Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Maya Devi Darjee v. Executive Engineer, Central Water Commission
W.P. (C) No. 09 of 2019
THE HIGH COURT OF SIKKIM: GANGTOK
(Civil Extra Ordinary Jurisdiction)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------SINGLE BENCH: THE HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE BHASKAR RAJ PRADHAN, JUDGE
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
W.P. (C) No. 09 of 2019
Maya Devi Darjee,
W/o Late Pirthi Ram Sewa,
R/o Lower Tareythang,
P.O. Bering & P.S. Pakyong,
East Sikkim-737106.
.… Petitioner
Versus
Executive Engineer,
Central Water Commission,
Sikkim Investigation Division,
Tadong, Gangtok,
East Sikkim-737102.
…. Respondent
-------------------------------------------------------------------------Application under Article 226 and 227 of the
Constitution of India.
Appearance:
Mr. Zangpo Sherpa and Ms. Mon Maya Subba,
Advocates for the Petitioner.
Mr. Karma Thinlay, Central Government Counsel with
Mr. Manish Kumar Jain, Advocate, for the Respondent.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------J U D G M E N T (O R A L)
(12.07.2019)
Bhaskar Raj Pradhan, J
1.
Late Pirthi Ram Sewa, a casual labourer working with
the Respondent, Central Water Commission while on his way
from Gangtok to Central Water Commission, Bhopal in the
Narmada
Division
after
receipt
of
letter
of
offer
of
Maya Devi Darjee v. Executive Engineer, Central Water Commission
W.P. (C) No. 09 of 2019
regularisation as skilled work assistance met with a fatal
accident and died on 26.04.2013. He had expressed his
willingness to proceed and join duty anywhere in India
pursuant to which he was called to Bhopal.
2.
Section 3 of the Employee’s Compensation Act, 1923
(the
said
Act)
provides
for
employers
liability
for
compensation if personal injury is caused to an employee by
accident arising out of and in the course of his employment.
The fact that late Pirthi Ram Sewa died on 26.04.2013 is not
an
issue.
The
Respondent,
it
seems,
did
not
pay
compensation payable on his death. This compelled the
Petitioner-wife of late Pirthi Ram Sewa to approach the Court
of the Commissioner for Workman’s Compensation, Sikkim
at Gangtok (the learned Commissioner). The application for
compensation was contested by the Respondent.
The
Respondent submitted before the learned Commissioner that
late Pirthi Ram Sewa having not been employed at the office
of the Central Water Commission, Bhopal on the date of his
death was not eligible to receive compensation. The learned
Commissioner rejected this contention and held that the
accident occurred in the course of his employment.
learned
Commissioner
determined
the
amount
The
of
compensation and directed the Respondent by order dated
02.06.2016
to
pay
an
amount
of
Rs.7,02,160/-
as
compensation within a period of two months from the date of
Maya Devi Darjee v. Executive Engineer, Central Water Commission
W.P. (C) No. 09 of 2019
the order. When the Respondent failed to make the said
payment of compensation within the prescribed period the
Petitioner approached the learned Commissioner once again
by filing an execution petition. The learned Commissioner
after examining the law was of the opinion that the
Commissioner under the said Act is not in a position to
execute the award but as the amount of compensation has
already been determined and ordered for payment the
parties should consider approaching the Civil Court for
execution of the award.
The Respondent neither appealed
against the order nor paid the compensation amount as
directed by the learned Commissioner compelling the
Petitioner to approach the Court of the learned District
Judge, East Sikkim, at Gangtok for execution of the learned
Commissioner’s order. Before the learned District Judge the
representative
of
the
Respondent
submitted
that
the
necessary approval for the release of the compensation
amount along with interest thereon @ 10% w.e.f. the date of
filing of the execution petition had been accorded by the
Ministry of Water Resources, River Development & Ganga
Rejuvenation, Government of India. A copy of the letter dated
27.11.2017 recording the said approval was also filed.
It
was informed that in view of the approval necessary
instructions has also been made and it was assured that
payment would be made within December, 2017. On such
Maya Devi Darjee v. Executive Engineer, Central Water Commission
W.P. (C) No. 09 of 2019
assurance from the Respondent the learned District Judge
on 06.12.2017 closed the case with the direction that the
payment shall be made within December 2017. The payment
however, was not paid in December but only on 19.01.2018.
Thereafter,
the
Petitioner
made
an
application
dated
07.02.2018 to the Respondent by which she claimed that the
interest amount should have been 12% as per the said Act
and the death compensation had been wrongly calculated
from 09.10.2017 to 10.12.2017 whereas it should have been
counted after one month from the date of death i.e.
