Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
Digitally
signed by
SHAYNA
KADRI
2026:CGHC:6677
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 9744 of 2023
1 - Manoj Singh Rajput S/o Late Ganpat Singh Rajput Aged About 42
Years Rojgar Sahayak At Gram Panchayat, Machandur, Janpad
Panchayat Durg, District : Durg, Chhattisgarh
... Petitioner(s)
versus
1 - State Of Chhattisgarh Through- Its Secretary, Panchayat And Rural
Development Department, Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan, Naya
Raipur, District : Raipur, Chhattisgarh
2 - Collector Durg, District : Durg, Chhattisgarh
3 - The Chief Executive Officer Durg, District : Durg, Chhattisgarh
4 - The Chief Executive Officer, Janpad Panchayat Durg, District : Durg,
Chhattisgarh
5 - The Secretary Village Panchayat Machandur, Janpad Panchayat
Durg, District : Durg, Chhattisgarh
... Respondent(s)
(Cause-title is taken from Case Information System)
For Petitioner
: Mr. A. S. Rajput, Advocate
For State
: Mr. Ashutosh Shukla, Panel Lawyer
For Resp. No. 4 : Ms. Pranoti Das, Advocate holding brief on
behalf of Mr. Goutam Khetrapal, Advocate
SB- Hon'ble Shri Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad
Order on Board
05/02/2026
1.
The present writ petition is being filed seeking following reliefs:-
“10.1 That, this Hon'ble court may kindly be pleased
to issue a suitable writ or writs for quashing /
set aside the order dated 13.12.23 (Annexure
P-3) passed by respondent no. 4 Chief
Executive Officer, Janpad Panchayat Durg,
District (C.G.). Durg
10.2 Any other relief / reliefs which may deem fit
and proper in the facts and circumstances of
the case, may also be allowed.”
2.
The facts of the case, in brief, are that the petitioner was initially
appointed on the post of Rojgar Sahayak on contractual basis by
the respondent No. 4 vide appointment order dated 19.12.2019,
and thereafter his services were extended from time to time
without any break, lastly up to 12.12.2023, in recognition of his
satisfactory performance and continued requirement of his
services. A copy of the appointment order dated 19.12.2019 has
been filed and marked as Annexure P-1. During the course of his
engagement, certain allegations regarding alleged irregularities
under the MGNREGA Scheme were levelled against the
Sarpanch of Gram Panchayat Machandur as well as the
petitioner. Pursuant thereto, an Enquiry Committee was duly
constituted by the competent authority to enquire into the said
allegations. After conducting a detailed enquiry, the Enquiry
Committee submitted its report, categorically holding that the
allegations levelled against the petitioner were baseless and false,
and no irregularity was found attributable to him. Despite the
aforesaid exoneration and without issuing any show-cause notice
or affording any opportunity of hearing to the petitioner, the
respondent No. 4 abruptly passed the impugned order dated
13.12.2023 removing the petitioner from the post of Rojgar
Sahayak, thereby violating the principles of natural justice and
acting in an arbitrary and illegal manner. Being aggrieved by the
said arbitrary action, the petitioner has been constrained to invoke
the extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court by filing the present
petition.
3.
Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the impugned
order dated 13.12.2023 passed by respondent No. 4 is wholly
illegal, arbitrary and contrary to the settled principles of law. It is
contended that the said order has been passed without issuing
any show-cause notice and without affording any opportunity of
hearing to the petitioner, thereby resulting in a gross violation of
the principles of natural justice. Learned counsel further submits
that the very foundation of the impugned order is vitiated
inasmuch as the reason assigned therein alleges that the Enquiry
Committee found the petitioner guilty, whereas a bare perusal of
the enquiry report clearly reveals that the allegations levelled
against the petitioner were found to be baseless and false, and no
adverse finding whatsoever was recorded against him. The
enquiry report, which has already been brought on record as
Annexure
P-2,
exonerates
the
petitioner
completely,
and
therefore, the conclusion drawn by respondent No. 4 is not only
perverse but also suffers from non-application of mind. It is further
argued that the impugned order has been passed in excess of
jurisdiction and by an authority lacking competence to remove the
petitioner from service, rendering the same void ab initio. Learned
counsel submits that the petitioner had been continuously working
on the post of Rojgar Sahayak since 19.12.2019 and had
rendered unblemished service, and the sudden and illegal
termination of his services has caused grave financial hardship
not only to the petitioner but also to his dependent family
members. Lastly, it is submitted that the impugned action of the
respondents, particularly respondent No. 5, is discriminatory,
arbitrary and violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of
India, as similarly situated persons have not been subjected to
such harsh and unjust treatment. On these grounds, learned
counsel for the petitioner prays for setting aside the impugned
order and for grant of appropriate relief in favour of the petitioner.
4.
Learned State counsel as also the learned counsel for the
respondent No. 4, opposing the submissions advanced on behalf
of the petitioner, submit that the petitioner has filed the present
petition challenging the order dated 13.12.2023 issued by the
answering respondent strictly in compliance of the directions
contained in the order dated 06/16.10.2023 passed by respondent
No. 3, and therefore no illegality or arbitrariness can be attributed
to the answering respondent. It is contended that while working as
Employment Assistant at Gram Panchayat, Machandur, the
petitioner, in connivance with the Sarpanch and Secretary of the
said Gram Panchayat, indulged in preparation of forged and
fabricated muster rolls in respect of works executed under the
MGNREGA Scheme, thereby causing substantial financial loss to
the State Government. Learned counsel further submit that an
inquiry was duly conducted by the Inquiry Team, which, after a
detailed investigation, submitted its report holding the petitioner
along with the Sarpanch and Secretary guilty of preparing forged
muster rolls and recommended recovery of the embezzled
amount from the erring persons. It is further submitted that on the
basis of the said enquiry report, recovery of the embezzled
amount was effected from the petitioner and other concerned
persons, and thereafter a note sheet was prepared and forwarded
to the competent authority recommending removal of the
petitioner from the post of Employment Assistant. Learned
counsel submit that prior to passing of the impugned order,
respondent No. 3 had issued a show-cause notice dated
01.05.2023 to the petitioner for initiating disciplinary action,
thereby affording him due opportunity. It is further contended that
vide order dated 06.10.2023, respondent No. 3 directed the
answering respondent to ensure removal of the petitioner from
service, and in compliance thereof, the impugned order dated
13.12.2023 was passed. It is emphasized that the petitioner was
appointed on contractual basis by the Chief Executive Officer,
Janpad Panchayat, Durg, and therefore the answering respondent
was duty-bound to act in accordance with the directions issued by
respondent No. 3. Learned counsel lastly submit that the order
passed by respondent No. 3, which forms the basis of the
impugned action, has not been challenged by the petitioner, and
therefore the present writ petition is misconceived and liable to be
dismissed at the threshold.
5.
I have heard learned counsel for the parties at length and has
carefully perused the pleadings and documents placed on record.
6.
The undisputed facts emerging from the record reveal that the
petitioner was initially appointed on the post of Rojgar Sahayak on
contractual basis vide appointment order dated 19.12.2019 issued
by respondent No. 4, and his services were extended from time to
time without any break, lastly up to 12.12.2023. During the
subsistence of his contractual engagement, certain allegations
regarding alleged irregularities under the MGNREGA Scheme
were levelled against the Sarpanch of Gram Panchayat
Machandur as well as the petitioner, pursuant to which an Enquiry
Committee was constituted by the competent authority.
7.
At the outset, it is to be noted that the enquiry report annexed by
the petitioner as Annexure P-2 clearly records a finding that the
allegations against the petitioner were baseless and false. The
respondents have not been able to demonstrate how, despite
such exoneration, the petitioner could be removed from service on
the same set of allegations. The impugned order does not
disclose any independent reasoning nor does it record any cogent
justification for discarding the findings of the Enquiry Committee.
