Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
GAHC040004822026
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT AT GUWAHATI
(The High Court of Assam, Nagaland, Mizoram and Arunachal Pradesh)
Itanagar Permanent Bench
Review Petition No. 4(AP)/2026
1. ShriMatheimLinggi, aged about 59 years, Son of Late G. Linggi, permanent
resident of Mayu-II village, P.O& P.S Roing, District Lower Dibang Valley,
Arunachal Pradesh.
2. ShriLokepLinggi, aged about 47 years, permanent resident of Dambuk,
presently residing at Mayu-II, PO& PS Roing,
District Lower Dibang Valley, Arunachal Pradesh.
3. Shri Newton Linggi, aged about 45 years, permanent resident of Dambuk,
presently residing at Ezengo, PO & PS Roing, District Lower Dibang Valley,
Arunachal Pradesh.
4. SmtiKomolaMito, aged about 52 years, permanent resident of Dambuk,
presently residing at Mayu-II, PO & PS Roing, District Lower Dibang Valley,
Arunachal Pradesh.
5.ShriAengaLinggi, aged about 31 years, permanent resident of Dambuk,
presently residing at Mayu-II, PO & PS Roing, District Lower Dibang Valley,
Arunachal Pradesh.
6. Miss LaxmiLinggi, aged about 32 years, permanent resident of Dambuk,
presently residing at Mayu-II, PO & PS Roing,
District-Lower Dibang Valley, Arunachal Pradesh.
7. Miss YaminiLinggi, aged about 30 years, permanent resident of Dambuk,
presently residing at Mayu-II, PO & PS Roing, District Lower Dibang Valley,
Arunachal Pradesh.
8. Miss AmiyaLinggi, aged about 26 years, permanent resident of Dambuk,
presently residing at Mayu-II, PO & PS Roing, District Lower Dibang Valley,
Arunachal Pradesh.
9. ShriAjoLinggi, aged about 24 years, permanent resident of Dambuk, presently
residing at Mayu-II, PO & PS Roing, District Lower Dibang Valley, Arunachal
Pradesh.
……Review petitioners
-Versus-
1. ShriBohomi Mimi, age S/o late Yora Mimi, resident of Sirang Village, PO & PS
Dambuk, District Dibang Valley, Arunachal Pradesh.
2.ShriBota Mimi, age Son of late Yora Mimi, resident of Mayu-II Village, PO & PS
Roing, District Lower Dibang Valley, Arunachal Pradesh.
3. ShriAjad Mimi @ Wuti Mimi, age Son of late Yora Mimi, permanent resident of
Intaya Village, PO & PS Roing, District Lower Dibang Valley, Arunachal
Pradesh.
4. The State of Arunachal Pradesh and 8 Ors. Represented by the Chief Secretary,
Govt. of Arunachal Pradesh, Itanagar.
5. The Secretary, Land Management, Govt. ofArunachal Pradesh, Civil Secretariat,
Itanagar.
6. The Principal Chief Conservator, Department of Environment and Forest, Govt.
of Arunachal Pradesh, Itanagar.
7. The Chief Conservator of Forest, Eastern Arunachal Circle, Tezu, Arunachal
Pradesh.
8. The Deputy Commissioner, Lower Dibang Valley District, Roing, Arunachal
Pradesh.
9. The National Hydroelectric Power Corporation, represented by its Chairmancum-Managing Director NHPC Office Complex Sector 33 Faridabad-121003,
Haryana.
10. The General Manager, Dibang Multipurpose Project, Mayu Sector, PO Roing,
LowerDibang Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh.
11. NarkoLinggi, Son of late AnggandoLinggi, resident of Village Sirang, Dambuk,
PS Roing, Lower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal Prades-792110.
12. Smti Rani Mimi, age 55, wife of Gandhi Mito, resident of Village Sirang, PS
Roing, Lower Dibang Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh-792110.
……Opposite party/Respondent
BEFORE
HON’BLE MR. JUSTICE ROBIN PHUKAN
Advocate for the review petitioners
:
Mr. T. Son
Advocate for the respondents No. 1, 2, & 3 :
Advocate for the respondents No. 4 to 10 :
Advocate for the respondents No. 11 & 12 :
Mr. M. Chanda.
Mr. R.H. Nabam, Addl.A.G.
