The court's order
The closing paragraphs of the judgment, in the court's own words. The reasons are in the full text below.
20. In view of the above discussion, the finding recorded by the learned Trial Court on issue No.1 is perverse and the same is accordingly set-aside. Issue No.1 is decided in favour of the husband.
21. In that view of the matter, the appeal filed on behalf of the husband is accordingly allowed. The judgment and decree dated
12. 09.2018 passed by the learned Trial Court is set aside. The marriage solemnized between the parties on 29.04.2004 stands dissolved. Office is directed to prepare the decree accordingly.
Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
[2026:RJ-JP:35163-DB]
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE FOR RAJASTHAN
BENCH AT JAIPUR
D.B. Civil Miscellaneous Appeal No. 5015/2018
CNR: RJHC020986012018 | URN: CMA / 7828U / 2018
Manoj Kumar Yadav S/o Shri Nathu Singh Yadav, Aged About 34
Years, B/c-Ahir, R/o Makdawa, Tehsil Kothkasim, District Alwar,
Rajasthan.
----Appellant
Versus
Saroj Devi W/o Manoj Kumar Yadav, D/o Shri Satveer Singh,
R/o-Vilalge Ghotda, Thana Khol, Tehsil Rewari, Haryana
----Respondent
For Appellant(s)
:
Mr. Samarth Sharma
For Respondent(s)
:
Mr. Rajneesh Gupta with
Mr. Rahul Sharma
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE INDERJEET SINGH
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SANDEEP TANEJA
Order
01/09/2026
1.
This appeal under Section 28 of the Hindu Marriage Act,
1955 (hereinafter to be referred as ‘Act of 1955’) has been filed by
the appellant (hereinafter to be referred as “husband”) against the
judgment and decree dated 12.09.2018 passed by the learned
Additional District Judge No.1, Kishangarhbas (Alwar) (hereinafter
to be referred as “the learned Trial Court”), whereby the learned
Trial Court dismissed the application under Section 13 of the Act of
1955 filed on behalf of the husband.
2.
Brief facts of the case are that the husband filed an
application under Section 13 of the Act of 1955 before the learned
Trial Court stating therein that the marriage between husband and
wife was solemnized on 29.04.2004 as per Hindu Rites and
[2026:RJ-JP:35163-DB]
(2 of 9)
[CMA-5015/2018]
Customs and out of their wedlock one daughter was born. It was
further stated in the application by the husband that the behaviour
of the wife from the very beginning of their marriage was cruel
with the husband and his family members. It was further stated
that the wife threatened the husband for committing suicide and
involving him in false criminal case. It was further stated that the
wife herself deserted the husband without any justifiable reason
and also lodged a criminal case against the husband for the
offences under Sections 498-A & 406 of IPC. It was further stated
that the wife has denied co-habitation many a times, lastly, prayed
for granting the decree of divorce.
3.
The wife submitted reply to the said application before the
learned Trial Court and denied the allegations levelled by the
husband and stated in the reply that the husband was in the habit
of beating her and the husband and his family members used to
demand dowry from her. She further stated that the husband had
thrown her out from the matrimonial home without any reason
and she is ready and willing to live with the husband, lastly,
prayed for dismissal of the application.
4.
On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, the learned Trial
Court framed the following issues:-
Þ1& vk;k] fookg ds i'pkr~ vizkfFkZ;k dk O;ogkj izkFkhZ o mlds
ifjtuksa ds izfr Øwjrkiw.kZ jgus ds vk/kkj ij izkFkhZ] vizkfFkZ;k ds
lkFk fnukad 29-04-2004 dks xzke xksBM+k rglhy jsokM+h
¼gfj;k.kk½ esa laiUu gq, vius fookg dks fo?kfVr djokdj
vius i{k esa fookg foPNsn dh fMØh izkIr djus dk vf/kdkjh
gS\
2& vk;k] vizkfFkZ;k us yxHkx nks lky ls vf/kd le; ls izkFkhZ dk
fcuk fdlh ;qfDr;qDr dkj.k ds ifjR;kx dj j[kk gS\ ;fn
gk¡ rks bldk izHkko\
3& vuqrks"k\Þ
[2026:RJ-JP:35163-DB]
5.
