Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/47
GAHC010109182025
2026:GAU-AS:8028
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/24/2026
MAYANK BANSAL
(PARTNER - QUANTUM INFRATECH
ASSAM)
ADDRESS HAVING RESIDENCE AT 2ND FLOOR
HOUSE NO. 33
BY-LANE NO. 4
TARUN NAGAR
GUWAHATI
ASSAM- 781005
VERSUS
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 5 ORS.
THROUGH THE SECRETARY
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE
MINISTRY OF FINANCE
NORTH BLOCK
NEW DELHI - 110001
2:STATE OF ASSAM
REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE
GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM
FINANCE AND TAXATION DEPARTMENT
GROUND FLOOR
F BLOCK
JANATA BHAWAN
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-781006
3:DEPUTY DIRECTOR
DGGI GUWAHATI ZONAL UNIT
H.N. 77
RUPKONWAR JYOTI PRASAD AGARWAL ROAD
Page No.# 2/47
OPP. SRIMANTA SANKARDEVA KALAKSHETRA
P.O.- PANJABARI
GUWAHATI-781037
4:ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER
CGST AND CENTRAL EXCISE
GUWAHATI DIVISION-II
GST BHAWAN
KEDAR ROAD
FANCY BAZAAR
GUWAHATI-781001
5:ADDITIONAL COMMISSIONER (APPEALS)
CGST
CENTRAL EXCISE AND CUSTOMS
3RD FLOOR
GST BHAWAN
KEDAR ROAD
MACHKHOWA
GUWAHATI-781001
6:COMMISSIONER
CGST
CENTRAL EXCISE AND CUSTOMS
3RD FLOOR
GST BHAWAN
KEDAR ROAD
MACHKHOWA
GUWAHATI-781001
-----------Advocate for : MR. A M BARUAH
Advocate for : DY.S.G.I. appearing for THE UNION OF INDIA AND 5 ORS.
Linked Case : WP(C)/25/2026
NADAR HUSSAIN
(PARTNER QUANTUM INFRATECH)
ASSAM ADDRESS HAVING RESIDENCE AT FLAT NO-701
FLOOR NO-7
BLOCK-D
SPANISH GARDEN
R G BARUAH ROAD
GUWAHATI-781023
VERSUS
Page No.# 3/47
THE UNION OF INDIA AND 5 ORS.
THROUGH THE SECRETARY
DEPARTMENT OF REVENUE
MINISTRY OF FINANCE
NORTH BLOCK
NEW DELHI - 110001
2:STATE OF ASSAM
REPRESENTED BY THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT.
OF ASSAM
FINANCE AND TAXATION DEPARTMENT
GROUND FLOOR
F BLOCK
JANATA BHAWAN
DISPUR
GUWAHATI-781006.
3:DEPUTY DIRECTOR
DGGI GUWAHATI ZONAL UNIT
H.N . 77
RUPKHOWAR JYOTI PRASAD AGARWAL ROAD
OPP. SRIMANTA SANKARDEVA KALAKHETRA
P.O. PANJABARI
GUWAHATI-781037.
4:ASSISTANT COMMISSIONER
CGST AND CENTRAL EXCISE
GUWAHATI DIVISION-II
GST BHAWAN
KEDAR ROAD
FANCY BAZAAR
GUWAHATI-781001.
5:ADDITIONAL COMMISSIONER (APEALS)
CGST
CENTRAL EXCISE AND CUSTOMS
3RD FLOOR
GST BHAWAN
KEDAR ROAD
MACHKHOWA
GUWAHATI-781001.
6:COMMISSIONER
Page No.# 4/47
CGST
CENTRAL EXCISE AND CUSTOMS 3RD FLOOR
GST BHAVAN
KEDAR ROAD
MACHKHOWA
GUWAHATI-781001.
------------
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE DEVASHIS BARUAH
For the Petitioner(s)
: Mr. B. Raichandani, Advocate
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. S. C. Keyal, Senior Advocate, CGST
: Mr. K. Jain, Advocate
·
Date on which Judgment was reserved
: 12.05.2026
·
Date of Pronouncement of Judgment
: 08.06.2026
·
Whether the pronouncement is of
the Operative Part of the Judgment
: N/A
·
Whether the full Judgment has been
Pronounced
: Yes
JUDGMENT AND ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. B. Raichandani, the learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the Writ Petitioners in both the writ petitions. I have also
heard Mr. S. C. Keyal, the learned Senior counsel assisted by Mr. K.
Jain, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the Respondents.
Page No.# 5/47
PRELUDE:
2.
In both the writ petitions, the Petitioners have assailed the
common Order-in-Original dated 04.02.2025 as well as the Orderin-Appeal dated 26.08.2025 whereby in exercise of powers under
Section 122(1A) of the Central Goods and Service Tax Act, 2017,
(for short, the Act of 2017), the Petitioners in both the writ
petitions have been respectively imposed a penalty equivalent to
the tax evaded by M/S Quantum Infratech, which is a partnership
firm wherein both the Petitioners are partners.
3.
The Petitioners herein have an alternative and efficacious
remedy to file Appeal under Section 112 of the Act of 2017.
However, the Petitioners have approached this Court by challenging
the Order-in-Original dated 04.02.2025 as well as the Order-inAppeal dated 26.08.2025 primarily on two jurisdictional issues,
which were(a)
The penalty in terms of Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017
can be imposed only upon the taxable person i.e. M/S Quantum
Infratech and not the Petitioners who are only partners of the said
firm. The basis of the said contention are the judgments of the
learned Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in the case of
Amit Manilal Haria and Others Vs. Joint Commissioner, CGST and
Page No.# 6/47
Central Excise and Another reported in 2026 SCC OnLine Bom 1510
and Shantanu Sanjay Hundekari Vs. Union of India and Others
reported in 2024 SCC OnLine, Bom 929.
(b)
The second jurisdictional issue is that Section 122(1A) of the
Act of 2017 was given effect to w.e.f. 01.01.2021 and as such, for
the periods prior to 01.01.2021 even assuming, there can be
imposition of penalty under Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017, the
Respondent Authorities could not have imposed penalty for the
period prior to coming into force of Section 122(1A) of the Act of
2017. In that regard, the Petitioners relied upon the judgment of
the Learned Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in Amit
Manilal Haria (supra).
4.
It is relevant at this stage to take note of that M/S Quantum
Infratech, the Partnership Firm wherein the Petitioners are partners
had filed a separate writ petition challenging the Order-in-Original
dated 04.02.2025 and Order-in-Appeal dated 26.08.2025 which
was registered and numbered as WP(C) No.20/2026. In the said
writ petition, the jurisdictional issue which was raised is as to
whether, it is permissible for the Proper Officer to issue a
consolidated Show Cause Notice in terms of Section 74 of the Act
of 2017 and thereupon to pass a consolidated order for various
financial years.