Mr. T.T. Tara, Sr. Counsel,
assisted by Ms. E. Smith.
Date on which judgment is reserved
:
22.06.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
:
21.07.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the
operative part of the judgment?
:
N/A
:
Yes
Whether the full judgment has been
pronounced?
JUDGEMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. T. Son, learned counsel for the petitioners; Mr. T. Garam,
learned counsel for the respondent Nos. 1, 2 & 3; Mr. R.H. Nabam,
learned Additional Advocate General for the State respondent Nos. 4 10; and Mr. T.T. Tara, learned senior counsel assisted by Ms. E. Smith,
learned counsel for the respondent Nos. 11 & 12.
2.
This review petition, under Section 114 read with Order
XXXXVII Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure is directed against the
order dated 19.03.2026, passed by this Court in WP(C) No.352/2025
and WP(C) No.247/2025.
3.
It is to be noted here that vide order dated 19.03.2026, both
the writ petitions were disposed of on the basis of the submission
advanced by learned counsel for both the parties.
Background Facts:-
4.
The background facts, leading to filing of the present review
petition, are briefly stated as under:Page 4 of 28
“In the year 2025, the Government of Arunachal Pradesh had
issued the Notification, under Section 10 of Balipara/Tirap/Sadiya
Frontier Track Jhum Land (Amendment) Act 2024, vide No. LMD13011/1/2021, dated 19.06.2025, in the name of the Governor of
Arunachal Pradesh, for acquisition for public purposes, a parcel of
land measuring 68.40 Hactares i.e. for construction of Right Bank
Road, from ADC Morh to Mithun Gate, at New Apali, under
Dambuk Sub-Division, LowerDibang Valley District, for the
construction of Dibang Multipurpose Project (2880 MW) in Lower
Dibang Valley District, Arunachal Pradesh. The boundary of the
land to be acquired 68.40 ha, is as under:North:- Private & Community Land
South:- Private & Community Land
East:-Private & Community Land
West:- Private & Community Land
The private lands of the petitioners were taken over for the
aforesaid purpose, without making any land compensation to the
petitioners for acquisition of the Land Measuring 68.88 hectares,
as per the Provisions of the Right to Fair Compensation and
Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement
Act 2013. Then as per the direction of the State Government, the
Deputy Commissioner, Lower Dibang Valley District accepted for
hearing the Claims and Objections, on the date of Final
Notification, but on 29-12-2025 and 30-12-2025, the Deputy
Commissioner, Lower Dibang Valley, Roing as well as ADC
Dambuk after taking over the final hearing, the ADC Dambuk all
of sudden, sent entire claims and objections before Deputy
Commissioner, Roing for final adjudication, as a result of which all
the parties were asked to submit Primary documents and on
being produce the primary documents, the ADC Dambuk took up
the hearing and after hearing, the ADC Dambuk submitted a
report, dated 15-10-2025,to the effect that petitioners do not
have any primary documentary evidence to proof their ownership.
The applicant, thereafter, obtained all relevant documents
through the RTI, issued by DLR&SO, Roing, Lower Dibang Valley
District and found that inspite of negative report on the primary
evidence adduced by the petitioner in WP(C)No. 352/2025 and
linked case No. WP(C) No. 247/2025, Shri Narko Linggi & 8 Ors.
had misled this Court that they have compromised the dispute,
amicably settled the dispute. Whereas, there is no written
documentary evidence to substantiate before the court as regard
the legality and validity of such amicable settlement which is
totally incorrect statements placed before the Court on 19-032026, by the learned counsel on behalf of petitioners and learned
counsel for the respondent No. 7, and the petitioner's counsel
without obtaining certified copy from the Registry, just took a
printout of the order copy from the website and later on,
submitted said order copy to Deputy Commissioner as well as the
ADC Dambuk without submitting any compromised letter and in
fact, there was no record of compromise between the parties.
Accordingly, on 19-03-2026, on the submission of learned counsel
for the writ petitioner, the writ petition stood closed without
providing any opportunity to the petitioners nor the petitioner's
ever impleaded in the said petition as party for fair and
transparent dispensation of justice.
It is the case of the petitioners that on 24-12-2025, the Deputy
Commissioner had issued Notice vide No. DL-LDV-22016/3/2023,
dated 18th December, 2025 and vide said notice, the applicant No.
