Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA
Civil Writ Jurisdiction Case No.1312 of 2025
======================================================
Manoranjan Singh S/o Late Haridev Singh, Resident of Village- Majharia,
P.S.- Buxar, District- Buxar, Bihar, presently serving as Nk in the Indian
Army, deployed in Counter Insurgency Operations under Headquarters
Counter Insurgency Force (Romeo), Jammu and Kashmir.
... ... Petitioner/s
1.
Versus
Punjab National Bank through its Chairman, Corporate Office, Plot No. 4,
Sector- 10, Dwarka, New Delhi- 110075.
2.
Zonal Manager, Punjab National Bank, Zonal Office, Patna, Bihar.
3.
Branch Manager, Punjab National Bank, Main Road Branch, Buxar, Bihar.
4.
The Superintendent of Police, Buxar, Bihar.
5.
The Officer-in-Charge, P.S. Cyber, Buxar, Bihar.
... ... Respondent/s
======================================================
Appearance :
For the Petitioner/s
For the Respondent/s
:
:
Mr. Shama Sinha, Adv.
Mr. Government Pleader (16)
======================================================
CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE A. ABHISHEK REDDY
ORAL ORDER
20-04-2026
Heard the learned counsel for the parties.
The present writ petition has been filed for the
following relief(s):“(I)
Issue
an
appropriate
writ/order/direction in the nature of mandamus directing
the Respondent Bank (Punjab National Bank) to
immediately restore the amount of Rs. 9,93,000/fraudulently withdrawn from the Petitioner's salary
account and to implement stringent measures to ensure
the safety and security of his account from any further
unauthorized transactions, in compliance with its
statutory and fiduciary duties as a public sector bank.
(II)
Issue
an
appropriate
writ/order/direction in the nature of mandamus declaring
the negligence and inaction of the Respondent Bank,
despite prior complaints of suspicious activity by the
Petitioner, as a breach of its statutory and fiduciary
duties, amounting to a constitutional tort and a violation
of the Petitioner's fundamental right under Article 21 of
Patna High Court CWJC No.1312 of 2025(13) dt.20-04-2026
2/15
the Constitution of India. Further, direct the Respondent
Bank to compensate the Petitioner for the financial loss,
mental agony, and harassment caused by its gross
negligence and failure to safeguard the Petitioner's
salary account.
(III).
Issue
an
appropriate
writ/order/direction in the nature of mandamus directing
the Respondent Bank Authorities to conduct a timebound and comprehensive investigation/inquiry into the
cyber fraud reported by the Petitioner, cooperate with
law enforcement agencies to bring the perpetrators to
justice, and identify internal lapses and fix accountability
within the Bank for its failure to take adequate preventive
measures, despite prior information and warnings about
the potential for such an offence.
(IV)
Issue
an
appropriate
writ/order/direction in the nature of mandamus directing
the Respondent Bank to implement and enforce stringent
safeguards and security mechanisms, in compliance with
regulatory standards and best practices, to prevent
fraudulent activities in the salary accounts of soldiers
and ensure the financial security of defence personnel.
(V) Pass any other writ/order/direction that
this Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper in the
interest of justice.”
3. The petitioner is a serving soldier in the Indian
Army presently working in the Rajouri District in Jammu &
Kashmir. As culled out from the pleadings, the petitioner is
having a salary account bearing Acc. No. 1567011300013527 in
the Respondent/ Punjab National Bank in Main Road Branch,
Buxar, Bihar. That on finding some suspicious activities in his
account, the petitioner gave a written complaint to the
respondent-Bank on 08.07.2024 and requested the Bank to
change the registered mobile number. However, the authority
without changing the mobile number unlocked the UPI access.
Patna High Court CWJC No.1312 of 2025(13) dt.20-04-2026
3/15
That prior to the complaint made by the petitioner, the petitioner
found suspicious activities on his mobile number and though
number of transactions have taken place for resetting the
password, user ID recovery, mobile banking activation, set
transactions pin, adding of payee (beneficiary account), the
Bank did not red flag these events and allowed the same to
continue. Thereafter, on 12.07.2024 a nominal deduction of Rs.
1 was made and the petitioner revisited the Branch and he was
falsely assured that his mobile number has been changed and his
account was secure. That on 14.07.2024 between the 10:55 AM
and 11:23 AM, seven fraudulent transactions took place and sum
of Rs. 9,93,000 was debited from the account of the petitioner.
