Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
APPELLATE SIDE
Present:The Hon’ble Justice Supratim Bhattacharya
F.M.A.T. 1224 of 2017
With
IA No. CAN 1 of 2017
(Old No. CAN 11023 of 2017)
Manoj Kumar Singh & Ors.
Vs.
Dolly Singh & Ors.
For the Appellants
: Mr. Dyutiman Banerjee
Mr. Amartya Basu
For the Respondents
: Mrs. Sohini Chakrabarty
No. 1 and 2
Ms. Prajaaini Das
Delivered On
: 27.02.2026
Supratim Bhattacharya, J.:
1. The present miscellaneous appeal has been preferred by the
appellants being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with an order of remand
passed by the Ld. Additional District Judge, 15 th Court Alipore, South24-Parganas in Title Appeal No. 420 of 2016.
2. Factual Matrix
Before the Ld. Trial Court
One Dolly Singh and Rakhee Singh claiming themselves to be
the wife and daughter
of one Raja Singh, who used to work as a
conductor at Lake Depot of the Calcutta State Transport Corporation,
has initiated the lis, being Title Suit No. 1560 of 2008 before the Ld.
Civil Judge (Junior Division) 3rd Court at Alipore, South -24 Parganas,
seeking to be declared as nominee entitled to all the death benefits of
the said Raja Singh and has also prayed for permanent injunction
restraining the Calcutta State Transport Corporation from releasing
the entire death benefits including the arrears of pension, provident
fund and gratuity to any third party or to the defendants namely Shiv
Dulari Singh, Manoj Kumar Singh, Rajesh Kumar Singh and Rina
Singh.
Through the plaint the plaintiffs namely Dolly Singh and Rakhee
Singh have stated that the said Dolly Singh was married to Raja Singh
on 27.07.1990 and Rakhee Singh has been born because of their
wedlock. It has further been stated that Raja Singh has expired
intestate on 26.04.2006 living behind the plaintiffs as his widow and
minor daughter. It has also been stated that in the statement of
accounts for the year 2003-2004 the name of Dolly Singh is depicted
as the sole nominee of Raja Singh for the payment of the entire share
of the provident fund lying in his name. It has also been stated that
time and again written representations were made before several
authorities namely the Manager of the Lake Depot, the Administrative
Personnel Officer and the Managing Director of the Calcutta State
Transport Corporation praying for release of the amount lying in the
name of Raja Singh in his provident fund account. In spite of efforts
made, neither any amount from the gratuity nor any amount of the
provident fund lying in the name of Raja Singh has been released in
favour of the said plaintiffs. It has also been stated that on 28.10.2007
notice was sent to the concerned authority through her Ld. Advocate
to release the entire death benefits including the arrear of pension,
provident fund and gratuity lying in the account of Raja Singh and the
said notice is deemed to be a notice under Section 80 of the Code of
Civil Procedure, though no specific section has been mentioned in the
said notice. It has also been stated that on 07.04.2008 a reply from
the Senior Audit Officer–II, Pension cell of the Calcutta State
Transport Corporation has been received mentioning about the
succession certificate and case No. 156 of 2006 before the Court of Ld.
District Delegate at Alipore wherein Shiv Dulari Singh has claimed the
death benefits of Raja Singh. It has also been stated that vide letter
dated 07.05.2008 the plaintiff has requested the authority not to
release any fund to Shiv Dulari Singh or anyone without adjudicating
the dispute between them.
In the said title suit the defendants No. 2 to 5 entered appearance and
filed written statement. Through the written statement the defendants
have stated that Raja Sigh alias Bhagawan Singh married Shiv Dulari
Singh in the year 1975. It has also been stated that Raja Singh never
married Dolly Singh and the question of a daughter of Dolly Singh
does not arise. It has also been alleged that Raja Singh alias Bhagwan
Singh was not at all the husband of Dolly Singh and taking similarity
of the name the said Dolly Singh in collusion with some frivolous
persons has made false claim. It has also been stated that there is no
nomination form in this regard and the same is out of fraud and Raja
Singh cannot make such nomination. The CSTC authority had
initially appeared in the title suit and had filed written statement but
ultimately
did not contest as such the suit was fixed for ex parte
hearing against the authority.
In the trial court the following issues were framed :
ISSUES
1. Whether the suit is maintainable in its present form and in law?
2. Whether plaintiffs have any cause of action to file the instant
suit?
