Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
2024:MLHC:905
Serial No.01
Regular List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
Reserved on : 17.09.2024
WP(C) No.239 of 2020
Date of Decision: 04.10.2024
_________________________________________________________
1. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
2.
Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
3.
Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
4.
Smt Marcellia A Sangma.
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya.
5.
Smt Miscilla Ch Marak.
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya.
6.
Shri. Ragatdo Sapsengra Ch Marak.
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya.
7.
Shri. Topward M Marak.
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya.
8.
Smt. Pinchi Balsera Ch Marak.
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya.
9.
Shri. Brara Bawendi Ch Marak.
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya.
10. Smti. Bristy Banme B Marak.
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya.
2024:MLHC:905
11. Shri. Sunil Louis K Sangma.
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya.
12. Smti. Ayshalina M. Sangma.
D/o(L) Crysilda M. Sangma
Aged about 32 years.
Resident of Chitoktak, Tura,
West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya.
(Substituted vide Court’s order dated 04-8-2022)
13. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
14. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
15. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
16. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
17. Struck off vide order 16.04.2021.
18. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
19. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
20. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
21. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
22. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
23. Chitoktak Community Hall
C/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya.
24. Shri. Mathew M. Sangma.
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya.
2024:MLHC:905
25. Smt Philmitha A. Sangma
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
26. Smt Betsie Rose Ch. Marak
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
27. Dr. Zeetha M. Sangma
R/o Dura/Chasingre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District,
Meghalaya
29. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
30. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
31. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
32. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
33. Smt Veronica M. Sangma
R/o Dura/Chasingre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District,
Meghalaya
34. Smt Zothampari D Shira
R/o Ganolgre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
35. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
36. Smt Marthina G Momin
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
37. Shri Trevor T Sangma
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
38. Shri Perolish M Sangma
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
39. Smt Premollina Ch Marak
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
2024:MLHC:905
40. Smt Chingchi Ch. Marak
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
41. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
42. Smt Minonish Ch.Marak
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
43. Shri Fixture A. Sangma
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
44. Shri Clasom T. Sangma
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
45. Smti Lesilda Ch Marak.
M/o (Smt Sandilla Ch. Marak)
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
46. Smt Rosallin A. Sangma
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
47. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
48. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
49. Shri Havard Sangma.
R/o Chibragre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
50. Smt Kenchida N Sangma.
R/o Chibragre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
51. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
52. Struck off vide order 14.03.2024.
53. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
2024:MLHC:905
54. Struck off vide order 14.03.2024.
55. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
56. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
57. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
58. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
59. Smt Esabella N Marak
R/o Ganolgre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
60. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
61. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
62. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
63. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
64. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
65. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
66. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
67. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
68. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
69. Smt Silne T Sangma
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
70. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
71. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
2024:MLHC:905
72. Smt Lydia Ch Marak
R/o Sangsanggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
73. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
74. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
75. Smt Shipra Ch Sangma
R/o Sangsanggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
76. Dr. Angelice A. Sangma
R/o Dura/Chasingre Akhingland,West Garo Hills District,
Meghalaya
77. Shri Rakseng A. Sangma
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
78. Smt Enonish A. Sangma
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
79. Shri Joshua N. Arengh
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
80. Smt Soja Dazziel Marak
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
81. Smt Rinarin Ch.Marak
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
82. Smt Senolla B. Marak
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
83. Shri Jondibar A. Sangma
R/o Dura/Chasingre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District,
Meghalaya
84. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
2024:MLHC:905
85. Smt Podini A. Sangma
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
86. Shri Ramrilberth M. Sangma
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
87. Shri Sudhir Sangma
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
88. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
89. Smt Persitha M Sangma
R/o Megonggre Akhingland, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya
90. Struck off vide order 02.09.2024.
...WRIT PETITIONERS
VERSUS
1.
State of Meghalaya represented by the Chief Secretary
Government of Meghalaya Shillong.
2.
Commissioner and Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya
Revenue and Disaster Management Department, Meghalaya,
Shillong.
3.
Joint Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya Revenue and
Disaster Management Department, Meghalaya Shillong.
4.
Commissioner and Secretary Government of Meghalaya, Public
Work Department (PWD) Meghalaya, Shillong.
5.
Executive Engineer P.W.D (Road) NH-cum Tura Central
Division, Tura, West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya.
2024:MLHC:905
6.
