Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/11
GAHC010023552017
undefined
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/3013/2017
ALIM UDDIN
S/O. NAZIM UDDIN, VILL. GORUBANDHA, P.O. SANDH KHAITI, P.S.
MAYANG, DIST. MORIGAON.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM and 2 ORS.
REP. BY THE COMM. and SECY. TO THE GOVT. OF ASSAM, REVENUE
DEPTT., DISPUR, GHY.-06.
2:THE DY. COMMISSIONER
MORIGAON
DIST. MORIGAON
ASSAM.
3:THE CIRCLE OFFICER
MAYONG REVENUE CIRCLE
MAYONG
DIST. MORIGAON
ASSAM
Advocate for the Petitioner
: MR.S ISLAM, MR.J AHMED,MS.M AHMED,MS.S R SAIKIA
Advocate for the Respondent : SC, REVENUE, GA, ASSAM
Linked Case : WP(C)/2238/2017
Page No.# 2/11
MD. ALIM UDDIN
S/O. NAZIM UDDIN
VILL. GORUBANDHA
P.O. SANDH KHAITI
P.S. MAYONG
DIST. MORIGAON
ASSAM.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM and 3 ORS.
REP. BY THE COMM. and SECY. THE GOVT. OF ASSAM
REVENUE DEPTT.
DISPUR
GHY.-06.
2:THE DY. COMMISSIONER
MORIGAON
DIST. MORIGAON
ASSAM.
3:THE CIRCLE OFFICER
MAYONG
DIST. MORIGAON
ASSAM.
4:SRI DHARMENDRA BORO
S/O. LT. MAYA RAM BORO
VILL. BALUKAJARI
P.O. BURGAON
P.S. MAYONG
DIST. MORIGAON
ASSAM
PIN-782121.
-----------Advocate for : MR.D BORA
Advocate for : SC
REVENUE appearing for THE STATE OF ASSAM and 3 ORS.
Page No.# 3/11
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE N. UNNI KRISHNAN NAIR
ORDER
Date : 14.07.2026
Heard Mr. J. Ahmed, learned counsel, appearing for the petitioner, in the
above noted 02 (two) writ petitions. Also heard Mr. S. Dutta, learned Standing
Counsel, Revenue & Disaster Management Department and Mr. J. K. Goswami,
learned Additional Senior Government Advocate, appearing for their respective State
Respondents.
2.
The petitioner by way of instituting WP(C).No.2238/2017, has prayed for a
direction upon the Respondent Authorities to appoint the petitioner as Goan Burah
of Bhalukajhari, Pabokati, Hatibhanga, Teteliguri, Koroguri, Gorubandha, Boramari
and Boramari Pam Kisamat villages under Pokorai Mouza of Mayong Revenue Circle,
in the District of Morigaon, in pursuance to an advertisement 16.02.2016, issued for
recruitment against the said post.
The petitioner by way of instituting WP(C).No.3013/2017, has assailed a fresh
advertisement dated 16.05.2017, issued by the Deputy Commissioner, Morigaon, for
recruitment against the post of Goan Burah of Bhalukajhari, Pabokati, Hatibhanga,
Teteliguri, Koroguri, Gorubandha, Boramari and Boramari Pam Kisamat villages
under Pokorai Mouza of Mayong Revenue Circle in the District of Morigaon.
3.
The issues involved in the above noted 02 (two) writ petitions being
identical, with the consent of the parties, the same were taken up for hearing
Page No.# 4/11
analogously and are being disposed of by the present order.
4.
As projected by the petitioner, in pursuance to an advertisement dated
16.02.2016, issued by the Deputy Commissioner, Morigaon, inviting applications
from eligible candidates for recruitment against the post of Gaon Burah of
Bhalukajhari, Pabokati, Hatibhanga, Teteliguri, Koroguri, Gorubandha, Boramari and
Boramari Pam Kisamat villages, under Pokorai Mouza of Mayong Revenue Circle in
the District of Morigaon, the petitioner along with one Dharmendra Boro, had
submitted their respective applications. Thereafter, the petitioner and the said
Dharmendra Boro were issued call letter requiring them to appear in a interview
scheduled on 03.08.2016. It is projected that the interview could not be held on
03.08.2016 and accordingly, the petitioner was issued with a fresh call letter on
21.02.2017, requiring him to appear in the interview now scheduled on 28.02.2017.
It is submitted that the petitioner had accordingly, appeared in the interview held on
28.02.2017, and had performed exceptionally well, therein, and he was expecting
that he being the only candidate in the fray for recruitment against the post of Gaon
Burah, as advertised vide the advertisement dated 16.02.2016, would be favoured
with an order of appointment. However, it is projected that the selection process
held in pursuance to the advertisement dated 16.02.2016, was not taken to its
logical conclusion and apprehending that the Respondent Authorities may readvertise the post, in question, the petitioner had moved before this Court by way
of instituting writ petition being WP(C).No.2238/2017. During the pendency of
WP(C).No.2238 /2017, the Respondent Authorities proceeded to issue a fresh
Page No.# 5/11
advertisement dated 16.05.2017, inviting applications for recruitment against the
post of Gaon Burah, which was earlier put up for recruitment vide the advertisement
dated 16.02.2016.