Page No.# 7/47
5.
This Court vide a separate judgment today i.e. 08.06.2026
opined that it is permissible for the Proper Officer to issue a
consolidated Show Cause Notice for various financial years in terms
with Section 74(1) of the Act of 2017 provided the same is
permissible in terms of Section 74(2) of the said Act of 2017. This
Court also opined in the said judgment that it is permissible for the
Proper Officer to pass a consolidated order for different financial
years in terms of Section 74(9) of the said Act of 2017 provided
the same is in consonance with Section 74(10) of the said Act of
2017. This Court had also opined that the doctrine of severability
would duly apply thereby excising from the purview of the said
Show Cause Notice those financial years which were barred for
determination of tax and similarly excising those financial years
which are barred in the consolidated order for determination of
tax.
This Court in the said separate judgment after deciding the
jurisdictional issue granted liberty to M/S Quantum Infratech to file
an appeal within 30 days from the date of the said judgment in
terms of Section 112 of the Act of 2017 and further directed that
till the Appeal is taken up for consideration by the Appellate
Tribunal, the interim order so passed in the said writ proceedings
shall continue, subject to filing the Appeal within 30 (thirty) days
Page No.# 8/47
from the date of the said judgment.
6.
The above perspective is relevant inasmuch as if the questions
which have been urged in the instant proceedings by the
Petitioners are allowed in their favour, then the Order-in-Original
dated 04.02.2025 as well as the Order-in-Appeal dated 26.08.2025,
qua the Petitioners in the instant proceedings can be interfered
with. However, in the circumstances, the jurisdictional questions
which have been urged in the instant proceedings are decided
against the Petitioners, this Court has to grant the liberty to the
Petitioners to approach the Appellate Tribunal. The reason for such
course of action is on the ground that if in terms of the liberty so
granted to the Partnership Firm of the Petitioners herein, the
appeal is preferred before the Appellate Tribunal and thereupon
the Appellate Tribunal interferes with the demand so made in the
Order-in-Original dated 04.02.2025 which have been confirmed by
the Order-in-Appeal dated 26.08.2025, then the imposition of the
penalty, qua the Petitioners in the instant proceedings, would be
impacted.
7.
In the backdrop of the above, the facts which led to the filing
of both the writ petitions are narrated herein under:
Page No.# 9/47
CONSPECTUS OF FACTS:
8.
The Petitioners in both the writ petitions are admittedly the
partners of a partnership firm in the name and style of M/S
Quantum Infratech which is engaged in the business of
construction of residential buildings. A Show Cause Notice was
issued on 03.08.2024 to M/S Quantum Infratech, the Petitioners in
both the writ petitions and one Smti Dejina Begum under Section
74(1) read with Section 122(1A) and Section 122(3)(a) of the Act
of 2017. The said Show Cause proceedings were initiated on the
basis of investigation being carried out against M/S Quantum
Infratech and its partners i.e. the Petitioners herein as well as the
Accountant of the M/S Quantum Infratech. During the course of
investigation, it was alleged that materials were found that there
were evasion of GST on supply of construction of residential
complex to landowners; under revert charge against the supply of
service by way of transfer of development rights; on account of
availment of ineligible ITC during the period from July, 2017 to
March, 2023, etc.
9.
In the said Show Cause Notice, the Proper Officer made
specific allegations against the Petitioners in both the writ petitions
Page No.# 10/47
at paragraph 9.6 and 9.7 which being relevant are reproduced
hereunder.
“9.6
Offences committed by Shri Mayank Bansal (Noticee No.2),
partner of M/s Quantum Infratech GSTIN 18AAAFQ3262E1ZH (Noticee
No.1) and Penalty: Further, Shri Mayank Bansal (Noticee No 2), being the
partner of the Noticee No.1 has concerned himself with the supply of services,
which he knows or has reasons to believe are in contravention of any provisions
of the Act or the rule made thereunder and thus appears to be person who
himself involved in offences specified above at para 9.1 to 9.4. He was liable to
declare the actual turnover and deposit/pay GST accordingly by filing statutory
GST return. Thus, he was well aware about the facts of omission and commission
in evasion of GST. However, he failed to act in accordance to the provisions of
CGST Act, 2017. He also failed to furnish the records/documents including
Customer-wise ledger account of income/outward supply sought vide summons
under Section 70 of the CGST Act, 2017 issued on 30-08-2023 and 01-11-2023
by raising objection to the proceeding vide letter dated 11-09-2023 and 09-112023 which appears to be the afterthought and deliberate attempt to hinder the
process of investigation and to hide the omission and commission done while
reflecting the tax liabilities. Thus, he also found involved in the offences as
described in Section 122(1)(i), Section 122(1)(xv), Section 122(1)(xvii) of the
CGST Act, 2017 as much as that they have suppressed the turnover and supplied
service without issue of any invoices as they collected undisclosed amount in
cash from their customers for supply of service for which they have not issued
any documents including invoices or receipt vouchers or any other documents
disclosing such particulars of receipt and as such have not declared such amount
by filing GST returns. Thus Shri Mayank Bansal (Noticee No.2) appears to have
concerned himself in retaining the benefits of transaction performed by supply of
taxable service without issuance of any Tax invoice and at whose instances such
transaction is conducted and as such rendering himself liable for penalty under
Page No.# 11/47
the provision of Section 122(1A) of CGST Act, 2017 read with similar provision
under Assam GST Act, 2017, which is quoted as under:Quote Section 122(1A) Any person who retains the benefit of a transaction
covered under clauses (i), (ii), (vii) or clause (ix) of sub-section (1) and at whose
instance such transaction is conducted, shall be liable to a penalty of an amount
equivalent to the tax evaded or input tax credit availed of or passed on.
Unquote.
9.7
Offences committed by Shri Nadar Hussain (Noticee No.3),
partner of M/s Quantum Infratech GSTIN 18AAAFQ3262E1ZH (Noticee
No.1) and Penalty: Further, Shri Nadar Hussain (Noticee No.3), being the
partner of the Noticee No.1 has concerned himself with the supply of services,
which he knows or has reasons to believe are in contravention of any provisions
of the Act or the rule made thereunder and thus appears to be person who
himself involved in offences specified above at para 9.1 to 9.4. He was liable to
declare the actual turnover and deposit/pay GST accordingly by filing statutory
GST return. Thus, he was well aware about the facts of omission and commission
in evasion of GST. However, he failed to act in accordance to the provisions of
CGST Act, 2017. He also failed to furnish the records/documents including
Customer-wise ledger account of income/outward supply sought vide summons
under Section 70 of the CGST Act, 2017 issued on 30-08-2023 and 01-11-2023
by raising objection to the proceeding vide letter dated 11-09-2023 and 09-112023 which appears to be the afterthought and deliberate attempt to hinder the
process of investigation and to hide the omission and commission done while
reflecting the tax liabilities. Thus, he also found involved in the offences as
described in Section 122(1)(i), Section 122(1)(xv), Section 122(1)(xvii) of the
CGST Act, 2017 as much as that they have suppressed the turnover and supplied
service without issue of any invoices as they collected undisclosed amount in
cash from their customers for supply of service for which they have not issued
Page No.# 12/47
any documents including invoices or receipt vouchers or any other documents
disclosing such particulars of receipt and as such have not declared such amount
by filing GST returns. Thus Shri Nadar Hussain (Noticee No.3) appears to have
concerned himself in retaining the benefits of transaction performed by supply of
taxable service without issuance of any Tax invoice and at whose instances such
transaction is conducted and as such rendering himself liable for penalty under
the provision of Section 122(1A) of CGST Act, 2017 read with similar provision
under Assam GST Act, 2017.”