Commissioner and Secretary to the Government Meghalaya,
Forest and Environment Department Meghalaya, Shillong.
7.
Principal Chief Conservators of Forest and Environment
Department, Government of Meghalaya, Meghalaya, Shillong.
8.
Divisional Forest Officer, Forest and Environment Department,
Government of Meghalaya, West and South -West Garo Hills
District (Territorial) (Division) Tura, Meghalaya.
9.
Commissioner and Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya,
Agriculture Department , Meghalaya Shillong.
10.
Commissioner and Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya,
Horticulture Department , Meghalaya Shillong.
11.
Commissioner and Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya,
Fishery Department , Meghalaya, Shillong.
12.
Collector, West Garo Hills District Tura, Meghalaya.
13.
Extra- Assistant Commissioner (Revenue), West Garo Hills
District Tura, Meghalaya.
14.
Garo Hills Autonomous District Council represented by its
Secretary (Revenue) Tura.
15.
Union of India represented by its Secretary, Ministry of Road
Transport and Highways, New Delhi.
16.
National Highways and Infrastructure Development Corporation
(NHIDCL) represented by General Manager, 3rd Floor, House no
206 Law College Road Dhankheti near Springfield School,
Meghalaya, Shillong.
17.
Meghalaya Institute of Governance (MIG), Lumpyngad Cottage,
Bishop Cotton Road, Shillong-1.
....RESPONDENTS.
2024:MLHC:905
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice B. Bhattacharjee, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) : Mr. H. L. Shangreiso, Sr. Adv with
Ms. M. Hajong, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
: Mr. S. Sen. GA. (R: 1 – 13)
Ms. N. Rajee, Adv. (R: 14)
Dr. N. Mozika, DSGI with
Ms. K. Gurung, Adv. (R: 15 & 16)
Mr. K. Ch. Gautam, Adv. (R: 17)
(JUDGMENT & ORDER)
By this writ petition, the petitioners have challenged the
Notification No. RDA 103/2015/365 dated 27-06-2019, the various
reports of hearing, and the Declaration vide No. RDA 103/2015/744
dated 08-06-2020 made under Section 11 (1), Section 15 and Section
19 (1) of The Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land
Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 (hereinafter
referred to as the RFCTLARR Act, 2013) in connection with the
acquisition of land measuring about 82B-3K-11L/110672.52 Sqm in
Chibragre, Ganolgre, Duragre, Chasingre, Meggonggre, Sangsanggre,
Darengre,
Dopgre,
Chekwatgre,
Daluagre,
Jenggitchakgre,
Ronggatagre,
Romba
Bolchugre,
Darak A-kong,
A-Dinggre,
Rongbibanggre,
Rongbretgre,
Wakkolnanggre,
Gimbil
Chisakgre,
Danabollonggre, Bolmapara, Amongpara, Kherapara Nokat, Kherapara
2024:MLHC:905
Songma,
Songmagre,
Mandagre,
Rengsipara,
Rangdapara,
Doldenggagre, Karonggre, Tibapara, and Magupara villages, West Garo
Hills District, for widening of National Highway-51 from Goeragre to
Chitoktak and Dobasipara to Dalu.
The petitioners have also
challenged the impugned minutes of meeting dated 03-10-2018 adopted
by the respondent No.12 and impugned letters dated 04-02-2020 and
06-02-2020 issued by the respondent No.14 by which the respondent
authorities excluded the portion of land known as ‘Right of Way’ (in
short ROW) while taking measurement of land for assessment of
amount of land compensation. Prayer has also been made for directing
the Collector to conduct a fresh survey by including ROW and
thereafter to acquire the land as per the fresh survey and to pay suitable
compensation to the petitioners in accordance with the RFCTLARR
Act, 2013.
1.
The fact of the case as can be revealed from the writ petition is
that the State-respondent vide letter No.RDA. 103/2015/172 dated 2802-2017 had assigned the upon the respondent No.16 the task of
conducting a Social Impact Assessment (SIA) study on the proposed
acquisition of land for the purpose of widening NH-51 from Goeragre
to Chitoktak and Dobasipara to Dalu in West Garo Hills District,
Meghalaya under the provisions of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013.
