Judgments
LegalFirms.in Judgments · legalfirms.in/judgments/marthi-krishan-vs-sunkari-narayanamma-20260803/ · Printed 22 Nov 2026
Civil

Marthi Krishan vs Sunkari Narayanamma

Add to a compilation

Keep judgments in folders, mark the paragraphs you rely on, and print a compilation with an index. It comes with the Research and Advocate Pro judgment plans and with a campus licence. Sign in · See the plans

Court
Andhra Pradesh High Court
Date
3 August 2026
Case No.
CRP 2738/2025
Result
Dismissed
Bench
Subba Reddy Satti
Cite this judgment
Citation
Link for your website or blog
Cite the court's own record or the law report in court filings.

The court's order

The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.

24. Given the discussion supra, the order under revision brooks no interference while exercising the jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India. The trial court appreciated all the contentions and passed a reasoned order. There are no merits in the revision. The revision is liable to be dismissed.

25. Accordingly, this Civil Revision Petition is Dismissed. No costs. As a sequel, all the pending miscellaneous applications shall stand closed. Whether the order is : Speaking Yes/No / Reasoned Yes/No Reportable Yes/No / Non-Reportable Yes/No

Filed under

Constitution of India Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Article 227, Constitution of India

The law this judgment cites

Opens the section on Law Maker (lawmaker.in), our sister site for law students.

Full Judgment Text

Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs, CC BY 4.0). The court's own copy is the authoritative text.

