Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
-1-
!
#
$
!
"
!
$
%&' % (
)*
'%
)
+
!"#" $% "
"
&
%
' $" "
%
( &
Digitally signed
by SHIVALEELA
DATTATRAYA
UDAGI
Location: HIGH
COURT OF
KARNATAKA
(
)
"
!
"!% %!$$
%#
' $" "
%
( &
(
)
"
$$!$!$ $
#
&
%"
'% "
"
$
" #
"
-2-
(
%#
'% "
!
#
$ $"
%
#
'% "
'
# % #!%!$$ !
!
*
&
*
+
""
# $$"$
#
*
(
!
+
""
%
!
"
# " #
! #%!
$
&
"$
'
%
*
#
"
'
%
*
#
%$#" !$ %
-3-
&
#
'#!
#
*
#
$ #
"
*
""
*
*
"
%"
%" #
%$
(
,
!
*
'"" %
( ' '
#
$$
!!$$! !$
#
! ##
#
#
+
""
.
,
-
&
,
-4-
!"
&
"
$ $
%$%""
.
,
/
(
""
# "
+
!" " ""
(
" "
(
,
&
#$ , -
&
"
"#
#
$
#$
&
(
(
234526 7895:2; <84 =>2 ?2=@=@8524: <@;2: 3 A2A8 :22B@5C
;23D2 8< =>@:
894= =8 E@=>643E =>2 ?2=@=@85 @5 42:?27= 8<
?2=@=@8524
@2
"
3779:26
>2 A2A8 @: =3B25 85 427846
-5-
5 D@2E 8< =>2 A2A8 =>2 ?2=@=@85 @: 6@:A@::26 3:
E@=>643E5 @5 42:?27= 8< ?2=@=@8524
3779:26
&*
"
#
$
>@: ?2=@=@85 @: <@;26 95624
3C34@B
943B:>3
3C3@5:=
=>2
35>@=3 " "
!" " ""
,34@:@5C
3;3H943C@
=>2 <@;2 8<
66;
89=
8:
8<
@D@; (96C2 I (
27=@85: #$
27=@85 #$ 8< 56@35 253;
=8
" " -
3;3H943C@
<84 =>2
"
#
"#
3779:26
$
K-
8" @2
3=@A3 356 =>2@4 A344@3C2 E3: :8;2A5@L26 85 "
8>3AA2635 3E
@5
=3=@85 ?256@5C 85
>3422< @: =>2 >9:H356 8< 42:?85625=
?24 =>2 79:=8A: 8<
>343=@F3
% ,<84 :>84= J
>2 <37=: 8< =>2 73:2 @: =>3=
H43>@A
8<
4@A2
@=F &8A25 8;@72
8<<2572: ?95@:>3H;2 95624
"
:22B@5C =8 G93:> ?487226@5C:
?2=@=@8524: 3779:26
42C@:=2426 HF
4 E
27=@85
' 6
3;@F3
% $$" 3:
9= 8< =>2 E26;87B =>2F
H2C8==25 $ 7>@;6425 356 =>2F >3??@;F ;@D26 =8C2=>24 =@;; =>2 F234
" "
= @: 3;;2C26 @5 =>2 78A?;3@5= =>3= 3<=24 " "
H2@5C =>2 >9:H356 8< 42:?85625=
3779:26
8 " 3;85C E@=> 3779:26
-6-
8 " :=34=26 =8 >343:: 42:?85625=
8 " H8=> ?>F:@73;;F 356
A25=3;;F HF 62A356@5C 366@=@853; 68E4F
@5:@:=26 <84 3 6@D8472 <48A 42:?85625=
625@26
8E2D24 3779:26
E@=> ?2=@=@8524
@2
8"
3779:26
?2=@=@8524:
: :97>
H2<842
42:?85625=' 8;@72
" "
"
"#
" 85
42:?85625=
?2=@=@8524:
#$# 4 E
9H:2G925=;F
<84 E>@7>
$
8:
:>2
" "
>2
@2
=>2
=8
8 " ;86C26 =>2 78A?;3@5=
" "
<84 =>2 8<<2572: ?95@:>3H;2 95624
#
=>2F H8=>
?24<84A26 =>2 :27856 A344@3C2
:3@6 A344@3C2 E3: :9??84=26 HF 3779:26