1 was directed to appear before him on the above mentioned
date and time alongwith relevant documents or any other
evidence in support of their claims/objections to his Office on or
before 26-12-2025, in continuation of land acquisition proceeding
relating to construction of the Right Bank Road from ADC Morh to
Mithun Gate, at New Aphali and additional facility area (from
area/stretch 1 to 4). It was also notified that claims and
objections regarding rightful ownership over the land notified for
acquisition measuring 68.88 Hectares. Then as directed by the
DC, Roing, the petitioners submitted documents alongwith the list
of relevant documents from Serial Nos. 1 to 40, as mentioned in
the list for perusal at the time of hearing. However, on the day of
29-12-2025, the DC, Roing, did not take up the final hearing and
it was adjourned for some other day, and that the land measuring
68.88 hectares, is still pending for disposal, whereas, the land
measuring 68.88 hectares has also been included in the order
passed by this Court on 19-03-2026, as well as land measuring
17.62 hectares, without impleading the names of the petitioners
in the joint petition filed by the parties in respect of the plot of
land measuring 17.62 hectares, out of 68.678 hectares, which is
innocuous. The petitioners are in possession of the said land and
the respondents cannot claim rights over the ownership of the
land since there is no any primary evidence relating to the land in
question as because the respondents failed to adduce any primary
evidence during the hearing before the ADC, Dambuk. Therefore,
the respondent in writ petition in WP(C) No. 352/2025 and WP(C)
No. 247/2025, had not impleaded the petitioners as necessary
parties as in the said two writ petitions before this Court and
obtain the order dated 19-03-2026 on surreptitiously with an
intention to draw benefits from the respondents authority without
any ownership of the land measuring 68.36 hectares (rounded of
68.40 Hectares).
The petitioners of the writ petitions are not the rightful owners
of lands and before being filed any petition for amicable
settlement of the case, the petitioners herein are entitled to be
heard and they should have been impleaded by this Court in the
connected writ petition. Now the petitioners are being affected by
the order dated 19-03-2026, passed by this Court in Writ Petition
No. 352/2025 and WP(C) No. 247/2025.
It is also their case that there is no any intentional and
willful and deliberate delay on the part of the petitioners for
delaying of filing the instant review petition before this Court, as
because the order was passed on 19-03-2026 by this Hon'ble
Court.
Being highly aggrieved by the Order dated 19-03-2026,
passed in WP(C) No. 352/2025 and WP(C) No. 247/2025 by this
Court, without impleading the petitioners as parties in both the
writ petition the petitioners preferred this review petition on the
following grounds amongst others:(A)
The learned counsels of the parties acted illegally and
with material irregularity by misleading this Court, got
the order dated 19.03.2026 passed, without impleading
the petitioners as necessary parties in WP(C) No.
352/2025 and WP(C) No. 247/2025 and thereby caused
irreparable loss and injuries and as such, the order dated
19-03-2026 is liable to be reviewed as the same being
not sustainable in law.
(B)
The hearing for claims and objections before the
Additional Deputy Commissioner, Dambuk has failed due
to deficiencies of primary evidence and accordingly, the
same were disposed of and that there is no any amicable
settlement between the parties.
(C)
The petitioners cases are pending before the Deputy
Commissioner, Lower Dibang Valley District, Roing.
(D)
There is no any fault on the part of petitioners in the
instant review petition.
5.
The respondents have not filed their objection/affidavit in this
petition.
Submission of learned counsel for the petitioners:-
6.
Mr. Son, learned counsel for the petitioners, at the time of
hearing, has re-iterated the grounds mentioned in the petition. He
submits that the petitioners herein are in possession of both the
stretches of land measuring 68.678 hectares and 17.62 hectares, and
they are the rightful owners and at the time of hearing claim and
objection, the ADC, has illegally held that they have no primary
documents to support their claim. He further submits that the
respondents herein had never impleaded the petitioner as party in the
writ proceeding and the order under review was passed without giving
an opportunity of being heard to them. Therefore, the petitioners
suffered serious prejudice and that there was no compromise as
submitted by the respondent before this Court at the time of hearing
of the writ petitions. Under the given factual scenario Mr. Son has
contended to allow this petition and to review the order dated
19.03.2026.
6.1.