Being aggrieved by the issuance of the fresh advertisement dated
16.05.2017, the petitioner has assailed the same by way of instituting
WP(C).No.3013/2017.
5.
Mr. J. Ahmed, learned counsel, appearing for the petitioner, after reiterating
the facts noticed, hereinabove, has submitted that the petitioner had the requisite
qualification which were mandated to be processed by a candidate, for appointment
as a Gaon Burah. He submits that the Respondent Authorities had considered his
educational qualification as well as had examined his merit during the interview
process which was conducted by a duly constituted Selection Committee, headed by
the jurisdictional Deputy Commissioner. Mr. J. Ahmed, submits that the Respondent
Authorities, on approaches made by the petitioner before them to know the reasons
for the delay occasioning in finalizing the process of selection involved, had never
intimated to the petitioner that the recruitment process as initiated vide
advertisement dated 16.02.2016, was cancelled on the ground that the performance
of the petitioner during the selection process was found to be not satisfactory. He
submits that the said plea was taken by the Respondents only in an affidavit filed in
the proceedings of WP(C).No.3013/2017 in the year 2022 and that too without
bringing on record any supporting documents to justify such claim taken by the
respondents before this Court.
Page No.# 6/11
6.
Mr. J. Ahmed, further submits that the petitioner being only the eligible
candidate in the fray and there being noting adverse found against him by the
Respondent Authorities, candidature of the petitioner could not have been rejected
by the Respondent Authorities on their own whims and caprices. He submits that
the petitioner had performed well during the interview and there was nothing
adverse coming on record in this connection against him. Accordingly, he submits
that the petitioner being the lone eligible candidate in the fray, the Respondent
Authorities could not have denied to the petitioner his due appointment as Gaon
Burah in pursuance to the advertisement, in question.
7.
Mr. J. Ahmed, has submitted that the Respondent Authorities, had proceeded
to issue fresh advertisement dated 16.05.2017, without issuing any order cancelling
the earlier recruitment process, initiated vide the advertisement dated 16.02.2016.
Mr. Ahmed, submits that the fresh advertisement was so issued basing on the
pressure brought upon by the Respondent Authorities from political circles. Mr.
Ahmed, submits that the Respondent Authorities succumbing to such pressure have
not declared the results of the selection held in pursuance to the advertisement
dated
16.02.2016.
Accordingly,
Mr.
Ahmed
submits
that
the
impugned
advertisement dated 16.05.2017, under challenge, in WP(C).No.3013/2017, would
mandate an interference from this Court.
8.
In the above premises, Mr. J. Ahmed, submits that the Respondent
Authorities, be directed to take the process of selection initiated vide the
advertisement dated 16.02.2016, to its logical conclusion and issue orders
Page No.# 7/11
appointing the petitioner against the post of Gaon Burah as advertised vide the said
advertisement dated 16.02.2016.
9.
Per contra Mr. S. Dutta, learned Standing Counsel, Revenue & Disaster
Management Department, as well as Mr. J. K. Goswami, learned Additional Senior
Government Advocate, appearing for the State Respondents, have submitted that in
pursuance to the advertisement dated 16.02.2016, a interview was scheduled on
28.02.2017, and therein, only the petitioner had appeared, inasmuch as, he was
only the eligible candidate in the fray. It is submitted that the performance of the
petitioner in the interview process not being found to be satisfactory, the selection
Committee had proceeded not to declare the results of the selection process and
accordingly, the said selection process came to be abandoned.
Thereafter, the Respondent Authorities had issued a fresh advertisement on
16.05.2017. It is submitted that the petitioner cannot be permitted to claim that he
must now be appointed irrespective of the fact that on evaluation of his merit by the
Selection Committee during the interview held in the matter, he was found to be not
suitable for being recommended for appointment against the post, in question.
10.
Accordingly, the learned counsels for the Respondents, submit that the
decision of the Respondent Authorities to not take the selection process initiated
vide the advertisement dated 16.02.2016 to its logical conclusion, being so arrived
at basing on reasonable grounds, the same would not mandate an interference from
this Court. Accordingly, they submit that the issuance of the fresh advertisement
was on account of the necessity existing to fill up the post, in question. It is further
Page No.# 8/11
projected that the results of the selection process held in pursuance to the
advertisement dated 16.02.2016, having not been declared, it cannot be contended
by the petitioner that he had performed exceptionally well in the said selection
process. Accordingly, it is submitted that fresh advertisement dated 16.05.2017,
would not mandate an interference from this Court and no direction would be called
upon to be issued requiring the Respondent Authorities, to appoint the petitioner
against the post of Gaon Burah as involved in the present writ petition.