=>2
3=24
27=@85
@5
4@A2
27=@85: #$ '
#$ 8<
3C3@5:= =>2
=>2 42:?85625=' 8;@72 785697=26
@5D2:=@C3=@85 356 ;3@6 7>34C2 :>22= 3C3@5:= =>2 ?2=@=@8524: HF
3443F@5C =>2A 3: 3779:26
?95@:>3H;2 95624
27=@85
#$ 8<
3C@:=43=2
=88B
8:
=8
27=@85: #$ '
"
<84 =>2 8<<2572:
"#
#
$ 4 E
5 4272@?= 8< =>2 7>34C2 :>22=
78C5@L3572
<84
=>2
3<842:3@6
=>2
8<<2572:
CC4@2D26 HF =>2 :3A2 =>2 ?2=@=@8524: ?42<24426 =>@: ?2=@=@85
:22B@5C =8 G93:> =>2 ?487226@5C:
%
;234526
2346 ;234526 7895:2; <84 =>2 ?2=@=@8524: 356
@C>
894=
8D245A25=
;23624 <84 =>2 42:?85625=
=3=2 :8 3;:8 ;234526 7895:2; <84 42:?85625=
8"
-7-
!
?34= <48A 94C@5C :2D243; 785=25=@85:
;234526
7895:2; <84 =>2 ?2=@=@8524: 785=25626 =>3= 85 8D243;; ?249:3; 8<
=>2 7>34C2 :>22= A3=24@3;:
?2=@=@8524: @ 2
?2=@=@8524
3779:26
3779:26
=>2 3;;2C3=@85: 3C3@5:= =>2:2
8:
=8
=>3= =>2F @5:=@C3=26
=8 @5:@:= 42:?85625=
8 " =8 C2=
366@=@853; 68E4F 356 3;:8 ?34=@7@?3=26 @5 =>2 :27856 A344@3C2
8<
3779:26
E@=>
?2=@=@8524
3779:26
"
77846@5C =8 >@A =>242 342 58 :97> A3=24@3;: <84=>78A@5C @5
=>2 7>34C2 :>22= =>3= 3779:26
A344@3C2 E@=> 3779:26
8"
?24<84A26 =>2 :27856
" 2M72?= =>2 843; :3F 8< 42:?85625=
2 3;:8 785=25626 =>3= 3;; =>2:2 ?2=@=@8524: 342 42:@6@5C
:2?343=2;F 3=
3;3H943C@ 356 =>2 3;;2C3=@85 @5 =>2 7>34C2 :>22=
@: =>3= 3779:26
3779:26
" 3=
?24<84A26 =>2 :27856 A344@3C2 E@=>
25C3;949
5 :97> 7@479A:=3572
=>2
@5D8;D2A25= 8< =>2:2 ?2=@=@8524: @: 7;234;F 89= 8< D25C23572 356
=>242
@: 58 :97>
?2=@=@8524:
:?27@<@7 A3=24@3;
?;3726 3C3@5:=
=>2:2
77846@5C;F ?43F: =8 3;;8E =>2 ?2=@=@85
;234526
7895:2;
<84
42:?85625=
8 " 78A?;3@535= 8??8:26 =>2 ?2=@=@85 HF 785=256@5C =>3= 85
?249:3; 8< =>2 7>34C2 :>22= A3=24@3;: =>242 342
3;;2C3=@85: <84=>78A@5C 3C3@5:= =>2:2 ?2=@=@8524: =>3= =>2F >3D2
-8-
@5:=@C3=26 3779:26
=8 >343:: 42:?85625=
366@=@853; 68E4F
94=>24
8 " =8 H4@5C
=>2 7>34C2 :>22= A3=24@3; 3;:8
6@:7;8:2: =>3= =>2:2 ?2=@=@8524: >3D2 37=@D2;F ?34=@7@?3=26 @5 =>2
:27856 A344@3C2 8< 3779:26
E@=> 3779:26
"
5 :97>
7@479A:=3572 >2 ?43F: =8 6@:A@:: =>2 ?2=@=@85
$
234526
@C>
894=
8D245A25=
;23624 8??8:26
=>2 ?2=@=@85 356 ?43F: =8 6@:A@:: =>2 ?2=@=@85
