Full Judgment Text
Text read from the judgment PDF published on the High Court's eCourts portal, through the
Indian High Court Judgments open data set (Dattam Labs,
CC BY 4.0).
The court's own copy is the authoritative text.
1/8
2026:CGHC:13693
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPS No. 13119 of 2025
•
Manoj Kumar Bhagat S/o Late T.R. Bhagat Aged About 47 Years Present
Working As A Field Officer, Zila Antyavasai Sahakari Vikas Samiti Raigarh,
District Raigarh Chhattisgarh
... Petitioner
versus
1. The State Of Chhattisgarh Through The Secretary, Department Of Schedule
Tribe And Schedule Caste Development, Mantralaya, Mahanadi Bhawan,
Atal Nagar, Nawa Raipur Chhattisgarh
2. The Managing Director Rajya Antyavasai Sahakari Vitya Evam Vikas Nigam
Tribal Research Institute Bhawan, Second Floor, Sector-24, Atal Nagar,
Nawa Raipur Chhattisgarh
3. Babubhai Shrivas Chief Executive Officer, Office Of The Collector Zila
Antyavasai Sahakari Vikas Samiti Raigarh, District Raigarh Chhattisgarh
4. Laxmi Prasad Kashyap Chief Executive Officer, Office Of The Collector Zila
Antyavasai Sahakari Vikas Samiti Bilaspur, District Bilaspur Chhattisgarh
5. Manharan Koshle Executive Officer, Office Of The Collector Zila Antyavasai
Sahakari Vikas Samiti Balodabazar, District Balodabazar-Bhatapara
Chhattisgarh
6. Smt. Seeta Srivas Executive Officer, Office Of The Collector Zila Antyavasai
Vyasahik Prashishank Kendra Kosa Jagdalpur, District Jagdalpur
Chhattisgarh
7. Rashmi Gupta Executive Officer, Office Of The Collector Zila Antyavasai
Sahakari Vikas Samiti Gariyaband, District Gariyaband Chhattisgarh
8. Smt. Nidhi Sinde Executive Officer, Office Of The Collector Zila Antyavasai
Sahakari Vikas Samiti Korba, District Korba Chhattisgarh
9. Naveen Kumar Sharma Executive Officer, Nigam Mukhyalaya Nawa Raipur,
District Raipur Chhattisgarh
10. Ghanshyam Prasad Bramhe Executive Officer, Office Of The Collector Zila
Antyavasai Sahakari Vikas Samiti Kondagaon, District Kondagaon
Chhattisgarh
11. Praveen Kumar Lata Executive Officer, Office Of The Collector Zila
Antyavasai Sahakari Vikas Samiti Bemetara, District Bemetara Chhattisgarh
12. Sandeep Shukla Executive Officer, Office Of The Collector Zila Antyavasai
Sahakari Vikas Samiti Janjgir, District Janjgir-Champa Chhattisgarh
2/8
13. Suresh Kumar Verma Executive Officer, Office Of The Collector Zila
Antyavasai Sahakari Vikas Samiti Raipur, District Raipur Chhattisgarh
14. Alakram Belsariya Executive Officer, Office Of The Collector Zila Antyavasai
Sahakari Vikas Samiti Narayanpur, District Narayanpur Chhattisgarh
15. Yogesh Kumar Sahu Executive Officer, Office Of The Collector Zila
Antyavasai Sahakari Vikas Samiti Beejapur, District Beejapur Chhattisgarh
16. Jitendra Baghel Executive Officer, Office Of The Collector Zila Antyavasai
Sahakri Vikas Samiti Dantewara, District Dantewara Chhattisgarh
17. Bhartendu Dewangan Executive Officer, Office Of The Collector Zila
Antyavasai Sahakari Vikas Samiti Jagdalpur, District Jagdalpur Chhattisgarh
18. Prahlad Dewangan Executive Officer, Office Of The Collector Zila Antyavasai
Sahakari Vikas Samiti Balrampur, District Balrampur-Ramanujganj
Chhattisgarh
19. Smt. Prabha Markande Executive Officer, Office Of The Collector Zila
Antyavasai Sahakari Vikas Samiti Mahasamund, District Mahasamund
Chhattisgarh
20. Miss Hemlata Jangde Executive Officer, Office Of The Collector Zila
Antyavasai Sahakari Vikas Samiti Sakti, District Sakti Chhattisgarh
... Respondents
For Petitioner
:
Mr. Roop Ram Nayak, Advocate
For Respondent-State
:
Ms. Anuja Nigam, Dy. Govt. Advocate
For Respondent No. 2
:
Mr. Ramnarayan Sahu, Advocate
For Respondent No. 3 & 4
:
Ms. Soumya Das, Advocate
Hon'ble Shri Parth Prateem Sahu, Judge
ORDER ON BOARD
20/03/2026
1.