11.
I have heard the learned counsel for the parties and also perused the
materials coming on record.
12.
In pursuance to an advertisement dated 16.02.2016, it is noticed that the
petitioner and one Dharmendra Boro, had submitted their respective applications.
However, Dharmendra Boro, being found to have not satisfied the requisite eligibility
criteria set out for recruitment as a Goan Burah, it was the petitioner who was the
only eligible candidate in the fray, for appearing in the selection process for the
post, in question.
13.
The petitioner, accordingly participated in the selection process and
appeared in an interview held on 28.02.2017. However, after conclusion of the
selection process, the results thereof, not being declared, the petitioner had
instituted WP(C).No.2238/2017. During the pendency of the proceedings in
WP(C).No.2238/2017,
the
Respondent
Authorities
having
issued
a
fresh
advertisement on 16.05.2017, for recruitment against the same post of Gaon Burah
against which the petitioner had already appeared for selection, the petitioner
Page No.# 9/11
proceeded to instituted WP(C).No.3013/2017, assailing the fresh advertisement.
14.
The Respondent Authorities in WP(C).No.2238/2017 have filed an affidavit
on 22.07.2022 and therein, have contended that the performance of the petitioner
in the interview scheduled on 28.02.2017 was found to be not satisfactory by the
selection Committee and accordingly no recommendation came to be made in his
favour.
15.
The contentions as made by the respondents in the said affidavit was not
disputed by the petitioner by way of filing of a rejoinder.
16.
Accordingly, this Court finds that the reason assigned by the respondents
for not taking the selection process to be initiated in pursuance to the advertisement
dated 16.02.2016, to be a cogent one. The petitioner having not been found by the
Selection Committee to be suitable for appointment against the advertised post, it
would not be permissible for this Court to direct the Respondent Authorities to still
appoint the petitioner against the post, in question. The fact that the petitioner was
the sole candidate in the said selection process will not still change the position,
inasmuch as, the petitioner was not found to be suitable for the appointment, in
question, by the Selection Committee.
17.
This Court further notices that the petitioner has not leveled any allegation
of malice, arbitrariness and/or bias against the members of the Selection
Committee. Accordingly, solely on the ground that the petitioner was the only
candidate participating in the selection process, this Court does not found any right
Page No.# 10/11
accruing to the petitioner to claim appointment against the post, in question, when
no recommendation in his favour is found to have been made by the Selection
Committee for such appointment.
18.
In view of the above discussion, the claim made by the petitioner in the
above noticed writ petitions for a direction upon the Respondent Authorities for
appointing him against the post of Gaon Burah, would not mandate an acceptance
by this Court.
19.
Having drawn the above conclusions, this Court would now examine the
challenge presented by the petitioner to the fresh advertisement dated 16.05.2017.
20.
As projected by the Respondents, the fresh advertisement dated
16.05.2017 was mandated to be issued as no recommendation came to be made in
favour of the petitioner (sole candidate) by the Selection Committee in pursuance to
the earlier advertisement dated 16.02.2016. It is further noticed that this Court vide
order dated 22.05.2017, while issuing notice in WP(C).No.3013/2017, had in the
interim kept the advertisement dated 16.05.2017 in abeyance. The said order
continues to hold the field.
21.
Considering the long delay occasioning since issuance of the advertisement
dated 16.05.2017 and the fact that the same remained dormant all along, many
more candidates in the meanwhile having become eligible for appointment as Gaon
Burah, this Court is of the considered view that the said advertisement at this stage
cannot be permitted to be revived and accordingly, the said advertisement dated
Page No.# 11/11
16.05.2017 stands set aside.
22.
The respondents having projected a necessity existing for filling up the post
of Gaon Burah advertised vide the advertisement dated 16.02.2016 and 16.05.2017,
this Court directs the Respondent Authorities to issue fresh advertisement
incorporating, therein, the norms presently in vogue for recruitment against the post
of Gaon Burah/Gaon Pradhan, in question.
23.
At this stage Mr. J. Ahmed, has submitted that the petitioner holds the
requisite eligibility criteria for recruitment against the post of Gaon Burah, in terms
of the eligibility criteria currently in vogue and is also within the age limit for such
recruitment .
24.
It is provided that, in the event, the petitioner satisfies the eligibility criteria
mandated for recruitment for the post of Goan Burah and is within the age limit
prescribed for such recruitment, in the event, the Respondents issue fresh
advertisement for recruitment against the post of Goan Burah, involved in the
present proceedings, the petitioner shall also be permitted to participate in the said
selection.
25.
With the above observations and directions, the above noted writ petitions
being WP(C).3013/2017 and WP(C).2238/2017, stands disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review