Accordingly, the respondent No.16 had prepared and submitted the SIA
report and Social Impact Management Plan in the month of December,
2018. A recommendation for acquisition of land under Section 8 (2) of
the RFCTLARR Act, 2013 was made on 17-06-2019 by the respondent
No.3 for construction of two lane (with paved shoulder) of the section
2024:MLHC:905
Tura to Dalu (Km 85 to Km 95 & Km 101 to Km 145) after due
consideration of all the reports. Subsequently, a preliminary notification
was issued by the respondent No.3 under Section 11 (1) of the
RFCTLARR Act, 2013 vide notification No.RDA. 103/2015/365 dated
27-06-2019. An objection against the land acquisition process was filed
by some project affected people of Megonggre Aking Sector on 05-092019. Thereafter, a notice under Section 15 of the RFCTLARR Act,
2013 was issued vide Memo No. TVG.18/2015/537 dated 03-10-2019
by the Additional Deputy Commissioner (Revenue), West Garo Hills,
Tura to all the concerned Nokmas and land owners inviting claims and
objections pertaining to the said acquisition of land. After that, various
reports of hearing were prepared by the respondent No.13.
After
submission of the reports, the Declaration under Section 19 (1) of the
RFCTLARR Act, 2013 was made by the respondent No.3 vide Memo
No. RDA.103/2015/744 dated 08-06-2014 declaring that the plot of
land measuring more or less 82B-3K-11L/110672.52 Sqm is required to
be taken by the Government for public purpose, namely, for widening
NH-51. Being aggrieved by the non-consideration of their objection,
the present writ petition has been filed by the petitioners challenging
the acquisition proceeding.
2.
The present writ petition was originally instituted by 90
(ninety) writ petitioners.
However, during pendency of the writ
petition, the names of the 44 (forty-four) writ petitioners were struck
off from the array of parties by orders dated 16-04-2021, 14-03-2024
and 02-09-2024 passed in connected Misc. Applications on the ground
that the said writ petitioners have already received the amount of land
2024:MLHC:905
compensation granted to them. The writ petition, thus, proceeded with
remaining 46 (forty-six) writ petitioners for final hearing.
3.
Mr. H. L. Shangreiso, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the
petitioners submits that the decision of the respondent authority to
proceed with the land acquisition proceeding is arbitrary and illegal,
inasmuch as, the acquisition proceeding could not have proceeded
without conducting any hearing and taking a decision on the objection
of the writ petitioners as per the mandate of Section 15 of the
RFCTLARR Act, 2013. The learned Senior Counsel argues that as per
the provisions of Section 15 (2) of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013, it is
mandatory for the collector to give an opportunity to the objector of
being heard and thereafter to make a report to the appropriate
Government containing his recommendation on the objection.
He
contends that it is not for the Collector either to accept or reject the
objection and the only duty cast on him is to make recommendation in
accordance with law. The learned Senior Counsel further submits that
as per Section 15 (3) of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013, the appropriate
Government shall take a decision on the objection, however,
declaration under Section 19 (1) of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013 in the
present matter was made without conducting any hearing and without
taking any decision on the objection dated 15-09-2019 filed by the
petitioners. He submits that the declaration under Section 19 (1) could
not have been issued without following the provision of Section 15 and
hence, the declaration dated 08-06-2020 made by the respondent No.3
is null and void. That apart, he submits that though the name of the
petitioners were included in the notification dated 27-06-2019 issued
2024:MLHC:905
under Section 11 (1) of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013, no notice was
served under Section 12 to the petitioners, which vitiates the land
acquisition proceeding. The learned Senior Counsel further submits
that the Collector has no authority to take a decision as to whether the
portion of land known as ROW be included or excluded while
computing the amount of land compensation and the decision to that
effect taken by him by adopting the impugned minutes of meeting dated
03-10-2018 and on consideration of the impugned letters dated 04-022020 and 06-02-2020 is highly erroneous and cannot be sustained in
law. He also submits that the order dated 07-08-2020 passed in MC
No. 125 of 2020 and the order dated 16-12-2021 passed in MC No. 88
of 2021 by which the prayer of the petitioners for stay of the land
acquisition proceeding was rejected and the project was allowed to
continue, would no way negate the grounds taken by the petitioners in
this writ petition as the orders passed at the interim stage would not
sanctify foundational illegality committed by the Collector in the
acquisition process. The learned Senior Counsel contends that the
decision of the respondents authorities to proceed with the acquisition
proceeding by ignoring the objection raised by the petitioners cannot be
termed as valid in law, and hence, the declaration made under Section
19(1) is liable to be set aside and quashed in persona and the matter
may be sent back to the Collector for proceeding from the stage of
Section 15 of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013, afresh with liberty to the
petitioners to appear before the Collector for an opportunity of being
heard. In support of his argument the learned Senior Counsel has
placed reliance on the following decisions of the Apex Court: -
2024:MLHC:905
i)
(2023) 6 SCC 512, Haryana State Industrial and Infrastructure
Development Corporation Limited and others versus Deepak
Aggarwal and Others.