Brief facts of the case are that meeting of Departmental Promotion
Committee (DPC) was convened on 29.09.2018 to consider the suitability of
the eligible Field Officers for their promotion to the post of Executive Officer.
In the said meeting, DPC considered name of petitioner as he was falling
within the zone of consideration, however, he was not recommended for
promotion because Annual Confidential Report (ACR) of petitioner of the
year 2016-17 was not available and his name was kept in circulation. In the
meeting of review DPC held on 10.02.2021 with reference to the DPC dated
29.09.2018, petitioner was found suitable for promotion, however, he was not
3/8
promoted due to pendency of departmental enquiry, which made the
petitioner to file this writ petition seeking following reliefs:
“10.1 That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to issue an appropriate writ of
mandamus/ direction / order to set aside Order
dated 11.09.2025 passed by the respondent No.
2 (ANNEXURE P-1), DPC dated 29.09.2018
convened by the DPC Committee (ANNEXURE
P-2), Order dated 06.10.2021 passed by the
respondent No. 2 (ANNEXURE P-3), Order
dated 25.04.2022 passed by the respondent No.
2 (ANNEXURE P-4), Order dated 02.06.2022
passed by the respondent No. 2 (ANNEXURE P5) and Order dated 01.10.2025 passed by the
respondent No. 2 (ANNEXURE P-6).
10.2
That, this Hon'ble Court may kindly be
pleased to issue an appropriate writ of
mandamus/ direction / order to the respondents
authority to grant / provide promotion to the
petitioner on the post of Executive Engineer with
effect from 29.09.2018 with seniority and all
consequential service benefits.
10.3 That, any direction or order may kindly be
passed in favour of the petitioner, which this
Hon'ble Court deems fit in the facts and
circumstances of the case. An affidavit in support
of this petition is filed herewith.”]
2.
Learned counsel for petitioner submits that petitioner was having good
service record till the date when the DPC convened meeting on 29.09.2018
for consideration of the name of eligible Field Officers for their promotion to
the post of Executive Officer. Name of petitioner was though considered,
however, he could not be recommended for promotion as the ACR of
petitioner for the year 2016-17 was not available. Non-availability of ACR of
petitioner of one year is due to administrative lapse on the part of
respondents for which petitioner cannot be made to suffer. It is contention of
learned counsel for petitioner that respondent-Department have convened
review DPC on 10.02.2021 with reference to the DPC meeting dated
29.09.2018.
Petitioner was found suitable but he was again not
recommended for promotion mentioning that a departmental enquiry is
4/8
pending consideration against him. He would submit that the candidature of
petitioner and his suitability is to be considered even if in review DPC as of
during first meeting of DPC dated 29.09.2018, on the said date petitioner was
not served with charge-memo nor any enquiry was pending against him and
therefore respondents ought to have recommended for issuance of order of
promotion when the candidature of petitioner is considered in review DPC
meeting held on 10.02.2021 in reference of the first meeting of DPC dated
29.09.2018. Direction be issued to the respondent-Department to issue order
of promotion in favour of petitioner with effect from the date when other Field
Officers were promoted to the post of Executive Officer pursuant to meeting
of DPC convened on 29.09.2018.
