Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/8
GAHC010181612019
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/5622/2019
MD. JAKIR ALI
S/O LATE RAKHMAT ALI @ RAKMAT ALI @ RAHMAT ALI, R/O VILL-NO. 1
KANDMARI, P.S.-MUKALMUA, DIST-NALBARI, ASSAM
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 5 ORS.
TO BE REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY, GOVERNMENT OF INDIA,
DEPARTMENT OF HOME AFFAIRS, NEW DELHI, INDIA
2:THE STATE OF ASSAM
TO BE REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF
ASSAM
DEPARTMENT OF HOME
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-6
3:THE ELECTION COMMISSION OF INDIA
NIRVACHAN SADAN
ASHOK ROAD
NEW DELHI-110001
4:THE OFFICE OF THE STATE COORDINATOR OF NATIONAL REGISTRAR
OF CITIZENSHIP (NRC)
ASSAM
1ST FLOOR
ACHYUT PLAZA
G.S. ROAD
BHANGAGARH
GUWAHATI-5
DIST-KAMRUP(M)
ASSAM
Page No.# 2/8
PIN-781005
5:THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
NALBARI
DIST-NALBARI
ASSAM
6:THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE (B)
NALBARI
DIST-NALBARI
ASSAM
Advocate for the petitioner
Advocate for the respondent No.1
Advocate for respondent No. 2 & 6
Advocate for the respondent No. 4
Advocate for respondent No. 5
Advocate for the Respondent No.3
: Mr. N.A Mazarbhuiya
: Mr. B. Sarma, CGC
: Ms. A. Verma, SC
: Mr. G. Sarma, SC
: Mr. P. Sarma, Govt. Adv.
: Mr. N. Kalita, SC, ECI
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SANJAY KUMAR MEDHI
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PRANJAL DAS
Date on which judgment is reserved
: 15.05.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 25.06.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
operative part of the judgment ?
: No.
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
: Yes
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Date : 25-06-2026
(Pranjal Das, J)tra
iptions
Heard Mr. N.A Mazarbhuiya, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Ms. A. Verma,
learned Standing Counsel, Home Deptt., for the respondent Nos. 2 & 6; Mr. G. Sarma, learned
Standing counsel, NRC for the respondent No. 4; Mr. N. Kalita, learned Standing Counsel, ECI for the
respondent No. 3; Mr. B. Sarma, learned CGC for the respondent No.1 and Mr. P. Sarma, learned State
Page No.# 3/8
counsel for the respondent No.5.
2.
The petitioner, Md. Jakir Ali, has invoked the provisions of Article 226 of the Constitution of
India to challenge the impugned judgment and opinion dated 09/05/2019 passed by the learned
Member Foreigners Tribunal No. 2, Nalbari in FT(Nal-2) Case No. 45/2015 (arising out of FT Case
No. 431 of 2007), further arising out of Memo No. PNB/B/5(B)2008/1067), dated 24/07/2008 whereby the petitioner, as proceedee was declared to be a foreigner of post 25/03/1971 stream, having
entered into India illegally after 25/03/1971. Thus, the reference was answered in favour of the State
and against the petitioner as proceedee.
3.
The facts in brief may be narrated herein below:
Upon receiving the reference from the Superintendent of Police Border, Nalbari, the learned
Tribunal issued notice to the petitioner whereupon he appeared and filed a written statement annexing
certain documents. Subsequently, during the proceeding, the petitioner, as proceedee had adduced the
evidence of two witnesses, being himself as DW-1 and one Gaon Bura as DW-2. He also exhibited five
documents. However, upon perusing the evidence and exhibited documents adduced from the side of
the petitioner, the learned Tribunal was unable to come to the finding that the petitioner is an Indian
citizen and accordingly, returned the finding against him, holding that he is a foreign national and an
illegal migrant post 25/03/1971 stream.
4.
