Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Page No.# 1/22
GAHC010254592025
2026:GAU-AS:10117
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT
(HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH)
Case No. : WP(C)/6519/2025
MATINUR RAHMAN
SON OF LATE MAQUIBAR RAHMAN, RESIDENT OF- SOUTH SARANIA,
GUWAHATI-03, ASSAM.
VERSUS
THE STATE OF ASSAM AND 5 ORS.
REPRESENTED BY THE ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVT.
OF ASSAM, FOOD, PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION AND CONSUMER AFFAIRS
DEPARTMENT, JANATA BHAWAN, DISPUR-06, ASSAM.
2:ADDITIONAL CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVT OF ASSAM
FOOD
PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION AND CONSUMER AFFAIRS DEPARTMENT
JANATA BHAWAN
DISPUR-06
ASSAM
3:THE COMMISSIONER
FOOD
PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION
CONSUMER AFFAIRS AND LEGAL METROLOGY
R.K. MISSION ROAD
P.O.-ULUBARI
DIST- KAMRUP(M)
ASSAM
PIN-781007
4:THE SECRETARY
Page No.# 2/22
FOOD
PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION AND CONSUMER AFFAIRS DEPARTMENT
JANATA BHAWAN
DISPUR-06
ASSAM.
5:THE DISCIPLINARY AUTHORITY CUM ENQUIRY OFFICER
SMTI ANASUA DUTTA BARUA
THE SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF ASSAM
FOOD
PUBLIC DISTRIBUTION AND CONSUMER AFFAIRS DEPARTMENT
JANATA BHAWAN
DISPUR-06
ASSAM.
6:THE DISTRICT COMMISSIONER
MORIGAON
DISTRICT- MORIGAON
ASSA
–B E F O R E –
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE KAUSHIK GOSWAMI
For the Petitioner
: Mr. D Das, Senior Advocate; Mr. K Mohammed;
Mr. Y Khound; Mr. S M Munir, Advocate.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. T C Chutia, Senior Govt. Advocate;
Mr. B Bikhaya, Advocate.
Date on which judgment
is reserved
:
N/A
Date of pronouncement
of judgment
: 21.07.2026.
Whether the pronouncement
is of the operative part
of the judgment ?
: No.
Whether the full judgment
has been pronounced
: Yes.
Page No.# 3/22
JUDGMENT & ORDER
Heard Mr. D Das, learned senior counsel assisted by Mr. K Mohammed,
learned counsel for the petitioner. Also heard Mr. T C Chutia, learned senior
government advocate assisted by Mr. B Bishaya, learned Government advocate
for the respondents.
2.
By way of the instant writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of
India, the writ petitioner has assailed the impugned order dated 04.08.2025,
whereby the disciplinary authority imposed the penalty of compulsory retirement
upon the petitioner on the basis of the enquiry report dated 23.04.2025
submitted by the enquiry officer pursuant to the show-cause notice dated
25.11.2024.
3.
The brief facts of the case are that the petitioner was appointed as a Sub-
Inspector in the Food, Public Distribution and Consumer Affairs Department,
Government of Assam on 18.01.1991. Thereafter, the petitioner served in
different capacities at various places after earning promotions from time to time.
In the year 2022, while serving at Kamrup (Rural) as Superintendent, the
petitioner was directed to function as the In-charge Assistant Director, Food,
Public Distribution and Consumer Affairs Department, by orders dated
13.12.2022 and 27.12.2022. Pursuant thereto, the petitioner joined as the Incharge Assistant Director at Morigaon. Subsequently, upon his promotion to the
post of Assistant Director, he joined the said post at Morigaon on 17.01.2024.
While discharging his duties at Morigaon, the petitioner was transferred by order
dated 18.09.2024 and was accordingly released on 08.10.2024. Aggrieved by
the transfer order, the petitioner instituted WP(C) No. 5316/2024 before this
Page No.# 4/22
Court. However, the said writ petition was subsequently withdrawn. Thereafter,
on 16.10.2024, the petitioner received a show-cause notice alleging the
following:
“It has come to the notice of the undersigned that you called a press conference
on 16/10/2024 and spoke on matters related to faulty government procedure
without following laid down rules and regulations of the government You were
released from your post at Morigaon district by the office of the undersigned
vide order no eCF MPE 106795/10 dt 08 10 2024 but you continued functioning
and signing files which is in gross violation of official rules Your allegation
against the undersigned is not tenable as per rule 145/3 of Assam Financial
Rules which clearly states that an officer on being released can handover
charge to the next Senior Gazetted Officer of the concerned department Your
behaviour and mode of functioning surmounts to insubordination and disrespect
towards your superior authority.