This Court finds substance in the contention of learned counsel
for the petitioner that the impugned order has been passed in
gross violation of the principles of natural justice.
8.
It is an admitted position that no show-cause notice or opportunity
of hearing was afforded to the petitioner prior to passing the
impugned order. Even assuming that a show-cause notice dated
01.05.2023 was issued by respondent No. 3, the impugned order
dated 13.12.2023 passed by respondent No. 4 does not reflect
any consideration of the petitioner’s reply or compliance with the
mandatory requirement of affording a reasonable opportunity of
hearing before imposing the extreme penalty of removal from
service. The contention of the respondents that the impugned
order was passed merely in compliance of the directions issued
by respondent No. 3 also does not impress this Court.
Compliance with superior directions cannot absolve the authority
from adhering to the principles of natural justice and from
independently applying its mind to the facts of the case. An order
passed mechanically, without application of mind and in disregard
of an enquiry report exonerating the employee, cannot be
sustained in the eyes of law.
9.
This Court is also unable to accept the submission that the writ
petition is not maintainable on the ground that the order passed
by respondent No. 3 has not been challenged. The impugned
order dated 13.12.2023, which has civil consequences for the
petitioner, is independently assailable, and merely because it is
stated to be passed in compliance of an earlier order does not
deprive the petitioner of his right to challenge the same. It is a
settled principle of law that even a contractual employee cannot
be removed from service arbitrarily or in violation of the principles
of natural justice. The action of the respondents, in the present
case, suffers from arbitrariness, non-application of mind and
procedural impropriety, and thus offends Articles 14 and 16 of the
Constitution of India.
10.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Swati Priaydarshani v.
State of Madhya Pradesh and Ors. reported in 2024 SCC
Online SC 2139, in which the ratio laid down by the Hon'ble
Supreme Court is to the effect that even in case of contractual
appointment, if any stigmatic order is to be passed, it may be
passed only after holding proper enquiry and after giving due
opportunity of hearing to the concerned delinquent/employee. The
Co-ordinate Bench of this Court in WPS No. 4969/2015 (Digambar
Chandrakar v. State of Chhattisgarh and others) decided on
22.08.2024 held that in order to pass a stigmatic or cumulative order,
the concerned authorities are required to hold a departmental enquiry
after giving due opportunity of hearing to delinquent/ employee.
11.
The view taken by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matter of
Swati Priyadarshini (supra) goes to show that before passing
any stigmatic order for removal of any employee from service, a
departmental enquiry is required to be done, which has not been
done in this case. In para 34 of the said judgment, the Hon'ble
Supreme Court has held as under:“34. It is profitable to refer to what five
learned Judges of this Court laid down in
Parshotam Lal Dhingra v. Union of India,
1957 SCC OnLine SC 5:
"28. The position may, therefore, be
summed up as follows: Any and every
termination of service is not a
dismissal, removal or reduction in
rank. A termination of service brought
about by the exercise of a contractual
right is not per se dismissal or
removal, as has been held by this
Court in Satish Chander Anand v.