ii)
(2017) 11 SCC 601, Kedar Nath Yadav Versus State of West
Bengal and Others.
iii)
(2012) 2 SCC 25, Kamal Trading Private Limited Versus State of
West Bengal and Others.
iv)
(2013) 4 SCC 210, Usha Stud and Agricultural Firms Private
Limited and Others Versus State of Haryana and Others.
v)
(2016) 14 SCC 746, State of Haryana and Another Versus
Devander Sagar and Others.
vi)
(2005) 7 SCC 627, Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited
Versus Darius Shapur Chenai and Others.
vii)
(2011) 5 SCC 142, Chairman-cum-Managing Director, Coal
India Limited and Others Versus Ananta Saha and Ors.
viii) (2010) 9 SCC 437, Kalabharati Advertising Versus Hemant
Vimalnath Narichania and Others.
ix)
(2004) 2 SCC 783, Karnataka Rare Earth and Another Versus
Senior Geologist, Department of Mines and Geology and
Another.
x)
(2011) 5 SCC 553, Radhy Shyam (dead) through LRS and Others
Versus State of U.P and Others.
xi)
(1970) 3 SCC 768, Chinta Lingam and Others Versus
Government of India and Others.
xii)
(2011) 12 SCC 695, National Textile Corporation Limited Versus
Nareshkumar Badrikumar Jagad and Others.
xiii)
Civil Appeal No. 6466 of 2024, Kolkata Municipal Corporation
& Anr. Versus Bimal Kumar Shah & Ors.
2024:MLHC:905
4.
On the other hand, Mr. S. Sen, learned GA appearing for the
State-respondents No.1 - 13 refutes the submission made on behalf of
the petitioners and submits that at no point of time the petitioners have
ever raised any objection to the acquisition proceeding in terms of
Section 15 of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013. The learned GA, by referring
to the objection dated 15-09-2019, submits that the petitioners’
objection is confined to the measurement of land and the amount of
compensation assessed by the State-respondents and not in relation to
the area and suitability of land proposed to be acquired, justification
offered for public purpose and the finding of the Social Impact
Assessment Report and, hence, does not come under the purview of
objection as defined by Section 15 (1) of the Act. He submits that all
the concerned Nokmas and land owners were informed by notice dated
03-10-2019 with regard to hearing under Section 15 in connection with
the claims and objections pertaining to the acquisition of land and
various dates were fixed for hearing from 16-10-2019 to 28-10-2019 as
per the schedule in the said notice. He further submits that consequent
to the appearance of concerned Nokmas and land owners, several
reports were prepared and forwarded to the appropriate Government
and thereafter the declaration dated 08-06-2020 under Section 19 (1) of
the RFCTLARR Act, 2013 was made by the respondent No.3. The
entire acquisition proceeding was conducted strictly in accordance with
the provision of law. The learned GA also contends that in view of
stipulation made in the related land patta and rule 23 of the rules under
the Assam Land and Revenue Regulation, 1886 as adopted by Garo
Hills Autonomous District Council, the arrears identified as ROW
2024:MLHC:905
cannot be included in the measurement of land for assessment of
amount of land compensation. He submits that since the petitioners’
objection is limited to the question of adequacy of compensation and
measurement of land, the same cannot be agitated in the present writ
petition as they can raise their grievances by availing the remedy
available under the related provision of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013. He
further submits that all the writ petitioners are not similarly situated as
only 18 out of the remaining 46 writ petitioners have signed the
objection dated 15-09-2019 and, the writ petition as such cannot be
entertained for not having common cause of action.
5.
Dr. N. Mozika, learned DSGI appearing for the respondents
No.15 and 16 endorses the submission made on behalf of the Staterespondents and further submits that the names of all the writ
petitioners are included in the list of beneficiaries who were awarded
compensation on account of the land acquisition, while some of them
have received the amount of compensation, the present petitioners did
not agree with the amount of compensation and being dissatisfied, have
refused to co-operate with the work of the ongoing project which in
turn has affected the public interest involved in the matter. He submits
that if, at all, the writ petitioners are not ready to accept that award for
the reason of inadequacy of rate of compensation and dispute with
regard to the measurement of land, they cannot seek redressal of their
grievance by filing the present writ petition as the Writ Court is not the
proper Court for settling such disputes.