(3 of 9)
[CMA-5015/2018]
The husband in support of his case submitted his own
evidence as AW-1 and of AW-2 to AW-4 and also submitted the
documentary evidence as Ex.1 to Ex.10. On the other side, the
wife submitted her own evidence as NAW-1 and of NAW-2 to NAW4 and no documentary evidence was produced on behalf of the
wife before the learned Trial Court.
6.
The learned Trial Court after recording the evidence and
hearing both the parties dismissed the application under Section
13 of the Act of 1955 filed by the husband vide its judgment and
decree dated 12.09.2018. Being aggrieved by the judgment and
decree dated 12.09.2018 passed by the learned Trial Court, the
husband has filed the present appeal before this Court.
7.
Learned counsel for the husband submits that the wife had
denied co-habitation since the year 2005 and she had also lodged
a false criminal case for the offences under Sections 498-A & 406
of IPC with regard to demand of dowry against the husband, in
which, during pendency of the matter before the learned Trial
Court, the husband was acquitted by the learned Judicial
Magistrate, Rewari vide its judgment dated 02.09.2015. A copy of
the said judgment dated 02.09.2015 was also produced before the
learned Trial Court as Ex.4. He further submits that the wife in her
statement recorded during the pendency of the proceedings under
Section 125 Cr.P.C. admitted that there is no physical relationship
between the husband and the wife since the year 2005. He further
submits that both the husband and the wife are living separately
since the year 2010 and there is no chance of their re-union.
Lastly, prayed for allowing the appeal.
[2026:RJ-JP:35163-DB]
8.
(4 of 9)
[CMA-5015/2018]
Learned counsel appearing on behalf of the wife has opposed
the submissions made by the learned counsel for the husband and
submits that the finding recorded by the learned Family Court is
based on sound appreciation of evidence and the same does not
require any interference by this Court. He further submits that the
husband cannot argue the appeal beyond the grounds mentioned
in the original application. He further submits that the wife is
always ready for living with the husband and on account of illbehaviour of the husband and demand of dowry, there was no
option with the wife except to lodge a criminal case against the
husband, lastly, prayed for dismissal of the appeal.
9.
In support of his contention, learned counsel for the wife
relied upon the judgment passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in
the matter of Bondar Singh and Ors. Vs. Nihal Singh & Ors.
(Civil Appeal No.7579/1999) decided on 04.03.2003.
10.
Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the
material available on record.
11.
The point of cruelty has been considered by the Hon’ble
Supreme Court at length in catena of judgments and in a recent
judgment delivered in the matter of Rakesh Raman Vs. Kavita
reported in 2023 17 SCC 433, wherein in paras No.17 and 18, it
was held as under:“17. Cruelty has not been defined
under the Act. All the same, the
context where it has been used, which
is as a ground for dissolution of a
marriage would show that it has to be
seen as a ‘human conduct’ and
‘behavior”
in
a
matrimonial
relationship. While dealing in the case
of Samar Ghosh (supra) this Court
opined that cruelty can be physical as
well as mental:-
[2026:RJ-JP:35163-DB]
(5 of 9)
[CMA-5015/2018]
“ 46…If it is physical, it is a question of
fact and degree. If it is mental, the
enquiry must begin as to the nature of
the cruel treatment and then as to the
impact of such treatment on the mind
of the spouse. Whether it caused
reasonable apprehension that it would
be harmful or injurious to live with the
other, ultimately, is a matter of
inference to be drawn by taking into
account the nature of the conduct and
its effect on the complaining spouse.