Union of India [(1953) 1 SCC 420:
1953 SCR 655]. Likewise the
termination of service by compulsory
retirement in terms of a specific rule
regulating the conditions of service is
not tantamount to the infliction of a
punishment and does not attract
Article 311(2), as has also been held
by this Court in Shyam Lal v. State of
Uttar Pradesh [(1954) 1 SCC 572:
(1955) 1 SCR 26]. In either of the two
above
mentioned
cases
the
termination of the service did not carry
with it the penal consequences of loss
of pay, or allowances under Rule 52 of
the Fundamental Rules. It is true that
the
misconduct,
negligence,
inefficiency or other disqualification
may be the motive or the inducing
factor
which
influences
the
Government to take action under the
terms of the contract of employment
or
the
specific
service
rule,
nevertheless, if a right exists, under
the contract or the rules, to terminate
the service the motive operating on
the mind of the Government is, as
Chagla, C.J., has said in Shrinivas
Ganesh v. Union of India, [58 Bom LR
673: AIR 1956 Bom 455] wholly
irrelevant. In short, if the termination
of service is founded on the right
flowing from contract or the service
rules
then,
prima
facie,
the
termination is not a punishment and
carries with it no evil consequences
and so Article 311 is not attracted. But
even if the Government has. by
contract or under the rules, the right to
terminate the employment without
going
through
the
procedure
prescribed
for
inflicting
the
punishment of dismissal or removal or
reduction in rank, the Government
may, nevertheless, choose to punish
the servant and if the termination of
service is sought to be founded on
misconduct, negligence, inefficiency
other disqualification, then it is or a
punishment and the requirements of
Article 311 must be complied with. As
already stated if the servant has got a
right to continue in the post, then,
unless the contract of employment or
the rules provide to the contrary, his
services cannot be terminated
otherwise than for misconduct,
negligence, inefficiency or other good
and sufficient cause. A termination of
the service of such a servant on such
grounds must be a punishment and,
therefore, a dismissal or removal
within Article 311, for it operates as a
forefeiture of his right and he is visited
with the evil consequences of loss of
pay and allowances. It puts an
indelible stigma on the officer affecting
his future career. A reduction in rank
likewise may be by way of
punishment or it may be an innocuous
thing. If the government servant has a
right to a particular rank, then the very
reduction from that rank will operate
as a penalty, for he will then lose the
emoluments and privileges of that
rank. If, however, he has no right to
the particular rank, his reduction from
an officiating higher rank to his
substantive lower rank will not
ordinarily be a punishment. But the
mere fact that the servant has no title
to the post or the rank and the
Government has, by contract, express
or implied, or under the rules, the right
to reduce him to a lower post does not
mean that an order of reduction of a
servant to a lower post or rank cannot
in
any
circumstances
be
a
punishment. The real test for
determining whether the reduction in
such cases is or is not by way of
punishment is to find out if the order
for the reduction also visits the
servant with any penal consequences.
Thus if the order entails or provides
for the forfeiture of his pay or
allowances or the loss of his seniority
in his substantive rank or the
stoppage or postponement of his
future chances of promotion, then that
circumstance may indicate that
although in form the Government had
purported to exercise its right to
terminate the employment or to
reduce the servant to a lower rank
under the terms of the contract of
employment or under the rules, in
truth and reality the Government has
terminated the employment as and by
way of penalty The use of the
expression "terminate" or "discharge"
is not conclusive. In spite of the use of
such innocuous expressions, the
court has to apply the two tests
mentioned above, namely, (1) whether
the servant had a right to the post or
the rank, or (2) whether he has been
visited with evil consequences of the
kind hereinbefore referred to? If the
case satisfies either of the two tests
then it must be held that the servant
has been punished and the
termination of his service must be
taken as a dismissal or removal from
service or the reversion to his
substantive rank must be regarded as
a reduction in rank and if the
requirements of the rules and Article
311, which give protection to
government servant have not been
complied with, the termination of the
service or the reduction in rank must
be held to be wrongful and in violation
of the constitutional right of the
servant."
12.
In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court is of the considered
opinion that the impugned order dated 13.12.2023 passed by
respondent No. 4 is unsustainable in law and deserves to be
quashed. Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed.
13.
The impugned order dated 13.12.2023 (Annexure P-3) passed by
respondent No. 4 is hereby quashed and set aside.
The
respondents are directed to consider the case of petitioner for
appointment to the post of Rojgar Sahayak in case vacancy is
available forthwith. However, it is made clear that it shall be open
to the respondents to proceed afresh in accordance with law, if so
advised, after affording due opportunity of hearing to the
petitioner.
No order as to costs.
Shayna
Sd/(Amitendra Kishore Prasad)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review