3.
Learned counsel for respondent-State would submit that petitioner is an
employee of Respondent no. 2 and the relief as prayed for in this writ petition
is against Respondent No. 2 and not from the State Government, therefore,
she is not making any submission on merits of the case.
4.
Learned counsel for Respondent No. 2 would submit that in the meeting of
DPC held on 29.09.2018 for promotion of Field Officers and the Chief
Instructors to the post of Executive Officer, name of petitioner was also
considered, however, he was not recommended for promotion because ACR
of petitioner of the year 2016-17 was not made available, and his name was
kept in circulation. Based on the recommendation made by the DPC, order of
promotion was issued on 05.10.2018. In review DPC held on 10.02.2021 with
reference to DPC meeting dated 29.09.2018, name of petitioner was again
considered, however, he was again not recommended for promotion on the
ground that departmental enquiry is instituted against him. It is contention of
learned counsel for Respondent No. 2 that in the meeting of DPC dated
31.03.2022, name of petitioner for promotion was again considered and his
name has been kept in circulation as the ACR of petitioner for the year 201920 was not received and further a departmental enquiry is pending against
5/8
him. In the departmental enquiry proceedings, charges levelled against
petitioner was found proved and he was inflicted with punishment of
withholding annual increment with non-cumulative effect vide order dated
20.03.2025. In DPC convened on 23.09.2025, again petitioner was found
eligible for promotion for the post of Executive Officer but as the petitioner
was inflicted with punishment of withholding of increment vide order dated
20.03.2025, his name was not recommended for promotion.
5.
I have heard learned counsel for the respective parties and also perused the
documents placed on record.
6.
When the case was listed for the first time on 20.11.2025, Court has directed
Respondent No. 2 to place on record proceedings of DPC for perusal and
also to call the Officer acquainted with proceedings of DPC. On 11.03.2026,
Smt. Gayatri Netam, Secretary, Chhattisgarh Antyavasai Sahakari Vitta
Evam Vikas Nigam appeared in person along with record of DPC and upon
hearing her, based on the proceedings of DPC dated 29.09.2018 and
10.02.2021 following was recorded:
“Upon putting query to the Officer present in this
Court, she submits that according to proceeding
recorded in DPC held on 29.09.2018, name of
petitioner was considered. However, due to
unavailability of the ACR of petitioner, his name was
kept in circulation. She submits that along with
petitioner, names of other 8 employees were also
kept in circulation for want of ACR of relevant
period. Meeting of review DPC was convened on
10.02.2021 and upon perusal of ACR of petitioner,
he was found suitable for promotion. However, on
the same day i.e. 10.02.2021, it was informed to
DPC that departmental enquiry is pending
consideration against the petitioner and therefore
he was not given promotion. Upon asking, she
clarifies that even sealed cover procedure was not
adopted. She, however, submits that on the date of
convening meeting of DPC in the year 2018, no
enquiry was pending against the petitioner and he
was suitable for promotion.”
6/8
7.
From the facts of the case, submission made by learned counsel for the
respective parties as also the submission made by the Secretary,
Chhattisgarh Antyavasai Sahakari Vitta Evam Vikas Nigam would show that
petitioner became eligible for consideration of his name for promotion on the
post of Executive Officer. In the meeting of DPC held on 29.09.2018 upon
considering the candidature of petitioner he could not be promoted only
because his ACR of the year 2016-17 was not made available to the DPC by
the department. According to Respondent No.2, name of petitioner has been
kept in circulation.
8.
Perusal of proceeding of review DPC convened on 10.02.2021 of the DPC
meeting dated 29.09.2018 would show that in review DPC petitioner was
found suitable as on
29.09.2018 for promotion but he could not be
recommended for promotion only because an departmental enquiry was
initiated against him in the year 2019.
9.