Date of reserved for orders : 27.07.2026 Date of pronouncement : 04.08.2026 Date of uploading : 0 .08.2026 APHC010553272025 IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH AT AMARAVATI (Special Original Jurisdiction) [3331] TUESDAY, THE 4th DAY OF AUGUST 2026 PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUBBA REDDY SATTI CIVIL REVISION PETITION NO: 2738/2025 Between: 1. MARTHI KRISHAN, S/O LATE RAMULU, AGED 63 YEARS, R/O SUNKARIPETA VILLAGE, MALICHERLA, VIZIANAGARAM MANDAL, VIZIANAGARAM DISTRICT. 2. SMT. SUNKARI APPALAKONDA, W/O LATE SURYANARAYANA, AGED YEARS, R/O SUNKARIPETA VILLAGE, MALICCHERLA, VIZIANAGARAM MANDAL, VIZIANAGARAM DISTRICT. ...PETITIONER(S) AND 1. SUNKARI NARAYANAMMA, W/O LATE PENTAYYA, AGED, 77 YEARS, R/O SUNKARIPETA VILLAGE, H/O MALICHERLA, VIZIANAGARAM MANDAL 85 DISTRICT 2. SUNKARI GOPALARAO, S/O LATE PENTAYYA, AGED 55 YEARS, R/O SUNKARIPETA VILLAGE, H/O. MALICHERLA. VIZIANAGARAM MANDAL DISTRICT. 3. SUNKARI RAMU, S/O LATE PENTAYYA, AGED 45 YEARS, R/O SUNKARIPETA VILLAGE, H/O. MALICHERLA, VIZIANAGARAM MANDAL AND DISTRICT 4. SUNKARI LAKSHMANA, S/O. LATE PENTAYYA, AGED 45 YEARS, R/O SUNKARIPETA VILLAGE, H/O. MALICHERLA, VIZIANAGARAM MANDAL AND DISTRICT. 5. RONGLI ESWARAMMA, W/O. SATYANARAYANA, AGED 62 YEARS, R/O RAYAVALASA VILLAGE, GANTYADA MANDAL, VIZIARIAGARAM DISTRICT 6. BODASINGI ADI LAKSHMI, W/O. APPALANAIDU, AGED 57 YEARS, R/O CHELLURU VILLAGE, VIZIANAGARAM MANDAL AND DISTRICT 7. CHANDAKA BANGARU LAKSHMI, , W/O. PRASAD, AGED 45 YEARS, R/O AYYANNAPETA VILLAGE, VIZIANAGARAM MANDAL AND DISTRICT. ...RESPONDENT(S): Petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India,praying that in the circumstances stated in the grounds filed herein,the High Court may be pleased to set aside the Order dated 25.08.2025 in I.A.No.326/2025 in O.S.No.28/2016 on the file of the Principal District Judge Vizianagaram and pass IA NO: 1 OF 2025 Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to grant stay of all further proceedings in O.S.No.28/2018 on the file of the Principal District Judge, Vizianagaram, pending disposal of the above CRP and to pass Counsel for the Petitioner(S): 1. G SAI NARAYANA RAO Counsel for the Respondent(S): 1. G RAMA GOPAL The Court made the following: ORDER The defendants in the suit filed the above revision against the order dated 25.08.2025 in I.A.No.326 of 2025 in O.S.No.28 of 2018 on the file of the Principal District Judge, Vizianagaram. 2. The respondents, being the plaintiffs, filed the suit O.S.No.28 of 2018 against the defendants for declaration of title and consequential permanent injunction etc. The defendants filed a written statement, contesting the suit. 3. The 1st defendant in suit O.S.No.28 of 2018, filed suit O.S.No.352 of 2012 on the file of the Principal Junior Civil Judge, Vizianagaram, seeking perpetual injunction against the plaintiffs 1 to 4, in respect of the plaint schedule properties. Some of the schedule properties in O.S.NO.28 of 2018 and O.S.No.352 of 2012 are similar. Later, the suit O.S.No.352 of 2012 was transferred to the Court of the Principal District Judge, Vizianagaram and renumbered as O.S.No.91 of 2018. 4. a) In the plaint in O.S.No.28 of 2018, it was pleaded that the 1 st plaintiff is the wife, the plaintiffs 2 to 4 are the sons and the plaintiffs 5 to 7 are the daughters of late Sunkari Pentayya, S/o Guruvulu. The plaint schedule properties originally belonged to Sunkari Guruvulu @ Gurayya. The said Sunkari Guruvulu had a sister by name Sannamma, and she was given in marriage to Marthi Appayya, paternal grandfather of the defendants 1 and 2. properties of Sunkari The plaint schedule properties are ancestral Guruvulu. The said Guruvulu entrusted management of the properties to Marthi Appayya. Sunkari Guruvulu has got only one son by name Pentayya, husband of the 1st plaintiff and father of plaintiffs 2 to 7, besides a daughter by name Appalamma. Marthi Appayya was blessed with a son by name Ramulu. The daughter of Guruvulu was given in marriage to Marthi Ramulu, father of defendants 1 and 2. Sunkari Pentayya and Marthi Ramulu used to live jointly. b) A partition was effected between Sunkari Pentayya and Marthi Ramulu, in which some of the properties fell to the share of Pentayya, some of the properties fell to the share of Ramulu and some properties were divided equally into two halves. In the said partition, Pentayya got the plaint „A‟ schedule properties to his share. He also got plaint „B‟ schedule properties, which are half of the extents in the full extents of the same survey numbers and the remaining extent in the said survey numbers fell to the share of Marthi Ramulu. Besides the plaint „A‟ & „B” schedule properties, Sunkari Pentayya got some other properties towards his share. c) During the survey and settlement, the name of Sunkari Pentayya was incorporated in fair adangal in respect of properties that exclusively fell to his share. In respect of properties, which were divided by Sunkari Pentayya and Marthi Ramulu in the same survey numbers, the names of both