Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:766
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 284 of 2023
Date of Decision: 24.10.2024
Maxim Infrastructure & Real Estate
(Shillong) Pvt. Ltd.
… Petitioner(s)
- Versus –
1. State of Meghalaya,
Represented by Commissioner & Secretary,
Department of Urban Affairs, Shillong
Meghalaya.
2. Commissioner & Secretary,
Excise, Registration, Taxation and Stamp Department,
Represented by its Director,
Shillong, Meghalaya
3. The Sub Registrar,
Office of the Deputy Commissioner,
East Khasi Hills District, Shillong
Meghalaya.
4. The Inspector General of Registration &
Superintendent of Stamps, Government of
Meghalaya, Shillong.
.. Respondent(s)
2024:MLHC:766
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner(s)
:
Mr. S. Jindal, Adv. with
Mr. I. Kharmujai, Adv.
Ms. T. Pohlong, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
:
Ms. S. Ain, GA with
Mr. E.R. Chyne, Adv.
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The brief facts of the case are that one H.M. Cements
Limited (HMCL) had entered into a deed of agreement for the
construction of a Five Star Hotel-cum-Commercial Complex, at the old
Municipal office premises at Jail Road, Shillong, and the project was
to be implemented on a Public Private Partnership (PPP) mode. The
stamp duty and registration charges on the said deed of agreement was
waived off by the State respondents, and as such no charges were paid
2024:MLHC:766
by HMCL. HMCL, then transferred the rights to another group
company namely Maxim Infrastructure & Real Estate Pvt. Ltd.
(MIREPL) which was approved by the State respondents. Thereafter,
MIREPL entered into insolvency proceedings before the National
Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) Guwahati Bench and pursuant to an
order dated 25.10.2019, MIREPL was taken over by a new promoter as
per the approved resolution plan and order of the NCLT. The Petitioner
company, was then formed by the new promoter to take up the project
and a fresh lease deed dated 19.10.2021 as required, was entered into
between the Petitioner and the Respondent No. 1. It is the case of the
petitioner that prior to entering into the lease deed, though repeated
requests had been made for waiver of stamp duty and registration
charges since the project was a PPP project, and that such waiver was
given to HMCL, the said request was denied by the respondents, which
compelled the petitioner to pay the stamp duty and registration charges
under protest. A request was also made for refund but the same was
also denied. Being aggrieved thereby, the petitioner is before this Court
with the instant writ petition.
2024:MLHC:766
2.
Mr. S. Jindal, learned counsel for the petitioner has
submitted that it is crucial to note that the intention of the parties was
to implement the project under the PPP mode and that the Meghalaya
Public Private Partnership Policy, 2021 at clause 6.F.1, has clarified
that the State Government would extend concessions on stamp duty for
land transfers in PPP projects, and as such no stamp duty or
registration charges were paid for the deed of agreements as per the
PPP policy. The learned counsel further submits that the resolution
plan submitted to the NCLT, which allowed the petitioner to take over
the project was based on an understanding that the project would
continue to be treated under the PPP mode, with all associated
concessions and waivers being extended to the petitioner, and as such
at the time of execution of the Lease Deed on 19.10.2021, the same
was not immediately registered nor was stamp duty paid thereon.
However, he submits on the Government’s recalcitrance to allow the
waiver, and on facing pressure from Marriot International, regarding
the registration of the Lease Deed, the petitioner then registered the
Lease Deed on 25.02.2022, paying Rs. 29,17,503/- towards stamp duty
and registration charges. The petitioner he submits, then by letter dated
2024:MLHC:766
04.03.2022, requested a refund for the amount paid, which however
met with the response vide letter dated 13.07.2022 issued by the
respondent No. 4, that the stamp duty and registration costs could not
be refunded because there is no provision for waiver under the PPP
mode unless notified.
3.