Notably, Mr. Son, when asked as to whether the petitioners
herein had filed any claim and objection regarding the land measuring
17.62 hectors, before the ADC/Deputy Commissioner, Lower Dibong
Valley district, submitted that they have not filed any claim and
objection in respect of 17.62 hectors of land, however, they have
made verbal claim and objection.
7.
Per contra, Mr. Nabam, learned counsel for the respondent
Nos. 4 to 10 submits that two different notifications were issued by
the respondent authorities for acquiring two different stretches of land
being 68.678 hectares and 17.62 hectares, and that the competent
authority had issued notice to the petitioner at the time of hearing
claims and objections and the petitioners herein had failed to produce
any primary documents in support of their claims of ownership of the
said stretch of land. He also submits that in respect of the 17.62
hectares of land the petitioners have not filed any claim and objection,
and as such this petition is not maintainable and accordingly, he has
contended to dismiss the same.
8.
On the other hand Mr. T. T. Tara, learned counsel for the
respondent Nos. 11 and 12, submitted that this petition is not at all
maintainable and the petition has been prepared in such language
which itself amounts to contempt and suo-moto contempt proceeding
may be initiated against the petitioners and their counsel. He also
submits that 17.62 hectares of land is different from the 66.678
hectares of land and since the petitioners have admittedly not filed
any claim and objection before the ADC/DC of the district, now they
cannot ask for review of the order dated 19.03.2026, wherein they
were not a party and on this count also this petition is liable to be
dismissed. He also submits that the petitioners have failed to show
existence of any ground for review of the order dated 19.03.2026 and
therefore, it has contended to dismiss this petition.
Mr. T. Garam, learned counsel for the respondent No. 1, 2 and
9.
3 also adopted the submissions advanced by Mr. Tara, learned counsel
for the respondent Nos. 10/11, and he further submitted that the
stretch of land measuring 17.62 hectares is different from stretch of
land of 68.678 hectares, and that the petitioners and respondents in
WP(C) No. 352/2025 and WP(C) No. 247/2025, have amicably settled
the dispute and they have also filed affidavits to that effect and as
such this review petition is devoid of substance and the same may be
dismissed.
10.
Having heard the submissions of learned counsel for both the
parties, this Court has carefully gone through the petition and the
documents placed on record and also gone through the order under
review, dated 19.03.2026. Also gone through the relevant provisions
of law.
11.
The principles, on which review is permissible, is well settled in
catena of decisions of Hon’ble Supreme Court. KamleshVerma v.
Mayawati and others, reported in (2013) 8 SCC 320, is one of
the notable case where Hon’ble Supreme Court has summarized the
principles as under:“Summary of the principles
20. Thus, in view of the above, the following
grounds of review are maintainable as stipulated by
the statute:
20.1. When the review will be maintainable:
(i)
Discovery of new and important matter or
evidence which, after the exercise of due
diligence, was not within knowledge of the
petitioner or could not be produced by him;
(ii) Mistake or error apparent on the face of
the record;
(iii)
Any other sufficient reason.
The words “any other sufficient reason” have been
interpreted in Chhajju Ram v. Neki [(1921-22)
49 IA 144: (1922) 16 LW 37: AIR 1922 PC 112]
and approved by this Court in Moran Mar
BasseliosCatholicos v. Most Rev. Mar Poulose
Athanasius [AIR 1954 SC 526 : (1955) 1 SCR
520] to mean “a reason sufficient on grounds
at least analogous to those specified in the
rule”.
The
same
principles
have
been
reiterated
in Union
of
India v. Sandur
Manganese & Iron Ores Ltd. [(2013) 8 SCC 337 :
JT (2013) 8 SC 275]
20.2. When the review will not be maintainable:
(i)
(ii)
A repetition of old and overruled argument is
not
enough
to
reopen
concluded
adjudications.
Minor mistakes of inconsequential import.
(iii)
Review proceedings cannot be equated with
the original hearing of the case.
(iv)
Review is not maintainable unless the
material error, manifest on the face of the
order, undermines its soundness or results in
miscarriage of justice.
(v)
A review is by no means an appeal in disguise
whereby an erroneous decision is reheard and
corrected but lies only for patent error.
(vi)
The mere possibility of two views on the
subject cannot be a ground for review.
(vii)
The error apparent on the face of the record
should not be an error which has to be
fished out and searched.