Pentayya and Ramulu were incorporated in the revenue records i.e. settlement fair adangal. However, pattadar pass book and title deed were issued in the name of Pentayya and full extents were mentioned to some items that fell to the share of Pentayya. d) Sunkari Pentayya died about 20 years back, and after his death, the plaintiffs, being the descendants, succeeded to the plaint A and B schedule properties along with other properties. Taking advantage of the innocence of the plaintiffs, the 1st defendant got incorporated his name in 1-B Register and also adangals in respect of plaint schedule properties along with his other properties. Thereafter, the 1st defendant filed suit O.S.No.352 of 2012 seeking perpetual injunction against the plaintiffs 1 to 4 by including some of the properties belonging to the plaintiffs, as if he has been in possession and enjoyment based on revenue records. They are also attempting to sell the properties to 3rd parties by showing manipulated revenue records. Hence, the suit was filed seeking declaration of title over the plaint A and B schedule properties and consequential permanent injunction. 5. The defendants filed a written statement and denied the averments in the plaint. It was contended, inter alia, that survey and settlement was conducted about 50 years back. The suit for declaration is to be filed within three years as per Article 58 of the Limitation Act; hence, the suit is barred by limitation. The plaintiffs concocted the revenue records and filed the suit. The plaintiffs were never in possession and enjoyment of the plaint schedule properties. The plaintiffs and their ancestors are in no way concerned with the plaint schedule properties. Sunkari Guruvulu never entrusted the management of properties to Marthi Appayya. Marthi Appayya never resided jointly along with Sunkari Guruvulu under one roof. There was no partition as pleaded. The averments in the plaint regarding the 1st defendant incorporating his name in 1-B Register and adangal were also denied. The defendants have been in peaceful possession and enjoyment of the plaint schedule properties. The plaint schedule properties are the ancestral properties of the defendants. After the death of the defendants‟ father, they succeeded to the plaint schedule properties as Class-I heirs. The revenue authorities updated the record of rights and mutated the name of the 1st defendant in the revenue records. The 1st defendant filed suit O.S.No.352 of 2012 against the plaintiffs 1 to 4 and pleaded title and possession over the schedule properties. 6. In O.S.No.28 of 2018, the following issues are framed: 1) Whether the suit is barred by limitation? 2) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled for the relief of declaration as prayed for? 3) Whether the plaintiffs are entitled for the relief of permanent injunction as prayed for? 4) To what relief? 7. In O.S.No.91 of 2018 (old suit O.S.No.352 of 2012), the following issues are framed: 1) Whether the plaintiff is in exclusive possession and enjoyment over the plaint schedule property by the date of filing of the suit? 2) Whether the frame of the suit is not correct as contended by the defendants? 3) Whether the plaintiff is entitled for relief of permanent injunction as prayed for? 4) To what relief? 8. A joint trial was conducted by the trial Court, and the evidence is recorded in O.S.No.28 of 2018. The 1st plaintiff examined himself as P.W.1 and got marked Exs.A1 to A18. She also examined P.Ws.2 and 3. The suit was posted for further evidence. At that stage, the plaintiff filed I.A.No.326 of 2025 under Order XVII Rule 3 of CPC to permit them to adduce rebuttal evidence, after adducing oral and documentary evidence by the defendants. 9. In the affidavit filed in support of the petition, while reiterating the averments in the plaint, it was contended that the plaintiffs adduced evidence in O.S.No.28 of 2018 and they cannot adduce negative evidence regarding the oral and documentary evidence to be adduced by the 1st defendant, being the plaintiff in O.S.No.91 of 2018. Thus, this application was filed to permit the plaintiffs to adduce rebuttal evidence, after the evidence of the defendants. 10. The defendants filed counter and opposed the application. It was contended that since both the suits were clubbed and the evidence is being recorded in O.S.No.28 of 2018, the plaintiffs cannot be permitted to adduce rebuttal evidence. 11. The trial Court by order dated 25.08.2025, allowed the application. 12. Heard Sri G.Sai Narayana Rao, learned counsel for the petitioners and Sri G.Ramagopal, learned counsel for the respondents. 13. Learned counsel for the petitioners would submit that no specific issue was framed casting burden on the defendants and thereby the plaintiffs cannot be allowed to adduce rebuttal evidence. The suit O.S.No.28 of 2018 was filed for declaration and injunction, and in the said suit, defendants filed a written statement, and hence, the plaintiffs are aware of the defence of defendants. When the relief of permanent injunction is common in both the suits, permitting the plaintiffs to lead rebuttal evidence will prejudice the case of the revision petitioners. 