The learned counsel then contends that the Indian Stamp
Act, 1899 read with the Registration (Meghalaya Amendment) Act,
2022, allows for such exemption on any instrument executed by or on
behalf or in favour of the Government and that the State Government
had inherent powers to reduce, remit or compound duties for any
particular class or classes of instruments. The learned counsel has
strenuously argued that there is no reasonable explanation of how
circumstances have changed, inasmuch as, in the same project under
the PPP mode while waiver had been accorded to HMCL, the same has
not been extended to the petitioner who had but substituted or stepped
into the shoes of HMCL. He further contends that the petitioner has
been subjected to unequal treatment and the decision of the
2024:MLHC:766
respondents is arbitrary and mala fide. In support of his submissions,
the learned counsel has placed reliance on the following decisions: -
i)
Godavari Sugar Mills Vs. State of Maharashtra (2011) 2
SCC 439 (Para 8(ii) (iv) & (vi)
ii)
ABL International Vs. Expert Credit
Corporation (2004) 3 SCC 553 (Para 27)
iii)
Asia Foundation Vs. Trafalgar House Construction (1997)
1 SCC 738 (Para 9)
iv)
Faquir Chand Vs. Uppal Agencies (2008) 10 SCC 345
(Para 30)
v)
B.K. Muniraju Vs. State of Karnataka (2008) 4 SCC 451
(Para 18)
vi)
Madras Alumimium Co. Vs. Tamil Nadu Electricity Board
(2023) 8 SCC 240 (Para 39 & 40)
vii)
SVK Infrastructures Vs. Delhi Tourism 2023 SCC OnLine
Del 6460 (Paras 8 & 10)
Guarantee
viii) M. Sudakar Vs. V. Manoharan (2011) 1 SCC 484 (Para 14)
ix)
4.
Wolstenhome International Vs. Twin Stars Industrial 2001
SCC OnLine Bom 194 (Para 13)
On behalf of the State respondents, Ms. S. Ain, learned
GA has firstly submitted that the writ petition is not maintainable for
2024:MLHC:766
refund of stamp duty lawfully collected and that a mandamus can only
be issued if the collection is illegal, and no claim of illegality has been
raised by the petitioner. She further submits that claim for such refund
can only be pursued through a suit and not by a writ petition, and that
the petitioner has failed to demonstrate that the decision to charge the
fees was arbitrary or irrational; and that further a writ for payment can
only be issued to enforce statutory functions. It has also been
contended by the learned counsel, that apart there being no violation of
any fundamental or legal rights to justify the writ petition, the
petitioner has already made the payment, and as such therefore no
cause of action subsists after the rejection of the waiver request. She
then submits that the petition is also barred by delay and laches as the
payment was made on 25.02.2022, after the refusal of the waiver in
February 2022, and that the petitioner has alternative remedy available
under the Indian Stamp Act, and that the Lease Deed itself contains an
arbitration clause at Article 15, thereof.
5.
On another limb of submission, it has been submitted that
the Meghalaya Public Private Partnership Policy (PPP) 2021 does not
2024:MLHC:766
grant automatic exemption, but there is a requirement of issuance of
separate notifications by the Government, and that fiscal support is
determined case by case which is discretionary, and that in the Policy
itself, the same has been termed as a concession and not exemption.
There being no concession agreement, she submits, the petitioner was
therefore bound to pay the stamp duty as agreed under the Lease Deed.
On other aspects of the matter, learned counsel has argued that the new
Lease Deed dated 19.10.2021, was a fresh agreement with new terms
distinct from the previous Deed, and that the new Lease Deed involved
a settlement of Rs. 2,25,00,000/- as full and final payment for all
previous arrears and demands, which therefore disallows any claim for
fiscal support on further concessions. The learned counsel then
concludes her submissions, by contending that the petitioner had
expressly agreed to bear and pay the stamp duty and registration fees
as provided at clause 21.1 of the new Lease Deed, and as such having
agreed to the same, is estopped from seeking exemption from payment.