Aggrieved by the same, the instant writ petition has been filed. In the written statement filed by
the petitioner as proceedee before the Tribunal, he stated that the reference proceeding is false and
concocted and that he is an Indian citizen by birth, who was born and brought up at Village Pachim
Bhanganmari under Mukalmua Police Station in the district of Nalbari, Assam. He further stated that
after erosion of the village, the petitioner, along with his family members shifted to the village of No.1,
Kandhbari. The petitioner stated that his father's name was recorded in the voters list of 1966 and that
his father's name is Rahmat Ali, alias Rakmat Ali. He also stated about his father's name being recorded
in the NRC of 1951 with regard to village Nadia under the jurisdiction of Nalbari Police Station in the
district of Nalbari. The petitioner stated that his name figured in the voters list of 1997 under No. 60,
Barkhetri, LAC of village Bhanganmari under Mukalmua Police Station. The petitioner reiterated in his
written statement that he is an Indian citizen by birth and having landed property at his residential
address.
5.
In support of his case, the petitioner, as proceedee adduced evidence as DW1 in which he stated
Page No.# 4/8
that his name is Jakir Ali and father's name is Rakmat Ali of No.1 Kandhmari village in the district
under the jurisdiction of Mukalmua Police Station in the district of Nalbari. He stated that in the NRC
of 1951, his father's name was mentioned at Sl. No. 5 of House No. 58 of village Nadia. He exhibited
the said document as Exhibit 1. The petitioner further deposed that his father's name also figured in the
voters list of 1966 of No.54, Chenga, LAC at Sl. No. 176 of village Nadia. He exhibited the document
as Exhibit 2. He further stated that his name has been mentioned in the voters list of 1997 against No.
60 Barkhetri LAC at Sl. No 117. He exhibited the document as Exhibit 3. He also exhibited the voters
list of 2014 as Exhibit 4, where his name is stated to have been recorded at Sl. No.108. However, he
stated that in the voters list of 1997, his name was wrongly recorded as Jagir Ali instead of Jakir Ali.
He also stated that in the voters list of 1966, his father's name has been recorded as Rahmat Ali though
the actual name was Rakmat Ali. He stated that he was born in village Pachim Bhanganmari under the
Police Station Mukalmua in the district of Nalbari. The petitioner also exhibited as Exhibit 5 an
affidavit made by him stating that in the voters list of 1997, his name was wrongly recorded as Jagir
Ali instead of Jakir Ali. He also stated that in the voters list of 1966, his father's name has been
mentioned in the 58 No. Chenga LAC. As already mentioned, he exhibited as Exhibit 5 an affidavit in
which he stated that in the voters list of 1997, his name was wrongly recorded as Jagir Ali instead of
Jakir Ali. He also stated in the voters list of 1966, his father's name has been wrongly recorded as
Rahmat Ali instead of Rakmat Ali. He stated that Jagir Ali and Jakir Ali are one and the same person as
also Rahmat Ali and Rakmat Ali. In questions put by the Tribunal, DW1, the proceedee, stated that his
father's name appeared as Rakmat Ali in the NRC of 1951, and his grandfather's name was Tafij Mistiri.
He stated that Rakmat is his father and Tafij is his grandfather. He stated that he is residing in the
present village for about 10/11 years and earlier, he was residing at village Bhanganmari, which is his
birthplace.
6.
One Khusnur Ali, (Gaon Bura) of village Kandhbar-1, 2, and 3, adduced evidence on behalf of the
petitioner as DW2, in which he stated that he was appointed as in-charge Gaon Burah in place of late
Jaynal Abdin, and that he had issued a certificate in the name of the petitioner. However, he did not
exhibit any such document as part of his evidence. He stated that for the last 10 years, the petitioner has
been residing at village No.1 Kandhbari, and that DW2 knew his father Rakmat Ali since long back,
and that the petitioner is the son of Rakmat Ali. He stated that he also knew his father, who was earlier
at Nadia. He also stated that he does not know the birth of the petitioner, and deposed that, in his view,
the petitioner is an Indian person. In cross-examination, he stated that he had seen Rakmat Ali 25 years
back, and he was aged about 40/45 years old.
Page No.# 5/8
7.
Mr. N.A Mazarbhuiya, the learned counsel for the petitioner, supporting the pleadings of the writ
petition, submitted that the petitioner is an Indian citizen by birth, having been born and brought up in
the aforementioned village. He stated that his father's name figured in the NRC way back in 1951 itself,
and that Tafij Mistiri was his grandfather and Gendi Bibi, his grandmother. He also submitted that the
petitioner's father figured in the voters' list of 1966, though his name was wrongly recorded as Rahmat
Ali instead of Rakmat Ali. It is submitted by the learned counsel that, due to the minor discrepancy in
name, the Tribunal ought not to have discarded the evidence of the petitioner and returned the finding
that he was a foreign national.