That the petitioner immediately lodged NCRP Complaint No.
30507240025799 and the Debit Card, UPI, IBS / MBS were
blocked and his account was frozen. Thereafter, the petitioner
has immediately reached the Superintendent of Police who
directed for registration of the FIR and FIR was lodged on
22.07.2024 bearing No. 33 of 2024 (Cyber P.S. Buxar). That on
25.07.2024, the respondent-Bank credited an amount of Rs.
9,93,000/- as shadow reversal to the petitioner’s account under
its customer compensation policy. Thereafter, the respondentBank on 13.08.2024 has again unilaterally debited the above
Patna High Court CWJC No.1312 of 2025(13) dt.20-04-2026
4/15
shadow credit of Rs. 9,93,000/- without putting the petitioner on
any prior notice or serving a copy of the enquiry report or giving
an opportunity of hearing. That despite intervention of several
senior army officers, the Bank has been taking its own sweet
time in conducting the investigation and resolve the matter.
4.
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the
petitioner has drawn the attention of the Court to the counteraffidavit filed by the respondent-Bank, that of the Police
Department and also the order dated 16.09.2025 passed by this
Hon’ble Court directing the respondent-Bank to bring on record
the report dated 25.07.2024. Learned counsel has stated that in
spite of a specific direction on 16.09.2025 by this Hon’ble Court
to bring on record the report dated 25.07.2024, the authority has
failed to do so and have instead filed a supplementary counteraffidavit annexing the copy of the report prepared by the Chief
Manager, IT, PNB on 03.03.2026. Learned counsel has
submitted that the act of the respondent-Bank in not taking due
care or precaution even after the complaint was made by the
petitioner clearly shows the negligent attitude and the failure of
the Bank in discharging its duties and protect the customers of
the Bank from Cyber frauds. Learned counsel has stated that at
no point of time, the petitioner has shared the OTPs which were
Patna High Court CWJC No.1312 of 2025(13) dt.20-04-2026
5/15
generated on his mobile and in the absence of any lapses on part
of the petitioner, the authority ought to have compensated the
petitioner for the loss of the money from his salary account.
Learned counsel has stated that the petitioner is serving in
Indian Army, that he is deployed in the counter insurgency
operations in Rajouri District Jammu & Kashmir putting his life
and limbs at risk. However, the respondent-Bank in an
irresponsible manner have failed to protect the interest of the
petitioner. That in spite of knowing fully well that the Bank was
at fault, they are not trying to resolve the matter and passing the
blame on the petitioner. Learned counsel has therefore, prayed
this Hon’ble Court to allow the present writ petition. Learned
counsel has relied on the judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme
Court in the case of State Bank of India Vs. Pallabh
Bhowmick & Ors. passed in Special Leave to Appeal (C) No.
30677/2024 and also the guidelines issued by the Reserve Bank
of India (RBI) to be followed by all the Banks.
5.
Per contra, the learned counsel appearing on
behalf of the respondent-Bank has vehemently opposed the very
maintainability of the present writ petition. Learned counsel has
stated that the petitioner was at fault as his cell phone was
hacked and appeared that the cell phone of the petitioner was
Patna High Court CWJC No.1312 of 2025(13) dt.20-04-2026
6/15
cloned. That the petitioner did not take any precautionary
measures to prevent the Cyber crime which could not have
taken place without his mistake. Learned counsel has stated that
the petitioner instead of promptly reporting the suspicious
activities on his phone has taken his own sweet time in
approaching the Bank. Further, it is stated by the learned
counsel for the respondent-Bank that the application made by
the petitioner for change of the registered mobile is not in the
requisite form and therefore, the Bank could not have acted on
the written complaint made by the petitioner. Further, the UPI
access was allowed at the request of the petitioner and therefore,
the Bank cannot be blamed for the Cyber crime. Learned
counsel has stated that the authority initially have on 25.07.2024
credited the amount of Rs. 9,93,000/- as shadow reversal but on
finding that the petitioner was at fault, the amount was reversed
on 13.08.2024. Learned counsel has therefore, prayed this
Hon’ble Court dismiss the present writ petition.
