Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/9
GAHC010290632023
2026:GAUAS:15223-DB
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/7625/2023
MD AFAZUDDIN
S/O MD. SUKOOR ALI, R/O VILL-GERUAGAON, P.S.-KHATOWAL, DISTNAGAON (ASSAM), PIN-782140
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 5 ORS
TO BE REPRESENTED BY THE MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS, NEW DELHI1
2:THE STATE OF ASSAM
TO BE REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY OF
HOME DEPARTMENT
DISPUR
GUWAHATI
ASSAM
3:THE SUPERINTENDENT OF POLICE (BORDER)
NAGAON
ASSAM
PIN-782001
4:THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER
NAGAON
DIST-NAGAON
ASSAM
PIN-782001
5:THE ASSAM STATE CO-ORDINATOR OF NRC
BHANGAGARH
GUWAHATI-5
Page No.# 2/9
6:THE ELECTION COMMISSIONER OF INDIA
NEW DELH
Advocate for the Petitioner
: S AHMED, MS A HUSSAIN
Advocate for the Respondent : DY.S.G.I., SC, ECI,SC, F.T,GA, ASSAM
BEFORE
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE KALYAN RAI SURANA
HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE PRANJAL DAS
ORDER
07.10.2026
(K.R. Surana, J)
Heard Mr. S. Ahmed, learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr.
Ashim Kr. Choudhury, learned CGC, Mr. G. Sarma, learned Standing Counsel, FT
and Border matters, Mr. N. Kalita, learned counsel appearing on behalf of Mr. A.
I. Ali, learned Standing Counsel, ECI and Mr. P. Sarmah, learned Additional
Senior Govt. Advocate for the State.
2.
In brief, the case of the petitioner is that by an opinion dated 07.12.2016,
passed by the learned Member, Foreigners Tribunal, 3 rd, Nagaon, in F.T. Case
No. NFT.(No.3) 36/2016, arising out of (Police Case No. F.T. 520/05), the
petitioner, namely, Md. Afazuddin was declared to be not a foreigner in between
01.01.1966 to 25.03.1971 stream. Accordingly, the reference being answered,
the same was disposed of.
3.
The petitioner on appearing before the learned Tribunal in connection with
notice received in NFT (No.3) Case No. 517/2016 filed petition no. 613/2023
dated 08.05.2023, inter alia stating that in another proceeding vide NFT (No.3)
36/16 (Police Case No. FT Case No. 520/05), the petitioner was declared to be
Page No.# 3/9
not a foreigner by an opinion dated 07.12.2016. Accordingly, it was prayed that
the petition be admitted and the petitioner be released from the present
proceedings.
4.
On the said petition, the learned Tribunal had summoned one Pradip
Kakati as CW-1, the statement was recorded on 11.07.2023 and accordingly on
the basis of the said statement, the learned Tribunal by placing reliance on
paragraph-26 of the case of Sarbananda Sonowal Vs. Union of India & Anr.
Reported in (2005) 5 SCC 665 was of the view that the Gaon Pradhan could not
state anything regarding the identity of the petitioner as the proceedee in the
earlier proceeding and accordingly, by invoking the principle of per incuriam the
learned Tribunal disagreed with the earlier opinion and directed the present
proceedings to continue.
5.
Accordingly, the learned counsel for the petitioner by referring to the case
of Sital Mandal Vs. Union of India & Ors. WP(C) 2099/2018, decided on
28.04.2022 as well as Abdul Kuddus vs. Union of India & Ors. (2019) 6 SCC 604
was submitted that it is well settled that the principle of res judicata applies in
the proceedings before the learned Tribunal.
6.
It is also submitted that the impugned order dated 29.08.2023 passed by
the learned Member, Foreigners Tribunal 3 rd, Nagaon, Assam, in No. NFT (No.3)
FT 517/16 (Police Case No. 125/15) be set aside and subsequent proceedings
be quashed.
7.
Per contra, the learned Standing Counsel for the FT and Border matters
has submitted that the Tribunal was required to first satisfy itself with regard to
the identity of the petitioner to be the proceedee in the earlier proceeding.
Accordingly, he opposes the prayer made in this writ petition. In support of his
Page No.# 4/9
submission he has placed reliance in the decision of Jamiruddin Mollah Vs. The
Union of India & 5 Ors. in WP(C) No. 4801/2025, decided on 31.10.2026 the
relevant paragraphs are extracted below:“5. Examined the materials available on record. Also considered the submissions made
by the learned counsel at the Bar and also considered the cited cases.
6.
