Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Serial No. 01
Supplementary List
HIGH COURT OF MEGHALAYA
AT SHILLONG
WP(C) No. 443 of 2020
Date of Decision: 24.03.2023
Smti. Marbline R. Marak
Vs.
State of Meghalaya & Ors.
Coram:
Hon’ble Mr. Justice H. S. Thangkhiew, Judge
Appearance:
For the Petitioner/Appellant(s) :
Mr. S. Deb, Adv.
For the Respondent(s)
Mr. B. Bhattacharjee, AAG with
Ms. R. Colney, GA.
:
i)
Whether approved for reporting in
Law journals etc.:
ii)
Whether approved for publication
in press:
Yes/No
Yes/No
JUDGMENT AND ORDER
1.
The brief facts of the case is that, the writ petitioner, is the widow
of a school teacher who was killed by the outlawed GNLA on 19.07.2012
at Resubelpara, North Garo Hills, accusing him to be a police informer.
The writ petitioner having 2(two) minor children being left destitute, then
approached the Chief Secretary to the Government of Meghalaya for
employment in any government post. Thereafter, the petitioner was
appointed temporarily as Assistant Teacher on 23.04.2013, and given
periodic extensions till 15.12.2020, whereafter, her services was
discontinued. During the course of her temporary employment, the writ
petitioner had preferred representations for regularization on humanitarian
grounds, which were forwarded by the concerned respondent No. 5 to
respondent No. 4 and respondent No. 2. From the materials it appears that,
the matter for regularization of her services was processed by the
respondents, as the writ petitioner was also qualified to hold the post as
Assistant Teacher. However, as there was no finality in the process, the
writ petitioner during the subsistence of her employment, has filed the
instant writ petition before this Court.
2.
Mr. S. Deb, learned counsel for the petitioner has submitted that,
the appointment of the writ petitioner was on humanitarian consideration,
and as such, such recruitment is not subject to the rigours of a regular
selection process. The learned counsel further submits that, though the
scheme for compassionate appointment is no longer in existence in the
State of Meghalaya, the appointment of the writ petitioner, not being under
any scheme, but made on humanitarian grounds on account of the
exceptional circumstance, that is, the death of her husband at the hand of
terrorists, is entitled for consideration for regular employment.
3.
The learned counsel has placed reliance on the recommendations
of the Fifth Meghalaya Pay Commission, wherein it has been provided
that, in exceptional cases where it is found that, the spouse or dependent
of the deceased government employee, is not gainfully employed, on
certification of the Deputy Commissioner, employment may be provided
on compassionate ground. It has been further submitted that, the writ
petitioner will come within the exception as the Deputy Commissioner of
North Garo Hills, sitting as the Member Secretary of the District Selection
Committee, North Garo Hills, had forwarded her application for
employment, vide letter dated 09.02.2015. The learned counsel concludes
by submitting that, the case of the writ petitioner being exceptional, the
respondents are liable to be directed to consider her case favourably.
4.
Mr. B. Bhattacharjee, learned AAG assisted by Ms. R. Colney,
learned GA on behalf of the State respondents, has submitted that, the
compassionate appointment scheme was discontinued on November,
2010, and no scheme was available on the day the writ petitioner’s husband
died. He further submits that, the petitioner though serving temporarily
from 23.04.2013 to 15.12.2020, has acquired no vested right to
regularization and that no appointment is permitted without passing
through the regular selection process. Learned AAG submits that,
recruitment to the post of Assistant Teacher is prescribed under Rule 6(5)
of the Meghalaya School Service Rules, 2012, and that as per the Rules,
appointments to the post of Assistant Teachers shall be made by direct
recruitment, the procedure of which shall be prescribed by the government
from time to time. He therefore submits that, the continuation of service
by a temporary or adhoc employee, would not confer such employee with
any right to be absorbed into service, if such employee was not appointed
as per the relevant rules. He concludes that no case has been made out for
regularization of the petitioner and as such, the writ petition deserves no
consideration.
5.
Having heard the learned counsels for the parties and examined
the materials on record, the undisputed facts that have emanated from the
case is that, the writ petitioner is the widow of a regular government
employee, who lost his life to militants leaving the writ petitioner and two
minor children destitute, and on humanitarian grounds was accorded
employment, though temporary, by the respondents. The fact that, the writ
petitioner is qualified for appointment to the post of Assistant Teacher is
also not in question, and the same has also been certified by the respondent
No. 5, while the consideration of the proposal for regularization of her
services was being processed. In this regard, two letters dated 15.10.2018
(Annexure -19) and 14.02.2019 (Annexure – 20) that are relevant, are
reproduced hereinbelow, to show that, the petitioner is qualified and that
there was a proposal to regularize the services of the petitioner, which
however culminated in her temporary employment not being renewed after
15.12.2020.
“OFFICE OF THE DIRECTOR OF SCHOOL
EDUCATION AND LITERACY,
MEGHALAYA :::::: SHILLONG.
No. DSEL/EL/GA/ADM/1/2016/180,
Dated Shillong the ____October, 2018.
From
:
Shri. A. Ch. Marak, MCS.
Director of School Education & Literacy,
Meghalaya, Shillong
To
:
The Special Officer to the Govt. of Meghalaya,
Education Department, Shillong.