2024:MLHC:905
6.
Ms. N. Rajee, learned Counsel appearing for the respondent
No.14 and Mr. K. Ch. Gautam, learned Counsel appearing for the
respondent No.17 adopted the submissions made on behalf of the
respondents No. 1 – 13 and the respondents No.15 & 16.
7.
In reply, the learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner submits
that the respondent-Collector in his counter-affidavit did not deny that
the objection dated 05-09-2019 was not an objection under Section
15(1) of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013 and, as such, the submissions
advanced by the learned GA and the learned DSGI have no foundation
in the pleading made by the Collector. Thus, submissions being
contrary to the pleadings are not worthy of acceptance by this Court.
8.
The submissions made by the learned Counsels for the parties are
taken note of and given a thoughtful consideration.
9.
As the entire writ petition is centered around the objection dated
15-09-2019 claimed to have been filed by the petitioners against the
acquisition proceedings, it is imperative to take into consideration the
contents of the said objection. Perusal of the said objection reveals that
the objection was filed by 66 project affected people of Megonggre
A'king Sector. There is no averment in the writ petition as to how
many of the petitioners are signatories to the said objection.
Furthermore, the nature of objection raised therein is only with regard
to the measurement of land and the amount of compensation. There is
no mention of any opposition to the area and suitability of the land
proposed to be acquired, justification offered for public purpose or to
2024:MLHC:905
the finding of the SIA report.
In fact, the concluding part of the
objection dated 15-09-2019 reads as follows: “7. In the light of the above stated facts and circumstances we
the domiciles fervently request you honour to kindly look into or
genuine grievances and arrange to pay a fair and reasonable
compensation without any discrimination to each and every one
of us and in the most transparent way, for which act of kindness
we shall ever be thankful and remember you. Similarly, we also
pray and request that we may not be dragged to the court for
seeking a legal justice.”
Thus, from the above, it is apparent that the objection raised therein has
no nexus with the provisions of law contained in Section 15 (1) of the
RFCTLARR Act, 2013 and no request was made therin to cancel or
abandon the land acquisition proceeding.
10.
The case record reveals that MC No. 125 of 2020 was filed along
with this writ petition with a prayer for staying the land acquisition
proceeding and the ongoing project during the pendency of the writ
petition. This Court vide order dated 07-08-2020 rejected the prayer
and directed the respondents or the agency engaged in the project to
maintain records as to the specific areas from where the number and
size of tree have been felled and removed and also keep records of the
location of the pucca structures which have been demolished in the
course of the widening of the highway. The order of rejection of stay
has not been challenged by the writ petitioners before any forum.
11.
The case record further reveals that during the pendency of the
writ petition, another Misc. Application being MC No.88 of 2021 was
preferred by the National Highway and Infrastructure Development
2024:MLHC:905
(NHIDC) Ltd. for ensuring availability of the working front in the
defined area of the project so as to enable the Corporation to complete
the road project which is in the interest of public on time. This Court
by order dated 16-12-2021, taking note of the earlier order dated 07-082020, directed the writ petitioners to abide by the order of this Court
and not cause disturbances and allow the project to continue as the
same is in public interest. It was further observed therein that since the
process of compensation was not complete, the petitioners be given a
chance to be heard and present their case as and when they are called
upon by the District Collector. The petitioners also did not challenge
the said order dated 16-12-2021.
12.