6. Admittedly, in the present case, the facts are not in
dispute, the withdrawal of the amounts from the account of the
petitioner on 14.07.2024 and the subsequent complaints made
by the petitioner to the Bank as well as to the Cyber Police,
crediting of the amount of Rs. 9,93,000/- and subsequent
Patna High Court CWJC No.1312 of 2025(13) dt.20-04-2026
7/15
reversal of the said amount on 13.08.2024 has not been denied
by the respondent-Bank nor the Police in their respective
counter-affidavits. The only question involved in the present
writ petition is as to whether the petitioner is at fault or the Bank
officials were negligent in allowing the Cyber fraud to take
place.
7.
Admittedly, on finding that there is some
suspicious activity on 26.06.2024 and 03.07.2024, the petitioner
has visited the respondent-Bank and submitted a written
complaint seeking change of his registered mobile number and
to unblock his salary account only after mobile number is
updated. In the writ petition, the petitioner has specifically
stated that on 07.07.2024, a suspicious link was sent to the
petitioner registered mobile number and he did not click on the
same suspecting it to be Cyber fraud. The factum of the
petitioner visiting the Bank on 08.07.2024 has not been denied
by the respondent-Bank, the authority while admitting that the
petitioner has given a written complaint has stated at Para no. 15
of the counter-affidavit as under ;
“The UPI transactions were unblocked
but without changing the registered phone number.
The petitioner was under an impression that the
number had been changed but without a fresh
registration on the UPI Application used, it was
evident that the number had not been changed
inasmuch as the request for changing the number
Patna High Court CWJC No.1312 of 2025(13) dt.20-04-2026
8/15
was not in the format duly prescribed for the same.”
8.
Further, in the counter-affidavit filed by the
respondent-Bank except stating at Para no. 13 that there is a
possibility of the petitioner mobile was hacked, which caused
OTPs to be shared with the fraudsters and that the petitioner had
shared the credential like OTPs, Pins, CVV number with the
fraudster for which he has raised the complaint with the Bank
for changing the registered mobile number. Further, since the
customer had to do UPI transactions, he restricted to unblocking
the UPI. The above statements clearly demonstrates that the
petitioner had informed the respondent-Bank well in advance
about the suspicious activities and that there was a threat from
the Cyber criminals well in advance on 08.07.2024 i.e. much
prior to the Cyber fraud which has taken place on 14.07.2024.
The authority while admitting that the petitioner had given a
written complaint on 08.04.2024 are trying to put the blame on
the petitioner by saying that the said written complaint was not
in the format duly prescribed by the Bank. It is pertinent to note
that the person who had received the written complaint from the
petitioner on 08.04.2024 is an employee of the Bank and the
employee should have informed the petitioner immediately that
for taking any customer complaint/ request, the same should be
Patna High Court CWJC No.1312 of 2025(13) dt.20-04-2026
9/15
in the prescribed form. However, the employee has failed to do.
Further, it is to be noted that immediately after receipt of the
complaint by the petitioner, the authority has given shadow
credit of Rs. 9,93,000/- i.e., the amount involved in the Cyber
crime on 24.07.2024. But after lapse of more than 20 days, the
same was reversed, on what basis the amount was reversed has
not been stated anywhere in the counter-affidavit except stating
that the same was on the basis of report dated 25.07.2024 (the
copy of the said report has not been annexed to the counteraffidavit). This Court gave a specific direction on 16.09.2025 to
bring the said report dated 25.07.2024 on record, the authority
except filing a supplementary counter-affidavit has not annexed
the copy of the said report therefore, an adverse inference has to
be drawn against the Bank and it has to be inferred that there
was no such report dated 25.07.2024 and the Bank officials only
to save themselves have reversed the shadow credit given to the
petitioner. Further, it is to be noted that along with the
supplementary counter-affidavit filed by the respondent-Bank, a
report named as “Analysis of Fraud” said to have been prepared
by the Chief Manager, IT, PNB dated 03.03.2026 i.e., after lapse
of almost more than 19 months from the date of reversal has
been annexed. Even as per the said report, the fact that the
Patna High Court CWJC No.1312 of 2025(13) dt.20-04-2026
10/15
petitioner has visited the Bank and spoke to the Deputy
Manager, Mr. Satish Kumar about the suspicious activity on
08.07.2024 has not been denied. In the said analysis, it is stated
that the petitioner has made a request for mobile number update
but the petitioner never confirmed that the mobile number was
actually changed. Annexure-R/4 annexed to the counteraffidavit clearly reveals that the petitioner had made a request
on 14.07.2024 at 03:05 PM and the remarks of the agents are
mentioned herein below;
“Agent Remarks:
Complaint against Suspicious
Transactions: As per customer VOC, this transaction has not
been done by customer-Total suspicious amount: Status of ADC
channel-9930001. Debit Card:blocked2. UPI:blocked3. IBS/
MBS :blocked4. Debit Freeze Transaction Status-:TL Raushan
Sir”
9. Thereafter, in the column Hot Listed Debit Card/
Disabled IBS User? it is mentioned as ‘Yes’ and as against the
Debit card blocked/ UPI blocked/ Account freezed / IBSMBS
blocked it is mentioned as “Yes” and reason is given as all
services block but AEPS not blocked due to error.