(viii) The appreciation of evidence on record is
fully within the domain of the appellate
court, it cannot be permitted to be advanced
in the review petition.
(ix)
Review is not maintainable when the same
relief sought at the time of arguing the
main matter had been negatived.”
11.1. Again in the case of Sanjay Kumar Agarwal v. State Tax
Officer and Another, (2024) 2 SCC 362, Hon’ble Supreme
Court referring to its earlier decisions, held as under:16. The gist of the aforestated decisions are that:
16.1. A judgment is open to review inter alia
if there is a mistake or an error
apparent on the face of the record.
16.2. A judgment pronounced by the court is
final, and departure from that principle
is justified only when circumstances of a
substantial and compelling character make
it necessary to do so.
16.3. An error which is not self-evident and
has to be detected by a process of
reasoning, can hardly be said to be an
error apparent on the face of record
justifying the court to exercise its
power of review.
16.4. In exercise of the jurisdiction under
Order 47 Rule 1CPC, it is not permissible
for an erroneous decision to be “reheard
and corrected”.
16.5. A review petition has a limited purpose
and cannot be allowed to be “an appeal in
disguise”.
16.6. Under the guise of review, the petitioner
cannot be permitted to reagitate and
reargue the questions which have already
been addressed and decided.
16.7. An error on the face of record must be
such an error which, mere looking at the
record should strike and it should not
require
any
long-drawn
process
of
reasoning on the points where there may
conceivably be two opinions.
16.8. Even the change in law or subsequent
decision/judgment of a coordinate or
larger Bench by itself cannot be regarded
as a ground for review.
12. In the instant case, admittedly, the petitioners were not a party in
writ proceeding, being WP(C) No. 352/2025 and WP(C) No. 247/2025.
And on such count, Mr. Tara, learned counsel for the respondent No.
11 and 12 raised the question of maintainability of this review petition
by a non party. Therefore, this court has to first address the issue first
that:
Can a non-party seek review of Court Order?
12.1.
At this stage it would be appropriate to refer to Section 114 of
the CPC which read as under.
Section 114, Review
(a) by a decree or order from which an appeal is
allowed by this Code, but from which no appeal
has been preferred.
(b) by a decree or order from which no appeal is
allowed by this Code, or
(c) by a decision a reference from a Court of Small
Causes,
May apply for a review of judgment to the Court
which passed the decree or made the order, and
the Court may make such order thereon as it
thinks fit.
12.2.
A plain reading of the section indicates that the key phrase of
the said section is 'any person considering himself aggrieved. So,
under this section, when any person is ‘aggrieved by the order,
whether or not he was party to the proceedings, in which the order
had been passed, he can seek review of the said order.
12.3.
While dealing with this issue Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case
of K. Ajit Babu and Others v. Union of India and Others,
reported in AlR 1997 SC 3277,has held as under:“4. As
stated
earlier,
the
appellant
has
challenged the impugned seniority list prepared
on the basis of the decision rendered by the
Central Administrative Tribunal, Ahmedabad in
Transfer Application No. 263 of 1986 dated 14-81987, by means of an application under Section 19
of the Act wherein there was no prayer for
setting aside the judgment dated 14-8-1987 of the
Administrative Tribunal. It is true that the
judgment given by the Central Administrative
Tribunal, Ahmedabad in TA No. 263 of 1986 would
have come in the way of the appellant. Often in
service matters the judgments rendered either by
the Tribunal or by the Court also affect other
persons, who are not parties to the cases. It may
help one class of employees and at the same time
adversely affect another class of employees. In
such circumstances the judgments of the courts or
the tribunals may not be strictly judgments in
personam affecting only the parties to the cases,
they would be judgments in rem. In such a
situation, the question arises: What remedy is
available to such affected persons who are not
parties to a case, yet the decision in such a
case adversely affects their rights in the matter
of their seniority. In the present case, the view
taken by the Tribunal is that the only remedy
available to the affected persons is to file a
review of the judgment which affects them and not
to file a fresh application under Section 19 of
the Act. Section 22(3)(f) of the Act empowers the
Tribunal to review its decisions. Rule 17 of the
Central Administrative Tribunal (Procedure) Rules
(hereinafter referred to as “the Rules”) provides
that
no
application
for
review
shall
be
entertained unless it is filed within 30 days
from the date of receipt of the copy of the order
sought to be reviewed. Ordinarily, right of
review is available only to those who are party
to a case. However, even if we give wider meaning
to the expression “a person feeling aggrieved”
occurring in Section 22 of the Act whether such
person aggrieved can seek review by opening the
whole case has to be decided by the Tribunal. The
right of review is not a right of appeal where
all questions decided are open to challenge. The
right of review is possible only on limited
grounds, mentioned in Order 47 of the Code of
Civil Procedure. Although strictly speaking Order
47 of the Code of Civil Procedure may not be
applicable to the tribunals but the principles
contained therein surely have to be extended.