The learned counsel in support of her arguments on the question of
maintainability, and claim of refund has relied upon the following
decisions :-
2024:MLHC:766
6.
i)
Suganmal Vs. State of M.P. AIR 1965 SC 1740
ii)
Union of India & Ors. Vs. Orient Enterprises & Anr. (1998)
3 SCC 501
iii)
Burmah Construction Co. Vs. State of Orissa, AIR 1962 SC
1320 reiterated in Godavari Sugar Mills Vs. State of
Maharashtra (2011) 2 SCC 439
iv)
Dhanyalakshmi Rice Mills Vs. Commr. of Civil Supplies
(1976) 4 SCC 723
Having heard the learned counsel for the parties, simply
put, the grievance of the petitioner is only with the non-extension of
the waiver on stamp duty and registration charges on the Lease Deed,
while for the same project itself with the initial promoter, this
concession had been extended. In this context, an examination of the
earlier Deed of Agreement dated 25.06.2010, reflects that by a noting
on the instrument itself dated 29.06.2010, fees had been exempted.
Coming to the current Lease Deed dated 19.10.2021, it can be seen
that at clause 1.1 thereof, the project is on the same plot of land i.e.
Plot No. 34, Jail Road Ward, Shillong, as shown in the earlier
agreement. Therefore, for all practical purposes, notwithstanding the
exit of the first promoter, the subsequent NCLT proceedings, and the
2024:MLHC:766
entry of the present petitioner, the project as described in clause 1.2, of
the earlier and present agreement, is with the same objective. This
Court therefore is only to examine as to whether the denial of the
waiver on registration charges and stamp duty by the State respondents
in the second instance, can be said to be arbitrary or mala fide to
warrant interference by this Court in exercise of powers under Article
226 of the Constitution of India.
7.
In this backdrop therefore, a cursory scrutiny of the
relevant Acts and Policy is necessary to be gone into. First while
looking at the Indian Stamp Act, Section 9 thereof, has provided for
the power to reduce, remit or compound duties, and for the sake of
convenience Section 9(1) (a) and (b) are reproduced herein below:“9. Power to reduce, remit or compound duties - [(1)]
The Government may, by rule or order published in the
Official Gazette(a) reduce or remit, whether prospectively or
retrospectively, in the whole or any part of the
territories under its administration, the duties with
which any instruments or any particular class of
instruments, or any of the instruments belonging to
such class, or any instruments when executed by or
in favour of any particular class of persons or by or
2024:MLHC:766
in favour of any members of such class, are
chargeable, and
(b) provide for the composition or consolidation of duties
of policies of insurance and in the case of issues by
any incorporated company or other body corporate
or of transfers (where there is a single transferee,
whether incorporated or not) of debentures, bonds or
other marketable securities.”
8.
Further in the Registration (Meghalaya Amendment) Act,
2022 a new section being 78A has been inserted after the existing
section 78, which reads as follows:“78A. Power to reduce or remit fees. – The State
Government may, if in its opinion it is necessary in the
public interest so to do, by order published in the
Official Gazette, reduce or remit the fees payable in
respect of any of the matters enumerated in clauses (a)
to (i) of Section 78, either generally or for any particular
class of cases and in respect of persons generally or of
any particular class or classes or persons, or in respect
of any particular class or classes of instruments.”
9.
The Meghalaya Public Private Partnership Policy (PPP)
2021, with regard to State Support at clause 6(vi) thereof, Fiscal
Support at clause E (I)(a) and with regard to Foregoing of Revenue
Streams at clause F (I), (II) has provided as hereinunder:-
2024:MLHC:766
“6 State Support
vi. Actual concessions/incentives and funding support
under the Policy will be separately decided and notified
by the Government from time to time.
E. Fiscal SupportI.
Incentive and Concessions
a) Government of Meghalaya will formulate sector
specified policies wherever required for providing
specific incentives & concessions as well as establish
mechanism for tariff setting, pricing arbitration,
safety, and operational standards etc.
F. Foregoing of Revenue Streams
Concessions covered under the above category are as
follows:
I.
II.
10.
Concession on Stamp Duty on transfer of land
Concession on conversation charges on land”
An overview of the above quoted provisions under the
Stamp Act, the Meghalaya (Registration Amendment) Act, shows that
any reduction, remission or compounding of Stamp duty by the
Government can only be by way of a Gazette Notification. Further, the
PPP Policy, 2021 in granting state support, fiscal support and
concessions such as in the instant case, which involves concession on
2024:MLHC:766
Stamp duty also specifically provides that the concession is specific
and as given in clause 6 (vi) under State Support, actual concessions
are to be separately decided and notified by the Government. As such,
what can be seen from the above noted quoted provisions is that for
reduction, compounding or for any concession, the same has to be by
due process, and cannot be claimed as a matter of right.