10.
In the said Show Cause Notice dated 03.08.2024, the
Petitioners in both the petitions were show caused as to why
penalty under Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017 read with the
Assam Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (for short ‘the Assam
Act’) should not be imposed upon them for acts of involvement in
evasion of GST and committing offence as mentioned in Paragraph
Nos. 9.6 and 9.7 of the said notice.
11. It is an admitted fact as would be seen from the materials on
record that the Petitioners herein did not submit any reply to the
allegations contained in Paragraph Nos. 9.6 and 9.7 of the Show
Cause Notice. Be that as it may, the Petitioners as well as the
authorized representative of M/S Quantum Infratech appeared for
personal hearing and pursuant thereto, the Order-in-Original dated
04.02.2025 was passed whereby the Proper Officer, amongst
others, categorically came to the opinion that both the Petitioners
Page No.# 13/47
failed to act in accordance with the provisions of the Act of 2017
and were found involved in offences as described in Section 122(1)
(i), 122(1)(xv), Section 122(1)(xvii) of the Act of 2017. It was also
opined in the Order-in-Original that both the Petitioners collected
undisclosed amounts in cash from their customers for supply of
service for which they did not issue any documents including
invoices or receipt vouchers or any other documents disclosing
such particulars of receipts and have concerned themselves in
retaining the benefits of the transaction performed by supply of
taxable service without issuance of any tax invoice. It was also
opined that it was at the instance of both the Petitioners such
transactions were conducted, and as such they were liable for
penalty under Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017 read with similar
provisions under the Assam Act.
12. The resultant effect was that both the Petitioners have been
imposed with penalty under Section 122(1A) to the extent of the
evaded tax.
13. Being aggrieved, M/S Quantum Infratech filed 6 (six) Appeals
against the Order-in-Original dated 04.02.2025 and the Petitioners
herein filed individual Appeals before the Appellate Authority.
Page No.# 14/47
14. The 8 (eight) appeals were taken up together for adjudication
by the Appellate Authority and vide the Order-in-Appeal dated
26.08.2025, all the appeals were dismissed, thereby confirming to
the Order-in-Original dated 04.02.2025 passed by the Adjudicating
Authority. It is under such circumstances both the writ petitions
were filed before this Court.
15. The learned Coordinate Bench of this Court vide an order
dated 07.01.2026 issued notice in both the writ petitions and
further directed that no coercive actions be taken in pursuance to
the orders passed by the Respondent Authorities against the writ
petitioners. The interim order thereupon had been extended from
time to time.
SUBMISSIONS MADE ON BEHALF OF THE LEARNED COUNSELS FOR
THE PARTIES:
16. Mr. B. Raichandani, the learned counsel appearing on behalf of
the Petitioners submitted that the transactions covered by Clause
(i), (ii), (vii) and (ix) of Sub-Section (1) of Section 122 of the Act of
2017 can only be committed by the taxable person, and therefore,
no other person other than the taxable person can be imposed the
penalty in terms with Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017. The
Page No.# 15/47
learned counsel submitted that in the instant case, the taxable
person is M/S Quantum Infratech and therefore the imposition of
penalty upon the Petitioners under Section 122(A) of the Act of
2017 was beyond the powers conferred upon the Proper Officer to
do so and as such, the impugned Order-in-Original dated
04.02.2025
as
well
as
impugned
Order-in-Appeal
dated
26.08.2025, insofar as penalty have been imposed upon the
Petitioners are required to be interfered with. In that regard, he
has referred to the judgments of the learned Division Bench of the
Bombay High Court in the case of Shantanu Sanjay Hundekari
(supra) and Amit Manilal Haria (supra) and submitted that the
learned Division Bench of the Bombay High Court had categorically
held in both the judgments that the penalty in terms of Section
122(1A) of the Act of 2017 has necessarily to be imposed upon the
taxable person inasmuch as the contravention can only be
committed by the taxable person. The learned counsel referred to
Paragraph Nos. 22 and 23 of the judgment of the learned Division
Bench of the Bombay High Court in the case of Amit Manilal Haria
(supra) to substantiate his submissions.
17. The learned counsel further submitted that the judgment in
the case of Amit Manilal Haria (supra) is based upon the judgment
of the Bombay High Court in the case of Shantanu Sanjay
Page No.# 16/47
Hundekari (supra) and the revenue had preferred an appeal before
the Supreme Court challenging the judgment in the case of
Shantanu Sanjay Hundekari (supra). The Supreme Court vide an
order dated 24.01.2025 in the case of Union of India Vs. Shantanu
Sanjay Hundekari reported in 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1358 dismissed
the said Special Leave Petition. The learned counsel therefore
submitted that applying the said law laid down by the learned
Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in Shantanu Sanjay
Hundekari (supra) as regards the interpretation to Section 122(1A)
of the Act of 2017, the Petitioners herein being not the taxable
person, they could not have been imposed penalty in terms with
Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017.
18. The learned counsel for the Petitioners further submitted that
a perusal of the Show Cause Notice dated 03.08.2024, the Orderin-Original dated 04.02.2025 as well as the Order-in-Appeal dated
26.08.2025 show that in respect to the period from 2017-18 to
2022-23, the proceedings were initiated and concluded. He
submitted that Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017 was inserted by
the Finance Act, 2020 w.e.f 01.01.2021 and therefore, for the
periods prior to 01.01.2021, no penalty could have been imposed
under Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017 upon the Petitioners even
assuming for argument sake though not admitting that penalty
Page No.# 17/47
under Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017 can be imposed upon the
Petitioners. In that regard, the learned counsel further referred to
the judgment of the learned Division Bench of the Bombay High
Court in the case of Amit Manilal Haria (supra) wherein this specific
issue was taken into consideration and it was held that a person
cannot be penalized under the law/provision which was not in force
for the period in which such alleged act are stated to have been
committed. Paragraph Nos. 29 and 30 of the said judgment was
relied upon.