10. However, in the remarks column, an entry is said
to be made by one Pradeep-5174496 on 25.07.2024 at 04:46:19
PM which reads as under;
“Investigation Report: Liability is at customer
level. Without sharing account No./Debit Card No./ATM
Patna High Court CWJC No.1312 of 2025(13) dt.20-04-2026
11/15
PIN/OTP, mobile banking can not be registered/activated.
Without
sharing
login/MPIN/transaction
password/registered mobile/Debit Card/ATM PIN/OTP
which comes only on customer's registered mobile No., ecommerce transactions/fund transfer can not be done using
IMPS.”
11. The above observations is on the basis of surmises
and conjuncture and not based on any evidence. The remarks
clearly reveals that without there being any report dated
25.07.2024, the authority by themselves have reversed the
shadow credit given to the petitioner.
12.
Under similar circumstances, a Division Bench
of Dehli High Court in the case of Hare Ram Singh Vs.
Reserve Bank of India & Ors. passed in W.P. (C) 13497/2022
has held as under;
“32. In the light of the aforesaid
regulations, it is evident that the security protocols
such as „2FA‟ or OTP verification had been
breached by a simple „malware‟ deployed by the
cyber fraudsters. Evidently, the online banking
service of the petitioner was linked with his mobile
number, which was being used to authenticate his
banking transactions, and the security apparatus of
the respondent Bank failed to detect any unusual
logging activity from a different Internet Protocol
Address that was being used by the fraudsters. It has
to be presumed that it is on account of the failure on
the part of the bank to put in place a system which
prevents such withdrawals, that the petitioner
suffered monetary losses.
33. Lastly, it is well established under
the Common Law, that funds in a bank account
belong to the bank, but the bank acts as an agent for
the principal (the customer). Consequently, the bank
Patna High Court CWJC No.1312 of 2025(13) dt.20-04-2026
12/15
cannot refuse to process an online transfer if it
appears to be authorized by the customer, however,
upon detecting fraud, the bank has an implied duty
to exercise reasonable care and take prompt action.
Unhesitatingly, there was patent deficiency in
services on the part of the bank, inasmuch as the
response of the bank was lukewarm, defective, and
not prompt. The respondent No. 2 i.e., SBI failed to
take immediate measures to take up the issue with
the other REs to whom the online payment had been
remitted.”
13. Further, the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of
State Bank of India Vs. Pallabh Bhowmick & Ors. passed in
Special Leave to Appeal (C) No. 30677/2024 has held as under;
“All transactions relating to the account of the
respondent No.1 – herein maintained with the petitioner - Bank
were found to be unauthorized and fraudulent. It is the
responsibility of the bank so far as such unauthorized and
fraudulent transactions are concerned. The Bank should remain
vigilant. The Bank has the best of the technology available today
to detect and prevent such unauthorized and fraudulent
transaction. Further, clauses 8 and 9 respectively of the RBI’s
Circular dated 6-7-2017 make the position further clear.
4. We also take notice of the fact that within 24
hours of the fraudulent transaction, the customer, i.e., the
respondent No.1 – herein brought it to the notice of the Bank.”
14. Further, the guidelines of the Reserve Bank of
India which reads as under;
“Fraud Risk Management
36. The REs shall document and implement the
configuration aspects for identifying suspicious transactional
behaviour in respect of rules, preventive, detective types of
controls, mechanism to alert the customers in case of failed
authentication, time frame for the same, etc.
