Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF ORISSA AT CUTTACK
W.P.(C) No.35860 of 2022
Mayadhar Bhuyan
….
Petitioner
Mr. A. Swain, Advocate
-versusState of Odisha and
Others
….
Opp. Parties
Mr. P.K. Panda, ASC
CORAM:
JUSTICE BIRAJA PRASANNA SATAPATHY
Order No
11. 1.
ORDER
23.07.2026
This
matter
is
taken
up
through
Hybrid
Arrangement (Virtual/Physical) Mode.
2.
Heard learned counsel appearing for the parties.
3.
Pursuant to order dated 21.04.2026, learned Addl.
Standing Counsel files an affidavit in Court with service of
copy on the learned counsel for the petitioner. The same
be kept in record.
4.
The present Writ Petition has been filed inter alia
with the following prayer: “Under the above facts, circumstances and
contentions, it is humbly prayed that this Hon'ble
Court may graciously be pleased to admit this writ
petition, call for the records and after hearing the
counsel for the petitioner would be pleased to issue
notice to the opposite parties under rule NISI as to
why the prayer made in this writ petition shall not
// 2 //
be absolute in case of non-filing of show cause or
showing insufficient cause;
And further would be pleased to issue a writ
of mandamus or any other suitable writ(s) by
directing the opposite parties to gr ant service
seniority and other service benefits including fixation
of pay by considering his seniority availed by
counterparts and retiral benefits in favour of the
petitioner after quashing the order dated 10.01.2022
vide Annexure-17 within a stipulated time;
And further would be pleased to pass any other
appropriate order(s)/direction(s) as deem fit and
proper as per the facts and circumstances of the
case.”
5.
It is contended that petitioner was duly selected
and appointed as against a regular Class-IV post vide
order of appointment issued on 11.02.1991 under
Annexure-1. Subsequently, when a decision was taken
to cancel the appointment so issued in favour of the
petitioner and 6(six) others vide order under Annexure1, petitioner along with others challenging such action,
approached the Tribunal by filing O.A. No.926 of 1994.
The Tribunal vide order dated 18.04.1995, passed an
order by directing the State-Opp. Parties to pay the
salary and allow the petitioner to continue. The
Tribunal further observed that if the authority so
desires to cancel the appointment, then adequate
opportunity of hearing be given.
5.1. It is contended that pursuant to such order passed
by the Tribunal vide order dated 04.09.1995, petitioner
along with 6(six) others, were allowed to re-join in their
posts. Thereafter, when vide order dated 30.11.1998
under Annexure-5, petitioner was again terminated
from his services w.e.f. 30.11.1998, challenging the
// 3 //
same, petitioner along with others approached the
Tribunal by filing O.A. No.3178(C) of 1998. However,
Tribunal when did not pass any interim order protecting
the interest of the petitioner, petitioner along with the
other applicant moved this Court by filing W.P.(C)
No.17903
of
1998.
This
Court
vide
order
dated
23.12.1998 under Annexure-7 passed the following
order:“The petitioner is aggrieved by the order dated
17.12.1998 passed by the Orissa Administrative
Tribunal in O.A. No.3178(C) of 1998. The Tribunal
refused to pass any interim order.
We direct that the services of the petitioner shall
not be terminated till the Tribunal disposes of the
aforesaid Original Application, which shall be
disposed of within three months.
The Writ Petition is disposed of.”
5.2. It is contended that on the face of such order
passed by this Court wherein Opp. Parties were
restrained not to terminate the services of the petitioner
till disposal of O.A. No.3178(C) of 1998, petitioner was
terminated
vide
order
dated
16.06.2000
under
Annexure-11/1.
5.3. It is contended that since after allowing the
petitioner to join and on the face of the order passed by
this Court under Annexure-7, petitioner was again
terminated
vide
Annexure-11/1,
salary,
order
petitioner
approached
the
dated
16.06.2000
claiming
release
Tribunal
by
under
of
filing
his
O.A.
No.1357(C) of 2002. The Tribunal vide order dated
13.01.2003 under Annexure-12, passed an interim
// 4 //
order by directing the authorities to disburse the salary
in favour of the petitioner as due and admissible.
5.4. Not only that similar order of termination passed
when was assailed by the aggrieved persons, the
Tribunal in different Original Applications, directed the
State-authorities to reinstate the said applicants and to
treat the period of absence from the date of termination
till the date of reinstatement as “no work no pay”.
5.5.
It is however contended that since petitioner was
protected by an order passed by this Court on
23.12.1998 under Annexure-7, on the face of such
order passed by this Court, there was no occasion on
the part of the Opp. Parties to terminate the petitioner
from his services vide order dated 16.06.2000 under
Annexure-11/1.