19. Mr. S. C. Keyal, the learned Senior counsel appearing on behalf
of the Respondents submitted that a perusal of Section 122 of the
Act of 2017 would show that the Legislature imposed penalty
under Sub-Section (1) of Section 122 of the Act of 2017 upon the
taxable person whereas the Legislature in Sub-Section (1A) and (3)
of Section 122 of the Act of 2017 have referred to “any person”.
The learned Senior counsel further submitted that Sub-Section (2)
of Section 122 of the Act of 2017 refers to a “registered person”
and not a “taxable person” or “any person”. The learned Senior
counsel therefore submitted that when the Legislature had
specifically differentiated in Section 122 of the Act of 2017, the
different types of persons, namely the “taxable person”, “any
person”, “registered person”, to arrive at a conclusion that the term
Page No.# 18/47
“any person” mentioned in Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017
would mean the “taxable person” would not only be contrary to the
Act of 2017 but would also amount to rewriting the provision of
Sub-Section (1A) of Section 122 of the Act of 2017.
20. The learned Senior counsel further submitted that Section 2 of
the Act of 2017 provides various definitions. The term “person” is
defined in Section 2(84) of the Act of 2017. Section 2(94) of the
Act of 2017 defines the term “registered person” whereas Section
2(107) defines the term “taxable person”. He therefore submitted
that when the Act of 2017 specifically defines the various types of
persons, i.e. “person”, “registered person” and “taxable person”
and uses the same in Section 122 of the Act of 2017 separately,
the opinion of the learned Division Bench of the Bombay High
Court rendered in the case of Shantanu Sanjay Hundekari (supra)
and Amit Manilal Haria (supra) cannot be said to be the correct law
laid down. In that regard, the learned Senior counsel also
submitted that in the case of Gurudas Mallik Thakur and Another
Vs. Commissioner of Goods and Service Tax and Another reported
in 2025 SCC Online Del 3108, the Delhi High Court had
categorically dealt with this issue and held that Section 122(1A) of
the Act of 2017 refers to such person who retains the benefit of
the transaction.
Page No.# 19/47
21. The learned Senior counsel also submitted that insofar as the
contention so made by the learned counsel appearing on behalf of
the Petitioners that Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017 have been
retrospectively applied, the learned Senior counsel referring to the
judgment of the Delhi High Court in the case of Bhupender Kumar
Vs. Additional Commissioner Adjudication, CGST Delhi North and
Others reported in 2025 SCC OnLine Del 4848 submitted that
Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017 shall implicate such individuals
who may be involved in such fraudulent transactions and the said
law cannot be set at naught by holding the same to be not
retrospectively applicable to transactions which took place prior to
the date when the law was enacted. The learned Senior counsel
submitted that what is required is on the day when the show cause
notice was issued, the provision of Section 122(1A) of the Act of
2017 was in place.
ANALYSIS AND DETERMINATION:
22. The points for determination in the present proceedings are:(i)
Whether the Petitioners in both the writ petitions who
are admittedly partners of M/S Quantum Infratech (the
taxable person) can be imposed penalty under Section
122(1A) of the Act of 2017?
Page No.# 20/47
(ii)
In the circumstance, the point for determination No.(i)
is
decided
against
the
Petitioners,
whether
the
provisions of Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017 can be
applied for the period prior to 01.01.2021 which is the
date of coming into force of Section 122(1A) of the Act
of 2017?
FIRST POINT FOR DETERMINATION:
23. Section 122 of the Act of 2017 being relevant is reproduced
herein under:
“122. Penalty for certain offences
(1)
Where a taxable person who––
(i)
supplies any goods or services or both without issue of any invoice or
issues an incorrect or false invoice with regard to any such supply;
(ii)
issues any invoice or bill without supply of goods or services or both
in violation of the provisions of this Act or the rules made
thereunder;
(iii)
collects any amount as tax but fails to pay the same to the
Government beyond a period of three months from the date on
which such payment becomes due;
Page No.# 21/47
(iv)
collects any tax in contravention of the provisions of this Act but fails
to pay the same to the Government beyond a period of three months
from the date on which such payment becomes due;
(v)
fails to deduct the tax in accordance with the provisions of subsection (1) of section 51, or deducts an amount which is less than
the amount required to be deducted under the said sub-section, or
where he fails to pay to the Government under sub-section (2)
thereof, the amount deducted as tax;
(vi)
fails to collect tax in accordance with the provisions of sub-section
(1) of section 52, or collects an amount which is less than the
amount required to be collected under the said sub-section or where
he fails to pay to the Government the amount collected as tax under
sub-section (3) of section 52;
(vii)
takes or utilises input tax credit without actual receipt of goods or
services or both either fully or partially, in contravention of the
provisions of this Act or the rules made thereunder;
(viii) fraudulently obtains refund of tax under this Act;
(ix)
takes or distributes input tax credit in contravention of section 20, or
the rules made thereunder;
(x)
falsifies or substitutes financial records or produces fake accounts or
documents or furnishes any false information or return with an
intention to evade payment of tax due under this Act;
(xi)
is liable to be registered under this Act but fails to obtain registration
Page No.# 22/47
(xii)
furnishes any false information with regard to registration particulars,
either at the time of applying for registration, or subsequently;
(xiii) obstructs or prevents any officer in discharge of his duties under this
Act;
(xiv) transports any taxable goods without the cover of documents as may
be specified in this behalf;
(xv)
suppresses his turnover leading to evasion of tax under this Act;
(xvi)
fails to keep, maintain or retain books of account and other
documents in accordance with the provisions of this Act or the rules
made thereunder;
(xvii) fails to furnish information or documents called for by an officer in
accordance with the provisions of this Act or the rules made
thereunder or furnishes false information or documents during any
proceedings under this Act;
(xviii) supplies, transports or stores any goods which he has reasons to
believe are liable to confiscation under this Act;
(xix)
issues any invoice or document by using the registration number of
another registered person;
(xx)
tampers with, or destroys any material evidence or document;
(xxi)
disposes off or tampers with any goods that have been detained,
seized, or attached under this Act,
Page No.# 23/47
he shall be liable to pay a penalty of ten thousand rupees or an amount
equivalent to the tax evaded or the tax not deducted under section 51 or
short deducted or deducted but not paid to the Government or tax not
collected under section 52 or short collected or collected but not paid to the
Government or input tax credit availed of or passed on or distributed
irregularly, or the refund claimed fraudulently, whichever is higher.
(1A)
[Any person who retains the benefit of a transaction covered under
clauses (i), (ii), (vii) or clause (ix) of sub-section (1) and at whose
instance such transaction is conducted, shall be liable to a penalty of
an amount equivalent to the tax evaded or input tax credit availed of
or passed on.]
