Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2025:MLHC:535
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 141 of 2019
Date of Decision: 24.06.2025
Smti. Masuami Paul Choudhury,
C/o (L) N. K Dhar
DHAR VILLA, Kenches’ Trace
Shillong-4
....Petitioner
- Versus4. The Management Committee of Hill View Secondary School,
Represented by its Chairman & Secretary,
Assam Regimental Centre, Happy Valley
Shillong-7, Meghalaya
5. The Principal,
Hill View Secondary School,
Happy Valley, Shillong-7, Meghalaya
6. The Union of India,
Represented by the Secretary,
Ministry of Defence, Raksha Bhawan,
New Delhi.
7. The Assam Regimental Centre,
Represented by the Commandant,
The Assam Regimental Centre,
Happy Valley, Shillong,
8. The Deputy Commandant,
The Assam Regimental Centre,
Happy Valley, Shillong.
……Respondents
2025:MLHC:535
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice W. Diengdoh, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s)
: Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, Sr. Adv. with
Mr. T. Dkhar, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. R. Debnath, CGC (For R 6-8)
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT
1.
The petitioners herein were appointed as Assistant Teachers of
the Hill View High School, Assam Rifle Regimental Centre, Happy
Valley, Shillong which received adhoc grant from the Government of
Meghalaya and was thus included as one of the adhoc secondary school in
the State, changing its name to Hill View Secondary School.
2.
It may be mentioned that initially this petition was preferred by
three petitioners who are teachers of the said HVSS. The petitioner No. 1,
Shri Arvind Kumar Pathak was appointed on 07.04.1993 as Asst. Teacher
(Hindi), the petitioner No. 2, Smti Mausami Paul Choudhury was
appointed on 18.02.1991 as Asst. Teacher (Social Science) and petitioner
No. 3, Smti Indrani Dutta was appointed on 21.08.1989 as Asst. Teacher
(Social Science).
3.
It is the petitioners’ case that after serving in the school as
permanent teachers for nearly 15 or 20 years, the school authorities tried
2025:MLHC:535
to reduce their permanent stature into one of a contractual one by issuing
related statement published in the newspaper ‘Shillong Times’ on
25.12.2003.
4.
Being aggrieved by such publication, the petitioners along with
15 other teachers approached this Court (the then Gauhati High Court,
Shillong Bench) with a petition being WP(C) 181(SH) of 2004 and this
Court vide order dated 26.08.2009 disposed of the same by directing the
school authorities not to disturb the service of the petitioners therein
without notice to them following due procedure.
5.
The school management then allowed the petitioners to continue
in their services as Asstt. Teachers without changing the service
conditions.
However,
after
ten
years
or
so,
the
school
authorities/Managing Committee issued the impugned communication
dated 14.02.2019 whereby the services of the petitioners were treated as
contractual and the same was deemed to have expired on 01.12.2004 for
petitioner No. 1, 01.12.2002 for petitioner No. 2 and 01.12.2003 for
petitioner No. 3. By the same letter dated 14.02.2019, the petitioners were
called upon to appear for an interview for the purpose of regularisation of
their services, respectively.
6.
The petitioners then forwarded a copy of this Court’s order dated
26.08.2009(supra) but the school authorities paid no heed to it and instead
issued show cause notice dated 26.03.2019 calling upon them to appear
before the Board of Officers for the interview, failing which their services
will be terminated.
2025:MLHC:535
7.
Eventually, the petitioners have submitted their individual reply
to the said show cause notice on 12.04.2019 reiterating that their services
is permanent in nature since nothing was communicated to them that the
same is contractual, even in the appointment letter. The order dated
26.08.2009 of this Court was also referred to indicate that the school
authorities cannot overlook the directions therein.
8.
Again, the school authorities rejected the said reply to the show
cause notice and has informed the petitioners that the performance
appraisal exercise for validation of the services of the teachers is mandated
by the Standing Operating Procedure (SOP) framed by the school. In this
connection, a second show cause notice was issued vide communication
dated 30.04.2019 and the petitioners were called upon to respond by
03.05.2019.
9.
The petitioners terming the action of the school management as
illegal and arbitrary has, therefore, approached this Court with this instant
writ petition with a prayer to set aside and quash the impugned
communication dated 14.02.2019 and the show cause notice dated
30.04.2019 apart from a direction that the services of the petitioners is not
to be disturbed.
10.