Subject
:
Proposal for Regularisation of Service in respect of
Smt. Marbline R. Marak, Officiating Asstt.
Teacher of Daram Union Govt. U.P. School.
Madam,
With reference to the above, I am to enclose herewith a
copy of letter No. SDSEO(R)/AP-6/11/2018/2651 Dt. 10.08.2018, for
your ready reference alongwith the enclosures therein received from
Sub-Divisional School Education Officer, Resubelpara, North Garo
Hills and to to inform you that Smt. Marbline R. Marak, Officiating
Asstt. Teacher of Daram Union Govt. U.P. School is trained to teach
as the Teacher is Graduate with B.Ed, for which the relevant
documents are being attached herewith for favour of your kind
information and necessary action.
Enclo : As stated.
Yours faithfully,
Director of School Education and Literacy,
Meghalaya, Shillong.
MemoNo.DSEL/EL/GA/ADM/1/2016/181, Dated Shillong the 15th October, 2018.
Copy to :The Sub-Divisional School Education Officer, Resubelpara,
North Garo Hills with reference to letter mentioned above.
Director of School Education and Literacy,
Meghalaya, Shillong.
GOVERNMENT OF MEGHALAYA
EDUCATION DEPARTMENT
No. EDN-103/2015/204
Dated Shillong, the 14th February, 2019.
From:
Smti. I. Lyngdoh,
Special Officer to the Government of Meghalaya,
Education Department.
To:
The Director of School Education & Literacy,
Meghalaya, Shillong.
Subject:-
Proposal for Regularisation of Service of Smti. Marbline
R. Marak, officiating Assistant Teacher of Daram Union
Govt. U.P. School.
Reference:-
No. DSEL/EL/GA/ADM/1/2016/159, dt. 18.05.2018.
Sir,
With reference to the subject cited above, I am directed to
inform you that the proposal for regularization of the adhoc Service of Smti.
Marbline R. Marak, Assistant Teacher, Daram Union Government Upper
Primary School is under examination of the Government in Personnel
Department.
Yours faithfully,
Special Officer to the Govt. of Meghalaya,
Education Department.
Memo. No. EDN-103/2015/204-A, Dated Shillong, the 14th February, 2019
Copy to:The Joint Secretary to the Govt. of Meghalaya, Personnel &
Administrative Reforms (B) Deptt. with reference to I/D. No. 360/2018, dt.
15.01.2019.
By Order etc.,
Special Officer to the Govt. of Meghalaya,
Education Department.”
6.
It is worthy to note that, prior to the letters given hereinabove, the
proposal for regularization of the services of the writ petitioner, was under
consideration by the respondents from 2015 onwards, and as submitted had
even been forwarded by the Member Secretary, District Selection
Committee (Deputy Commissioner), North Garo Hills, for consideration
vide letter dated 09.02.2015. This Court notes the fact that, the
compassionate appointment scheme, has since been discontinued and in
the normal course, the dependents of a government employee who dies in
harness, cannot apply for appointment on compassionate grounds, which
are appointments made outside the regular selection process. However,
what cannot be ignored is the fact that, the case of the petitioner is truly an
exceptional case, due to the tragic circumstances, which has been
elaborated earlier.
7.
The recommendations of the Fifth Meghalaya Pay Commission,
in its report also had discussed this aspect that is, the question of
compassionate appointment in exceptional cases by recommending at
Paras – 8.5.3 and 8.5.4 as follows:
“8.5.3 The Commission notes that the scheme for
providing employment on compassionate ground to
the next of kin of a government employee who dies
while in service was introduced by the Government
of Meghalaya as a welfare measure to provide
relief from extreme hardship to the family of a
deceased employee belonging to Group ‘C’ and ‘D’
categories only. And on the recommendation of the
Fourth Meghalaya Pay Commission the scheme
was discontinued for the reason that the existing
facilities and benefits, including social security
cover, available to the family of the deceased
government employee who dies while in service
were quite adequate.
8.5.4 The Commission examined the submissions
made by various Service Associations and Groups
of government employees for revival of the
Scheme. After careful consideration of all aspects,
the Commission recommends that in exceptional
cases, where it is found that the spouse or a
dependant of the deceased government employee is
not gainfully employed, as duly certified by the
concerned
Deputy
Commissioner,
suitable
employment may be provided by the Government to
one
member
of
the
deceased
employee’s
dependant(s), preferably a female dependant,
keeping in view the social and cultural traditions
and practice of the Khasi, Jaintia and Garo
population of the State.”
8.
This Court therefore, taking into account the entire facts and
circumstances of the case, deems the case of the writ petitioner to be
worthy of being given due consideration by the respondents for
appointment on humanitarian grounds, moreso, as the proposal for
regularization, had already been initiated by the respondents themselves
on the representation of the writ petitioner. This concession which is being
given by this Court, however, shall not serve as a precedent as the case of
the writ petitioner is surely an exceptional case, which deserves
consideration.
9.
The State respondents shall complete the exercise preferably
within a period of 4(four) months from the date of this order.
10.
As ordered, this writ petition accordingly is disposed of.
11.
No order as to costs.
Judge
Meghalaya
24.03.2023
“D.Thabah-PS”
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review