(1B)
[Any electronic commerce operator, who is liable to collect tax at
source under section 52]
(i)
allows a supply of goods or services or both through it by an
unregistered person other than a person exempted from
registration by a notification issued under this Act to make
such supply;
(ii)
allows an inter-State supply of goods or services or both
through it by a person who is not eligible to make such interState supply; or
(iii)
fails to furnish the correct details in the statement to be
furnished under sub-section (4) of section 52 of any outward
supply of goods effected through it by a person exempted
from obtaining registration under this Act,
Page No.# 24/47
shall be liable to pay a penalty of ten thousand rupees, or an amount
equivalent to the amount of tax involved had such supply been made
by a registered person other than a person paying tax under section
10, whichever is higher.]
(2)
Any registered person who supplies any goods or services or both on which
any tax has not been paid or short-paid or erroneously refunded, or where
the input tax credit has been wrongly availed or utilized,
(a)
for any reason, other than the reason of fraud or any wilful
misstatement or suppression of facts to evade tax, shall be liable to
a penalty of ten thousand rupees or ten per cent of the tax due from
such person, whichever is higher;
(b)
for reason of fraud or any wilful misstatement or suppression of facts
to evade tax, shall be liable to a penalty equal to ten thousand
rupees or the tax due from such person, whichever is higher.
(3)
Any person who––
(a)
aids or abets any of the offences specified in clauses (i) to (xxi) of
subsection (1);
(b)
acquires possession of, or in any way concerns himself in
transporting, removing, depositing, keeping, concealing, supplying,
or purchasing or in any other manner deals with any goods which he
knows or has reasons to believe are liable to confiscation under this
Act or the rules made thereunder;
(c)
receives or is in any way concerned with the supply of, or in any
Page No.# 25/47
other manner deals with any supply of services which he knows or
has reasons to believe are in contravention of any provisions of this
Act or the rules made thereunder;
(d)
fails to appear before the officer of central tax, when issued with a
summon for appearance to give evidence or produce a document in
an inquiry;
(e)
fails to issue invoice in accordance with the provisions of this Act or
the rules made thereunder or fails to account for an invoice in his
books of account,
shall be liable to a penalty which may extend to twenty-five thousand
rupees.”
24. This Court also finds it relevant to take note of the definition
of the terms “person”, “taxable person” and “registered person”.
The term “person” has been defined in Section 2(84) of the Act of
2017. The said Sub-Section (84) of Section 2 of the Act of 2017
being relevant is reproduced herein under:
“(84) “person” includes—
(a)
an individual;
(b)
a Hindu Undivided Family;
(c)
a company;
Page No.# 26/47
(d)
a firm;
(e)
a Limited Liability Partnership;
(f)
an association of persons or a body of individuals, whether
incorporated or not, in India or outside India;
(g)
any corporation established by or under any Central Act, State Act or
Provincial Act or a Government company as defined in clause (45) of
section 2 of the Companies Act, 2013 (18 of 2013);
(h)
any body corporate incorporated by or under the laws of a country
outside India;
(i)
a co-operative society registered under any law relating to cooperative societies;
(j)
a local authority;
(k)
Central Government or a State Government;
(l)
society as defined under the Societies Registration Act, 1860 (21 of
1860);
(m)
trust; and
(n)
every artificial juridical person, not falling within any of the above;”
25. From a perusal of the above quoted Sub-Section, it would
Page No.# 27/47
show that the term “person” includes various entities including an
individual. One can say it to be the genus of different types of
persons.
26. Section 2(107) defines the term “taxable person”. The said
definition being relevant is reproduced herein under:
“2(107)
“taxable person” means a person who is registered or liable to be
registered under section 22 or section 24;”
27. A perusal of the above definition would show that a taxable
person is a person who is registered or liable to be registered
under Section 22 or Section 24 of the Act of 2017. In other words,
the person who makes a taxable supply of goods or services or
both with an aggregate turnover of a particular amount. The
taxable person is a species of the term “person” who is registered
or liable to be registered under the Act of 2017.
28. Section 2(94) defines the term “registered person” and the
said definition being relevant is reproduced herein under:
“2(94) “registered person” means a person who is registered under section 25 but
does not include a person having a Unique Identity Number;”
The “registered person” would be a sub-species of a “taxable
Page No.# 28/47
person”.
29. Therefore, a conjoint reading of Sections 2(84), 2(107) and
2(94) of the Act of 2017 would show that “person” would include
various entities whereas a “taxable person” is a person who is
liable to be registered under Section 22 or 24 of the Act of 2017
and includes a registered person whereas a “registered person” is
a person who is registered under Section 25 of the Act of 2017.
In the backdrop of the above, let this Court analyze Section 122
of the Act of 2017.
30. Sub-Section (1) of Section 122 of the Act of 2017 specifically
refers to “taxable person” and further stipulates the penalties that
can be imposed upon the “taxable person” who commits various
violations or omits to carry out certain requirements as mentioned
in Clauses (i) to (xxi) of Section 122(1) of the Act of 2017.
31. Sub-Section (1A) of Section 122 of the Act of 2017 however
comes into play in respect to transactions covered under Clauses
(i), (ii), (vii) and (ix) of Sub-Section (1) of Section 122 of the Act of
2017. The said Sub-Section (1A) of Section 122 of the Act of 2017
refers to “any person”. A further perusal of Sub-Section (1A) of
Section 122 of the Act of 2017 further qualifies the term “any
Page No.# 29/47
person” who would come within the ambit of Sub-Section (1A) of
Section 122 of the Act of 2017. There is twin requirement to come
within the scope of Sub-Section (1A) of Section 122 of the Act of
2017. They are:
(a) the person who retain the benefit of the transactions covered
under clauses (i), (ii), (vii) and (iv) of Sub-Section (1) of Section
122 of the Act of 2017; and
(b)
it is at the instance of that person such transaction was
conducted.
32. Another aspect which is of relevance is the person to be
identified to come within the scope of Section 122(1A) of the Act of
2017 is upon the adjudication carried out under Section 122(1) in
respect to a taxable person who had committed the violations as
stipulated in Clauses (i), (ii) (vii) and (ix) of Section 122(1) of the
Act of 2017.
33. Let this Court further proceed on the analysis of Section 122
of the Act of 2017. Sub-Section (2) of Section 122 of the Act of
2017 categorically refers to the term “any registered person”
whereas Sub-Section (3) of Section 122 of the Act of 2017 refers to
“any person”.
Page No.# 30/47
34. The above analysis of Section 122 of the Act of 2017 and
more particularly Sub-Sections (1), (1A), (2) and (3) of Section 122
would show that the Legislature had identified which "person"
would be liable for the penalty. The Legislature in the opinion of
this Court having analyzed the requirement and with specific intent
inserted Sub-Section (1A) after Sub-Section (1) of Section 122 of
the Act of 2017. The Legislature could have inserted or merged the
contents of Sub-Section (1A) of Section 122 with Sub-Section (3)
of Section 122 of the Act of 2017. But it appears from the
legislative intent that Sub-Section (1A) was inserted after SubSection (1) specifically to deal with the person who retained the
benefits of a transaction and at whose instance such transaction
was conducted by the taxable person. At the cost of repetition, a
taxable person includes a person who is liable to be registered or a
person who is registered. In that process Sub-Section (1A) of
Section 122 of the Act of 2017 envelops both a registered person
as well as a person who is liable to be registered.