Cruelty can be even unintentional:…The absence of intention should not
make any difference in the case, if by
ordinary sense in human affairs, the
act complained of could otherwise be
regarded as cruelty. Intention is not a
necessary element in cruelty. The relief
to the party cannot be denied on the
ground that there has been no
deliberate or wilful ill- treatment.”
This Court though did ultimately give certain illus
trations of mental cruelty. Some of these are as
follows:
(i)
On
consideration
of
complete
matrimonial life of the parties, acute
mental pain, agony and suffering as would
not make possible for the parties to live
with each other could come within the
broad parameters of mental cruelty.
(xii) Unilateral decision of refusal to have
intercourse for considerable period without
there being any physical incapacity or
valid reason may amount to mental
cruelty.
(xiii) Unilateral decision of either husband
or wife after marriage not to have child
from the marriage may amount to cruelty.
(xiv) Where there has been a long period
of continuous separation, it may fairly be
concluded that the matrimonial bond is
beyond repair. The marriage becomes a
fiction though supported by a legal tie. By
refusing to sever that tie, the law in such
cases, does not serve the sanctity of
marriage; on the contrary, it shows scant
regard for the feelings and emotions of
the parties. In such like situations, it may
lead to mental cruelty. (emphasis
supplied)
[2026:RJ-JP:35163-DB]
(6 of 9)
[CMA-5015/2018]
18. We have a married couple before us who
have barely stayed together as a couple for
four years and who have now been living
separately for the last 25 years. There is no
child out of the wedlock. The matrimonial
bond is completely broken and is beyond repair. We have no doubt that this relationship
must end as its continuation is causing cruelty on both the sides. The long separation
and absence of cohabitation and the complete breakdown of all meaningful bonds
and the existing bitterness between the two,
has to be read as cruelty under Section
13(1) (ia) of the 1955 Act. We therefore
hold that in a given case, such as the one at
hand, where the marital relationship has
broken down irretrievably, where there is a
long separation and absence of cohabitation
(as in the present case for the last 25
years), with multiple Court cases between
the parties; then continuation of such a
‘marriage’ would only mean giving sanction
to cruelty which each is inflicting on the
other. We are also conscious of the fact that
a dissolution of this marriage would affect
only the two parties as there is no child out
of the wedlock.”
12.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of Narasimha
Sastry Vs. Suneela Rani reported in 2020 (18) SCC 247
wherein para No.13, it is held as under:“13. In the present case, the prosecution
is launched by the respondent against
the appellant against the appellant under
Section 498-A IPC making serious
allegations in which the appellant had to
undergo trial which ultimately resulted in
his acquittal. In the prosecution under
Section 498-A IPC not only acquittal has
been recorded but observations have
been made that allegations of serious
nature are levelled against each other.
The case set up by the appellant seeking
decree of divorce on the ground of
cruelty has been established. With regard
to proceeding initiated by the respondent
under Section 498-A IPC, the High Court?
made the following observation in para
15: (Rani Narsimha Sastry case, SCC
OnLine
Hyd)
"15. ... Merely because the respondent
[2026:RJ-JP:35163-DB]
(7 of 9)
[CMA-5015/2018]
has sought for maintenance or has filed a
complaint against the petitioner for the
offence punishable under Section 498-A
IPC, they cannot be said to be valid
grounds for holding that such a recourse
adopted by the respondent amounts to
cruelty.”
The above observation of the High Court
cannot be approved. It is true that it is
open for anyone to file complaint or lodge
prosecution for redressal of his or her
grievances and lodge a first information
report for an offence also and mere
lodging of complaint or FIR cannot ipso
facto be treated as crueltv. But, when a
person undergoes a trial in which he is
acquitted of the allegation of offence
under Section 498-A IPC, levelled by the
wife against the husband, it cannot be
accepted that no cruelty has been meted
out on the husband. As per the pleadings
before us, after parties having been
married on 14-8-2005, they lived
together only 18 months and, thereafter,
they are separately living for more than a
decade now.”