14. On the other hand, learned counsel for the respondents would submit that the 1st defendant, being the plaintiff in O.S.No.91 of 2018 (old suit O.S.No.352 of 2012), seeks perpetual injunction. In the said suit, he claimed exclusive title over the property. The plaintiffs in O.S.No.28 of 2018 cannot adduce negative evidence in anticipation of evidence to be led by the plaintiff in O.S.No.91 of 2018 (old suit O.S.No.352 of 2012). Considering the said fact, the trial Court allowed the application. 15. Now, the points for consideration are: 1) Whether in the facts and circumstances of the case, the plaintiffs are entitled to lead rebuttal evidence? 2) Whether the order dated 25.08.2025 in I.A.No.326 of 2025 in O.S.No.28 of 2018 on the file of the Principal District Judge, Vizianagaram, suffers from illegality, and brooks interference of this Court? 16. The facts narrated supra do not require reiteration. Normally in a suit for declaration of title and permanent injunction, the plaintiff has to succeed on the strength of his own case and cannot depend upon the weakness in the case of the defendant. In this case on hand, the plaintiffs filed the suit for declaration and perpetual injunction. The 1st defendant filed suit for injunction and asserted title to the properties. Thus, as seen from the pleadings, both the parties to the suit asserted title and possession. The suit for injunction was transferred from the Court of Principal Junior Civil Judge, Vizianagaram to the Court of Principal District Judge, Vizianagaram, where the suit for declaration and injunction is pending. The evidence is being recorded in O.S.No.28 of 2018. Even in a suit for perpetual injunction, based on title, the Civil Court also considers the title incidentally. 17. The concept of rebuttal evidence is traceable to Order XVIII Rule 3 CPC. Order XVIII CPC envisages hearing of the suit and examination of witnesses. It is apt to extract Rule 3 of Order XVIII for better understanding, which reads thus: 3. Evidence where several issues.—Where there are several issues, the burden of proving some of which lies on the other party, the party beginning may, at his option, either produce his evidence on those issues or reserve it by way of answer to the evidence produced by the other party; and, in the latter case, the party beginning may produce evidence on those issues after the other party has produced all his evidence, and the other party may then reply specially on the evidence so produced by the party beginning; but the party beginning will then be entitled to reply generally on the whole case. 18. Thus, a bare reading of the Rule, the issues in a suit play, a prominent role regarding rebuttal evidence. One of the requirements to be satisfied for reserving the right to lead rebuttal evidence is that there shall be an issue in respect of which the burden of the proof lies on the other party. The reservation of the right of adducing rebuttal evidence need not be expressed, and it can be exercised by way of filing a memo on behalf of the party who has begun the evidence on his side. Of course, if the reservation is express, the matter would present no difficulty. But such a reservation could also be implied in a case where the counsel for such a party makes a statement that he is closing the evidence of his party in the affirmative only. In such a case, it must be held that the party had implicitly reserved the right to adduce rebuttal evidence. 19. When the trial goes on, there are various stages of evidence. Normally the plaintiff begins the case, and thereafter evidence will be closed. Later, the defendant starts the evidence; the defendant‟s evidence will be closed. If the burden on a particular issue is on the opposite party, the plaintiff should make an application to lead rebuttal evidence. 20. In this case, as noted supra, two suits were filed; one for declaration and injunction and the other for perpetual injunction. Plaintiffs in both the suits are asserting title to the property. Though the other suit is filed for perpetual injunction, it was also based on title. The burden visà-vis possession and title rests upon the plaintiff in the transferee suit i.e. O.S.No.91 of 2018, though a common trial was conducted. The plaintiff in the present suit necessarily provides an opportunity to rebut the evidence to be led by the defendant, who is the plaintiff in the other suit. Precisely the first issue in O.S.No.91 of 2018, i.e. “Whether the plaintiff is in exclusive possession and enjoyment over the plaint schedule property by the date of filing of the suit”, the burden lies on the plaintiff in O.S.No.91 of 2018. In respect of the said issue, the plaintiff in O.S.No.28 of 2018 must be provided an opportunity to lead the rebuttal evidence. 