Under the given circumstances you are asked to show cause as to why
disciplinary action should not be taken against you for gross insubordination
and wilful noncompliance of government order.
Your reply should reach the office of the undersigned within 2 (Two) days of
receipt of this notice.”
4.
Pursuant thereto, the petitioner submitted his reply on 18.10.2024,
denying all the allegations leveled in the said show-cause notice. In the
meantime, by order dated 14.11.2024, respondent No. 5 placed the petitioner
under suspension.
5.
Subsequently, respondent No. 5 issued another show-cause notice dated
25.11.2024, accompanied by the statement of allegations, the list of witnesses
and the list of documents, alleging, inter alia, the following charges:
“In exercise of the power conferred under Rule-9(2) of the Assam Services
(Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1964 read with Article 311 of the Constitution of
India, you are hereby directed to show cause as to why disciplinary
proceedings shall not be initiated against you and why any of the penalties
prescribed in Rule-7 of the Assam Services (Discipline and Appeal) Rules, 1964
Page No.# 5/22
will not be inflicted upon you on the following charges.
Whereas, in the interest of public service, you were transferred to Margherita,
Dist Tinsukia vide Govt. Notification No. eCF 202094/12 dated 18.9.2024.
Whereas, the District Commissioner, Morigaon released you from the post of
Assistant Director, FPD&CA Morigaon on 08.10.2024 vide Order No.Ecf. MPE.
106795/10 dated 08/10/2024 and you were directed to handover charge to
Smt. Sulakshana Borpartrogohain, ACS, Addl. DC, Morigaon vide letter No.
CA.1/2024/Pt-II/62 dated 16.10.2024.
Whereas, as per charge handing over report received in the Department vide
No.MSA.39/91/Pt-II/ dated 18.10.2024, however, you handed over charge of
Assistant Director, FPD&CA, Morigaon on 18th October, 2024 to Smt.
Sulakshana Borpartrogohain, ACS, Addl. DC, Morigaon.
Whereas, the District Commissioner. Morigaon vide letter Memo No.MPE.
7/2022/53-A dated 16.10.2024 had issued you a show cause notice and
alleged that you have been continuing to function and sign official files with ill
intention and with exercising unauthorized power, in gross violation of official
rules. Also you had called a press conference on 16th October 2024 and spoke
on matters related to faulty Government procedures and criticized the
Government in public domain.
Whereas, as per reports received from the District Commissioner. Morigaon,
although you were released from the charge of Assistant Director FPD&CA,
Morigaon on 08.10.2024. however, you were found continuing to sign official
documents after being released from the post of Assistant Director, FPD&CA,
Morigaon, with Ill intention and with exercising unauthorized power which is
gross violation of official rules and serious breach of official procedure, exercise
of unauthorized power, therefore you are charged with Whereas, as per reports
received from the District Commissioner Morigaon you had called a press
conference on 16.10.2024 and spoke on matters related to faulty Government
procedure without following laid down rules and regulations of the Government,
and in violation of Assam Civil Services Conduct Rules, 1965 thus, committing
insubordination and gross misconduct, violation of Assam Civil Services
Conduct Rules, 1965, therefore you are charged with.
Whereas, although you were transferred from Morigaon to Margherita, in the
interest of public service, you blatantly defied Government directions, thus
committing insubordination and gross misconduct, therefore you are charged
with.
Thus, by non-compliance of Government Orders referred herein above and with
your aforementioned unauthorized activities, you have showed complete
disregard to the orders of the Government, which is unbecoming of a
Government servant and construed as insubordination and misconduct in
violation of Assam Civil Services Conduct Rules, 1965.
Page No.# 6/22
Now therefore, you are directed to submit your written statement in defense on
the above charges within 10 (ten) days from the date of receipt of this
communication.
Enclosed.
1. Statement of allegations
2. List of Witnesses
3. List of documents”
6.
The petitioner submitted his written statement of defence denying all the
charges leveled against him. Notwithstanding the same, the respondent
authorities initiated departmental proceedings, and by communication dated
27.01.2025, the petitioner was directed to appear before the enquiry officer.
7.