13.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of Parveen Mehta
Vs. Inderjit Mehta reported in 2002 (5) SCC 706 in para
No.16, has held as under:“16. In the case of Savitri Pandey vs. Prem
Chandra Pandey this Court construing the
question of 'cruelty' as a ground of divorce
under Section 13(1)(i-a) of the Act made the
following observations :
"6. Treating the petitioner with cruelty is a
ground for divorce under Section 13(1)(i-a) of
the Act. Cruelty has not been defined under the
Act but in relation to matrimonial matters it is
contemplated as a conduct of such type which
endangers the living of the petitioner with the
respondent. Cruelty consists of acts which are
dangerous to life, limb or health. Cruelty for
the purpose of the Act means where one
spouse has so treated the other and manifested
such feelings towards her or him as to have
inflicted bodily injury, or to have caused
reasonable apprehension of bodily injury,
suffering or to have injured health. Cruelty may
be physical or mental. Mental cruelty is the
[2026:RJ-JP:35163-DB]
(8 of 9)
[CMA-5015/2018]
conduct of other spouse which causes mental
suffering or fear to the matrimonial life of the
other. "Cruelty", therefore, postulates a
treatment of the petitioner with such cruelty as
to cause a reasonable apprehension in his or
her mind that it would be harmful or injurious
for the petitioner to live with the other party.
Cruelty, however, has to be distinguished from
the ordinary wear and tear of family life. It
cannot be decided on the basis of the
sensitivity of the petitioner and has to be
adjudged on the basis of the course of conduct
which would, in general, be dangerous for a
spouse to live with the other. In the instant
case both the trial court as well as the High
Court have found on facts that the wife had
failed to prove the allegations of cruelty
attributed to the respondent.
Concurrent findings of fact arrived at by the
courts cannot be disturbed by this Court in
exercise of powers under Article 136 of the
Constitution of India. Otherwise also the
averments made in the petition and the
evidence led in support thereof clearly show
that the allegations, even if held to have been
proved, would only show the sensitivity of the
appellant with respect to the conduct of the
respondent which cannot be termed more than
ordinary wear and tear of the family life."
15.
We have gone through the judgment and decree dated
12.09.2018 passed by the learned Trial Court and the evidence
submitted by the parties before it.
16. We have gone through the statement of the wife recorded
before the learned Trial Court, where in her cross-examination,
she has admitted that their marriage was solemnized in the year
2004 and after one year of their marriage, there was no cohabitation between them.
17.
We have also considered the statement of the husband
recorded before the learned Trial Court, in which, he has
specifically stated that the wife has denied co-habitation with
[2026:RJ-JP:35163-DB]
(9 of 9)
[CMA-5015/2018]
him after the year 2005. In our considered view, denial of cohabitation by the wife amounts to cruelty with the husband.
18.
We have also considered the document Ex.4 produced by
the husband before the learned Trial Court i.e. judgment dated
02.09.2015 passed by the Court, whereby, the husband has
been acquitted by the Court for the offences under Sections 498A & 406 of IPC. In our considered view, lodging of false criminal
case against the husband by the wife amounts to cruelty with
the husband.
19.
We have also considered the fact that the husband and the
wife both are living separately since the year 2010 and there is
no chance of their re-union at this point of time. In our
considered view, asking both them to live together at this point
of time amounts to cruelty to both of them, as there is no
chance of their re-union.
20.
In view of the above discussion, the finding recorded by
the learned Trial Court on issue No.1 is perverse and the same is
accordingly set-aside. Issue No.1 is decided in favour of the
husband.
21.
In that view of the matter, the appeal filed on behalf of the
husband is accordingly allowed. The judgment and decree dated
12.09.2018 passed by the learned Trial Court is set aside. The
marriage solemnized between the parties on 29.04.2004 stands
dissolved. Office is directed to prepare the decree accordingly.
22.
Record of the learned Court below be sent back.
(SANDEEP TANEJA),J
93/Upendra Pratap Singh
(INDERJEET SINGH),J
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review