8.
In support of his contentions, the learned counsel for the petitioner cited the decision of Sirajul
Hoque -Vs- State of Assam & Ors., reported in (2019) 5 SCC 534.
9.
On the other hand, the learned Standing counsel for the respondents Nos. 2 & 4, Ms. A. Verma
submits that the written statement does not contain relevant particulars such as shifting of the village,
names of the siblings of the petitioner, and also his mother's name. It is submitted that the Gaon Bura
has not proved the purported certificate as per the procedure. It is submitted that there are discrepancies
in the name of his father and that the petitioner, as proceedee has not been able to discharge the burden
under section 9 of the Foreigner's Act, 1946.
10. In support of her contentions, the learned counsel for the respondent Nos. 2 & 6 relied on the
decision of Basiron Bibi -versus- Union of India & Others,
reported in 2018(1) GLT 372 (para
30).
11. We have perused the pleadings of the writ petition, the evidence and documents, and other relevant
materials available before the Tribunal to adjudicate within the ambit of certiorari jurisdiction as to
whether the impugned opinion is sustainable in law and facts.
12. As part of this evidence, the petitioner has exhibited as Exhibit 1, the NRC of 1951, in which his
projected father's name figured. However, the name mentioned therein is Rahmat Ali, who is stated to
be the son of Tafij Mistiri. On the basis of this exhibited document, perhaps it can be held that the said
Rakmat Ali, whose name figured in the NRC of 1951, was present in India at that time and he was an
Indian citizen.
13. The next document exhibited by the petitioner was a voter's list of 1966, in which the said Rakmat
Ali again figures at Sl. No. 176, along with Tafij Mistiri and Gendi Bibi, who are stated to be his parents
and grandparents of the petitioner. Thus, on the basis of this document also, as the name of Rakmat Ali
Page No.# 6/8
figures in the voter's list of 1966, prior to the cutoff date, he can be taken as a citizen of India. Thus, on
the basis of Exhibits 1 and 2, the said Rakmat Ali can be taken to be an Indian citizen.
14. The petitioner projects the said Rakmat Ali as his father. It is well settled that under Section 9 of
the Foreigner's Act 1946, the burden of proving that the proceedee is not a foreigner is upon him or her.
Further, it is well settled by a catena of decisions of this Court and of the Hon’ble Supreme Court that
to discharge that burden under Section 9, the proceedee has to show a linkage through documentary
evidence with an ancestor who was an Indian citizen prior to the cutoff date of 1971.
15. So now it remains to be determined in this case as to whether the petitioner, as proceedee
succeeded in proving this linkage through documentary evidence with his projected father. Exhibit 3 is
the certified copy of the voter's list of 1997, where the name of the petitioner is stated to have figured.
However, the name mentioned as the petitioner is Jagir rather than Jakir. Of course, in his testimony,
the petitioner as DW1 stated that it was wrongly recorded as Jagir instead of Jakir. Another
discrepancy is that the name of his father in Exhibit 3, the voter's list of 1997, is recorded as Rahmat
instead of Rakmat. Here also, the DW1, the petitioner, stated in his deposition that his actual name of
his father is Rakmat Ali rather than Rahmat Ali, as mentioned in the NRC of 1951 and the voter's list of
1966.
16. Another document exhibited is Exhibit 4, which is a voter's list of 2014, in which the name of the
petitioner appears this time as Jakr, and his father's name is mentioned as Rakmat. It is stated that this
time, the petitioner's name has been correctly recorded as also that of his father, unlike the purported
mistake with regard to his name as Jakir in the voter's list of 1997. With regard to these discrepancies,
the petitioner has filed an affidavit, which has been exhibited as Exhibit 5. However, in view of Section
3 of the Indian Evidence Act, stating that a sworn affidavit of declaration by itself would not be
evidence within the meaning of the Indian Evidence Act - the learned Tribunal discarded Exhibit 5, and
we are of the opinion that there is no error or infirmity in such an approach of the Tribunal in
discarding Exhibit 5, the self-affidavit of the petitioner.