3. Whether plaintiff no. 1 is the legally married wife of Raja Singh.
4. Whether plaintiffs served any notice u/s 80 C.P.C.
5. Whether plaintiff no.1 is the sole nominee of Late Raja Singh in
respect of his provident fund.
6. Whether the court fees paid is correct ?
7. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to the reliefs as prayed in the
plaint.
8. What other relief/reliefs if any plaintiffs are entitled to?
On behalf of the plaintiffs two witnesses deposed they are PW1 Dolly
Singh and PW2 Rakhee Singh.
The following documents have been exhibited on behalf of the
plaintiffs:
1. Document: Original PAN Card of P.W.2. Exhibit-1
2. Two original voter cards of Plaintiff Nos.1 & 2 - Exhibit-2
3. Death Certificate of Raja Singh. Exhibit-3
4. Original annual statement of A/c for the Year 2003-04 of
CSTC, Central provident Fund bearing the name of P.W.1.
Exhibit 4 (after objection)
5. Copy of circular issued by CSTC dated 1.4.04. Exhibit-5
6. True copy of letter dated 28.10.2007 Issued by Ld.
Advocate of the plaintiffs along with two postal receipts.
Exhibit-6 (with objection)
7. Receipt of two copies of letter dated 28.10.2007 served
upon concerned Office and by hand. Exhibit - 7 (with
objection).
8. Letter dated 07.04.2008 issued by Sr. Audit Officer-II,
Pension Cell of CSTC. - Exhibit-8 (With objection).
9. Receipt copy of letter dated 7.5.2008 Issued by Ld.
Advocate for the plaintiff No.1 in favour of Managing Director
A/C Officer, Administration personnel Officer & Depot
Manager, Lake Depot CSTC. -Exhibit -9 (with Obj.)
10. Birth Certificate of Rakhee Singh by KMC. - Exhibit -10
(with objection)
11. Admit card of Madhyamik and H.S. Examination of
Rakhee Sing Exhibit-11
12. Character Certificate dated 20.06.2008 of Rakhee Singh
issued by Binodini Girls' High School. Exhibit -12 (after
Objection)
13. Certified copy of application for Revocation of succession
certificate & Original information slip. Exhibit-13 (after
Objection).
On behalf of the defendants Manoj Kumar Singh adduced evidence
and has exhibited the following documents:
1. Xerox copy of birth certificate of Rakhee Singh – Exhibit – A
2. Ration Card of Bhagwan Singh Exhibit B (after Obj.)
3. Original licence of conductor stands in name of Bhagwan
Singh. Exhibit-C
4. Identity card of Bagwan Sing issued By CSTC, Lake Depot.
Exhibit-D
5. Pass book of Bhagwan Sing of UBI, Lake Gardens Branch.
Exhibit-E
6. News paper publication dated 14.02.2007 in Hindu Daily
Newspaper - Exhibit-F
7. Mark Sheet of Rina Singh issued by Madhya Siksha
Parisad, Uttar Pradesh. Exhibit-G
8. Three Original voter Cards of defendants Exhibit H
(Collectively)
9. Passport of D.W.1 Exhibit - I.
10. Admit Card of Bagwan Singh issued by Calcutta
University. Exhibit-J
11. Certificate of Madhyamik in the Name of D.W.1 issued by
Madhyamik Siksha Parisad, U.P. Exhibit-K.
12. Two certificate issued by Pradhan Of Muriary Gram
Panchayat, U.P. -Exhibit -L (Series) With objection.
13. Pariwar Register issued by Khanda Vikash Adhikari,
Balia U.P.- Exhibit -M (with Objection)
14. Two pay slips in the name of Bhagwan Singh and Raja
Singh Respectively issued by CSTC. Exhibit - N (series).
15. Two certificates issued by Councillor, 89 Ward of KMC Exhibit-O (Series).
16. Official seal and signatures of. CSTC Authority on receipt
copy of D.W.1 to Depot Manager CSTC, Lake. Exhibit-P
17. Order for expunge dated 30.05.06 made By Lake Depot,
Depot Manager Exhibit -Q
18. Seal and signature of concerned Authority of Charu
Market Police Station on G.D. dated 25.02.2016 lodged by
wife of Deceased Raja Singh. Exhibit-R.