The enquiry was thereafter conducted by respondent No. 5. Upon
conclusion thereof, the enquiry officer held that Charge Nos. 1 and 2 stood
proved, whereas Charge No. 3 was not fully established. The enquiry report was
submitted on 23.04.2025.
8.
Thereafter, in compliance with Rule 9(A) of the Assam Services (Discipline
and Appeal) Rules, 1964 (hereinafter referred to as “the 1964 Rules”), the
enquiry report was furnished to the petitioner on 08.05.2025. The petitioner
submitted his representation on 03.06.2025, disputing the findings recorded in
the enquiry report.
However, by order dated 04.08.2025, respondent No. 5 imposed upon the
petitioner the penalty of compulsory retirement under Rule 7(v) of the 1964
Rules.
9.
Aggrieved thereby, the petitioner has approached this Court by filing the
present writ petition.
Page No.# 7/22
10. Mr. D. Das, learned senior counsel appearing for the petitioner, submits
that the entire departmental proceeding is vitiated, being arbitrary, contrary to
the statutory procedure and violative of the principles of natural justice.
According to the learned senior counsel, respondent No. 5 acted both as the
enquiry officer and the disciplinary authority. Having conducted the enquiry
herself, respondent No. 5 thereafter accepted her own findings and imposed the
penalty of compulsory retirement upon the petitioner.
11. It is further submitted that during the course of the enquiry, the
Presenting Officer relied upon a preliminary enquiry report prepared by
respondent No. 3. However, the petitioner was never furnished with a copy of
the said report, nor was he associated with the preliminary enquiry.
Consequently, the petitioner had no opportunity to controvert the contents
thereof or cross-examine any witness examined during such enquiry. It is
contended that reliance upon such material, behind the back of the petitioner,
has caused serious prejudice and has vitiated the entire enquiry.
It is also submitted that, in any event, the punishment of compulsory retirement
is grossly disproportionate to the charges alleged.
12. In support of his submissions, learned senior counsel has relied upon
Nirmala L. Jhala vs. State of Gujarat & Another, reported in (2013)
4 SCC 301, to contend that the materials collected during a preliminary
enquiry cannot be relied upon in a regular departmental enquiry unless the
delinquent is associated with such enquiry and afforded an opportunity to
contest the same. According to the learned senior counsel, the reliance placed
upon the preliminary enquiry report in the present case is in clear violation of
the principles of natural justice.
Page No.# 8/22
13. Per contra, learned senior counsel appearing for the respondents submits
that the disciplinary authority imposed the impugned penalty solely on the basis
of the evidence adduced during the regular departmental enquiry. It is
contended that no procedural irregularity was committed in the conduct of the
enquiry and that the petitioner was afforded adequate opportunity of defence
throughout the proceedings. It is further submitted that the enquiry report
along with the preliminary enquiry report submitted by the respondent No. 3
was furnished to the petitioner before the penalty was imposed and, therefore,
the enquiry was conducted strictly in accordance with law, warranting no
interference by this Court in exercise of its writ jurisdiction.
14. I have given my thoughtful consideration to the submissions advanced by
the learned counsel appearing for the parties. I have also perused the materials
available on record and considered the authorities cited at the Bar.
15. It is well settled that while exercising jurisdiction under Article 226 of the
Constitution of India, this Court does not sit as an appellate authority over the
findings recorded in a departmental enquiry. This Court neither re-appreciates
the evidence nor examines the adequacy or reliability thereof, provided the
enquiry has been conducted in accordance with law. Interference is warranted
only where the enquiry is conducted by an incompetent authority; where the
prescribed procedure has not been followed; where there has been violation of
the principles of natural justice; where the authorities have been influenced by
irrelevant or extraneous considerations; where admissible evidence has been
wrongly excluded or inadmissible evidence has materially influenced the
findings; where the conclusions are wholly arbitrary or perverse; or where the
findings are based on no evidence.