The aforesaid orders dated 07-08-2020 and16-12-2021 make it
amply clear that this Court explicitly declined to stay the land
acquisition proceeding and the ongoing public project. Since, there was
no further challenge to the aforesaid orders, the question which now
remains for adjudication is only with regard to the claims of the writ
petitioners concerning the adequacy of compensation and measurement
of land. Even the prayer made in the writ petition by the petitioners
would show that the grievance of the petitioners is specifically in
relation to the quantum of compensation and measurement of land. The
relevant parts of the prayer made in the writ petition are as follows: “(i) directing the respondents especially respondent Collector to
Conduct fresh survey and take measurement of the land
including 8.295 more or less meters width in stretches situated
from the edge/end of the exiting 4.75 width meters of NH-51,
West Garo Hills District, Meghalaya including trees, crops
attached thereon in the presence of the writ petitioners as well as
2024:MLHC:905
providing adequate opportunity of being heard under the
provisions of “The Right to Fair Compensation And
Transparency In Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and
Resettlement Act, 2013”,
ii) directing the respondent state to appoint the Administrator as
require under section 43 of the “The Right to Fair Compensation
and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and
Resettlement Act, 2013” to conduct survey and prepare the
Rehabilitation and Resettlement scheme for the writ petitioners
whoever duly entitled,
iii) directing the respondents thereafter, to acquire their land as
per the result of the fresh survey and total measurement of land
as prayed in (i) above and pay the suitable compensation to the
writ petitioners for acquiring their land including the trees,
crops etc attached there to in accordance with the provisions of
“The Right to Fair Compensation And Transparency In Land
Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013” and
pass such other order/orders as Your Lordships may deem fit and
proper in the facts and circumstances of the case.
And for this act of kindness, the petitioner as in duty bound shall
ever pray.
13.
The declaration dated 08-06-2020 made by the respondent No.3
under Section 19 (1) of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013 specifically
mentioned that the number of families likely to be resettled due to land
acquisition is ‘Nil’. The learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners has
not made any argument on the question of displacement of person due
to acquisition of land and no issue was raised with regard to
rehabilitation and resettlement of any person and appointment of
Administrator in terms of Section 43 of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013.
Hence, it is construed that the petitioners have no grievance with regard
to the rehabilitation and resettlement in the matter.
2024:MLHC:905
14.
Any objection to the measurement of land for the reason of non-
inclusion of part of land identified as ROW by terming it as a part and
parcel of private land, is essentially an objection falling under the
purview of Section 64 of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013. If petitioners
have any claim of ownership or interest over ROW, they are free to
raise it before the appropriate authority in accordance with law.
The
claim of right and interest over a plot of land, inclusion or exclusion of
any part thereof for proper measurement of land, and payment of
adequate compensation thereof in a land acquisition proceeding cannot
be considered in writ jurisdiction as any person aggrieved by
measurement of land and inadequacy of compensation has the remedy
to seek reference by filing written application as provided in Section 64
of the RFCTLARR Act, 2013.
15.
Since, it is clear that the objection dated 15-09-2019 is not an
objection seeking cancellation or abandonment of the land acquisition
proceeding on the grounds mentioned in Section 15 (1) of the
RFCTLARR Act, 2013, detailed discussions on the case laws relied on
by the learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner is found not necessary
as all those decisions relate to the issues concerning Section 15 of the
RFCTLARR Act, 2013. In fact, except for raising the grievance of
non-inclusion of ROW in the measurement of land, the petitioners have
not raised any other ground for objection against the land acquisition
proceeding.
16.
The contention of the petitioners that the collector has no
authority to exclude ROW from the measurement of land on the basis
2024:MLHC:905
of impugned resolution dated 03-10-2018, impugned letters dated 0402-2020 and 06-02-2020 also do not merit much attention at this stage
as such decisions of the Collector has no bearing in the exercise of
statutory right of the petitioners in terms of Section 64 of the
RFCTLARR Act, 2013. In case, the petitioners do not accept the award
for the reason of non-inclusion of ROW in the measurement of their
lands, they can take recourse of Section 64, and in such a situation, the
Collector’s decision in that regard cannot be treated as final and would
be subject to the decision made in accordance with law.
17.
For the reasons and discussions made above, the petitioners have
failed to make out a case for any interference with the land acquisition
proceedings in this matter.
However, it would be open for the
petitioners to raise their grievances with regard to the measurement of
land and inadequacy of compensation in terms of provisions of law
contained in the RFCTLARR Act, 2013 by filing a written application
requiring reference of the matter under Section 64 of the said Act. In
the event, the petitioners prefer to file any written application raising
such grievance, the respondent No.12 shall deal with in accordance
with law in the light of the observation made hereinabove.
18.
The writ petition stands disposed of in the aforesaid terms.
19.
The interim orders passed in MC[WP(C)] No. 136 of 2024 and
MC[WP(C)] No. 139 of 2024 stand vacated.
2024:MLHC:905
20.
There will be no order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
04.10.2024
“Biswarup PS”
BHATTACHARJEE
Date: 2024.10.04 16:38:11 IST
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review