At the outset, it is well settled position that the principles of res judicata in the
proceedings before the Foreigners Tribunal, as held by the Supreme Court of India in
the case of Abdul Kuddus (supra). The relevant observations of the Supreme Court of
India is quoted below:-
"24. The opinion/order of the Tribunal, or the order passed by the Registering
Authority based upon the opinion of the Foreigners Tribunal, as the case may
be, can be challenged by way of writ proceedings. Thus, it would be incorrect
to hold that the opinion of the Foreigners Tribunal and/or the consequential
order passed by the Registering Authority would not operate as res judicata.
Both the opinion of the Tribunal and the Order of the Registering Authority
result in determination of rights/status under the statute and by an authority
after a contest on the merits which would necessarily operate as a bar to
subsequent proceedings before the same authority for re-determination of the
same issue/question. This court in Shrimati Ujjambai v. State of Uttar Pradesh &
Anr., AIR 1962 SC 1621 has held that the principles of res judicata equally apply
to quasi-judicial bodies. Whenever a judicial or quasi-judicial Tribunal gives a
finding on law or fact, its findings cannot be impeached collaterally or in a
second round and are binding until reversed in appeal or by way of writ
proceedings. The characteristic attribute of a judicial act or decision is that it
binds, whether right or wrong. Thus, any error, either of fact or law, committed
by such bodies cannot be controverted otherwise by way of an appeal or a writ
unless the erroneous determination relates to the jurisdictional matter of that
body."
7. The decision of Abdul Kuddus (supra) has been followed in the case of Tarabanu
Begum (supra). The decision of Tarabanu Begum (supra) has been followed in the case
of Swapan Dutta (supra). The application of the principles of res judicata is reiterated
in the case of Rejia Khatun @ Rezia Khatun (supra) and Sital Mandal (supra).
8.
However, in the case of Jahir Ali (supra), this Court, by following the decision of
Page No.# 5/9
the Supreme Court of India in the case of Abdul Kuddus (supra), had reiterated that
principles of res judicata will apply in the proceedings before the Foreigners Tribunals.
Nonetheless, the matter was remanded back to the Foreigners Tribunal with the
following observations, that is quoted herein below:“16. Accordingly, for the reasons recorded above, we allow this petition by
remanding the matter to the concerned learned Tribunal to consider the case of
the petitioner afresh by giving him an opportunity to prove that the present
petitioner, namely, Jahir Ali, aged about 52 years, S/O Nesar Ali @ Mesar Ali,
R/O Ward No.6, PO & PS-Mangaldai, District-Darrang, Assam, is one and the
same person in whose favour an opinion was earlier given by the same Tribunal
on 15.07.2015 in F.T. Case No.771/2012 that he was not a foreigner.
Accordingly, the opinion rendered on 22.11.2018 passed by the learned
Foreigners' Tribunal(1st), Mangaldai, Darrang, in F.T. Case No.860/2007 is set
aside."
8.
In the present case, apart from the notice which has been served on the
petitioner in the purported second proceeding of NFT(No.3) FT 517/2016,
arising out of (Police Case No. 125/15), there is no material to show as to
enable the Court to satisfy itself with the identity of the petitioner to be the one
who has been a proceedee in the previous proceeding of FT Case no. NFT(No.3)
36/2016 arising out of Police Case No. FT 520/05.
9.
In the considered opinion of the Court, in order to apply the principles of
res judicata, it is the first and foremost requirement of the learned Foreigners
Tribunal to determine whether the proceedee in the previous proceeding of F.T.
Case No. NFT.(No.3) 36/2016, arising out of (Police Case No. F.T. 520/05) is the
same person who is arrayed as the proceedee in Petition No. 613/2023 in No.
NFT (No.3) FT 517/16, arising out of (Police Case No. 125/15).
10.
In further considered opinion of the Court, such a determination cannot be
made unless the petitioner files his written statement and produces his
documents on which he intends to rely upon. Only thereafter, the learned
Page No.# 6/9
Tribunal will be able to arrive at a satisfaction that both the proceedees are
same and one person. The State respondents, if so advised, may also produce
evidence before the learned Tribunal to show that the proceedees in both the
cases are two different persons.
11.
In the event, the learned Tribunal arrives at a satisfaction that the
proceedee in both cases is the same, then the learned Foreigners Tribunal shall
be bound to apply the principles of res judicata in light of the law well settled on
the point.
12.
In this regard, the Court is inclined to refer to the decision of the Supreme
Court of India in the case of Abdul Kuddus (supra) Tarabanu Begum (supra),
Swapan Dutta(supra), Rejia Khatun @ Rezia Khatun (supra) and Sital Mandal
(supra).
13.
The Court would also like to deal with the issue as to whether it would be
appropriate for this Court to examine the documents annexed to this writ
petition so as to record its satisfaction that the proceedees in both the cases are
same and one person.
14.