Page No.# 9/22
16. In State of Andhra Pradesh vs. S. Sree Rama Rao, reported in
AIR 1963 SC 1723, the Apex Court held that the High Court, while exercising
jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution, is not constituted as a Court of
appeal over the decisions rendered in departmental proceedings. The relevant
observations read as follows:
“7. There is no warrant for the view expressed by the High Court that in
considering whether a public officer is express the misconduct charged against
him, the rule followed in criminal trials that an offence is not established unless
proved by evidence beyond reasonable doubt to the satisfaction of the Court,
must be applied, and if that rule be not applied, the High Court in a petition I
under Article 226 of the Constitution is competent to declare the order of the
authorities holding a departmental enquiry invalid. The High Court is not
constituted in a proceeding under Article 226 of the Constitution a court of
appeal over the decision of the authorities holding a departmental enquiry
against a public servant it is concerned to determine whether the enquiry is
held by an authority competent in that behalf, and according to the procedure
prescribed in that behalf, and whether the rules of natural justice are not
violated, Where there is some evidence, which the authority entrusted with the
duty to hold the enquiry has accepted and which evidence may reasonably
support the conclusion that the delinquent officer is guilty of the charge, it is not
the function of the High Court in a petition for a writ under Article 226 to review
the evidence and to arrive at an independent finding on the evidence. The High
Court may undoubtedly interfere where the departmental authorities have held
the proceedings against the delinquent in a manner inconsistent with the rules
of natural justice or in violation of the statutory rules prescribing the mode of
enquiry or where the authorities have disabled themselves from reaching a fair
decision by some considerations extraneous to the evidence and the merits of
the case or by allowing themselves to be influenced by irrelevant considerations
or where the conclusion on the very face of it is so wholly arbitrary and
capricious that no reasonable person could ever have arrived at that conclusion,
or on similar grounds. But the departmental authorities are, if the enquiry is
otherwise properly held, the sole judges of facts and if there be some legal
evidence on which their findings can be based, the adequacy or reliability of
that evidence is not a matter which can be permitted to be canvassed before the
High Court in a proceeding for a writ under Article 226 of the Constitution.”
Page No.# 10/22
17. A reading of the aforesaid judgment makes it abundantly clear that
interference is permissible where the enquiry is conducted in violation of the
principles of natural justice or the statutory rules governing the enquiry, or
where the decision-making process is vitiated by irrelevant considerations,
perversity or arbitrariness.
18. Bearing the aforesaid principles in mind, this Court now proceeds to
examine the facts of the present case.
19. It appears from the records that respondent No. 5 issued the show-cause
notice dated 25.11.2024 alleging that the petitioner failed to hand over charge
upon his transfer and continued to function in the post from which he had
already been relieved. Along with the show-cause notice, the statement of
allegations, list of witnesses and list of documents were furnished.
20. It further appears that, by order dated 24.01.2025, the Joint Secretary to
the Government of Assam, Food, Public Distribution and Consumer Affairs
Department appointed respondent No. 5 as the Enquiry Officer to enquire into
the charges framed against the petitioner. By communication dated 27.01.2025,
the petitioner was informed that the enquiry would commence on 29.01.2025.
The petitioner admittedly participated in the enquiry proceedings.
21. Upon completion of the enquiry, respondent No. 5 submitted the enquiry
report. A perusal of the report reveals that, while arriving at the findings on the
points for determination, respondent No. 5 also relied upon the findings
recorded in a preliminary enquiry conducted by respondent No. 3, which had
been produced by the Presenting Officer during the departmental enquiry.
Admittedly, a copy of the said preliminary enquiry report was never furnished to
Page No.# 11/22
the petitioner.
22. It further appears that after considering the petitioner’s representation
dated 03.06.2025 against the enquiry report, respondent No. 5 herself
proceeded to consider the enquiry report, the petitioner’s representation and
the materials on record, and by order dated 04.08.2025 imposed upon the
petitioner the penalty of compulsory retirement under Rule 7(v) of the 1964
Rules.
23. At this stage, it would be apposite to refer to Rule 7 of the 1964 Rules,
which reads as follows:
“7. Nature of penalties. The following penalties may, for good and sufficient
reason and as hereinafter provided, be imposed on a Government servant,
namely: (i) censure;
(ii) withholding of increments of promotion;
(iii) recovery from pay of the whole or part of any pecuniary loss caused by
negligence or breach of orders to the Government of Assam or the Central
Government or any other State Government, or any local or other authority to
whom services of a Government servant had been lent;
(iv) reduction to a lower service, grade or post, or to lower time-scale, or to lower
stage in a time-scale; a
(v) compulsory retirement;
(vi) removal from service which shall not be disqualification for future
employment;
(vii) dismissal from service, which shall ordinarily be a disqualification for future
employment.”
24. Rule 7 enumerates the various penalties which may be imposed upon a
Government servant, including compulsory retirement under clause (v) and
dismissal from service under clause (vii), the latter ordinarily operating as a
disqualification for future employment.