19. L.T.I. of defendant No.2 and The seal of C.S.T.C. Authority
on Letter dated 12.09.2007 issued by Shiv Dulari Singh to
depot Manager, Lake Depot. Exhibit - S
20. LTI and seal on letter dated 03.08.2007 issued by Shib
Dulari Singh to MD and Chairman of CSTC Lake Depot.
Exhibit-T
21. Carbon copy of letter dated 4.12.2007 issued by Ld.
Advocate of the Defendants to the DEPOT Manager, Lake
Depot, CSTC- Exhibit-U
22. Copy of letter dated 11.03.2008 Written by Ld. Advocate
for the defendant To the Law Officer, CSTC. Exhibit - V
23. Letter dated 01.08.2006 issued by Law Officer, CSTC, to
Ld. Advocate of the Defendants. Exhibit – W
24. Letter dated 14.12.2007 written By Sr. Law Officer, CSTC
to the mother of D.W.1. Exhibit-X
25. Succession Certificate issued by District Delegate at
Alipore in Act 39 Case No.156 of 2006. Exhibit -Y (with
Objection).
26.. Certified copy of various order in Connection with Act.
No.39 case No, 156 of 2006 passed by Ld. Dist. Delegate
Exhibit -Z (Obj.)
27. Certified copy Bailif report in case No. 156 of 2006Exhibit - A-1 (after Objection)
28. Newspaper publication dated 14.2.07 In Hindu Daily
Newspaper- Exhibit -B-1
29. letter for payment dues dated 15.04.2008 issued by Sr.
Law Officer, CSTC to mother of D.W.1. - Exhibit - C-1 (after
Objection)
30. Blank nomination form which was Lying with the file of
the deceased Father of D.W.1 Exhibit - D-1 (after Objection).
Ultimately the Ld. Civil Judge (Junior Division) 2nd Additional Court at
Alipore after perusal of the oral and documentary evidence has been
pleased to dismiss the suit on contest on 30th August, 2016.
Before the Ld. First Appellate Court
Being aggrieved by and dissatisfied with the Judgment of the Ld. Trial
Court passed in the aforementioned title suit the plaintiffs preferred a
title appeal being Title Appeal No. 420 of 2016 which was ultimately
disposed of by the Ld. 15th Additional District Judge at Alipore. In the
said title appeal an application under Order XLI Rule 27 of the Code of
Civil Procedure was also filed.
The Ld. First Appellate Court after taking into consideration the oral
and documentary evidence on record and the submission of the Ld.
Counsels representing the contending parties and also taking into the
consideration the application filed under Order XLI Rule 27 of the said
Code framed three points which are as follows:
i) whether the Ld. Trial Court is justified in its decision in
dismissing the title suit filed by the plaintiffs, appellants herein
on contest under the backdrop of this consideration that the
plaintiffs appellants herein are not entitled to get any decree as
prayed for since the main prayer of the plaintiffs/appellants to
declare the plaintiff/appellant No.1 as a legally married wife of
Raja Singh has not been properly proved in the suit ?
ii) Whether the impugned judgment and decree is to be
cofirmed ?
iii) Whether the impugned judgment and decree is sustainable
in the eye of law ?
The Ld. First Appellate Court considering the documents
produced
on
behalf
of
the
appellants/plaintiffs
and
the
respondents/defendants and taking into consideration oral evidence
adduced on behalf of the contending parties and after considering the
submission of the Ld. Counsels representing the appellants and the
respondents and also taking into consideration the application filed
under Order XLI Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure filed on behalf of
the appellants /plaintiffs has reached the following finding:
“Hence, it is,
Ordered
That the instant Appeal being Title Appeal No.420 of 2016, is
allowed after allowing the application under order 41 rule 27
of the CPC filed by the plaintiffs/Appellants against the
Defendant/Respondent No.1 ex-parte and Respondent Nos. 2
to 4 on contest. The impugned Judgment and Decree, dated
30.08.2016, passed by the Ld. Civil Judge (Jr. Divn) 2nd
Additional Court, Alipore, 24 Parganas (South) in T.S. No.1560
of 2008 is hereby set aside.