5.6. It is however contended that O.A. No.3178(C) of
1998 after being transferred to this Court was disposed
of vide order dated 06.08.2021 under Annexure-15 with
the following direction:“Considering the contentions raised by learned
counsel for the parties and after going through the
records, this Court, while quashing the order of
termination under Annexure-4, permits the petitioner to
bring to the notice of the authority with regard to the
orders dated 27.10.2011 and 09.01.2013 passed by
the Odisha Administrative Tribunal in O.A. No.452 of
2010 and O.A. No.2328 of 1998 respectively and if the
case of the petitioner is covered by the said orders, the
authority shall consider the same and pass appropriate
order reinstating the petitioner in service treating the
period of termination as “no work no pay” in view of
judgment passed by the apex Court in Vijaya Alok
Singh v. Union of India, (2007) 2 SCC (L & S) 664 and
the petitioner shall not be eligible for any remuneration
// 5 //
during the period he was out of service, but shall be
eligible for seniority and other service benefits including
notional fixation of pay, excepting arrear salary. The
order shall be implemented within a period of three
months from the date of receipt of copy of this order.”
5.7. It is contended that on the face of such order
passed by this Court under Annexure-15, claim of the
petitioner was rejected vide the impugned order dated
10.01.2022 under Annexure-17, inter alia on the
ground that petitioner is not similarly situated as like
the applicant in O.A. No.452 of 2010.
5.8. Learned counsel for the petitioner contended that
since petitioner on the face of the order passed by this
Court
under
Annexure-7
was
terminated
w.e.f.
16.06.2000 and the order of termination initially issued
on 30.11.1998 was quashed by this Court while
disposing O.A. No.3178(C) of 1998 under Annexure-15,
the ground on which petitioner’s claim has been
rejected, cannot be held as legal and justified.
5.9. It is further contended that since in the meantime
petitioner
has
already
attained
the
age
of
superannuation, by treating the petitioner to have
continued in service till he attained the age of
superannuation, Opp. Parties be directed to release all
the pensionary benefits as due and admissible to the
petitioner.
6.
This Court when finds that counter affidavit has
been filed justifying the impugned order passed on
// 6 //
10.01.2022 under Annexure-17, passed the following
order on 21.04.2026:
“1. This matter is taken up through Hybrid Arrangement
(Virtual/Physical) Mode.
2.
Heard learned counsel for the parties.
3.
Pursuant to order dated 18.03.2026, learned Addl.
Govt. Advocate produced the instruction provided by the
Directorate of Animal Husbandry & Veterinary Services so
provided vide letter dated 08.04.2026 with service of copy
on the learned counsel for the petitioner in Court. The same
be kept in record.
4.
Basing on the instruction, learned Addl. Govt.
Advocate contended that even though this Court while
disposing WPC(OAC) No.7178 of 1998 vide order dated
06.08.2021 quashed the order of termination and directed
for reinstatement of the petitioner in the light of the order
passed by the Tribunal in O.A. No.452 of 2010 and O.A.
No.2328 of 1998, but petitioner during pendency of the
Original Application before the Tribunal, was again
terminated vide letter available under Annexure-11/1
w.e.f. 16.06.2000 basing on the letter issued on
07.06.2000.
4.1. It is contended that since such order of termination
was never assailed by the petitioner on the face of the
order passed by this Court on 06.08.2021 under
Annexure-15, petitioner is not eligible and entitled to get
his retiral benefits.
4.2. It is also contended that by the time such order was
passed by this Court, petitioner had already attained the
age of superannuation on 31.01.2020.
5.
To the stand taken in the instruction and the
submission made by learned Addl. Govt. Advocate,
learned counsel for the petitioner taking this Court to the
order dated 23.12.1998 so passed in OJC No.17903 of
1998, contended that this Court while disposing the said
Writ Petition vide order dated 23.12.1998, passed an order
that the petitioner shall not be terminated till disposal of
O.A. No.3178(C) of 1998.
5.1. It is contended that the said original application after
being transferred to this Court, was disposed of as
W.P.C(OAC) No.3178 of 1998 vide order dated 06.08.2021.
It is accordingly contended that since this Court in the said
Writ Petition specifically passed an order that petitioner
shall not be terminated till disposal of O.A. No.3178(C) of
// 7 //
1998, the order of termination passed under Annexure11/1 is not only illegal but also contemptuous and
accordingly there was no requirement to challenge the said
order.
5.2. It is also contended that such order available under
Annexure-11/1 was never brought to the notice of this
Court, when this Court disposed of W.P.C(OAC) No.3178 of
1998 vide order dated 06.08.2021.
6.
Learned Addl. Govt. Advocate is directed to obtain
instruction as to how on the face of the order passed by
this Court on 23.12.1998 in OJC No.17903 of 1998 under
Annexure-7 and during pendency of O.A. No.3178(C) of
1998, petitioner was again terminated vide order available
under Annexure-11/1 w.e.f. 16.06.2000.
7.
As requested by learned Addl. Govt. Advocate, list
this matter on 06.05.2026.
Free copy to Mr. C.K. Pradhan, learned Addl. Govt.
Advocate for compliance.”
7.
Pursuant to the said order, an affidavit is filed in
Court today by the learned Addl. Standing Counsel.
Stand taken in Para-4 and 5 of the said affidavit reads
as follows:“4.
That, it is humbly submitted that, in
pursuance to the order dated 23.12.1998 of this
Hon’ble Court passed in OJC No.17903 of 1998, the
Petitioner was allowed to join in his service vide letter
No.1704 Dt.12.10.1998 of the SDVO, Nabarangpur
and he has joined in his service on 12.10.1999.