17. The learned Tribunal held that due to the discrepancies in the names of the father, the linked
evidence cannot be taken to have been established with the Indian citizen ancestor of the petitioner.
Except for the testimony of the petitioner in his deposition and his self-affidavit, Exhibit 5, which was
rightly discarded by the learned Tribunal - there is no other exhibited documents during the proceeding
to establish that Jagir and Jakir are one and the same person and that Rahmat Ali, mentioned in the
voters' list of 1997 and 2014, is the same person as Rakmat Ali mentioned in the NRC of 1951, Exhibit
Page No.# 7/8
1, and the voters' list of 1966, Exhibit 2.
18. We are of the opinion that the learned Tribunal was not incorrect in opining that it cannot be
automatically held that the Rahmat Ali, figuring in 1951 NRC and voters' list of 1966 - is the Rahmat
Ali figuring in the voters' list of 1997 and 2014. The projected Indian citizen ancestor of the petitioner
with whom the vital documentary link has to be established is mentioned as Rahmat Ali on two
occasions, spanning 1951 to 1966 and when the name of the petitioner appears in the voters' list of
1997 and in 2014, it is with Rahmat Ali, rather than with Rakmat Ali. Even if, for a moment, the
discrepancy with regard to the name Jagir and Md. Jakir is overlooked for the moment - since the
name is mentioned as Jakir along with Rahmat in the voters' list of 2014 - however, the discrepancy
regarding the name of Rahmat Ali vis-a-vis Rakmat Ali remains and cannot be overlooked in our
consideration. The inordinate period from 1966 to 1997 where there is no voters list remains
unexplained and that period is most crucial which covers the cut off date.
19.
Reliance upon the case of Sirajul Hoque (supra) will not come to the aid
of the petitioner. In the said case, while the Hon’ble Supreme Court had laid
down that minor discrepancy in the voters list may be ignored, the same is with
a rider that all other things are to remain consistent. In that case, except a
minor change in the name of the grandfather of the proceedee from Kematullah
to Kefatullah, all other things were consistent. For ready reference, the relevant
observations are extracted hereinbelow:
“3. There is no doubt that the great grandfather`s name Amtullah
appears as Amtullah throughout the document. Equally, there is no doubt
about the father's name which appears as Hakim Ali throughout. The only
discrepancy found is that in some of the documents Kefatullah later
becomes Kematullah. However, what is important to note is that his
father's name Amtullah continues as Amtullah and the other family
members associated continued as such. Also produced are NRC
Registration details of the year 1971 of the grandfather who is noted to
be Kefatullah in this document. Other voters lists are then produced
Page No.# 8/8
where the letter F becomes the letter M with other family names
remaining the same. In fact, the appellant has himself produced a
document of 1981 from the Income Tax Department giving his Permanent
Account Number. Apart from these documents, certain other later
documents have also been produced including photo identity cards issued
by the Election Commission of India and identity cards issued to his
brother including voters lists in which the appellant's name appears.”
20. Further, the decision in Basiron Bibi (supra) relied upon by the respondent’s side held inter-alia
that once the voter list has been adduced in evidence by the petitioner - the petitioner cannot insist that
only that portion of the voter list which goes in favour of the petitioner should be accepted and the
portion against the petitioner should be overlooked. It was held that the documents should be
appreciated as a whole.
21. Consequently, in the instant case and in the backdrop of the above discussion, we have no option
but to come to the considered opinion that during the proceeding, the petitioner as proceedee was
unable to discharge the burden under Section 9 of the Foreigner's Act 1946 and was unable to prove by
cogent documentary evidence his linkage with his ancestor, who was an Indian citizen, prior to the
cutoff date of 25/03/1971.
22. In such view of the matter, we hold that there is no infirmity in the opinion of the learned Tribunal
dated 09/05/2019. The same is accordingly upheld and confirmed being order dated 09/05/2019
passed by the learned Member, Foreigners Tribunal No.2, Nalbari in F.T(Nal-2) Case No. 45/2015.
23. Consequently, the writ petition stands dismissed. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
24. The records be sent back forthwith.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review