35. Let this Court now take the submission of the learned counsel
for the Petitioners that the taxable person can only commit the
violations stipulated in Clauses (i), (ii), (vii) and (ix) of Section
122(1) of the Act of 2017 and this contention had been upheld by
the learned Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in Shantanu
Page No.# 31/47
Sanjay Hundekari (supra) and Amit Manilal Haria (supra).
36. It is the opinion of this Court that the said submission is
misconceived. In fact, the said submission is too narrow an
interpretation to the provision of Section 122 of the Act of 2017
and more particularly taking into consideration the definition of
“person”, “taxable person” and “registered person”. True, if the
taxable person is the sole proprietor or an individual who solely is
responsible for the commission of the violations contained in
Clauses (i), (ii), (vii) and (ix) of Section 122(1) of the Act of 2017,
then the taxable person would be the person as mentioned in SubSection (1A) of Section 122 of the Act of 2017. But let this Court
take the example of a Company, LLP, Partnership Firm, or any
juridical person which is the taxable person. Can the Company, LLP,
Partnership Firm or any juridical person on its own without the
involvement of a natural person commit the violations as
mentioned in clauses (i), (ii), (vii) and (ix) of Section 122(1) of the
Act of 2017. The answer would be a simple “No”.
37. Therefore with great respect, this Court cannot agree with the
proposition of law laid down by the learned Division Bench of the
Bombay High Court in Shantanu Sanjay Hundekari (supra) and
Amit Manilal Haria (supra). It is the opinion of this Court that the
Page No.# 32/47
proposition of law laid down by the learned Division Bench of the
Bombay High Court in Shantanu Sanjay Hundekari (supra) and
Amit Manilal Haria (supra) if accepted, it would render the
provision of Sub-Section (1A) of Section 122 of the Act of 2017
otiose and nugatory.
38. The opinion herein rendered by this Court finds support from
the observation of the learned Division Bench of the Delhi High
Court in the Gurudas Mallik Thakur (supra). Paragraphs 27 and 29
of the said judgment are reproduced hereunder:
“27. The purpose of section 122(1A) of the CGST Act is clearly to make persons who
may be responsible for having created bogus invoices and having utilised ITC without
the receipt of goods and services and for distributing ITC in contravention of section
20 of the CGST Act. It can be seen that the manner in which companies function is
that there is a management who would be taking the decisions on behalf of taxable
persons. These companies being inanimate, the responsibility has, by the wisdom of
the Legislature, been fixed under section 122(1A) of the CGST Act upon any person
who retains the benefits of a transaction.
29. Such activities would have a greater financial impact on society in general and
the economy in particular, therefore section 122(1A) of the CGST Act has been enacted
to also make such persons liable under these circumstances.”
39. In the backdrop of the above, it is relevant to take note of that
the Petitioners herein in both the writ petitions in spite of the
allegations contained at Paragraph Nos. 9.6 and 9.7 of the Show
Cause Notice dated 03.08.2024 did not submit any reply denying to
Page No.# 33/47
those allegations. The Order-in-Original dated 04.02.2025 points
out that it is at the instance of the Petitioners herein that
transactions were committed by M/S Quantum Infratech and the
Petitioners herein have retained the benefit of the transactions.
40. The findings of the Proper Officer at Paragraphs 20.6 and 20.7
of the Order-in-Original dated 04.02.2025 have been affirmed by
the
Appellate
Authority
in
the
Order-in-Appeal
and
more
particularly, paragraph 21(J).
41. Under such circumstances, it is therefore the opinion of this
Court that in view of the two conditions being satisfied by the fact
finding authority that the Petitioners herein have retained the
benefit of the transactions covered under Clause (i) and Clause
(vii) of Sub-Section (1) of Section 122 of the Act of 2017 and at
their instance, such transactions were conducted, the Petitioners
herein would come within the ambit of Section 122(1A) of the Act
of 2017 and would be liable to the penalty.
42. The above therefore answers the first point for determination.
SECOND POINT FOR DETERMINATION:
43. For deciding the present point for determination, this Court
Page No.# 34/47
finds it relevant to take note of how the learned Division Bench of
the Bombay High Court as well as the Delhi High Court dealt with
the issue as to the applicability of Section 122(1A) of the Act of
2017 which came into operation w.e.f. 01.01.2021. The learned
Division Bench of the Bombay High Court in the case of Amit
Manilal Haria (supra) observed at Paragraph Nos. 29 and 30 as
herein under:
“29.
The other contention as urged on behalf of the petitioners is that the
competent authority did not have jurisdiction to retrospectively apply the
provisions of sub-section (1A) of section 122 which came to be incorporated
in the CGST Act by Act No. 12 of 2020 with effect from January 1, 2021.
Admittedly, the period in question, subject matter of the show-cause notice
is the period from July 2017 to July 2023. Thus, according to the petitioners,
the period from July 2017 to January 1, 2021 is the period, when such penal
provision was not in existence. Thus, there could not have been any
retrospective application of any penalty provision. The law in this regard is
well-settled including considering the clear provision of article 20(1) of the
Constitution which reads thus:
“20. Protection in respect of conviction for offences.—(1) No person
shall be convicted of any offence except for violation of a law in force
at the time of the commission of the act charged as an offence, nor
be subjected to a penalty greater than that which might have been
inflicted under the law in force at the time of the commission of the
offence.
(2)….” (emphasis [ Here printed in italics.] supplied)
30.
Thus, a person cannot be penalised under the law/provision which was not
in force for the period in which such alleged acts are stated to have been
Page No.# 35/47
committed. There could not have been any retrospective application of
section 122(1A) of the CGST Act in issuing the impugned show-cause notice
for the period July 2017 to January 1, 2021, and for such reason also the
impugned order-in-original insofar as such period is concerned, cannot be
sustained.”
44. From the above quoted paragraphs, it would be seen that the
learned Division Bench of the Bombay High Court held that as the
Show Cause Notice was for the period from July, 2017 to July,
2023, and the period from July, 2017 to 1st January, 2021 is the
period when Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017 was not in
existence, there could not have been any retrospective application
of any penalty provision. The learned Division Bench of the
Bombay High Court arrived at the said opinion on the basis of
Article 20(1) of the Constitution which stipulates that no person
shall be convicted of any offence except for violation of law in
force at the time of commission of the act charged as an offence,
nor the person be subjected to a penalty greater than that which
might have been inflicted under the law in force at the time of
commission of the offence.