5. That, it is humbly submitted that while
things stood as thus, the SDVO, Nabrangpur by
enclosing a report of the then Govt. Pleader,
Nabrangpur dtd.05.11.1999, sought clarification from
the Director, AH & VS, Odisha, Cuttack regarding
continuation of the service of the petitioner vide Letter
No.1831 dtd.06.12.1999. Subsequently, in pursuance
of the Letter No.15118 dt.07.06.2000 of the then
Director, Animal Husbandry & Veterinary Services,
Odisha, Cuttack, the petitioner was again terminated
by the SDVO, Nabarangpur vide Order No.903 dated
16.06.2000.”
8.
Learned Addl. Standing Counsel basing on the
affidavit, contended that since petitioner was terminated
// 8 //
vide
order
dated
16.06.2000
and
that
order
of
termination was never set aside nor was ever assailed
by the petitioner, petitioner is not eligible and entitled to
get any benefit.
9.
Having heard learned counsel for the parties and
considering the submission made, this Court finds that
petitioner along with 6(six) others were appointed as
against regular Class-IV posts vide order of appointment
issued on 11.02.1991 under Annexure-1. Thereafter,
when it was decided to cancel the order of appointment
so issued in favour of the petitioner, petitioner along
with 6(six) others approached the Tribunal by filing O.A.
No.926 of 1994. The Tribunal while directing the StateOpp. Parties to pay the salary and to allow the
petitioners to continue observed that, if the authorities
so desire, they can cancel the order of appointment by
giving opportunity of hearing to the petitioners.
9.1. Pursuant to such order of the Tribunal, petitioner
was allowed to join in his services with issuance of a
fresh order on 14.09.1995 under Annexure-3. However,
when the petitioner was issued with a show-cause as to
why his appointment will not be cancelled, petitioner
submitted his reply on 26.11.1996 under Annexure-4.
Without proper appreciation, when petitioner was again
terminated
vide
order
dated
30.11.1998
under
Annexure-5, the matter was carried to the Tribunal in
O.A. No.3178(C) of 1998.
// 9 //
9.2. The Tribunal when did not pass any interim order
on such application of the petitioner, petitioner along
with another, approached this Court by filing OJC
No.17903
of
1998.
This
Court
vide
order
dated
23.12.1998 under Annexure-7, while disposing the Writ
Petition, directed that services of the petitioner shall not
be terminated till disposal of O.A. No.3178(C) of 1998.
9.3. However, it is found that on the face of such order
passed by this Court on 23.12.1998, petitioner was
again terminated on 16.06.2000 under Annexure-11/1.
It is found that O.A. No.3178(C) of 1998 was ultimately
disposed of by this Court vide order dated 06.08.2021
under Annexure-15 and this Court while disposing the
matter
with quashing of the impugned order of
termination
dated
30.11.1998
under
Annexure-5,
directed Opp. Parties to consider the claim of the
petitioner to get seniority and other service benefits
including Notional Fixation of Pay and release Arrear
Salary.
9.4. However, this Court held that for the period
petitioner remained terminated, he will not be entitled
to get any salary basing on the principle of “no work no
pay”. On the face of such order passed by this Court,
claim of the petitioner was rejected vide the impugned
order dated 10.01.2022 under Annexure-17.
9.5. This Court after going through the materials
available on record, is of the view that order of
termination passed on 30.11.1998 which was the
// 10 //
subject matter of challenge in O.A. No.3178(C) of 1998,
when the tribunal vide order dated 17.12.1998 declined
to protect the interest of the petitioners, the same was
assailed before this Court in OJC No.17903 of 1998.
This Court with a direction on the Opp. Parties not to
terminate the services of the petitioner till disposal of
the Original Application, disposed of the matter vide
order dtd.23.12.1998 under Annexure-7. On the face of
the such order passed on 23.12.1998 under Annexure7, this Court is of the view that no such order of
termination could have been issued on 16.06.2000 once
again.
9.6. Since on the face of the order passed by this Court
under Annexure-7, petitioner was terminated w.e.f.
16.06.2000 and order of termination so passed on
30.11.1998 under Annexure-5 was set aside by this
Court while disposing W.P.C(OAC) No.3178 of 1998, this
Court is of the view that petitioner is required to be
treated to have retired from his services on attaining the
age of superannuation.
9.7. While holding so, this Court directs Opp. Parties to
pay the retiral benefits as due and admissible to the
petitioner by fixing his pay notionally all through as
against a Class-IV post. This Court directs Opp. Party
Nos.2 and 3 to complete the entire exercise within a
period of 4(four) months from the date of receipt of this
order. Petitioner however will not be entitled to get any
// 11 //
other service benefits save and except, Pension and
other retiral benefits as due and admissible.
10. The Writ Petition stands disposed of accordingly.
(Biraja Prasanna Satapathy)
Judge
Basudev
Digitally Signed
Signed by: BASUDEV SWAIN
Reason: Authentication
Location: High Court of Orissa, Cuttack
Date: 28-Jul-2026 16:49:08
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review