It is settled law that when name of employee is considered in review DPC
which convened subsequently with reference to the meeting of DPC which
was earlier held, then the suitability of the employee for his promotion is to be
considered with reference to the date of first meeting of the DPC convened
on earlier occasion. In the facts of the case, relevant date would be
29.09.2018 for assessing the suitability of petitioner for his promotion. It is
not in dispute that the DPC has considered the ACR of prior period to the
date of convening of meeting, upon consideration of ACR prior to
29.09.2018, the review DPC in its meeting dated 10.02.2021 had found
petitioner suitable for promotion and therefore the DPC ought to have
recommended name of petitioner for promotion without taking note of any
adverse remark or pendency of enquiry which was subsequent to the first
meeting of DPC held on 29.09.2018. On 21.02.2021, only the departmental
enquiry proceeding was pending.
Relevant portion of the proceedings
7/8
recorded by the DPC after convening of the meeting dated 10.02.2021 is
extracted below for ready reference.
“
क 10.02.2021
आ
त
. . .
भगत,
)
भगत
उ
+
उ
)
भगत
10.
ग(
त
अ
ग
।
च
त
+
)
ण
क
)
।"
In the same proceedings, it is also mentioned that on the date of convening
of review DPC meeting dated 10.02.2021 no opinion is received by the
establishment about pendency or initiation of enquiry against petitioner, it
cannot be made available to the review DPC. It was made available only on
04.10.2021. In the aforementioned facts of the case also, where on the date
of meeting convened of the review DPC on 10.02.2021, there was no
material before the DPC that any enquiry is pending against petitioner.
11.
In the aforementioned facts of the case and discussion made above, when
the candidature of petitioner was considered on 10.02.2021 in a review DPC
meeting with reference to the meeting of DPC dated 29.09.2018 then in the
opinion of this Court the candidature of petitioner is to be considered based
on the records of prior to 29.09.2018 for his promotion. The review DPC
could not have taken into consideration the subsequent ACRs or material
against petitioner. Pendency of departmental enquiry because of which
petitioner was held to be non-suitable was of the year 2019 or thereafter and
not available on 29.09.2018 and therefore respondents have committed error
in arriving at a conclusion that the petitioner was not suitable for promotion in
a review DPC meeting held on 10.02.2021 with reference to the meeting of
DPC dated 29.09.2018, more so when the documents showing pendency of
enquiry was made available much after the date of review DPC ie.,
श्री
में
सी
डी
यू
रि
जि
यो
को
नां
पी
य
का
र
मा
कु
र
का
हुये
श्री
या
टा
से
ह
ज
रा
मि
स
ला
जि
ति
नो
श्री
था
या
म
के
ने
स्थि
सं
हो
ते
र
मा
यु
य
ची
ति
न
दो
प
सू
री
का
धि
त्रा
र
मा
कु
ज
नो
म
क्षे
या
पा
यु
में
ति
न
दो
प
म
ना
प
य
गी
भा
वि
वि
के
जाँ
प
तु
हे
ति
न
दो
प
म
ना
का
न
नु
म
ना
का
मा
कु
ज
नो
म
र
है
ता
स्
ना
जा
वि
दि
04.10.2021, whereas review DPC was held on 10.02.2021
8/8
12.
Accordingly, the writ petition is allowed and the respondents are directed to
convene the meeting of review DPC with reference to the DPC meeting
dated 29.09.2018 and pursuant to the observation made by the DPC in its
meeting dated 10.02.2021, finding petitioner to be suitable as on 29.09.2018,
name of petitioner be recommended for promotion and accordingly
appropriate order to be passed in this regard for his promotion. Petitioner
shall be granted notional promotion from 05.10.2018 when other employees
considered along with petitioner, were promoted. Petitioner will be entitled for
all consequential benefits with seniority.
Sd/-
pwn
PAWAN
KUMAR
JHA
Digitally
signed by
PAWAN
KUMAR JHA
(Parth Prateem Sahu)
JUDGE
This page is for informational and research purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
Consult a qualified advocate for advice specific to your situation.
Is your name in this judgment and should it be masked, or is something on this page wrong?
Request a review