Page No.# 12/22
25. Rule 8 of the 1964 Rules reads as follows:
“8. Disciplinary Authority. 1. The Governor may impose any one or more of the
penalties specified in rule 7 on any Government servant 2. Without prejudice to
the provisions of sub-rule (1), but subject to the provisions of sub-rule (3) any
one or more of the penalties specified in rule 7 may be imposed on member of a
State Service by the Appointing Authority or by any other authority empowered
in this behalf by a general or special order of the Governor. 3. Notwithstanding
anything contained in this rule no penalty specified in clauses (iv) to (vii) of the
rule 7 shall be imposed by an authority lower than the Appointing Authority.”
26.
Rule 9 of the 1964 Rules, which prescribes the procedure for imposing
penalties, reads as follows:
“9. Procedure for imposing penalties.
(1) Without prejudice to the provisions of the Public Servant; (Inquiry) Act, 1850,
no order imposing on a Government servant any of the penalties specified in
rule 7 shall be passed except after an inquiry, held as far as may be in the
manner hereinafter provided.
(2) The Disciplinary Authority shall frame definite charges on the basis of the
allegations on which the inquiry is proposed to be held. Such charges together
with a statement of the allegations on which they are based shall be
communicated in writing to the Government servant, and he shall be required to
submit, within such time as may be specified by the Disciplinary Authority, a
written statement of his defence and also to state whether he desires to be
heard in person.
*(2.1) At the time of delivering the charges, the Disciplinary Authority shall
invariably furnish to the Government servant a list of documents and witnesses
by which each article of charges is proposed to be sustained.
Explanation- In this sub-rule and sub-rule (3), the expression "the Disciplinary
Authority" shall include the authority competent under these rules to impose
upon the Government servant any of the penalties specified in Rule 7.
(3)
The Government servant shall, for the purpose of preparing his defence, be
permitted to inspect and take extracts from such official records as he may
specify, provided that such permission may be refused if for reasons to be
recorded in writing, in the opinion of the Disciplinary Authority such
records are not relevant for the purpose or its against the public interest to
allow him access thereto :
Page No.# 13/22
Provided that when a Government servant is permitted to inspect and
take extracts from official records due case shall be taken against
tempering removal or destruction of records.
(4)
On received of the written statement of defence, or if no such statement is
received within the time specified the Disciplinary Authority may itself
inquire into such of the charge as are not admitted or, if it considers it
necessary so to do, appoint for the purpose a Board of Inquiry or an
Inquiring Officer.
(5)
The Disciplinary Authority may nominate any person to present the case in
support of the charges before the authority inquiring into the charges
(hereinafter referred to as the inquiring authority). The Government servant
may present his case with the assistance of any other Government servant
approved by the Disciplinary Authority, but may not engage
a legal practitioner for the purpose unless the person nominated by the
Disciplinary Authority as aforesaid is a legal practitioner or unless the
Disciplinary Authority, having regard to the circumstances of the case so
permits.
(6)
The Enquiring Authority shall, in the course of the enquiry consider such
documentary evidence and take such oral evidence as may be relevant or
material in regard to the charges. The Government servant shall be entitled
to cross-examine witnesses examined in support of the charges and to give
evidence in person and to adduce documentary and oral evidence in his
defence. The person presenting the case in support of the charges shall be
entitled to cross-examine the Government servant and the witnesses
examined in his defence. If the Inquiring Authority declines to examine any
witness or to admit any document in evidence on the ground that his
evidence or such document is not relevant or material, it shall record its
reasons in writing.
(7)
At the conclusion of the inquiry, the inquiring Authority shall prepare a
report of the enquiry, recording its findings on each of the charges together
with reasons therefor.
["Explanations- If in the opinion of the Enquiring Authority the proceedings
of the enquiry establish any article of charge different from the original
article of the charge it may record its findings on such article of charge :
Provided that the findings on such article of charge shall not be
Page No.# 14/22
recorded unless the Government servant has either admitted the
facts on which such article of charge is based or has a reasonable
opportunity of defending himself against such article of charge"].
(8)
(9)
The record of the inquiry, shall include
(i)
the charges framed against the Government servant and the
statement of allegations furnished to him under sub-rule (2);
(ii)
his written statement of defence, if any;
(iii)
the oral evidence taken in the course of the enquiry;
(iv)
the documentary evidence considered in the course of the inquiry;
(v)
the orders, if any, made by the Disciplinary Authority and the
Inquiring Authority in regard to the inquiry; and
(vi)
a report setting out the findings on each charge and the reasons
therefor.