: 789;6 H2 C3=>2426 <48A 427846:
6@:?9=2 =>3= =>2 A344@3C2 8< 42:?85625=
E@=> 3779:26
' 6 H43>@A
@= @: 58= @5
8 " E3: :8;2A5@L26
>3422< @5 =>2 F234
$$" 356
=>2F >3D2 C8==25 $ 7>@;6425 89= 8< =>2@4 E26;87B
>2
3;;2C3=@85: 3C3@5:= =>2:2 ?2=@=@8524: @5 =>2 7>34C2 :>22= 342
=>3= =>2F >3D2 >343::26 42:?85625=
68E4F
8 " =8 H4@5C 366@=@853;
8E2D24 85 ?249:3; 8< =>2 7>34C2 :>22= A3=24@3;: 356
6879A25=: ?;3726 HF =>2 ;234526 7895:2; =>2:2 ?2=@=@8524: 342
42:@6@5C :2?343=2;F 3E3F <48A =>2 A3=4@A85@3; >8A2 356
<94=>24 3;;2C3=@85 =>3= =>2:2 ?2=@=@8524: >3D2 37=@D2;F @5D8;D26
@5 =>2 :27856 A344@3C2 8< 3779:26
E@=> 3779:26
" @:
785724526 =>2 7>34C2 :>22= A3=24@3;: 6@:7;8:2 =>3= 3779:26
?24<84A26 =>2 :27856 A344@3C2 E@=> 3779:26
" 3=
-9-
25C3;949 @5 =>2 F234 " "
42:?85625=
8 " 95624
2M72?= =>2 843; :=3=2A25= 8<
27=@85
3H:8;9=2;F 58 :97>
A3=24@3;: ?;3726 @5 =>2 7>34C2 :>22= =8 ?48D2 =>3= =>2 3779:26
>36 ?24<84A26 =>2 A344@3C2 E@=> 3779:26
" 3= =>2
@5:=@C3=@85 356 @5D8;D2A25= 8< =>2:2 ?2=@=@8524:
5 :97> 7@479A:=3572 =>2
851H;2
?2M
894= @5 =>2
73:2 8<
42?84=26 @5
! "# $ %&
3= ?343C43?>
8 % >2;6 =>3= =>2
894= :>89;6 H2 7342<9; @5 ?487226@5C 3C3@5:= =>2 6@:=35=
42;3=@D2: @5 74@A2: ?24=3@5@5C =8 A3=4@A85@3; 6@:?9=2: 356
68E4F 623=>:
>2 42;3=@D2: 8< =>2 >9:H356 :>89;6 58= H2
48?26'@5 85 =>2 H3:@: 8< 8A5@H9: 3;;2C3=@85: 95;2:: :?27@<@7
@5:=3572 8< =>2@4 @5D8;D2A25= @5 =>2 74@A2 342 A362 89=
= @:
3;:8 :2==;26 ?8:@=@85 8< ;3E =>3= @< 3 ?24:85 @: A362 =8 <372 3
74@A@53; =4@3; 85 :8A2 C25243; 356 :E22?@5C 3;;2C3=@85: E@=>89=
H4@5C@5C 85 427846 35F :?27@<@7 @5:=3572: 8< 74@A@53; 785697= @=
@: 58=>@5C H9= 3H9:2 8< ?4872:: 8< =>2
894=
>2
894=: ?8:2 3
69=F =8 :9HN27= =>2 3;;2C3=@85 ;2D2;;26 @5 =>2 78A?;3@5= =8 3
=>8489C> :749=@5F =8 <@56 89= E>2=>24 =>242 @: 35F C3@5 8< =49=>
@5 =>2 3;;2C3=@85: 84 E>2=>24 =>2F 342 A362 85;F E@=> =>2 :8;2
- 10 -
8HN27= 8< @5D8;D@5C 724=3@5 @56@D@693;: @5 3 74@A@53; 7>34C2 A842
?34=@79;34;F E>25 3 ?48:279=@85 34@:2 <48A 3 A3=4@A85@3;
6@:?9=2
"
' (
*
94=>24 =>2
85OH;2
#
?2M
894= @5 =>2 73:2 8<
42?84=26 @5
$$ +*) >2;6 @5 ?343
8: "
356 " 3: 956240
)
!