11.
Coming to the Lease Deed dated 19.10.2021 executed
between the parties, though the same may be with regard to the same
project and plot of land in question, an examination of the recitals
reveals that apart from the petitioner being aware as to the
circumstances and outstanding amounts payable, the lease was entered
into on the agreement for payment of Rs. 2.25 Crores for settlement of
all past outstanding dues by the petitioner, and at clause 21.1 of the
new Lease Deed, the petitioner had specifically agreed to bear the
necessary Stamp duty for registration. Article 21 thereof, of the said
Lease Deed is reproduced hereinbelow:-
2024:MLHC:766
“ARTICLE-21 STAMP DUTY
21.1 The Stamp duty and registration fee on this Deed
shall be borne and paid by the Leasee.”
12.
The Lease Deed at Article 15 thereof, has also provided
for arbitration in the event there is a dispute or differences or questions
relating to, or arising out of the agreement. The parties therefore, are
bound by the recitals of the Lease Deed and any right or obligation
will necessarily emanate from the Deed itself. Furthermore, there
being no express provision contained in the Lease Deed allowing the
exemption or concession as claimed by the petitioner, and the same
having been executed as a fresh Lease agreement, though the terms
and conditions may be somewhat similar, in the considered view of
this Court no recourse or reliance can be placed on the old Lease Deed
to seek the relief as claimed before a writ court. This observation is
made as the claim of the petitioner alleging arbitrary action on the part
of the respondents, in the fact and circumstances of the case is not
present, and it cannot he held that the amount had been collected
illegally by the respondents, as for exemption of Stamp duty, or for any
2024:MLHC:766
concession to be made, the same has to be done in accordance with law
and policy as provided.
13.
Another aspect that cannot be overlooked is that the
petitioner has already paid the Stamp duty, and as such the instant writ
petition has been reduced to one seeking a mandamus for refund which
will be permissible or entertainable only if the petitioner can make out
a case that the said amount has been collected illegally. As held in the
case of Union of India & Ors. vs. Orient Enterprises & Anr. (1998) 3
SCC 501, praying for the issue of a writ of mandamus is not ordinarily
maintainable for the simple reason that a claim for such refund can
always be made in a suit against the authority and that no petition will
be normally entertained for the purpose of merely ordering refund of
money of which the petitioner claims a right. It is further noted that
though in an appropriate case as held in the case of ABL International
Ltd. & Anr vs. Export Credit Guarantee Corporation (supra) that a
writ petition involving a consequential relief of monetary claim is also
maintainable, in the instant case however, the amount claimed cannot
2024:MLHC:766
be said to be consequential to warrant the issuance of a writ of
mandamus.
14.
Without further discussing the decisions as placed by the
learned counsels or dwelling on other facts, the impugned orders
cannot be said to be arbitrary and/or the rights of the petitioner violated
in any manner to warrant interference under Article 226 of the
Constitution. Any dispute or difference that the petitioner may harbour
against the respondents as to any claim, is clearly in the realm of civil
law and in the instant case with an arbitration clause being present in
the Lease Deed itself, the petitioner has ample alternate remedy which
may be availed of.
15.
However, before parting with the records, it is observed
that though on the position of law, no relief will be permissible to the
writ petitioner in the instant proceedings, then again, considering the
circumstances and situation of the case, as the stamp duty payable is
for the same project, wherein the State had deemed it fit to exempt the
earlier entity from such payment, it is provided that the dismissal of
2024:MLHC:766
the instant petition will not debar the State respondents from
considering the matter afresh.
16.
In the light of the foregoing discussions, and in the
circumstances of the case, the instant petition is not entertained and is
accordingly disposed.
JUDGE
Meghalaya
24.10.2024
“V. Lyndem PS”
VALENTINO LYNDEM
Date: 2024.10.24 15:40:23 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review