The Disciplinary Authority shall, if it is not the Inquiring Authority; consider
the record of the inquiry and record its finding on each charge.
(10) Major Penalties.
If the Disciplinary Authority having regard to its finding on the charges
and on the basis of evidence adduced during the inquiry, is of the opinion
that any of the penalties specified in Clauses (iv) to (vii) of Rule 7 should
be imposed on the Government servant it shall make an order imposing
such penalty and it shall not be necessary to give the Government
servant any opportunity of making representation on the penalty
proposed to be imposed :
Provided that in every case where it is necessary to consult the
Commission the record of the inquiry shall be forwarded by the
Disciplinary Authority to the Commission for its advice and such
advice shall be taken into consideration before making an order
imposing and such penalty on the Government servant"].
(11) Minor Penalties.
Page No.# 15/22
If the Disciplinary Authority, having regard to its findings on the charges,
is of the opinion that any of the penalties specified in clauses (i) to (iii) of
Rule 7 should be imposed, it shall, pass appropriate orders and in every
case in which it is necessary to consult the Commission, shall do so, after
consulting the Commission.
(12) (a) Notwithstanding anything contained in this rule, it shall not be
necessary to follow the procedure laid down in the preceeding sub-rules in
cases where it appears to the authority competent to impose the penalty at
the initial stage of the proceedings that the penalty of censure would be
adequate, but if at any later stage it is proposed to impose any other
penalty specified in Rule 7, the procedure laid down in the said rules shall
be followed.
(b) No order imposing the penalty of censure shall however be passed,
except after(i)
the Government servent is informed in writing of the proposal to
take action against him and of the allegations on which it is
proposed to be taken and given an opportunity to make any
representation he may wish to make; and
(ii)
such representation, if any, is taken into consideration by the
Disciplinary Authority.”
27. A plain reading of Rule 9(2) makes it clear that the disciplinary authority is
required to frame definite charges based upon the allegations and communicate
the same, together with the statement of allegations, to the delinquent
Government servant, calling upon him to submit his written statement of
defence.
28. It is further evident from Rule 9 (7) that, upon conclusion of the enquiry,
the Enquiry Officer is required to prepare a report recording findings on each of
the charges with reasons therefor. Rule 9 (9) further contemplates that where
the disciplinary authority is not itself the Enquiry Officer, it shall consider the
record of enquiry and record its findings on each charge.
Page No.# 16/22
29. In the present case, respondent No. 5 admittedly functioned as the
Enquiry Officer and conducted the enquiry culminating in the enquiry report.
Thereafter, respondent No. 5 also proceeded to act as the disciplinary authority
and accepted her own findings while imposing the impugned penalty upon the
petitioner.
30. It also transpires from the enquiry report that respondent No. 5 relied
upon the findings recorded in the preliminary enquiry conducted by respondent
No. 3 while deciding the points for determination. Admittedly, a copy of the said
preliminary enquiry report was never supplied to the petitioner.
31. The questions which, therefore, arise for consideration are: (i) whether
reliance upon a preliminary enquiry report during the course of a regular
departmental enquiry, without furnishing a copy thereof to the delinquent
employee, vitiates the enquiry on account of violation of the principles of natural
justice; and (ii) whether, in the facts of the present case, respondent No. 5
could have simultaneously acted as the Enquiry Officer and thereafter, as the
disciplinary authority, accepted her own enquiry report and imposed the penalty.
32. It appears from the enquiry report submitted by respondent No. 5 that
while recording her findings on the points for determination in respect of the
charges framed against the petitioner, she had, inter alia, relied upon the
findings recorded in the preliminary enquiry conducted by respondent No. 3 and
produced by the Presenting Officer during the course of the departmental
enquiry. The said position is further fortified by the affidavit-in-opposition filed
by respondent Nos. 4 and 5, wherein the enquiry officer has categorically
admitted that the preliminary enquiry report dated 30.11.2024 constituted one
of the material pieces of evidence relied upon during the regular departmental
Page No.# 17/22
enquiry. Paragraph 14 of the affidavit-in-opposition reads as follows:
“14 That with regard to the statement made in paragraph No. 16 to the writ
petition the deponent begs to state that the statement made therein is not true.