Otherwise there being no limitation on the power
of review it would be an appeal and there would
be no certainty of finality of a decision.
Besides that, the right of review is available if
such an application is filed within the period of
limitation. The decision given by the Tribunal,
unless reviewed or appealed against, attains
finality. If such a power to review is permitted,
no decision is final, as the decision would be
subject to review at any time at the instance of
the party feeling adversely affected by the said
decision. A party in whose favour a decision has
been given cannot monitor the case for all times
to come. Public policy demands that there should
be an end to law suits and if the view of the
Tribunal is accepted the proceedings in a case
will never come to an end. We, therefore, find
that a right of review is available to the
aggrieved persons on restricted ground mentioned
in Order 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure if
filed within the period of limitation.”
12.4.
Again in the case of Sri Gopa Bandhu Biswal v Krishna
Chandra Mohanty and Others, reported in (1998) 4 SCC 447,
following the decision in K. Ajit Babu(supra) Hon’ble Supreme
Court has held as under:“10. In the present case, however, it is urged
that the four applicants who filed the two review
petitions before the Tribunal were not parties to
the main petition. They were also not parties to
the special leave petition filed before this
Court which was dismissed. However they are
parties aggrieved and hence are entitled to apply
for a review of the main judgment of the
Tribunal. It is contended by them that the
judgment of the Tribunal holding that the two
cadres of Deputy Superintendent of Police and
Assistant Commandant were a single cadre till 511-1980, has affected the chances of promotion of
the applicants and, therefore, the applicants,
being persons aggrieved, are entitled to maintain
such review petitions when they had not been
parties to the earlier judgment as well as the
earlier special leave petition. We will assume
for the time being that the applicants are
persons aggrieved. Even so, the question is
whether they can have a judgment which has
attained finality by virtue of an order of this
Court, set aside in review. There is no doubt
that as between the parties to the main judgment,
the
judgment
is
final
and
binding.
The
respondents, State of Orissa and Union of India,
are, therefore, bound to give effect to the
judgment of the Tribunal in TA No. 1 of 1989 in
the case of GopabandhuBiswal. If this is so, can
a third party by filing a review petition get
that same judgment reviewed and obtain an order
that GopabandhuBiswal is not entitled to the
benefits of the directions contained in the main
judgment since that judgment is now set aside? In
our view this is wholly impermissible. It will
lead to reopening a matter which has attained
finality by virtue of an order of this Court. The
applicants, even if they are persons aggrieved,
do not have, in the present case, a right of
review under any part of Order 47 Rule 1. Even
under Order 47 Rule 1(2), the party not appealing
from a decree or order can apply for review only
on grounds other than the grounds of appeal which
were before the appellate court, and during the
pendency of the appeal. In the present case all
the grounds which were urged in review were, in
fact, urged before the Tribunal at the time when
the Tribunal decided the main application and
they were also urged by the petitioner in the
special leave petition which was filed before
this Court. The special leave petition has been
dismissed. The same grounds cannot be again urged
by way of a review petition by another party who
was not a party in the main petition.
11. According to the applicants certain documents
though produced before the Tribunal were not
noticed by the Tribunal in deciding the main
matter. Even so, once a judgment of a Tribunal
has attained finality, it cannot be reopened
after the special leave petition against that
judgment has been dismissed. The only remedy for
a person who wants to challenge that judgment is
to file a separate application before the
Tribunal in his own case and persuade the
Tribunal either to refer the question to a larger
Bench or, if the Tribunal prefers to follow its
earlier decision, to file an appeal from the
Tribunal's judgment and have the Tribunal's
judgment set aside in appeal. A review is not an
available remedy.