"
#
$
%
$ '
(
&
$ '
$ %
)
- 11 -
, )
!
*+,
#
!
(
.
!
*+,
#
/ .
"
. !
.
#
-
!
*+,
#
.
#
5 =>2 @5:=35= 73:2
3 H342 ?249:3; 8<
7>34C2 :>22= A3=24@3;: 7;234;F :>8E: =>3= =>2 3;;2C3=@85: A362
HF =>2 78A?;3@535= 42:?85625=
8 " 342 D3C92 356 8A5@H9:
=>24 =>35 =>2 3;;2C3=@85: =>3= =>2 >9:H356 @ 2
3779:26
356 >@: <3A@;F A2AH24: A25=3;;F >343::26 >24 E@=> 3 62A356
<84 68E4F =>2 78A?;3@535= >3: 58= ?48D@626 35F :?27@<@7 62=3@;:
- 12 -
84 62:74@H26 35F ?34=@79;34 @5:=3572 8< >343::A25=
A25=@8526 =>2 =@A2
63=2
>2 >3: 58=
?;372 84 3 A35524 @5 E>@7> =>2
3;;2C26 >343::A25= 87794426 84 =>2 62=3@;: 8< =>2 53=942 8<
62A356 84 @=: ?34=@79;34:
>242<842 =>2 7>34C2 :>22= ;37B:
785742=2 356 ?427@:2 3;;2C3=@85:
>2 =24A J7492;=FK 73558= H2
2:=3H;@:>26 E@=>89= :?27@<@7 @5:=3572
>2 :3A2 E23B25: =>2
73:2 8< =>2 ?48:279=@85 356 73:=: :24@89: 689H= 85 =>2
?48H3H@;@=F 8< =>2 D24:@85 8< =>2 78A?;3@535=
>2 A242 C25243;
3;;2C3=@85: 8< >343::A25= E@=>89= ?8@5=@5C 89= =>2 :?27@<@7
62=3@;: E89;6 58= H2 :9<<@7@25= =8 785=@592 74@A@53; ?487226@5C:
3C3@5:= 35F ?24:85
#
= @: :2==;26 ?8:@=@85 8< ;3E =>3=
894=: >3D2 =8 H2
7342<9; 356 739=@89: @5 623;@5C E@=> 78A?;3@5= 356 A9:= =3B2
?43CA3=@7
A3=4@A85@3;
423;@=@2:
@5=8
6@:?9=2:
785:@6243=@85
E>242
=>2
E>@;2
3;;2C3=@85:
623;@5C
>3D2
E@=>
=8 H2
:749=@5@L26 E@=> C423= 7342 356 7@479A:?27=@85 @5 84624 =8
?42D25= A@:7344@3C2 8< N9:=@72 356 3H9:2 8< ?4872:: 8<
5 AF 785:@62426 D@2E
?487226@5C: 3C3@5:= =>2 ?2=@=@8524: @ 2
894=
785=@593=@85 8< 74@A@53;
3779:26
8:
=8
@:
- 13 -
58=>@5C H9= 3H9:2 8< ?4872:: 8<
894=
77846@5C;F
?487226 =8
?3:: =>2 <8;;8E@5C0
@
@@
>2
4@A@53;
2=@=@85 @5 42:?27= 8< ?2=@=@8524
3779:26
>2
4@A@53;
2=@=@85 @5 42:?27= 8< ?2=@=@8524
8: " =8
@@@
@:
# 3779:26
-
8:
=8
@:
-
-
>2 ?487226@5C: 3C3@5:= =>2 ?2=@=@8524: 3779:26
8:
=8
@5
" " - 42C@:=2426 HF
8;@72
!" " ""
3;3H943C@
, 4@A2
@=F &8A25
=3=@85 <84 =>2 8<<2572: ?95@:>3H;2 95624
27=@85: #$ '
#$ 8<
66;
"
"#
#
$ 4 E
27=@85
?42:25=;F ?256@5C 85 =>2 <@;2 8<
@D@; (96C2 356 (
3;3H943C@ @: >242HF
G93:>26
,*
%
@:=
;
8 0 #%
!
!
)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review