37. System alerts shall be parameterised and
monitored in terms of various applicable parameters. Such
parameters, as applicable could be: transaction velocity (e.g.,
fund transfers, cash withdrawals, payments through electronic
modes, adding new beneficiaries, etc.) in a short period, more so
Patna High Court CWJC No.1312 of 2025(13) dt.20-04-2026
13/15
in the accounts of customers who’ve never used mobile app/
internet banking/ card ever (depending upon the type of payment
channel), high risk merchant category codes (MCC) parameters,
counterfeit card parameters (String of Invalid CVV/ PINs
indicates an account generation attack), new account
parameters (excessive activity on a new account), time zones,
geo-locations, IP address origin (in respect of unusual patterns,
prohibited zones/ rogue IPs), behavioural biometrics,
transaction origination from point of compromise, transactions
to mobile wallets/ mobile numbers/ VPAs on whom vishing fraud
or other types of fraud is/are registered/ recorded, declined
transactions, transactions with no approval code, etc.
38. Fraud analysis shall be conducted to identify
the reason for fraud occurrence and determine mechanism to
prevent such frauds.
39. The staff, especially in the fraud control
function, shall be educated about frauds and trained in the
following skills and areas of expertise:
a. Fraud control tools and their usage;
b . Investigative techniques and procedures;
c. Cardholder and merchant education techniques
to prevent fraud;
d. Scheme/ Card operating regulations;
e. Data processing and analysis and liaising or
communicating withlaw enforcement agencies; and
f. The requisite skills required to (i) set and
update appropriate rules, (ii) monitor the exceptions thrown
based on the rules on a continuous basis and take necessary
actions promptly, (iii) communicate/ escalate wherever required
to appropriate authorities, and (iv) differentiate false positives
from the rest.
40. REs shall maintain updated contact details of
service providers, intermediaries, external agencies and other
stakeholders (including other REs) for coordination in incident
response. REs shall put in place a mechanism with the
stakeholders to update and verify such contact details. REs shall
also formulate specific SOPs to handle incidents related to
payment ecosystem to mitigate the loss either to the customer or
RE.”
15. Further, the RBI circular dated 06.07.2017 titled
“Customer Protection/ in unauthorized bank transactions, it is
stated at Clause 12 that the burden of proving customer liability
in case of unauthorized electronic banking transactions shall lie
on the Bank. In this particular case, the respondent-Bank has
been unable to prove that at any point of time before the Cyber
Patna High Court CWJC No.1312 of 2025(13) dt.20-04-2026
14/15
crime was committed, the petitioner had either pressed the link,
shared the OTPs or done any overt act which could have
enabled the Cyber criminals to commit the fraud with the active
connivance of the petitioner. On the other hand, the petitioner
was diligent enough and he had immediately approached the
Bank well in advance even before the Cyber crime took place
and made a written complaint to the Bank to change the mobile
number. However, the authority instead of doing the needful are
putting the blame on the petitioner. It is to be noted that the
Bank is the custodian of the money of the petitioner, a common
man cannot be expected to be tech savvy and well conversant
with the banking regulations, Banking Apps, online banking
system, whereas the respondent-Bank are supposed to be well
equipped and well conversant with the methods and modus
operandi of the Cyber criminals as they have to deal with the
such crimes day in and day out. The authority instead of red
flagging the illegal transactions, did not take the necessary
precautions nor acted diligently on the written complaint made
by the petitioner. The Bank officials are coming up with a lame
excuse that the written complaint made by the petitioner on
08.07.2024 was not in the required form. The respondent-Bank
should have been more diligent while processing the application
Patna High Court CWJC No.1312 of 2025(13) dt.20-04-2026
15/15
made by the petitioner who is serving army personnel and
deployed in sensitive areas where anti-insurgency operations are
taking place. The least that can be expected from the Bank was
to see that the petitioner was given the due respect and
cooperation to resolve the crisis. The Bank officials should
remember that the petitioner is putting his life and limb at risk
so that the citizens of this country can feel safe and sleep
peacefully.
16. Having regard to the above mentioned facts and
circumstances, this Court has no hesitation to allow the present
writ petition and consequently direct the respondent-Bank to
credit the amount of Rs. 9,93,000/- to the petitioner’s salary
account at the earliest preferably within a period of two weeks
from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
17.
With the above direction, the present writ
petition stands allowed to the extent indicated.
(A. Abhishek Reddy, J)
Ayush/U
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review