12. Undoubtedly when the Tribunal interprets
service rules and regulations, the interpretation
so given may affect other members of that service
— past, present or future. One can understand a
wider meaning in this context being given to the
phrase “person aggrieved”, thus enlarging the
right of persons to intervene either at the
hearing before the Tribunal, or in appeal, or for
filing a review petition. Nevertheless, this
right must be exercised at the appropriate time
and in accordance with law. A review petition
must be within the scope of Section 22(3)(f) of
the Administrative Tribunals Act read with Order
47 Rule 1 and must comply with the Rules framed
under the Administrative Tribunals Act. The
present review applications are not within the
principles laid down in Order 47 Rule 1. They
also do not comply with the relevant Rules. Rule
17 of the
Central
Administrative
Tribunal
(Procedure) Rules, 1987 prescribes, inter alia,
that
no
application
for
review
shall
be
entertained unless it is filed within thirty days
from the date of the receipt of a copy of the
order sought to be reviewed. In the present case
the review petitions were filed one and a half
years after the main judgment was delivered and
one year after the special leave petition was
dismissed. We do not find any explanation for
this delay.”
12.5. In
the
case
of
Union
of
India
vs.
Nareshkumar
Badrikumar Jagad & Ors., reported in (2019) 18 SCC 586,
wherein Hon’ble Supreme Court has reiterated that a third party can
file review if it is 'aggrieved by the order sought to be reviewed. The
Court succinctly held thus:-
“18. Reverting to the question of whether the
Union of India has locus to file the review
petition, we must immediately advert to Section
114 of the Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) which,
inter
alia,
postulates
that
“any
person
considering himself aggrieved” would have locus
to file a review petition. Order 47 CPC restates
the position that any person considering himself
aggrieved can file a review petition. Be that as
it may, the Supreme Court exercises review
jurisdiction by virtue of Article 137 of the
Constitution which predicates that the Supreme
Court shall have the power to review any judgment
pronounced or order made by it. Besides, the
Supreme Court has framed Rules to govern review
petitions. Notably, neither Order 47 CPC nor
Order 47 of the Supreme Court Rules limits the
remedy of review only to the parties to the
judgment under review. Therefore, we have no
hesitation in enunciating that even a third party
to the proceedings, if he considers himself an
aggrieved person, may take recourse to the remedy
of review petition. The quintessence is that the
person should be aggrieved by the judgment and
order passed by this Court in some respect.”
Thus, from the aforesaid discussions, the legal proposition,
12.6.
which can be crystallized are as under:(i) ordinarily a right of review is available only to
those who are party to a case,
(ii) in circumstances where the oral judgments may
also affect other persons, who are not parties to
the cases, such judgments being strictly not
judgments in personam, affecting only the parties
to the cases, a right of review should be
available to the aggrieved persons with the leave
of the Tribunal/Court on the restricted grounds
provided the application is filed within the
period of limitation,
(iii) the right of review of the decisions of the
tribunal or court should be available only on
limited grounds mentioned in Order 47, CP.C
12.7.
In view of the aforesaid legal proposition, if the petitioners are
aggrieved by the order under review, they can maintain the petition on
the limited grounds mentioned in Order 47 CPC.
13.
Now, adverting to the facts of the instant case, this Court finds
that admittedly, the petitioners herein had not filed any claim and
objection before the ADC/DC of Lower Dibang Valley district in respect
of the stretch of land measuring 17.62 hectors, which according to the
learned counsel for the respondents herein, is completely different plot
of land from that of 68.687 hector of land. Mr. Garam, learned counsel
for the respondent Nos. 1, 2 and 3 and Mr. Nabam, learned Addl. A.G.
for the respondent Nos. 4 to 10 and Mr. Tara, learned counsel for the
respondent Nos. 10 and 11, referring to Draft Preliminary Notification,
dated 20th June 2025, which relates to 17.62 hectors located at the
right bank of Dibang river, and page No. 204, which is Notification No.
LMD-13011/1/2021/583, dated 20th June, 2025, and the boundary of
the same and location is described herein below :North :- Private & Community Land
South :- Private & Community Land
East :- Private & Community Land
West :- Private & Community Land
Thus, both the parcels of land are two different plots of land
and the learned counsel for the respondents have rightly pointed this
out at the time of hearing. And this Court finds substance in the same.