The charge sheet to the Petitioner were issued vide Show Cause Notice dated
25.11.2024 However, the Enquiry Report dated 30.11.2024 as was conducted
by Respondent no. 3 was an enquiry report conducted in the field i.e. in the O/o
the District Commissioner, Morigaon to trace out the unauthorized activities,
post his release from the charge of Assistant Director, FPD&CA, Morigaon vide
order dated 08.10.2024 As such, the Enquiry Report dated 30.11 2024
conducted by the Respondent No. 3 was the material evidence for the enquiry
conducted by Respondent No 5 in connection with the DP case drawn against
the Petitioner.”
33. The question as to the evidentiary value of a preliminary enquiry in a
regular departmental proceeding is no longer res integra. The Apex Court in
Narayan Dattatraya Ramteerthakhar vs. State of Maharashtra,
reported in (1997) 1 SCC 299, categorically held as follows:
“The preliminary inquiry has nothing to do with the enquiry conducted after
issue of charge-sheet. The former action would be to find whther disciplinary
enquiry should be initiated against the delinquent. After full-fledged enquiry
was held, the preliminary enquiry had lost its importance.”
34. The aforesaid principle came to be further explained by the Apex Court in
Nirmala J. Jhala vs. State of Gujarat & Another, reported in (2013)
4 SCC 301. After considering Narayan Dattatraya Ramteerthakhar
(Supra) along with several earlier authorities, the Apex Court authoritatively
held that the materials collected during a preliminary enquiry cannot constitute
evidence in a regular departmental enquiry unless such materials are duly
proved in accordance with law and the delinquent is afforded an effective
Page No.# 18/22
opportunity to contest the same. The relevant observations are reproduced
below:
“45. In view of the above, it is evident that the evidence recorded in preliminary
inquiry cannot be used in regular inquiry as the delinquent is not associated
with it, and opportunity to cross-examine the persons examined in such inquiry
is not given Using such evidence would be violative of the principles of natural
justice.
46. In Ayaaubkhan Noorkhan Pathan v State of Maharashtra³1 this Court while
placing reliance upon a large number of earlier judgments held that crossexamination is an integral part of the principles of natural justice. and a
statement recorded behind back of a person wherein the delinquent had no
opportunity to cross-examine such persons, the same cannot be relied upon.
47. The preliminary enquiry may be useful only to take a prima facie view, as to
whether there can be some substance in the allegation made against an
employee which may warrant a regular enquiry.
48. A prima facie case does not mean a case proved to the hilt but a case which
can be said to be established if the evidence which is led in support of the case
were [to be] believed While determining whether a prima facie case had been
made out or not the relevant consideration is whether on the evidence led it was
possible to arrive at the conclusion in question and not whether that was the
only conclusion which could be arrived at on that evidence" (Vide Martin Burn
Ltd v R.N Banerjee32, AIR p. 85, para 27) [See also Bangalore Woollen Cotton
and Silk Mills Co. Ltd v B Dasappa33, VC Shukla v State (Delhi Admn )34,
Dalpat Kumar v Prahlad Singh35 and Cholan Roadways Ltd. v G.
Thirugnanasambandam36].
49. The issue, as to whether in the instant case the material collected in
preliminary enquiry could be used against the appellant, has to be considered
by taking into account the facts and circumstances of the case. In the
preliminary enquiry, the department placed reliance upon the statements made
by the accused-complainant and Shri CB Gajjar, Advocate Shri C B Gajjar in his
statement has given the same version as he has deposed in regular enquiry
Shri Gajjar did not utter a single word about the meeting with the appellant on
17-8-1993, as he had stated that he had asked the accused-complainant to pay
Rs 20,000 as was agreed with by Shri PK Pancholı, Advocate. Of course, Shri
CB Gajjar, complainant, has definitely reiterated the stand he had taken in his
complaint. The charge-sheet served upon the appellant contained 12 charges.
Only the first charge related to the incident dated 17-8-1993 was in respect of
the case of the complainant The other charges related to various other cıvıl and
Page No.# 19/22
criminal cases The same were for not deciding the application for interim reliefs,
etc.”
35. A conjoint reading of the aforesaid decisions leaves no manner of doubt
that the object of a preliminary enquiry is only to enable the employer to
ascertain whether there exists a prima facie case warranting initiation of
disciplinary proceedings. Such an enquiry is merely exploratory in nature and is
not intended to determine the guilt of the delinquent. Consequently, the findings
recorded in a preliminary enquiry cannot, by themselves, be treated as
substantive evidence in a regular departmental proceeding unless the materials
collected therein are independently proved during the regular enquiry after
affording the delinquent full opportunity to rebut the same.