It is in the said context that it would be appropriate to mention that while
exercising a challenge to the orders or opinion passed by the learned Foreigners
Tribunal , this Court exercises certiorari jurisdiction and not appellate or
revisional jurisdiction. Therefore, there are inherent limitations in the power of
the Court while exercising certiorari jurisdiction to examine documents as is
required to be done by the Tribunal as the Court of first instance, and thus,
transforms itself from a writ court to Court exercising original jurisdiction. The
limitations on the power of the Court while exercising certiorari jurisdiction have
been settled by the Supreme Court of India in the case of Central Council for
Page No.# 7/9
Research in Ayurvedic Sciences vs. Bikartan Das, 2023 INSC 733: (2023) 0
Supreme (SC) 763, the paragraph 77 thereof is quoted below:
“77. The purpose of certiorari, as we understand, is only to confine the inferior
tribunals within their jurisdiction, so as to avoid the irregular exercise, or the nonexercise or the illegal assumption of it and not to correct errors of finding of fact or
interpretation of law committed by them in the exercise of powers vested in them
under the statute. The accepted rule is that where a Court has jurisdiction it has a
right to decide every question which crops up in the case and whether its decision is
correct or otherwise, it is bound to stand until reversed by a competent Court. This
Court in G. Veerappa Pillai v. Messrs Raman and Raman Ltd. Kumbakonam, Tanjore
District and Others, (1952) 1 SCC 334 observed:
"26. Such writs as are referred to in Article 226 are obviously intended to
enable the High Court to issue them in grave cases where the subordinate
tribunals or bodies or officers act wholly without jurisdiction, or in excess of it,
or in violation of the principles of natural justice, or refuse to exercise a
jurisdiction vested in them, or there is an error apparent on the face of the
record, and such act, omission, error, or excess has resulted in manifest
injustice. However extensive the jurisdiction may be, it seems to us that it is
not so wide or large as to enable the High Court to convert itself into a court of
appeal and examine for itself the correctness of the decision impugned and
decide what is the proper view to be taken or the order to be made.”
15.
This Court under a similar context had passed an order dated 31.10.2025
in the case of Jamiruddin Mollah vs. Union of India and Ors. WP(C) No. 4801/25
wherein by referring to paragraph nos. 20 to 23 of the case of Hari Vishnu
Kamath vs. Ahmad Ishaque, AIR 1955 SC 233: which is quoted from (1954) 0
Supreme (SC) 175 and held that in the absence of any determination by the
learned Tribunal as to whether or not the proceedees in both cases are same
person or not, if this Court ventures to examine the documents of the petitioner,
then this Court will be exercising original jurisdiction not vested in this Court
while deciding a writ petition under certiorari jurisdiction.
16.
Accordingly, the Court is of the considered opinion that ends of justice
would be met by directing the petitioner to file his written statement as well as
Page No.# 8/9
his evidence and documents in support of his defence, thereupon, the learned
Member, Foreigners Tribunal 3rd, Nagaon shall give an opportunity to the
petitioner, namely, Md. Afazuddin to prove that he as well as the proceedee in
the proceedings of FT Case No. NFT (No.3) 36/2016 is one and the same
person in whose favour the opinion dated 07.12.2026 was rendered by the said
learned Tribunal, declaring that he is not a foreigner.
17.
It would be open to the learned Tribunal to examine the documents
appended to the reference and it would also open to the State to establish that
the petitioner is not the proceedee in the previous proceedings of FT Case No.
NFT (No.3) 36/2016.
18.
However, if it is found that the present petitioner is the same person who
was the proceedee in the proceedings of FT Case No. NFT (No.3) 36/2016, the
subsequent proceeding of NFT (No.3) FT 517/16 arising out of (Police Case No.
125/15) shall be dropped.
19.
Subject to the observations and directions contained in this order, without
interfering with the said order dated 29.08.2023, under challenge, the matter is
remanded back to the said learned Tribunal to decide the matter in accordance
with the directions contained in the order.
20.
The petitioner who is duly represented by his learned counsel shall enter
appearance before the said learned Tribunal on or before 11.11.2026 by
producing a certified copy of the order and also file his written statement along
with all the documents on which he intends to rely upon.
21.
The learned Tribunal shall give reasonable opportunity to the petitioner to
file his evidence and produce witnesses and effort should be made by the
learned Tribunal to dispose of the proceedings within the time prescribed under
Page No.# 9/9
Paragraph 3(14) of the Foreigners (Tribunals) Order, 1964, and/or Paragraph17(14) of the Immigration and Foreigners Order, 2025 as applicable.
22.
The Registry shall return back the Tribunal Records expeditiously.
23.
The writ petition stands disposed of.
24.
There shall be no order as to costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review