13.1. It also appears that in respect of the stretch of land measuring
68.40 hectares, the petitioner, namely, Matheim Linggi, had filed
claims and objections and after hearing, the competent authority had
rejected the claim due to absence of primary documents. Though Mr.
Son, learned counsel for the petitioners submitted that in respect of
the stretch of land measuring 17.62 hectares the petitioners had not
filed any written claim and objection, yet verbal claim and objection
was made, yet, his submission leaves this Court unimpressed. Another
contention of Mr. Son is that the claim of the petitioners was illegally
rejected by the ADC/DC, Roing, the said issue cannot be raised in this
review petition and also this Court cannot examined the said issue in
review petition. The petitioners may seek any appropriate legal
remedy available to them to get such issue addressed.
13.2. Notable, the order, being sought to be reviewed was passed on
19.03.2026,in WP(C) No. 352/2025 and WP(C) No. 247/2025, on the
basis of submissions advanced by learned counsel for both the parties.
The same was not decided on merits. No issues raised in the said
petitions were adjudicated and no prayers made in the said petitions
were allowed. It was submitted at the Bar that the dispute between
the parties in both the petitions, has already been settled amicably,
and therefore, they have filed a joint application before the Deputy
Commissioner, Roing, Lower Dibang Valley, in respect of a plot of
land, measuring 66.678 hectares, acquired for the construction of the
Dibang Valley Multipurpose Project, by NHPC.It is further submitted at
the bar that the parties are not willing to pursue these two writ
petitions and as such, the same may be closed by directing the Deputy
Commissioner, Roing, Lower Dibang Valley, to dispose of the joint
application, filed by the petitioners before him, in respect of a plot of
land, measuring 17.62 hectares, out of 66.678 hectares. And
accordingly, taking note of the submissions of the learned counsel for
both the parties and also, in view of amicable settlement of the
dispute by the parties, this Court was pleased to close both the writ
petitions, directing the Deputy Commissioner, Roing, Lower Dibang
Valley district, to dispose of the application, jointly filed by both the
parties, in respect of the plot of land measuring 17.62 hectares, out of
66.678 hectares.
13.3.
Thus, it becomes apparent that both the writ petitions were not
adjudicated on merits, rather, the same were disposed of on the
ground of the same being compromised by the parties with a direction
to dispose of the application jointly filed by the parties. Since the
matter is still pending before the DC, then, the petitioners may still
raise an objection there.
13.4.
Now, the learned counsel for the aforesaid respondents submits
that both the stretches of land are different and separate notifications
were issued by the competent authority. And as such, the Deputy
Commissioner, Roing, Lower Dibang Valley district, may be directed to
deal with the joint applications filed by them in terms of the settlement
arrived at by the parties and as indicated in the said joint application.
14.
Under the given factual as well as legal matrix, this Court is of
the considered opinion that the present review petition is not
maintainable, for the following reasons:(i)
None of the grounds for maintaining a review petition, as
mentioned in the case of Kamlesh Verma (supra) and
also in the case of Sanjay Kumar Agarwal (supra)
could be demonstrated by the review petitioners.
(ii)
There is no discovery of any new and important matter
or evidence which, after the exercise of due diligence,
was not within knowledge of the petitioner or could not
be produced by him;
(iii)
The petitioners have failed to demonstrate any mistake
or error apparent on the face of the record;
(iv)
The petitioners have also failed to assign any other
sufficient reason.
15.
In the result, this Court finds no merit in this petition and
accordingly, the same stands dismissed. Since the grounds for filing
this petition appear to be not bona-fide one, and is also seem to be an
abuse of the process of the court and since the tone and tenor of the
language used in drafting the petition appear to be derogatory, this
Court, while dismissing the same, is also inclined to impose a cost of
Rs. 25,000/ (Rupees Twenty Five Thousand) only for dissuading him in
such misadventure in future. The cost shall be deposited with the
Gauhati High Court Legal Services Committee, Itanagar Permanent
Bench, within a period of four weeks from today, by the review
petitioner No. 1.
16.
Consequent upon dismissal of this review petition, the Deputy
Commissioner, Roing, Lower Dibang Valley district, shall deal with the
joint application filed by the private respondents herein in terms of the
settlement arrived at by them and as indicated in the said joint
application, as observed in para No.13.3, of this order.
Sd/- Robin Phukan
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review