench of this Court in WP(C) No.442 of 2020 dated 30.11.2021 said
to be in case of a similarly situated employee for seeking review of the
judgment of the Division Bench of this Court in WA No.256 of 2021 passed
on 16.11.2021. This can’t be a ground for review.
In such circumstances, since this present review petition suffers
from inordinate and unexplained delay, we are not inclined to allow the
application for condonation of delay. Accordingly, the same is dismissed.
Consequently, the Review Petition No.44 of 2023 is also dismissed.
(T. AMARNATH GOUD) J
DIPESH
DEB
Dipesh
DIPESH DEB
Date: 2023.09.01
12:58:07 +05'30'
(APARESH KUMAR SINGH) CJ
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review