Mr. H.L. Shangreiso, learned Sr. counsel for the petitioners along
with Mr. T. Dkhar, learned counsel, at the outset has submitted that when
this petition was filed, there were three petitioners however, in course of
these proceedings the services of two of them has since ceased on
superannuation and accordingly, appropriate prayer was made before this
Court to delete their names from these records. Accordingly, vide order
2025:MLHC:535
dated 22.08.2024 the name of the petitioner No. 3, Smti. Indrani Dutta was
deleted and similarly, vide order dated 28.04.2025 the name of petitioner
No. 1, Shri. Arvind Kumar Pathak was also deleted. Only the petitioner
No. 2, that is, Smti. Mousami Paul Choudhary remains. As such, this
petition may be taken to have been pursued by the said petitioner No. 2
only.
11.
Coming to the merits of the case, the learned Sr. counsel has
submitted that on the petitioner being duly appointed vide related
communication dated 18.02.1991 her status has been indicated as a
temporary teacher on three months’ probation. However, vide a public
notice issued through newspaper (Shillong Times) dated 25.12.2003 the
petitioner among others were called upon by the school authorities to
collect their fresh contract of appointment.
12.
Being aggrieved by such publication, the petitioner along with
others had approached this Court by filing WP(C) No. 181 (SH) 2004 and
this Court vide order dated 26.08.2009 had directed the school
authorities/Managing Committee not to alter the service conditions of the
petitioners without first putting them to notice.
13.
However,
the
school
authorities
vide
the
impugned
communication dated 14.02.2019 has conveyed to the petitioner that her
contract has expired in the year 2004 and for issuance of a fresh contract
in order to regularise her services she is to appear for a fresh interview
slated to be held on 16.02.2019, failing which, her appointment will be
treated as invalid.
2025:MLHC:535
14.
The learned Sr. counsel has reiterated that on being issued show
cause as to why the petitioner did not appear on the date of interview, she
had replied that her appointment vide letter dated 08.02.1991 has conferred
permanent stature to her service even after having completed the three
months’ probation period, as such, her services cannot be termed as a
contractual one. Even otherwise, the issue of her services being contractual
in nature has been decided by this Court vide order dated 26.03.2019
(supra), as such, the impugned communication dated 14.02.2019 is legally
not tenable.
15.
Again, this Court vide the said order dated 26.08.2009 (supra) had
directed the school authorities to issue prior notice to the petitioner if her
service condition is to be altered, the reliance of the school authorities on
the said Standard Operative Procedure (SOP) cannot be taken into account
since no copy of the said SOP was ever provided to the petitioner.
16.
The tone and tenor of the show cause notice No. 02 dated
30.04.2019 has clearly indicated that the failure of the petitioner to appear
for the interview will be construed as her unwillingness to continue and
will thereby result in termination of her service. In the light of the attending
factors as has been pointed out hereinabove, the learned Sr. counsel
submits that such contemplated action on the part of the school authorities
smacks of illegality and arbitrary action which may not be condoned by
this Court and as such, the impugned communications referred to are liable
to be set aside and quashed.
17.
Mr. R. Debnath, learned CGC is present in court but has
submitted that he is not holding the brief for the respondents Nos. 4 & 5
2025:MLHC:535
Managing Committee. As the Central Government Counsel, he is
representing only respondent Nos. 6, 7 and 8, the Union of India,
represented by the Secretary, Ministry of Defence and the Assam
Regimental Centre. However, the learned CGC has maintained that these
respondents have no part in this dispute, the same being between the
School Management and the Teachers as such, no argument was advanced
by him in this case. This Court vide order dated 02.06.2025 has, therefore,
proceeded ex parte against the respondent Nos. 4 & 5, respectively.
18.
From the materials available on record, including the contents of
this writ petition, what can be understood is that the petitioner on receipt
of communication dated 12.02.2019, the language of the same is couched
in a manner to give the impression that firstly, the service of the petitioner
as a teacher of the Hill View Secondary School (HVSS), Shillong is a
contractual one since expired in the month of December, 2004 and
secondly, that an interview was fixed by the authorities in order to
regularise their services, as such, her service is in danger of termination in
spite of having taught in the said school for about 20 years. Hence this
petition.
19.
In the first instance, the nature and character of the employment
of the petitioner is required to be determined. It is the contention of the
petitioner that her services as a teacher of the school (HVSS) is permanent
since she was initially appointed in the year 1991 in a temporary capacity
with probation period of 3(three) months. However, having served the
school as teacher for more than 20(twenty) years, she has, therefore,
claimed that her status is now as a permanent teacher.
2025:MLHC:535
20.
On the other hand, the respondent/Managing Committee vide the
impugned communication dated 14.02.2019 has termed the employment
of the petitioner as a contractual one since the wordings at para 1 of such
letter reads thus “…that contract period of the contract had expired in
2004. Fresh contract has not been given by management of HVSS
thereafter…”. This is contrary to what has been stated by this respondent
in the affidavit-in-opposition dated 03.10.2019 sworn by the Secretary,
Hill View Secondary School, Assam Regimental Centre wherein at para 9
of the same it has been categorically stated that the petitioner was
appointed as temporary primary teacher in the year 1991 and that this
appointment is only for 1(one) year after completion of probation and
further that the appointment being temporary can be terminated at a
month’s notice by either party.