36. Examining the facts of the present case in the light of the aforesaid settled
principles, this Court finds that the enquiry officer herself has treated the
findings recorded in the preliminary enquiry as one of the foundational materials
while deciding the points for determination framed in the departmental
proceeding. The enquiry report clearly reflects that the conclusions arrived at
therein were not based solely upon the evidence adduced during the regular
enquiry, but were also influenced by the findings recorded in the preliminary
enquiry.
37. The above conclusion stands further reinforced by the specific stand taken
by respondent No. 4 in paragraph 14 of the affidavit-in-opposition, wherein the
enquiry officer has unequivocally admitted that the preliminary enquiry report
dated 30.11.2024 constituted “the material evidence” in the disciplinary
proceeding. Such an admission leaves no room for doubt that the preliminary
enquiry report was not merely referred to for the limited purpose of initiating
Page No.# 20/22
the disciplinary proceeding but was, in fact, relied upon while determining the
guilt of the petitioner.
38. Admittedly, the said preliminary enquiry report was never furnished to the
petitioner during the pendency of the regular departmental enquiry. The
contention advanced on behalf of the respondents that the report was
subsequently supplied to the petitioner along with the enquiry report does not
cure the defect. Furnishing the report after the enquiry had concluded could not
have enabled the petitioner to explain the allegations contained therein,
controvert the materials collected during the preliminary enquiry or effectively
cross-examine the persons whose statements formed the basis thereof. The
opportunity contemplated under the principles of natural justice is an
opportunity before the material is relied upon and not after the findings have
already been recorded.
39. Equally untenable is the submission of the respondents that no prejudice
has been caused to the petitioner. The concept of prejudice in departmental
proceedings cannot be viewed in a narrow or technical sense. The petitioner, in
his representation dated 03.06.2025 against the enquiry report, had specifically
asserted as follows:
“The bemusing fact here is that the enquiry team from the commissionerate
office did not ask me to appear before them, nor did they hear me or ask for any
kind of explanation or clarification from my end during the enquiry against me.
This implies that the enquiry was not done in a proper judicious manner by the
enquiry team.”
The above objection clearly demonstrates that the petitioner had
consistently asserted that he had been completely excluded from the
Page No.# 21/22
preliminary enquiry and was denied any opportunity to participate therein.
40. This Court, therefore, has no hesitation in holding that the preliminary
enquiry was conducted behind the back of the petitioner. The report prepared
pursuant thereto was admittedly relied upon as material evidence during the
regular departmental enquiry without the petitioner ever being associated with
such enquiry or being afforded an opportunity to controvert the materials
collected therein or cross-examine the persons whose statements were relied
upon. Such a course of action is in the teeth of the law laid down by the Apex
Court in Nirmala J. Jhala (supra) and constitutes a clear violation of the
principles of natural justice. The departmental enquiry, therefore, stands
vitiated.
41. In view of the foregoing discussion, the first issue is answered in favour of
the petitioner. Once this Court has reached the conclusion that the departmental
enquiry itself stands vitiated for violation of the principles of natural justice, it is
neither necessary nor expedient to examine the second issue relating to the
legality of respondent No. 5 acting simultaneously as the enquiry officer as well
as the disciplinary authority. Any opinion rendered thereon would be purely
academic.
42. Consequently, the enquiry conducted against the petitioner stands vitiated
and is hereby set aside. As a natural corollary, the impugned order dated
04.08.2025 imposing the penalty of compulsory retirement, having been
founded upon such vitiated enquiry, also cannot be sustained and is accordingly
quashed.
Page No.# 22/22
43. The respondents shall consequently reinstate the petitioner in service in
accordance with law. The consequential service benefits shall also be regulated
in accordance with the applicable rules and shall abide by the outcome of any
fresh proceeding, if initiated.
44. It is, however, made clear that this Court has not examined the merits of
the allegations levelled against the petitioner. The interference is confined solely
to the legality of the decision-making process. Accordingly, it shall be open to
the respondents, if so advised, to initiate and conclude fresh disciplinary
proceedings against the petitioner from the stage of the defect noticed herein,
strictly in accordance with law and after complying with the principles of natural
justice.
45. With the above observations and directions, the instant writ petition,
stands allowed and disposed of.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review