45. On the other hand, the learned Division Bench of the Delhi
High Court in the case of Bhupender Kumar (supra) observed at
paragraph Nos.24 and 25 as herein under:
Page No.# 36/47
“24. In so far as the retrospective application of Section 122(1A) of CGST Act is
concerned, the same would be governed by the date of the SCN. The SCN
was issued on 8th March, 2024. The law has been clearly amended to also
implicate such individuals who may be involved in such fraudulent
transactions and the said law cannot be set at naught by holding the same to
not be retrospectively applicable to transactions which took place prior to the
date when the law was enacted. On the day when the SCN was issued, the
provision Section 122 (1A) was in place.
25.
The manner in which fraudulent ITC has been availed would also show that it
was a continuous process and not a one time act of the parties involved.
Under such circumstances Section 122(1A) of the CGST Act was clearly
applicable.”
46. The above quoted paragraphs would show that the learned
Division Bench of the Delhi High Court observed that retrospective
application of Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017 would be
governed by the date of the Show Cause Notice. In that case, the
Show Cause Notice was issued on 08.03.2024 and as on that date,
the law clearly implicated such individuals who may be involved in
such fraudulent transactions and the said law cannot be set at
naught by holding the same to not be retrospectively applicable to
transactions which took place prior to the date when the law was
enacted. It was also observed that the date when the Show Cause
Notice was issued, the provisions of Section 122(1A) of the Act of
2017 was in place. The learned Division Bench of the Delhi High
Court had also observed that the manner in which the fraudulent
Page No.# 37/47
ITC had been availed would also show that it was a continuous
process and not a one time act of the parties involved for which
Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017 was clearly applicable.
47. At this stage, this Court also finds it relevant to note that in
the case of Mukesh Kumar Garg Vs. Union of India and Others
reported in 2025 SCC OnLine Del 3324, two questions arose for
consideration before the learned Division Bench of the Delhi High
Court. One was as to whether the penalty under Section 122(1A)
of the Act of 2017 could have been imposed upon any person
other than the “taxable person” and the second, on the
retrospective application of Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017. The
learned Division Bench of the Delhi High Court was not inclined to
entertain the instant writ petition on those two issues and granted
liberty to the Petitioner therein to avail remedies under Section 107
of the Act of 2017. A Special Leave to Appeal was filed before the
Supreme Court which was registered and numbered as Special
Leave to Appeal (Civil) No.18178/2025. The said Appeal is
presently pending. The Supreme Court vide an order dated
04.08.2025 granted leave and passed an order of stay on the
recovery of the amount subject to deposit of 25% of the demand
before the GST Department. The said order dated 04.08.2025
being relevant is reproduced herein under:
Page No.# 38/47
“1.
Two primary contentions have been raised. First, Section 122(1) of the
Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (for short ‘the Act’) would not
be applicable to the petitioner as he is a non-taxable person. Secondly,
the provisions of Section 122 (1A) of the Act which came into force w.e.f.
01.01.2021 cannot be applied retrospectively for the Assessment Years
2017- 2020.
2.
Leave granted.
3.
In the meanwhile, there shall be stay on the recovery of the amount
directed to be deposited provided the appellant deposits 25% of the
demand before the GST Department either through Electronic Ledger or
through Cash Ledger.”
48. In the backdrop of the above, let this Court now consider as to
whether Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017 can be applied
retrospectively or whether there is any requirement to apply
Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017 retrospectively.
49. Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017 applies to person who(a) retains the benefit of a transaction covered under Clauses (i),
(ii), (vii) or (ix) of Sub-Section (1) of Section 122 of the Act of
2017; and
(b) at whose instance such transaction was conducted.
Page No.# 39/47
50. A perusal of Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017 would show
that the penalty is sought to be imposed on account of violation of
Clauses (i), (ii), (vii) and (ix) upon the person at whose instance
such violation occurred and the person had retained the benefits
out of the said transaction. Section 122(1) of the Act of 2017 had
been there since the date when the Act of 2017 came into force.
Therefore Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017 do not create any
independent
violation
nor
does
it
enlarges
the
violations
contemplated under Section 122(1) of the Act of 2017. The
legislative intent behind Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017 is
solely to identify the person at whose instance the violations took
place and if the person had retained the benefits, the person would
be liable to a penalty as mentioned therein.
51. This Court further finds it relevant to observe this that the
term "retains benefits of a transaction covered under Clauses (i),
(ii), (vii) & (ix) of Sub-Section (1)” clearly indicates that the penalty
is relatable to the violations referred to in the Clauses (i), (ii), (vii)
and (ix) of Sub-Section (1) of Section 122 which was in existence
since the inception of the Act of 2017 and as such, there being no
new violations created by Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017, there
is no question of the said Sub-Section to be applied retrospectively.
Page No.# 40/47
52. This Court also finds it relevant to take note of Section 132 of
the Act of 2017. It is of importance to note that opening words of
Section 132(1) of the Act of 2017 was amended w.e.f 01.01.2021.
The opening words of Section 132(1) reads as:
“Whoever commits, or causes to commit and retains the benefit arising
out of, any of the following offences, namely ....”
Prior to the amendment, the opening words of Section 132(1) of
the Act of 2017 read as follows:
“Whoever commits any of the following offences...”
The offences have been clearly mentioned in Clauses (a), (b),
(c), (d), (e), (f), (h) (i) & (l) of Section 132(1) of the Act of the Act
of 2017 and the punishments have been mentioned in Clauses (i)
to (iv) of Section 132(1) of the Act of 2017.
Therefore Section 132 specifically refers to offences. However
Section 122 refers to penalties for the violations mentioned in
Clauses (i) to (xxi) of Section 122(1) of the Act of 2017. The
question therefore arises as to whether Section 122(1A) of the Act
of 2017 even if for argument sake is required to be applied
retrospectively, would it violate Article 20(1) of the Constitution as
Page No.# 41/47
was held by the learned Division Bench of the Bombay High Court
in Amit Manilal Haria (supra). In the of opinion of this Court, with
great respect, the learned Division Bench of the Bombay High
Court failed to take note of the difference between an offence and
penalty in respect to a civil adjudication while applying Article
20(1) of the Constitution. This difference would be apparent from
the law laid down by the Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court
in the case of Jawala Ram and Others Vs. State of Pepsu reported
in 1961 SCC OnLine SC 47. Paragraphs 6, 7, 8, 9 & 10 being
relevant are quoted hereunder:
“6.
The main contention raised by Mr Naunit Lal before us in support of the
present appeal is that Section 3 and Section 4 of the Pepsu Sirhind Canal and
Western Jumna Canal Rules (Enforcement and Validation) Act 4 of 1954 are
unconstitutional being in contravention of Article 20(1) of the Constitution.