21.
Logically speaking, temporary appointment would refer to a
situation where there is a vacant post available but not being filled up
permanently, as such, so as not to disturb the process, temporary
appointment is made for the time being. Contract appointment is usually
made with a definite timeline, say for example, for a period of 1(one)
month or 6(six) months or 1(one) year and if not renewed, the same stands
terminated on the expiry of such period.
22.
Since the nature of initial appointment of the petitioner is said to
be that of a temporary nature, therefore the School Management cannot
later say that the same is contractual in nature. On this score, the impugned
communication dated 14.02.2019 is found to be defective vis-à-vis the
character of the petitioner’s employment which carries the impression that
2025:MLHC:535
her appointment was that of a contractual teacher. This has also been
asserted by the respondent/Managing Committee in the said affidavit-inopposition wherein at para 20 is found this statement “…it is stated that
the service of petitioners were always contractual and with
recommendation by the Board of Officers after validation of these
employees will get further employment as per rules of the school
applicable all employees of Secondary Section. The Management
Committee has given contracts to all the teacher of HVSS and same rules
will be applicable to these employees...” Though such stipulation is found
at Section 4.10 of the SOP, providing for contract for a period of one
academic session there is no indication that the said SOP was made known
to the petitioner. However, even the assertion of the petitioner that her
employment has become permanent, there is nothing on record to confirm
such claim.
23.
It is perhaps because of such stipulation in the SOP that the
School Management Committee has issued a similar notification
published in the Shillong Times on 25.12.2003, which reads as “To all
teachers of Hill View Secondary School, to please collect their pay on 31 st
Dec, 2003 between 9 am to 1 pm along with the fresh contract of
appointment, failing which it will be deemed that you are not interested
and will have no more claim to your service in the School. Secretary,
Managing Committee, Hill View Secondary School.” the same being the
consideration for this Court to have passed the order dated 26.08.2009 in
WP(C) 181 (SH) of 2004 (supra).
2025:MLHC:535
24.
It may not be out of place to also reproduce the communication
dated 14.02.2019 which reads as follows:
“BY HAND
Hill View Secondary School
C/o Assam Regimental Centre
Happy Valley, Shillong-7
Case File No : 151/HVSS/PRI
14 Feb 2019
Mr. Arvind Kumar Pathak
APPOINTMENT OF TEACHERS
1. This is to bring to your notice that contract period of your
contract had expired in 2004. Fresh contract has not been given
by management of HVSS thereafter. In view of the above, fresh
interviews have been called on 16 Feb 2019 in order to regularize
the services of the existing teachers whose contract has expired.
2. Vide circular Number 18 and 11 Sep 2018, you have been
asked to deposit service documents alongwith appointment letter,
which is not received by management till date.
3. In view of the above, you are intimated that if you fail to
produced appointment letters stating appointment as regular
teacher, you will be treated as contractual teacher. Interviews will
be conducting on 16 Feb 2019 at HVS at 0930 hrs for regularizing
your services, failing which your appointment in HVSS will be
treated as invalid.
(Geeta Mahadik)
Major
Secretary
for Patron”
25.
On comparison, it would appear that the context of the two
communications dated 25.12.2003 and the one dated 14.02.2019 refers to
2025:MLHC:535
the same subject matter, that is, renewal of contract of the teachers of
HVSS.
26.
Since this issue has been dealt with by this Court in WP(C) 181
(SH) of 2004 vide order dated 26.08.2009, the relevant portion of the
judgment reading as follows:
“6. …I disposed of the writ petition providing that the respondent
Managing Committee shall not alter the service conditions of the
petitioners without first putting them to notice. In other words, the
petitioners will continue to be governed by the prevailing service
conditions and in case of any necessity to alter the same, the
Managing Committee will do so by following the due procedure.”
27.
This Court being bound by such ruling which has since attained
finality, the same ratio can also be suitably applied to the case of the parties
herein.
28.
Accordingly, the impugned communication dated 14.02.2019 as
well as the show cause notice dated 30.04.2019 are hereby set aside and
quashed. The service of the petitioner is not to be dispensed with at this
juncture but it is left open to the respondent/Managing Committee to
comply with the policies of the school as far as employment of teachers is
concerned, however by following due procedure.
29.
In the event, this writ petition is hereby disposed of. No cost.
Judge
TIPRILYNTI KHARKONGOR
Date: 2025.06.24 18:19:44 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review