16.05.2013 to 10.12.2017. The Respondent replied to the
said communication vide letter dated 05.06.2018 informing
the Petitioner to approach the competent authority and
stating that further payment of interest could be made only
after the Court order or approval of the competent authority.
The Petitioner, therefore, desired to approach the learned
Commissioner. Accordingly after having had an appropriate
application drafted sought to present the same before the
learned Commissioner. However, it is submitted that the
said application was not accepted and returned to the
complainant without any consideration. It is in these
circumstances, that the Petitioner has approached this
Court for appropriate reliefs by filing the present Writ
Petition.
Maya Devi Darjee v. Executive Engineer, Central Water Commission
W.P. (C) No. 09 of 2019
3.
The present Writ Petition seeks directions upon the
Respondent to make payment of interest @ of 12% per
annum from the date of the accidental death of late Pirthi
Ram Sewa till the date of final payment. Additionally the
Petitioner seeks a further direction upon the Respondent to
make payment of penalty amounting to 50% of the principal
amount of death compensation as per Section 4 A (3) (a) (b)
of the said Act.
4.
Heard, Mr. Zangpo Sherpa, learned Counsel for the
Petitioner and Mr. Karma Thinlay Namgyal, learned Central
Government Counsel for the Respondent.
5.
Mr. Karma Thinlay submitted that the facts are not in
dispute and therefore, there is no need to file a counter
affidavit. He sought to raise two oral objections. His first
contention that on the date of the accident late Pirthi Ram
Sewa was not in the employment of the Central Water
Commission, Bhopal had been raised before the learned
Commissioner and determined in favour of the Petitioner.
The Respondent has not appealed against the learned
Commissioner’s
order.
The
Respondent
is
therefore
precluded from raising it in the present writ proceedings.
6.
The second objection raised by Mr. Karma Thinlay was
with regard to the Petitioner’s submission before the learned
District Judge as reflected in the order dated 06.12.2017. A
perusal of the said order and the records reflect that in spite
Maya Devi Darjee v. Executive Engineer, Central Water Commission
W.P. (C) No. 09 of 2019
of
the
learned
Commissioner’s
direction
to
pay
the
compensation to the Petitioner, the Respondent failed to do
so. This compelled the Petitioner to seek execution of the
Commissioner’s order dated 02.06.2016. The records reveal
however, that even after assurance given to the learned
District Judge the same was not respected and payment was
made only on 19.01.2018. Section 4A of the said Act clearly
contemplates not only the manner but also the extent of
interest as well as penalty to be paid in the circumstances
described. If the requirement of the provision were satisfied
it was incumbent upon the learned Commissioner to have
directed payment of interest and penalty. This Court is of the
view that the prayer for closure of the execution petition
before the learned District Judge due to the assurance given
by the Petitioner, wife of a casual labourer, cannot be taken
as a waiver as sought to be argued. The Respondent’s
assurance was not fulfilled in the first place. The prayer for
closure is reflective of the frustration due to the delay in
receiving the compensation. This should not deter this Court
in passing appropriate directions upon the Respondent to
pay the compensation interest and penalty which is due and
payable to the Petitioner if the circumstances demands and
the law permits.
Maya Devi Darjee v. Executive Engineer, Central Water Commission
W.P. (C) No. 09 of 2019
7.
Section 4A of the Employee’s Compensation Act, 1923
deals with compensation to be paid when due and penalty
for default. The said section reads as under:
“4A. Compensation to be paid when due and
penalty for default.(1) Compensation under Section 4 shall be paid as soon as
it falls due.
(2) In cases where the employer does not accept the liability
for compensation to the extent claimed, he shall be bound to make
provisional payment based on the extent of liability which he
accepts, and, such payment shall be deposited with the
Commissioner or made to the [employee], as the case may be,
without prejudice to the right of the [employee] to make any further
claim.
(3) Where any employer is in default in paying the
compensation due under this Act within one month from the date it
fell due, the Commissioner shall—
(a) direct that the employer shall, in addition to the amount of the
arrears, pay simple interest thereon at the rate of twelve per
cent per annum or at such higher rate not exceeding the
maximum of the lending rates of any scheduled bank as may
be specified by the Central Government, by notification in the
Official Gazette, on the amount due; and
(b) if, in his opinion, there is no justification for the delay, direct
that the employer shall, in addition to the amount of the
arrears and interest thereon, pay a further sum not exceeding
fifty per cent of such amount by way of penalty:
Provided that an order for the payment of penalty shall not be
passed under clause (b) without giving a reasonable opportunity to the
employer to show cause why it should not be passed.
Explanation.—For the purposes of this sub-section, “scheduled bank”
means a bank for the time being included in the Second Schedule to the
Reserve Bank of India Act, 1934 (2 of 1934).
(3-A) The interest and the penalty payable under sub-section (3) shall
be paid to the [employee] or his dependant, as the case may be.”