Other points that he wanted to urge were (i) that the provisions of Rules 32
and 33 do not apply to the facts of the present case, and (ii) that the notice
served before the levy was made was not sufficient. As however it appeared
clear to us that neither of these points was taken before the High Court we
have not given him permission to raise these points before us, in the
circumstances of this case. Another point that Rules 32 and 33 are beyond the
scope of the rule-making provisions of the Act was mentioned by the learned
counsel but was later abandoned.
7.
The only point for our consideration therefore is whether Section 3 and
Section 4 of the Pepsu Sirhind Canal and Western Jumna Canal Rules
(Enforcement and Validation) Act, 1954, infringes the provisions of Article
Page No.# 42/47
20(1) of the Constitution. Article 20(1) provides that no person shall be
convicted of any offence except for violation of a law in force at the time of
the commission of the act charged as an offence, nor be subjected to a
penalty greater than that which might have been inflicted under the law in
force at the time of the commission of the offence. It is argued on behalf of
the appellants that the application by these sections of rules allowing the
imposition of special rates which have been imposed under the provisions of
Rules 32 and 33 of the Pepsu Sirhind Canal Rules, which could not have been
imposed at the time the water was used is bad, as thereby the appellants have
been subjected to a penalty greater than that which might have been inflicted
under the law in force at the time of the commission of the offence.
8.
This argument is based on the assumption that the use of water by the
appellants was an “offence” and that the imposition of an enhanced water
charge under Rules 32 and 33 read with Section 31 of the Canal Act for such
use was “a penalty” for such an “offence”. This assumption is clearly wrong.
“Offence” as was pointed out by this Court in Maqbool Hussain case where
Article 20(2) of the Constitution came up for consideration has not been
defined in the Constitution. So under Article 367 which provides that General
Clauses Act, 1897 shall apply for the interpretation of the Constitution the
word “offence” in the several clauses of Article 20 must be understood to
convey the meaning given to it in Section 3(37) of the General Clauses Act.
That section defines an “offence” to mean an act or omission made punishable
by any law for the time being in force.
9.
Punishment is the mode by which the State enforces its laws forbidding
the doing of something, or omission to do something. Punishment may take
different forms. It may be a mere reprimand; it may be a fine; it may be
whipping; it may be imprisonment — simple or rigorous; it may even extend to
death. But whatever the form, punishment is always co-related to a law of the
Page No.# 43/47
State forbidding the doing or the omission to do something. Unless such a law
exists, there is no question of any act or omission being made “punishable”.
Have we in the present case any law forbidding the unauthorised user of the
water which Section 31 of the Canal Act provides will be charged at rates that
may be prescribed by rules? Quite clearly, there is none. In providing for a
change to be made for use of water at rates that may be prescribed by rules
the legislature is not prohibiting the use of water. The word “unauthorised use”
in the section does not import any idea of prohibition. The intention of the law
clearly is to obtain payment for water used; and the fact that the rates
prescribed may be high cannot alter this position.
10.
We are therefore of opinion that the use of the water by the petitioners
was not an “offence” and the order for levy of special rates for user thereof
was not the imposition of a penalty for an offence. When the Sub-Divisional
Canal Officer or the Canal Commissioner was dealing with the matter they had
to decide whether these petitioners had used water in an unauthorised
manner and if so at what rates they should be charged for such use. In doing
this, they were not trying anybody for any offence; and the fact that special
rates were imposed did not deprive these rates of their essential character of a
charge for water used and did not convert them into any penalty for the
commission of an offence. There is therefore no scope here for the application
of the provisions of Article 20(1) of the Constitution.”
53. Let this Court analyze the issue from another angle. From a
perusal of Sections 122(1) and 122(1A) of the Act of 2017, it would
show that Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017 is complementary to
Section 122(1) of the Act of 2017. Section 122(1A) of the Act of
2017 would not spring into action and until violations of Clauses
Page No.# 44/47
(i), (ii), (vii) and (ix) of Section 122(1) of the Act of 2017 by the
taxable person is adjudicated upon. Under such circumstances, the
question of applying Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017
retrospectively or not does not arise. It is however clarified that
when the Show Cause Notice was issued, Section 122(1A) of the
Act of 2017 should be in operation. This Court duly agrees with the
observations of the Delhi High Court in the case of Bhupender
Kumar (supra).
54.
Accordingly
this
Court
decides
the
second
point
for
determination opining that the application of Section 122(1A) of
the Act of 2017 in the case of Petitioners do not call for
interference.
55.
The
above
therefore
answers
the
second
point
for
determination.
56. In the previous segments of the instant judgment, this Court
had categorically observed that if the jurisdictional issues raised
are decided against the Petitioners, this Court would have to
permit the Petitioners to avail remedies under Section 112 of the
Act of 2017 inasmuch as this Court has permitted the firm namely
M/S Quantum Infratech in the separate judgment and order dated
Page No.# 45/47
08.06.2026 rendered in WP(C) No.2922/2025 to approach the
Appellate Tribunal.
57. This Court finds it relevant to clarify that this Court had only
decided the jurisdictional issues and not on the quantum of penalty
against the Petitioners. The questions whether the Petitioners
retained the benefits of the transaction as well as whether it was at
the instance of the Petitioners, such transactions were carried are
kept open which the Petitioners can challenge before the Appellate
Tribunal, if so advised. The observations made in the present
judgment to the effect that the Petitioners retained the benefits of
the transactions and at the instance of the Petitioners, the
transactions were carried out were on the basis of the finding of
facts arrived at in the Order-in-Original as well as in the Order-inAppeal.
CONCLUSION:
58. Accordingly, the instant writ petition stands disposed of with
the following observations and directions:
(i)
In terms with Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017, penalty can
be imposed upon the Petitioners unless and until the findings
Page No.# 46/47
of facts arrived at by the Proper Officer in the Order-inOriginal dated 04.02.2025 as well as by the Appellate
Authority in the Order-in-Appeal dated 26.08.2025 qua the
Petitioners are interfered with by the Appellate Tribunal.
(ii)
Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017 would be applicable
against the Petitioners for any transactions covered under
Clauses (i), (ii), (vii) and (ix) of Sub-Section (1) of Section 122
of the Act of 2017 even for the period prior to coming into
effect of Section 122(1A) of the Act of 2017.
(iii) The Petitioners herein are granted liberty to file respective
Appeal before the Appellate Tribunal within a period of 30
days from today, and if such Appeal is filed within the said
period, the Appellate Tribunal shall consider the said
Appeal(s) on its merits without insisting on the question of
limitation.
(iv) This Court further observes and directs that if the Appeal(s)
is/are filed within the time permitted in the preceding clause,
the interim orders so passed in the respective writ
proceedings to the effect that no coercive measures should be
taken against the Petitioners shall continue till the stay
Page No.# 47/47
application are taken up for consideration by the Appellate
Tribunal.
(v) There shall be no orders as to cost.
Bijoy
Saha
Digitally signed
by Bijoy Saha
Date: 2026.06.08
19:49:11 +05'30'
Comparing Assistant
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review