It is made further clear that the Ld. Trial Court shall decide
suit on remand by re-adjudicating the issue no.3, 5, 7 and 8
on the basis of evidence on record as already filed on behalf
of both sides in the suit along with the documentary evidence
as filed on behalf of the plaintiffs/Appellants along with the
application under order 41 rule 27 of the C.P.C. The instant
suit shall be re-admitted under the original file and number in
the register of the Civil Suit in the Ld. Trial Court. The Trial on
remand be completed within six months from the date of
communication of this order.
It is also made clear that the evidence as recorded earlier in
the Trial of the suit and the material documents, as sought to
be produced before this Court of Appeal as Additional
evidence under the provision of Order 41 rule 27 of the CPC
after being admitted, be also the part of the evidence in the
trial on remand.”
Thereby allowing the title appeal after allowing the application under
Order XLI Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure and setting aside the
judgment passed in Title Suit No. 1560 of 2008. The Ld. First Appellate
Court has remanded
the suit
directing the Ld. Trial Court to
readjudicate the issues No. 3, 5 , 7 and 8 on the basis of evidence on
record along with the documentary evidence as filed on behalf of the
appellants /plaintiffs along with the application under Order XLI Rule 27
of the said Code. This being the impugned order. The appellants have
preferred the present appeal challenging the same.
3. Mr. Dyutiman Banerjee being assisted by Mr. Amartya Basu the
learned Counsels representing the appellants during his submission
has stated the following:
i)
The Trial Court has minutely gone into both oral and
documentary evidence and after considering verbal evidence
and the documents has been pleased to adjudicate the suit.
ii)
He has further submitted that there being no marriage
certificate produced on behalf of the plaintiff the Ld. Trial Judge
has not been pleased to accept the contention of the appellant.
iii)
He has further submitted that marriage between Raja Singh
alias Bhagawan Singh since deceased and Shiv Dulari took
place long ago in the year 1975.
iv)
He has further submitted that Raja Singh never ever married
Dolly Singh as such there cannot be existence of any daughter.
v)
He has further submitted that Dolly Singh and Rakhee Singh
are fraudulently claiming themselves to be the wife and
daughter of the said Raja Singh since deceased
vi)
He has further submitted that the title suit filed by Dolly Singh
and Rakhee Singh do not have any legs to stand upon as
because Calcutta State Transport Corporation has been made a
party being defendant No. 1 but no notice under Section 80 of
the Civil Procedure Code has been served upon the said
transport corporation prior to the institution of the title suit.
vii)
He has further submitted that the impugned judgment passed
by the Ld. First Appellate Court has not critically examined the
evidence on record both oral and documentary while passing
the impugned judgment.
viii)
He has further submitted that the lis instituted by Dolly Singh
and Rakhee Singh is nothing but a case inflicted upon the
appellants/defendants harassing them.
ix)
He has also submitted that the order of remand directing
further trial of the suit is not required
as the documents
intended to be brought on record will not alter the fate of the
litigation.
x)
The Ld. Counsel has relied upon the judgment cited at 2024
SCC Online Guj 3987.
Banking upon the aforesaid facts and circumstances the said
counsel has prayed for allowing the present appeal thereby
setting aside the order of remand.
4. Mrs. Sohini Chakrabarty being assisted by Ms. Prajaaini Das, the
learned Counsels representing the respondents during her submission
has stated the following
i)
The respondents plaintiffs have filed an application under Order
XLI Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure and through the said
application some documents have been relied upon to be
brought on record.
ii)
She has further submitted that for the purpose of bringing the
new documents on record further trial is required and for that
the order of remand is the correct step taken by the Ld. First
Appellate Court.
iii)
She has further submitted that the respondent wife/plaintiff
has sought to bring on record the documents which are to be
taken into consideration to come to the just conclusion of the lis
for which further trial is required and the Ld. First Appellate
Court has correctly remanded the matter.
iv)
The Ld. Counsel has relied upon the judgment reported at
(2004) 4 SCC 26.
Relying on the aforementioned facts the learned counsel has
sought for dismissal of the present appeal and thereby affirming
the impugned judgment.
5. From the submission of the learned counsels and on perusal of the
impugned judgment and the judgment passed by the Ld. Trial Court,
the fact which lies upon this Court is to assess as to whether
order of remand
the
passed by the Ld. First Appellate Court is in
accordance with law or not.