21. In Nalajala Narasayya VS Nalajala Sitayya 1, a Division Bench of the composite High Court on a reference after considering an earlier judgement of the High Court of Andhra Pradesh and the Punjab & Haryana High Court held as follows: “11. From the aforesaid decisions, we are of the view that the reservation of the right of adducing rebuttal evidence need not be express and need not always be by way of a memo filed on behalf of the party who has begun the evidence on his side. Of course, if the AIR 1992 AP 97 reservation is express, the matter would present no difficulty. But such a reservation could also be implied in a case where the counsel for such a party makes a statement that he is closing the evidence of his party in the affirmative only. In such a case, it must be held that the party had implicitly reserved the right to adduce rebuttal evidence. Kodandaramayya, J. implied such a reservation on the facts of the case before him particularly because the plaintiff in that case had not adduced any evidence whatsoever on some issues on which the burden lay on the opposite party. We are of the opinion that the view taken by Kodandaramayya, J. that reservation need not be express but could be implied and which view is supported by the judgment of the Division Bench of the Punjab and Haryana High Court, is correct and does not run counter to the provisions of O. XVIII, R. 3, CPC. In our view, the reservation could be implied from the facts and circumstances of the case or the conduct of the case. We do not, therefore, agree with the view of Panduranga Rao, J, that reservation should always be express or by way of a memo filed on behalf of the party who begins the evidence on his side.” 22. The contention of the learned counsel for the petitioner that the plaintiffs already let in evidence regarding the possession and hence the question of rebuttal evidence doesn‟t arise, this Court is not persuaded by the said contention, since the burden of proof lies on the plaintiff in suit O.S.No.91 of 2018 regarding the possession. Then only the plaintiff in O.S.No.28 of 2018 will be able to rebut that evidence. Though the issue of possession appears to be the same in the first breadth, however, it is not alike. Both the plaintiffs have to lead separate evidence in respect of their claims. In that view of the matter, the I.A. filed by the respondents herein seeking to adduce rebuttal evidence was answered by the learned trial court from a correct perspective. The judgment cited by the learned counsel for the petitioner rendered by the Bombay High Court in Womens Co-operative Bank Ltds. Thr. Chairperson/General Manager and another Vs. Vikas Bhagwant Sawkar and others 2, may not apply to the facts of this case. 23. The scope of a revision under Art 227 of the Constitution of India was dealt with in Nandi Infrastructure Corridor Enterprises Ltd. and Another Vs. B.Gurappa Naidu and Others3, wherein the Hon‟ble Apex Court considered the judgments in Shalini Shyam Shetty Vs. Rajendra Shankar Patil 4 ; Estralla Rubber Vs. Dass Estate (P) Ltd. 5 , and Garment Craft Vs. Prakash Chand Goel 6 and summarised the principles as follows: “35. In short, the principles laid down in the above matters, is as follows: a) The power of superintendence under Article 227 is not to be exercised unless there has been an (a) unwarranted assumption of jurisdiction, not vested in Court or tribunal, or (b) gross abuse of jurisdiction or (c) an unjustifiable refusal to exercise jurisdiction vested in Courts or tribunals. b) It is also well settled that the High Court while acting under this Article cannot exercise its power as an appellate court or substitute its own judgment in place of that of the subordinate court to correct an error, which is not apparent on the face of the record. c) The High Court exercising supervisory jurisdiction does not act as a court of first appeal to reappreciate, reweigh the evidence or facts upon which the determination under challenge is based. 2025 SCC OnLine Bom 2809 2026 SCC OnLine SC 745 (2010) 8 SCC 329 (2001) 8 SCC 97 (2022) 4 SCC 181 Supervisory jurisdiction is not to correct every error of fact or even a legal flaw when the final finding is justified or can be supported. The High Court is not to substitute its own decision on facts and conclusion, for that of the inferior court or tribunal.” 24. Given the discussion supra, the order under revision brooks no interference while exercising the jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India. The trial court appreciated all the contentions and passed a reasoned order. There are no merits in the revision. The revision is liable to be dismissed. 25. Accordingly, this Civil Revision Petition is Dismissed. No costs. As a sequel, all the pending miscellaneous applications shall stand closed. ___________________________ JUSTICE SUBBA REDDY SATTI PVD Whether the order is : Speaking Yes/No / Reasoned Yes/No Reportable Yes/No / Non-Reportable Yes/No

This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.

Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong? Request a review

All AP HC judgments →