8.
Compensation under Section 4 of the said Act shall be
paid as soon as it falls due. In re: Pratap Narain Singh Deo
v. Srinivas Sabata & Anr.1 the Supreme Court held that it
was the duty of the Appellant/proprietor under Section 4(a)
(1) of the said Act, to pay the compensation at the rate
(1976) 1 SCC 289
Maya Devi Darjee v. Executive Engineer, Central Water Commission
W.P. (C) No. 09 of 2019
provided by Section 4 as soon as the personal injury was
caused to the Respondent. This judgment by a four Judge
Bench was once again followed in re: Saberabibi Yakubbhai
Shaikh v. National Insurance Company2 in which it was
observed that in various judgments including Pratap Narain
Singh Deo (supra) it was held that compensation has to be
paid from the date of the accident.
9.
In view of the aforesaid, it is evident that the
Respondent was required to pay compensation to the
Petitioner from the date of the accident i.e. 26.04.2013 as
determined by the learned Commissioner and as reflected in
the death certificate.
The Respondent however, did not
make payment of compensation to the Petitioner when it fell
due.
10. The Petitioner has also made a further claim of penalty
of 50% of the principal amount of death compensation. This
claim for penalty is as per Rule 4A (3)(b) of the said Act.
Under the said provision where an employer is in default in
paying the compensation due under the said Act within one
month from the date it fell due the learned Commissioner
shall if, in his opinion there is no justification for the delay,
direct that the employer shall in addition to the amount of
the arrears and interest thereon, pay a further sum not
exceeding 50% of such amount by way of penalty.
(2014) 2 SCC 298
Maya Devi Darjee v. Executive Engineer, Central Water Commission
W.P. (C) No. 09 of 2019
11. The scheme under Section 4A of the said Act is clear.
Compensation under Section 4 has to be paid as soon as it
falls due. It falls due on the date of the accident. This was a
case in which the employer did not grant compensation to
the Petitioner. The Petitioner therefore, approached the
learned
Commissioner
for
appropriate
orders.
The
Respondent chose to contest this application instead of
paying compensation. The records reveal that compensation
amount as calculated by the learned Commissioner was paid
only after the Petitioner had approached the learned District
Judge
for
executing
the
direction
of
the
learned
Commissioner. That too after the period the Respondent had
assured payment. The undisputed facts as reflected above
makes it evident that the Respondent was in default in
paying the compensation due under the Act within one
month from the date it fell due. The facts also revealed that
there is no justification for the delay in payment.
12. In such circumstances, the learned Commissioner was
required to direct the employer, to pay the interest as
provided in Section 4A(3) (a) of the said Act as well as pay
the penalty as envisaged by Rule 4A(3) (b) of the said Act.
This was the mandate of the law. The Petitioner has stated
that an appropriate application was filed before the learned
Commissioner for seeking the relief as prayed for on
affidavit. The said application was returned instead of
Maya Devi Darjee v. Executive Engineer, Central Water Commission
W.P. (C) No. 09 of 2019
receiving it, considering it on merits and disposing it by
passing appropriate directions.
The determination under
Section 4A of the said Act is required to be done by the
learned Commissioner. The learned Commissioner did not do
so. Sending the case back to the learned Commissioner
would further delay the determination and grant of prayers
for interest and penalty. The uncontroverted facts reveal that
the Petitioner, wife of a casual labourer, has been running
from pillar to post from the year 2013 chasing the legitimate
compensation due to her for the death of her husband who
had been gainfully employed by the Respondent. This Court
is of the view that any further delay in determination would
not serve the purpose of the said Act. The Respondent was
given
an
opportunity
to
contest
the
Writ
Petition.
Opportunity therefore, was granted to the Respondent to
show cause as to why the order for penalty should not be
passed. The Writ Petition had sought a specific prayer for
penalty. The Respondent chose not to file a counter-affidavit.
13. The undisputed facts which have not been contested by
the Respondent leads to the inevitable conclusion that the
provision of Section 4A (3) (a) and (b) are attracted in the
present case. In the circumstances, the Writ Petition is
allowed.
14. The Respondent is directed to make payment as per
Rule 4A (3) (a) and (b) of the said Act of both the simple
Maya Devi Darjee v. Executive Engineer, Central Water Commission
W.P. (C) No. 09 of 2019
interest @ 12% per annum on the amount due from the date
of the accident i.e. 26.04.2013 till date of final payment as
well as penalty of 50% of the amount of compensation
payable to the Petitioner within a period of three months
from the date of this judgment.
15. No order as to costs.
(Bhaskar Raj Pradhan)
Judge
12.07.2019
to/
Approved for reporting: yes.
Internet: yes.
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review