6. Along with the first appeal the appellants/plaintiffs have filed an
application under Order XLI Rule 27 of the code of Civil Procedure
thereby seeking to produce additional evidence through several
documents which are as follows:
“1. Original transfer certificate of Raja Singh son of Dhari
Chand Singh dated 16.01.1981 issued by Jadavpur Hindi
Vidyapit.
2. Original letter of intimation dated 24.02.2005 to Raja Singh
issued by Binodini Girls' High School.
3. Original Ration Card of Raja Singh issued by the
Government of West Bengal.
4. Original mark sheet for the year 2001 to 2002 of Rakhi
Singh.
5. Original mark sheet for the year 2003 to 2004 of Rakhi
Singh.
6. Original application of health insurance of Raja Singh before
the A.P.O Maniktala depot CSTC.
7. Original birth certificate of Rakhee Singha (Singh) issued by
Kolkata Municipal Corporation Health Department.
8. Original Death certificate of Raja Singh issued by Kolkata
Municipal Corporation Health Department.
9. Statement of account in the name of Raja Singh for the year
2002 to 2003.
10. Original allowance statement of Raja Singh for the month
of February, 2006.
11. Original right to information letter dated 19.05.2017.
12. Four original photographs of Raja Singh on his marriage
and his family.
13. Original envelope along with caveat notice.”
7. From the lis it transpires that the issue involved is as to who is the
legally married wife of
the deceased Raja Singh alias Bhagawan
Singh. Whether it is Dolly Singh or Shiv Dulari Singh. This
determination will set forth the right of the persons to the terminal
benefits. It is fact that both Dolly Singh and Shiv Dulari Singh have
claimed themselves to be the wife of Raja Singh and thereby seeking
the
amount lying in the provident fund, gratuity and pension in
respect of Raja Singh.
8. Through the application under Order XLI Rule 27 of the Code of Civil
Procedure the respondents/plaintiffs have sought for adducing
documents which relates to the transfer of Raja Singh issued by
Jadavpur
Hindu
Vidyapith
dated
16.01.1981
and
extends
to
document relating to the year 2017.
9. There being no married certificate produced on behalf of either of the
contending parties, Court has to reach to the just conclusion
considering the other circumstantial evidence among which, what can
be better than documentary evidence . These documents which have
been stated to be brought on record and are not yet in the record are
to be proved, for which oral evidence is required and
the opposite
party is required to be given opportunity to cross-examine on those
documents to prove or to disprove the authenticity, veracity of those
documents. Such number of documents can only be taken into
consideration after taking evidence on record, so opportunity of
adducing further evidence is required to be given for which further
trial is required.
The issues framed by the Ld. Trial Court are to be dealt with
elaborately after taking into consideration the new documents, which
have been sought to be produced, after taking oral evidence.
10.
The judgment cited on behalf of the appellants which has been
reported in 2024 SCC OnLine Guj 3987 has been passed in relation to
a petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India. In the said
case the matter involved was handing over of vacant and peaceful
possession of land wherein the documents which were sought to be
produced as additional documents were resolution passed by
the
Board of Directors of a company and copy of an order passed by the
City Deputy Collector Ahmedabad, West. The Ld. Judge in the said
case has rejected the application on the ground that the Court is of
the considered view that on the evidence which has been adduced on
record, it is in a position to pronounce the judgment. So in the said
case referred to by the appellants the judge felt that sufficient
evidence was there to pronounce the judgment, which is not the case
in our hand. In the present lis to reach the just conclusion, Court has
to
take
into
consideration
respondents/plaintiffs intend to
the
documents
bring on record.
which
the
Thus, in the
present case the documents which have been intended to be brought
through the application under Order XLI Rule 27 of the Code of Civil
Procedure will be of help to the Court to come to the correct
conclusion and to pronounce the judgment. So the judgment cited on
behalf of the appellants do not help the cause of the appellants.
11.
So this Court is also of the same view as that of the Ld. First
Appellate Court.
12.
The appeal being F.M.A.T. 1224 of 2017 stands thus
dismissed accordingly CAN 1 of 2017 stands disposed of.
13.
Parties shall be entitled to act on the basis of the server copy of
the judgment and order placed on the official website of the Court.
14.
Urgent Xerox certified photo copies of this judgment, if applied
for, be given to the parties upon compliance of the requisite
formalities.
(Supratim Bhattacharya, J.)
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review